November 11, 2005 To: Chairs Directors Deans Departmental Assistants Subject: CUPE Local 4904 Unit 3 – Invigilators As you are all aware, while invigilation responsibilities continue to be an obligation and responsibility of the faculty member or instructor, additional support may be required from time to time. In these circumstances, individuals hired, as invigilators will automatically become members of CUPE, Local 3904, Unit 3. Background Information: It has been the University’s position that individuals who are hired solely and exclusively to proctor tests, midterms, quizzes and exams are to be paid the TA – Category 2 rate ($14 per hour for the 2005/2006 academic year and $15 per hour for the 2006/07 academic year) for any hours worked. In addition, it is the University’s position that individuals who received an Assistantship appointment and are required to carry out a number of assistantship duties (such as tutoring, supervising labs, student counseling, etc), including proctoring tests, midterms, quizzes and exams are to receive the appropriate payment outlined in Article 20.02 of the Collective Agreement (based on their status and/or or academic qualifications they possess – Master rate, PhD rate or TA undergraduate rate). The Union raised issues with respect to the University’s position regarding individuals who are hired solely and exclusively to proctor terms, midterms, quizzes and exams and are paid the TA-Category 2 rate. Current Status: In order to address the University’s needs with respect to consolidated examinations scheduled in a common venue (e.g. the Ryerson gym and the Metro Toronto Convention Centre) and in order to resolve the issues between the parties the University and the Union agreed to the following with respect to qualifications, posting, and pay rates: Position Title and Position Duties Individuals hired solely and exclusively to carry out invigilation responsibilities will be referred to as “Exam Invigilators” and they will carry 1 out the position duties and possess the competencies as reflected in Attachment A. Collective Agreement Provisions All applicable provisions of the 2004-2007 collective agreement will apply to “Exam Invigilators”, except as stated in this communication. Posting and Selection Details The University will post Exam Invigilator positions pursuant to Article 11 of the Collective Agreement. The Academic Integrity Officer or his/her designate will evaluate applicants and determine appointments for the position vacancies. The Academic Integrity Officer or his/her designate will evaluate the applicants based on the qualifications and criteria stated below, and determine appointments: i) ii) iii) iv) v) enrolment in a Masters or Ph.D. programme academic status of the candidate, such that greater preference within the Department/School is accorded in order of priority, first to Doctoral candidates, then Master’s candidates; academic performance; relevant experience, which is defined as any experience(s) that can be applied or deemed useful to the duties and responsibilities of an Exam Invigilator; and previous positive evaluation of performance as an Exam Invigilator at the University, if applicable. If there are posted Exam Invigilator vacancies unfilled following the posting procedures the Academic Integrity Officer or his/her designate will fill the unfilled vacancies in an appropriate manner. The parties understand and agree that greater preference is accorded in order of priority, first to Ryerson Doctoral candidates, then Ryerson Master’s candidates, and then non-Ryerson students/individuals. Performance Assessment The Exam Supervisor will complete a performance evaluation of the employee in accordance with the Performance Evaluation Form attached as Attachment B. The Exam Invigilator will be assessed after each examination session. A copy of this assessment will be sent to the employee, with a copy to the Union. Should the Employee have any concerns regarding the performance review he may discuss his/her concerns with his/her Exam Supervisor or with the Academic Integrity Officer. 2 Training/Orientation Session Exam Invigilators will be required to complete a mandatory one-hour “invigilation” training session, prior to carrying out invigilation duties. The University will pay for such time and the employee will receive their appropriate hourly rate of pay for such time. The Academic Integrity office will coordinate this training session. Rates of Pay For any particular term/semester, should an individual obtain a Teaching Assistant appointment (and carries out an appropriate combination of duties, including proctoring/invigilating duties, as outlined in article 12.01 of the Collective Agreement), and such individual in addition receives an additional appointment(s) as an Exam Invigilator he/she shall maintain his/her Teaching Assistant rate of pay (i.e. Master, Ph.D. TA – Category 1 rate of pay) with respect to his/her Exam Invigilation appointment(s). The applicable rates of pay can be found in Article 20.02 of the Collective Agreement or at http://www.ryerson.ca/working/employees/collectiveagreements/collect3904u 3/index.html . Should an individual be employed only as an Exam Invigilator he/she shall be paid $17.00 per hour for the time period September 1, 2005 to August 31, 2006, and $18.00 per hour for the time period September 1, 2006 to August 31, 2007. Count towards Maximum Hours of Work As you know, a TA/GA can normally work an average of 10 hours per week over the three terms of the academic year to a maximum of 130 hours per term or 390 hours per academic year. An exception exists where a TA/GA can work up to 195 hours one term provided he/she does not work more than 65 hours in each of the other two terms in the academic year, for a total of 325 hours in an academic year. Normally, in other circumstances the TA/GA can work up to 130 hours in a term or 390 hours per academic year. Please note that individuals who are hired, solely and exclusively as Exam Invigilators and who hold an active appointment as a Teaching/Graduate Assistant the Exam Invigilator hours will not count towards the maximum semester/academic year hours described above ( and outlined in Article 1, Definitions, specifically clause 1.05 and Article 13, Workload and Hours of Work provisions of the collective agreement). This exemption will apply whether the current Teaching/Graduate Assistant appointment includes or does not include a requirement for exam invigilation duties The above is effective the Fall 2005 term and shall expire August 31, 2007. Any individuals hired as Exam Invigilators for the Fall term and have not received the above noted pay rate will receive a retroactive pay adjustment as soon as reasonably possible. 3 Administrative Details: i) The following administrative details apply in cases where Department/Schools have the direct responsibility to hire Exam Invigilators. (It does not include the hiring of Exam Invigilators for mass examinations scheduled in a common venue). In cases where the successful applicant is not currently employed as a Teaching/Graduate Assistant Departments/Schools can use the automated system, TAGA, to hire Exam Invigilators. The system provides the following features: creation of job postings; on-line application for candidates; on-line access to applications for screening and rating of applicants; maintenance of seniority credits; generation of Workload Confirmation form for appointments, with associated workload details; and Generation of Workload Confirmation form for workload changes. Please note in the above case where an individual obtains only an Exam Invigilation appointment (and is not hired as a Teaching/Graduate Assistant) Department/Schools are required to submit timesheets indicating the actual hours the individual has worked so that appropriate payment can occur. ii) In cases where the successful applicant has an active/current Teaching/Graduate Assistantship and the individual obtains a separate Exam Invigilation Appointment Departments/Schools are requested to complete the Assistantship Revision Workload Confirmation Form (http://www.ryerson.ca/working/employees/collectiveagreements/collect3 904u3/index.html ) in order to process and ensure payment for the additional Exam Invigilation hours. The normal process with respect to distribution/processing continues to apply with respect to the Exam Invigilation hours. In cases where Departments/Schools do not have the direct responsibility to hire Exam Invigilators, e.g. in the case of a common venue such as the Ryerson gym and Metro Convention Centre, the Academic Integrity office will be coordinating the activities with respect to hiring and payment of such individuals. Your appropriate contacts with respect to questions are outlined below: Issue Training with respect to TAGA Individual Meredith Englander, HR Contact Information M2englan@ryerson.ca or at extension 4143 4 CUPE Local 3904 Unit 3 Collective Agreement interpretation Forms and process questions Exam Invigilation in a common venue Systems User Documentation & Training Specialist Human Resources http://www.ryerson.ca/working/contact.html#hrs Consultant Human Resources Services Advisor Donna Bell, Academic Integrity Officer http://www.ryerson.ca/working/contact.html#hrs dbell@ryerson.ca or at extension 5011 Nellie De Lorenzi Manager, Employee Relations /attachments 5