D E L I V E R Y S E R V I C E S JANUARY 7, 2015 2014 Delivery Services Survey Analysis DELIVERY SERVICES SURVEY ANALYSIS Abstract In November 2014 a customer service survey for Delivery Services was created with Qualtrics. The campus was solicited for their satisfaction of Delivery Services and the results were collected over a period of several weeks. An initial glance at the results suggests that most campus Delivery Service customers are satisfied with the level of service provided. Despite the generally positive results, some elements of Delivery Services were pointed out as being sub par. Delivery Services can use these results to make improvements to better serve the campus community. Survey results 21 individuals started and all completed the survey. As you can see in figure 1, the participants were faculty (11%) or staff (89%), No student workers responded to this survey. Figure 1 – Who Took the Survey In addition, the survey was designed in such a fashion as to not allow the survey taker to skip any questions, they were able to list N/A as a valid response. In most cases this presents few if any problems, it does however, result in what may seem like inconsistent totals at times. This report will focus on three areas, Staff, Services, and Overall Satisfaction. In reviewing and analyzing the data from these three series of questions I believe we can best illustrate and address areas of deficiency. 2|Page DELIVERY SERVICES SURVEY ANALYSIS Staff Respondents were asked to rate the staff of the four divisions of Delivery Services, the mail center, central receiving, inventory control and surplus. The participants were asked to rate the staff of each division based on their courteousness. They could rate weather they feel the staff is courteous based on a scale agreement, strongly agree, agree, neither agree nor disagree, disagree, or strongly disagree. Figure 2 shows the results below. The majority of respondents agreed that the staff is courteous but they were a few respondents that selected strongly disagree. The Mail Center: 84% answered agree or strongly agree, 11% responded with strongly disagree, and 5% neither agreed nor disagreed Central Receiving: 79% answered agree or strongly agree, 11% responded with strongly disagree, and 10% neither agreed nor disagreed Inventory Control: 8% answered agree or strongly agree, 16% responded with strongly disagree or disagree, and 26% neither agreed nor disagreed Surplus: 68% answered agree or strongly agree, 16% responded with strongly disagree or disagree, and 16% neither agreed nor disagreed Figure 2 – Staff Ratings Based on Courteousness 3|Page DELIVERY SERVICES SURVEY ANALYSIS The next question about the staff was focused on how knowledgeable they would rate the staff in each division. They could rate how knowledgeable the staff is based on a scale agreement, strongly agree, agree, neither agree nor disagree, disagree, or strongly disagree. Figure 3 shows the results below. The majority of respondents agreed that the staff is courteous but they were a few respondents that selected a level of disagreement. The Mail Center: 73% answered agree or strongly agree, 11% responded with strongly disagree, and 6% neither agreed nor disagreed Central Receiving: 74% answered agree or strongly agree, 21% responded with disagree or strongly disagree, and 6% neither agreed nor disagreed Inventory Control: 58% answered agree or strongly agree, 16% responded with disagree or strongly disagree, and 26% neither agreed nor disagreed Surplus: 63% answered agree or strongly agree, 16% responded with disagree or strongly disagree, and 21% neither agreed nor disagreed Figure 3 – Staff Ratings Based on Knowlegde The participants were asked if the Delivery Services staff was helpful in creating solutions to problems. They were asked to rate the staff on a scale of agreement, definitely agree, somewhat agree, neither agree nor disagree, somewhat disagree, definitely disagree, or unsure. 79% answered agree or somewhat agree. 11% neither agree nor disagree, 10% answered somewhat disagree or definitely disagree 4|Page DELIVERY SERVICES SURVEY ANALYSIS Services The next set of questions focused on the services provided by Delivery Services. Participants were asked to rate the services from each division. The results are broken down by question and divisions below. Delivery Services delivers inbound mail, freight and materials in a timely manner: The Mail Center: 63% answered agreed or strongly agree, 21% answered disagree or strongly disagree, 16% answered neither agree nor disagree. Central Receiving: 58% answered agreed or strongly agree, 37% answered disagree or strongly disagree, 5% answered neither agree nor disagree. How would you rate your satisfaction with the solutions proposed by Delivery Services to overcome obstacles? The Mail Center: 80% answered in the satisfied range, 7% answered in the dissatisfied range, 13% answered neutral. Central Receiving: 75% answered in the satisfied range, 19% answered in the dissatisfied range, 6% answered neutral. Inventory Control: 56% answered in the satisfied range, 6% answered in the dissatisfied range, 38% answered neutral. Surplus: 56% answered in the satisfied range, 6% answered in the dissatisfied range, 38% answered neutral. How would you rate the delivery services response time to inquiries and requests for assistance? The Mail Center: 69% answered in the satisfied range, 6% answered in the dissatisfied range, 25% answered neutral. Central Receiving: 88% answered in the satisfied range, 12% answered in the dissatisfied range, 0% answered neutral. Inventory Control: 63% answered in the satisfied range, 6% answered in the dissatisfied range, 31% answered neutral. Surplus: 63% answered in the satisfied range, 6% answered in the dissatisfied range, 5|Page DELIVERY SERVICES SURVEY ANALYSIS 31% answered neutral. FedEx Participants were asked how satisfied they are with the FedEx billing process. Most respondents answered satisfied or neutral. 50% of people responded in the satisfied range, 33% were neutral and 18% answered with some level of dissatisfaction. The results can be seen in Figure 4 below. There were 2 respondents that left comments about reasons for their dissatisfaction: “billing is not transparent, hard to link up the shipments with billing charges” and “impossible to know pricing, especially for various options, sometimes charges are reasonable, sometimes ridiculous.” Both comments are related FedEx billing not being clear, this is an area that could be improved. Figure 4 – FedEx Billing Satisfaction Website Participants were asked to rate Delivery Services website as a useful resource the results were positive for all divisions. The Mail Center: 60% answered in the satisfied range, 13% answered in the dissatisfied range, 27% answered neutral. Central Receiving: 53% answered in the satisfied range, 20% answered in the dissatisfied range, 27% answered neutral. Inventory Control: 44% answered in the satisfied range, 12% answered in the dissatisfied range, 44% answered neutral. Surplus: 47% answered in the satisfied range, 13% answered in the dissatisfied range, 6|Page DELIVERY SERVICES SURVEY ANALYSIS 40% answered neutral. Policies and Procedure Participants were if they felt adequate information is provided regarding the Delivery Service’s policies and procedures. The participants agreed that they were provided with adequate information, 56% answered in the agree range, while each level on disagreement received 13%. The results can be seen in Figure 5 below. Figure 5 – Adequate Infornation Provided Overall Satisfaction When respondents were asked about overall satisfaction with Delivery Services the results were generally rated as satisfied. Below is a breakdown of how each division was rated. The results can be seen in Figure 6 below. The Mail Center: 87% answered in the satisfied range, 0% answered in the dissatisfied range, 13% answered neutral. Central Receiving: 74% answered in the satisfied range, 26% answered in the dissatisfied range, 0% answered neutral. Inventory Control: 67% answered in the satisfied range, 6% answered in the dissatisfied range, 27% answered neutral. Surplus: 75% answered in the satisfied range, 12% answered in the dissatisfied range, 13% answered neutral. 7|Page DELIVERY SERVICES SURVEY ANALYSIS Figure 6 – Overall Satisfaction Responses to Comments: The participants were asked four questions that allowed the participants to respond with text comments 1 - What type of information concerning Delivery Services do you think would be beneficial to UNLV campus community? How to track our own packages. Delivery Services provides links for ‘Package Tracking’, to track packages, sent by Fedex, DHL, US Mail and UPS, on their website. All that is required is the tracking number, of the package being sent, to verify if the package was signed for by Central Receiving personnel or Mail Center personnel. Once a Fedex, DHL or UPS package is signed for by Central Receiving personnel, you can go to the ‘Internal Tracking’ link on their website, to check the status of the package. Here is the link for ‘Package Tracking’ and ‘Internal Tracking: http://delivery.unlv.edu/tracking 8|Page DELIVERY SERVICES SURVEY ANALYSIS More than one pick up time per day for outgoing mail. The Mail Center is currently evaluating if it possible to add another pick up for outgoing mail. The number of resources available, at the Mail Center, will determine if an additional pick up can be maintained, on a permanent basis. Instructions on how to properly fill out a shipping authorization form. Instructions on how to properly fill out a Shipping Authorization Form has been added to Central Receiving Users Guide. It is now available on their website. Here is the link to the ‘Users Guide’: http://delivery.unlv.edu/ReceivingInformation What services they provide, their schedules, suggestions for addressing packages Information pertaining to the services provided, schedules and examples for addressing packages are found in the Central Receiving Users Guide, Central Receiving procedures, the Mail Center’s Users Guide and the Mail Center’s procedures. Here are the website links: Mail Center Users Guide and Procedures: http://delivery.unlv.edu/MailCenter%20Information Central Receiving Users Guide and Procedures: http://delivery.unlv.edu/ReceivingInformation 2 - What areas of improvement do you feel that Delivery Services would need to make in order to deliver a better service to the UNLV campus community? Deliver packages in a more timely manner. All next day, second day, or other expedited packages will be delivered to the departments on the same day they are received at the receiving warehouse, if receipt at the Receiving warehouse is by 12:00 P.M. All packages received by Delivery Services that do not carry any sort of expedited indication, will be delivered within a maximum of three working days. All mail received will be delivered the same day, provided the inbound address is correctly specified. 9|Page DELIVERY SERVICES SURVEY ANALYSIS Mail on campus should not take a week or more to be delivered All interdepartmental mail is picked-up daily, in the afternoon. On the following day, the interdepartmental mail and the incoming mail, from the U.S Postal Service, are sorted and delivered to the established mail stops, on the scheduled routes. Wish you did not fold mail and band it Federal mail that needs to be metered and sealed should be presented to the Mail Center, with all flaps out (not down or tucked in) in a stacked form, rubber banded together. This allows the mail to be processed and mailed in a fast and efficient manner. Why can't Fedex deliver directly to buildings? Many respondents asked why Fed Ex, UPS and other commercial carriers could not deliver directly to customer offices. UNLV has adopted a closed campus policy for the safety of the campus community. Allowing those carriers to attempt direct deliveries would create extra vehicles on campus, driving on sidewalks and pathways designed for pedestrian and not vehicle traffic. To further complicate matters, commercial carriers will deliver to only one location per address, and the entire Maryland Parkway campus shares a single mailing address. In addition, a vital role of Central Receiving is to provide a third party check and balance system to provide proof of merchandise receipt and delivery for the purpose of releasing payment. Other complications would arise if Inventory Control was unable to bar code the required equipment in Receiving, causing more of a disruption to the inventory cycle. Delivery and pick up of packages to the Paradise Campus Central Receiving does not currently have sufficient staff nor equipment (things such as trucks, etc.) to enable it to provide regular deliveries for off-campus entities. Many off campus locations possess a mailing address separate from the university’s main mailing address of 4505 South Maryland Parkway. Those customers should feel free to utilize their own mailing address to ensure timely receipt of their materials. 10 | P a g e DELIVERY SERVICES SURVEY ANALYSIS 3 - Are there any services that are not currently offered by Delivery Services that you would like to see offered? Information on obtaining alternative shipping for first class postage The UNLV Mail Center and Student Union have a self-service postage kiosk. The kiosk provides UNLV faculty, staff, and students a self-service, easy-to-use way to send mail, without having to wait in line at the post office. The Mail & Go kiosk is simple to use and can process mail for both domestic and international destinations. The kiosk is located in the Student Union across from the game room, next to the vending machines Once you finish getting postage for your mail, all you need to do is take it to the Student Union information desk, for drop-off. Pickup time for outbound mail is 10 a.m. Monday through Friday, excluding holidays. 4 - Do you have any additional comments or concerns? Surplus should be staffed 8-5.. The Surplus Operations section used to only have one FTE assigned, so 8:00am to 5:00pm staffing was not always possible. Due to the increased sales activity, we have been able to increase the staffing and the hours of operation are 8:00am to 5:00pm, Monday to Friday. Whenever a department has surplus items to drop off, the department should contact the Surplus section to schedule a drop off date and time. This will allow the surplus personnel to have adequate space and storage racks available for the surplus items. Analysis The survey results indicate a general level of satisfaction within all divisions in Delivery Services. There are areas, such as FedEx billing and timeliness of package delivery where comments indicate that service levels should be improved. Despite the indicated general level of satisfaction noted, I feel it important to point out that the sample size for the survey is relatively small, and the number of respondents accounts for only a small percentage of the campus faculty and staff community. 11 | P a g e