DETERMINATION ON WHETHER A SUBSTANCE IS A HAZARDOUS SUBSTANCE PURSUANT TO SECTION 26 OF THE HSNO ACT Application Code HAZ03003 Application Type Section 26 – determine whether a substance is hazardous under the HSNO Act. Applicant Plastics New Zealand (Inc) Date Application Received 2 April 2003 To be considered by The Hazardous Substances Standing Committee of the Authority. Purpose of the Application To determine whether certain polyamides are hazardous Applications Advisor (Operations Group) Noel McCardle Scientific Advisor (Science & Analysis Group) Tania van Maanen Introduction Polyamides are a class of polymers that have recurring amide groups as an integral part of the main polymer backbone. For the purposes of this s26 determination, no heteroatoms may be present other than those comprising the (amide) linkage. They are more commonly known as nylons and are synthesized from intermediates such as dicarboxylic acids, diamines, amino acids and lactams. Nylons form fibres easily and are used in a wide range of applications eg clothing, house furnishings, automotive parts, parachutes, ropes and nets and packaging. The aromatic polyamides (aramids) are a special subgroup of the polyamides which have benzene rings between the amide bonds rather than aliphatic carbon chains. Aramids are tough, flame resistant and durable fibres and are marketed under such names as Kevlar® and Nomex®. No polymer manufacture is currently undertaken in New Zealand. Plastics are imported into the country in the form of granules from which a range of products are manufactured. Manufactured articles are exempt from the HSNO approval process but polymer granules fall within the HSNO definition of a substance and as such, a HSNO approval is required if any of the HSNO hazardous property thresholds is exceeded. Substance Definition Polyamides are a class of polymers that have recurring amide groups as an integral part of the main polymer backbone. For the purposes of this s26 determination, no heteroatoms may be present other than those comprising the amide linkage. Further, the definition is limited to those polyamides (not containing additives) with a number average molecular weight greater than 10 000 amu and with residual monomer, catalyst and solvent impurities present at levels less than ERMA New Zealand section 26 determination HAZ03003 Page 1 of 6 0.1%. In addition, polymers that are cationic (or potentially cationic) or those that are water absorbing, are specifically excluded from this definition. Examples of polyamides are listed in the application form HS7, provided as Appendix 1 to this document. Hazardous Property Assessment An assessment of polyamides against the HSNO thresholds was provided in the application form (attached as Appendix 1 to this document). It is noted that often limited or no information was available on these types of substances for a number of endpoints, especially data on polyamides as a group. Where information was available on specific polyamides, this has been provided. However, it is recognised that this s26 determination is limited to polyamides of very high molecular weight (i.e. greater than10 000 amu) and as discussed in the application form, such substances are not likely to be bioavailable and therefore highly unlikely to adversely affect either human health or the environment. A summary of the hazardous property assessment is provided below. Class / Sub-class Detail Threshold Class 1 – Explosiveness Polyamides are not considered explosive. They do not meet the HSNO criteria for an explosive substance and are not listed in the UN Recommendations on the Transport of Dangerous Goods. Not triggered Class 2,3,4 – Flammability Polyamides are not considered flammable. They do not meet the HSNO criteria for a flammable substance and are not listed in the UN Recommendations on the Transport of Dangerous Goods. Not triggered Sub-class 5.1 – Oxidisers Polyamides do not meet the HSNO definition/criteria for an oxidising substance. Not triggered Subclass 5.2 – Organic peroxides Polyamides do not meet the HSNO definition/criteria for an organic peroxide. Not triggered Sub-class 6.1 – Acute toxicity Polyamides are not considered to be acutely toxic as defined by the HSNO criteria. It has been reported that polyamide plastics have no known toxic effects. Rats fed Nylon 6 at 12500 mg/kg and Nylon 6,12 at 5000 mg/kg showed no adverse effects. Another acute oral study reported no mortalities when rats were fed up to 7500 mg/kg of Kevlar®. Not triggered ERMA New Zealand section 26 determination HAZ03003 Page 2 of 6 Class / Sub-class Detail Threshold Sub-class 6.3 – Skin irritancy Polyamides are not considered to be skin irritants as defined by the HSNO criteria. In a skin irritation study, a group of 100 subjects exposed to nylon for ten 24 hour applications followed by a 24 hour challenge after a two week rest period showed no reaction. Two skin irritation studies of Nomex® had negative results. Not triggered Sub-class 6.4 – Eye irritancy No information was located to indicate that polyamides would be eye irritants as defined by the HSNO criteria. Not triggered Sub-class 6.5A – Respiratory sensitisation No information was located to indicate that polyamides would be respiratory sensitisers as defined by the HSNO criteria. Not triggered Sub-class 6.5B – Contact sensitisation No information was located to indicate that polyamides would be contact sensitisers as defined by the HSNO criteria. Two skin sensitisation studies of Nomex® had negative results. Not triggered Sub-class 6.6 – Mutagenicity No information was located to indicate that polyamides would be mutagenic as defined by the HSNO criteria. Not triggered Sub-class 6.7 – Carcinogenicity No information was located to indicate that polyamides would be carcinogenic as defined by the HSNO criteria. The International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) has classified Nylon 6 and p-aramid fibrils as class 3 substances [unclassifiable as to carcinogenicity to humans] i.e. i.e. not unclassifiable as a carcinogen under HSNO. Not triggered Sub-class 6.8 – Reproductive / developmental effects No information was located to indicate that polyamides would be reproductive/developmental toxicants as defined by the HSNO criteria. Tests on Nylon 12 reported no toxic effects on reproductive function, embryos, or offspring development. Not triggered Sub-class 6.9 – Target organ systemic effects No information was located to indicate that polyamides would be target organ systemic toxicants as defined by the HSNO criteria. Long term rat and dog feeding studies of Nylon 6, Nylon 6,6 and Nylon 6,12 show no adverse physiological effects. In a separate feeding study involving Nylon 11, rats fed doses up to 5000 mg/kg bw/day and dogs fed doses up to 2500 mg/kg bw/day showed no toxic effects. Not triggered ERMA New Zealand section 26 determination HAZ03003 Page 3 of 6 Class / Sub-class Detail Threshold Class 8 – Corrosivity Polyamides are not considered to be corrosive to metals (sub-class 8.1), to skin (sub-class 8.2) or to the eye (sub-class 8.3). Polyamides are not listed in the UN Recommendations on the Transport of Dangerous Goods. Not triggered Class 9 - Ecotoxicity Polyamides are not considered to be ecotoxic due to their low reactivity and high molecular weight. As such, they will not be bioavailable and therefore highly unlikely to adversely affect aquatic life (subclass 9.1), soil organisms (sub-class 9.2) terrestrial vertebrates (subclass 9.3) or terrestrial invertebrates (sub-class 9.4). Although polyamides may not be rapidly biodegradable, they will not bioaccumulate due to their low bioavailablitiy. Not triggered Other information As discussed in the application form (attached as Appendix 1 to this document), polyamides of molecular weight > 10,000 meet the USEPA polymer exemption rule and the NICNAS polymers of low concern criteria. Furthermore, various polyamides are permitted by the US Food and Drug Administration (USFDA) “as articles or components of articles intended for use in contact with food” (CFR Title 21 paragraphs 177.1500, 177.1632, 177.2355). Recommended Determination If the Authority is of the view that polyamides are not hazardous under the HSNO Act, then the Authority may: a) determine that polyamides as defined are not hazardous pursuant to section 26 of the HSNO Act 1996; and b) direct the Chief Executive to arrange for notice of this determination to be placed in the Gazette. Dr Donald Hannah, Manager, Science and Analysis Date: 10 July 2003 ERMA New Zealand section 26 determination HAZ03003 Page 4 of 6 Determination by the Authority The recommended determination is approved. Mr Tony Haggerty, Chair Hazardous Substances Standing Committee Date: 30 July 2003 ERMA New Zealand section 26 determination HAZ03003 Page 5 of 6 Appendix 1 Application form HAZ03003 (attached) ERMA New Zealand section 26 determination HAZ03003 Page 6 of 6