McLuhan, Marshall & Powers, Bruce R. The Global Village: Transformations in
World Life and Media in the 21
Press, Inc., 1989. st Century. New York: Oxford University
Key Terms:
left-brain thinking: linear; systematic; sequential; fixed boundaries; visual; pertaining to the “ground”
right-brain thinking: without boundaries; simultaneous; acoustic; pertaining to the
“figure”
ground: provides setting (background) in which to perceive figure; subliminal
figure: “geometric construct” (71); the medium
visual space: tangible; fragmented
acoustic space: intangible; integrated
artifact: medium of communication (eg: words)
archetype: the original model after which new models are formed
Chapter 1 – “The Resonating Interval:”
resonating interval exposes relationship between figure and ground
four-fold process of transformation of the artifact: tetrad
Tetrad o main purpose: to expose hidden ground, providing context in which to understand the artifact o allows simultaneous understanding of visual and acoustic space o composed of a set of testable questions:
1.
“What does any artifact enlarge or enhance ?
2.
What does it erode or obsolesce ?
3.
What does it retrieve that had been earlier obsolesced?
4.
What does it reverse or flip into when pushed to the limits of its
potential?” (9) o eliminates fragmentation of process of understanding – reveals the whole o allows humans to think about the effects of the artifact
“Technological enlargement is a process toward excess… man should make as his first object
the recognition of pattern as a means to avoid excess and achieve equilibrium.” (12)
“The medium is the message.” (6) o medium – the technology and what comes along with it o reshapes the “ground”
Chapter 2 – “The Wheel and the Axle:”
Western communication and education is too linear – the tetrad serves to provide a balance between left and right
new divergence in Western society from traditionally visual understanding of the message – newfound emphasis on the relationship of the acoustic space to the visual space
fragmented nature of phonetic alphabet o devastating effects of phonetic alphabet on traditionally oral Greek communications o visual emphasis of alphabet/printing
the archetype does not account for the “ground”
archetype and new technologies – new ideas in the context of old clichés
Chapter 3 – “Visual and Acoustic Space:”
visual space as side effect of phonetic alphabet
importance of money (metal money as archetype) and the compass, in trade – intensified human consciousness o human need to exchange/store property (42) o even in present day, most things boil down to monetary value o compass as representation (externalization) of human “sense of direction on this planet” (42)
phonetic alphabet as basis of Western linguistic development (45)
visual space: created by Greek phonetic literacy; connected logically but with no ground; perceived through the eyes; “mind’s eye”
acoustic space: natural space; non-literate; “mind’s ear;” no boundaries; cultural
“When we say bicultural we mean the fortune to have a foot placed, as it were, in both
visual and acoustic space…” (45)
Chapter 4 – “East Meets West in the Hemispheres:”
Western civilization emphasizes “left-brain thinking over right brain cognition” (48)
other cultures (eg: Inuit) operate with more “’hemispheric symmetry’” (Trotter) o stronger preference toward right-brain thinking – processes of rituals, familiarity with land o less emphasis on “’seeing is believing’” (56) o even more value placed upon right-brain thinking o comprehension occurs based upon ritual, oral tradition, intuition, etc.
species development dependent upon understanding of relationship between left and right
“We must teach ourselves to abandon the tendency to view the environment in a hierarchical and totally connective way, to center ourselves instead in the arena of interplay between the
two modes of perception and analysis, which is comprehensive awareness.” (49)
rarity to achieve “true balance” of left and right brain, but achievement yields a
“comprehensive awareness”
“true consciousness” may be realized through perfect balance of diachronic (visual) and synchronic (acoustic) lines
Chapter 5 – “Plato and Angelism:”
“multi-sensory” equilibrium allows for immediate readjustment to any new conditions
angelism: focus on one point of view, lacking ground; emphasized by Plato
Plato fearful of the influence of the right hemisphere on left hemisphere academics
(ie: memory, empathy, etc. getting in the way of logic)
quantitative philosophy highlights ability of phonetic alphabet to “translate other languages into itself,” whereas right-brained cultures, based on oral tradition, resistant to “penetration” of other cultures and societies
left-brain technologies (eg: propaganda) allow influence over oral cultures
propaganda of the church and its effects on other cultures
while emergence of visual had devastating effects on oral culture, some believe the rise of individualism was brought about by rise of phonetic alphabet
“’But at this time… there arose a new faith in reason, freedom, and the brotherhood of new
men – the new faith, and, as I believe, the only possible faith, of an open society.’” (61)
Chapter 6 – “Hidden Effects:”
artifacts as extension of human body
experiences always occur on psychic and social grounds - any change to the senses brings about completely different experience (eg: going blind)
basis of contemporary Western communications theories: left-hemisphere and lineal; ignores environment; communication as “literal matching rather than making” (75)
“The information source changes this message into the signal which is actually sent over the communication channel from the transmitter to the receiver.” (75)
Western communication lacks “multiplicity” of effects of medium
tetrad must be employed in order to fully understand subliminal effects of the artifact and the ground
innovation is the combining of new and old artifacts in order to drive invention – viewing traditional archetypes within the context of their environments
nothing has meaning outside of the context of its environment (“figure-minus-ground”)
Final Thoughts:
in the 21 st century, an age of developing technologies, humankind must take into account both the visual and acoustic interpretations of the medium and the message
rise of left-brain visual culture saw the decline in traditional oral tradition
re-emergence of appreciation of acoustic space alongside the visual
tetrad serves as means of viewing the medium as a whole
dangerous to ignore either element of space – risk of missing the message
For Discussion:
What are the technological evidences of the 21 visual and acoustic perception of space? st century shift from solely visual to