Evolution Lecture 25
Chapter 18
Topics for today:
Four modes of geographic speciation
1. Genetic factors that lead to reproductive isolation
2. Evidence from:
• natural populations
• experimentation
Mechanisms of speciation
Reproductive isolation is key
Geographic factors reduce gene flow and allow reproductive isolation to evolve (4
ways)
Genetic factors cause reproductive isolation
1. Genetic divergence due to:
• Ecological selection
• Sexual selection
2. Break up of positive epistasis (Dobzhansky-Muller)
3. Cytoplasmic incompatibility
4. Chromosome divergence (polyploidy, cytological change)
5. Recombination in hybrids
Four geographical modes of speciation
Fig. 18.1 new 16.1 old
A. Allopatric speciation: physical barrier
Most common mechanism of speciation?
Defined by reduction in movement of individuals and gametes
Distance not necessarily important
Diverge due to drift and selection
Reproductive isolation is a by-product of selection
Renewed contact may result in
o complete isolation
o hybridization
Evidence for allopatric speciation
Incipient prezygotic and/or postzygotic mating barriers among geographic
populations
o Experimental pairing of individuals within and between populations
o Do they mate?
Molecular differentiation among allopatric populations
o Mitochondria DNA of six freshwater fish species
o Distinct eastern and western clades in all species
Fig. 18.3 new 16.3 old
Molecular differentiation among allopatric populations
o Mitochondria DNA of six freshwater fish species
o Distinct eastern and western clades in all species
o Gene flow reduced by Appalachian moutains
o Isolation occurred 3-4 myo
Filg 18.3 new 16.3 old
Increasing geographic overlap of species
Allopatric species originally separated
How should the geographic overlap of closely related species pairs
change over time?
Can only increase or stay at zero
Genetic divergence used as an index for time since divergence
Fig. 18.5 new 16.5 old
Causes of reproductive isolation in allopatry?
Genetic divergence via ecological selection
o Reproductive isolation evolves as a by-product of selection on other traits
(pleiotropic effects)
o Example 1
o Test mating compatibility of herbivorous insects that specialize on
different hosts
Fig. 18.8 new 16.7 old
o Example 2
Evidence is stronger if the pattern of isolation is repeated (parallel
divergence)
Three-spined stickleback
Fig. 18.8 new 16.7 old
Genetic divergence – sexual selection
o Different male traits may evolve by female choice in different populations
ultimately causing reproductive isolation
o Two populations of bush crickets
o Example 1 Ephippiger ephippiger
Different male traits may evolve by female choice in different
populations ultimately causing reproductive isolation
Two populations of bush crickets
Differences in♀ choice drive differences in ♂ song
Fig. 18.12 new 16.10 old
o Example 2
Sexual selection on males is strongest when there is high variance
in reproductive success
Fig. 18.12 new 16.9 old
Dobzhansky-Muller incompatibility
o Populations have same allele frequencies initially
o Mutations occur that have positive epistatic effects with alleles at other
loci & are fixed by selection
o Hybridization breaks up positive epistasic relationships that differ among
populations
Fig. 18.7 new 16.6 old