THE FUTURE OF THE YOUTH IN SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY IN GHANA Jophus Anamuah-Mensah I must thank the organizers for inviting me to be a discussant for this brilliant exposition. I deem it a great honour. The presentation has been very comprehensive and enlightening as it examined the past, the present and the future of the youth in science and technology and underscored the support for science and technology development in the first Republic. In examining the present situation, the author looked at the low level of support for the management of S&T, the perception and performance of the youth in S&T. She also examined the organizing structures for developing the youth in S&T such as the training institutions – SSS, polytechnics, universities – resources for S&T – science resource centres, S&T museum, teachers. The paper also looked at strategies for engaging the youth in S&Tpartnership between universities, polytechnics, and industry, involvement of the youth in IKS and agriculture, introduction of ICT, and use of Ghanaian scientists in the diaspora. While I agree with most of the issues raised, I will like to re-echo some of the salient points in the presentation, point to some of the issues emanating from lack of national commitment to science and technology and comment on the future of science and technology for the youth in Ghana. Ghana’s participation in the global knowledge system depends on the development of a strong science and technology base. Science and technology knowledge is currently the currency for economic and social transformation of nations. to be future scientists and technologists, the country can raise itself out of its present situation where science and technology knowledge is not part of the everyday thinking and practice of most of people. This would be more than the 2.6% of students currently enrolled in tertiary education (Addae-Mensah, 2000). Initiatives such as Lagos Plan of action, the New Partnership for Africa’s Development (NEPAD) and its recently constituted appendage, African Forum on Science and Technology for Development (AFSTD) requires serious commitment to and investment in S&T; that is, investment in capacity building in research and institutional development for generating and harnessing knowledge for the effective implementation of these initiatives. The youth constitute a major player in this since they are the ones to carry the burden of reconstructing the society in order to ensure its survival. The 2000 census indicates that Ghana has a very young population with about 44% of the population below 14 years, about 60% of the population under 25 years of age and with only about 5% over 65 years of age. The young are found in the kindergartens, basic and senior secondary schools, universities, polytechnics, private tertiary institutions and research institutions. Our failure to turn this youthful population through science and technology into skilled human capital has already begun to create serious social problems such as increasing unemployment in the country. If nothing is done for this group, a bleak future will befall our nation. But if only 10% of the youth aged 25 years and below (about 1,200,000) are trained. The future role of the youth in science and technology can be said to be three-fold. First, the youth need to receive the accomplishments of science and technologythat is, the theories, explanations, enquiry skills and accumulations of evidence – from the previous generation (Jegede & Solomon, 2000). The youth in this role, according to Sir Isaac Newton are ‘standing on the shoulders of giants’. They become the scientists who create, add on to and use the accumulated body of knowledge; they carry out research at the cutting edge of knowledge. Not all the youth can be located here; for rapid development of the country, up to 10% may be expected to play this role. The second is for the youth to be equipped with relevant science and technology skills and entrepreneurship to enable them enter the world of work. The President’s Committee on the Review of Education Reform indicated that “about 30% of the labour force engaged in production have never been to school. Only about 1.6% of the total educated workforce posses some qualification in technical and vocational education and only 5% have received training at secondary or higher level” (GOG, 2003). In my estimation, 30-40% of the youth will be needed to play this role if the country is to embrace science and technology as the two pillars of growth. The third is the role of ‘societal reconstruction’ which enables the individual to deal with “ social decisions relating to issues concerned with technology and science” (Jegede & Solomon, 2000). In this age of information, it is the expectation that every citizen should be scientifically literate to enable him/her make informed choices and contributions on matters related to science and technology in order to participate in decisions affecting their lives as well as contribute to solving problems affecting society. Most of the issues faced by the youth relate to the impact of new technologies on the environment and the activities of the youth. Such people should have basic working knowledge of science and technology to enable them make intelligent and informed decisions on issues related to science and technology and to provide strong support for the activities of science – research and development. It is expected that 50-60% of the youthful population who may become politicians, media practitioners, lawyers or accountants should have this societal reconstructionist orientation. This should enable all citizens to exercise their democratic right by participating in decisions concerning the future development of this country. It is estimated that less than 15% of Ghanaians of ages 15years and above are scientifically literate (Government of Ghana, 2003). I fully agree with the author that the promotion of science and technology in Ghana received its greatest support from the highest level of the country’s administration during the Nkrumah era. If we want to capture the commanding heights of science and technology, then we definitely need to go back to utilize the strategies that worked well in our favour during those years. We need to embrace the spirit of ‘sankofa’ especially when it seemed to have helped in resolving some of the pressing issues at the time. The president, Dr. Nkrumah was in charge of the drive to use science and technology for development just as Malaysia has done, infrastructural development and provision of equipment were assured, and those who pursued science studies in the universities received extra support while science teachers were given differential salaries. Characteristics of the Ghanaian Youth The young people in the country are faced with unfulfilled aspirations. They see the plight of those who have dared to embrace the scientific fraternity. They know the fields of science where majority of those who have gone before them have found satisfactionengineering, medicine and computing. But these young people have enormous potential bottled up in them and it is only when substantial resources are applied that this potential can be released. The youth in a science and technology propelled society will be required to be creative, communicate well, think critically, work cooperatively, find solutions to problems they encounter, maintain their motivation in the face of difficulties and connect with people and ideas If there is any future left for our youth, this future should be found in increased resource allocation to research and development in science and technology. The current financial allocation to science and technology which hovers between 0.3-0.5% of GDP is grossly inadequate. In some countries, the allocation to research and development alone far supersede this. South Africa spends 0.76% of GDP while Israel, USA and the countries of the European Union allocate 4.8%, 2.8% and 1.9% (on the average) of GDP respectively on research and development (ACU, 2004). Perception of youth on S&T The result of the questionnaire on the perception of youth on science and technology is very revealing. The reference to the inadequate resources for science and technology education at the senior secondary school, polytechnics and universities by the students warrants serious attention by the Ministry of Education. For example, the laboratories should be adequately equipped with basic instruments and materials and should be manned by competent technicians. If this is not done, the positive perception students at all levels have for science as reported by Dr. Entsua-Mensah would be lost. In the choice of professions, there were cases of dysfunctional choices by some university students especially those from UEW, KNUST and UCC. For example, students who had enrolled in certain career-directed study fields such as science teaching at UEW selected pharmacy as their future career. Such students seemed to have unwillingly accepted enroll in programmes that were not their first or second choice. This may have something to do with the selection of SSS students into programmes at the universities. Enrolment in courses of study at the universities should be re-examined as it does not seem to cater for the needs/career choices of the youth. Facilities need to be expanded and more programmes introduced to cater for the different interests of the students. The study reported in the paper revealed that students pursuing science studies in the universities and research institutes had a low image of research scientists in the society. To reverse this trend, the following initiatives will have to be taken: Research scientists will have to showcase their innovative works through publication in the popular media as well as talks to students in the schools and universities. The government can also play a critical role by ensuring that tools and other materials needed for research are made available. A Best Researcher Award scheme should be instituted in each institution and in the nation as a whole. Mr. Chairman, any science education programme that fails 40% or more of its students needs to be re-examined; for no country can develop its science and technology effectively if over 40% fail to understand basic concepts in the subject. For example, the result of the SSSCE indicates that in 2002, over 40% failed core mathematics, elective mathematics and physics. The situation becomes even more alarming when those with grade E’s are added to the failures since most universities do not accept grade E. We cannot build a strong science and technology base with grade Es. Science subjects Years 2000 C- Maths 41 Biology 49 Chemistry 51 Physics 41 E-Maths 40 2001 51 42 39 43 55 2002 50 27 34 50 40 60 50 40 2000 30 2001 20 2002 10 0 Cmath Chem Emath Figure 1: Failure rate in science in SSSCE subject Years 2000 2001 2002 cmaths 63 71 73 Biology 80 72 61 Chem 75 66 62 Physics 73 75 79 Emaths 63 79 64 Figure 2: Students with Grades F and F+E in SSSCE in 2002 80 70 60 50 Grade F 40 30 Grade F+E 20 10 0 Cmath Chem Emath Over 60% failed to get a Grade D in all the pure science subjects. The case of mathematics is very serious as mathematics forms an integral part of all sciences. In the universities, mathematics lecturers have become endangered species and this in turn is manifested in the small number of mathematics teachers in both the basic and senior secondary schools. The International Science Programme of the University of Uppsala, Sweden estimates the density of PhD holders in mathematics to be about one per one million inhabitants (Prof. Alllotey, personal communication). Initiatives such as that being pursued by the Institute of Mathematical Sciences involving the use of seasoned professors in both local foreign universities is contributing to the training of a number of Masters and PhD students in various areas of mathematics. In addition, the summer camps on the teaching of science and mathematics for secondary school teachers is serving as a motivation for teachers since this is the only opportunity available to science and mathematics teachers to keep abreast with pedagogical content issues in their fields. Support for such initiatives can help in preparing the youth to meet challenges of the future. One of the major undesirable fallout of the education system is the production of thousands of school leavers at the JSS and SSS levels who have no employable skills and yet have to fend for themselves. While the suggestion that technical and vocational institutions be set up to cater for them is laudable, other measures can be taken to give them appropriate skills. This includes the setting up of Apprentice training Scheme to be overseen by a National Apprentice Training Board as recommended by the President’s Committee on Review of Education Reform in Ghana. The Board will supervise the curricula, registration, duration and certification. Open Community colleges through private participation but with government support. These colleges will provide opportunities for further studies and or skill training for the youth. Mentoring the Youth This is critical to the development of a career path in science for the youth. Mentors excite interest in junior colleagues. This experience is however rare in the universities. In the university, newly recruited scientists struggle to keep afloat with little or no support. A formal mentoring system should be established in all institutions to ensure that young scientists recruited into the universities or research institutions are attached to professors and senior scientists in their fields of study to receive advice and support. The mentoring can take the form of joint research, publications and presentations at conferences and seminars. The youth of this country are not receiving adequate encouragement to pursue careers in science and technology due to a number of factors including inadequate budgetary allocation to science and technology and lack of information on future career prospects. This has resulted in the following: Inadequate allocation of funds to the pursuit of science and technology education at all levels of education; The country has a weak science and technology base with science and technology infrastructure almost non-existent; Poor laboratory and workshop facilities for science teaching at all levels; Lack of career guidance in the schools; students are only familiar with a few professions in science and technology, e.g. medicine, engineering; Inadequate numbers of science, mathematics and technical and vocational teachers; university enrolment in these disciplines has been as low as 60:40 humanities/science over the years; Teaching methods do not encourage critical thinking and problem solving; science is therefore learnt as an unexciting collection of facts; Participation of females in science and technology is low; Poor infrastructure for research in science and technology at the universities and research institutions; Lack of well motivated and adequate personnel for performing cutting edge research who can mentor the young scientist; postgraduate research is therefore very low and unattractive; Most industries in Ghana, including the small and medium sized enterprises (SMEs) are not involved in technological innovation which has the potential of attracting the youth. They, therefore, stand a great risk of marginalisation as a result of lack of scientific personnel who can bring about improvement in the industry. Multi –national companies carry out their research and development activities outside the country and therefore do not provide opportunities for developing indigenous capacity. About 30% of the labour force, engaged in production have never been to school. Only about 1.6% of the total educated workforce posses some qualification in technical and vocational education and only 5% have received training at secondary or higher level. It is clear that unless appropriate action is taken Ghana runs the risk of not being able to provide emerging industries with the required human capital.