National Roads Authority 2010 Project Management Guidelines Phase 3 Design A3.6 Design Report (Sample Template) Sample Design Report (based on Design Working Papers) Executive Summary 1.0 Brief Summary of the Key Findings of the Design Report. Introduction & Description Brief Description of the Scheme including an overview of scheme development to date. Purpose of the Design Report. Scheme Operational Goals and Design Strategies. Proposed Construction Procurement Method (e.g. Design-Build). Summary of Route Selection Process including the evaluation of alternatives. Summary of Peer Review Process, if completed. 2.0 Identification of Need Strategic Fit and Priority within the National Road Programme. Road Development Policy - National, Regional, and Local (reference to NDP, T21, NRNS, NSS together with Regional and County Development Plans). Scheme Specific Need (National Road Traffic demands, completion of interurban link, removal of national road through traffic from urban bottlenecks etc) 3.0 Traffic Modelling, Road Type & Safety Summary of findings of Traffic Modelling Report. Confirmation of Scheme Level of Service Requirements. Comparison with ‘Do-Nothing’ Scenario. Confirmation of Year of Opening and Design Year. Forecast Traffic Flows for the Design Year. Selection of Road Type (based on ‘Incremental Analysis’ Assessment Report). Summary of Safety Assessment from Project Appraisal Balance Sheet (PABS) per the NRA Project Appraisal Guidelines. Summary of the Road Safety Audit Stage 1 Report, including the Design Team Response and Audit Team Acceptance. Summary of Health & Safety Risk Assessment confirming that the Scheme can be constructed, operated and maintained in a safe manner Working Document Page 1 of 5 Version 1.0 January 2010 National Roads Authority 2010 Project Management Guidelines 4.0 Phase 3 Design Geometry (including Relaxations & Departures) Applicable Technical Standards (DMRB). Confirmation of Calculation / Determination of Design Speed. Mainline Cross Section (dimensions per relevant Road Construction Detail including side slopes and working space requirements). Summary of Horizontal Alignments. Summary of Vertical Alignments. Reproduction of approved Principal Geometric Parameters Report (See Appendix A3.1). Confirmation of Stopping Sight Distance along the Scheme (including details of any verge or median widening required to achieve SSD). For single carriageways, confirmation of Full Overtaking Sight Distance (FOSD) and calculation of Overtaking Value. Summary of Relaxations and Departures for Standards (including approvals, where necessary). 5.0 Strategy for Junctions & Side Roads Overview of Junction Strategy for the scheme (as per the Approved Junction Strategy Report) Tabular Summary of Side Roads Tabular Summary of geometric parameters for each side road Tabular Summary of Interchanges (slip lanes, roundabouts etc.) Tabular Summary of geometric parameters for each Interchange 6.0 Ground Investigation, Optimisation Soil Classification & Earthworks Balance Overview of Geotechnical conditions along the scheme Tabular Summary of Ground Investigation Contract Overview of soil classification along the scheme based on Ground Investigation Contract Identification of areas of soft ground requiring infill and areas where additional acceptable material can be sourced within the land-take. Tabular Summary of Earthworks Balance Optimisation Working Document Page 2 of 5 Version 1.0 January 2010 National Roads Authority 2010 Project Management Guidelines 7.0 Phase 3 Design Drainage, Structures & Pavement Drainage Overview Summary of Carriageway Drainage (including tabular summary of drainage design parameters) Summary of design of bridges and culverts (including a schedule of culverts) Summary of any scheme specific flood alleviation proposals necessary to neutralise the risk of scheme runoff in flood sensitive areas Summary of any other drainage proposals (attenuation ponds, oil/petrol interceptors etc.) Summary of Principal Structures on the scheme (Road, Rail, River bridges etc.) Summary of Minor Structures (Culverts, Accommodation Underpasses etc.) Where necessary, provide a justification for the provision of each structure. Confirm that structural designs were referred to NRA Structures Unit for comment and that these comments have been incorporated into the design. Confirm that consents / approvals have been obtained where necessary (e.g. OPW Section 50 consents for crossing of watercourses, Iarnród Éireann Letter of Initial Acceptance for crossing of railways etc.) Confirmation of pavement type (flexible, rigid or composite) Pavement design load (million standard axles) and Design life (years) Tabular Summary of pavement design for mainline, side roads, slip roads, junctions and interchanges 8.0 Services, Land Use & Accommodation Works Overview of Service Conflicts along the scheme Tabular Summary of service conflicts for each of the principal service providers (ESB, telecom, Bord Gais etc.) together with a recommendation on diversion of services Summary of Land Acquisition Requirements for the Scheme Summary of Land use, affected landowners and requirements to acquire residential properties and/or other buildings Tabular Summary of Proposed Accommodation Works including accesses, Underpasses, access tracks etc. Working Document Page 3 of 5 Version 1.0 January 2010 National Roads Authority 2010 Project Management Guidelines 9.0 Phase 3 Design Cost Estimation Summary of Scheme Base Cost and Total Scheme Budget (including the TSB for the Main Construction Contract element of the scheme) determined in accordance with the NRA Cost Management Manual Confirmation that a Preliminary Risk Analysis Report has been prepared for the Scheme 10.0 Economic Assessment Where necessary, re-iterate the rationale for selecting this route if it did not generate the most economical Cost-Benefit Analysis results (Benefit to Cost Ratio) during the Route Selection Process in Phase 2 Overview and Tabular Summary of Results of Cost-Benefit Analysis carried out in accordance with the NRA Project Appraisal Guidelines Confirmation that CBA Results were certified by NRA Strategic Planning Unit 11.0 Conclusions & Recommendations Confirmation that the scheme will meet NRA requirements and that the Need for the Scheme has been established Confirmation that the scheme as designed will be able to cater for forecast Design Year traffic volumes Confirmation that the scheme will bring about a reduction in the frequency and severity of accidents Confirmation that the scheme has been designed in accordance with applicable standards and in accordance with policy documents Confirmation that the Cost-Benefit Analysis has shown that the scheme is economically viable and a worthwhile project to progress Recommendation that the Scheme as described in this Design Report be approved by the NRA so that it will form the basis for the Land Acquisition and statutory processes to follow. Working Document Page 4 of 5 Version 1.0 January 2010 National Roads Authority 2010 Project Management Guidelines Phase 3 Design Appendices Copy of Approved Junction Strategy Report Copy of Road Safety Audit Stage 1 Report Copy of Preliminary Structures Reports together with approvals and consents as necessary Copy of approval of NRA Project Appraisal Deliverables from NRA Strategic Planning Unit Copy of outcome of Peer Review Process including copy of Design Team Response, if required. Copy of Cost-Benefit Analysis Report Drawings Working Document Page 5 of 5 Version 1.0 January 2010