Lesson Topic: Dakota War of 1862 in Minnesota Grade level: Eighth Grade Length of lesson: Fifty Minutes with Outside Preparation Stage 1 – Desired Results Content Standard(s): The student will know and understand the impact of the Dakota War of 1862. Understanding (s)/goals Essential Question(s): What different perspectives exist regarding this Students will understand that there exist event? What caused the Dakota War of 1862 multiple perspectives for any given event. according to what you have learned from the This involves engagement on a social, differing perspectives examined? moral, emotional, and cognitive level This focuses on the cognitive, affective, and (domains). We all have our own psychomotor domains. It includes making perspectives and this directly attaches the value judgments based on differing lesson to the learner by making perspectives after careful examination and connections with what the student already testing. knows (Zull, 2002). In what ways does this conflict resonate today? This question will connect the historical content with the contemporary world that the students live in and lead them to make connections between the past and the present. Zull (2002) writes at length about connections and this directly relates to the idea of brain development. Student objectives (outcomes): Students will be able to: Identify different perspectives using primary documentation; analyze said perspectives in historical context within a small group; prepare/produce a way to convey perspectives to other groups; consider and compare other perspectives through group activity; summarize findings and make conclusions. Affective Domain: Stage One emphasizes the affective domain in a variety of ways. It calls on students to interact on at least four levels of Affective Domain (Bloom, Krathwol, & Masia, 1964). In dealing with multiple perspectives students will both receive and respond to a primary source document. Students will respond to this in a small group setting where listening and respecting others is a must. Students will also be called upon to place value in separate areas in order to compose a cohesive presentation to other groups regarding assigned perspective. Value will also be emphasized when groups convey their message to others, and receive others’ findings. Students will be called upon to organize the perspectives they have been exposed to by historical documentation and other students, relate their own perspective, compare multiple perspectives, and synthesize different values in order to both summarize and make conclusions regarding what they have learned. Cognitive Domain: Stage One involves students with each level of Bloom’s Cognitive Domain (1956). Students will operate on prior knowledge and that which they gain through the analysis of primary documentation and through interactions with other students regarding perspectives and how they differ. Students must explain what they have learned to others by summarizing information in their own words (comprehension). Students must apply what they have learned in generating a verbal argument for their view and expressing it to other groups in class. They must further apply this understanding in taking in what others have to say regarding different perspectives that they have not been exposed to (Compare/Analyze). This involves combining what they understand regarding their assigned perspective with new material and sorting it out in order to promote deeper understanding (Synthesis). Students will be exposed to multiple perspectives and asked to determine causation (Evaluation). Psychomotor Domain: The students will be engaged in the generation, verbalization, and the active testing of ideas generated in class. They will be engaged in discussion with other groups to test what they have learned and to further reach toward an understanding of the issues during group work. All of this is active learning according to Zull (2002). (Above annotations apply to all three stages in this lesson plan) Stage 2 – Assessment Evidence Performance Task(s): Other Evidence: Students must demonstrate what they Students will come to class prepared to have learned and what they are discuss the Dakota War of 1862 from learning in the classroom group assigned perspective obtained through activity. They must further primary document reading demonstrate what they have/are (independent). learning while participating in class This portion reinforces the cognitive domain in wide discussion relating the material that it provides students the base knowledge they are working with as well as their that will aid them in understanding the issues. conclusions based on thorough It also expands on what they have learned evaluation. previously and will aid them in class to move This task touches on all domains. Students throughout the rest of the cognitive domain as must apply what they have learned - cognitive - they will, at a minimum, apply this base in their group work by interacting with other knowledge to the in class activity. students - affective - and actively testing their Students will work in small groups ideas – psychomotor – by publicly voicing their with primary documentation in order to analysis and conclusions (Zull 2002). discuss perspectives in a group The in class group activity is working activity. This will allow students to toward the essay due at the end of the work with different perspectives inunit that will serve as an overall class while working toward their summative assessment in which summative essay assessment directly students will be asked to write a related to these perspectives. One research paper from one of the existent student from each group will be perspectives represented. responsible to discuss findings in large Students will apply what they have learned class discussion concluding group during this lesson to their summative activity. assessment. They will need to make Group work is an integral part of work in the connections between this lesson with lessons affective and this task covers the entire domain. that have come before and lessons that will As discussed in stage one, during group work come after in order to successfully complete students will receive and respond to the essay assessment. This will be emphasized information, place value on what they have in the classroom activity as well as the learned, organize differing perspectives, and individual reflection on the topic assigned for internalize value while participating (Bloom, et homework (exercise listed at the end of Stage al., 1964). The cognitive domain (Bloom, Three). This task will be built on learning that 1956) is also involved here and in the class takes place in all domains. wide discussion. This will include the cognitive domain in its entirety (check stage one explanation). The psychomotor domain is utilized as well. Students will engage in actively testing their ideas with their peers by vocalizing their thoughts and listening to what others have to say. Students will use in-class folders to independently reflect on issues discussed during group activity. This assignment will involve the students’ independent engagement with the material. It involves all that was learned during the class and the students’ prior knowledge as well. This means that the affective and cognitive are directly related to this as well as the psychomotor. The psychomotor domain involves what Zull (2002) calls active learning. The students will be asked to write, in their own words, what they have learned and apply that to what they think regarding the subject. Stage 3 – Learning Plan Learning Activities: Materials and Resources: 1. Northern Lights Textbook. 2. Primary sources. Each student will receive a copy of a primary source (more on this in letter B. of Development/Body section) to work with during class period. This will be provided at the end of the preceding day’s class period. 3. Folder with prepared reflection topic included and group assignment for in-class activity. 4. Classroom with individual desks or group tables and blackboard/chalk (minimum). 5. Pens/pencils. 6. Students. 7. Teacher. 8. Imagination. Timeline (approximations in minutes): Introduction: (Students enter classroom, retrieve folders (beginning of each class period), and find seats before the bell rings). A. Teacher will direct this portion of lesson using the following methods: a. Reviewing yesterday’s lesson using perspectives through primary documentation in order to examine attitudes toward slavery in Minnesota. b. Segue into today’s topic by reading short excerpt from Big Eagle, a Dakota chief, directly related to the beginning of the Dakota War of 1862. c. Students will be asked to respond verbally to what they have just heard from teacher with the floor open to ideas and questions (5 minutes for oration, Q/A, and idea generation introductory activity). Development/Body: B. Introduce primary source activity regarding perspectives and how students will be interacting with the material during class. Direct students to form into their assigned groups based on which perspective they received. Students will form into ten groups of three students (thirty student class). Each group will be looking at this issue through primary documentation relating one of the following perspectives: Dakota (e.g. traditional or farm), white settler (e.g. fur trader, missionary, or farmer), U.S. Government (e.g. treaty document, soldier, or politician). Students will form into groups (6 minutes). C. Guiding question for initial group discussion provided in folder: According to your assigned perspective, what may have caused the Dakota War of 1862? (7 minutes for group discussion). Students will record discoveries and ideas. D. Each group will be asked to send out two representatives to the other groups (one to each group) in order to both gather their perspective/s regarding the initial question and offer theirs (9 minutes). E. Students will return to their initial groups and share their findings with other group members and answer the following guiding question written on the black board: According to what you learned from the other groups and your own perspective, what caused this conflict? (9 minutes). Conclusion: F. One member from each group will present group findings to class. This report will include their initial thoughts regarding the event and whether or not those perspectives changed after the group activity. This report will be done in an informal manner and generate points of discussion for the entire class (12 minutes). G. Folder reflection exercise to end lesson. Students will be given reflection questions during the last 2 minutes of class and will be allowed to bring this home and have ready to hand in the following day. The teacher will introduce this exercise and announce that their responses will be used for tomorrow’s lesson. Students will reflect on the following: 1. What did you learn from today’s group activity? Did learning about the other perspectives change your mind or not? Explain. 2. Which perspective seemed to you to be the most compelling and why? If you choose to write your essay regarding this topic which perspective will you write from and why? 3. Do you see any connections between any of the following: the Dakota War of 1862, slavery, and the Civil War? Explain. 4. Is this relevant today? How? Psychomotor Domain All students will read primary documentation and participate in group activity exposing them to various perspectives. All students will write an independent reflection directly related to this lesson. Most students will read primary documentation, engage in meaningful discussion regarding both their assigned perspective and that of their peers. During discussion students will test their perspectives against others in order to gain a deeper understanding of the complexity of the entire issue. Students will incorporate this into their thought process and their written independent reflection. Some students will incorporate what they have learned in this lesson by actively seeking to discover other person’s perspectives through active testing in their everyday lives. Cognitive Domain All students will be exposed to new knowledge through written sources and verbal discussion. Most students will display comprehension and application in oral discussion and written reflection. Some students will further compare the differing perspectives represented (analysis); combine differing perspectives in order to gain an understanding of the subject (synthesis); and come to conclusions supported by multiple perspectives (evaluation). Affective Domain All students will receive new information/phenomenon through both written work and verbal communication and they will have to respond to this in speech and writing. Most students will respond by joining in small group discussion and intergroup work comparing the differing perspectives and drawing conclusions based on a variety of viewpoints. Students will gain a deeper level of understanding by applying what they learn during classroom activities into their written reflection (valuing/organization). Some students will apply what they have learned regarding differing perspectives to their lives by gaining an understanding regarding the importance of perspective and the impact that they have on events (Internalizing values).