Instituto de Ciências
Sociais
Universidade de Lisboa
ASIA-EUROPE DEMOCRATISATION AND JUSTICE SERIES
NEW TRENDS IN POLITICAL FINANCING REGULATION IN ASIA AND EUROPE:
THE NEW ROLE OF MONITORING & ENFORCEMENT BODIES
Lisbon, 18-19 Fevereiro 2010
ICS/Universidade de Lisboa or Auditório AR
CONFERENCE CO-ORDINATORS:
ORGANIZATION:
COLLABORATION:
PARTICIPANTS:
Luís de Sousa, ICS/UL and Natalia Figge, ASEF
Instituto de Ciências Sociais of the University of Lisbon and Asia Europe
Foundation.
Council of Europe, GRECO – Group of States against Corruption,
Assembleia da República Portuguesa, Transparency International.
35 Asian and European experts from relevant bodies in ASEM ministries,
practitioners in the field of political financing and representatives from
international and regional institutions (such as relevant bodies in the
Council of Europe, the ASEAN Secretariat, the EC) national and
international NGOs, the academe, think tanks, research institutes and
the media.
DRAFT PROGRAMME
DAY I, THURSDAY 18 FEBRUARY
REGISTRATION
(9:00)
WELCOME TO PARTICIPANTS
(9:30)
Jorge Vala (Director of ICS/UL, Portugal)
Sol Iglesias (Director of the Intellectual Exchange Department, ASEF) and Luís de Sousa (ICS/UL,
Portugal)
KEYNOTE ADDRESS
(10:00)
President of the Portuguese Assembleia da República,
Mr. Jaime Gama
(TBC)
SESSION 1. SETTING STANDARDS IN COUNTRIES UNDERGOING POLITICAL TRANSITION
(10:45-12:45)
Chair: António Costa Pinto (Chairperson of the Portuguese Political Science Association)
Rei Shiratori
President of the Institute for Political Studies, Japan
“Party System Emergence and Consolidation in Transitional Countries in Asia”
1
Instituto de Ciências
Sociais
Universidade de Lisboa
Goran Fejic
Senior Adviser to the Secretary-Generals Office, IDEA, Sweden
“Democracy and the challenge of illicit political financing”
Christophe Speckbacher
Head of Section – GRECO Secretariat
“Political financing: an overview of shortcomings and best practices identified in GRECO country reports
so far”
Debate
Lunch
SESSION 2. INSTITUTIONAL INNOVATION, PERFORMANCE AND CAPACITY BUILDING
(14:15-16:00)
Chair: Manuel Meirinho (ISCSP/Universidade Técnica de Lisboa, Portugal)
Tai-Hwan Lee
Senior Research Fellow at Regional Studies Program, Sejong Institute, Korea
“Enforcement aspects in Asian Political Financing Regulatory Regimes”
Miguel Fernandes
Former President of the Entidade das Contas e Financiamentos Políticos, Portugal
“Political Financing Supervisory Bodies as Innovative Responses to Political Financing”
Coffee break
Hadar Gumay
Executive Director of the Centre for Electoral Reform (CETRO), Indonesia
“The Role of Election Monitoring Organisations”
Debate
ROUNDTABLE 1. THE ROLE OF SUPERVISORY BODIES: MISSION, COMPETENCES, INDEPENDENCE, GUARANTEES,
INTERINSTITUTIONAL COOPERATION AND ENFORCEMENT
(16:00-17:30)
Chair: Luís de Sousa (ICS/UL, Portugal)
Roundtable PFSB participants
(see list below)
Q&A
********************
2
Instituto de Ciências
Sociais
Universidade de Lisboa
DAY II, FRIDAY 19 FEBRUARY
SESSION 3. THE WATCHDOG ROLE OF CIVIL SOCIETY: POTENTIAL, APPLICATION AND LIMITS
(9:00-11:00)
Chair: Balint Molnar (Freedom House Europe)
Navraj Singh Ghaleigh
Law School, University of Edinburgh, UK
“New Media – A Tool to Help Civil Society Monitoring Political Financing?”
Damaso Magbual
Chairman of ANFREL (Asian Network for Free Elections), Philippines
“Civil Society in Asia as a Watchdog – Electoral Monitoring”
Coffee break
Justin Fisher
Director of Magna Carta Institute, Brunel University, UK
“The Limits of Civil Society in Monitoring Political Finance”
Debate
ROUNDTABLE 2. ANCHORING THE MONITORING AND REGULATORY ACTION OF POLITICAL FINANCING SUPERVISORY BODIES
IN CIVIL SOCIETY
(11:00-12:30)
Chair: Tinatin Ninua (Transparency International – Political Corruption Programme)
Roundtable PFSB participants
(see list below)
Q&A
Lunch
SESSION 4. COMPARATIVE AND REGIONAL REGULATORY REFORMS
(14:00-15:40)
Chair: Goran Fejic (Senior Adviser to the Secretary-Generals Office, IDEA, Sweden)
Eswaran Sridharan
Academic Director of the University of Pennsylvania Institute for the Advanced Study of India (UPIASI),
India
“Regulatory reforms on party and election financing in India and Asian in comparative perspective”
Tinatin Ninua
Transparency International – Political Corruption Programme
“Political finance regulations: bridging the enforcement gap. Comparative findings from Bangladesh,
Indonesia and Nepal”
Wojciech Gagatek
Institute of Political Science, Warsaw University, Poland
3
Instituto de Ciências
Sociais
Universidade de Lisboa
“Political financing regulation at the supranational Level: lessons drawn from the EU”
Debate
Coffee break
CONCLUSIONS
(16:15-16:40)
Rapporteur: Natalia Figge (ASEF)
“Presentation of main outcomes of the various plenary sessions and roundtables discussions”
NEXT STEPS: 10 GUIDING PRINCIPLES FOR THE INSTITUTIONAL CAPACITATION OF SUPERVISORY BODIES
(16:40-17:00)
Rapporteur: Luís de Sousa (ICS/UL, Portugal)
CLOSING REMARKS
(17:00-17:30)
ASEF Executive Officer
(TBC)
************************
4
Instituto de Ciências
Sociais
Universidade de Lisboa
LIST OF ROUNDTABLE PARTICIPANTS
EUROPEAN PFSB
ASIAN PFSB
UNITED KINGDOM
Stephen Rooney, Director of Communication, The
Electoral Commission
INDIA
S.Y. Quraishi, Election Commissioner of India
THAILAND
Apichart Sukhagganond, Chairman
Office of the Election Commission of Thailand,
IRELAND
David Waddell, Secretary, Standards in Public
Office Commission
PHILIPPINES
Jose A.R. Melo, Chairman
Commission on Elections (COMELEC),
LATVIA
Natalja Titova, Division of Control of Financing of
Political Parties, Latvian Anti-Corruption Bureau
(KNAB)
INDONESIA
Abdul Hafiz Anshary, Chairman,
General Election Commission (KPU)
PORTUGAL
Margarida Salema, Entidade das Contas e
Financiamentos Políticos, Tribunal Constitucional
JAPAN
Ms Department, Election Administration
Committee, Tokyo Metropolitan Government
SLOVENIA
Igor Šoltes, Chairman, Court of Audit
5