Introduction In partnership with the company Trexima Zlín, the Czech Ministry of Industry and Trade (MIT) conducted a survey of labor costs in businesses that are overseen by the Ministry. This survey looked at overall industry wages in 2005, as well as the historical trends in these wages over the period from 2002 through 2005. The survey also included an examination of the compensation received by the various management levels of the businesses in these industries overseen by the Ministry. The more detailed monitoring and analysis of the trends in the changes of labor costs and management compensation in these companies is seen to be of increasing importance – especially with respect to the Czech Republic's membership in the EU and its integration into the labor and industry market structures of a unified EU. 1. Labor Cost Levels in the Industries Covered by the Ministry of Industry and Trade during 2005 and Developments since 2002 The labor cost survey was conducted on the basis of a statistical sample and looked at the trends in the wages paid by the businesses and organizations that fall within the MIT pool of businesses during both 2005 and over the 2002 – 2005 period. The data was compared to the average labor costs applicable across the entire Czech economy. For 2005, the survey covered between 705,000-814,000 employees from 2,512-3,111 businesses – all of which fell within the MIT pool of businesses. The character and the size of the sample groups captured sufficient data to permit regional breakdowns of the industries looked at. The average hourly wage paid by the businesses within the MIT pool of businesses showed the following trends over the period from 2002-2005. In 2002, the average hourly wage indicator saw a year-to-year change of + 5.7% and the average wage in 2002 was CZK 99.31/hour. In 2003, the wage indicator showed a year-to-year change of + 6.3%, resulting in an average wage of CZK 105.53/hour in that year. In 2004, the year-to-year change dropped to + 5.2% and the average wage reached CZK 111.00/hour. In 2005, the data showed a year-toyear wage increase of + 4.5% and the average wage reached the level of CZK 115.95/hour. The overall average hourly wages paid to the employees of the businesses that are part of the MIT pool of businesses grew by 16.8% over the survey period. In the same period, the average hourly wages paid by the businesses across the entire Czech economy grew by 18.8%. In terms of the growth rate of average wages in the 2001-2004 period, the most significant growth took place in the 'manufacture of building supplies' sector (+ 28.7%). The 1 03200 – Department of Economic Policies lowest level of growth, on the other hand, for average wages was seen in the 'tourism' industry sector (+ 0.4%). In 2005, the highest average wages were reported in the energy sector (CZK 167.85/hour) and the lowest average wages were paid in the textile industry (CZK 69.06/hour). Over the 2002-2005 period, the disparity between the average wages paid within the MIT pool of businesses and the average wages for the entire domestic economy widened. In 2005, the average wages paid by businesses within the MIT pool of businesses were at the level of 95.4% of the average wages reported for the businesses across the entire domestic economy. In 2002, this ratio had been at a level of 97.5%. 2 03200 – Department of Economic Policies Average Hourly Wage Data for 2002-2005 (Comparison between the Industries Covered by MIT and the Overall Economy) Chart Legend: Axis: (vertical) Average Hourly Wage (CZK/hour) (horizontal) Quarters (of the year) (left to right) MIT Industry Pool Overall Domestic Economy Annual Average – Domestic Economy Annual Average – MIT Industry Pool In a breakdown by region of the wages paid by businesses that make up the overall domestic economy versus the wages paid by the businesses that are part of the MIT pool of businesses, there was a substantial variation in disparity levels. For example, the wages paid by the MIT pool of businesses were at an 87.0% level in Prague, while the same comparison reversed and went to 104.2% in Central Bohemia. The greatest increase in wages over the 2002-2005 period was seen in the Vysočina Region (+ 22.3%) and the Central Bohemia Region (+ 21.0 %), followed by the South Moravia Region (+ 20.5%). The lowest level of wage increases was reported in the Hradec Králové Region, where the increase was 14.0%, followed by the Moravia-Silesia Region, where wages grew by 14.4%. The earnings multiple (wage gap) between the 12th (lowest) and the 1st (highest) wage levels in the Czech economy increased to 5.41 in 2002 and to 5.79 in 2003. In 2004, the multiple dropped slightly to a level of 5.76. In 2005, the earnings multiple reversed and went back up again, increasing to a multiple of 5.92. The trend indicates that the differentiation in the wage multiple is being widened in favor of more highly qualified (or skilled) labor. When broken out into the individual wage levels, the greatest growth can be seen in the lowest 12th and 11th levels as well as at the top 1st wage level. The least growth was seen in the 6th wage level. The average wages paid to the employees in the businesses that are part of the MIT pool of businesses in 2005 – based on the level of education – ranged from a low of CZK 13,241/month for employees with a basic or unfinished (high school) education to a high of CZK 39,377/month for employees with a college degree. 3 03200 – Department of Economic Policies When broken down into age categories, the highest average wages in 2005 was paid to workers in the 60+ age group (CZK 129.78/hour) and in the 30-39 age group (CZK 122.51/hour). The lowest wages were paid to the 20 and below age group (CZK 65.69/hour). When analyzed from the perspective of the size of the business, the data shows that in the 2002-2005 period, the highest average wages were paid by businesses with 5,000 or more employees. The lowest wage levels tended to be found in businesses with 24 or fewer employees. The businesses that are part of the MIT pool of businesses reported having paid lower wages to women (CZK 91.11/hour) than to men (CZK 131.50/hour) in 2005. In 2005, the average wages paid to female workers reached a level equal to 69.1% of the average wages paid to male workers. In a comparison of male and female wages paid to businesses in the overall Czech economy, versus wages paid in the particular businesses that make up the MIT pool, men in the overall economy received wages that averaged 3.1% higher and women received wages that were approximately 10.0% higher – i.e. the businesses that make up the MIT pool tended to pay lower wages across the board. 2. Compensation of Management in Businesses within the MIT Industry Pool in 2005 The survey looked at the gross salaries paid to those individuals employed by the businesses that are part of the MIT pool of businesses who held a management position in 2005, based on the KZAM–R classification. The sample pool contained data on the earnings of 30,253 managers (of whom 9,668 are women). The sample represented a total of 1,656 businesses that fall within the MIT pool of businesses. The management staff was broken out for positions in the top three of the (above identified) compensation levels. The 1st management level refers to senior management. The 2nd management level includes managers who directly report to senior management and who manage their own staffs. The 3rd management level includes managers and supervisors who directly report to 2nd level management and who also manage/supervise their own staffs. 4 03200 – Department of Economic Policies The data collected shows that generally, there has been an increase in the number of managers employed by these businesses. In 2004 the average number of management staff employed by the businesses that are part of the MIT pool of businesses was 20. By 2005, this number had increased by 1 person at the 3rd management level and the total average size of the management staff grew to 21 (vs. 20) persons (1 person at the 1st management level, 3 persons at the 2nd management level and 17 persons at the 3rd management level). The size and the structure of the management staff primarily depended on the size of the company. Companies employing 99 or fewer staff were on average led by a 3-member management team (the same as in 2004). Large companies with more than 3,000 employees were on average run by 293 managers, positioned at the surveyed management levels (vs. 213 managers/supervisors in 2004). In 2005, the average salary paid to the managers located the 1st, 2nd and 3rd management levels and employed by the businesses within the MIT pool of businesses was CZK 614,000/year – i.e. CZK 51,167/month. In 2005, the growth rate in the average salary paid to management dropped to the level of + 1.8% (from + 7.1% in 2004). In 2005, the salary growth rate ranged from + 3.1% for the 3rd management level to roughly + 5.3% growth at the 1st management level. Within the MIT pool of businesses, management salaries went up by + 1.8% and across the entire domestic economy, the rate of growth was + 1.3%. The size of the management salaries was seen to be correlated to the following: The size of the business, the average wage paid by the company, the longer term profitability trends in the business within the respective industry and the type of ownership and the overall profitability profile of the company. A strong relationship to the above factors was especially evident in the 1st management level – i.e. senior management. In 2005, the highest average salaries were paid to the senior management of business with 1,000-2,999 employees and to the deputy directors and professional directors of businesses with 3,000 and more employees. The highest salary levels (CZK 821,000/year or CZK 68,415/month) were paid to the management of companies where the average salary paid to the employees of these companies was above CZK 20,000/month. 5 03200 – Department of Economic Policies The lowest paid group were the managers of co-ops whose average annual earnings (CZK 817,000 or CZK 68,000/month at the 1st management level; CZK 576,000 or CZK 48,000/month at the 2nd management level; and, CZK 195,000 or CZK 16,300/month at the 3rd management level) did not even reach a level corresponding to 50% of the salary levels paid to their counterparts in their sector. Substantial differences were evident between the salaries at the 2nd and the 3rd management levels. In the category of professional directors and deputy directors (2nd management level), the highest salaries (CZK 1,153,000/year or 96,083/month) were traditionally paid to chief financial officers, followed by human resource directors (CZK 1,112,000/year or 92,666/month) and marketing directors (CZK 1,102,000/year or 91,833/month). The lowest salaries were paid to the technical directors and investment officers (CZK 907,000/year or 75,583/month) who replaced the operations managers, who previously ranked in this bottom position. In the data analyzed from the 2005 sample, the average annual salary paid to a manager (without any differentiation for the different management levels) corresponded to 237.1% of the average salary paid by businesses and companies within the MIT pool of businesses (a management salary at the 1st management level had a multiple of 6.237, the 2nd management level had a multiple of 4.202 and the 3rd management level had a multiple of 1.973). In terms of the businesses across the entire domestic economy, the average management salary reached a level corresponding to 239.5 % of the average wage. 6 03200 – Department of Economic Policies Comparison of Management Compensation at the Different Levels of Management (Both MIT Pool and Overall Economy) (in %) Chart Legend: Axis: (vertical) Relationship in % (horizontal) Year (left to right) 1st Management Level 2nd Management Level 3rd Management Level The average management salary had the following breakdown: Base salary – 64.93%; premiums and bonuses – 23.69%; extras and additional payments – 2.45%; other salary items – 0.04%; and, reimbursements – 8.85%. The percentage breakdowns for these salaries varied across the individual management levels. The salary structure showed a trend where the base salary component was increasing at the expense of premiums and bonuses (the change was roughly 0.5 percent). Women represented 32.1% of the management employed by businesses within the MIT pool of businesses (vs. 32.4% across the entire economy). In terms of the differences between male and female salaries, the average salary paid to female managers reached only 62.1% of that paid to men at the 1st management level; 73.5% at the 2nd management level; and, 53.1% at the 3rd management level. The majority of the management positions staffed by women 7 03200 – Department of Economic Policies were at the 3rd management level (internal department managers), with companies having over 500 employees and with an average salary of CZK 200,000/year or 16,667/month (domestic employers). 8 03200 – Department of Economic Policies