MSc / Dip Philosophy (Taught) University of Edinburgh Programme Handbook Session 2010-2011 MSc/Dip Philosophy 2010/2011 1. 2 Introduction This document is the individual programme handbook for the Taught MSc in Philosophy. Please read it carefully. It should be read in conjunction with the following documents: School of Philosophy, Psychology and Language Sciences (PPLS) Taught MSc Handbook Code of Practice for Taught Postgraduate Programmes Postgraduate Assessment Regulations The Edinburgh University Students’ Association (EUSA) also provides some useful guides, such as an International Students’ Guide. See their webpage for more details: Edinburgh University Students’ Association (EUSA) www.eusa.ed.ac.uk/ Finally, you will also find lots of useful information on the Department of Philosophy’s own postgraduate webpages, and on the corresponding webpages maintained by the School of Philosophy, Psychology and Language Sciences (PPLS): Department of Philosophy Postgraduate Webpage http://www.philosophy.ed.ac.uk/postgraduate/ School of Philosophy, Psychology and Language Sciences (PPLS) Postgraduate Webpage http://www.ppls.ed.ac.uk/students/postgraduate/index.php Disclaimer Please note that this document is intended to provide students with information in a convenient form. If there is any inconsistency between it and the University Regulations, the latter takes priority. 2. The Structure of the MSc The Taught MSc programme in Philosophy is made up of 180 credits of assessment. The dissertation is worth 60 credits, and you will also take 60 credits of courses in each of the two semesters. Since all Philosophy MSc courses are worth 20 credits, this means that you will typically take three courses in each of the two semesters of your degree. The curriculum provides a taught survey of key philosophical topics as well as an introduction to individual research. The coursework aims to give the student a thorough grounding in the techniques of analytical philosophy. Students attending courses are expected to carefully read the assigned articles or texts before the seminar, and be prepared to join in discussion. Each student has a supervisor who oversees the student’s progress; this role is initially played by the Programme Director, then by the Dissertation Supervisor. In addition to seminars organised specifically for this curriculum, students may be encouraged to attend certain undergraduate lectures. Supervisors’ and student’s rights and responsibilities during the dissertation stage are described in the relevant sections of the Code of Practice for Taught Postgraduate Programmes and the PPLS Taught MSc Handbook. MSc/Dip Philosophy 2010/2011 3 (a) Core MSc Courses The following two courses are core to this MSc programme. Semester 1 Introduction to Philosophical Method [PHIL11008] Semester 2 Advanced Philosophical Method [PHIL11009] The Introduction to Philosophical Method is compulsory for students who do not have a strong background in philosophy, e.g. whose first degree is not in philosophy. Students with a strong background in Philosophy need not take it with the approval of their Programme Director. All students, however, must take the Advanced Philosophical Method course. (b) Other MSc Courses If you take both Introduction to Philosophical Method and Advanced Philosophical Method, and you are not pursuing any of the available specialisations within the MSc in Philosophy, then you must also take either any four of the following courses or a combination of some of these courses with some PG version of UG courses and/or one PG course outside Philosophy. Please see section 2 (c) below. Semester 1 Ancient Philosophy (Survey) [PHIL11016] Introduction to Mind, Language and Embodied Cognition [PHIL11037] Value Theory 1 [PHIL11006] Early Modern Philosophy 2: Theories of Mind and Body in early modern philosophy [PHIL11049] Epistemology I [PHIL11094] Semester 2: Ancient Philosophy (Texts 1) [PHIL11017] Advanced Topics in Mind, Language & Embodied Cognition [PHIL11038] Value Theory 2 [PHIL11007] Early Modern Philosophy 1: British Enlightenment Philosophy [PHIL11060] Epistemology 2 [PHIL11093] The MSc/Dip Philosophy Degree Programme Table for 2010/2011 and full course outlines for all these courses, including the two core courses, can be found here: https://www.star.euclid.ed.ac.uk/ipp/ptmscphily1f.htm If you just take Advanced Philosophical Method, and you are not pursuing any of the available specialisations within the MSc in Philosophy, then you must also take either any five of the aforementioned courses or a combination of some of these courses with some PG version of UG courses and/or one PG course outside philosophy. Please see section 2 (c) below. MSc/Dip Philosophy 2010/2011 4 MSc Specialisations As part of the MSc in Philosophy programme, you can specialise in one of five areas. Specialisation in Ancient Philosophy The MSc in Philosophy with Specialisation in Ancient Philosophy aims to introduce students to some key themes in ancient philosophy as discussed by the major thinkers and schools of ancient philosophy. Typical themes are likely to include the theories of reality, cognition, virtue, and cosmology, whilst the philosophers to be covered are likely to include the Presocratics, Plato and Aristotle, as well as Hellenistic and post-Hellenistic philosophical schools (Stoics, Sceptics, Epicureans, Neoplatonists) and individual thinkers. Whether you take Introduction to Philosophical Method and Advanced Philosophical Method, or just the latter, for this specialisation it is required that you take, among your option courses, the following two courses: Ancient Philosophy (Survey) [PHIL11016] Ancient Philosophy (Texts 1) [PHIL11017] Specialisation in Early Modern Philosophy The MSc in Philosophy with Specialisation in Early Modern Philosophy aims to introduce students to the central ideas and debates in British and European philosophy in the long seventeenth century (Descartes to Hume). The often interwoven themes typically explored in this specialisation range over topics in metaphysics and epistemology, such as the nature of substance, mind-body relations, the nature of ideas, scepticism, intellectual intuition, to topics in ethics, political philosophy, science and theology, such as the nature and possibility of individual and political freedom, moral laws of nature, the status of scientific law, and religious enthusiasm. Whether you take Introduction to Philosophical Method and Advanced Philosophical Method, or just the latter, for this specialisation it is required that you take, among your option courses, the following two courses: Early Modern Philosophy 1: British Enlightenment Philosophy [PHIL11060] Early Modern Philosophy 2: Theories of Mind and Body in Early Modern Philosophy) [PHIL11049] Specialisation in Ethics The MSc in Philosophy with Specialisation in Ethics addresses central questions both in metaethics, normative ethics, and moral psychology. In metaethics, questions about the nature of moral judgment, as well as questions about the metaphysical and epistemological commitments associated with moral thought, are all addressed. In normative ethics, traditional debates between consequentialists, contractualists and deontologists take centre stage. Finally, the department has a special strength in moral psychology, an area which in many ways stands at the intersection between metaethics and normative ethics. Here, the main questions addressed concern the relationship between reasons, beliefs, desires, and agency. The philosophical relevance of empirical work in cognitive psychology and experimental economics also plays a prominent role. Whether you take Introduction to Philosophical Method and Advanced Philosophical Method, or just the latter, for this specialisation it is required that you take, among your option courses, the following two courses: MSc/Dip Philosophy 2010/2011 5 Value Theory 1 [PHIL11006] Value Theory 2 [PHIL11007] Specialisation in Mind, Language & Embodied Cognition What kind of thing is the mind, and how do brain, body, world and action conspire to support thought, experience and adaptive success? This MSc specialisation tackles this large and elusive question from a variety of angles including (but not limited to) the emerging perspective of ‘embodied and situated cognition’. Typical topics and themes include: activity, intervention, and representation; sensorimotor models of perception; the extended mind; language and thought; naturalized theories of content; perception and perceptual experience; agency and self-awareness; rationality and emotion; narratives and social institutions. Whether you take Introduction to Philosophical Method and Advanced Philosophical Method, or just the latter, for this specialisation it is required that you take, among your option courses, the following two courses: Introduction to Mind, Language, and Embodied Cognition [PHIL11037] Advanced Topics in Mind, Language, and Embodied Cognition [PHIL11038] Specialisation in Epistemology What is knowledge? If we have any knowledge at all, which kinds of knowledge are there, how do we come to possess knowledge, and what structure and value does knowledge have? By examining various themes and theories in contemporary epistemology, this MSc specialisation aims to assess various answers to these muchdebated questions. Examples include scepticism, contextualism, the closure principle, internalism/externalism, foundationalism/coherentism, the a priori/a posteriori and virtue epistemology. You will take Epistemology I in the first semester. This seminarbased course provides an advanced introduction to a range of topics in contemporary epistemology. In the second semester you will take Epistemology II. This course is closely linked with the research seminar run by the Epistemology research cluster. Thus students will be required to present a paper in this seminar series. Whether you take Introduction to Philosophical Method and Advanced Philosophical Method, or just the latter, for this specialisation it is required that you take, among your option courses, the following two courses: Epistemology I [PHIL11094] Epistemology 2 [PHIL11093] (c) Courses Outside Philosophy and PG versions of UG courses You can take up to 40 credits of courses outside Philosophy as part of your optional courses provided that i) the courses are taught at the appropriate level, ii) they are philosophically relevant, either in general, or specifically for each of the offered specialisations, iii) there is space available, and iv) you obtain permission from both the MSc Director and the relevant course organiser. Details of these courses can be found here: Postgraduate Courses (Philosophy and Non-Philosophy) www.timetab.ed.ac.uk/TimetabPG.html You could also take, as part of your optional courses, up to 40 credits of the postgraduate version (level 11) of the undergraduate courses (level 10) taught by the Philosophy Department. Details of these courses are available here: MSc/Dip Philosophy 2010/2011 6 List of courses within Philosophy https://www.star.euclid.ed.ac.uk/ipp/cx_sb_phil.htm Please note that special assessment method and assessment criteria would be set up for these courses. (d) Auditing Courses Students can also choose to audit one or more courses (i.e. they attend the course but do not take any assessment for credit). The audit course study mode is called ‘Class Only’ and your records will reflect this type of enrolment. However, remember that you would need to get permission from your Programme Director and the Course Organiser of the course, who may, in some cases, request that you contribute to the course in some way—e.g., by giving a presentation—even if you are just auditing the course. Also some courses may be too full to allow for this type of enrolment. 3. Residence and Leave of Absence Students are expected to remain in residence throughout the two semesters. If you need to be absent you must get prior permission of the Programme Director. Students should also remain in or near the Edinburgh area during the summer months when writing their dissertation. If you need to carry out work elsewhere this must be cleared with your Programme Director and dissertation supervisor and there must be a mutually agreed schedule for supervision. You must also ensure that you remain in regular contact throughout your absence. Please refer to the relevant section of the PPLS Taught MSc Handbook for further guidance. 4. Other Academic Activities Our postgraduates are an important part of the philosophical community, and you are strongly encouraged to participate in the various seminars, colloquia, workshops and conferences hosted by the Department of Philosophy. A full list of these activities can be found here: Research Activities Hosted by the Department of Philosophy http://www.philosophy.ed.ac.uk/events/ Of these research activities, there are several regular research seminars that are worth highlighting: Postgraduate Work-in-Progress Seminar http://www.philosophy.ed.ac.uk/events/seminars/work-in-progress.html In this weekly seminar series, work is presented by postgraduates, faculty and, occasionally, visitors. All postgraduate students are strongly encouraged to attend. Postgraduate Professional Development and Research Training Seminars http://www.philosophy.ed.ac.uk/events/seminars/ProfessionalDevelopmentSe minars.html These seminars occur at regular intervals throughout the year and are meant MSc/Dip Philosophy 2010/2011 7 to provide additional training for postgraduates. Visiting Speaker Seminar http://www.philosophy.ed.ac.uk/events/seminars/friday-seminars.html Visiting faculty present papers. These meetings provide an opportunity to meet visiting philosophers and keep abreast of current research. All postgraduates are strongly encouraged to attend, and people often go out for drinks and dinner afterwards. University of Edinburgh Student Philosophy Society http://philsoc.tardis.ed.ac.uk/ The University of Edinburgh’s student Philosophy Society is extremely active and hosts a regular raft of visiting speakers and other events, such as study days. Philosophy, Psychology and Informatics Reading Group http://www.ppls.ed.ac.uk/ppig/index.htm Reading group which brings together researchers from PPLS and Informatics to discuss philosophically relevant empirical research. Faculty / PG Afternoon Tea Once a week, Philosophy staff and postgraduates meet for an informal chat over tea and biscuits. Meetings are held 3 - 4pm, in the 7th floor common room of the Dugald Stewart Building. Do also keep your eyes open for events hosted by other Departments that may be of relevance to your research. 5. Administration of the Programme The Philosophy’s Postgraduate Programme is part of the PPLS Graduate School. The Programme Director for the MSc/Dip in Philosophy is Dr. Alasdair Richmond (A.Richmond@ed.ac.uk). Any queries about the degree programme as a whole should be directed to him. As noted above, however, at an appropriate point in the degree programme you will be assigned a dissertation supervisor. This person will then be your principal contact regarding academic matters related to the specifics of your degree (e.g., the direction you should take in your research). Programme Director Office Hours for 2010/11: Tuesday’s 1pm to 2pm and by email appointment. Please note that all administration for this degree programme is handled by the PPLS Postgraduate Office. If you have an inquiry of a purely administrative nature, then please contact Lynsey Buchanan (lynsey.buchanan@ed.ac.uk) who is the PPLS administrator who deals with this degree programme. Dr. Jesper Kallestrup (jesper.kallestrup@ed.ac.uk) is the Philosophy Postgraduate Director, with responsibility for the Philosophy Postgraduate Programmes as a whole. The Postgraduate Director of Studies for PPLS, who has responsibility for the PPLS Postgraduate Programmes as a whole, is Prof Simon Kirby in Semester 1 (simon@ling.ed.ac.uk) and Professor Duncan Pritchard in Semester 2 (duncan.pritchard@ed.ac.uk). MSc/Dip Philosophy 2010/2011 6. 8 Assessment (a) Coursework Essays Semesters 1 and 2 Each individual MSc course within Philosophy is normally assessed by means of an approximate 2500 word essay. The course teachers will provide a list of essay questions (or you may negotiate a title of your preference, with the discretion of the course teacher). Please note that essays that are more than 10% over the maximum recommended essay length (not including footnotes and references) may be penalised. For postgraduate Philosophy courses owned by the School of Philosophy, Psychology and Language Sciences, each essay must be handed in to the PPLS Postgraduate Office (Room 1.06, Dugald Stewart Building) by 4pm of the appropriate deadline. All coursework should have a cover sheet attached. The deadlines are as follows: Coursework Deadlines Semester 1 Courses: Thursday 9th December 2010 Semester 2 Courses: Monday 28th March 2011 Further guidance on PPLS assessment submission can be found in the relevant section of the PPLS Taught MSc Handbook. For postgraduate courses owned by other Schools or subject areas, students should be aware that these courses will have their own separate methods of assessment and deadlines. It is the responsibility of the students to find out the correct assessment information for all of their courses from the Course Organisers. (b) Dissertations The deadline for handing in completed dissertations to the PPLS Postgraduate Office is as follows: Dissertation Deadline Friday 19th August 2011 by 4pm For further information on dissertations, please see the relevant section of your PPLS Taught MSc Handbook (e) Postgraduate Common Marking Scheme Please see the relevant section of the PPLS Taught MSc Handbook. Students should be aware that marks for assessed coursework and dissertations are provisional, and may be modified when considered at the Board of Examiners meeting. The External Examiner is involved in this process (e.g. in considering borderline and disputed cases) and determining that overall assessment decisions are of an appropriate standard. (f) Extensions See the relevant section of the PPLS Taught MSc Handbook. (g) Penalties See relevant section of the PPLS Taught MSc Handbook. MSc/Dip Philosophy 2010/2011 7. 9 Plagiarism and Referencing The guidance given below is intended to clear up any misunderstandings you may have about plagiarism in relation to Philosophy. The University’s general guidance for students about plagiarism can be found here: University of Edinburgh’s Guidance on Plagiarism www.aaps.ed.ac.uk/regulations/Plagiarism/Intro.htm This guidance includes the University’s procedures for dealing with different kinds of plagiarism and advice about what to do if you are accused of plagiarism. If, having read these guidance notes, you are still unsure about how to avoid plagiarism, then you should approach the Programme Director for further advice. The key to avoiding plagiarism is to make sure that you give correct references for anything that you have taken from other sources to include in your academic work. This might include, for example, any ideas, theories, findings, images, diagrams or direct quotations that you have used. Note also that you are not permitted to submit the same essay, or even parts of the same essay, for two distinct courses. In Philosophy we expect you to use something similar to one of the systems commonly used in the humanities and social sciences such as Chicago, APA, MLA, or Turabian (see http://www.lib.duke.edu/libguide/works_cited.htm for details; note that no one system dominates in philosophy journals or amongst philosophy publishers). You should use one of these systems to signal, within the text of your work, the origins of any material taken from another source, even if you have put it into your own words. If you take any material word for word from another source it is essential that you make it clear to your reader that this is what you have done. If you take material from another source, change a few words and then include the reference you may still have committed a plagiarism offence because you have not made it clear to your reader that you have essentially reproduced part of the original source. You should either express the ideas fully in your own words and give the reference or else use clearly labelled direct quotes. Bear in mind that if you include too many direct quotes in your work this may reduce your grade, as the marker will find it difficult to see evidence of your own understanding of the topic. You must also include a references section at the end of your work that provides the full details of all of the sources cited within the text. You should be aware that, for work done in your other subject areas, you might be expected to use a different referencing system. Numerous websites give further guidance on plagiarism. Here are some that you may find useful: www.princeton.edu/pr/pub/integrity/pages/plagiarism.html http://dissc.tees.ac.uk/Plagiarism/Plag-4.htm www.utexas.edu/lbj/students/writing/plagiarism.pdf Please also refer to the relevant section of the PPLS Taught MSc Handbook. Referencing For an excellent example of a referencing system for bibliographic entries at the end of one’s essay, take a look at the following: The Philosophical Review’s Stylesheet www.arts.cornell.edu/philrev/info/stylesheet.html MSc/Dip Philosophy 2010/2011 8. 10 Appeals Procedures for academic appeals are described in section 10.3 of the Code of Practice for Taught Postgraduate Programmes. 9. Academic Staff For a list of current members of staff in the Department of Philosophy and their research interests please consult the Department’s website: Department of Philosophy Staff Listing http://www.ppls.ed.ac.uk/philosophy/people You should refer to this list when choosing a dissertation topic. Please be aware that members of the department who are on leave will not be available to supervise dissertations. 10. Support and Guidance The Programme Director, Dr. Alasdair Richmond (A.Richmond@ed.ac.uk), is available as a first line of pastoral support and advice for any scholarly or personal issues which may arise whilst you are on the Programme. It is your responsibility to inform the Programme Director immediately of any problems that are interfering with your coursework or progress through the Programme, including any religious or medical requirements that might affect your participation in any aspect of the Programme. In addition, you should feel free to discuss problems of a personal or scholarly nature with your dissertation supervisor. (See the Code of Practice for Taught Postgraduate Programmes for more details regarding the rights and responsibilities of students and supervisors). Alternatively, you may contact either Dr. Jesper Kallestrup (jesper.kallestrup@ed.ac.uk), the Philosophy Postgraduate Director, or Lynsey Buchanan (lynsey.buchanan@ed.ac.uk) in the PPLS Postgraduate Office. Additional Academic Support Advice on Study Skills is available from the Centre for Teaching, Learning and Assessment. The relevant webpage is below for information: Centre for Teaching, Learning and Assessment www.tla.ed.ac.uk/ Other sources of specialist academic and pastoral support are listed in Appendix III of the Code of Practice for Taught Postgraduate Programmes. 11. Student Feedback and Representation Student feedback and evaluation is a valued input to curriculum and programme review and development at the University of Edinburgh. You will be asked to complete an evaluation form for each of the courses that you take. Students are also strongly advised to complete the annual University questionnaire for taught postgraduate students, details of which will be made available during May/June. Informal feedback is of course welcome at any time. MSc/Dip Philosophy 2010/2011 11 Feedback forms for completion can be found on the PPLS Postgraduate webpages http://www.ppls.ed.ac.uk/students/postgraduate/taught_research_masters.php#Evalu ations Postgraduate Representatives There are two postgraduate representatives for philosophy who attend Departmental staff meetings to represent postgraduate interests and raise concerns or questions from Philosophy postgraduate students. They can also, via the PPLS school representatives, raise issues at school level. Representatives are also welcome to participate in the Edinburgh University Students’ Association. The philosophy postgraduate representatives for this year will be confirmed at the beginning of semester 1. Philosophy Postgraduate Staff-Student Consultative Committee This meets three times a year and represents a more formal opportunity for staff and postgraduate students to meet and discuss the Department’s postgraduate provision. The members of faculty who attend this committee are: Dr. Jesper Kallestrup (Philosophy Postgraduate Director and MSc by Research Philosophy Programme Director) Dr. Alasdair Richmond (MSc/Dip Philosophy Programme Director and Philosophy Assistant Director of Graduate Studies) Prof. Mike Ridge (MSc by Research Ethics & Political Philosophy Programme Director) Dr. Inna Kupreeva (MSc/Dip Ancient Philosophy Programme Director) Dr Julian Kiverstein (MSc/Dip Mind, Language & Embodied Cognition Programme Director) The student members of this committee include the two Philosophy postgraduate representatives (see above) and a representative selection of other Philosophy postgraduate students (e.g., at least one taught MSc student, at least one first-year PhD student, and so on). There are typically around six student members of this committee. Complaints If you have a complaint regarding your degree programme, then you should in the first instance contact the Programme Director, Dr. Alasdair Richmond (A.Richmond@ed.ac.uk). Dr. Jesper Kallestrup is the Philosophy Postgraduate Director (jesper.kallestrup@ed.ac.uk), Professor Andy Clark is the Head of the Department of Philosophy (andy.clark@ed.ac.uk), and Dr. Andy McKinlay is the Head of the School of Philosophy, Psychology and Language Sciences (hos.ppls@ed.ac.uk). 12. Facilities Teaching Rooms In general, most classes are taught in the Dugald Stewart Building and George Square area. However, it should be noted that courses provided by other Schools may be taught elsewhere in the university. MSc/Dip Philosophy 2010/2011 12 Computing Support The Dugald Stewart Building houses a computing lab on the 1st floor (Room 1.16) that students automatically have day access to once fully matriculated (from 9am– 5pm). Out of hours and weekend access can be gained by completing an Induction Tour of the building. Induction Tours for Philosophy students will be held on Thursday 16th September 2010 starting in the Dugald Stewart Building Common Room (7th floor). Students can either attend the 11.00am - 12 noon session OR 12 noon - 1.00pm but only attend the tour session that they have confirmed with the PG Office via email prior to arrival. If you do not attend the Induction Tour your out of hour’s swipe card access will be revoked. The College of Humanities and Social Science also have various suites of computer labs for use by Postgraduates. Information about these 'Open Access' labs can be found on the Computing Services website: http://www.ucs.ed.ac.uk/fmd/central_labs.html Some of these have restricted usage, but the HSS Support team recommend the use of the Computer Labs in the Main University Library, George Square. They can be contacted on Tel.50 3000. Other Departmental Rooms Students are also encouraged to use the following rooms within the Dugald Stewart Building; Common Room on the 7th Floor: A place to meet other postgraduate students and members of the School, have lunch, coffee, reading when it’s quiet etc. G.03 study room. Available as a quiet study space for all taught students in LEL/Philosophy. See the Postgraduate Office for the door code. Mail Any mail for you will be left with the PPLS PG Office. You will receive an email from the PG Office when your mail has been delivered and is ready for collection. Libraries There are three libraries in Edinburgh, which are likely to be the main sources of information, books, etc. Others include the libraries in other Departments. The City of Edinburgh also has a good lending library on George IV Bridge. The Main University Library This is the University’s main collection of humanities books and manuscripts, as well as many books in science and mathematics. The main science and maths library is the James Clerk Maxwell library at King’s Buildings. The Haldane Library This is the Department of Philosophy’s library, which has a limited stock of philosophy books. It is now combined with the Psychology Library and is housed in the Psychology building on the North side of George Square (7 George Square). Graduate students are entitled to borrow books. Please note that these must be returned after one month. MSc/Dip Philosophy 2010/2011 13 The National Library of Scotland A copyright library, this is Scotland’s main research library, and is located on George IV Bridge. You will probably not need to use it, but if you do, their website http://www.nls.uk/ has details about how to get a reader’s ticket (you need to bring your University card with you and proof of your address e.g. from a utility bill, bank statement etc). Out of hours and weekend access to the Haldane library Students should be aware that they need to attend a Health & Safety Induction and Tour of the Psychology Building if they would like out of hours and weekend access to the Haldane Library in Psychology Building (7 George Square). Tour sessions will be confirmed early in Semester 1. Dr. Alasdair Richmond Director of MSc Programme in Philosophy Department of Philosophy University of Edinburgh July 2010