Teaching Program Select Units for the New South Wales Ancient History Higher School Course using the Heinemann Ancient and Medieval History series and Heinemann Ancient and Medieval History Teacher’s Resource and Assessment Disk 2 By Vicki Greer Unit 1: Core Study: Cities of Vesuvius: Pompeii and Herculaneum Targeted Outcomes Students: H 1.1 describe and assess the significance of key people, groups, events, institutions, societies and sites within their historical context H 2:1 explain historical factors and assess their significance in contributing to change and continuity in the ancient world H 3.1 locate, select and organise relevant information from a variety of sources H 3.2 discuss relevant problems Principal Focus Students learn to: • comprehend and analyse a range of archaeological and written sources relevant to the core study of the cities of Pompeii and Herculaneum use sources to reconstruct aspects of life in Pompeii and Herculaneum in AD 79 • evaluate the implications of gaps in the evidence for reconstructing life in Pompeii and Herculaneum in AD 79 • describe and assess different methods used by Selected Resources Heinemann Ancient and Medieval History: Pompeii and Herculaneum Heinemann Ancient and Medieval History Teacher’s Resource and Assessment Disk Websites located in www.hi.com.au/ancient of sources for reconstructing the past H 3.3 analyse and evaluate sources for their usefulness and reliability H 3.4 explain and evaluate differing perspectives and interpretations of the past H 3.5 analyse issues relating to ownership and custodianship of the past H 3.6 plan and present the findings of historical investigations, analysing and synthesising information from a range of sources H 4.1 use historical terms and concepts appropriately H 4.2 communicate a knowledge and understanding of historical features and issues using appropriate oral and written forms. Students Learn About: Non-examinable background • stages of occupation • brief historical overview up to and including the eruption of AD 79 • early discoveries and brief history of the excavations • representations of Pompeii and Herculaneum over time Examinable content: 1 Geographical context • the physical environment: the geographical setting, natural features and resources of Pompeii and Herculaneum • plans and streetscapes of • • • • archaeologists, historians and other specialists to investigate the sites over time evaluate different representations of Pompeii and Herculaneum over time discuss relevant issues of conservation and reconstruction; custodianship of the sites and the display of human remains present the findings of investigations of key features or issues relevant to the study of Pompeii and Herculaneum communicate effectively in oral and written forms to describe and analyse features and issues of the study. TEACHING AND LEARNING STRATEGIES (incorporating students learn to) : Examine key events in the settlement and occupation of Pompeii and Herculaneum and construct a chronology of stages of occupation Source Study : Sulla’s attack on Pompeii Source Study: The Campathian earthquakes Examine the early explorations of Pompeii and Herculaneum Case Study: The age of antiquarianism – Sir John Sloane (1778-1823) Critical Inquiry: techniques of early digs by Prince D’Elbeuf, Alcubierre, Wincklemann, Weber, La Vega, Fiorelli, Mau, Spinazzola, Maiuri Locate Anglo American Project in Pompeii website to assess the ways in which improvements in archaeological methods have changed the way archaeology is practised at either Pompeii or Herculaneum. Map study: location, setting and geographical features of Pompeii and Herculaneum. Use excerpts from Tactitus and Statius to describe what the Vesuvius area might have looked like before the eruption of AD 79. Critical Inquiry: Compare Strabo and Florus’ descriptions of Mount Vesuvius. Pompeii and Herculaneum Draw up chart which lists the resources/produce of Pompeii and Herculanuem with archaeological and written evidence for each. Write a one page letter from a wealthy Roman living in a villa in Pompeii or Herculaneum encouraging a friend to move to the area. Plan studies of townscapes of Pompeii and Herculaneum. 2 The nature of sources and evidence • the range of available sources, both written and archaeological, including ancient writers, official inscriptions, graffiti, wall paintings, statues, mosaics, human and animal remains • the limitations, reliability and evaluation of sources • the evidence provided by the sources from Pompeii and Herculaneum for: – the eruption – the economy: trade, commerce, industries, occupations – social structure; men, women, freedmen, slaves – local political life – everyday life: leisure activities, food and dining, clothing, health, baths, water supply and sanitation – public buildings – basilicas, temples, fora, theatres, palaestra, amphitheatres – private buildings – villas, houses, shops – influence of Greek and Egyptian cultures: art, architecture, religion – religion: temples, household gods, foreign cults, tombs. Read Pliny the Younger’s description of the AD 79 eruption. Sequence and describe the events and phenomena experienced by Pliny the Elder. Using Pliny the Younger’s accounts, create an annotated timeline of the events of the eruption of Vesuvius. Assess the reliability of Pliny the Younger’s letters for our understanding of the destruction of Pompeii and Herculaneum. Research Pliny the Elder’s life, character and interests. Write an account of the eruption that he might have written if he had survived. Account for the difficulties faced by modern historians when trying to establish absolute dates for events recorded in ancient sources. Examine the studies of Professor Haraldur Sigurdsson of the stratigraphical deposits at Pompeii and Herculaneum and his interpretation/timetable of the eruption and how the settlements were destroyed. Compare the evidence from Pliny the Younger’s letters and Sigurdsson’s stratigraphical analyses to decide which provides the most reliable account of the eruption. Examine evidence and artifacts from private houses (House of the Faun, House of the Vetti, House of the Surgeon, House of the Moralist, insulae, House of the Mosaic Atrium, House of the Wooden partition, The Trellis House). Students construct a “social ladder” of Roman society, using status symbols used by Romans to illustrate the structure of society. Examine the House of Stephanus the Fuller and the Bakery of Modestus as evidence for working and middle class Roman lives. Create chart of the places in Pompeii and Herculaneum frequented by women and explain what the evidence reveals about the role of women in Roman society. Case Studies of written and archaeological evidence on Eumachia, a prominent woman of Pompeii, priestesses, businesswomen, tradeswomen, prostitutes, slave and foreign women. Examine the Forum complex of Pompeii: Explain what evidence in the Forum shows the power of the emperor in Roman society. Describe the activities that took place on a typical day at the Forum. List the main buildings of the Forum of Pompeii (Temples, Commercial areas such as the macellum, building of Eumachia, civic buildings). Explain what these buildings show us about religion, commerce and government. Examine main buildings relating to public entertainment such as the ampitheatre of Pompeii, the large palaestra, the large Theatre, the Odeon, the Palaestra in Herculaneum. Examine water towers and public fountains, public baths/thermae in Pompeii and Herculaneum such as the Stabian baths and the Forum baths to describe their purpose and functions. Examine the Temple of Venus, the Temple of Isis, artifacts found in the House of Julia Felix to assess the influence of Egyptian and Greek culture on art, architecture and religion. Assess what written and archaeological sources reveal about religious practices in Pompeii and Herculaneum, the role and importance of the Imperial Cult and foreign cults. 3 Investigating, reconstructing and preserving the past • changing methods and contributions of nineteenth and twentieth century archaeologists to our understanding of Pompeii and Herculaneum Using the information in Chapter 3, choose which archaeologists belong in either The Archaeological Hall of Fame or The Archaeological Walk of Shame. Students must use evidence to justify their response. • changing interpretations: impact of new research and technologies Sequence and describe actions taken by international and national groups to preserve Pompeii and Herculaneum. • issues of conservation and reconstruction: Italian and international contributions and responsibilities; impact of tourism • ethical issues: study and display of human remains Case study: the work of Australian researchers (The Australian expedition to Pompeii, Dr Penelope Allison, Dr Estelle Lazer, Jayne Pont, Steven Ellis) to illustrate the impact of changing new research and technologies on our understanding of Pompeii and Herculaneum. Examine conservation techniques, problems and issues highlighted in The House of the Coloured capitals, wall paintings, Villa of the Papyri, The papyrus scroll library, House of the Menander and the sanctuary of Artemis Orthia. Summarize the main areas of debate and concern under the following headings: Custodianship, conservation issues, ethical issues. Debate: Is Professor Guzzo right in declaring a moratorium on new excavation? Class discussion: should the casts and skeletons of victims of the AD 79 eruption be displayed or be given a ‘proper’ burial? (If they should be buried, where and how?) Unit 2: Ancient Society: Spartan Society to the battle of Leuctra 371BC Targeted Outcomes Students: H 1.1 describe and assess the significance of key people, groups, events, institutions, societies and sites within their historical context H 2.1 explain historical factors and assess their significance in contributing to change and continuity in the ancient world H 3.1 locate, select and organise relevant information from a variety of sources H 3.2 discuss relevant problems of sources for reconstructing the past H 3.3 analyse and evaluate sources for their usefulness and reliability H 3.4 explain and evaluate differing perspectives and interpretations of the past H 3.6 plan and present the findings of historical investigations, analysing and synthesising information from a range of sources H 4.1 use historical terms and concepts appropriately H 4.2 communicate a knowledge and understanding of historical features and issues using appropriate oral and written forms. Students Learn About: 1 The geographical setting • the geographical setting, natural features and resources of ancient Sparta • significant sites: Sparta 2 Social structure and political organisation Students learn to: • ask relevant historical questions • locate, select and organise information from a range of sources to describe and analyse the key features of the ancient society • describe and evaluate the role and nature of key features of the ancient society • explain and assess the significance of historical factors contributing to change and continuity within the ancient society • evaluate the usefulness and reliability of sources • explain and evaluate differing perspectives and interpretations of the ancient society • plan and present the findings of investigations on aspects of the ancient society, analysing and synthesising information from a range of sources • communicate an understanding of relevant concepts, features and issues using appropriate oral and written forms. Selected Resources Heinemann Ancient and Medieval History: Spartan Society to 371BC Heinemann Ancient and Medieval History Teacher’s Resource and Assessment Disk Websites located in www.hi.com.au/ancient TEACHING AND LEARNING STRATEGIES (incorporating students learn to) : Map study: landscape, climate and resources. Examine written sources (Herodotus book I, 66, Plutach Lives: Lycurgus) to debate: Lycurgus, Man or Myth? • the issue of Lycurgus (the Great Rhetra) • roles and privileges of the two kings Describe the roles and responsibilities of the kings, Ephors, Gerousia and Ekklesia. Create a diagram or graphic representation that shows the structure of • government: ephorate, gerousia, ekklesia Spartan Society. • social structure: Spartiates, perioeci, ‘inferiors’, helots Class discussion: how did the need to control the helots affect Spartan life • role of the Spartan army Source studies:, the Spartan military, syssitia, krypteia, the agoge. • control of the helots: the military, syssitia, krypteia Read Xenophon Polity of the Lacedaemonians I, Plutarch Sayings of Spartan Women Moralia III, 241 to describe the differences between the lives of Spartan women from those who lived in other parts of Greece. and social organization? • artisans, helots • educational system: agoge • role and status of women: land ownership, inheritance, education 3 The economy • land ownership: agriculture, kleroi, helots • technology: weapons, armour, pottery • economic roles of the periokoi (‘dwellers around’) and helots Create mind maps on the Spartan economy. Read and discuss Plutarch’s account of Lycurgus’ division of the land of Sparta. Explain the aim of this division. Create a PowerPoint presentation or small group oral presentation on Spartan technology. Compare Tytraeus’ and Plutarch’s accounts of the economic obligations of the helots. • economic exchange: use of iron bars, trade Source study: Spartan trade. 4 Religion, death and burial • gods and goddesses: Artemis Orthia, Poseidon, Apollo Source Studies: gods of Mount Olympus, the significance of Poseidon, Apollo and Artemis for Spartans. • myths and legends: Lycurgus and the Dioscuri Create illustrated programs of events for the Karneia, Hykathia and Gymnopedia. • festivals: Hyakinthia, Gymnopaedia, Karneia Extended response: describe the religious roles of the Spartan kings. • religious role of the kings Read Herodotus Book V, 58 to list the main rituals observed on the death of a Spartan king and Plutarch Lives: Lycurgus to describe burial customs for ordinary Spartans. Explain the significance of the Dioscuri and the Heraclidae. • funerary customs and rituals 5 Cultural life • art: sculpture, painted vases, bone and ivory carving • architecture: Amyklaion, Menelaion, the Sanctuary of Artemis Orthia • writing and literature: Alcman and Tyrtaeus Examine Spartan artefacts (The Laconian Rider, laconain black figure pottery, ivory carvings) to assess the traditional view that Sparta lacked a rich cultural life. Site Studies: the acropolis of Sparta, the Sanctaury of Apollo, the Menelaion and the Sanctuary of Artemis Orthia. Read excerpts of the poetry of Alcmann and Tyrtaeus. Describe what they reveal about the narure of Spartan literature: are they poetry or propaganda? Account for the usefulness and reliability of ancient writings on Sparta. • Greek writers’ views of Sparta: Herodotus, Thucydides, Xenophon, Aristotle, Pausanias, Plutarch 6 Everyday life • daily life and leisure activities List FIVE pieces of archaeological evidence that have been used by historians to discover what life was like in Ancient Sparta. Under each item, explain what has been learned or surmised from it. • food and clothing Describe the kinds of work, leisure and community activities in which Spartans could participate and those from which they were barred. • marriage customs • occupation Working in pairs, write a Spartan marriage guidance column. Create a poster communicating Spartan attitudes towards marriage and the family. Unit 3: Personalities in Their Times: Hatshepsut Targeted Outcomes Students: H1.1 describe and assess the significance of key people, groups, events, institutions, societies and sites within their historical context H2.1 explain factors and assess their significance in contributing to change and continuity in the ancient world H3.1 locate, select and organise relevant information from a variety of sources H3.2 discuss relevant problems of sources for reconstructing the past H3.3 analyse and evaluate sources for their usefulness and reliability H3.4 explain and evaluate differing perspectives and interpretations of the past H3.6 plan and present the findings of historical investigations, analysing and synthesising information from a range of sources H4.1 use historical terms and concepts appropriately H4.2 communicate a knowledge and understanding of historical features and issues using appropriate oral and written forms Students Learn About: 1 Historical context • geography, topography and resources of Egypt and its neighbours Students learn to: • use appropriate terms and concepts in communicating about the personality • locate, select and organise information in relation to the chosen personality • identify key issues and features about the personality • make deductions and draw conclusions about the personality • weigh up the relative reliability of the available sources and assess their usefulness for a study of the personality • identify and analyse the varying images of the personality • explain and evaluate differing perspectives and interpretations of the personality in ancient and modern sources • present the findings of historical investigations of issues and features of the personality • communicate coherently in oral and written forms to explain and evaluate significant events and achievements in the personality’s life • synthesise information to construct an evaluation of the personality’s significance and legacy. Selected Resources Heinemann Ancient and Medieval History: Personalities Heinemann Ancient and Medieval History Teacher’s Resource and Assessment Disk Websites located in www.hi.com.au/ancient TEACHING AND LEARNING STRATEGIES (incorporating students learn to) : Map study: landscape, climate and resources. Create illustrated chronology of Eighteenth Dynasty • historical overview of the early Eighteenth Dynasty Class readings and discussion of social, political, military and economic structures of the early New Kingdom period. • overview of the social, political, military and economic structures of the early New Kingdom period • relationship of the king to Amun • overview of religious beliefs and practices of the early New Kingdom period 2 Background and rise to prominence • family background • claim to the throne and succession: Divine Birth and Coronation reliefs Create family tree for Hatshepsut. Explain what Hatshepsut’s genealogy reveals about the role of marriage in the pharoanic class. Teacher overview of the roles of kings and queens. Write an account of Hatshepsut’s accession to the throne. • political and religious roles of the king and queen in the Seventeenth Dynasty and early Eighteenth Dynasty • marriage to Thutmose II 3 Career • titles and changes to her royal image over time • foreign policy: military campaigns and expedition to Punt Examine images of Hatshepsut to: – determine possible Egyptian reactions/views on a female pharaoh – identify the symbols of pharaonic power used in each representation of Hatshepsut – suggests reasons why Hatshepsut had herself represented ijn these ways. • building program: Deir-el Bahri, Karnak, Beni Hasan (Speos Artemidos) and her tombs Summarize main events of the expedition to Punt. Assess the significance of the expedition to Hatshepsut’s reign. Extended response: Was Hatshepsut a peace maker or a war maker? Examine the inscription from the Punt relief at Deir el Bahri. Assess its reliability as a source of information about Hatshepsut. • religious policy: devotion to Amun and promotion of other cults Create a table which explains the significance of the following people to the study of Hatshepsut: Thutmose I, Thutmose II, Thutmose III, Ahmose, Neferure, Senenmut. • relationship with the Amun priesthood, officials and nobles including Senenmut Write paragraphs explaining Hatshepsut’s association with: Deir el Bahri, Punt, Nubia, Sinai. Write an interview between a modern day political commentator and • relationship with Thutmose III; co-regency and later defacement of her monuments 4 Evaluation • impact and influence on her time • assessment of her life and reign • legacy • ancient and modern images and interpretations of Hatshepsut. Hatshepsut. The interview should focus on her building program and religious policies. Students suggest reasons for the defacement of her monuments. Design three panels of the wall paintings for Hatshepsut’s tomb which communicate what they think are the most important things about her life and influence. Beneath each panel, write an explanation of the choices they have made in their design using specific historical evidence in support. Read and compare Steindorff and Steele, Dorman, Robins and Tyldesley’s view of Hatehepsut. Account for similarities and differences in each perspective. Class debate: Was Hatshepsut manipulative or misunderstood? Materials used in the development of this Teaching Program come from the Board of Studies NSW Ancient History Stage 6 Syllabus 2004.