REPUBLIC OF BOTSWANA NORTH EAST DISTRICT DEVELOPMENT PLAN 6: 2003 – 2009 Masunga “Towards Realisation of Vision 2016: Sustainable and Diversified Development Through Competitiveness in Global Markets” NORTH EAST DISTRICT COUNCIL NORTH EAST DISTRICT DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE MINISTRY OF LOCAL GOVERNMENT P24.00 FOREWORD The North East District Development Plan 6 (DDP 6) which covers a period of six (6) years from April 2003 to March 2009 presents projects, which are a product of extensive grass root consultations with villagers during the drafting period. The plan has incorporated the National Development Plan 9 theme of “Towards Realization of Vision 2016: Sustainable and Diversified Development through Competitiveness in Global Markets”. The North East District does not have a strong private sector that plays an important role in market activities hence this document does not provide details on that aspect. However, institutions such as the Village Development Committees, District Development Committee and various village level organizations play an important role in maintaining an environment conducive for the development of village level infrastructure and the provision of services such as schools, clinics, other health facilities, etc. This plan has been to a large extent produced from the proposals presented by the village level institutions, which includes Dikgosi, Councillors, Religious leaders, VDCs etc. They have participated in the process of producing this report through continuous consultations and their involvement. Owing to limited current statistical data on unemployment and poverty levels yet, the district like the rest of the country is faced with problems of unemployment, poverty and the continued threat from the HIV/AIDS epidemic as our most critical issues. The contributing factor to unemployment has been the problems of continued drought in the district during the period resulting in a fewer numbers of people engaging in agricultural activities. During the latter part of DDP 5 the district was struck by Foot and Mouth disease in the areas of Matsiloje and Matshelagabedi, and then followed by the latest outbreak at Matopi. The incident caused the killing of over 15 000 cattle in 2002/03. On the other hand, the economic and political situation in neighboring Zimbabwe is causing additional problems of influx of illegal immigrants into the country through ungazzeted points along the border of the district. The situation overstretches the limited resources in terms of security and administration of justice. This is the first plan to take strategic planning approach at the district level by aligning gaols and objectives to address emerging challenges such as economic diversification, employment creation, poverty reduction, the fight against HIV/AIDS, and public sector reforms like Performance Management System (PMS), environmental protection, rural development and human resources development. The plan has carried forward some of the incompleted projects from DDP5, which have become a priority in DDP6. Despite the limited or overstretched resources at the disposal of Government, the North East District through this plan, seeks to achieve all planned activities. i TABLE OF CONTENTS FOREWORD TABLE OF CONTENTS APPENDICES LIST OF TABLES LIST OF FIGURES AND MAPS LIST OF ACRONYMS 1 DISTRICT AND PEOPLE i ii xii xiii xiv xiv 1 1.1 DISTRICT GEOGRAPHIC SETTING 1 1.1.1 Regional Influences 1 1.2 INSTITUTIONAL ARRANGEMENTS 1 1.2.1 Communication Links 2 1.3 DISTRICT ENVIRONMENTAL FEATURES 2 1.3.1 1.3.2 1.3.3 1.3.4 1.3.5 Climate Topography Geology Hydrology Natural Resources 2 2 4 4 4 1.4 DISTRICT SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT 7 1.4.1 1.4.2 1.4.3 1.4.4 1.4.5 1.4.6 1.4.7 1.4.8 1.4.9 1.4.10 Socio-Cultural Characteristics Population Characteristics, Density and Distribution Age-Sex Structure Migration HIV/AIDS and its Economic Implications Home Based Care Programme and Orphanhood Projected Population Growth Trends, 1991 - 2019 Economic Activity Employment and Unemployment Constraints to Development 7 8 8 10 10 10 11 11 12 13 1.5 DISTRICT ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT 13 1.5.1 1.5.2 1.5.3 1.5.4 1.5.5 1.5.6 Agricultural Sector Commercial Activities Tourism Manufacturing/Industry Mining Public Sector 14 15 15 15 16 16 1.6 STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT PRINCIPLES 16 2 REVIEW OF THE DDP5 AND LONG TERM DEVELOPMENT POTENTIAL 17 ii 2.1 INTRODUCTION 17 2.2 ACHIEVEMENTS/OPPORTUNITIES - DDP5 17 2.2.1 2.2.2 2.2.3 2.2.4 2.2.5 2.2.6 2.2.7 2.2.8 2.2.9 2.2.10 2.2.11 2.2.12 2.2.13 2.2.14 Agriculture Industrial and Commercial Development Wildlife and National Parks Tourism Mining Education and Training Health Social & Community Development Immigration, Customs and Excise District Administration Tribal Administration Botswana Police Government Revenue Office Physical Infrastructure 17 19 19 19 20 20 22 23 24 24 24 25 25 25 2.3 LONG TERM PLANNING FRAMEWORK 26 2.3.1 2.3.2 Integrated District Land Use Plans and Structure Plans District Settlement Strategy 26 26 2.4 PROBLEM AREAS AND MAJOR UNRESOLVED ISSUES 27 2.4.1 2.4.2 2.4.3 2.4.4 2.4.5 2.4.6 2.4.7 2.4.8 2.4.9 2.4.10 2.4.11 2.4.12 Agriculture Industrial and Commercial Development Wildlife & National Parks Education & training Health Social & Community Development District Administration Tribal Administration Government Revenue Office Immigration, Customs & Excise Energy Sources and Power Physical infrastructure 27 27 28 28 28 29 29 29 29 29 29 30 2.5 LONG TERM PLANNING FRAMEWORK 30 2.5.1 2.5.2 2.5.3 Integrated Land Use Plan Environmental and Conservation Strategies Revised National Settlement Policy 30 31 31 2.6 LINKS TO NDP9 THEME 31 3 DDP 5/UDP 2 DEVELOPMENT GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 33 3.1 PLANNING FRAMEWORK 33 3.1.1 3.1.2 3.1.3 3.1.4 Vision 2016 National and District Environmental Key Issues Ministry of Local Government Strategic Plan Long Term District Plans 33 36 37 37 iii 3.2 DDP6/UDP2 – OVERALL GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 39 3.2.1 Summary of Key Issues 39 3.3 DDP6/UDP2 DEVELOPMENT GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 40 3.4 FRAMEWORK FOR MONITORING SECTOR GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 41 3.5 FRAMEWORK FOR MONITORING ENVIRONMENTAL GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 42 3.6 FRAMEWORK FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT 42 3.6.1 3.6.2 Evaluation of Key Environmental Issues with Overall Goals and Objectives Evaluation of Policies and Programmes against Overall Goals and Objectives 42 43 4 ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION 44 4.1 INTRODUCTION 44 4.1.1 4.1.2 Institutional Framework Consultation Priorities 44 44 4.2 ENVIRONMENTAL POLICIES AND LEGISLATION 44 4.2.1 4.2.2 4.2.3 4.2.4 4.2.5 4.2.6 4.2.7 4.2.8 Tourism Policy 45 Community Based Natural Resource Management (CBNRM) 45 National Master Plan for Arable Agriculture and Dairy Development (NAMPAADD) 45 Citizen Entrepreneurial Development Agency (CEDA) 45 National Settlement Policy (NSP) 45 Waste Management Act 45 Housing Policy 45 National Conservation Strategy (NCS) 46 4.3 DDP 6 ENVIRONMENTAL GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 46 4.4 FRAMEWORK FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT 47 4.5 PROPOSED ENVIRONMENTAL ENVIRONMENTAL PROGRAMS. 4.6 RESOURCE REQUIREMENT FOR DDP 6 48 4.6.1 Issues and Strengths 48 5 STRATEGIES TO IMPLEMENT LAND USE PLANNING DISTRICT 48 51 5.1 INTRODUCTION 51 5.1.1 5.1.2 Institutional Framework Consultation Priorities 51 52 5.2 LAND USE POLICIES AND LEGISLATION 52 5.2.1 5.2.2 5.2.3 5.2.4 5.2.5 National Policy on Natural Resources Conservation and Development North East District Settlement Strategy Wildlife and Conservation Policy Tourism Policy Community Based Natural Resources Management 52 53 53 53 53 iv 5.2.6 5.2.7 5.2.8 5.2.9 5.2.10 National Master Plan for Arable Agriculture and Dairy Development (NAMPAADD) 53 Financial Assistance Policy/Citizen Etrepreneural Development Agency 53 National Settlement Policy 53 Housing Policy 54 Waste Management Act 54 5.3 DISTRICT LAND USE PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT 54 5.3.1 5.3.2 District Settlement Strategy (DSS) Land Use Resource Assessment 54 54 5.4 LAND USE PLANNING GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 55 5.5 FRAMEWORK FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT 56 5.5.1 5.5.2 Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues with Sector Goals and Objectives Evaluation of Sector Policies and Programs 56 56 5.6 PROPOSED STRATEGIES TO ACHIEVE LAND USE GOALS 57 5.7 RESOURCE REQUIREMENT FOR DDP 6 57 5.7.1 5.7.2 5.7.3 Performance Targets for DDP6 Development Budget for DDP6 Plan Monitoring Program 57 58 58 6 SETTLEMENT AND HOUSING 59 6.1 INTRODUCTION 59 6.1.1 6.1.2 Institutional Framework Consultation Priorities 59 61 6.2 NATIONAL POLICIES AND LEGISLATION 61 6.2.1 6.2.2 6.2.3 6.2.4 District Settlement Strategy National Housing Policy Self Help Housing Agency (SHHA) Institutional Housing 61 63 63 64 6.3 SETTLEMENT AND HOUSING 65 6.3.1 6.3.2 Settlement Patterns and Geomorphology Housing Demand and Supply 65 67 6.4 SETTLEMENT AND HOUSING SECTOR GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 67 6.5 FRAMEWORK FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT 68 6.6 RESOURCE REQUIREMENTS FOR DDP6 69 6.6.1 6.6.2 6.6.3 Strengths Issues Plan Monitoring Program 69 69 69 7 7.1 AGRICULTURE INTRODUCTION 70 70 v 7.1.1 7.1.2 7.1.3 Institutional Framework Strategic Plan for Ministry of Agriculture Agriculture Consultation Priorities 70 70 71 7.2 NATIONAL POLICIES AND LEGISLATION 72 7.2.1 7.2.2 7.2.3 7.2.4 7.2.5 National Master Plan for Arable Agriculture and Dairy Development Community Based Natural Resource Management (CBNRM) Policy (Draft) Arable Land Development Programme (ALDEP) Tribal Land Act Convention on Combating Desertification 72 72 72 73 73 7.3 AGRICULTURAL SECTOR ACTIVITIES 73 7.3.1 7.3.2 7.3.3 Arable Sub Sector Horticulture Livestock Sub Sector 73 74 74 7.4 AGRICULTURE SECTOR GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 75 7.5 FRAMEWORK FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT 76 7.6 STRATEGIES TO ACHIEVE THE AGRICULTURAL SECTOR GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 77 7.7 RESOURCES REQUIREMENT FOR DDP6 77 7.7.1 7.7.2 7.7.3 7.7.4 Issues and Strengths Development Budget Performance Targets Plan Monitoring Program 77 78 79 79 8 TRADE INDUSTRY WILDLIFE AND TOURISM 80 8.1 INTRODUCTION 80 8.1.1 8.1.2 8.1.3 8.1.4 Institutional Framework Strategic Plan for Ministry Trade and Industry Role of the Private Sector Consultation Priorities 80 80 81 81 8.2 NATIONAL POLICIES AND LEGISLATION 82 8.2.1 8.2.2 8.2.3 8.2.4 8.2.5 8.2.6 Game Ranching Policy (2002) Ostrich Management Policy (1994) Community Based Natural Resource Management (CBRNM) Policy (Draft) Botswana Tourism Master Plan (2000) Tourism Policy (1990) Citizen Entrepreneurial Development Agency (CEDA) 2001 82 82 82 82 83 83 8.3 TRADE AND INDUSTRY 83 8.3.1 8.3.2 8.3.3 Industrial and commercial Development Wildlife and National Parks Tourism 83 84 84 8.4 SECTOR GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 85 8.5 FRAMEWORK FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT 86 8.5.1 Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues with Sectoral Goals and Objectives 86 vi 8.5.2 Evaluation of Sector Policies and Programs 86 8.6 STRATEGIES TO ACHIEVE GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 87 8.7 RESOURCE REQUIREMENTS FOR DDP6 87 8.7.1 Issues and Strengths for Trade, Industry, tourism and wildlife 87 9 EDUCATION AND TRAINNING 88 9.1 INTRODUCTION 88 9.1.1 9.1.2 9.1.3 9.1.4 Institutional Framework Strategic Plan for Respective Ministries Role of the Private Sector Education Consultation Priorities 88 89 89 90 9.2 NATIONAL POLICIES AND LEGISLATION 90 9.3 EDUCATION 90 9.3.1 9.3.2 Schools Training 90 92 9.4 EDUCATION AND TRAINING SECTOR GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 94 9.5 FRAMEWORK FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT 95 9.5.1 9.5.2 Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues with Sector Goals and Objectives Evaluation of Sector Policies and Programs 95 96 9.6 STRATEGIES TO ACHIEVE EDUCATION AND TRAINING GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 96 9.7 RESOURCE REQUIREMENT FOR DDP6 97 9.7.1 9.7.2 9.7.3 9.7.4 Issues and Strengths for Education and Training Performance Targets for DDP6/UDP2 Development Budget for DDP6/UDP2 Plan Monitoring Programme 97 97 98 99 10 HEALTH 100 10.1 INTRODUCTION 100 10.1.1 10.1.2 10.1.3 10.1.4 Institutional Framework Strategic Plan for Respective Ministries Role Of Private Sectors Consultation Priorities 100 101 103 103 10.2 NATIONAL POLICIES AND LEGISLATION 104 10.2.1 10.2.2 10.2.3 10.2.4 National Policy on HIV/AIDS National Health Policy Health Strategy and Plans Environmental Health Policies and Legislations 104 104 104 105 10.3 HEALTH 106 10.3.1 Environmental Health 106 vii 10.3.2 10.3.3 10.3.4 10.3.5 Hospital Services District Health System Primary Health Care Control of Pandemic Disease 106 106 106 107 10.4 HEALTH SECTOR GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 108 10.5 FRAMEWORK FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT 109 10.5.1 10.5.2 10.5.3 Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues With Sector Goals and Objectives Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues with Sector Goals and Objectives Evaluation of Sector Policies and Programs 109 109 110 10.6 STRATEGIES TO ACHIEVE THE HEALTH SECTOR GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 110 10.7 RESOURCE REQUIREMENTS FOR DDP6/UDP2 111 10.7.1 10.7.2 10.7.3 10.7.4 Strengths for Health Services Issues for Health Services Performance Targets for DDP6/UDP2 Plan Monitoring Programme 111 111 111 112 11 MINISTRY OF LABOUR AND HOME AFFAIRS 113 11.1 INTRODUCTION 113 11.1.1 11.1.2 Strategic Plans for Respective Ministries Culture and Social Consultation Priorities 113 115 11.2 NATIONAL POLICIES AND LEGISLATION 116 11.2.1 11.2.2 11.2.3 11.2.4 11.2.5 11.2.6 11.2.7 11.2.8 National Child Welfare Policy The National Youth Policy Disability Policies Social Welfare Women and Development Sports and Recreational Policy National Registration Act Information Media Policy 116 116 116 117 117 117 118 118 11.3 LABOUR, CULTURE AND SOCIAL SERVICES 118 11.3.1 11.3.2 11.3.3 11.3.4 11.3.5 11.3.6 11.3.7 11.3.8 Sports and Recreation Social Welfare Culture and Youth National Library Service Civil and National Registration Women and Development Museums, Monuments and Art Gallery Non-Governmental Organisations 118 119 119 119 120 120 121 121 11.4 LABOUR, CULTURE AND SOCIAL SERVICES SECTOR GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 122 11.5 FRAMEWORK FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT 123 11.5.1 11.5.2 Environmental Education and Awareness Creation 124 Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) And Strategic Environmental Planning (SEP) 124 viii 11.5.3 11.5.4 11.5.5 Funding for Community Environmental Projects Dissemination of Environment and Land Related Legislations Review of Policies and Legislations 11.6 STRATEGIES TO ACHIEVE THE LABOUR, CULTURE AND SOCIAL SERVICE SECTOR GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 125 11.7 RESOURCE REQUIREMENTS FOR DDP6 126 11.7.1 11.7.2 11.7.3 11.7.4 Issues and Strength For Labour, Culture and Social Services Performance Targets for DDP6 Development Budget for DDP6 Plan Monitoring Program 126 126 127 127 12 MINERALS, ENERGY AND WATER 124 124 125 128 12.1 INTRODUCTION 128 12.1.1 12.1.2 12.1.3 12.1.4 Institutional Framework Strategic Planning Framework Role of the Private Sector Consultation Priorities 128 129 129 129 12.2 NATIONAL POLICIES AND LEGISLATION 130 12.2.1 12.2.2 12.2.3 12.2.4 12.2.5 12.2.6 12.2.7 Waste Management Act Minerals Policy Energy Policy The National Settlement Policy Tribal Land Act National Water Master Plan [NWMP] Water Policy 130 130 130 131 131 131 131 12.3 MINING, ENERGY AND WATER 132 12.3.1 12.3.2 12.3.3 Mining Sector Energy Sector Water Sector 132 133 135 12.4 MINERALS, ENERGY AND WATER SECTOR GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 136 12.5 FRAMEWORK FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT 136 12.6 STRATEGIES TO ACHIEVE THE MINERALS, ENERGY AND WATER SECTOR 137 12.7 RESOURCE REQUIREMENTS FOR DDP 6 137 12.7.1 12.7.2 12.7.3 Issues and Strengths Development Budget Performance Targets and Plan Monitoring Program 137 138 138 13 WORKS, TRANSPORT AND COMMUNICATIONS 139 13.1 INTRODUCTION 139 13.1.1 13.1.2 Institutional Framework Strategic Plan for Ministry of Local Government 139 140 ix 13.1.3 13.1.4 13.1.5 Strategic Plan for Ministry of Transport, Works and Communications Role of the Private Sector Consultation Priorities 140 141 141 13.2 NATIONAL POLICIES AND LEGISLATION 141 13.2.1 13.2.2 13.2.3 13.2.4 13.2.5 13.2.6 13.2.7 Roads Act Local Government Act Transport and Safety Policy Civil Aviation Policy Telecommunications Act Meteorological Services Policy Postal Services Act 141 142 142 142 142 143 143 13.3 WORKS, TRANSPORT AND COMMUNICATION 143 13.3.1 13.3.2 13.3.3 13.3.4 13.3.5 13.3.6 13.3.7 13.3.8 Roads Transport and Road Safety Railways Civil Aviation Central Transport Organisation Telecommunications Postal Services Department of Architecture and Buildings 143 144 144 144 145 145 146 146 13.4 WORKS, TRANSPORT AND COMMUNICATIONS GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 146 13.5 FRAMEWORK FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT 147 13.6 STRATEGIES TO ACHIEVE WORKS, TRANSPORT GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 13.7 RESOURCE REQUIREMENTS 149 13.7.1 13.7.2 13.7.3 13.7.4 Issues and Strengths Development Budget Perforamnce Targets Plan Monitoring Programme 149 149 149 150 14 LAW, JUSTICE AND SECURITY AND COMMUNICATIONS SECTOR 148 151 14.1 INTRODUCTION 151 14.1.1 14.1.2 14.1.3 Institutional Framework Role of the Private Sector Consultation Priorities 152 152 152 14.2 NATIONAL POLICIES AND LEGISLATION 152 14.2.1 14.2.2 14.2.3 14.2.4 14.2.5 14.2.6 14.2.7 14.2.8 Immigration Act Botswana Police Act Immigration and Citizenship Botswana Police Service Customs and Exercise Local Police and Customary Court Administration of Justice Independent Electoral Commission 152 153 153 154 154 155 155 155 x 14.3 LAW JUSTICE AND SECURITY GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 156 14.4 FRAMEWORK FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT 156 14.4.1 14.4.2 Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues with Sector Goals and Objectives Evaluation of Sector Policies and Programs 157 157 14.5 STRATEGIES OBJECTIVES 14.6 RESOURCE REQUIREMENTS 158 14.6.1 14.6.2 14.6.3 14.6.4 Issues & Strengths for Law Justice and Security Performance Targets Development Budget for DDP6 Plan Monitoring Programme 158 158 158 158 15 TO ACHIEVE LAW, JUSTICE AND SECURITY SECTOR GOALS AND 157 LOCAL GOVERNMENT 160 15.1 INTRODUCTION 160 15.1.1 15.1.2 15.1.3 15.1.4 Institutional Framework Strategic Plans for Respective Ministries Role of Private Sector Consultation Priorities 160 160 161 162 15.2 NATIONAL POLICIES AND LEGISLATION 162 15.2.1 15.2.2 15.2.3 15.2.4 15.2.5 15.2.6 15.2.7 15.2.8 15.2.9 Tribal Land Act Local Police Act Waste Management Act Local Government District Councils District Administration Tribal Administration Land Board Law and Order 162 162 163 163 163 164 164 165 165 15.3 LOCAL GOVERNMENT GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 165 15.3.1 15.3.2 15.3.3 15.3.4 District Council District Administration Tribal Administration Land Board 165 166 167 167 15.4 FRAMEWORK FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT 168 15.4.1 15.4.2 Evaluation of Sector Goals and Objectives against Key Environmental Issues Evaluation of Sector Goals and Objectives Against Key Environmental Issues 168 169 15.5 STRATEGIES TO ACHIEVE LOCAL GOVERNMENT SECTOR GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 170 15.6 RESOURCE REQUIREMENT FOR DDP 6 170 15.6.1 15.6.2 15.6.3 Issues and Strengths Performance Targets Development Budget 170 171 171 xi 15.6.4 16 Plan Monitoring Program CONTINGENCY PLANNING 171 173 16.1 INTRODUCTION 173 16.1.1 16.1.2 Institutional Framework Disaster Relief Sector Priorities 173 174 16.2 NATIONAL POLICIES AND LEGISLATION 174 16.2.1 16.2.2 National Disaster Master Plan National Food Security Strategy 174 174 16.3 CONTINGENCY PLANS 175 16.3.1 16.3.2 16.3.3 16.3.4 Drought Veld Fires Disaster Management Foot and Mouth Disease 175 175 175 176 16.4 FRAMEWORK FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT 176 16.4.1 16.4.2 16.4.3 16.4.4 16.4.5 Disaster Management Objectives Drought Management Objectives Evaluation of Sector Goals and Objectives Evaluation of Sector Policies and Programmes Proposed Projects/Activities 176 176 176 177 178 16.5 RESOURCE REQUIREMENTS 178 16.5.1 16.5.2 16.5.3 Issues and Strengths Performance Targets Proposed Projects 178 178 179 17 PLAN MONITORING AND EVALUATION 180 17.1 INTRODUCTION 180 17.1.1 17.1.2 Institutional Framework Review of Plan Monitoring Activities During DDP 5 180 180 17.2 ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING ACTIVITIES 181 17.3 FINANCIAL AND PERSONNEL CONSTRAINTS 181 17.4 PROPOSED PLAN MONITORING ACTIVITIES DURING DDP6 181 17.4.1 17.4.2 17.4.3 Project Reviews Annual Plans Mid Term Review 181 182 182 APPENDICES APPENDIX A: DISTRICT COUNCIL PROJECTS 183 xii LIST OF TABLES Table 1.1: Table 1.2: Table 1.3: Table 1.4: Table 1.5: Table 2.1: Table 3.1: Table 3.2: Table 3.3: Table 3.4: Table 4.1: Table 4.2: Table 4.3: Table 4.3: Table 4.4: Table 5.1: Table 5.2: Table 5.3: Table 5.4: Table 5.5: Table 5.6: Table 6.1: Table 6.2: Table 6.3: Table 7.1: Table 7.2: Table 7.3: Table 7.4: Table 7.5: Table 7.6: Table 8.1: Table 8.3: Table 8.4: Table 8.5: Table 8.7: Table 9.1: Table 9.2: Table 9.3: Table 9.4: Table 9.5: Table 9.6: Table 9.7: Table 9.8: Table 9.9: Table 9.10: Table 9.11: Table 11.2: Table 10.1: Table 10.2: Table 10.3: Table 10.4: Table 10.5: Table 10.6: Land Tenure in the North East District Population Characteristics of North East District Commercial Activity in North East District Employment and Unemployment District Population by Major Industry Planned and Implemented Education Facilities DDP5 Ministry of Local Governement Key Result Areas DDP6 Overal Development Goals and Objectives Key Environmental Issues with Overall Goals and Objectives Evaluation of Policies/Programmes against Ovearll Goals and Objectives Goals and Objectives Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues with Sector Goals and Objectives Evaluation of Sector Policies and Programs Performance Targets Development Budget Goals and Objectives Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues with Sector Goals and Objectives Evaluation of Sector Policies and Programs Potential Impacts of Projects and Mitigation measures Performance Targets For DDP 6 Development Budget For DDP 6 Housing Situation per Institutions in North East District Goals and Objectives Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues with Sector Goals and Objectives Agricultural Sector Goals and Objectives Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues with Sector Goals and Objectives Evaluation of Sector Policies and Programs Agricultural Sector Strategies Development Budget Performance Indicators North East Historical Sites Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues with Sectoral Goals and Objectives Evaluation of Sector Policies and Programs Trade and Industry Strategies Plan Monitoring Programme Day Care Centres in the District Primary Education Enrollment Enrollment of Non-Formal Learners Planned Enrolment for Zwenshambe Brigades Planned Enrolment for Senyawe Brigades Education and Training Sector Goals and Objectives Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues with Sector Goals and Objectives Evaluation of Sector Policies and Programs Strategies to Achieve Education and Training Goals and Objectives Performance Targets for DDP6/UDP2 Proposed Development Projects for DDP6 – Brigades and Non-Formal Planned Projects DDP6 - Secondary School Projects Components of Primary Health Care Health Sector Goals and Objectives Environmental Key Issues with Sector Goals and Objectives Evaluation Health Sector Polices and Programs Strategies to Achieve Health Sector Goals and Objectives Performance Targets for DDP6 1 8 11 12 12 21 37 40 42 43 46 47 47 49 49 55 56 56 57 57 58 64 68 68 75 76 77 77 78 79 85 86 86 87 87 90 91 92 93 93 94 95 96 96 97 98 99 107 108 109 110 110 112 xiii Table 11.1: Table 11.2: Table 11.3: Table 11.4: Table 11.5: Table 11.6: Table 11.7: Table 12.1 Table 12.2: Table 12.3: Table 12.4: Table 12.5: Table 12.6: Table 12.7: Table 13.1: Table 13.2: Table 13.3: Table 13.4: Table 13.5: Table 13.6: Table 13.7: Table 14.1: Table 14.1: Table 14.3: Table 14.4: Table 14.5: Table 15.1: Table 15.2: Table 15.3: Table 15.1: Table 15.5: Table 16.1: Table 16.3: Table 16.4: Mininstry of Labour and Home Affairs Departments and Divisons Labour, Culture and Social Services Sector Goals Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues with Sector Goals and Objectives Evaluation of Sector Policies and Programs Strategies to Achieve Labour, Culture and Social Services Goals and Objectives Performance Targets for DDP6 Development Budget for DDP6 Sources of Energy used in Households in Botswana for Lighting, Cooking and Heating Minerals, Energy and Water sector Goals and Objectives Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues with Sector Goals and Objectives Evaluation of Sector Policies and Programs Minerals, Energy and Water Sector Strategies Development Budget Performance Indicators and Plan monitoring Postal Services in North East District Works, Transport and Communications Goals and Objectives Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues with Sector Goals and Objectives Evaluation of Sector Policies and Programs Works, Transport and Communications Strategies Development Budget Performance Targets for DDP 6 Law, Justice and Security Goals and Objectives Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues with Sector Goals and Objectives Evaluation Of Sector Policies and Programs Proposed Projects, Potential Impacts and Mitigation Measures Development Budget District Council Goals and Objectives District Administration Goals and Objectives Tribal Administartion Goals and Objectives Land Board Goals and Objectives Evaluation of Sector Goals and Objectives with Key Environmental Issues Evaluation of Sector Goals and Objectives Proposed Projects, Potential Impacts and Mitigation Measures Proposed Projects 114 122 123 125 125 127 127 Space 134 136 136 137 137 138 138 146 146 147 148 148 149 150 156 157 157 157 158 165 166 167 167 168 176 178 179 LIST OF FIGURES AND MAPS Map 1.1: Map 1.2: Figure 1.1: Map 6.1: Geographical Location of the North East District Administration Boundary Population Pyramid for North East District North East District Land Use 3 5 9 66 LIST OF ACRONYMS AD AIDS ALDEP ALSP AOJ ARAP ARV Agricultural Demonstrator Acquired Immune Deficiency Virus Arable Land Development Programme Accelerated Lands Servicing Programme Administration of Justice Accelerated Remote Area Development Programme Anti Retroviral Therapy xiv BAMB BBS BCG BDC BDF BHC BIDPA BLDC BMC BML BNPC BOCCIM BPC BPS BR BTC BTC BVI Botswana Agricultural Marketing Board Botswana Building Society Bacille Callmtte Guerin Botswana Development Corporation Botswana Defence Force Botswana Housing Corporation Botswana Institute of Development and Policy Analysis Botswana Livestock Development Corporation Botswana Meat Commission Botswana Material Loan Botswana National Productivity Center Botswana Confederation of commerce, Industry and Manpower Botswana Power Corporation Botswana Postal Services Botswana Railways Botswana Telecommunications Corporation Botswana Technology Centre Botswana Vaccine Institute CBNRM CBNRMP CBO CBS CCF CEDA CHA CITES CJSS CMS CSO CTF CWC DA DABS DAHP DC DCPF DDC DDP DEPC DHPC DET DEMS DHT DLUPU DMSAC DO (D) DO (L) DSM DSS Community Based Natural Resource Management Community Based Natural Resource Management Programme Community Based Organisations Community Based Strategy Community Conservation Fund Citizen Entrepreneurial Development Agency Controlled Hunting Area Convention on International Trade of Endangered Species Community Junior Secondary School Central Medical Stores Central Statistics Office Community Trust Fund Child Welfare Clinic District Administration Department of Architecture and Building Services Department of Animal Health and Production District Commissioner Department of Crop Production and Forestry District Development Committee District Development Plan District Education Planning Committee District Health Planning Committee District Extension Team Department of Electrical and Mechanical Services District Health Team District Land Use Planning Unit District Multi Sectoral AIDS Committee District Officer Development District Officer Lands Department of Surveys and Mapping District Settlement Strategy xv DTRP DVET DWA DWNP Department of Town and Regional Planning Department of Vocational Education and Training Department of Water Affairs Department of Wildlife and National Parks EWTC Early Warning Technical Committee FAB FAP FMD FWE Forestry Association of Botswana Financial Assistance Policy Foot and Mouth Disease Family Welfare Educator GDA GDP GFPA GNP General Duty Assistants Gross Domestic Product Greater Francistown Planning Area Gross National Product HIV HATAB HBC HIES Human Immuno Deficiency Virus Hotel and Tourism Association of Botswana Home Based Care Household Income and Expenditure Survey IFS IMDC KRA Integrated Field Services Inter Ministerial Drought Committee Key Result Area LA LAC LB LBRP Local Authority Livestock Advisory Centre Land Board Labour Based Relief Programme MCH/FP MFDP MLHA MLG MMEWA MOA MOE MOH MTIWAT MTP MSP MWTC Maternal and Child Health/Family Planning Ministry of Finance and Development Planning Ministry of Labour and Home Affairs Ministry of Local Government Ministry of Minerals, Energy and Water Affairs Ministry of Agriculture Ministry of Education Ministry of Health Ministry of Trade, Industry, Wildlife and Tourism Medium Term Plan Ministry of State President Ministry of Works, Transport and Communications NCS NDB NDDC NDP NDMO NEDC NES National Conservation Strategy National Development Bank National District Development Conference National Development Plan National Disaster Management Office North East District Council National Eco-Tourism Strategy xvi NGO NSP Non Governmental Organisation National Settlement Policy O&M OP Organization and Methods Office of the President PDC PHC PMS PMTCT Production Development Committee Public Health Care Performance Management System Prevention of Mother To Child Transmission RAC RDC RDCD RECC RIIC RNPE Rural Administration Centre Rural Development Council Rural Development Coordination Division Rural Extension Coordinating Committee Rural Industries Innovation Centre Revised National Policy on Education SADC S&CD SEA SHHA SLOCA SMME STD SWOT Southern African Development Community Social and Community Development Strategic Environmental Assessment Self Help Housing Agency Small Livestock Owners in Communal Areas Small, Medium and Micro Enterprises Sexually Transmitted Disease Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, Threats TA TB TEC TGLP TILB Tribal Administration Tuberculosis Total Estimated Costs Tribal Grazing Land Policy Tourism Industry Licensing Board UDP UB UNDP UDC Urban Development Plan University of Botswana United Nations Development Programme Urban Development Committee VA VCT VDC VET VHT VIP VTC Veterinary Assistant Voluntary Counselling and Testing Village Development Committee Village Extension Team Village Health Team Ventilated Improved Pit latrines Vocational Training Centre WIT WMA WUC Work Improvement Team Wildlife Management Area Water Utilities Corporation xvii CHAPTER 1 1 DISTRICT AND PEOPLE 1.1 DISTRICT GEOGRAPHIC SETTING North east district is the second smallest district in the country. The district fits within the lines of longitude 27'15 and 28 east, and between latitude 20'30 and 21'25 south. The district is bordered by the Central District in the west and south with the Shashe River forming the boundary. In the east and north is Zimbabwe, with the Ramokgwebana River forming much of the boundary. The Francistown urban area is surrounded by the North East District, which has a tremendous influence on the delivery of services as well as transfer of technology to the district. The district has different types of land ownership as shown in table 1.1. The district has an area of 5 993 square kilometres. However, in order to increase both the Francistown area and the tribal land the government bought some freehold farms. Table 1.1: Land Tenure in the North East District Type of Land Tenure Freehold Land State Land Tribal/Communal Land Total District Area in sq kms 2 569 33 3 391 5993Km % of total land 42.9 0.5 56.6 100% Source: Draft North East District Settlement Strategy, 2001 1.1.1 Regional Influences The location of the district, in relation to Zimbabwe and Francistown, means that the district has been influenced socially, economically, and educationally. Francistown and Bulawayo, the two major urban areas, sandwitching the district, act as service centres for all the above activities. North East residents have acquired urban habits and a considerable number of people have been educated from these places. The influences are found in other spheres of life like family connections, cultural affinity and others. 1.2 INSTITUTIONAL ARRANGEMENTS The district has four local authorities the district administration, tribal administration, land board and district council. The Tribal Administration is one of the oldest institutions in Botswana. It administers justice under customary law and support for community initiatives. The District Administration has the primary responsibility of ensuring effective representation of central government. Additionally it is responsible for coordinating district development planning. The land board deals with dermacation and allocation tribal land while the district council is responsible for provision of services such as sanitation services, health services, infrastructure services etc. 1 1.2.1 Communication Links Access to and communication within the North East District in terms of roads, railways, telecommunications, etc., is comparatively better compared to other districts in the country. The District is mainly connected to Francistown and the rest of the country through the follwing gazetted roads; Ramokgwebana-Ramatlabama, Ramokgwebana-Sebina-Francistown and Matsiloje-Francistown tarmacked roads and Tshesebe-Mulambakwena earth surfaced road. The rest of the roads are un-gazetted, with some of them earth surfaced and others dirty. The area to the south of Matsiloje is mainly characterized by tracks and is not easily accessible, especially during the rainy season. The main railway line from Ramatlabama to Ramokgwebana passes through the eastern part of the district and this line carries passengers and freight both within Botswana and to and from Zimbabwe. Botswana Telecommunication Corporation (BTC) has done commendable work to serve the district. The only village, which has not been provided with a public telephone, is Ditladi. However, reception of radio Botswana broadcasts is weak. Therefore, this issue needs to be addressed urgently if we are to achieve the ideals of vision 2016 of an informed and educated nation. 1.3 DISTRICT ENVIRONMENTAL FEATURES 1.3.1 Climate The climate in the North East District has distinct summer and winter seasons. Winters are generally mild except for occasional cold winds. The minimum temperature can be as low as 5 degrees centigrade with maximum temperatures of 23 degrees. Summers, at times are very hot with maximum averages of 30 degrees centigrade and minimums of 17 degrees. The district has fair annual rainfall averages ranging between 400 millimetres (in the south) and 500 millimetres (in the north), but it falls only during a few months from october to march, usually in thunderstorms. 1.3.2 Topography The entire North East District is undulating with isolated hills such as Matsiloje, Mpaninpani and Gungwe Hills. The land rises from 930m in the south to 1300m above sea level to the north. 2 Map 1.1: Geographical Location of the North East District 3 1.3.3 Geology Masunga lies within the country’s major dyke, which traverses the country (in a 70km wide belt in the north east district) stretching between Francistown and central district. Basement rock outcrops are quite evident in the area. Apart from these outcrops the land is generally flat. Soils are well drained and moderately deep (about a metre) with medium texture soils developed from basic igneous and metamorphic rocks. The texture varies from loamy sand to clay loam. The flood plains of the Rati River and other streams have a high proportion of soils that have little or no irrigation potential. 1.3.4 Hydrology The district has several ephemeral rivers and streams. The principal rivers include Shashe, Vukwi, Tati, Ntshe, Sikukwe, and Ramokgwebana. The direction of drainage is towards the south. These rivers are able to store considerable amounts of water in the sub-surface sand layer for most of the year. The rivers and streams carry floodwater after rainstorms during the rainy season, but for the rest of the year they are dry. 1.3.5 Natural Resources 1.3.5.1 Soils Soils are generally well drained and moderately deep. The soils are sandy loam and sandy clay with the gravel about 50 centimetres below the surface. Clay soils occur between Makaleng and Kalakamati and north of Francistown. Some of this area comprises base rock and very shallow soils associated with hills and ridges. Substantial portions of the soil are not suitable for dry-land farming due to their chemical composition and low water holding capacity. 1.3.5.2 Vegetation The vegetation of the district is characterised mainly by tree savanna with Mophane trees predominating. Since the north and west of the district are the most cultivated areas, only large trees have been left of the original woodland. Patchy grass cover is found on most of the communal lands and those parts of the freehold land, which are not overgrazed. Areas inhabited by Mophane trees have a poor grass cover. 1.3.5.3 Wildlife There is very little wildlife in the district and most of it is on the freehold farms. The animals in this area are under the authority of the department of wildlife and national parks. Freehold land owners are only allowed to hunt during the hunting season, though the potential for wildlife tourism is very slim. 4 Map 1.2: Administration Boundary 5 1.3.5.4 Energy Energy supplies in the north east district are mainly made up of electricity connected from Francistown to Tati Siding and also from Francistown to Masunga through a 66kv line stepped down to 400 watts internal distribution through 11kv lines. The main consumers are council and central government departments, primary hospital, the senior and junior secondary schools, Botswana Telecommunication Corporation, small commercial and industrial businesses and about 300 domestic consumers. Other sources of energy are paraffin, candles for lighting and fuel wood, which is almost depleted except in the southern part of the district. Gas is also used domestically. 1.3.5.5 Water The district is bordered and crossed by many ephemeral streams and rivers. The principal ones are the Shashe, Vukwi, Tati, Ntshe, Sikukwe and Ramokgwebana Rivers. A considerable amount of water is stored in the larger sand rivers throughout the dry season. This provides the major source of water for both human and livestock populations in the district. The most common water resources are boreholes, sandpits and wells. There is one large dam in the district, the Shashe Dam, near Shashe village. There are several dam sites, which were identified in the district such as Ntimbale and Lower Shashe. Other important sources of water are acquifers, which are predominatly found in the Makaleng area. There are also smaller dams in the district, which however, lack maintenance and proper management and end up having short-term lives. The reasons advanced for the poor state of smaller dams are, the poor designs and workmanship that lead to their inability to store water for longer periods. Because of these shortcomings, people who are supposed to maintain them become reluctant to do so since the dams do not meet people’s water requirements. The communities have expressed willingness to maintain these facilities if built properly. The North East district has many sources of water including boreholes, wells, and pits along its rivers. There are 140 boreholes in the freehold farms and 50 council operated boreholes. Due to the absence of adequate ground water sources in the district, more than 30 per cent of the boreholes drilled are dry while several have saline water, especially in the Makaleng area. Borehole yields vary from one area to another according to the types of underlying rocks. The yields range from 1500 to 7000 litres per hour. Villages such as Zwenshambe, Gulubane and Ramokgwebana have boreholes with very poor yields. These have been abandoned and the villages get their water sources from other villages through water transfer schemes. In Masunga there is a collector well, which is operated during rainy seasons only. This method helps in supplementing the few low yielding boreholes within Masunga, whose water demand has kept rising. It is estimated that more than 60% of all boreholes in the district have declining yields due to the persistent drought that has affected the area. Only the southern parts of the district have good yielding boreholes. On the issue of private connections, only those villages with enough water supplies are allowed to be connected to individual consumers. The water supply responsibility is shared between the Department of Water Affairs and the Water and Wastewater department of the district council. Since DDP5, a greater share of responsibility for larger villages, and more rehabilitation work, has been taken by Council. 6 1.3.5.6 Minerals Between 1869 and 1966 there were more than 50 gold mines in the district. Silver was also produced as a by-product of these operations. Mines such as Tekwane, Golden Eagle, Mop East, Puel Nervack, Penhalonge and Rainbow are believed to still contain unworked gold reserves. Copper and nickel ore reserves are being exploited at Selkirk and Phoenix. There are some known reserves at other places in the northern part of the district. Reserves of arsenic, asbestos, kyanite and iron also exist. Iron, limestone and lithium in the district are also said to be in reasonable quantities. The limestone in the Matsiloje hills is being exploited for the manufacture of cement and soapstone products from the processes. Quarried and blasted stones are also used for building. 1.4 DISTRICT SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT 1.4.1 Socio-Cultural Characteristics Located within the district but administratively separate is the city of Francistown, founded in 1867 and named after Mr Daniel Francis, the first white gold prospector. In the mid 19th century the Bakhurutse immigrated into the Tati area and settled there. Early in the 19th century the disturbances that were brought about by a revolution in the Zulu state, resulted in mass migrations known as the Mfecane. This had created a vacuum in the area as people fled from the warlike Zulus. It was during the Mfecane that Mzilikazi passed through the Tati district causing more political disturbances. Ethnically, the district comprises the Bakalanga, Barolong, Batalaote, and Bakhurutse. In the 1840s the Ndebele under Mzilikazi forced the Bakalanga and Bangwato to flee from the district southwards into Bangwato land. At that time gold was discovered between the Shashe and the Ramokgwebana rivers. In 1880 Lobengula, king of the Ndebele leased mining rights to the Tati Company. In 1893 after the defeat of Lobengula, the Tati Concession was placed within the Bechuanaland protectorate. The Bakalanga and Bangwato who had fled to the Tati district began to return, but there were conflicts between them and the Tati Company. This problem was partially resolved in 1905 by establishing a reserve of a mere 344 square miles (891km2) in the north and west of the district for African occupation. By 1913 after the reserve was already overcrowded the Bakhurutse had to move to Tonota. Other communities also moved into Ngwato territory. Groups of Rolong, Talaote and Nyai came into the district, thus counter balancing out migration and overcrowding. During all this period the people of the district were actively involved in the mining of gold and other minerals, which were sold to the Arabs and Europeans who traded in valuable western goods. At the height of this important trade the Rozwi Mambo (a zimbabwean king) emerged as a strong leader who controlled a monopoly over gold, and prevented the Asians and Arabs from having direct contact with the Tati inhabitants. In this way the mambo controlled and engaged in trade with the east coast of southern and central Africa. The Bakalanga traditionally do not settle in a compact form of settlement, but scatter within a big geographical area. In most cases when a village is originally established, it is composed mostly of a family and relatives, e.g. Matenge, Masunga, Butale, Sechele, Gambule etc. The headmen of such villages bear the same name as the village. 7 Although the district settlement pattern is not one of compact villages surrounded by zoned lands and cattle posts, the villagers raise cattle as well as doing arable farming around their homes. However, the villages dominated by Bangwato and Barolong are composed of wards, occupied by different families. They have separated their grazing areas and the fields from their villages 1.4.2 Population Characteristics, Density and Distribution Table 1.2 shows the population figures from the 2001 census. The North East has a total population of 49 399 persons of which 53.1% are females showing the dominance of female in the population structure of the district which compares well with the national scenario. The district has several sparsely populated and scattered all over the district. With an area of 5993km2, the district has a population density of 8.2 which has increased from 7.2 recorded in the 1991 census. The population density of the district is more than the national average of 2.9 according to the 2001 population and housing census. 1.4.3 Age-Sex Structure Table 1.2: AGE 00-04 05-09 10-14 15-19 20-24 25-29 30-34 35-39 40-44 45-49 50-54 55-59 60-64 65-69 70-74 75- 79 80-84 85- 89 90- 94 95+ TOTAL Population Characteristics of North East District Males 3,168 3,694 3,974 3,279 1,677 1,296 1,024 863 752 680 579 398 423 398 361 253 206 82 27 30 23 164 Percentage 50.2 51.1 51.6 51.6 46.3 45.3 44.5 41 39.5 37.7 39.3 38.2 39.5 38.2 38.9 37.8 39.7 34 24.3 36.1 46.9 Females 3,138 3,539 3,722 3,077 1,944 1,566 1,278 1,244 1,168 1,140 893 642 647 644 567 417 313 159 84 53 26 235 Percentage 49.8 48.9 48.4 48.4 53.7 54.7 55.5 59 60.5 62.3 60.7 61.8 60.5 61.8 61.1 62.2 60.3 66 76.7 63.9 53.1 Total 6 306 7 233 7 696 6 356 3 621 2 862 2 302 2 107 1 902 1 802 1 472 1 040 1 070 1 042 928 670 519 241 111 83 49 399 Source: Population and Housing Census, 2001. The age-sex structure can also be studied through the use of the population pyramid see Figure 1. The pyramid has two bar charts connected. One on the left shows males while the right one represents females. The different age cohorts are shown in the middle from the youngest at the bottom to the oldest at the top. The pyramid is broad-based showing a young population i.e. high proportion of children although the age 0-9 age cohorts are smaller than the 10-14, depicting declining child bearing (fertility). High proportion of children shows the need for provision of health and educational facilities to cater for children. There is a low proportion of the older population and particularly skewed towards women showing a lower proportion of males in the 65-95 age categories. 8 North East 2001 Figure 1. Population by Age and Sex 95+ 90-94 Male Female 85-89 80-84 75-79 70-74 65-69 60-64 55-59 50-54 45-49 40-44 35-39 30-34 25-29 20-24 15-19 10-14 5-9 4000 3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0 0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500 4000 4500 0-4 Population Figure 1.1: Population Pyramid for North East District 9 The number of households in North East district was 10 834 in 2001 representing 2.68% of the total househols in the country. From these 45.4% are male-headed households were while 54.6% are female-headed households showing predominance of female over males in household headship. Female-headed households generally have less cash income, lesser land ownership rights and fewer cattle than their male counterparts. This calls for increasing opportunites for women when planning and also making them accessible to other economic oppportunities lik their male counterparts 1.4.4 Migration The district’s population during the 1991 and 2001 intercensal period was affected by both natural increase and migration trends. During that period, North East District gained a total of 5 717 immigrants from various parts of Botswana while outward migration was recorded at 3 820 people. 1.4.5 HIV/AIDS and its Economic Implications As stated under the social situation of the district, the AIDS pandemic is a serious threat to both the economies of the district and the nation at large. According to the 2002 sentinel survey carried out in pregnant women, out of the 196 women who enrolled for the survey 83 were positive showing a 38.6% HIV prevalence rate. . Francistown and Tutume has the highest HIV rates in the country. Their close proximity, social attractions and employment opportunities are major factors in the spread of HIV in the district. Multiple partners, intergenerational sexual activity, casual and unprotected sex, and prostitution are also factors in the spread of this disease. The scourge is depleting the country’s as well as the district’s valuable skilled human resource that government has invested so heavily in. It also impacts negatively on productivity in this district as those affected by the pandemic spend more time in hospital than at work. Further more a lot of resources and efforts that should have been used for other developments venture are now directed towards addressing the scourge. 1.4.6 Home Based Care Programme and Orphanhood The Home Based Care Programme continues to run despite the problems of staffing. The district had 219 registered home-based care patients in the last quarter of 2002 out of which 131 are female and 88 are male. The figure represents an increase by 44 more patients from previous quarter’s figure of 175. Medical statistics further reveal that, of the 219 patients, 74 were confirmed HIV positive, 88 were diagnosed with HIV related conditions but refused to test, while 57 have other chronic illnesses. During the quarter, of the 28 deaths recorded, 24 were HIV related and 4 were due to other chronic conditions. There were currently 93 home-based care patients on food basket, which depends on the condition of their illness. Concerning orphans the district recorded the 3.5% of orphans as relates to the district population being the third largest in the country 10 1.4.7 Projected Population Growth Trends, 1991 - 2019 The district had a population of 43 354 in 1991. From 1981 to 1991 the district’s annual population growth rate was put at 1.9%. This was one of the lowest growth rates in the country, followed by Southern and Kweneng districts at just above 3.0% per annum. Due to the high migration to towns because of unemployment and low agricultural productivity, and as a result of persistent drought, this growth rate is expected to drop even further to as low as 1.7% by the end of 2019. A medium rate of 1.9% for the next 10 years is, therefore, predicted and a lower medium rate of 1.7% per annum is assumed for the remaining part of the long-term planning period. 1.4.8 Economic Activity There are no major economic activities in the district, neither manufacturing nor wholesale establishments. There are a number of small-scale construction companies carrying out some maintenance work to various institutions in the district. There are also some projects supported by the Financial Assistance Policy (FAP), especially in the horticultural sub-sector that operates under financial and managerial strain. There is no record of any of these projects successfully developing into medium scale projects. Some of them collapsed after receiving funding. The district has several retail commercial enterprises, such as general dealers, restaurants, butcheries, bottle stores, cooperative shops, chibuku depots, supermarkets, filling stations, and several miscellaneous shops of a lower order. Table 1.3: Commercial Activity in North East District Type of Commercial/Industrial Activities General dealers Fresh produce Super Market Take away Restaurants Liquior Resturant Bottle stores Bar Specialised Dealer Dry Cleaner Pharmacy Hair Dresser Filling Station Motor Dealer Garage/workshop Hair Dresser Hotel Liquor Wholesale Trvale Agent Club Liquior Total in District 82 22 10 8 44 2 54 23 4 0 5 3 1 2 6 0 2 0 0 Source: North East District Settlement Strategy, 2001 Agriculture is a dominant activity, although it is mainly for subsistence purposes. The persistent drought that has ravaged the area during the last few years has reduced the water potentialities. An effort needs to be initiated to find solutions to low crop production. Extension staffs in the 11 agriculture sub-sector think that lack of commitment by farmers has also led to poor crop-yields in the district. 1.4.9 Employment and Unemployment According to the 2001 census, the district had 14 349 economically active persons (12 years and above) and this was 29% of the district population. Of these 10 193 were employed persons in both seasonal and non-seasonal paid jobs while 1647 were engaged in unpaid seasonal and nonseasonal work. The remaining 2 509 of the economically active population were actively seeking work. The majority of those employed were in six key villages of Masunga, Matsiloje, Tati Siding, Makaleng, Tsamaya and Tshesebe. Others were from Mapoka and Zwenshambe. In addition, there were people who worked in various places but were not paid, for example those working in family businesses, at lands/farms or cattle posts. For further details see Table 1.4 below. Economically inactive persons include those doing housework, students, retired persons or others not stated. The 2001 census showed that the district had 34 988 economically inactive persons. This was more than the number of economically active persons, which was 14 349 a dependency ration of 1:2. This literally means that approximately one working person economically supports two people. Of the economically inactive persons, 6 680 were doing housework, 10 041 were students and 595 were retired workers, 39 persons were engaged in other activities and 62 persons did not state their employment status. Unemployment was high among the age group 15-24 and low among age group 60-64. The high unemployment trend was also evident among the age group 65+. Table 1.4: Employment and Unemployment Employment Seasonal work paid Seasonal work unpaid Non seasonal work paid Non seasonal work unpaid Job seeker Home maker Student Retired Sick Other Unknown Not applicable Total Total 1 371 1 295 8 822 352 2 509 6 680 10 041 595 934 39 62 16 699 49 399 Proportion 2.8% 2.6% 17.9% 2.6% 5.1% 13.5% 20.3% 1.2% 1.9% 0.08% 0.13 33.8% 100 Source: Central Statistics Office, 2001 The district populace employed in non-seasonal work is mostly on construction as represented 24.3% followed by public administration and those engaged in agricultural activity. Table 1.5: District Population by Major Industry Major Industry Agriculture Fishing Mining and Quarrying Manufacturing Electricity, Gas and Water Supply Number of People 1 226 296 607 90 Proportion 12% 2.9% 5.9% 0.89% 12 Major Industry Construction Wholesale and retail trade Hotels and Resturant Transport, Storage and Communications Financial intermediaries Real Estates, Renting and Business Activities Public Administration Education Health and Social Work Other Community, Social and Personal Service Activities Private Household with Employed Persons Foreign Mission Internal Organisation Unknown Total Number of People 2 490 1 020 197 202 36 258 1 644 1 120 381 143 474 1 58 10 243 Proportion 24.3% 10% 1.9% 2% 0.4% 2.5% 16% 10.9% 3.7% 1.4% 4.6% 0.01 0.57% 100 Source: Central Statistics Office, 2001 Informal sector productivity is rather difficult to quantify due to the fact that most informal sector activities are carried out within households using family manpower. It is usually the non-cattle owners who get involved in such activities, which include firewood sellers, bricklayers, carpenters and other craftsmen 1.4.10 Constraints to Development Traditional employment like agriculture is not featuring as much as expected in the district. One factor that accounts for little agricultural activity is the presence of generally poor soils, insufficient water supplies and poor rainfall throughout the district. This means that ways must be found to diversify the economy to activities like industry and commerce, small and medium business sectors, which are not doing well at the moment in the North East District. Industrial development/activity has been low due to lack of raw materials, lack of basic infrastructure, water, and skilled labour and general lack of capacity to attract investors to the district. The poor accessibility to some parts of the district, especially during the rainy seasons, does not encourage investors to move from accessible and dominant towns such as Francistown and Selebi-Phikwe. The high HIV prevalence in the district poses a growing concern to development. The rates are highest in the most productive age group i.e. 20-40. This predisposes the district populace to high rates of illness, loss of workdays, low productivity and production, etc. 1.5 DISTRICT ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT The district has a few economic activities with agriculture being the dominant activity though practiced on a subsistence basis. Other activities found in the district are commercial, mining, government sector, and small-scale manufacturing. It is important to note that manufacturing enterprises referred to here is those assisted under the small-scale financial assistance policy. All in all, the district’s economic basis has not diversified as it still largely depends on subsistence agriculture and to a lesser extent mining. There is a general downward trend in agricultural productivity in the whole district, which is consistent with what is happening in the rest of the country. This trend is in line with structural transformation through the share of agriculture fall as economic development proceeds while other sectors of the economy advance. However this situation is disturbing for a small country like Botswana, which should at least be able to produce enough food to meet its domestic requirements. Unemployment still continues to be the biggest challenge in the district due to low employment opportunities as stated elsewhere in the text. 13 The North East district is no exception from the rest of Botswana in terms of the standard of living. Using national figures and looking at the current situation one can infer that the standard of living for the majority of Batswana is still low. According to the HIES and BIDPA Poverty Study, about 38% of households were living below the poverty datum line in 1993/94. In the absence of disaggregated data it will only be fair to conclude that the district is equally affected. The extent of poverty is further exacerbated by the AIDS pandemic, which is ravaging the country. Poverty still remains a major challenge and ways of tackling it needs to be identified as a matter of urgency. 1.5.1 Agricultural Sector The dorminant agricultural activity is subsistence farming. In addition there are a few other commercial agricultural activities. These nclude freehold farms, which account for 41.5% of all land uses in the district. There are however a few commercial undertakings in the district both under arable and pastoral agriculture. These are poultry, piggery, horticulture, dairy production and small stock, although their scale of production is small and therefore have minimal impact to national production. Most, if not all, of these projects were funded through the Financial Assistance Policy (FAP). 1.5.1.1 Arable Agriculture Most of the farmers use animal draught power for ploughing operations. Only a few rely on hired tractors. In 1998/99 total area ploughed was 17477 hectares. Low hectarage was ploughed in the year 1999/2000 because of floods, 4876 ha were ploughed. In 2000/2001, the total area ploughed was 6921, which was more than area ploughed in the previous. There has been a downward trend in food production for the past five years 1995-2000. A number of factors are attributed to this viz; drought, poor soil fertility, lack of interest by the youth hence only old people are involved in the activity, poor crop management practices, low adoption of technology, ongoing government programmes such as drought, and other labour intensive programmes during the cropping season which seemingly compete for manpower with Agriculture.. Horticulture production is mostly done at a small-scale level. There are 44.41 ha under horticulture production in the district. The number of farmers engaged in this production is 21. 1.5.1.2 Pastoral Agriculture The district livestock production in communal grazing zone is estimated at 41 093 cattle, 29 137 goats, 1 895 sheep, 5 947 donkeys and 95 horses (department of livestock and animal production). In freehold farms the population of livestock is estimated at 19 081 cattle, 1 409 goats, 616 sheep, 111 horses and 65 donkeys. Even though these farms cover a large portion of the district, they are characterised by low population density of about 0-5 persons per square kilometre. This means that most of the land in these farms is under-utilised. Freehold farmers seem to have dual grazing rights as their cattle roam from their farms into communal grazing areas because most of the farms have falling and poorly maintained fences. The farms also provide employment on a small scale to people living in communal areas. 14 It is important to note that livestock farming in the district is also practised on a subsistence basis. Farmers only sell animals when there is need for money not when they are ready for market. Apart from cattle rearing farmers in the district have taken advantage of government support programmes provided by government to set up income generating undertakings. Some of the activities referred to above are, poultry production, small stock production, dairy production, and to a lesser extent piggery. 1.5.2 Commercial Activities Apart from agriculture, there are also a number of commercial activities in the district. These include among others, restaurants, general dealers, butcheries, cooperatives, chibuku depots, supermarkets, filling stations and recently lodges and motels. These provide employment and essential goods and services to the community of North East District although Francistown still remains the major centre as a service and goods supplier. There are a total of 182 commercial activities in the district with an estimated employment of 5461. These comprise of 3 lodges, 53 general dealers, 21 fresh produce, 6 supermarkets, 32 liquor restaurant, 8 bottle store, 28 bars, 2 pharmacies, 5 hair saloons, 4 filling stations, and 2 garages. 1.5.3 Tourism Tourism in the district is not well developed. The expansion of the hospitality sector, is a positive development as it is likely to encourage and complement the development of the tourism industry in the district which is as of now contributing marginally or non at all in terms of total output and/or developments in the district. This is in line with the broader national/regional objectives of enhancing the country/region’s competitiveness in the tourism sector. Although the district is not rich in game, it has great potential in eco-tourism. There are sites of historical interest in the district such as the Domboshaba ruins, rock paintings, old mines especially near Domboshaba ruins and Vukwi ruins and some in Farm 1-NQ, and old pottery in some caves. As of now the sites remain unknown to the outside world. There is also the Supa–Ngwao museum located in Francistown, which intends educating communities on conservation of natural heritage and historic sites as well as promoting cultural festivals. Efforts are being made to encourage communities to utilise these sites, through CBNRM programme. 1.5.4 Manufacturing/Industry The manufacturing sector in the district has not yet asserted itself2. There are no large and medium scale enterprises. Most of the manufacturing businesses found in the district are FAP funded and their scale of production is small, each with an average employment of 2 people. According to information from IFS follow-up report (December 2000), there is a total of 130 projects in operation with a total employment of 370. The apparent lack of major manufacturing 1 Note that the exact number of people employed in commercial activities is just an estimate. It is assumed here that on average each commercial activity employs 3 people. 2 Manufacturing here will be used to represent industrial sector, as it is the most important component of industry. 15 businesses in the district may be attributed to the district’s proximity to Francistown, which is attractive to investors because of factors such as availability of market, well developed service sector and modern infrastructure. There are also a number of construction companies in the district. The exact number of these companies in the area is not known and while the number of people employed according to the 2001 census is 2490 (24.8%) in absolute numbers recording the largest activity in the district. 1.5.5 Mining The district is not well endowed with large mineral deposits, however, there are several mining activities in the district. These include mining of nickel at phoenix and selkirk mines, gold at small scale at metore joren mine, cement mine at KCL technologies. There are also mining for gravel, river sand and pit sand like Francistown quarry, Top Drawer and Panda Quarry. The appropriate number of staff for mines in the North East District eight hundred and sixty one (861) and this is expected to rise as there is a possibility of mining gold at proposed Mupane gold mine. 1.5.6 Public Sector The public sector is made up central and local government. It is one of the major sectors in the district and provides services to residents of the district. Government employs an estimated 1796 people. The government continues to put up infrastructure as a way to create a conducive environment for investment and economic development. During the DDP5, government a primary hospital, and a stadium were constructed. Furthermore, a major infrastructure development project in Tati Siding, which is expected to be complete in 2003, was undertaken. These efforts are expected create the necessary conditions for attraction of investors in the North-East villages. 1.6 STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT PRINCIPLES Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA), is an environmental assessment applied at the strategic level of the planning hierarchy, that is, policies, plans and programmes. Analysis of potential environmental consequences at the level performed concurrently and interactively with the planning process enables incorporation of environmental considerations into plans, policies and programmes. The SEA will examine the effect of overall goals and objectives, sectors’ goals and objectives and ramifications on policies and programmes. The intention of sea focuses on strategic or priority issues and creates guidelines or terms of reference and criteria to address detailed issues later at planning stages. Sea examines development on environment and has potential to inform policy and plan making, thus promoting sustainable development and ensuring informed decisionmaking. The aim of the strategic environmental assessment will therefore be to examine the proposed developments within the context of the ecological (natural or biological) objectives of the district, national and international levels. At the local level, the sea will attempt to examine the relationship between the proposed development and its inherent potential. 16 CHAPTER 2 2 REVIEW OF THE DDP5 AND LONG TERM DEVELOPMENT POTENTIAL 2.1 INTRODUCTION This chapter will highlight progress made in the implementation of the district development Plan 5 and problems encountered. The main achievements of the District Development Plan 5 include the improvement in the health status of communities through provision of primary health facilities such as clinics and health posts in various villages, improved education facilities, increased access through provision of road infrastructure, improved public health through provision of sanitary facilities and refuse collection. However it is important to note that the district experienced some failures owing to some bottlenecks and natural disasters. The main bottlenecks, which hampered development, were lack of skilled manpower, lack of funding, and shortage of staff and office accommodation. The floods that occurred in 2000 also affected the district, like elsewhere in Botswana. The impact of the floods was a real set back as a lot of time and resources was directed at correcting the damage caused. 2.2 ACHIEVEMENTS/OPPORTUNITIES - DDP5 2.2.1 Agriculture 2.2.1.1 Crop Production and Forestry A total of 700 people benefited from ALDEP packages. The demand for the programme was so high that its Total Expenditure Ceiling was exhausted before the end of the plan period resulting in the programme being halted. However farmers who had already made down payment when the programme was stopped continued to be assisted. National Fruit Tree Nursery: Masunga Nursery: The nursery is fully operational. It is currently producing 20,000 tree seedlings per year and generates P5 800.00 per annum. Ditladi Nusery: The project was a carry over from DDP4/NDP7 TO DDP5/NDP8. Funds were sub-warranted to dabs and the initial tendering were done in 98/99 but due to some delays with DABS, the project was re-tendered during the current financial year and award of tender is still awaited. Horticulture: Efforts to promote horticultural activities in the district still continue. The construction of a fresh produce market in Francistown is complete. The market has already started operating. The area earmarked for horticulture at Impala, has been developed although it is still awaiting water connection. About 12 farmers who have been allocated plots have started operating with an estimated employment of 41 people. Conservation: The planned conservation projects were implemented as follows: 13 diversional channels measuring 3510m in 288ha. 48 gully control structures measuring 341m 17 88 contour banks measuring 20198.80m in 368.60ha The matsiloje conservation project is practically complete. What remains is installation of electricity to intensify drawing of water from the river. Development of Extension Services: The district did not implement all the planned staff houses in the district. Out of the five houses planned only one was constructed in Makaleng leaving a backlog of 4 houses. In addition, two of the three houses planned for electrification have been wired but have not yet been connected to the Botswana Power Corporation grid. The houses are in Matshelagabedi, Matsiloje and TatiSiding. The section is faced with the following constraints Iadequate water suppy - the nursery has capacity to produce 30 000 seedlings but due to shortage of water production has reduced to 20 000 annually. It is anticipated that with the construction of the Ntimbale Dam and the development of the Maintengwe well field the district water shortage problem will be addressed. Possibilities of using water from the sewerage ponds for watering the nursery will be considered. Conflicting land use especially in the village of Tsamaya. The area which was earmarked for horticulture is no longer there due to village growth encroachment into the lands area. Construction of gully control structures was delayed due to shortage of machinery. Shortage of animal draught power furthered by restriction of ivestock movement in the district due to FMD. 2.2.1.2 Animal Health and Production During the year 2002, an outbreak of Foot and Mouth Disease was reported at Matsiloje and Matshelagabedi areas and towards the end of the year another outbreak was reported in Matopi and Tseteng areas. This led to the killing of 12000 cattle in Matsiloje/Matshelagabedi and 4000 cattle in Matopi/Tseteng areas. Famers were compensated in cash and with animals and a labourbased programme was introduced as a relief measure. The department is currently constructing an electric fence between Botswana and Zimbabwe where the FMD is suspected to be coming from. The fence is expected to prevent cross border movements of animals. The project is undertaken at a cost of P6 million and is anticipated to be completed by the end of 2003. Further more the department through the labour-based disaster relief programme is relocating watering points and cattle crushes from near the borderline as a measure to further prevent the across the border crossing of livestock. Service to Livestock Owners in Communal Areas (SLOCA): A total of 24 SLOCA applications have been approved with a total grant of P119,400 since the beginning of the DDP5. These included water reticulation, handling facilities, fodder storage baw, drift fences and spray races. The SLOCA grant is too small in view of the size of the projects the grant is financing. The district proposed the increased of SLOCA grants from P13 000 to P50 000 Fencing Policy: The suitability study for two portions of farm 77 NQ for the north east district has been done. Details of allocation are with land board. Commercial Farming: Poultry projects: a total of 47 broiler and 6 layer projects are operating with an employment of 173 people. Total FAP grant for these projects is P1, 850,006 18 Dairy projects: total number of projects operating is 10 with an employment of 28 people. The milk concentration center at Tshesebe will be carried forward to ddp9 due to lack of funding. 2.2.2 Industrial and Commercial Development 2.2.2.1 Integrated Field Services The Production Development Committee (PDC) approved 174 projects since the beginning of the plan period. Total investment and total grant for these projects were P17 001 301.64 and P9 885 404.62 respectively. The projected employment was 766 and compared to actual employment of 208. Out of these approved projects 18 were cancelled as they failed to pay their contributions while 12 projects started and later collapsed. All in all 144 projects are operating. The district office is manned by one officer, which makes it difficult to adequately carry out follow-ups of entrepreneurs. Entrepreneurs are followed up to verify materials and equipment received in order to authorise payments. They are also visited to check progress on their projects and offer advice. 2.2.2.2 Commercial Affairs There are also a number of commercial activities in the district. These include restaurants, general dealers, butcheries, cooperatives, chibuku depots, supermarkets, filling stations and of late lodges and motels. There are a total of 182 commercial activities in the district with an estimated employment of 5463. These comprise of 3 lodges, 53 general dealers, 21 fresh produce, 6 supermarkets, 32 liquor restaurant, 8 bottle store, 28 bars, 2 pharmacies, 5 hair saloons, 4 filling stations, and 2 garages. 2.2.3 Wildlife and National Parks The department of wildlife has facilitated the formation of a total of 45 school based wildlife clubs, 35 of which are for primary schools, 9 for community junior secondary schools and 1 for the senior secondary school. There are however, no community projects in the districts but a workshop has been held for councillors and chiefs in the district to sensitise them on Community Based Natural Resource Management. There is potential in the district for CBNRM as there are some historical sites like Domboshaba ruins that communities could use for tourism. 2.2.4 Tourism Historical sites in the district are being developed as part of prmoting cultural tourism. The community conservation fund was established during DDP5 to fund Community Based Natural Resources Management Program (CBNRMP). The district has not yet benefited from this fund although mobilisation of communities was done. 3 Note that the number of people employed in commercial activities is just an estimate. It is assumed here that on average each commercial activity employs 3 people. 19 2.2.5 Mining The district is not well endowed with large mineral deposits, however, there are several mining activities taking place in the district. These are Shashe and Selkirk mines. The minerals found in these mines are gold and nickel respectively. The mines employ a total of 730 people. In addition to the above, there is a relatively new cement mine near Matsiloje. There is also small-scale mining in freehold farms e.g. Near Sechele village where gold is also mined. 2.2.6 Education and Training 2.2.6.1 Non-Formal Education In its attempt to establish learning oriented society the department has managed to maintain an annual enrolment of 600-900 learners out of the planned 1200. Through the programme, 53 young literacy learners were transferred to different primary schools and placed at different levels while 85 learners have graduated from the literacy programme. In addition, the department was able to successfully launch two new activities namely literacy at the workplace in government, private and parastatal institutions, and “English as a second language” and as a post literacy activity. The department managed to undertake a pilot exercise of the adult basic education course even though it was not budgeted for in the DDP5. A survey for the out of school education for children in rural and urban areas has been conducted to identify the children and their needs. Training on post literacy related skills (candle making, poultry, sewing & knitting etc.) has been conducted every financial year. 2.2.6.2 Primary Education The district has achieved very little in meeting the need for primary school facilities. For this plan period, the district was allocated P10 million to implement recommendation 14 of the Revised National Policy on Education. An assessment was done to identify all items needed per school and a breakdown done per year. The district therefore gave priority to teacher’s quarters and classroom blocks following on the eradication of backlog on these core facilities. The district also implemented this programme by use of the drought relief labour intensive programme. The table below indicates the achievement made by need per item and the existing backlog. Although the backlog is high, the district has been successful in reducing classroom backlog. The thrust of the education construction was to a large extent pursuant to the Revised National Policy on Education. The policy amongst others, emphasises on the provision of adequate facilities to provide a conducive teaching and learning environment. To that extent, the distrct has not been able to implement all the planned projects due to limited financial allocation. In preparation for the new feeding menu to be introduced to the district beginning of DDP6, the district is modifying 7 kitchens constructed through the 2001/2 drought relief programme, 12 kitchens will be constructed through the 2002/3 drought relief programme, 2 through the disaster relief programme and the remaining 20 will constructed through the education construction capital programme. 20 Table 2.1: Facility Classrooms Teachers quarters Latrines/toilets Administraion blocks Kitchens Store rooms Bus Library Solar/elect. Planned and Implemented Education Facilities DDP5 Planned projects/items 1997/98-2002/2003 Approved Projects 1997/98-2002/2003 55 332 133 41 41 123 1 82 Achievement Total Implemented Projects Back log 37 105 10 - 18 227 123 41 41 123 0 3 12 33 152 10 21 Capital LG 1102 33 152 48 - Drought Relief Programme 18 78 33 - - - 19 - 1 3 7 1 60 10 0 70 Source: Education Department - NEDC, 2002 2.2.6.3 Secondary Education Junior Secondary Education: There are ten (10) Junior Secondary Schools within the district, which are adequate to admit all standard seven-school leavers from the primary schools. Some of them are already experiencing a short fall in the number of Form 1 students to be admitted. Extensions to the academic areas, teachers’ houses and hostels where necessary have been done in schools as follows: Batanani – extension to Home economics block Toilet block 2 x 6 bay ablutions Cycle maintenance to buildings/facilities Matsiloje - buildings 6 x 3 bedroom teachers houses 1 x art room block 1 x science lab Cycle maintenance to existing facilities Pelaelo – extension to Home economics lab Toilet block Cycle maintenance to existing facilities Tashatha – buildings 2 x 3 bedroom teachers houses 1 x double classroom block 1 x science laboratory Cycle maintenance to existing facilities. Thamani – extension to Home economics block 21 Toilet block Cycle maintenance to existing facilities. All the junior secondary schools have been supplied with computers. The cycle maintenance and extensions in the remaining junior secondary school will continue into the next plan period. These will include the extension to office accommodation as well as upgrading of sporting facilities. Senior Secondary Education: The district has only one Senior Secondary School - Masunga Senior Secondary School. The school facilities are being extended by putting more staff houses and also undertaking remedial works to existing facilities. By the end of DDP5 the project was experiencing difficulties, the contractor had cash flow problems hence shortage of materials onsite.This hampered the progress of the project. Brigades: Zwenshambe brigade has not implemented the development projects under phase II as was anticipated in the DDP5. This has affected the starting of the planned courses in the plan period. Although the envisaged expansion of the brigade has not taken place, enrolment has risen from 128 in 1997 to 192 in 2001. The brigade has also produced 62 graduates in business studies out of which 80% are working in various parts of the country. The installation of electricity improved performance of some units such as sorghum mill, carpentry, and building. The brigade has secured a piece of land for the expansion of the brigade. Senyawe brigade gives training of Building works, Computer Operations and Accounting. The brigade has 128 instructors and 10 support staff. Most of the projects planned for have been undertake this includes fencing of the Brigade, Purchase of equipment for computer classes, staff houses, classroom blocks and building slab. 2.2.7 Health 2.2.7.1 Health/Clinics Department The department has made strides in provision of infrastructure to ensure that the overall goal of health for all by the year 2000 and beyond is achievable. All projects that were approved were successfully implemented with the exception of construction of a maternity wing at Matshelagabedi. By the end of DDP5 the maternity wing was completed except for the sluice facility which had to be installed prior to the fuctioning of the maternity wing. The completed projects include, construction of two health posts at Matopi and Botalaote/toteng, upgrading of health post to clinic at Ramokgwebana and to clinic with maternity in Matshelagabedi, seven staff houses, and electrification of health facilities in 17 villages, which were electrified through the rural electrification program during DDP5. With regard to manpower for the new projects the council has not achieved much because of the manpower ceilings. However 21 out of 70 posts were approved and are filled. In addition, 10 home based care posts were approved and are currently filled. The shortage of nurses still exists in the district. 22 The department has critical shortage of nurses’ houses and shortage of transport. This is an acumalted backlog since DDP4; the current plan will attempt to address this shortage. 2.2.7.2 National AIDS Programme The district launched the District Multi- Sectoral Aids Committee (DMSAC) in November 1998 and later formed sub-committees to encourage greater participation. Since the inception of the DMSAC, it has undertaken several activities including community mobilisation by conducting kgotla meetings, facilitating in conducting of a ‘need assessment on HIV/AIDS’ study, and workshops. Other achievements include the training and orientation of Family Welfare Educators and nurses on Home-Based Care Strategy, the formation of Village AIDS Committees to provide community based HIV/AIDS service delivery in the district, and HIV/AIDS sensitization sessions with various target groups to effect a multi-sectoral approach in tackling the epidemic. Health programmes such as Home-Based Care Programmes, PMTCT etc have been started during the period under review and have progressed well. Porta cabins have been procured to facilitate counseling since there is shortage of consulting rooms in clinics. Lay counselloers have also been employed in attempt to address issues of inadequate counseling services. Equipment such as television sets and VCRs have been purchased to facilitate health education. 2.2.7.3 Environmental Health Most of the planned projects under the District Development Plan have been implemented. The projects undertaken include 66 VIP latrines, 100 dry compost latrines, and purchase of vacuum tanker through the National Rural Sanitation Programme (NRSP). In addition to the above, the district has been allocated funding to construct a sanitary landfill during the 2001/2002 financial year though the landfill was not yet completed by the end DDP5 equipemt of the landfill was procured. The District Council was also able to complete fencing of dumping site at Kalakamati, conduct Malaria control spraying exercise, and purchase of water testing kits. A total of two 7 tonne trucks and 4x4 hilux vehicle were procured through through Malaria Decentralisation Programme package. Littering has been a cause of concern of concern throughout the plan period, health education campaigns have been held to mobilise communities to clean the surroundings. Clean-up campaigns and village competition have also been conducted to encourage communities to district villages clean. According to the 2001 Population and Housing Census it has been established that only 13% of the 10 384 households in the district were accessible to adequate sanitation facilities while 62.4% had inadequate facilities, 24.3% had no saniation facilities at all and the remaining 0.3% was not known. The district will during DDP6 intensify in the provision of saniation facilities through the subisdised NRSP. 2.2.8 Social & Community Development 2.2.8.1 Village Infrastructural Projects The district implemented 24 out of the 105 projects in DDP5 under the LG 1109 programme. The achieved projects include 5 day care centres, 2 community halls, 5 houses (i.e. 3 x 4 houses & 2 x 23 LA2 houses), 2 storerooms for the destitute programme, guesthouse, kgotla toilet, and a stand pipe. 2.2.8.2 Training Support Component The department also managed to organise 5 courses under training support component of LG 1109 programme between 1998 and 2000. These courses include, VDC leadership course, 3 workshops and a youth training course. 2.2.8.3 Social Welfare The number of destitue persons has been increasing in the district showing increasing poverty levels. The main contributory factor has been the narrow ecoomic base of the district with low commercial and industrial activities even poor informal sector. Low rainfall and poor soil have largerly lowered production in the agriculture sector lowering household food security. Shortage of food, low employment opportunities and low literacy levels have resultantly made a proportion of the district eligible for destitute person programme. 2.2.9 Immigration, Customs and Excise The immigration offices and six (6) housing units have already been constructed in Masunga and three departments are occupying the buildings. The departments are civil registration, national registration and immigration. Equipment and furniture will be supplied once the project is finished. The major constraint facing the department is the influx of Zimbabwean emigrants into the district, both legal and illegal. This has also led to high level of assaults, rape, burglary and breakings. The immigration office has been repatriating Zimbabweans to their country. This is a costly exercise. Kgotla meetings will continue to be held sensetise members of the public about harbouring Zimbabwean illegal emigrants. 2.2.10 District Administration District administration has managed to establish a standing District Disaster Preparedness Committee, which is made up of civil servants and local representatives. The district also successfully managed to assist communities affected by floods in 2000 by providing temporary shelter and supplying them with food and clothing. 2.2.11 Tribal Administration The department managed to increase the number customary court presiding officers by one to speed up case hearings, and increased the number of local police officers. It is anticipated that more courts will be upgraded as planned. The department constructed 8 out of the 12 customary courts planned. The construction of the remaining four customary courts may be carried to DDP 6 as funds under this vote have been exhausted. Communication: Telephones have been installed in most of the customary courts except in 4 customary courts while four courts were issued with local police radios. 24 Transport: Since the beginning of the plan period the department received 11 vehicles and a combi, which were distributed to customary courts in the district. The customary courts which benefited are, Matsiloje, Gulubane, Tatisiding, Masunga, Mapoka, Tshesebe, Ditladi, Senyawe, and Jackalas 1. 2.2.12 Botswana Police Construction of Tshesebe Police Station started in February 2000 at the cost P3 380 000 for a double storey office block, one high cost house, five medium costs, twenty-five low cost and six servants quarter houses, all at the cost of P1 376 393. Towards the end of DDP5 it was almost complete and handing over is expected beginning of DDP6. A four kilometre tarred road from the Police Station to the main road is also expected to be complete by October 2003 at the cost of P2,6 million. 2.2.13 Government Revenue Office The department has managed to decentralise payments of imprests, goods and services. These payments were initially done at the Attorney General at head quarters. 2.2.14 Physical Infrastructure 2.2.14.1 District Housing and Land Servicing For the entire plan period, about 102 housing units were planned to be constructed and funds amounting to P5.1 million were allocated for the project. This number comprises 24 for district administration, 18 for tribal administration, 23 for the district council and 18 for land board. Since the beginning of the plan period about 13 houses for the District Council and Land Board were successfully completed within the stipulated time. Currently about 21 houses for district administration and tribal administration are under construction. In addition, the district council has been allocated funds to construct about 14 houses for its staff during the 2001/2002 financial year. Council in conjunction with land board has prepared local area plans for Makaleng, Matopi, Jackalas 1 and Tsamaya villages. Preparation of layout plans for Masunga, Tatisiding, Matshelagabedi and Shashe Bridge has been completed. Land servicing project is ongoing at a cost of P68 million in Tatisiding. The project entails tarmacking of internal roads and drainage, sewerage network, water supply scheme and streetlighting. Additional works entailing servicing of 110 industrial plots will be included during DDP6 as well as Phase II Infrastructural development of Masunga Village. It is anticipated that the projects will nhance the viability level of the district making it a lucrative area for investment; additionally creating empoyment for the district population. 2.2.14.2 Transport and Communications Council Roads: The district council continues to provide road infrastructure in order to improve communication. During this plan period, 111.60 km of roads was gravelled, and 17 out of the 34 planned culverts were constructed. However no bridges were constructed as planned in the DDP5. According to the plan, kilometres to be gravelled were 2 per road and the total length to be 25 gravelled was 48 kilometres. However during implementation the whole length of the road was gravelled as it was realised that spot improvement could not make roads passable as the soils in the North East area is generally clay and collapsible. 2.2.14.3 Water and Waste Water This has been the most difficult area to develop due to lack of water sources in most parts of the district. Nevertheless, the main achievements in DDP5 include improvement of the health status of the communities through improved water supply and sanitation in most of the villages in the district. The district has been able to undertake 44 water development projects out of the planned 62 projects in the whole district. These projects include provision of additional water source and rehabilitation, provision of additional standpipes, extension and construction of sewerage ponds and effluent disposal in Masunga, and procurement of equipment. About 55% of the district villages still have water shortage problems. Water bowsers have been procured to bowse water to hardhit villages. Maitengwe wellfield and Ntimbale Dam will explored during DDP6 to improve the water situation in the district. The infrastructural development project in Tatisiding includes provision of sewer network in the area. 2.2.14.4 Energy Sources and Power The main thrust for the sector was to make use of the Rural Electrification Programmme. Through the programme, villages of Jackalas 1, Matsiloje, Makaleng, Mapoka,, Ramokgwebana, Moroka, Sekakangwe, Nlapkhwane, Mosojane, Senyawe Themashanga, and Siviya were electrified since the beginning of the plan period. 2.3 LONG TERM PLANNING FRAMEWORK 2.3.1 Integrated District Land Use Plans and Structure Plans The district land use plan has not yet been done except for the portions 25 and 27 of farm 77NQ, which were bought by government to augment tribal land. The need to have a land use plan was identified during DDP4. The production of the plan was to be carried out early DDP5. The plan was supposed to address balanced development relating to mixed activity of arable agriculture, livestock production, mining activities, and settlement location and growth. A 24-year Structural Plan for Masunga village, Greater Francistown Planning Area - including Tatisiding, Shashe Bridge and Matshelagabedi were developed. Layout plans for the three clusters in Masunga i.e. C, D and E extensions. These are earmarked for servicing during DDP6. 2.3.2 District Settlement Strategy The North East District Settlement Strategy (NEDSS) is updated to capture new developments. The thrust of the strategy is to guide the District Council in locating and prioritising development opportunities within the objectives of the National Settlement Policy. The NEDSS formulates strategies that will 26 Elaborate the NSP at the district level and facilitate its implemetation Review the land use patterns and designateland to the use that will derive the optimum use Provide guidelines on the settlement to be promoted for growth Propose for the provision of infrastructure service for the next 24 years based on the projected population Facilitate coordination and implementation of sectoral plans Ensure equitable distribution of economic resources linked with resource potential area – promote balanced development Provide for protection of scarce resources and environmetal manangement. The preliminary draft of North East District Settlement Strategy (2000-2004) has been completed and is to be forwarded to relevant institutions for comments. 2.4 PROBLEM AREAS AND MAJOR UNRESOLVED ISSUES 2.4.1 Agriculture 2.4.1.1 Crop Production and Forestry The following were identified as hampering developments in the sector: Shortage of water; the nursery has the capacity to produce 30,000 seedlings but due to shortage of water production was reduced to 20,000. Conflicting land uses; the area earmarked for horticulture in Tsamaya is no longer available owing to village encroachment into the dam area. Construction of gully control structures was delayed mainly because of lack of machinery. Lack of implementation capacity by DABS delayed construction of the planned staff houses. The houses that were planned for electrification have not yet been electrified due to delays from DEMS and BPC. Some projects like the district agriculture offices in Masunga still remain unfunded. 2.4.1.2 Animal Health & Production 2.4.2 SLOCA funding is limited resulting in a backlog of applications. SLOCA grants were said to be small in view of the size of the projects they fund, such as borehole equipping, water reticulation, kraals and crushes, and dip tanks. Lack of skilled manpower hamper implementation of programmes in the district. Industrial and Commercial Development 2.4.2.1 Integrated Field Services Shortage of manpower made it difficult to undertake all the planned activities in DDP5, which include conducting follow-ups, training would-be entrepreneurs, and disseminating information on FAP. 27 2.4.3 2.4.4 Wildlife & National Parks There are administrative issues such as payment of subsistence allowances to primary school teachers that hinder wildlife clubs activities. The emergence of environmental education clubs in schools facilitated by ministry of education is another problem in that they play the same role in conservation but compete for the same resources. Education & training 2.4.4.1 Non-Formal Education The programme has not been able to achieve its stated objectives due to the following problems: Lack of manpower to cover all clusters. Inadequate funds for payment of literacy teachers. Unstipulated condition of service for literacy teachers. Lack of structures for holding learning sessions. Lack of transport. Groups embarking on home economics activities are in most cases not in production because of group dynamics, lack of market, and low quality of products. 2.4.4.2 Primary Education 2.4.5 Cost escalations in the construction sector have reduced the number of projects to be implemented. Funding limitation and capacity constraints leading to fewer projects implemented. The backlog on core facilities remains high. Health 2.4.5.1 Primary Health Care Manpower Constraints: there is still shortage of manpower. As a result of the manpower ceiling, the department is not able to create posts for the new facilities e.g. the upgraded clinics and new health posts need family welfare educators but presently upgraded clinics still have one family welfare educator. Inadequate Transport: the other problem, which hinders progress, is shortage of transport in the health facilities and district health team. 2.4.5.2 National AIDS Programme Historically, there has been a problem of compiling accurate statistics on HIV/AIDS in the district, as testing facilities were available only in Francistown prior to the opening of the Masunga Primary Hospital. Another problem identified is the lack of adequate transportation to cover the district and publicize HIV/AIDS messages. Efforts should be made to include a provision for HIV/AIDS programme implementation in all sectoral budgets. 28 2.4.5.3 Environmental Health The construction of VIP latrines was not done from 1997/98 up to 1999/2000 due to delays by the Ministry of Local Government to approve funding. This resulted in a backlog of 600 VIP latrines. The 600 VIP latrines were constructed during 2002/03 financial year and they are all complete. 2.4.6 Social & Community Development The planned projects were not all achieved mainly due cost overruns owing to delays by communities to mobilise the required 10 percent contribution. This is so because the communities prefer to work in other government programmes such as drought relief and labour intensive road works where there are incentives. 2.4.7 District Administration The problem faced by District Administration is that of co-ordinating regionalised departments mostly based in Francistown. The majority of departments get instructions from their parent ministries hence little allegiance is paid to the co-ordinating department. Shortage of staff also hampers the efficiency of the department. 2.4.8 Tribal Administration The department has identified lack of transport, shortage of staff and stafe houses as factors that hampered efficient service delivery during the plan period. 2.4.9 Government Revenue Office The government revenue office is constrained by shortage of staff, and lack of transport to perform its duties. 2.4.10 Immigration, Customs & Excise The following were identified as constraining the department: 2.4.11 Shortage of staff houses. Lack of adequate manpower to man the Masunga office. Influx of emigrants – both legal and illegal this overwhelms the existing staff. Energy Sources and Power The major constraint is that consumer connection in the electrified villages is very low despite the availability of electricity. 29 2.4.12 Physical infrastructure 2.4.12.1 District Housing and Land Servicing The district was not able to achieve its target due to the lack of implementation capacity of DABS. This delayed implementation of the program in that the whole program was halted pending DABS completing district and tribal administration houses. As a result a backlog of 49 housing units developed. The move to transfer implementation of district housing for central to district council has been a good move and it is anticipated that the shortage of housing problem will be alleviated. Land servicing in the district is moving at a slow pace as the financial allocation for the project was exhausted prior to end of plan period. 2.4.12.2 Water and Waste water The department was not able to implement sewerage scheme projects as planned as a result of inadequate developments in the villages of Tsamaya, Tshesebe, Matshelagabedi and Makaleng. The department experienced the following problems; Lack of water sources: A number of water improvement projects could not be carried out whilst others were partially done because of lack of water sources in the following villages -: Pole, Kgari, Masingwaneng, Mbalambi and Ramokgwebana. Lack of funding: Some projects, like rehabilitation of water supply and additional water source at senyawe, were not implemented due to lack of funding. Lack of skilled manpower: Lack of skilled manpower like engineers made implementation of DDP5 projects very difficult. Implementation of unplanned emergency projects: Installation of Matopi water supply and construction of f/town – Masunga emergency water pipeline and catering for settlement areas like Gungwe, Mbali, and Ntemane reduced the allocated funds for the planned projects. 2.4.12.3 Transport and Communications The implementation of the district roads program during the ddp 5 was largely constrained by the following: Increase of construction costs which limited the number of projects implemented. This increase in costs was mainly caused by inadequate water in the district, and unavailability of suitable material (gravel) within reasonable distance. Lack of funding to undertake the planned projects such as Kgari and Ntshe bridges and lack of machinery and equipment such as bull dozers and tipper trucks. Free hold farms continue to hinder development of roads. For example letsholathebesechele and matsiloje – matopi have not been undertaken as planned as they pass through freehold farms. 2.5 LONG TERM PLANNING FRAMEWORK 2.5.1 Integrated Land Use Plan The major constraints in land use planning are: 30 2.5.2 Lack of human resources Shortage of land; the district is dominated by freehold farms which cover 50% of the land mass. Conflicting land uses; this is further exacerbated by the mushrooming of settlements which are encroaching into land earmarked for agriculture, and other uses. In addition, tribal land in the district exists as pockets divided by free hold farms. This hinders development especially roads linking the pockets. Environmental and Conservation Strategies During DDP 6, the district’s environmental objectives include forming community trusts to conserve the environment and utilise natural resources, rehabilitation of some degraded land by constructing drifts and planting trees, and educating the community about conservation of natural resources. The core goal that encompasses the objective is to foster environmental friendly practices through formulation, review and facilitation of relevant environmental policies and legislation as well as promotion of research and monitoring. The continued over exploitation of natural resources e.g. Cutting of live trees, mining of river sand pit sand and gravel, especially for commercial purposes, therefore defeats the objectives of environmental and conservation strategies. 2.5.3 Revised National Settlement Policy The National Settlement Policy is concerned with the geographical location of development in the country and the opportunities and services various settlements have to provide for their residents. It is also concerned with the physical and equitable distribution of the population to productive resources and basic social services. Therefore the reduction of the population range of tertiary centres from 500 to 250 meant that more settlements now qualify to be provided with social services like health, education etc thus overstretching the already minimal resources of the district. There are already some concern and uncertainty about the feasibility and sustainability of the policy. For example, it is feared by some that arable and cattle-post areas might lose land to proliferation of settlements and villages. 2.6 LINKS TO NDP9 THEME The theme for the national development is “towards realisation of vision 2016: sustainable and diversified development through competitiveness in global markets”. This theme is important in ensuring that NDP9/DDP6 programmes and activities reflect the national goals and objectives as enshrined in the vision 2016. The DDP6 is directly linked to the theme as the activities and programmes proposed aim at meeting the national goals and objectives. The economy of the district is still dependent on agriculture and to a lesser extent on mining. Depicting a narrow and undiversified local economy. In view of this factor, the communities proposed construction of factory shells, market stalls, and major village infrastructure development projects as a way to encourage the development of industry, which will help to diversify the economy. It is also evident that the district has potential to further diversify within the agriculture through irrigation, though this may be curtailed by insufficient water supply. Streams could be dammed for irrigation purposes. 31 In addition to the above, a lot of projects proposed entailed primary school facilities, primary health facilities and road construction. These are in line with the overall national goals and objectives and the vision 2016. Some of the pillars of the vision are; “an educated and informed nation, and a prosperous, productive and innovative nation”. These objectives will be achieved through provision of the above infrastructure. 32 CHAPTER 3 3 DDP 5/UDP 2 DEVELOPMENT GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 3.1 PLANNING FRAMEWORK Planning framework for the development process is based on the formation of overall goals and objectives, leading to planned activities, programs and projects with set targets. The planning framework is guided or is based vision 2016, macro-economic outline and policy framework, the National Development plan, strategic plans of the Ministry of Local Government and other ministries, Strategies of the relevant parastatals and lastly the socio-economic status of the district in terms of opportunities, constraints and challenges. The plan assumes that all factors will remain constant and finance will be availed to carry out projects as stated and scheduled. The plan further assumes that manpower will be available to implement the plan and will be exercise high level of productivity. 3.1.1 Vision 2016 Vision 2016 provides a broader framework for longterm planning. It forms the basis for planning and represents the ideals and aspirations of the country. The vision also has direct focus on national principles of democreacy, development, self-reliance and unity. The District Development Plan 6 and National Development Plan 9 has been aligned to the vision 2016 whose theme is “Towards Realisation of Vision 2016: Sustainable and Diversified Development through Competitiveness in the Global Markets.” 3.1.1.1 An Educate and Informed Nation The plan puts education as a priority area and will pursue all strategies which will be towards achieving that all the district populace has basic education which will enable assimilation of new developments and innovations. The strategies pursued will not be confined to classroom learning but also focus on non-formal education, distance learning, environmental education, crafts and business skills. The plan recognises that global competitiveness largely accentuates on the manpower being able to withstand competition with the outside world as such education is very essential. The district will continue to upgrade schools and provide facilities as stated in the revised policy so as to create an environment conducive to teaching-learning. During DDP5 the schools in the district have performed well as exhibited by one junior school in 2002 becoming second in the country. Such efforts are excellent and need to be encouraged through provision of requisite equipment and intensification on the education process itself through provision of audio-visual in school and further improvement will be made through the use of communication linkages such television, radio and availability of print media in the district. With regard to tertiary education the district has two brigades the Zwenshambe and Senyawe. With the only 2 brigades with limited number of students to enrol this has left the district with little opportunities for tertiary education. These have poorly performed over the years and need to be upgraded to be able to reach the required standard. 33 3.1.1.2 A Prosperous, Productive and Innovative Nation The North East district has little economic activities largely overshadowed by its proximal position to Francistown. It should be well noted that proximity to the city of Francistown has both negative and positive aspects. The negative being that it competes with Francistown in luring investment and as such Francistown as a service centre with both financial and business services, out-rightly disqualifies/beats the district. It should however be noted that some areas of the district which serve as dormitory to Francsitown have potential of growing into investment centres. That is in the event there is land shortage in Francistown; these can serve as alternative business/investment location especially with the availability of serviced land. The district will therefore during DDP6 venture in to land servicing in view of promoting industry The minimal commercial activities existing in the district are not diversified and more skewed towards general dealers and bars resultantly with low employment level. Production is very low in the district. The crop sub-sector has under-performed during DDP5 due to persistent drought, lack of water and declining interest in agriculture. Pursuant to competitiveness and diversification as the theme accentuates, the district is set to exhaust and capitalise in areas and formulate strategies where it has competitive advantage. These strategies will involve land servicing of potential investment locations, improvement of communication network and linkages, intensification on the promotion of the informal sector through use available government programmes and taking advantage of the available market for local produce in Francistown and Zimbabwe. 3.1.1.3 A Compassionate, Just and Caring Nation Pursuant to this ideal provision of social safety will be strengthened to ensure large coverage. Community structures and political structure will continue to be used to assist in the identification of the disadvantaged people in the society. The revised destitute policy has largely attempted to address the previous concerns as regards service provision. The policy will go a long way in improving the livelihood on the disadvantaged populace. It takes into account the dependants of the destitute person. Efforts to restore the disintegrating traditional family support system will be instigated through use of local chiefs and existing traditional structures. The spirit of volunteerism as a good social fibre will be encouraged through social mobilisation especially with regard to Home-based Care Volunteer work. Efforts to destigmatise the HIV/AIDS will be encouraged, care and show compassion towards the sick will be encouraged. Newly constructed building will provide for disabled and the existing ones will be modified to ensure that there is no connotation of segregation through the type of construction undertaken. Additionally efforts will made to integrate special education into the normal school system as the policy suggests. Transport will also be procured during the plan period to ferry disabled pupils to and from school. Communities will be mobilised through different forum and social welfare supports system to encourage parents to take disabled children to school. 34 3.1.1.4 A Safe and Secure Nation To address the issue of national security the department of tribal administration, administration of justice, the police and other law enforcement officers such as bye-law officers are responsible for the security of the nation. To address crime prevention law enforcement facilities will continue to be improved i.e immigration offices in Matsiloje, upgrading of police station etc. The district is having a serious influx of Zimbabweans and there has been a considerable crime cases reported to have been committed by illegal immigrants from Zimbabwe. Formation of locally-based crime prevention structures will be encouraged, strengthening and empowerment of existing ones will also be done to ensure a standing partnership with the community on such matters. Drought has been persistent in the district interfaced with foot and mouth outbreak. The two have persisted as problems to the district. Cases of veld fire outbreak and floods do occur but are not common. To circumvent these problems, a contingency plan will be drawn in effort to allow for preparedness in the event there is occurrence of these emergencies. Village-based Committees responsible for disaster management will be formed and a clear-cut reporting system will also be formulated. This will hamper a fragmented and disjointed approach to management of disaster. 3.1.1.5 An Open, Democratic and Accountable Nation The vision ideal advocates for transparency and good governance, and further calls for an accountable and responsible nation that can be able to recognize good political leadership and vote for it. Some residents of the district like the rest of the country, absolve themselves from the responsibility of choosing the right political leadership and do not recognize voting as a constitutional right. This has been exhibited by low participation during election, kgotla meetings, political rallies, educational rallies and other forms of decision-making meetings. This has resulted in the district populace failing to recognize failure on the part of the leadership and has also furthered the ignorance of the members of the public regarding development plans, existing pieces of legislations and government policies and programmes. To address the above the different district-based government departments will engage in educational tours, rallies and open-air meetings to sell their services and ideas to the people. The Independent Electoral Commission will embark on social mobilization and public education on voter rights. Further to that communities will also be sensetised on accountability and collective responsibility. 3.1.1.6 A Moral, Tolerant, United and Proud Nation The vision 2016 stresses the importance of cultivating and preserving moral values of society. Through cultural activities, dissemination of tradition and cultural values and precepts will be pursued. There has been a declining effect on cultural values and norms exhibited by the extraction of the social (moral) fibre of respect especially among the youth. A collaborative action from all stakeholders including the Dikgosi, associations and different cultural groups towards restoration of cultural values and beliefs will be pursued. It will be unfortunate for the district to loose its ethnicity and that will be prevented through establishment of cultural villages where traditions, history and evolution of ethnic group in the district will be displayed. The same could also be done in open meetings. 35 Peace, harmony and unity among the district membership is very important and will be encouraged by interacting different community groups in different foras. Compassions and tolerance will be encouraged also especially for economically disadvantaged people and towards those with physical disability. Identification of such people will also be done in a concerted way such that no one is missed out and all the needs are addressed through existing government programmes. Collaborative effort with cultural groups and religious fronts will be intensified in view of promotion of moral ethics and productivity and disregard laissez-faire and permissive tendencies. 3.1.2 National and District Environmental Key Issues 3.1.2.1 Land Shortage Inequitable distribution of land, competing livestock and arable and wildlife uses, non existent sub-market value, lease rentals and the absence of coherent land policy have resulted in land degradation, speculative land acquisition, non-development, non-compliance, encroachment, overgrazing and an increasing number of land disputes. Land in the district is very limited as the district is surrounded by freehold farms and there is no room for expansion of the district except through acquisition/purchase of freehold farms. For areas adjacent to the city of Francistowmn there is a lot of influx into those areas and land grabbing for speculative purposes as exhibited by exponential growth of population in such areas e.g. Tatisiding and Matshelagabedi. 3.1.2.2 Water Water consumption is growing and water is increasingly becoming a scarce resource. Water consumption has increased due to a gradual shift form the traditional method of living to modernisation where a considerable amount of water is consumed per day as opposed to the traditional 20 litres consumption per day per person for rural areas (old design manual). Boreholes and wells are drying up and, underground stocks are largely unknown and aquifers becomes polluted. Interest in water demand management and water harvesting is growing but still lacking broad societal acceptance and support. Water shortage has become a growing daily concern in the district. 3.1.2.3 Natural Resource Utilization The major concern is over-harvesting of natural resources such as sand, gravel and other aggregates. Some contractors extract without prior permission, while some members of the public extract gravel haphazardly. There is need for identification of one controlled area which communities will agree on it and fence it. Burrow pits are mostly left open without being rehabilitated and in certain areas become dumping areas. 3.1.2.4 Pollution and Waste Management Land and soil pollution takes place through littering, in landfills and via large unmonitored industrial practices. Waste management has been a problem in the district owing to requisite adequate personnel and equipment. As such collection of waste has been irregular and insufficient. 36 Consequently the problem of haphazard waste disposal erupted. Littering has also been a growing concern and mostly pronounced around the busy shopping areas Surface and groundwater pollution through effluent discharge, hazardous chemicals’ disposal and nitrates from human waste is on the increase Medical waste is posing an emerging problem related to the HIV/AIDS home based care programme. The secrecy surrounding the HIV/AIDS disease inhibits proper management and disposal of this waste. 3.1.2.5 Energy Land degradation and the cutting of live trees remain serious concerns for firewood usage as a traditional means to provide energy. As an alternative solar energy use will be promoted during the plan period. 3.1.3 Ministry of Local Government Strategic Plan The Ministry’s responsibility is to provide basic physical and social infrastructure to the communities. The Ministry’s strategic plan is that of ensuring efficient operation of local authorities through policy direction, capacity building and supervision. The key result areas are as reflected in table 3.1 below: Table 3.1: Ministry of Local Governement Key Result Areas KRA Customer Satisfaction Policy Implementation Improved Quality of Life Productivity and Organisation Effectiveness 3.1.4 Objectives To ensure customer satisfaction through timely delivery of quality service. To ensure continuous improvement in service delivering through a two way communication process. To improve Local Authorities project implementation through timely submission of project memoranda. To ensure education dissemination of information and effective consultation of communities. To promote sustainable self-reliance among communities through Community Based Strategy and LG 1109. To improve quality of life by coordinating and providing basic infrastructure and services. To reduce the level of crime by adopting community policy. The local authorities recognise the need to developmental human resource strategies to improve the level of productivity. Promote effective understanding of Batswana of Botswana’s culture by facilitating documentation of customary laws. Ensure coordination of departmental activities through the development and implementation of sound policies, guidelines and effective leadership teams Long Term District Plans The North East District does not have a land use plan, however long term planning is elaborated in Draft District Settlement Strategy (DSS), draft structural plan for Masunga, Greater Francistown Structural Plan and village plans. After the main long term plans have been finalised village plans will receive similar attention and be finalised 37 3.1.4.1 District Settlement Strategy The settlement strategy is a 24 year plan (2000 – 2024) spatial plan, which proposes hierarchy of settlements and gives the district guidance in the prioritisation of development within the confines of the National Settlement Policy. The DSS intends to elaborate both National Development Plan and National Settlement Policy at the District level and to facilitate their implementation. It will identify the settlement hierarchy in the District and provide guidelines for the location of infrastructure and services in each hierarchical level of settlement. Furthermore the strategy will facilitate economic growth through the promotion of agricultural, industrial and public service growth and development, promote growth in settlement, which will serve as central service centres for surrounding settlements. The plan furthers the efficient use and conservation of natural resources thereby attaining sustainable development. The plan has emphasised the need for a Water Point Survey, which will assist in identification of alternative water sources in view of limited water resources in the district. 3.1.4.2 Greater Francistown Planning Area The plan was to provide a guide for the expansion of Francistown city. This was to provide a framework for integrating economic, social, institutional and physical development with Greater Francistown. 3.1.4.3 Northern Regional Master Plan The objective of regional planning is to get optimal utilisation of services and economies of scale in the region. It seeks to provide guidance in the provision of services and infrastructure in the region in terms their centrality and adequacy and their role promoting regional growth. It further assesses socio-economic status of various settlements, existing physical linkages and strategise the development of weaker ones. The northern regional plan will be a 24 year plan and will be considered for preparation during DDP6. 3.1.4.4 Masunga Land Use Plan There is no development for the district headquarters but there is the land use map which has zoned the village in to different land uses. The plan has been approved by the land board and the council and served as an agreed basis for development of the villages. 3.1.4.5 Detailed Layout Plans Detailed layout plans were prepared for different clusters in Masunga. Layout plans were also prepared for other villages such as Tatisiding, Makaleng and Shashe Bridge. 38 3.2 DDP6/UDP2 – OVERALL GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 3.2.1 Summary of Key Issues 3.2.1.1 Environmental Issues Shortage of Land for livestock and Crop Production because a large portion of the district is covered by freehold farms, resulting with the need to purchase land to augment tribal land. Loss of Agricultural land to other development e.g. settlement expansion. Slow implementation of Community Based Strategy aiming at communities utilizing natural resources sustainable to meet their economic needs. Rehabilitation of Gullies in the district. The district is mostly covered by streams, therefore, becomes prone to erosion. Cutting of live trees for firewood and indiscriminate collection of river sand , pit sand and gravel as a result of the construction boom, especially in greater Francistown Planning area (GFPA). Absence of integrated Land Use Plans making land delivery difficult for land authorities. Non-observance of land development covenant. Most of allocated land remains undeveloped for a long time, seeking strict monitoring and enforcement of Land development covenant. Mostly land is acquired for speculative purposes Delay in servicing of demarcated plots, in the process delaying land allocation. Indiscriminate and illegal extraction of soil, sand and aggregates is a growing concern. Extraction is done haphazardly leaving the district scenery undesirable. 3.2.1.2 Socio-Economic key issues Poverty: Poverty is prevalent in the district especially among women who are mostly headed a larger proportion of households than their male counterparts. The poverty situation is aggravated by high rate of unemployment among the same group as most of them are unskilled or semi skilled to secure proper paying jobs. The other factor is lack of employment opportunities in the district due to low industrial and commercial activity. Drought has also persisted over the years impoverishing the district populace reliant on land-based/agriculture resources. Erosion of Self Reliance: Community participation on development activities is observed to be deteriorating. Communities’ interest is cash oriented than voluntary work. This has not only inevitably lowered community participation but also destroyed the self-reliance fibre envisioned in Vision 2016. The lack of self-reliance is further observed to be replaced by reliance on government. This was deemed to be aggravated by government intervention through poverty alleviation and economic empowerment strategies. These have created dependence, which will need a radical paradigm shift. Waste Management: The Home based Care Programme as a responsive tool and support structure was formed without prior thought of disposal of clinical waste in homes. In view of the stigma attached coupled with insufficient manpower and equipment for collection of such waste has resulted in improper disposal of clinical waste in homes. 39 Crude dumping of waste by the general public and littering were also mentioned as areas of concern. Low Production in the Agricultural Sector: The crop sub-sector was found to be performing below the mark largely due to lack of well-formulated and targeted policies subservient to enhancing productivity in the sub-sector. Abuse of ALDEP was indicated specifically the draught power package which never met its intended use. Persistent drought and general loss of interest in rain-fed arable agriculture, very minimal arable land for cultivation and inadequate water for irrigated agriculture have attributed to the decline in the performance of the sub sector. This has therefore resulted in low contribution of arable production as a supplementary food resource in the household food basket. In that situation the district populace reliant in agric production and land-based resources have remained the economically weak become worse-off. As a way to enhance production, communities recommended servicing of lands areas especially water provision. HIV/AIDS: The virus has infected a considerable number of the rural people. Households are unable to cope with the results both socially and economically. Community members are left financially and emotionally drained by the disease. Though the framework in terms of structures at institutional and community levels do exist to fight the virus, the stigma and lack of openness continue to reverse efforts made in the fight against the epidermic. Unemployment and Underemployment: There are low-income opportunities existing in the village precipitated by lack of diversified rural economy. Those employed are employed in low income earning activities or in the temporary relief intervention such as Drought or Disaster Relief Programme (Labour Intensive Public works Programme) and temporary employment in the construction sector. The employment level of the district according to 2001 statistics was recorded at 41.6% while 2 509 people were recorded as actively seeking work representing the showing an unemployment level of 10.2%. Statistics for the underemployed district populace was not available in the census results. 3.3 DDP6/UDP2 DEVELOPMENT GOALS AND OBJECTIVES Table 3.2: DDP6 Overal Development Goals and Objectives Goals To promote industrial and commercial development. To increase agricultural productivity Objectives To put up factory shells in certain areas like Matsiloje, Tati Siding, Matshelagabedi and Moroka villages to encourage industrial development. Intensification of information dissemination on CEDA, public education and extension support. Plan and service industrial plots in the designated areas. Apply appropriate technology, taking into account the weather conditions in this country. Make more land available through acquisition of freehold farms. Apply land reclamation practices and conservation of fertile agricultural land. Promotion of small agriculture holdings including horticulture production. 40 Goals To ensure adequate water supply for both human and other uses. To work towards achieving basic health care and social welfare by the end of the plan period. To strengthen district institutions. To ensure a sound financial base for Council. To continue to sensitise the village institutions/individuals to appreciate the need to identify, plan and implement projects and programmes that meet their sociocultural, ecological, and economic needs through sustainable utilization of available resources even natural resources. To promote orderly and progressive use of land in the district Promotion of tourism To ensure protection and conservation of the environment. Human Resource Development 3.4 Objectives Produce integrated pest control measures e.g. quelea birds and armyworm Construct dams to promote irrigation and livestock watering. Construct dams, introduce rain harvesting measures, build small earth dams and introduce recycling of water for woodlots. Connect North East District to the planned lower Shashe Dam and Ntimbale Dam. For Peri Urban areas - Water supplied by WUC through Council must be on a cost recovery basis. Intensify primary health programmes. Adopt improved waste management measures. Conduct mass educational campaigns on major social issues, e.g. HIV/AIDS, TB, STD, teenage pregnancy, etc. Conduct appropriate health research activities, e.g. TB and AIDS. Introduce effective co ordination of DDC, DET and VETS. Train grassroots institutions. Regularly monitor and review both the District Development Plan and related institutional structures. Achieve adequate staffing of key Central and Local Government posts. Improve communication linkages between the district based local authorities and farms. Identify potential sources of revenue for councils. Ensure cost efficiency by sound budgeting, expenditure and financial management. Introduce the cost recovery and cost-sharing principle to ensure sustainability in the provision of services. Improve collection of fees on the provision of basic services such as health, education, water, waste collection, etc. Promote environmental conservation awareness through educational campaigns and initiatives. Development of nature and culture preservation site at specific areas. To develop land policy that will ensure optimal use of land. To develop an integrated land use plan for the district. Development an eco-tourism strategy joining it with other places on interest in the nearby district and settlements. Preparation of an inventory of places of interest and of historical/cultural value in district. To develop systems which will foster protection of the environment by developers including government institutions To incorporate Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) in our development processes. To pursue human resource development to ensure the relevance and good performance of the strategies for economic empowerment Improvement of the education system as well as provision of facilities and an environment conducive for learning. Creating opportunities for lifelong learning such as distance learning and non-formal education. Efficient allocation of human resources FRAMEWORK FOR MONITORING SECTOR GOALS AND OBJECTIVES Performance targets will be set per sector and with verifiable indicators to facilitate the monitoring of the plan. The monitoring and implementation of the plan is the mandate of Plan Management Committee and DDC. The committee is comprised of chief executives of the four local authorities and 41 planners. The district commissioner and council secretary are co-managers and they perform the duties of these committees. DDC is composed of all heads of department of local government, central government and parastatals in the district. Each member reports progress of the plan implementation regularly and quarterly progress report are sent to the Ministries of Local Government, Lands and Housing, Finance and Development Planning (Rural Development Coordination Division) and copies to all permanent secretaries. The core function of DDC is to coordinate the DDP, therefore forms framework for monitoring sector goals and objectives. 3.5 FRAMEWORK FOR MONITORING ENVIRONMENTAL GOALS AND OBJECTIVES Verifiable indicators will be set to facilitate monitoring of sector goals and objectives. The mandate of DDC is to prepare and co-ordinate the DDP and for monitoring environmental goals and objectives, there are sub-committees which have the responsibility of advising DDC on environmental issues. The sub-committees include DLUPU that is composed of professional officers from local government and central government. DLUPU report regularly to DDC and advice land board on application on environmental issues. Its main function is to prepare and coordinates district land use plan. Another sub-committee is DET. It evaluates and monitors the plan by ensuring preparation, implementing and monitoring annual plans. During DDP 6, these committees, especially DLUPU will carry environmental reviewing and prepare District environmental Action Plan as a framework for monitoring environmental goals and objectives. 3.6 FRAMEWORK FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT In DDP 6, the emphasis is on the need to conserve and preserve our environment in development processes, so that all projects and programmes are socially, economically and ecologically sustainable. In most cases, planning does not consider the natural environment. Development programmes and projects are often implemented with little or no consideration of the environment. In order that adverse effects of development on the environment are minimised it is important that environment issues are integrated in development policies and programmes. During DDP 6 preparation, the NED attempted to integrate environmental issues into the development processes based on the principles set out in the Environmental Planning Manual. 3.6.1 Evaluation of Key Environmental Issues with Overall Goals and Objectives Table 3.3: Key Environmental Issues with Overall Goals and Objectives Goals and Objectives Promote industrial and commercial development – broadening the district resource base. Environmental Key Issue Air pollution. Waste disposal. Ground water contamination. Community empowerment through community natural resource management projects. Loss of biodiversity. Ensure sustainable financial council. Ensure adequate water supply. Nil base for Ground water depletion. Strategy Groundwater conservation and protection. Demand of waste management plans from industries. Enforcement of available legislation e.g Waste Management Act. Develop an incentive for sustainable use of natural resources. Establish community collection of natural resources user fee. Nil Groundwater conservation. As a long term water recycling. Use of water from ponds. Rain water harvesting, Planting of crops with low water consumption. 42 Goals and Objectives Environmental Key Issue Increase Productivity in the agricultural sector – promotion of livestock production, arable production, small holdings. Land degradation, overgrazing, increased demand for water, pollution, waste disposal, migration of wildlife during construction of cordon fences, over utilisation of some tree species used for drift fences and field parameter fences. Conflict with wildlife management. Nil Strengthening of local structures and district institution. Promotion of Tourism Development. Improving the infrastructural level of the district. 3.6.2 Loss of biodiversity. Mushrooming of settlement around the tourism project. Opening access to fragile eco-system. Land degradation through overextraction of sand and other aggregates, cutting down of trees, soil erosion, and damage of ecosystem. Strategy Public education on water conservation methods. Waste management plans for small agriculture holding with possibility of pollution. Use of recycled water for irrigation. nil Undertake an EIA Re-planting of trees. Rehabilitation of burrow pits. Controlled mining of aggregates. Creation of dongas. Evaluation of Policies and Programmes against Overall Goals and Objectives Table 3.4: Evaluation of Policies/Programmes against Ovearll Goals and Objectives Goals and Objectives Promote industrial and commercial development – broadening the district resource base Community empowerment through community natural resource management projects Ensure sustainable financial council. Ensure adequate water supply. base for Increase Productivity in the agricultural sector – promotion of livestock production, arable production, small holdings. Strengthening of local structures and district institution. Promotion of Tourism Development. Improving the infrastructural level of the district. Environmental Issues Air pollution from industrial emissions. Poor waste disposal from industry. Increase in waste generated around industrial and commercial centres. Ground water contamination. Loss biodiversity. Lack of ownership and economic benefit by the community from the environment that surrounds it. Underutilisation and improper usage of natural resources. Nil Policies and Programmes (Environmental) Industrial Development Policy Privatisation Policy Waste Management Act Ground water depletion. Lack of conservation in the use of water. National Water Master Plan National Settlement Policy District Settlement Strategy Transboundary agreements (Multi-lateral Environmental Agreements) and protocols National Conservation Policy National Agriculture Master Plan Water Master Plan Overgrazing. Land degradation. Overgrazing. Increased demand for water Groundwater pollution. Waste disposal from small holdings. Lack of knowledge of better farming techniques. Nil Loss of biodiversity. Improve conservation. Generate revenue to protect the environment. Land degradation through over-extraction of sand and other aggregates. Cutting down of trees, Soil erosion. National Conservation Policy Community Based Natural Resources Mgt Policy draft Nil Nil Tourism Act Eco-Tourism Strategy Transboundary agreements and protocols District Land Use Plan 43 CHAPTER 4 4 ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION 4.1 INTRODUCTION The North-East district freehold farms occupy an area of 2 569 km2 which is 42.9% of the district land. Many rivers and streams that are in the district are susceptible to environmental problems like soil erosion and land degradation due to excessive extraction of sand and gravel hence requiring sound environmental conservation strategies. Furthermore Vision 2016 has advocated for the sustainable use of renewable and non-renewable resources and that be a fully integrated approach towards their conservation and development for sustainable use of natural resources. Therefore by the year 2016 Batswana will take pride in their clean and unlittered surroundings. 4.1.1 Institutional Framework Environmental conservation in the district is the responsibility of various institutions. These include the Land Board, Council, Tourism, Agriculture, and others. Non-Governmental Organizations and Community Based Organizations are also important players in the management of the environment. Coordination of these institutions is the responsibility of the District Land Use Planning Unit (DLUPU). DLUPU is a sub-committee of the District Development Committee. The Land Board Secretary chairs DLUPU and the Lands Officer is the Secretary. 4.1.2 Consultation Priorities Environmental conservation issues that arose from community consultations included the following: 4.2 Population pressure arising from the size of the district as well as land tenure Over-utilization of natural resources like sand, gravel and firewood. Pollution of water sources especially by pit latrines Land degradation arising from overgrazing by livestock Indiscriminate waste disposal Poor environmental policing and monitoring. ENVIRONMENTAL POLICIES AND LEGISLATION There are some environmental policies that the district needs to pay attention to. If the district does not implement them properly they can lead to adverse ecological impacts. However, projects in DDP 6 will be subjected to Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA), Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA), Audit and monitoring. These environmental management tools will be assisted where necessary by environmental management plans and systems. The fore-going policies include the following: 44 4.2.1 Tourism Policy The proliferation of tourism activities in the district will bring both positive and negative aspects of developments, e.g. on the positive side there will be employment creation and ready markets for local produce such as vegetables and handicrafts. The negative aspect is that the increased tourism is likely to destroy the district heritage such as the limited cultural and archaeological sites. 4.2.2 Community Based Natural Resource Management (CBNRM) The CBNRM policy was introduced in order for the community to take responsibilities in conservation of their natural resources. In the process the residents are able to raise some funds to develop their communities. This will in turn lessen the dependency on government grants. 4.2.3 National Master Plan for Arable Agriculture and Dairy Development (NAMPAADD) This programme is meant to improve arable agriculture and dairy production. This will lead to self-sufficiency in food production and dairy products in the district. Because of the intensive nature of the proposed developments, there is likelihood of some negative impacts. Waste from extensive agricultural production and use of artificial fertilizers could lead to ground water pollution and loss of biodiversity. 4.2.4 Citizen Entrepreneurial Development Agency (CEDA) These are basically financial assistance packages meant to assist local entrepreneurs to venture into viable projects. In the process, they are expected to create employment and alleviate poverty in the rural areas. In the absence of an integrated land use plan, haphazard land allocation arising from increased demand for land partly due to CEDA loans could lead to loss of bio-diversity and groundwater pollution. This is due to the fact that an inventory of natural resources and their location in the district has not been done. 4.2.5 National Settlement Policy (NSP) NSP was meant to guide the provision of services to settlements based on economic criteria to ensure that public resources are used efficiently. The provision of services to small settlements that are spread over a wide geographic area is not cost effective since the cost per unit is high. The provision of services to small settlements has also lead to loss of a lot of fertile agricultural land to settlements. 4.2.6 Waste Management Act The piece of legislation is meant to manage waste generation and disposal. It will result in proper waste disposal and recycling. If the act is not enforced the waste generated by projects resulting from the above policies could be dumped at illegal sites and pollute the environment. 4.2.7 Housing Policy The policy direction in the housing sector during DDP5 was guided by the 1981 National policy on Housing and the Revised National Policy on Housing of 2000. Housing delivery will be facilitated through the design and development of affordable housing schemes for all income 45 groups. The National Policy on Housing aims at the provision of decent and affordable housing for all Batswana with a safe sanitary environment. The negative aspect of this development is that use of sanitary facilities like pit latrines in residential areas could lead to pollution of ground water sources more especially that most of the villages in the district use boreholes. Furthermore the increased use of modern building material results in excessive use of natural resources such as river sand, gravel and water. 4.2.8 National Conservation Strategy (NCS) The primary goals in formulating the strategy are to pursue policies and measures that promote sustainable use of natural resources and minimizing negative environmental effects. Furthermore it provides the broad framework for many sectoral ministries and interest groups throughout the country for dealing with environmental issues. 4.3 DDP 6 ENVIRONMENTAL GOALS AND OBJECTIVES During DDP 6, the district’s environmental objectives include forming community trusts to conserve the environment and utilise natural resources, rehabilitation of some degraded land by constructing drifts and planting trees, and educating the community about conservation of natural resources. The core goal that encompasses the objective is to foster environmental friendly practices through formulation, review and facilitation of relevant environmental policies and legislation as well as promotion of research and monitoring. The continued over exploitation of natural resources e.g. cutting of live trees, mining of river sand, pit sand and gravel, especially for commercial purposes, therefore defeat the objectives of environmental and conservation strategies. Table 4.1: Goals and Objectives Goals To foster environment friendly practices through review and facilitation of implementation of relevant environmental policies and legislation as well as promotion of research and monitoring. Objectives To conduct workshops for 42 villages on conservation by 2005 To form two community based conservation trust every two years till March 2009. To educate the community on rainwater harvesting by 2005. To Develop District Environmental Strategy by 2005. To facilitate research on key environmental issues for duration of DDP 6. To prepare and implement district waste management plan by 2009. To improve waste management in the district through preparation of district waste management plan. To privatize refuse collection in selected villages by 2003. To educate community on waste management till 2009. To collect data on existing burrow pits by 2003. To minimize adverse environmental impacts of wasteland by reclaiming burrow pits and waste dumps. To reduce loss of biodiversity through improved fire management strategy. To assess potential use of burrow pits and waste dumps by 2003. To carryout geo-technical surveys by 2005. To develop and implement the district fire management strategy by 2009. To conduct public seminars on fire management till 2009. To collect data on rehabilitable gullies by 2003. To reduce soil erosion by rehabilitating gullies. To rehabilitate gullies by 2009. 46 4.4 FRAMEWORK FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT It should be noted that these environmental policies and programs are aimed at enhancing environmental protection and as such their adverse potential impacts are stated in the table below. Table 4.2: Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues with Sector Goals and Objectives Goals Objectives Conduct workshops for 42 villages on conservation by 2005. Environmental Key Issues Littering and indiscriminate waste disposal To foster environment friendly practices through review and facilitation of implementation of relevant environmental policies and legislation as well as promotion of research and monitoring Form 2 community based conservation trusts every two years until March 2009 Loss of biodiversity Privatize refuse collection selected villages by 2003 To reduce loss of biodiversity through improved fire management strategy Table 4.3: Negative impacts will known after the plan be Plan preparation in Educate community on waste management till 2009 Collect data on existing burrow pits by 2003 To minimize adverse environmental impacts of waste land by reclaiming burrow pits and waste dumps Educate community on waste management Educate community on rainwater harvesting by 2005. Develop district environmental strategy by 2005. Prepare and implement waste management plan by 2009. To improve waste management in the district through preparation of district waste management plan Strategy Proper waste management Soil erosion Tree planting Littering and waste disposal Provision of sanitary facilities Provide fire breaks Assess potential use of burrow and waste dumps by 2003 Carryout geo-technical surveys by 2005 Develop and implement the district fire management strategy by 2009 Loss of vegetation Conduct public seminars on fire management till 2009 Evaluation of Sector Policies and Programs Policies and Programs Goals and Objectives To raise incomes in rural areas in order to reduce urban drift Tourism Policy Community Based Natural Management (CBNRM) Resources National Master Plan for Arable Agriculture and Dairy Development (NAMPAADD) Citizen Entrepreneurial Development Agency (CEDA) National Settlement Policy (NSP) To promote rural development and to stimulate the provision of other services in remote areas of the country. Diversify economic development in rural areas through sustainable use of natural resources. Ensure communities benefit from the management of their natural resources. Increased agricultural output and productivity Diversification of the agricultural base Empowerment of citizen entrepreneurs. Provide a comprehensive set of guidelines for national physical planning and to provide a framework for guiding the distribution of investment in a way that Environmental Issues Destruction of district heritage such as the limited cultural and archeological sites No negative impacts anticipated as the projects will be meant to conserve the environment Pollution to ground water resources Loss of biodiversity and ground water pollution Loss of fertile agricultural land to settlements 47 Policies and Programs Housing Policy Waste Water/Sanitation Management Policy 4.5 Goals and Objectives reflects the settlements’ population size, economic potential, level of infrastructure and settlements’ role as service centres. To channel more Government resources to low and middle lower income housing in both urban and rural areas. Environmental Issues Increased extraction of natural resources like gravel and sand To promote housing as an instrument for economic empowerment and poverty alleviation. To foster partnership with private sector and all major employers in home development and facilitating home ownership. Provide framework for the development of a affordable and sustainable waste water/sanitation infrastructure and management Pollution of resources. ground and surface water Water-borne diseases PROPOSED ENVIRONMENTAL STRATEGIES TO IMPLEMENT DISTRICT ENVIRONMENTAL PROGRAMS. As stated earlier DDP 6 projects, policies and programs are subjected to some environmental management tools e.g. EIA, audit and management plans designed to assist conserve the environment. Projects on environmental conservation are intended to rehabilitate the degraded environment and manage resource utilization without degrading the environment. Therefore, the activities to be carried under environmental conservation do not have a significant environmental impact. 4.6 RESOURCE REQUIREMENT FOR DDP 6 4.6.1 Issues and Strengths The success of the district plan implementation is mainly based on availability of adequate resources. The resources also have to be used efficiently. For the formulation of a sustainable plan and implement it very easily, a SWOT analysis has to be performed. The analysis reveals the strengths, weakness, opportunities and threats within the system of structures that assist plan implementation. 4.6.1.1 Strengths Sound legislation in place that provides framework within which to operate. Availability of relevant structures for implementation and enforcement of environmental policies and programs. Abundant natural resources and historic/cultural sites. Issues Lack of relevant policies to protect historic/cultural sites. Lack of land use plan encourages mushrooming of settlements and loss of agricultural land to other uses. Shortage of tribal land, putting more pressure on natural resources. Lack of capacity to enforce and disseminate information on environmental legislations. 48 Table 4.3: Performance Targets Goal Activity Conduct workshops for 42 villages on conservation Start April 2003 Finish April 2005 April 2003 Mar 2008 April 2003 April 2005 April 2003 April 2005 April 2006 Mar 2009 April 2003 June 2003 April 2003 July 2003 Mar 2004 June 2004 Aug 2003 Nov 2003 Mar 2004 June 2004 Mar 2004 Mar 2004 To develop and implement the district fire management strategy. April 2003 Dec 2008 Conduct public seminars on fire management. April 2003 Mar 2009 Collect gullies April 2003 July 2003 April 2004 March 2009 Form two community conservation trust To foster environment friendly practices through, review and facilitation of implementation of relevant environmental policies and legislation as well as promotion of research and monitoring. based Educate the community on rain water harvesting Develop District Environmental Strategy Facilitate research on key environmental issues for last half of DDP 6. Prepare and implement district waste management plan. To improve waste management in the district through preparation of district waste management plan. To minimize adverse environmental impacts of waste land by reclaiming burrow pits and waste dumps. Privatise refuse selected villages collection in Carry-out geo-technical investigation Collect data on existing burrow pits Assess potential use of burrow pits and waste dumps. Carryout geo-technical survey. To reduce loss of biodiversity through improved fire management strategy. To reduce soil erosion by rehabilitation gullies Monitoring Report to DLUPU, DDC, Land Board and council. data on rehabilitable Regular presentation to DDC, Land Board and Council Report to reference group every three months. Submit report to Dept of Lands. Report to reference group every three months Report to DLUPU, District Conservation committee and ARB Report to DLUPU, DDC, NCSA, land board, Council and ARB Rehabilitate gullies approximately Table 4.4: Development Budget Goal To foster environment friendly practices through, review and facilitation of implementation of relevant environmental policies and legislation as well as promotion of research and monitoring. To improve waste management in the district through preparation of district waste management plan. To minimize adverse environmental impacts of wasteland by reclaiming burrow pits and waste dumps. Activity Conduct workshops for 42 villages on conservation Amount (PULA) 50 000 Form two community based conservation trust to be determined Educate the community on rain water harvesting 50 000 Develop District Environmental Strategy 10 000 Facilitate research on key environmental issues Prepare and implement district waste management plan. 50 000 Privatize refuse collection in some villages. To be determined Educate community on waste management. Collect data on existing burrow pits 50 000 100 000 Assess potential use of burrow pits and waste dumps. Carry geo-technical survey. 49 Goal To reduce loss of biodiversity through improved fire management strategy. Activity To develop and implement the district fire management strategy. Conduct public seminars on fire management. Collect data on rehabilitable gullies. To reduce soil erosion by rehabilitating gullies. Amount (PULA) 50 000 100 000 Rehabilitate gullies appropriately 50 CHAPTER 5 5 LAND USE PLANNING 5.1 INTRODUCTION North East District which is the second smallest district in the country covers an area of 5 993 km2. It consists of freehold farms covering an area of 2 569 km2, state land 33 km2 and tribal land 3 391 km2. The District is bordered and crossed by many ephemeral streams and rivers. The soils are generally well drained and moderately deep, characterised by tree savannah. Land Use Planning in the district is determined by many factors viz mushrooming of settlements, shortage of tribal land and extensive freehold farms within tribal land. Effective and efficient land and environmental management must be guided by sound land use planning in order to zone land in a manner that fertile agricultural land will be preserved and use natural resources in a sustainable manner. This will be going in line with the aspiration of Vision 2016. 5.1.1 Institutional Framework Land use planning is a cross sectional issue involving ministries, departments, parastatals, private sector and community at grass roots level. The ministries are at decision-making level and are advised by district authorities on issues of the environment. The responsibility of land use planning lies with the Ministry of Lands and Housing. It co-ordinates land use planning at national and local levels. The ministries involved in land use planning process have strategic plans targeted at the sustainable use of natural resources. These include, Ministry of Local Government, Ministry of Lands and Housing, Ministry of Agriculture and Ministry of Trade, Wildlife and Tourism. 5.1.1.1 Ministry of Local Government The mission statement of the Ministry of Local Government is desired future excellence on service delivery, development coordination, capacity building and customer care in its quest for continuous development. 5.1.1.2 Ministry of Lands and Housing Ministry of Lands and Housing also carry development coordination targeted to land use planning. The mission statement for the Ministry of Lands and Housing is to provide excellent service in management and development of land, facilitation of housing delivery as well as promotion of environmental protection in development process. In North East District the two ministries are represented by the Land Board that is responsible for tribal land administration and allocation while the Council is responsible for land use planning and service provision. 51 5.1.1.3 Ministry of Agriculture Ministry of Agriculture, with its five departments of Animal Health & Production, Crop Production & Forestry, Agricultural Research, Co-operatives and Ministry management is also much involved in land use planning process. Its mission statement is to be committed in providing leadership in the development of sustainable, diversified and competitive agriculture and conservation of natural resources to contribute to the achievement of sustainable environment. In North East the ministry is represented by three departments namely Crop Production and Forestry, Animal Health and Production and Co-operatives while the rest are based in Francistown. 5.1.1.4 Ministry of Trade, Wildlife and Tourism The other involved is the Ministry of Trade, Wildlife and Tourism. Its mission statement is to create an environment conducive for business, protects consumer rights, and manages wildlife resources to meet local and global challenges. All the ministries plans are in line with government aspirations to transform the public service through PMS and WITS. The ministry is represented by the departments of Integrated Field Services based in Masunga village while Wildlife and National Parks, and Tourism cover the district from Francistown. 5.1.2 Consultation Priorities Shortage of tribal land for livestock and crop production because a large portion of the district is covered by freehold farms. This necessitates purchase of freehold farms to augment tribal land. Loss of agricultural land to other development e.g. settlement expansion. Rehabilitation of gullies in the district. The district is mostly covered by streams and rivers that make it become prone to erosion. Cutting of live trees for firewood and indiscriminate collection of river sand, pit sand and gravel as a result of the construction boom, especially in greater Francistown planning area (GFPA). Absence of integrated land use plans making land delivery and management difficult for land authorities. Most of allocated land remains undeveloped for a long time. This calls for strict monitoring and enforcement of land development policies and procedures. Slow process of planning and surveying of plots for different uses resulting in delay in land allocation. Sale of plots especially in peri-urban settlements. 5.2 LAND USE POLICIES AND LEGISLATION 5.2.1 National Policy on Natural Resources Conservation and Development The 1990 National Policy on Natural Resources Conservation and Development is founded on sustainable development. Development planning aims to meet the needs of present generation without the expense of future generation. One of the tenets of Vision 2016 is a prosperous productive and innovative nation. 52 5.2.2 North East District Settlement Strategy The district is well placed to realize these policies because of its vast potential of natural resources that can be harnessed for the welfare of the community. The North East District Settlement Strategy will help realize these policies as it needs to set out clearly the wishes, needs and aspirations of the community with regards to land use and development in general. 5.2.3 Wildlife and Conservation Policy The goals of preservation and conservation expressed in the Wildlife and Conservation Policy are consistent with objectives of Tourism Policy, the district’s potential on tourism and utilization of natural resources for economic benefits could have adverse impact on the ecology. They form portion of the District Land use Plan and other management plans for example Management Plan for collection of River Sand, Pit Sand and Gravel will be a step in the right direction. 5.2.4 Tourism Policy There are a few tourism related projects allocated land in the district. These include lodges, cultural villages and change of land use from cattle ranching to game ranching especially in freehold farms. 5.2.5 Community Based Natural Resources Management Communities are slowly realizing that they can form trusts and utilize natural resources for their economic benefits. They intend to form trusts to control harvesting of river sand, pit sand and gravel. Others have been allocated land as trust to create botanical garden and rock rabbit park and a lodge. 5.2.6 National Master Plan for Arable Agriculture and Dairy Development (NAMPAADD) The scheme is meant to improve the performance of the agricultural sector through the introduction of improving technologies and mechanisms. Tati district is among the first priority areas targeted for development of rain fed agriculture. The minimum land parcel that can be farmed viably under mechanized rain fed conditions is 150 ha and farms with land less than 150 ha are encouraged to form cultivation groups to meet the minimum requirement that is not practical for North East as the average farm size for farmers is 5 ha. 5.2.7 Financial Assistance Policy/Citizen Etrepreneural Development Agency There is shortage of land in the district, however, projects were started using FAP and still projects are starting and others improved through CEDA. 5.2.8 National Settlement Policy The district is small in land mass and has many villages and more settlements are lobbying to be recognized as villages because NSP has reduced population threshold for defining a village from 500 to 250. 53 5.2.9 Housing Policy The policy strives for better housing for Batswana. The policies could encourage loss of agricultural land, crowding and inadequate service provision. 5.2.10 Waste Management Act The fact that the Act is not effectively enforced, therefore, the waste generated by projects resulting from the above policies could be dumped at illegal sites and pollute aquifers. 5.3 DISTRICT LAND USE PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT There is no integrated land use plan for the district. It is anticipated that during DDP 6 it will be produced to ensure successful implementation of goals and objectives of land use planning. Land use planning should be guided by encouraging community to stay within village boundaries, conserving natural resources, minimizing natural and man made disasters. This could be achieved by integrating land use plan and national policies. In the district it is important to release a highest degree of mixed land use, therefore the land use plan has to establish whether there are merits in the situation or whether the situation must be discontinued. 5.3.1 District Settlement Strategy (DSS) Long term planning is elaborated in the District Settlement Strategy (DSS) that is to be implemented. It needs to recognize that the trend of few households breaking away and changing agricultural land to settlement and calling for unbudgeted services is unwarranted and must be discouraged. DSS is unsuccessful in this endeavor as there is no integrated land use plan to guide development. Lack of land use plan could also encourage unsustainable use of natural resources. An integral land use plan is overdue for the North East. 5.3.2 Land Use Resource Assessment Given the District’s fragile natural resource base measures have to be taken to ensure optimal use of its resources. Furthermore, as the district is well endowed with ephemeral rivers, there is a need to allocate land for economic activities along these rivers. Land use resource assessment can be viewed as shown below. 5.3.2.1 Soil Soils in the district are mostly fertile for agricultural use despite being prone to erosion because of many streams. Some parts of the district, the soils are fertile but due to their high clay content require mechanization to work for particular arable use. The major problem is erosion, shortage of land, and high potential for pollution from use of chemicals. 5.3.2.2 Vegetation Vegetation in the North East District is mainly characterized by tree savanna with mophane tree predominating. The northern and western part of the district is mostly cultivated area, leaving large trees on original woodland. Patchy grass cover is found on communal lands and on freehold farms not overgrazed. Areas with mophane trees have poor grass cover. 54 5.3.2.3 Water The district has many ephemeral streams and rivers. The principal ones are Shashe, Vukwi, Tati, Ntshe, Sikukwe and Ramokgwebana. A considerable amount of water is stored in larger sand rivers throughout the year. This provides the major source of water for both human and livestock population during dry seasons. The most common sources being boreholes, sand pits, small dams and wells. 5.3.2.4 Wildlife The district has little game except a few in freehold farms. The animals are under the authority of DWNP. The potential for Wildlife Tourism is very small. A few freehold farmers have resorted from cattle ranching to wildlife ranching. Despite the little wildlife tourism potential, the district has a great potential for Cultural Tourism. It has many cultural and historic sites. 5.3.2.5 Minerals Up to 1966 there were more than 50 gold mines in the district. Though closed some of these mines are believed to still contain unworked gold reserves. There are gold explorations in the district, e.g. Muphanephane Mine in the Matsiloje area. Copper and Nickel ore reserves are being exploited at Selkirk and Phoenix. Reserves of arsenic, asbestos, Granite and iron also exist. There is also cement mining in Matsiloje hills. 5.4 LAND USE PLANNING GOALS AND OBJECTIVES Based on consultation priorities and critical assessment of issues in the district, the land use and conservation objectives during DDP 6 are: Table 5.1: Goals and Objectives Goals Objectives To prepare North East District Land Use Plan by 2005. To facilitate efficient and equitable land distribution in North East District through appropriate policies. To provide water point survey by 2005. To speed up land allocation through land servicing and streamlined land allocation procedures To facilitate the purchase of freehold farms to augment tribal land and for village expansion. To prepare Management Plan for collection of pit sand, river sand and gravel by 2004. To prepare village layout for 3 villages by 2005. To service 500 demarcated plots in Masunga and Tati Siding every two years until 2008/09. To improve coordination between all land authorities. To facilitate the purchase of 4 freehold farms by 2005. To facilitate relaxation of legal requirements for repossession of common law plots by 2003. To facilitate speedy development of allocated land in the district through relevant policies. To encourage development of freehold farms in the entire district. To facilitate reclamation of wasteland through assessment of potential use of land. To repossess and re-allocate 100% of the customary rights undeveloped in Tati Siding, Masunga and Matshelagabedi by 2003. To inventories allocated land in North East by 2004. To carryout education campaigns through the whole period To inventories freehold farms in the district by 2004. To inventories existing borrow pits, quarries and waste dumps sites in North East District by 2004. To assess potential uses of borrow pits along roads by 2004. 55 To rehabilitate dongas by planting trees for four villages every two years for the entire DDP 6. To improve the perception of customers towards land allocating authorities in the district through public education on land matters. To discourage allocation of burrow pits within the Greater Francistown Planning area To conduct public campaigns on land use concern every year in the District for the duration of DDP. To conduct workshops on land allocation procedures every two years for Land Board members, land overseers and staff for the entire plan. 5.5 FRAMEWORK FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT 5.5.1 Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues with Sector Goals and Objectives Table 5.2: Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues with Sector Goals and Objectives Goals Objectives Prepare NED land use plan by 2005. To facilitate efficient and equitable land distribution in the district. Provide a water point survey. Prepare management plan collection sand and gravel by 2004. Prepare layout plans for three villages on quarterly basis. To speed up land allocation. To purchase freehold farms to augment tribal land. 5.5.2 Service 500 demarcated plots in Masunga and Tati Siding every two years. Purchase 4 freehold farms by 2005. Environmental Key Issues Nil Strategy Nil Cutting trees. Tree planting Disturbance of the ecological system. Engage human than machines. Dust pollution No negative anticipated. Nil impacts labour Evaluation of Sector Policies and Programs Table 5.3: Evaluation of Sector Policies and Programs Policies and Programs District Settlement Strategy Tourism Policy Self Help Housing Agency Waste water / Sanitation Management policy National Settlement Policy Housing Policy Goals and Objectives To provide a hierarchical order of settlements for efficient service provision Maximize sustainable social and economic benefits from tourism resources Promote home ownership to low and middle income lower groups Provide framework for the development of a affordable and sustainable waste water / sanitation infrastructure and management Protect environment through sustainable land use planning To channel more Government resources to low and middle lower income housing in both urban and rural areas. Environmental Issues Ground water pollution and other aquifers. Excessive use of natural resources like sand and gravel Pollution of ground and surface water resources. Water-borne diseases Haphazard settlements affect environmental sensitive areas Increased extraction of natural resources like gravel and sand To promote housing as an instrument for economic empowerment and poverty alleviation. To foster partnership with private sector and all major employers in home development and facilitating home ownership. 56 5.6 PROPOSED STRATEGIES TO ACHIEVE LAND USE GOALS Table 5.4: Potential Impacts of Projects and Mitigation measures Goal To facilitate efficient and equitable land distribution through appropriate policies To speed up land allocation through land servicing and streamlined land allocation procedures To facilitate the purchase of more land to argument tribal land and for village expansion. To facilitate speedy development of allocated land in the district through relevant policies. To facilitate management of freehold farms by the district. To facilitate reclamation of wasteland through assessment of potential use of land. To improve the perception of customers towards land allocating authorities in the district through public education on land matters. Projects Preparation of land use plan, water point survey, and management plan and village layout. Land servicing Purchase freehold farms Compensate owners of ploughing fields affected by villages’ expansion. Initiation of relaxation of repossession requirement. Plot repossession and reallocation. Mitigation Nil Tree cutting, ecological disturbance Loss of biodiversity Nil Tree-replanting Cutting down trees, cross of biodiversity, dust and noise pollution, destruction of artifacts and excessive extraction of construction materials. Nil Inventorising freehold farms Nil Tree re-planting, archeological impact assessment before plot demarcation, Land Board to manage site for extraction of building materials. Nil To inventories and assess potential use of borrow pits. Rehabilitate dongas. Nil Nil Conduct public workshops Nil Nil campaigns 5.7 RESOURCE REQUIREMENT FOR DDP 6 5.7.1 Performance Targets for DDP6 Table 5.5: Negative Impact Nil and Performance Targets For DDP 6 Goal To facilitate efficient and equitable land distribution through relevant policies To speed up land allocation through land servicing and stream lined land allocation procedures. To facilitate the purchase of more land to augment tribal land and for village expansion. To facilitate speedy development of allocated land in the district through relevant policies Activity Prepare land use plan Prepare water point survey Prepare Management Plan Prepare village layouts Land Servicing Revise land allocation Guide lines Facilitate purchase Initiate relaxation requirements repossession Repossess & allocate 100% of customary titles in Tati Siding, Masunga and Matsiloje To facilitate management of free hold farms by the district. To facilitate reclamation of waste land through assessment of the potential use To inventories allocates land. Inventories freehold farms Inventories waste dumps. Assess potential of waste dumps Start Date June 2003 End Date Dec 2004 Monitoring Quarterly reports to DLUPU, DDC, Land Board, Council and LDC June2003 Dec 2004 April 2005 June 2006 March 2003 April 2003 Feb 2004 April 2004 March 2007 April 2008 Feb 2004 April 2005 Quarterly reports to DLUPU, DDC April 2003 Aug 2003 April 2003 April 2005 Present to Land Board and Lands. Bio-monthly reports to Land Board, DLUPU and DDC April 2003 Dec 2004 April 2004 Dec 2004 Feb 2005 April 2005 Quarterly reports to DLUPU, DDC, Land Board and Council Present Report to DLUPU, Lands and DDC. Submit report to Lands and Land Board. 57 Goal of land. Activity Start Date April 2005 End Date Aug 2005 Monitoring To improve public perception towards Tati Land Board through public education. Conduct public education Conduct workshops for Land Board June 2003 July 2009 Regular reporting to DDC May 2004 May 2009 5.7.2 Development Budget for DDP6 Table 5.6: Development Budget For DDP 6 Goal To facilitate efficient and equitable land distribution through relevant policies. Activity Prepare land use plan Amount (Pula) P2 000 000 Prepare water point survey Prepare Management Plan To speed up land allocation through land servicing and stream lined land allocation procedures. To facilitate the purchase of more land to augment tribal land and for village expansion. To facilitate speedy development of allocated land in the district through relevant policies. Prepare village layouts Land Servicing P50 000 000 Revise land allocation guide lines Facilitate purchase P15 000 000 Initiate relaxation repossession requirement P50 000 Repossess and allocate 100% of customary titles in Tati Siding, Masunga and Matsiloje To facilitate management of free hold farms by the district. To facilitate reclamation of waste land through assessment of the potential use of land. To improve public perception towards Tati Land Board through public education. To inventories allocated land. Inventories freehold farms P50 000 Inventories waste dumps. P50 000 Assess potential of waste dumps Conduct public education P100 000 Conduct workshops for Land Board 5.7.3 Plan Monitoring Program The mandate of DDC is to prepare and co-ordinate the DDP and for monitoring environmental goals and objectives, there are sub-committees which have the responsibility of advising DDC on environmental issues. The sub-committees include DLUPU that is composed of professional officers from local government and central government. DLUPU report regularly to DDC and advise land board on application on environmental issues. Its main function is to prepare and coordinates district land use plan. Another sub-committee is DET. It evaluates and monitors the plan by ensuring preparation, implementing and monitoring annual plans. During DDP 6, these committees, especially DLUPU will carryout environmental review and prepare District Environmental Action Plan as a framework for monitoring environmental goals and objectives. 58 CHAPTER 6 6 SETTLEMENT AND HOUSING 6.1 INTRODUCTION This chapter deals with policies and acts relating to housing and settlements. It describes the Government’s effort as regards improvement of housing in the Country. It also highlights on Government policies, which seek to facilitate provision of housing to the public in general and in particular disadvantaged groups such as women and the disabled as mentioned in Vision 2016. The chapter further describes progress made by the North East District in preparation of the district’s settlement strategy and implementation of the housing policy. It is important for the finalisation of the settlement strategy during this plan period in order to curb mushrooming of settlements that is common in the district 6.1.1 Institutional Framework Housing is a cross-sectional issue involving a lot of ministries and other government departments. Departments whose functions have a direct effect in the housing delivery system in Botswana are as outlined below. 6.1.1.1 Department of Surveys and Mapping The Department of Surveys and Mapping is charged with the responsibility of collecting, analysis, preparation, evaluation and dissemination of land information. The department also designs and implements cadastral surveys for the delivery of residential, commercial and industrial plots in state lands. 6.1.1.2 Department of Lands The department is mandated to oversee the allocation use and management of state land through government policies and statutes. 6.1.1.3 Land Boards Land Boards countrywide have been established to be responsible for tribal land administration and allocation of land for residential, commercial, industrial, civic and community, and agricultural uses. Likewise, Tati Land Board in the North East District exists for the same purpose. 6.1.1.4 Department of Housing The Department of Housing is a professional service department within the Ministry of Lands and Housing that is responsible for the designing and formulation of national housing policies, monitoring and provision of guidance to local authorities both urban and rural, private developers and other institutions in the implementation of the national housing programmes and related infrastructure projects. 59 6.1.1.5 Attorney General’s Chambers (Deeds Registry) Deeds Registry is headed by a Registrar who shall have the power to do any act or thing that may lawfully be done under Deeds Registry Act: The Registrar Register grants or leases of land lawfully issued by the government or any other competent authority. Attest or execute and register deeds of transfer of land. Register cessions of registered mortgage bonds. Register cancellations of registered mortgage bonds. 6.1.1.6 Department of Town and Regional Planning The department provides professional and technical advice to both the Minister of Lands and Housing, and Town and Country Planning Board. It also provides guidance and professional support to physical planners in local authorities in all matters related to the preparation, implementation and control of development of detailed plans and layouts and all other relevant planning issues. But in the overall National Housing and Settlement are the primary responsibility of Ministry of Lands, Housing and Environment and Ministry of Local Government. 6.1.1.7 Ministry of Lands, Housing and Environment The primary responsibility of housing and settlement lies mainly with Ministry of Lands, Housing and Environment whose main function entails: National Physical Planning, which involves determination of optimal utilization and proper ordering of land space through policies and Laws. Administering of land both in urban areas and rural areas through established institution. Provision of services, information on surveying, mapping and remote sensing that lay the foundation for physical planning, infrastructure, provision and progressive land administration. Establishment of settlement, which may be due to different social, economic and environmental reasons. Provision of excellent services in management and development of land. Facilitation of housing delivery. Propmotion of environmental protection with other partners in development. 6.1.1.8 Ministry of Local Government The Ministry of Local Government mainly provides civil, political and administrative function in the district through the established local government institution, Council, District Administration, Tribal Administration and Land Board. The Ministry’s major responsibilities are: Provision of basic physical and social infrastructure. 60 Ensuring efficient operation of Local Authorities through policy direction, capacity building and supervision. Social welfare and community mobilization to facilitate participation in development process. In addition to this responsibilities the Ministry of Local Government provide basic housing for all local authorities employees within the framework of policies provided by Ministry of Lands, Housing and Environment. 6.1.2 Consultation Priorities Public sector reform is one of the major emphases of NDP9. Its is a broad based term entailing, right sizing the public sector, productivity with a view to increasing overall economic efficiency and effectiveness. Also there is the issue of environment, which is also a priority for NDP9. As a way of implementing policy thrust of NDP 9, North East District adopted these two principles as the basis for DDP6 consultation. It is a proven fact that accommodation plays a pivotal role as far as productivity of staff is concerned therefore staff housing is one of the major challenges of DDP6. Integrating environmental concerns in our development processes also is a major challenge, which North East District has to address itself to. The following are therefore specific consultation priorities for North East District Plan 6: 6.1.2.1 Institutional Housing Provision of adequate housing for staff of North East District Protection of environment Securing land in advance for project 6.1.2.2 Self Help Housing Program (SHHA) 6.2 Facilitation of housing delivery system through sustainable loan systems Provision of adequate land for SHHA beneficiaries Protection of the environment Fast tracking the roll out SHHA to the rest of the District Awareness campaign for Rural Housing Policy NATIONAL POLICIES AND LEGISLATION There are a number of policies, which were prepared to try and address the issue of land use and settlement proliferation and National Housing concerns. National Settlement Policy is one such policy. The objective of the National Settlement Policy is to rank settlement in a hierarchical order for efficient and equitable provision of social services and physical infrastructure. 6.2.1 District Settlement Strategy North East District is a district characterized by mixed land use activities and proliferation of settlement, which often came as a result of some families turning their ploughing areas into permanent residence away from the provision of the National Settlement Policy. 61 This practice in itself makes provision of social, economic infrastructure and other government programmes such as SHHA difficult to implement. North East District is currently preparing its District Settlement Strategy. This is done with the leading help of Department of Town and Regional Planning in Francistown. Major challenges of this district strategy are: To promote balanced development and ensure an equitable distribution of economic and social activities linked to resource potential areas. To propose infrastructure and services for the twenty-four (24) years based on the projected population for the district. To facilitate the coordination and implementation of sectoral development programmes and projects in the district. To provide a guideline to the local authorities in the district on the settlement, which they should promote for growth based on the established settlement hierarchy and resources within their catchment area. To review the existing land use patterns and designate land to the use that will derive the maximum benefit from it. To elaborate both the National Development Plan and the National Settlement Policy at the district level facilitating their implementation. By fully addressing these challenges the North East District expect to achieve the following: Facilitate economic growth rate of the district. Create additional employment opportunities to curtail rural-urban migration. Facilitate efficient use and conservation of the natural resources thereby attaining sustainable development. Provide a framework for social and physical infrastructure provision. Presently the district has three areas with approved development plans governed by Town and Country Planning Act and these are Tati siding, Shashe Bridge and Matshelagabedi. All these settlements fall under the Greater Francistown Planning area. More areas like Masunga are planned to be declared Planning Areas during DDP6. Town and Country Planning Act apply in these areas but due to lack of capacity by the district, implementation of these plans has not been fully monitored. This has resulted in developers in these areas flouting the Town and Country Planning Act by not observing development setbacks. Failure by developers to observe building setbacks result in unnecessary government expenditure when government want to put up infrastructure. This is so since government has to pay compensation to people whose properties have been affected by infrastructure. A case in point is in Tati siding where the Government is paying well over one and a half million in compensation that could have been avoided. 62 6.2.2 National Housing Policy The need for a housing policy became apparent in the 1980s. This was triggered by growing urbanization of Botswana’s population, which came with new challenges and rising expectations. A consultant was engaged in 1996 to review the Housing Policy and make appropriate recommendations. Some of the major findings reported to be hindering housing delivery system were: Lack of Land for Housing: Land has been established as a major input in the delivery of housing. Land transaction, title deed, high serviced land costs, lack of efficient utilisation of land, shortage of land surveyors and centralisation of land management have been identified as some of the bottlenecks hindering land delivery process. Housing Finance: Housing finance was identified as one of the major inputs to housing delivery. The available housing finance is mostly urban focused and is mainly targeted to private sector housing development. This does not cater for the majority of the people especially in rural areas. To try to curtail this, the Government of Botswana introduced Rural Housing Policy as part of an overall housing and poverty alleviation. In trying to facilitate housing delivery system North East District engaged in the preparation of layout plans for the villages of the district. Three hundred (300) plots have been made available for survey in Masunga area. As soon as base maps for other areas within Masunga are made available 1500 plots will be availed through preparation of village layout plans. Another area on the list of preparation of layout plans in Matshelagabedi. The pre-planned plots in this village have been exhausted. As soon as land has been acquired and base map prepared by Land Board, Council will design 2000 plots. Other villages still have layout plans to last them for one or two years before being exhausted. 6.2.3 Self Help Housing Agency (SHHA) Self Help Housing Agency (SHHA) is a programme, which was recently introduced in the nontownship areas, to facilitate the provision of affordable housing to low and middle income ranging between P4 400 to P36 400 per annum. The program ensures this by means of providing building material loans and Technical advice to the beneficiaries of the SHHA scheme. The National Housing Policy (Government Paper No. 2 of 2000) provides the general framework within which rural housing system should operate. The general thrust of the policy is to prepare a National Plan of action to guide the National Development Programmes, settlement planning and shelters provision as a preparatory process for Housing, consisted of key institutions from all sector that have a significant influence on human settlements and shelter. According to the policy “the Government’s long term goal is to ensure safe and sanitary housing for everyone”. The short term goals is to encourage the building of houses for all income levels at a price which would ensure that no citizen of an urban area is forced to reside in an unauthorized settlement and to improve the quality of housing in rural area by offering the Physical Planning of such settlements and the introduction of modified version of the SHHA scheme in a forming of SHHA Loan. 63 The major focus of the Government is to facilitate housing development in the rural areas. Efforts will be made to integrate shelter provision with job creation and income generation. In addition SHHA in the rural areas is still at the grassroots stage, but housing demand can be estimated that about 40% to 50% of households own their houses in the rural areas and major villages respectively, looking at the migration of those who have already applied for SHHA loan effect from November 2001. Government Paper No. 2 of 2000 on housing recommends the following housing delivery system. Emphasis on low-income group ranging from P4 400 to P24 300 per annum. Middle-income group ranging from P24 300 to P36 400 per annum. The program is administered by the District Councils Self Help Housing Agency (SHHA) Efforts would be made to improve the standard of living in urban and rural areas in a balanced manner and to utilize the human and natural resources in an economically, socially, ecologically and sustainable manner. All developments will be preceded by planning and engineering studies as well as environmental impact assessment. Under the policy, settlements designated as primary centers will be accorded a higher priority for development. The rural primary centers referred to as major villages will be upgraded to urban standard in terms of infrastructure and services, including a few secondary centers designated as sub- districts and district headquarters. In this case Masunga will be given the first priority as District Headquarter. Tati Siding and Matshelagabedi villages will also be considered to be upgraded to urban standard because of all feasibility study carried out in the area and surveyed to the cadastral standard. It is also planned to allow the provision of basic services. Settlements with population of over 1000 will be planned and developed. 6.2.4 Institutional Housing Institutional housing for the four local authorities is the responsibility of Ministry of Local Government through Department of Local Government Development. Staff accommodation continues to be a problem for North East District. Although these four local authorities engage in construction of staff houses every financial year, but the need for more housing continues to grow. This is mainly due to the fact that more Government programs are introduced which result in more personnel being employed who in turn increase housing demand. Presently the following housing stock exists in the district: Table 6.1: Institution Council District Admin Tribal Admin Land Board Primary Education Primary Health Totals Housing Situation per Institutions in North East District Housing Stock 221 84 28 35 332 52 836 Current Housing Shortage 40 28 None 234 302 DDP 6 Planned Houses 77 plus 2 Flats 32 54 9 120 21 313 – 2 Flats Source: NED Housing Situation Analysis, 2003 64 Note that the shortage indicated is based on existing manpower as depicted in the establishment registers of these institutions. In addition a nation wide program to address education facilities backlog is currently planned to address the backlog situation in the districts. 6.3 SETTLEMENT AND HOUSING 6.3.1 Settlement Patterns and Geomorphology North East District is relatively flat. However it is doted by a number of hill outcrops such as Matsiloje in Matsiloje Village, Mupanipani in Matsiloje. Gungwe hills in Gungwe Village, Mambidi hills in Jackalas II, Kalakamati Hills in Kalakamati Village that seem connected geographically. The land rises from 930m in the south to 1300m above sea level to north resulting in a number of dongas and cross of rivers and streams flowing mostly to the south. Settlements in the district are most linear in nature extending along linear feature such as streams or roads. The villages in this district are dispersed all over the district with population ranging for 200 to 4800. There are 42 recognized villages, but more and more breakaway families are coming up to seek recognition as settlements from the Government. This is fuelled by local politics, which takes advantage of lack of land use plan. Shortage of land in the district has led to congestion mainly of land activities in some settlement in the district making provision of infrastructure and other social services extremely difficult and costly. The average distance between villages in the district is 7 km or less. Other types of residential developments in the district are found in the city of Francistown. Land use includes residential, commercial, industrial, civic and community, agriculture recreational and other Land users. 65 Map 6.1: North East District Land Use 66 6.3.2 Housing Demand and Supply There is acute shortage of residential land use in the district. This residential land use pressure is more pronounced in the areas falling under greater Francistown. This has lead in extreme cases to squatting. Out- Immigration of people from the city to areas in its periphery and migration of people from far place to areas near the city continue to increase pressure on residential land use in areas like Tati Siding, Matshelagabedi, Shashe Bridge and Ditladi. This has resulted in the Land Board compulsorily acquiring agricultural land in the periphery of the villages to argument the already stressed residential land use type. Shortage of land for residential purposes has hundred housing supply in the district especially in areas near the city of Francistown where the housing demand is high. For instance in Tati Siding alone the waiting list is 12 000 and there is no land, as the remaining ploughing areas have not been acquired. The housing stock resulting is below average in peripheral areas and moderately above average in areas falling under greater Francistown. In trying to pick the standard the housing stock, the district has engaged in infrastructure provision in selected areas like Masunga and presently in Tati Siding. More infrastructure in planned for Masunga with P2.12 million approved for infrastructure design during the financial 2003/2004 and probably other areas under greater F/town planning area in DDP6. 6.4 SETTLEMENT AND HOUSING SECTOR GOALS AND OBJECTIVES The North East District Settlement and Housing goals and objectives were derived from a series of consultations with the communities of North East District. The micro economic outline and the policy frame work for NDP 9 was used to inform or direct the consultation. The following goals and objectives were derived; To facilitate home ownership by eligible residents of the District by rolling out SHHA Scheme to all the villages in the district starting from 2003. To avail plots to eligible citizen to enable those eligible to apply for SHHA by preparing four village plans with 1000 plots every year starting from 2003. To promote environmental awareness and facilitation of its integration into development process by 2003 Integrate tree planting or landscaping in all government projects by year 2003. By introducing environmental tax bye-law for all construction projects. To facilitate reclamation of wasteland by zoning this wasteland into land use that can derived optimum benefit. The district will do this through community projects and the target is to start five project of this nature every year from year 2003. The district’s role in these projects will be to facilitate and the community and NGOs will do most of the work. 67 Table 6.2: Goals and Objectives Goals To secure land in the district for distribution to eligible developers. Objectives To facilitate the purchase of farms and fields for village expansion. To promote the concept of Community Based Natural Resource Management. To facilitate land Reclamation in the District. To control natural resource harvest like pit sand, river sand and gravel by having pre determined points where they could be harvested. To facilitate home ownership in the district by providing Self Help Housing loans to eligible citizens. To zone areas which are deemed sterile for development to land use that can derive maximum benefit. To prepare layout plans for four villages every year to speed up land allocation. To introduce environmental tax – byelaw to be enforced on all construction projects especially government projects. To protect, conserve and enhance the quality of the environment in the district. To integrate tree planting or landscaping in all government construction or development process. To facilitate housing ownership and delivery in the district. 6.5 To promote the use of human labour instead of machines in site clearing to ensure selective cutting of trees. To build four satellite offices in the district to help fast track the roll out of Rural Housing programme. FRAMEWORK FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT Vision 2016 has emphasized the need to conserve and preserve our environment, the nation’s greatest asset, in our development processes. This is in order that all projects carried out are socially, economically and environmentally sustainable. In trying to reach our communities through programs and projects that will ultimately uplift them from poverty and other socio-economic hardships, the environment is often the victim. This development programs and projects are often implemented with little or no consideration given to our national asset, the environment. To significantly reduce the adverse effect of development on the environment, it is imperative that we integrate environmental issues in our development policies, programs and projects. Below shows a development approach that North East District adopted to try and integrate environmental issues in the development processes in the district. Table 6.3: Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues with Sector Goals and Objectives Goals Secure land in the district for distribution to eligible developers. Facilitate land reclamation in the district Facilitate home ownership in the district by providing SHHA loans to eligible citizens. Protect, conserve and enhance the quality of the environment in the district. Objectives Purchase of farms and fields for village expansion. Control natural resource harvest like river sand, pit sand and gravel. Environmental Key Issues Loss of natural vegetation. Strategy Tree planting. Burrow pits. Soil erosion. Have pre-determined collection points. Prepare layout plans for four villages every year. Indiscriminate cutting of live trees. Introduce environmental tax bye laws. Indiscriminate cutting of trees. Enforcement of tax bye laws. Promote the use of human labour instead of machines in bush clearing. Non selective cutting of trees. Preserve trees spices. Rehabilitate burrow pits. Plant trees. 68 6.6 RESOURCE REQUIREMENTS FOR DDP6 For North East District Plan 6 to realize its goals and objectives, there is need for resources to be available and organized in a sustainable fashion. To have a sustainable plan and ultimately implement it with utmost ease a SWOT analysis has to be performed. This analysis will reveal the strengths, weakness, opportunities and threats within the system of the structures that will help see to implementations of the plan. 6.6.1 6.6.2 Strengths Sound legislation in place that provides a framework within which to operate. Abundant River sand and pit sand means that people can cheaply secure them for building purposes. Issues Shortage of land for allocation. Housing loan repayment period too short taking into consideration that the cost of housing has gone high. Mushrooming of settlements. Cutting of more trees to make way for housing construction. The SHHA department has to establish itself administratively and otherwise during the DDP6 in order to reach more people in North East District by securing more offices in Masunga and building some satellite offices in areas like Tati Siding. About ten more officers are needed to implement the Rural Housing Policy. These officers will form the four units within Self Help Housing Agency, which are Administration, Technical Unit, Accounts and Community Dev. Transport will also be required to make the unit perform its functions effectively. 6.6.3 Plan Monitoring Program Plan monitoring will be done through quarterly progress reports to the District Development Committees, Council Committees and Full Council. These will also be presented to the ministries of Lands and Housing and Local Government. Areas that fall within the Greater Francistown will be monitored by the Francistwon Town Council, Department of Town and regional Planning, Department of Lands and Departrment of Surveys and Mapping through Stateland Allocation Committee. The Department of Wildlife and National Parks, Museum and Art Gallery and that of Tourism will play a significant role in monitoring wildlife, archeological and tourism activities respectively, as there are quite a significant number of their activities in the District. 69 CHAPTER 7 7 AGRICULTURE 7.1 INTRODUCTION Agricultural sector is an important source of food and has a high contribution in rural income, employment and investment opportunities. Hence it is the third largest employer in the District according to the 2001 Population and Housing Census with 1 226 people i.e. 12 %. Subsistence farming is practiced in most parts of the district. The main crops grown are sorghum, millet, groundnuts, beans and watermelons. In the north and Tati Siding arable and pastoral farming are mixed, whereas Makaleng and Matsiloje are the only areas, which have defined lands for arable and grazing areas. Commercial farming is mainly conducted in freehold farms. The main activity carried out is the livestock production and game ranching. Fodder and vegetable production are done in small quantities. Agricultural sector is currently performing poorly in the District because of poor soils, persistent drought and unreliable rainfall pattern. Although free hold farms occupy 41.5% of the districts land, most of them are underutilized or not optimally used. The total number of cattle in the district is estimated at 30 000, 11 700 goats, 1100 sheep, 4100 donkeys and 6 horses, with owners of the livestock mostly aged between forty and eighty years. Livestock grazing is still being practiced in communal land. However, majority of farmers do not own grazing land. Generally there is a problem of shortage of land for both arable and pastoral farming in the district. 7.1.1 Institutional Framework The Ministry of Agriculture is made up of five (5) departments – Animal Health and Production, Crop, Production and Forestry, Agricultural Research, Co-operatives and Ministry Management. However in the North East District the ministry is represented by three departments namely Crop, Production and Forestry, Animal health and Production and Co-operatives while other 7.1.2 Strategic Plan for Ministry of Agriculture The vision of the Ministry of Agriculture is committed to provide dynamic leadership in the development of sustainable, diversified and competitive Agriculture and Conservation of Natural resources to contribute to the achievement of food security, poverty alleviation and socioeconomic growth in partnership with stakeholders. The mission of the Ministry of Agriculture is to formulate and implement innovative policies, programs, and regulatory framework and provide quality service to our customers in order to promote diversified, competitive and sustainable agricultural sector through: Development and transfer of appropriate agricultural technologies. Timely prevention and control of pests and diseases of plants and animals. Development of Cooperatives and farmers associations. Conservation of Agricultural resource. 70 The main policy objectives of the Ministry of Agriculture are: To improve food security and standard of living at both household and national level. To diversify the agricultural production base. To increase output and productivity to ensure competitiveness in the market through maintenance of proper business records. To increase employment creation for the growing labour force in the North East District through encouragement of formation of viable cooperative enterprises. To conserve scarce agricultural and land resources for future generations and formation of cooperative groups. The most appropriate pillar for the agricultural sector is prosperous, productive and innovative society. The agriculture sector’s contribution to the countries revenue has been declining over the past decades. Through its various policies the sector has been trying to bring back the country’s agriculture sector to life. Recent developments such as NAMPAADD encourage farmers to be more productive and practice commercial farming, which seemed to be non-existent in Botswana culture. With the introduction of CEDA more farmers are now willing to purchase land and practice commercial farming which can feed this nation. 7.1.3 Agriculture Consultation Priorities The consultations established the following planning priorities: Shoratge of Water: There is a shortage of water in the District. It was suggested that government should build /construct multi purpose dams in the district for human consumption, watering livestock, small-scale businesses and irrigation purposes. It is also important that communities should be encouraged to make full use of rainwater through water harvesting techniques from rooftops, and by collecting surface runoff. Currently in the district, only institutional houses are provided with tanks for harvesting rainwater while communities do not. Shortage of Land: The district also has a problem of shortage of land as mostly free hold farms surround it; this has a negative impact on the grazing areas and land for cultivation. It also weakens economic status of the communities who rely on agriculture for a living. The new settlement policy also poses a problem on the livestock industry as land that is available would be used more on residential and for ploughing purposes hence grazing land is not given priority. Soil Erosion: The North East District has a problem of soil erosion mainly because of the many rivers that run through the district. This has resulted in the formation of gullies and dongas. As such conservation measures should be put in place to prevent soil erosion in fields. Natural Disasters: The district is also prone to foot and mouth disease outbreaks, which threatens to wipe out the livestock industry in the area. This has become a major problem since most villages are bordered by Zimbabwe where most of the outbreaks are reported. Continuous monitoring of the veterinary fence should be done and repairs/maintenance to the damaged parts should be made immediately if the disease is to be controlled. 71 7.2 NATIONAL POLICIES AND LEGISLATION 7.2.1 National Master Plan for Arable Agriculture and Dairy Development The plan seeks to improve performance of the agricultural sector, by modernizing it through the introduction of improved technologies, efficient use and management of human, land and water resources, mechanization and commercialization of agricultural operations. The plan focuses on rain fed agriculture, irrigated agriculture, dairy farming, infrastructure, post harvest facilities, irrigation water supply, institutional reforms, promoting business opportunities, risk minimization and plan implementation. NAMPAADD is mainly targeted to three critical sub-sectors: Rain fed agriculture Irrigated agriculture Dairy farming Rainfed Agriculture: NAMPAADD has identified first and second priority an area suitable for rainfed agriculture and Tati Agricultural District is among the first priority areas. The minimum size of land that can be farmed viably under mechanized rainfed conditions is 150 hectares. Farmers with less than 150 ha are encouraged to join cultivation groups to form units of 150 ha each. The fields do not necessarily have to be adjacent. Currently in Tati Agricultural District the average field size is 5 ha. As such formation of cultivation groups will require about 30 farmers in a cluster, which practically is not manageable. Irrigated Agriculture: Areas suitable for vegetable production were identified basing on soil suitability, availability of water, production parameters and marketing aspects. Under irrigated agriculture, Tati agricultural district was not identified as a potential area. However, this does not discourage farmers who are interested in venturing in this business. The area of concern is the fact that the Department of Geological Survey has indicated that there is no ground water in Tati agricultural District that can satisfy irrigation projects. It will not be wise to advise farmers to drill boreholes for irrigation purposes. The problem could be addressed through the construction of multi- purpose dams, more so the terrain for dam construction is very good in the District. 7.2.2 Community Based Natural Resource Management (CBNRM) Policy (Draft) CBNRM is a development approach that supports natural resource conservation and its objective is to diversify economic development in rural areas through the sustainable use of natural resources and to increase opportunities for community organization to obtain direct benefits from the use of natural resources. There are no CBNRM projects in the district so far, but mobilization of communities by the department of wildlife and national parks has been done. 7.2.3 Arable Land Development Programme (ALDEP) The second phase of ALDEP commenced in July 1996 after winding up of the first phase in 1993. The second phase objectives focused on the strengthening of extension services and training, technology transfer, and encouraging the previous beneficiaries to efficiently utilize the packages obtained in phase one. 72 ALDEP was a down payment/grant scheme, where eligible farmers were required to make a down payment of 10 % or 15% of the total cost of the package for males and females respectively, and the government paid a balance of 85% and 90% for males and females respectively. Eligible farmers were assisted in obtaining the following packages: animal draught power (either donkeys or cattle), water catchment tank, scotch cart, fencing material, plough, cultivator, harrow, planter, and threshing machine and mini silos in District. This phase was suspended pending review in August 2001. 7.2.4 Tribal Land Act The Tribal Land Act provide for the establishment of the Tribal Land Boards: to vest tribal land in such boards to define the powers and duties of such boards and to provide for matters incidental thereto. Since there is a problem of shortage of land in the district, the land board has resorted to buying ploughing fields from members of the community to augment the shortages. This solves the problem of shortage of land for residential purposes but increases shortage of land for ploughing and grazing hence there is a conflict in allocation of land in the district. 7.2.5 Convention on Combating Desertification The North East District already has a problem of desertification in areas surrounding the railway line and near the Francistown City. This is because wood harvesting is being practiced commercially in these areas resulting in deforestation. However measures such as planting of trees during National Tree Planting Day will be carried out during the plan. Bush fires also result in loss of vegetation; maintenance of firebreaks and construction where they are not available will be carried out during the plan period to control deforestation. 7.3 AGRICULTURAL SECTOR ACTIVITIES Tati Agricultural District consists of eleven agricultural extension areas. Tati Agricultural District services most of the North East District villages whilst other villages are serviced by Tonota Agricultural District; these are Matsiloje, Matopi, Matshelagabedi, Patayamatebele, Ditladi and Shashe Bridge. 7.3.1 Arable Sub Sector The Department of Crop Production and Forestry is one of the major extension arms of the Ministry. It consists of five major divisions – Crop production, Plant Protection, Forestry, Range Ecology and Bee-keeping, Land utilization and Extension. These are supported by the administration support services. In the North East the ministry is represented by the following departments: Crop Production, Forestry, Animal Health and Production, all of which operate from Masunga while the remaining two operate from the Francistown Region. The department of Crop Production and Forestry’s core business is to empower the farming communities through transferring appropriate technologies (innovations) to improve productivity and competitiveness of the arable sub sector and ensure sustainability as well as profitability. 73 In the North East district about 70% of farmers who own land do plough at the start of each ploughing season provided there is adequate rainfall. The main crops grown are sorghum, millet, groundnuts and beans mainly because they are able to withstand periods of drought and high temperatures. Most farmers in the North East cultivate on average 3-5 hectares per household and the average age of those who take part in farming activities ranges from forty to seventy five years. Poor farming methods, poor techniques and inadequate funds are some of the issues, which result in low agricultural production. Arable farming has been declining in the past four years due to the persistent drought that has been affecting the district. More people who have been relying on agriculture for a living are now being employed in the Labour Intensive Programme. However, the department intends to improve performance of the crop sub-sector by pursuing the following strategies during DDP 6: 7.3.2 High quality advisory and technical services to customers. The development of appropriate extension messages. Efficient and effective extension delivery services characterised by regular farm visits, farm demonstrations and farmer training. Cultural practices that promote moisture conservation such as double ploughing, minimum tillage in small holder sub-sector. Introducing drought tolerant and early maturing varieties of crops. Carrying out on-farm demonstrations to enhance adoption of technologies. Intensifying the use of integrated pest management. Horticulture Horticultural development is geared towards diversifying the rural economy and creating employment and income generation opportunities. The sector has not been performing well due to shortages of water. Farmers should be encouraged to practice water-harvesting techniques to augment shortages of water that are prevalent in the district. A market does exist in the district however if the supply exceeds demand farmers can always sell their produce to customers in Francistown and other districts bordering the North East. Farmers are being encouraged to start small-scale vegetable production by applying for funds through CEDA. The department will focus on the following in order to strengthen the sector: 7.3.3 Development of a marketing information network and collection of production baseline data. Establishment of demonstration plots. Mobilisation and strengthening of existing horticultural/marketing associations. Improvement of horticultural productivity through targeting 5 farmers per year. Livestock Sub Sector The department of Animal Health and Production’s objective is to improve livestock extension, control trans – boundary diseases, improve programme delivery in order to satisfy stakeholder as well as promote diversification. This is achieved through projects such as Improvements to Disease Control, Animal Disease Emergency Control, SLOCA, Dairy Improvement, Livestock Marketing Facilities, Livestock Water Development, Artificial Insemination Services, Fisheries 74 Development, Ostrich Demonstration and Training Farm, Poultry Development, Improvements to National Veterinary Laboratory and Improvements to Livestock Advisory Centers. The North East district is prone to outbreaks of Foot and Mouth disease due to its proximity to Zimbabwe where most outbreaks originate. The department of Animal Health and Production will continue to monitor the outbreaks and maintain the cordon fence that has been constructed to curb cross border infections. Since the district has shortage of land for livestock farming purposes, acquiring farms surrounding or near tribal land should be greatly emphasized if NAMPAADD is to be implemented in the district. Already the Department of Lands is negotiating with government to buy four farms, which could be used for farming purposes if approved. The department is also being faced with the problem of shortage of water for livestock, rehabilitating the existing structures for watering livestock would solve this problem and constructing dams where feasible. The Livestock Identity and Trace –Back System( LITS) programme will be implemented in the District during the plan period. Cooperatives sub-sector The department of co-operative development is responsible for the registration of co-operative societies and ensuring compliance with the co-operative societies act, encouraging formation of co-operative societies, assisting in efficient operation of co-operative societies through business advice and provision of human resource development programmes to the co-operative movement. It is divided into primary and secondary societies. Primary societies includes thrift & loan societies which provide savings and credit facilities to members, consumers co-operatives, marketing and multipurpose societies which market livestock and farm produce, and sell consumer goods and farm inputs to members and a small number of producer co-operatives. Co-operatives create employment for the rural people in their areas of operation. The co-operative groups that operate in the North East district are, Kuzwibatila poultry, Laedza piggery, Tshwaraganang poultry, Ntimbale ranch and Bonatla small stock. 7.4 AGRICULTURE SECTOR GOALS AND OBJECTIVES Table 7.1: Agricultural Sector Goals and Objectives Goals To improve livestock production in the district through effective disease control and prevention measures. Objectives Increase vaccination coverage of livestock diseases to 95% by march 2007. Revive of livestock farmers committees in five extensions areas by march 2008. Construction of four loading ramps by march 2004. To facilitate dissemination of available information to North East farming communities and stakeholders through extension agents. To sensitize staff on HIV/AIDS awareness campaigns through organized counseling, issuing of condoms and formation of subCommittees in respective work places. Distribute 50kg fodder seeds to five farmers per extension area by march 2008. Conduct six workshops annually Create HIV/AIDS awareness in three veterinary camps by march 2004 75 Goals Objectives Rehabilitate two dams in Tati district by march 2005. Constructed three dams in Tati district by march 2008. Provision of assistance for both livestock and arable farmers by providing physical infrastructure. Drilling and equipping of boreholes by 2008/09. Construct 3 dams in Tati district by march 2008. Construct one staff house in Tati district by march 2008. Construct two ALDEP type houses by 2006/07 Electrification of one house by 2003/04. Ensure a continuous flow of goods and services from natural resources without damaging their capacity to recover through sustainable utilization. 7.5 Rehabilitation and reclamation of graded land in five strategic areas by 2008/09. FRAMEWORK FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT Table 7.2: Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues with Sector Goals and Objectives Goals To improve livestock production in the district through effective disease control and prevention measures. Objectives Revive of livestock farmers committees in five extensions areas by march 2008. Construction of four loading ramps by march 2004. Environmental Issues Clearing of bushes. Strategies Replanting of trees. Excavation of rocks. Rehabilitation of burrow pits and affected sites. Littering. Provision of refuse bags. Distribute 50kg fodder seeds to five farmers per extension area by march 2008. Soil erosion. Provision of septic tanks. Land degradation. Create HIV/AIDS awareness in three veterinary camps by march 2004. Provision of assistance for both livestock and arable farmers by providing physical infrastructure. Rehabilitate two dams in Tati district by march 2005. Construct three dams in Tati district by march 2008. Clearing of bushes. Replanting of trees. Excavation of rocks. Rehabilitation of burrow pits and affected sites. Littering. Provision of refuse bags. Drilling and equipping of boreholes by 2008/09. Soil erosion. Provision of septic tanks. Land degradation. Construct 3 dams in Tati district by march 2008. Ensure a continuous flow of goods and services from natural resources without damaging their capacity to recover through sustainable utilization. Construct one staff house in Tati district by march 2008. Construct two ALDEP type houses by 2006/07 Clearing of bushes. Replanting of trees. Excavation of rocks. Rehabilitation of burrow pits and affected sites. Electrification of one house by 2003/04. Littering. Rehabilitation and reclamation of graded land in five strategic areas by 2008/09. Provision of refuse bags. Soil erosion. Provision of septic tanks. Land degradation. 76 Table 7.3: Evaluation of Sector Policies and Programs Policies and Programs Goals/Objectives To reform small-scale farming by introducing modern agricultural and commercially oriented practices. Environmental Issues Over grazing Land Degradation National Master Plan For Arable Agriculture and Dairy Development. Littering To diversify economic development in rural areas through sustainable use of natural resources Soil Erosion Over grazing Land Degradation Community Based Natural Resource Management Littering Soil Erosion Over grazing Land Degradation Tribal Land Act Littering Soil Erosion Over grazing To facilitate technology transfer, strengthening training and extension services. Arable Land Development Program Land Degradation Littering Soil Erosion 7.6 STRATEGIES TO ACHIEVE THE AGRICULTURAL SECTOR GOALS AND OBJECTIVES Table 7.4: Agricultural Sector Strategies Projects Loading Ramps Drilling and equipping of bore-holes Computerization House Electrification Construction of houses Construction of dams Rehabilitation and reclamation of degraded land Potential Impact Cutting of trees, Land degradation, Littering, Soil Erosion Cutting of trees, Land degradation, Littering, Soil Erosion Nil Action Planting of trees, Land rehabilitation, Provision of waste disposal bins Planting of trees, Land rehabilitation, Provision of waste disposal bins Nil Nil Cutting of trees, Littering Cutting of trees, Land degradation, Littering, Soil Erosion Cutting of trees, Land degradation, Littering, Soil Erosion Nil Planting of trees, Provision of waste disposal bins Planting of trees, Land rehabilitation Provision of waste disposal bins Planting of trees, Land rehabilitation, Provision of waste disposal bins 7.7 RESOURCES REQUIREMENT FOR DDP6 7.7.1 Issues and Strengths 7.7.1.1 Strengths Trained personnel and farmers. Availability of funds (donor funding). Availability of training facilities. Access to research findings. 77 Introduction of new government reforms and programs. Technical support. 7.7.1.2 Issues 7.7.2 High ratio of farmers in relation to available personnel. Poor communication. Untargeted farmer training, which is not district specific. Misplacement of staff. Inadequate staff accommodation. Recurrence of drought. Desertification. Frequent Foot and Mouth disease outbreaks. Brain Drain. Shortage of transport. Shortage of land and water. Development Budget Table 7.5: Development Budget Project Project Description Location Estimated Cost AG 101 - Livestock Marketing Facilities AG 102 - Livestock Water Development AG 103 - Ministry Of Agriculture Computerisation Loading Ramps Drilling and equipping of bore-holes Computerisation of the following offices (Department of Animal Health and Production, Department of Crop Production and Forestry and Cooperatives) North East North east Masunga P 372 000.00 P 1 700 000.00 North East P 3 150 048.00 Makaleng P 166 000.00 North East P 2 890 000.00 AG 206 - SLOCA AG 216 - Improvements to Disease Control AG 301 - Arable Lands Development Programme AG 302 - Irrigation and Water Development AG 315 - Development of Extension Services AG 354 - Horticultural Development AG 358 - Soil Conservation House Electrification Construction of dams Rehabilitation degraded land and reclamation of Nlaphkwane Pole Masingwaneng A/ds Shashe A/ds Tsamaya North east Matshelagabedi Mapoka Masingwaneng Jackalas1 Shashe Bridge P 440 476.00 Implementation Year 2003/04 2006/07 P 112 500 P 1 129 800 78 7.7.3 Performance Targets Table 7.6: Performance Indicators Objectives Revive livestock farmers committees in five extensions areas by march 2008. Construction of four loading ramps by march 2004. Distribute 50kg fodder seeds to five farmers per extension area by march 2008. Create HIV/AIDS awareness in three veterinary camps by march 2004. Rehabilitate two dams in Tati district by march 2005. Indicators Livestock Farmers Committee revived in five extension areas by March 2008. Four loading ramps constructed by March 2004. 50 kg fodder seeds distributed to five farmers per extension area by March 2008. HIV/AIDS awareness created in three veterinary camps by March 2004. Two dams in Tati District rehabilitated by March 2005. Constructed three dams in Tati district by March 2008. Drilling and equipping of boreholes by 2008/09. Construct one staff house in Tati district by march 2008. Construct two ALDEP type houses by 2006/07 Electrification of one house by 2003/04. Rehabilitation and reclamation of graded land in five strategic areas by 2008/09. Three dams constructed in Tati District by March 2008. Boreholes drilled and equipped by 2008/09. One staff house constructed in Tati District by March 2008. Two ALDEP type houses constructed by 2006/07. One house electrified by 2003/04. Graded land rehabilitated and reclaimed in five strategic areas by 2008/09. 7.7.4 Plan Monitoring Program Plan monitoring in the form of monthly, quarterly and annual reports will be provided during the course of the plan period to effectively assess performance of the agriculture sector. Reports to District Drought Relief committee, District Extension Team and District Development Committee would be made quarterly to monitor progress of projects to be implemented. 79 CHAPTER 8 8 TRADE INDUSTRY WILDLIFE AND TOURISM 8.1 INTRODUCTION The Trade, Wildlife and Tourism Sector in the North East plays an insignificant role in the economy of the district. The trade sector has created employment for at least 1020 people in the district in accordance with the 2001 population census. There are generally limited employment opportunities due to low formal and informal sector employment. Manufacturing sector in the district is very small given the District’s proximity to Francistown, which is a more attractive location. The North East has potential for nature- culture based tourism, which has not yet been fully exploited for the benefit of local communities. In an effort to ensure that revenues accrued from tourism are spread throughout the country, the eco-tourism strategy was initiated. The strategy also aims at diversifying the tourism product. The integral part of the programme is the inventory of historical sites and heritage attractions. However through the Government policies and programs such as CEDA and CBNRM programme, where communities are expected to utilize these financial programs to diversify the economy, which is overly reliant on agriculture. The vision 2016 pillar of a Prosperous, Productive and Innovative Nation has most relevance to the mandate of the Ministry of Trade, Industry, Wildlife and Tourism. This extensively covers sustainable growth and diversification under which the issues of productivity, stakeholder partnership, citizen empowerment, use of Local Resources, Global Competitiveness, Industrialization, Science And Technology, Manufacturing, trade, small scale business, tourism and wildlife management fall. Vision 2016 advocates for the development of a diversified economy in various sectors including mining, agriculture, manufacturing, services and tourism. In response to this challenge, the Ministry has, through its strategic plan, committed itself to providing an environment conducive for sustainable diversification of the economy. 8.1.1 Institutional Framework In the North East, the Ministry of Trade, Industry, Wildlife and Tourism is represented by the departments of Integrated Field Services that operates from the District Headquarters in Masunga, Wildlife and National Parks, and Tourism, which operate from Francistown. 8.1.2 Strategic Plan for Ministry Trade and Industry The vision of the Ministry of Trade, Industry, Wildlife and Tourism will have enabled Botswana to be a vibrant, self-sustaining and diversified economy, ranked among the best in the world and, made it a destination of preferred choice for investors and tourists by 2016. 80 The mission statement of the Ministry of Trade, Industry, Wildlife and Tourism will be to create an environment conducive for business, protect consumer rights, and manage wildlife resources to meet local and global challenges. It will be regarded as a proactive, dynamic and results- driven organization facilitating economic prosperity for Batswana. The Ministry subscribes to the following set of values, which are the foundation of its culture: Integrity, effective communication, professionalism, motivated employees, productivity, team work and innovation/creativity. 8.1.3 Role of the Private Sector The private sector and NGOs are important stakeholders in the wildlife tourism industry. They have shown a tangible interest in improving communities as well as the department of Wildlife and National Parks and Tourism. The private sector provides technical expertise (through research for example) and compliments some government development projects through capacity building and funding. The private sector plays a much bigger role in commercial activities in the district, there are currently 94 general dealers, 16 fresh produces, 9 supermarkets, 27 liquor restaurants, 68 bars, 11 specialized dealers, 15 salons, 3 filling stations, 5 garage workshops and 1 pharmacy. These projects altogether have created employment for 1020 people in the North East. Some companies undertake joint venture partnership with communities from which communities learn the business aspect of the wildlife industry. NGOs on the other hand mobilize, train and empower extension workers and communities to develop and initiate successful CBNRM projects. The private sector is consulted by the Government through various bodies on governmental policies, regulations, programs and legislative issues. Environmental Heritage Foundation has taken up initiatives to help communities of Jackals 1 and Ramokgwebana to set up projects involving land reclamation and botanical garden. It has also helped communities of Tati Siding with funds to register a trust, which will oversee community environmental initiatives. 8.1.4 Consultation Priorities Lack of inventory of potential tourism sites: A number of sites exist throughout the North East District, but the majority of them are totally undeveloped in terms of accessibility and visitor oriented presentation. An inventory of these sites will be developed and an assessment in terms of their potential use for tourism purposes will be carried out. Shortage of land/conflicting landuses: Since there exists a problem of shortage of land in the district, the outcome of the consultations was that, this problem limits to some extent the type of projects requested to small, micro and medium projects excluding completely large-scale projects [horticulture, dairy farming, and poultry], which could be enhancing the commercial sector in the district. Insufficient financial assistance grants: Communities would like to see the Financial Assistance Policy grant increased so that they can be able to undertake large-scale projects but since FAP has been replaced by CEDA, it should be noted that their concerns have been answered. One of the 81 issues that potential beneficiaries of CEDA have raised is the cumbersome nature of the application forms and these needs to be addressed during the DDP6 period. 8.2 NATIONAL POLICIES AND LEGISLATION 8.2.1 Game Ranching Policy (2002) The policy is aimed at increasing economic returns from wildlife resources outside protected areas. It also promotes the use of game ranches in the conservation of threatened and endangered species. Game ranching in the North East is still at an infancy stage with eight licenses issued but only two game ranch operating in Matsiloje at the moment and four ostrich farms, this is the case currently in the country at large. 8.2.2 Ostrich Management Policy (1994) The policy aims to preserve the ostrich population and promote their conservation through sustainable utilization. Ostriches are a viable resource and it is the intention of the government to exploit this resource for the development of the nation. The department of Wildlife and National Parks intends to start educational campaigns to mobilize people to start taking into consideration ostrich farming as an essential business in diversifying the economy during implementation of District Development Plan 6. 8.2.3 Community Based Natural Resource Management (CBRNM) Policy (Draft) CBNRM is an approach that links conservation with development and the ministry has been involved with CBNRM projects for communities since 1989 by offering technical and capacity building support. There are now over 20 Community Based Organizations (CBO’s) throughout the country that utilizes wildlife and veld products. The Community Conservation Fund (CCF) was established to fund CBNRM projects. The district has not yet benefited from this fund, as there are no CBNRM projects formed yet but mobilization is on going. A workshop was held for the district’s leadership (councilors, chiefs and VDC representatives) to sensitize them on CBNRM program. 8.2.4 Botswana Tourism Master Plan (2000) The Botswana Tourism Master plan was finalized in May 2002 and it serves as a basic guideline for the development of tourism, enabling decision makers to agree on the principles for the direction for the next decade. The Plan forms the end of an opinion-building phase but more especially it should be regarded as the starting point of an implementation process. It will also ensure that tourism plays a leading role in the economic growth of the country. Some of the recommendations are currently being implemented and these include an awareness campaign through a local drama group, the design of a grading system and the formulation of a National Eco-tourism Strategy (NES), whose final draft has been drawn. Other issues that still need to be done include the establishment of a national tourist board, strengthening of the private sector through HATAB which is the umbrella organization, zoning of land to address land issues and the promotion of domestic tourism. The plan will ensure that tourism plays a leading role in the economic growth of the country. 82 8.2.5 Tourism Policy (1990) The government’s position on tourism in contained in the Tourism Policy, Government Paper No. 2 of 1990. This policy was born out of the realization that; the industry has not been given due prominence in the past: the potential of the industry is growing at a rapid rate, so much that it is regarded as possible generator of economic activity in many parts of the economy and the country; Batswana were not likely to benefit from the realization of the potential unless a new framework of policy is put in place. The overall objective of the tourism policy is to obtain on a sustainable basis, the greatest possible net social and economic benefits for Batswana from their tourism resources, scenic beauty, wildlife and unique ecological, geological and cultural characteristics. The policy seeks to shift the mix of tourists away from those who are casual campers towards those who occupy permanent accommodation. Encouraging the latter while discouraging the former, through target marketing and the imposition of higher fees for the use of public facilities. The policy also introduced a number of additional programmes like the reorganization of the system of concessions, rents and taxation and the introduction of a system of licensing and regulation for accommodation establishments. A system of grading for these enterprises will also be introduced. 8.2.6 Citizen Entrepreneurial Development Agency (CEDA) 2001 As a reformation and consolidation of FAP and the SMME schemes, the government established the CEDA, where potential investors are assisted through highly subsidized loans, training, monitoring and mentoring, as well as provision for venture capital fund. This was another government’s effort to deal with the real constraints affecting the development of citizens businesses and citizen participation in the economy. The venture capital fund is available to both citizens and foreigners whereas the financial assistance policy is in the form of loans at subsidized rates are available to citizens. The Department of Tourism will continue to encourage Batswana to invest in the tourism industry through CEDA. However, in the next development plan there is need to review CEDA in order to determine if it is achieving its primary objectives. At the moment CEDA is administered only in Gaborone, there is need to decentralise its activities to the districts as potential clients travel several kilometres to get the service. 8.3 TRADE AND INDUSTRY 8.3.1 Industrial and commercial Development The industrial and commercial sector does not perform satisfactory in the entire District despite the fact that villages of Masunga, Tshesebe and Tati Siding have fully planned and developed industrial and commercial sites. There are few entrepreneurs in the private sector who have opened some commercial activities such as bakeries, grain milling, and motor garages. According to the Tati Land Board report of 2002, 347 plots for industrial activities were made available throughout the District. Most of the activities, which take place in these plots, are more service oriented e.g. garages/workshops, supplies, warehouses and poultry farming. The Ministry of Trade, Industry, Wildlife and Tourism offer some investment incentives in the form of loans through CEDA. The industrial and commercial sector in the District is not doing 83 well due to lack of markets, poor management and lack of entrepreneurial skills, shortage serviced land and poor infrastructure such as roads and electricity. During DDP 6 the District will consider building stalls in strategic areas to assist small businesses. Communication links will be improved as well and electricity provided in eleven villages. The Tati Land Board will also facilitate acquisition of serviced industrial and commercial plots with less delay. 8.3.2 Wildlife and National Parks The Department of Wildlife and National Park’s aim is to take the management of wildlife to the people to ensure their appreciation, participation and benefit from natural resources. This entails involvement of communities and Non-Governmental Organization (NGO’s) in the utilization and Conservation of environmental assets. Through this, communities will realize the economic value of wildlife, and nature based tourism that forms an important growth Industry. The North East Region is not rich in wildlife resources but there is no doubt that the area has several historical/cultural and archaeological sites which offer a good potential for tourism. These include the Domboshaba Ruins, Kalakamati Rock Paintings and many more. In order to exploit these resources, and develop and promote tourism in this region, the Department of Tourism has established an office in Francistown. The office serves Francistown and the North East District and also shares Tutume Sub District with the Selibe-Phikwe office. Community education/mobilization will be done in conjunction with the Wildlife Department, which administers the Community Conservation Fund (CCF) so that information on tourism related projects could be provided to the communities. 8.3.3 Tourism Tourism is not well developed in the district. But there are quite a number of sites, which have been developed for tourism related activities as indicated in table 8.1. There is a problem of destruction of the historical sites; some artifacts are reported missing or stolen. There is also inadequate information on location of some historical sites and areas of scenic beauty. The strategy during DDP 6 would be to sensitize the community on the importance of the historical sites. The District will also explore the possibility to identify scenic beauty and market them. 84 Table 8.1: North East Historical Sites Site Name Vukwi Ruins Domboshaba Ruins Nlapkhwane Rock Paintings Tati Training Institute Mambindi ruins Mowana Magic Tree Rock Paintings Description of Sites The site includes large alluvial traces near the village of Vukwi. The site is good for camping and also as a picnic sport. The Vukwi river scenic at this site with big boulders and pools of water usually remains even after the rest of the river. The site is located on the western side of Masunga village, about 6.5 km from Kalakamati. The most interesting features on the site are stonewalls and the ancient mud floors that are associated with the popular Zimbabwe ruins. There are indicators that this place is being vandalized as some artifacts were reported to be missing. The site is located on the northern side of Nlapkhwane village on the Botswana- Zimbabwe border. Although very little is known about the site the rock paintings depicting wild animals are attractive. It is believed that the area is an extension of Matopo area in Zimbabwe. The Institute is believed to be the first in the District and the country. The ruins are located on the eastern side of the Tati river around Mulambakwena village. These are ruins found at Jackalas I. Found at the Themashanga turn-off. Tourist as well as locals put money under the tree with the belief that they are offering to ancestors. These are found near Themashanga and Mapoka village Source: North East Settlement Strategy – Draft Final, 2000 8.4 SECTOR GOALS AND OBJECTIVES Table 8.2: Trade and Industry Sector Goals and Objectives Goal To promote and facilitate sustainable utilization and conservation of wildlife resources through active participation of communities. To minimize human- wildlife conflict by ensuring that Batswana appreciate and benefit from their environmental assets. To facilitate the development of viable projects by encouraging entrepreneurs to conduct feasibility study for every new project. Objective To develop an inventory of historical sites in the district. To mobilize and train communities in the North East District that has potential resources in establishing Community Based Organization by 2004. To have viable projects in 60% of the Schools with environmental clubs in the district by 2005 To have reduced the killing of problem animal by 10% per annum by year 2006. To have reduced the length of time taken to attend to problem animal reports to five days by 2004. To have trained all communities that experience problems from large animals to undertake problem animal control by 2003 To conduct at least three start Your Business Course for the entrepreneurs in the NE District by 2003. To conduct at least four Training Needs Analysis Course in the North East District by the year 2003. To foster Citizen Entrepreneurial Development Agency (CEDA) To facilitate two workshops where entrepreneurs in the North East will be briefed about CEDA and its requirements by the year 2003. 85 8.5 FRAMEWORK FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT 8.5.1 Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues with Sectoral Goals and Objectives Table 8.3: Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues with Sectoral Goals and Objectives Goal Objective To develop an inventory of historical sites in the district. To promote and facilitate sustainable utilization and conservation of wildlife resources through active participation of communities. To mobilize and train communities in the North East District that has potential resources in establishing Community Based Organization by 2004. To have viable projects in 60% of the Schools with environmental clubs in the district by 2005 To have reduced the killing of problem animals by 10% per annum by year 2006. To minimize human- wildlife conflict by ensuring that Batswana appreciate and benefit from their environmental assets. To have reduced the length of time taken to attend to problem animal reports to five days by 2004 Environmental Issues Clearing of bushes Strategies Littering Provision of refuse bags. Overgrazing Keeping low stocking rates. Soil erosion Rehabilitation of affected land. Clearing of bushes Replanting trees. Littering Provision of refuse bags. Overgrazing Keeping low stocking rates. Soil erosion Rehabilitation of affected land. Littering Provision of refuse bag Littering Provision of refuse bags To have trained all communities that experience problems from large animals to undertake problem animal control by 2003 To facilitate the development of viable projects by encouraging entrepreneurs to conduct Feasibility study for every new project. To foster Citizen Entrepreneurial Development Agency (CEDA). 8.5.2 To conduct at least four Training Needs Analysis Course in the North East District by the year 2003. To facilitate two workshops where entrepreneurs in the North East will be briefed about CEDA and its requirements by the year 2003. Evaluation of Sector Policies and Programs Table 8.4: Evaluation of Sector Policies and Programs Policies and Programmes Goals/Obectives To promote the use of game ranches in the conservation of threatened and endangered species and to increase economic returns from wildlife resources. To preserve the ostrich population and promote their conservation through sustainable utilization. Game Ranching Policy Ostrich Management Policy Community Based Management Natural Resource Botswana Tourism Master Plan Tourism Policy Citizen Agency To conduct at least three start Your Business Course for the entrepreneurs in the NE District by 2003. Replanting trees. Entrepreneurial Development To obtain on a sustainable basis, net social benefits for Batswana from their tourism resources, scenic beauty, wildlife and unique ecological, geological and cultural characteristics. To assist potential investors in setting up or expanding businesses in areas of manufacturing, agriculture, mineral processing and linking services. To assist potential investors in setting up or expanding businesses in areas of manufacturing, agriculture, mineral processing and linking services. To assist potential investors in setting up or expanding businesses in areas of manufacturing, agriculture, mineral processing and linking services. Environmental Issues Land degradation Overgrazing Land degradation Overgrazing Land degradation Overgrazing Land degradation Overgrazing Land degradation Overgrazing Land degradation Overgrazing 86 8.6 STRATEGIES TO ACHIEVE GOALS AND OBJECTIVES Table 8.5: Trade and Industry Strategies Project Start your business course Bookkeeping Course Start up Wildlife utilization projects (Guinea fowl, ostrich farms and game ranches) Facilitate formation of Community Based Natural Resource Management organizations. Potential Impacts Littering Soil degradation and erosion. Change of land use Cutting of trees Littering Mitigation Measures Provision of plastic bags and waste bins including proper disposal of the waste. Selective cutting of trees Proper waste disposal measures would be used (provision of waste bins). 8.7 RESOURCE REQUIREMENTS FOR DDP6 8.7.1 Issues and Strengths for Trade, Industry, tourism and wildlife 8.7.1.1 Strengths Availability Trained personnel. Availability of funds. Availability of training facilities. Availability of transport. 8.7.1.2 Issues Shortage of office accommodation. Misplacement of staff. Table 8.7: Plan Monitoring Programme Goal/Objective To mobilize and train communities in the North East District that has potential resources in establishing Community Based Organizations by 2004. To increase participation of Batswana in the wildlife sector with the view to realize its economic value by the end of the plan period. Strategy Facilitate formation of Community Based Organizations in Gambule, Matsiloje and Nlaphkwane Start up wildlife utilization projects i.e. Guinea fowl farms, Ostrich farming and game ranching. Target End of 2006. Monitoring Presenting monthly and quarterly reports to District Extension Team and District Development Committee. End of 2009 Presenting monthly and quarterly reports to District Extension Team and District Development Committee. To facilitate the development of viable projects by encouraging entrepreneurs to attend courses offered by IFS Start your business course (10) End of 2009 Presenting monthly and quarterly reports to Production Development Committee and District Development committee. Basic Book keeping course (20) (P 60 000) 87 CHAPTER 9 9 EDUCATION AND TRAINNING 9.1 INTRODUCTION Vision 2016 envisages that Botswana will be an educated and informed nation by its 50th year of independence. In line with this, the Ministry of Education through other ministries like Ministry of Local Government will provide quality education and training that is accessible to learners of all age groups to enable individuals to attain their potential and contribute to the national socioeconomic and technical advancement. In providing quality education and training, the ministry will provide an enabling environment or learning through efficient and effective management of the national education and training system. 9.1.1 Institutional Framework To carry out its mandate at national level, the Ministry of Education consists of nine departments namely, Primary Education, Secondary Education, Teachers Training and Development, Curriculum Development and Evaluation, Non Formal Education, Student Placement and Welfare, Teaching Service Management, Vocational Education and Training and Examination Research Division. Out of the nine departments, only two of have offices in Masunga and they are Nonformal and Primary Education whilst Secondary Education operates from Francistown. There are no special schools/centres within the district for people with disabilities. Screened children with disabilities are therefore sent to appropriate schools/centres in areas where they are located. During this plan period special education units will be constructed in new schools planned for at Tatisiding and Patayamatebele. At District level Primary Education is the joint responsibility of two departments, that of Primary Education in the District Council and of Primary Education in the Ministry of Education. The two departments work hand in hand in managing Primary Education within the District 9.1.1.1 Department of Primary Education – Council The Department is responsible for: Provision of infrastructure, stationery and equipment to primary schools. Provision of the auxiliary staff in Primary schools. Transportation of pupils and Teachers during educational tours and sporting activities. Administration of Primary School feeding program. 9.1.1.2 Department of Primary Education – Ministry of Education Provision of curriculum materials to schools. Giving professional advice to both Council and schools. Inspecting schools and advising the authorities on conditions prevalent in schools through written reports. Administration of teacher’s welfare. 88 Although provision of primary school facilities and materials is the domain of the two departments, the private sector like contractors, publishers, and business community are partners in the development of primary education through building of school infrastructure and provision of books and stationery to support curriculum delivery. 9.1.2 Strategic Plan for Respective Ministries 9.1.2.1 Ministry Of Education The mandate of the ministry is to provide quality education and training that is accessible to learners of all age groups and to create opportunities for life-long learning to enable individuals to attain their full potential and contribute to the national socio-economic and technological advancement. To achieve its mandate, the ministry has set itself key results areas viz: A high level of HIV/AIDS awareness. A competent national human resource. Quality and relevant education and training. Open access to and equity in life-long education. An enabling learning environment. 9.1.2.2 Ministry Of Local Government The mandate of the Ministry of Local Government (in relation to Local Authorities) is to provide basic physical and social infrastructure (e.g. water provision, primary school and clinics construction) to the community. The other core business as stipulated in the ministry strategic plan is that of ensuring efficient operation of local authorities through policy direction, capacity building, and supervision. To achieve its mandate, the ministry has set itself key results areas viz: 9.1.3 Customer satisfaction. Policy implementation effectiveness. Improved quality of life of communities. Productivity and organizational effectiveness. Role of the Private Sector There are no privately owned primary and secondary schools in the district except for Day Care Centres. There are three privately owned day care centres in the district, which are at Tatisiding, Masunga and Senyawe village. Day care centres in the district play the role of furnishing young children below school going age, with a place for developing wholly i.e. the children have a chance to develop their mental abilities or cognitively, spiritually, socially, physically and otherwise. The children acquire love for learning and gain exposure to the learning environment. Therefore when children graduate from the centre, they have confidence to sit in class, speak openly and freely and they are freer at primary schools than children who have not been to day care centres. 89 9.1.4 Education Consultation Priorities Most communities have seen the importance of education especially to their children. They suggested more additional schools especially vocational centres and education centres in the district. 9.2 NATIONAL POLICIES AND LEGISLATION The National Policy on Education aspires for the provision of quality, equity and access to basic education, which are considered a fundamental human right. The education system therefore aims at developing moral and social values, cultural identity and self-esteem, good citizenship and desirable work ethics. The District Development Plan is therefore designed to address the policy needs, which the Revised National Policy on Education (RNPE) and the vision 2016 aspire for. However, the RNPE may be constrained by the implementation capacity to undertake the projects by council. These implementation constraints are mainly in terms of inadequate manpower and financial resources. 9.3 EDUCATION 9.3.1 Schools 9.3.1.1 Pre-School Education Although the RNPE recognizes pre-school education as an important integral component of the education system, it is still not well established. There is therefore need for clear guidelines from the Ministry of Education on how it is going to be incorporated within the education system and that of structure. Issues that need to be revolved relate to development of syllabus. However, there are 21-day care centres in the whole district. As alluded to above, these do not have a syllabus to follow. Out of the 21-day care centres 1 is run by council, 3 are privately owned, and 17 are run by communities through VDCs. The table below contains the details; Table 9.1: Name of Village 1. Tatisiding 2. Tatisiding 3.Shashe Bridge 4. Masunga 5. Senyawe 6. Masunga 7.Themashanga 8. Siviya 9. Matsiloje 10.Masukwane 11. Tsamaya 12. Jackalas I 13.Zwenshambe 14. Sekakangwe 15. Kalakamati 16. Gulubane 17. Sechele 18. Mambo 19. Makaleng 20. Matenge 21. Mapoka Day Care Centres in the District Name of Centre Itsoseng Day Care Disneyland Shashe Day Care Boswa jwa Ngwana Pretty Angel Masunga Day Care Themashanga Day Care Siviya Day Care Matsiloje Day Care Masukwane Day Care Tsamaya Day Care Jackalas I Day Care Zwenshambe Day Care Sekakangwe Day Care Kalakamati Day Care Gulubane Day Care Sechele Day Care Mambo Day Care Makaleng Day Care Matenge Day Care Mapoka Day Care Ownership Community Based Private Community Based Private Private Council Community Based Community Based Community Based Community Based Community Based Community Based Community Based Community Based Community Based Community Based Community Based Community Based Community Based Community Based Community Based Remarks Operating Operating Operating Operating Operating Operating Operating Operating Operating Operating Operating Operating Operating Operating Operating Operating Operating Operating Operating Operating Operating Source: Social and Community Development, 2003 90 9.3.1.2 Primary Education The North East District has 41 schools with an enrolment of twelve thousand and sixty two (12,062) pupils and an establishment of five hundred and six teachers (506). Due to the growth of the enrolment, three new schools have been included in the DDP6 Plan period. Refer to item 16.7. Table 9.2: Primary Education Enrollment SCHOOL Makaleng Mambo Gulubane Masingwaneng Matopi Matshelagabedi Matsiloje Mapoka Moroka Jackalas No 1 Ramokgwebana Kgari Masukwane Pole Butale Mbalambi Sekakangwe Nlapkhwane Mulambakwena Zwenshambe Letsholathebe Masunga Mosojane Vukwi Ditladi Pelotelele Tatisiding Siviya Jackalas No 2 Themashanga Tsamaya Mowana Tshesebe Senyawe Mabudzane Gungwe Kalakamati Matenge Sechele Gambule Botalaote/Toteng Total Classes Enrollment Teachers 12 7 11 7 6 20 15 15 21 14 14 8 11 6 8 12 88 19 11 15 8 19 10 6 12 8 22 14 14 19 17 6 13 17 6 7 8 7 7 7 7 554 282 131 322 161 108 679 377 389 501 276 315 168 171 101 156 315 233 524 309 422 164 677 222 77 322 224 924 360 332 517 483 120 322 427 114 105 216 109 124 141 142 12062 13 7 12 8 7 22 16 16 18 15 14 9 10 7 9 13 8 20 13 17 8 23 12 7 13 10 23 15 15 20 17 7 14 18 7 7 8 7 7 7 7 506 EXISTING FACILITIES C/Rooms T/Q 12 7 11 7 7 21 15 18 21 13 14 8 11 8 10 11 8 20 13 15 8 21 13 6 13 11 24 14 14 19 17 8 13 18 8 6 10 7 8 7 8 503 11 7 8 7 7 17 10 11 14 10 7 6 8 5 6 7 5 11 16 8 6 14 2 7 9 9 16 6 14 15 8 5 11 13 5 6 6 6 4 7 7 357 BACKLOG 1X2 C/Rooms 1X2 W/C T/Q 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 2 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 7 0 0 0 0 0 2 0 1 1 1 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 1 1 1 0 2 0 0 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 0 1 0 0 21 1 1 4 1 5 6 5 4 5 5 3 2 1 3 6 1 9 0 8 2 9 4 1 7 7 1 5 7 2 1 5 2 1 2 1 3 130 Source: North East District Council, 2003 9.3.1.3 Secondary Education The District has 8 Junior Secondary Schools and 1 Senior Secondary School with an enrolment of 3716 and 1270 respectively. The total establishment for both the Senior and Junior Secondary Schools is 76 and 220 respectively. 91 9.3.1.4 Private Schools There are no Primary, Secondary and Tertiary private schools in the district except for three-Day Care Centres, which are in Tatisiding, Masunga and Senyawe. 9.3.1.5 Non-Formal Education In its attempt to impart the Revised National Policy on Education in establishing a learning oriented society the department targeted 1 200 adult literacy learners every financial year. The 2001 population and housing census report shows that adult literacy in the district is 67.3%. Below is a table to reflect this: Table 9.3: Enrollment of Non-Formal Learners Year Total No. Of Learners M F 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 993 1190 1014 684 835 319 328 328 228 268 674 862 686 456 567 Source: North East Non-formal District Annual Report, 2001 The decreases in learners’ figures are attributed to a number of factors such as the floods disasters: Adult learners were engaged in re-building their houses. The absence of Literacy Group Leaders as the programme is unable to attract and keep such people in the programme. Improper monitoring and supervision of literacy groups due to lack of transport have also lead to this decrease. 9.3.1.6 Special Education The Government is committed to the education of all children including the disabled ones and therefore will intensify efforts to increase access to education for disabled children. The district has one rehabilitation officer under clinics department, who is responsible for the welfare of disabled persons. In its endeavour to implement the 1994 Revised National Policy on Education which envisages equal opportunities for all persons regardless of their disabilities, the Clinics Department screen/assess and place children with disabilities in special school/centres according to their disabilities. The department of primary education has planned for special education facilities in the new primary schools to be constructed during the plan period at Tatisiding and Patamayatebele. The department will also buy two minibuses (16 Seater) for disabled children within the district. Tashatha CJSS in Tatisiding has been expanded by adding a unit of the Deaf that caters for the students with such needs from the whole of the north from Dibete. 9.3.2 Training 9.3.2.1 Vocational Training The only tertiary training institution in the district is the Brigade. There are two Brigades in the district namely, Zwenshambe Brigade and Senyawe Brigade. The Brigade is an autonomous community based institution engaged in Vocational Training and Commerce. The institution is registered under the Trust Laws of Botswana governed by the Board of Trustees made up of 92 representatives from the community, the Brigade Staff, the Trainees, the Ministry of Education (DVET) and Ex-Officio Members. The Ministry of Education through Department of Vocational Training (DVET) and the Board of Trustee helps in seeing that the Brigade runs smoothly. The Ministry of Education [DVET] also provides a subsidy for training materials, and other logistics (such as stationery, protective clothing, and printing for training purposes, student food, sports activities, etc) and technical advice as well as professional advice on the smooth running of brigades. On the other hand, the board of trustees is responsible for the day-to-day operation of the brigade. Zwenshambe Brigade Development Trust Zwenshambe Brigade has three (3) units, namely the Building and Plastering, Business and Secretarial Studies, Carpentry and Joinery with a total of one hundred and ninety two (192) trainees and an establishment of seventeen (17) Instructors and twelve (12) support staff. Due to the high demand of places for Vocational and Technical Education, one (1) unit for AutoMechanics and an expansion of the Business and Secretariat Studies is being embarked on under DDP5 plan period. The Business School will be based in Masunga to cater for the working class in the evening. Table 9.4: Planned Enrolment for Zwenshambe Brigades Course Carpentry Building Auto Mechanics Secretarial Panel Beating Welding Plumbing Auto Electrical Draughting Total 2004 80 80 16 40 216 2005 80 80 32 40 232 2006 80 80 48 40 16 16 16 16 16 328 2007 80 80 48 40 32 32 32 32 32 408 2008 80 80 48 40 48 48 48 48 48 488 Source: Zwenshambe Brigade, 2003 Senyawe Brigade Development Trust Senyawe Brigade has two (2) Training Units, namely the Building & Plastering and the Business & Computer Studies, with a total of one hundred and twenty (120) trainees and an establishment of eight (8) Instructors and eleven (11) support staff. A two-classroom block and a staff house are under construction with funds received from a donor (Breweries KMS Trust). It is hoped that the classroom block will be completed in time for the May 2003 intake of new Accounting and Secretarial Classes. Table 9.5: Planned Enrolment for Senyawe Brigades Course Building and Plastering Accounting Computer Studies Secretarial Carpentry Dressmaking 2004 80 40 20 20 - 2005 80 40 20 20 - 2006 80 40 20 20 16 16 2007 80 40 20 20 32 32 2008 80 40 20 20 48 48 93 Course Plumbing Livestock Management Horticulture Total 2004 2005 160 160 2006 16 16 16 240 2007 32 32 32 320 2008 48 48 48 400 Source: Senyawe Brigade, 2003 9.4 EDUCATION AND TRAINING SECTOR GOALS AND OBJECTIVES Table 9.6: Education and Training Sector Goals and Objectives Goals Sector Goals And Objectives-Central Govt Objectives To strengthen managerial and supervisory mechanisms in schools through continued support to the school management teams. To regularly conduct inspection in all schools so as to improve teaching and learning procedures. To provide quality education to all school age going children in the district. To encourage teachers to intensify the existing school development programmes so as to improve their professional being. To improve testing procedures through the Criterion Referenced Testing Programme To instill the spirit of self-supervision in all our school through management workshops and seminars. To ensure that HIV/AIDS school committees give support to those infected and affected. To strengthen coordinating of HIV/AIDS activities in schools. To ensure that HIV/AIDS coordinators in schools are given the relevant training to address HIV/AIDS issues. To encourage equal treatment of both teachers and pupils irrespective of their health status. To inculcate behavioural change in sexuality. Primary Education Sector Goals and Objectives To provide conducive learning environment for a cross-section of learners by development of adequate and accessible infrastructure and provision of enough equipment, stationery and materials. To construct all the planned development projects before the end of District Development Plan 6. To modify certain identified existing facilities to make them accessible to children with special educational needs before the end of DDP6. Secondary Education Goals And Objectives To strengthen the departments coordination of HIV/AIDS activities and enhance individuals knowledge and understanding. To offer learning opportunities that produce graduates with knowledge and skills required for life in a rapidly changing technological and socioeconomic environment. To increase skills level for effective participation in the global economy. To promote access and use of information and communication technology to the management and delivery of education and training. To establish HIV.AIDS coordination and monitoring committees and provide support. To infuse HIV/AIDS concept in the secondary education curriculum and support community outreach activities. To train personnel to offer support to infected individuals. To implement curricular at secondary school level for the development of learners, who have broad knowledge and skill base, who are critical thinkers, creative, resourceful and independent. To implement curricular and institutional activities that promotes community participation. To implement vocational curricular that creates opportunities for promotion of business studies and entrepreneurship training. To create more spaces at senior secondary school level such that 70% of junior certificate output could be admitted. To introduce countrywide e-bases management information system with components for e–learning during the plan period. To provide Internet access to students in all secondary schools by the end of the plan period. 94 Goals Non-Formal Education Goals And Objectives To create, empower the population and maintain a fully literate life by providing access to learning opportunities for its clients in the NE District. To strengthen the Department operations by posting qualified staff in the NE District. To improve access to education through provision of adequate facilities. To improve access of education through provision of adequate transport NE District Objectives To review, retain, upgrade, re-deploy the literacy group leaders and Adult Education To plan, design and implement /life skills To post qualified staff in two villages of North East District by 2003 To construct residential, and office accommodation at the selected villages by 2008 To establish and equip resources and learning centers in selected villages of the NE by the end of the plan period. To mainstream and infuse HIV/AIDS AND STD issues into the departments programmes and learning /teaching materials by Vision 2016. Zwenshambe Brigade- Goals and Objectives To provide vocational skills to a cross section of students who are predominately primary and secondary school leavers through development of adequate and accessible infrastructure and equipment. To construct all the planned development projects before the end of the District Development Plan 6. To intensify Training with Production to give students practical experience during the plan period. Senyawe Brigade-Goals and Objectives To provide an environment conducive for learning and holistic training programmes that emphasizes ‘Learning with Production’ for a crosssection of learners by development of adequate infrastructure, practical training, provision of appropriate equipment, and upgrading of local staff. To construct more classroom blocks and acquire adequate equipment to cater for the programs indicated in the table on planned enrolment. To expand the production program as per plan to enhance the practical aspect of training. To send staff for upgrading courses through the Ministry of Education (DVET) 9.5 FRAMEWORK FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT Sustainable development demands an environmentally conscious nation. In the current development plan period a deliberate effort has been made to consider environmental goals in the development hierarchy. The implementation of any physical infrastructure project has a great impact on the environment. It is on account of this that any project must be socially, economically and environmentally sustainable. All sectors involved in industrial construction would be made aware of the need for environmental preservation and conservation through public education and national policies that give direction as to how construction should be undertaken to avoid natural resource depletion. 9.5.1 Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues with Sector Goals and Objectives Table 9.7: Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues with Sector Goals and Objectives Goal To provide conducive learning environment for a cross-section of learners by development of adequate and accessible infrastructure and provision of enough equipment, stationery and materials. Objectives To construct all the planned development projects before the end of District Development Plan 6. Potential Impact Deforestation and desertification due to bush clearing during construction. Excessive extraction of river sand pit sand. Burrow pits. Loss of Biodiversity. Mitigation measures Conduct an Environmental Impact Assessment. Replanting landscaping. of tree and Rehabilitation of used burrow pits. Designation of extraction points. river sand Uncontrolled dumping of rubble. 95 Goal Objectives Potential Impact Mitigation measures Controlled disposal of rubble e.g. Land filling. Underground water pollution. Soil Erosion. To create, empower the population and maintain a fully literate life by providing access to learning opportunities for its clients in the NE District. To improve access to non-formal education through provision of adequate facilities. To review, retain, upgrade, redeploy the literacy group leaders and Adult Education. To plan, design and implement /life skills. To construct residential, classroom, and office accommodation at the selected villages by 2008. Pressure on water resources. Littering Provision of refuse receptacles. Intensify public cleanliness. of education Excessive extraction of river sand pit sand Replanting landscaping. tree and Burrow pits. Rehabilitation of used burrow pits. Loss of Biodiversity. Uncontrolled dumping of rubble. Soil Erosion. Designation of extraction points. river sand Controlled disposal of rubble e.g. Land filling. Pressure on water resources. 9.5.2 Evaluation of Sector Policies and Programs Table 9.8: Evaluation of Sector Policies and Programs Policies and Programs National Education Policy Goals and Objectives To construct all the planned development projects before the end of District Development Plan 6. Environmental Issues Deforestation and desertification due to bush clearing during construction. Excessive extraction of river sand pit sand Burrow pits Loss of Biodiversity Uncontrolled dumping of rubble Underground water pollution Soil Erosion Teacher Capacity Building Program 9.6 Facilitate students and teachers’ use of Information Communication Technology (ICT) to increase their knowledge base on HIV/AIDS prevention Pressure on water resources Air and noise pollution in areas where generators will be used. STRATEGIES TO ACHIEVE EDUCATION AND TRAINING GOALS AND OBJECTIVES Table 9.9: Strategies to Achieve Education and Training Goals and Objectives Proposed Projects Construction of Classrooms, Hostels, and Other facilities Teachers quarters, Potential Impacts Deforestation and desertification due to bush clearing during construction. Mitigation Measures Conduct an Environmental Assessment. Excessive extraction of river sand pit sand. Replanting of tree and landscaping Impact 96 Proposed Projects Potential Impacts Burrow pits. Mitigation Measures Rehabilitation of used burrow pits Loss of Biodiversity. Designation of river sand extraction points Uncontrolled dumping of rubble. Controlled disposal of rubble e.g. Land filling Underground water pollution. Soil Erosion. Pressure of water resources. Littering Workshops and seminars. 9.7 RESOURCE REQUIREMENT FOR DDP6 9.7.1 Issues and Strengths for Education and Training -Provision of waste receptacles -Public education 9.7.1.1 Strengths Community involvement in day-to-day school activities. Change in sexual behaviour. Networking with stake holders. School management team members are all qualified. 90% of primary teachers are qualified. Provision of basic education services. 9.7.1.2 Issues 9.7.2 Poor results in some schools. Resource constraints including finances and lack of equipment. Limited use of information technology. 10% of untrained primary school teachers. Epidemics e.g. HIV/AIDS within the learning environment. Lack of harmonization of policies and Acts. Limited funds for implementation of projects. Population escalation or decline. Unexpected natural disasters. Lack of special education facilities. Performance Targets for DDP6/UDP2 Table 9.10: Performance Targets for DDP6/UDP2 Project Construction of Education Facilities Location District Goal/Objective Improve access to education 16 Seater Combi for Disabled [2] District Transportation of disabled students to their respective schools Performance Indicator Completion of the projects by the end of the plan period Purchase of the 16 seater by the end of 2004/2005 97 9.7.3 Development Budget for DDP6/UDP2 9.7.3.1 Primary Education For primary education projects refer to Chapter 15. 9.7.3.2 Vocational Training and Non-Formal Education The table below provides details for Brigades and Non-Formal project proposals for DDP6. Some information on the budget and year of implementation of some projects for Non-Foramal (represented by * in the table) was not available at the time of plan preparation. Therefore, this information will be obtained from the respective institutions during the impelmentation phase. Table 9.11: Proposed Development Projects for DDP6 – Brigades and Non-Formal Project Zwenshambe Brigade Panel Beating Welding Plumbing Electrical Computer maintenance lab Draughting 6 x Staff houses Senyawe Brigade Hostel Blocks Staff houses Computer Lab Carpentry workshop Welding Workshop Business Studies Central Admin block Non-Formal Education Design and implement Adult Basic Education Programme, post literacy out of school education for children. To train 8 Adult Education and 80 facilitators /LGLs on approaches and methods of delivering out of school education curricular. Construct LA2 house at Tsamaya Construct office at Tsamaya village Purchase of 1 double cab vehicle Production of learning teaching HIV/AIDS and post literacy materials Formation and monitoring of committees in the 42 villages Conduct 60 mobilization workshops 2003/2004 2004/2005 2005/2006 2006/2007 2007/2008 2008/2009 1,200,000 1,400,000 1,200,000 1,300,000 1,400,000 2,300,000 1,800,000 1,500,000 200,000 500,000 1,000,000 1,000,000 1,000,000 500,000 * * * * * * P18000.00 P20000.00 P50000.00 P40000.00 P40000.00 P40000.0 P250 000.00 * * * * P350 000.00 * * * * * * * * P5000.00 P5000.00 P5000.00 P7000.00 P7000.00 P7000.00 P18000.00 P20000.00 P20000.00 P20000.00 P20000.00 P20000.00 98 Secondary Schools Projects ED 801 The following is a list of projects the Ministry of Education funded during DDP6. Table 11.2: Planned Projects DDP6 - Secondary School Projects Projects Classroom, Teacher’s Quarters Laundry room Kitchen Classroom Hostel Block Ablution Block Laundry room Classroom Classroom Teacher’s Quarters Laundry Room Kitchen Classroom Teacher’s Quarters Kitchen Classroom Teacher’s Quarters Classroom Teacher’s Quarter Laundry Room Classroom Blocks Toilet Block Classroom Block Teacher’s Quarters Hostel Blocks Ablution Blocks Laundry Room Classroom Teacher’s Quarter Laundry Room Classroom Block Classroom Pavilion Teacher’s Quarters Ablution Blocks Laundry Room Total 9.7.4 Quantity 1 3 1 1 1 3 1 1 1 1 3 1 1 1 4 1 1 4 1 1 1 1.5 1 1 2 2 2 1 1 3 1 1 1 1 3 2 1 Name of School Batanani CJSS Village Mapoka Total Cost 1 155 275.00 Maenjani CJSS Sekakangwe 1 859 838.00 Maruje CJSS Matsiloje CJSS Masunga Matsiloje 150 150.00 876 150.00 Pelaelo CJSS Makaleng 1 968 225.00 Ramoja CJSS Ramokgwebana 1 384 600.00 Shanganani CJSS Tsamaya 542 750.00 Tashatha CJSS Tati Siding 786 500.00 Thamani CJSS Tshesebe 1 207 788.00 Zwenshambe CJSS Zwenshambe 2 254 800.00 12 186 076.00 Plan Monitoring Programme The achievement of the goals through the objectives set out is to be monitored through site visits, project and programme reports and their evaluation. Progress will be reported to Education Planning Committee, DDC and Full Council all stake holders. The construction of new facilities, conducting workshops will improve the quality of education in the district. 99 CHAPTER 10 10 HEALTH 10.1 INTRODUCTION Vision 2016 envisages that by the year 2016 all Batswana will have access to good quality health services, including both preventive and curative services within reasonable travelling distance. Health has been given special attention in Vision 2016 because one of the ultimate goals of this long-term vision is to have a healthy nation that is fully involved and can contribute meaningfully to development. The district has major urban influences due to its location and proximity position to Francistown. The socio- economic status of the district also influences health patterns and behaviors. The Government is the main provider of the health care in the district and is supplemented by private practitioners in Francistown who also cover the district. 10.1.1 Institutional Framework The Ministry of Health is responsible for Health Policy formulation on behalf of the Botswana government. The Ministry is guided by a National Health Policy that was officially adopted through Presidential Directive CAB 21 (B) 195 of July 1995. The Ministry has five [5] departments namely: Ministry Management, Primary Health Care, Hospital Services, Health Manpower and Technical Support Services. Ministry Management: Plays the role of enabler through coordination of overall administrative and resource support services [finance, transport, material and facilities] within all the departments of the Ministry. Primary Health Care: Responsible for integration of preventive, promotive, rehabilitative, and appropriate curative health care through the participation and involvement of community groups at all levels of the health delivery system. Hospital Services: Covers broad areas include: Diagnosis Service, Support to Primary Health Care, Treatment Services, Research, Professional Standard and Management of Health Services. Health Manpower Department: is responsible for ensuring that human resources for health in all disciplines and all levels of the service are provided, equitably distributed and optimally utilized. Technical Support Services: provides technical support to all the departments within the Ministry in terms of the development, implementation and maintaining the National Drug Policy. Masunga Primary Hospital: Has a 50-bed capacity (including 8 costs) located in Masunga Village. It serves a general population of 49399 [according to 2001 population and housing census], of which 38532 (i.e. 78%) fall in the immediate catchment area. The hospital serves as a referral point for eight clinics and 24 health post in various villages of the district. During 2002 a total of 318 clinical, confirmed HIV/AIDS and related conditions were documented. This was an increase 100 of 4.6% compared to 2001 where there were 304 cases. One hundred and twelve [112] hospital deaths out of a total of 156 that occurred in 2002 were a result of conditions. District Heatlth Team: The District Health Team (DHT) under the North East District Council has two main sections, Clinics, and Environmental Health. Clinics Department: Responsible for the provision of curative, preventative, rehabilitative and promotive health services. The first contact period for clients is the mobile stop. From mobile stops clients are seen at Health Posts, which are managed by Registered Nurses with or without maternity. The clinics are managed by Registered Midwives. Doctors see clients in the clinics and some of the busy Health Posts once or twice a month. From the clinics patients are referred to Masunga Primary Hospital. Patients may also be referred directly to the hospital from the Health Post or Clinic without being seen by the DHT doctors, when circumstances demand. The clinics section is also responsible for attending to needs of disabled clients, through the rehabilitation programme. The Environmental Health Section is responsible for the control of factors in the environment that may have deleterious effects on human health. It also refers to the theory and practice of assessing, correcting, controlling and preventing physical, chemical, biological, social and psychosocial factors in the environment that can potentially affect the health of present and future generations. This control is carried out through the following functions: Control of communicable diseases Food quality monitoring Sanitary refuse collection, storage and disposal Proper disposal of human excreta Pollution control Water quality monitoring The section is headed by the Senior Environmental Health Officer and has Environmental Health Technicians at the DHT. They are also sanitation attendants in some villages responsible for litter picking. The section is also responsible for ensuring that each household and business premise have adequate and safe sanitation facilities and water supply. The section is also responsible for monitoring food hygiene in shops, restaurants and supermarkets. 10.1.2 Strategic Plan for Respective Ministries 10.1.2.1 Ministry of Health The mandate of the Ministry of Health (in relation to Local Authorities) is to provide basic health care and infrastructure development in the form of hospitals, clinics, health posts, mobile stops and nurses’ accommodation. In order to achieve its mandate the ministry has set itself the following Key Result Areas: Improved health status of the nation. Customer satisfaction. Organisational efficiency and effectiveness. 101 Human Resource Management (HRM). 10.1.2.2 Ministry of Local Government The mandate of the Ministry of Local Government (in relation to Local Authorities) is to provide basic physical and social infrastructure (e.g. Water provision, primary school and clinics construction) to the community. The other core business as stipulated in the ministry strategic plan is that of ensuring efficient operation of local authorities through policy direction, capacity building, and supervision. To achieve its mandate, the ministry has set itself key results areas viz: Customer satisfaction. Policy implementation effectiveness. Improved quality of life of communities. Productivity and organizational effectiveness. The key areas in the strategic plan of the Ministry of Local Government that relate to health include: Increasing the training of staff (20%) in specialized skills, which includes the health cadre. Support the self-development of staff in private study. Develop and implement a Ministry HIV/AIDS policy based upon the national policy on HIV/AIDS. Develop a proactive HIV intervention strategy. 10.1.2.3 Ministry of Lands, Housing and Environment The Ministry of Lands and Housing is responsible for managing land and related functions, facilitation of national housing development programmes and promoting environmental management throughout the country. In the management of land the ministry responsibility entails: The key areas in the Ministry of Lands and housing strategic plan that relate to health include: Increasing the amount of land available for equitable distribution. Facilitating the reclamation of wasteland. Facilitating home ownership. Fostering environment friendly practices. Promoting environmental education and its facilitation into the formal education system. Creating an environment conducive for employee motivation. 10.1.2.4 National AIDS Coordinating Agency (NACA) NACA was established during DDP5 and launched on 29/10/2000. NACA is responsible for coordinating, facilitating, and monitoring and evaluating the coordinated efforts that are geared towards addressing the HIVAIDS scourge and its impact. It also provides a common vision for all who participate and contribute to the national HIV/AIDS response. NACA serves as the secretariat to the National AIDS Council. The strategic plans developed in the Medium Term Plan II focus on two major objectives: (i) preventing the spread of HIV and (ii) mitigating the impact of HIV/AIDS at all levels of society. 102 10.1.3 Role Of Private Sectors The private sector plays an important role in the provision of health care. They provide infrastructure, curative and prevention services, counseling, communication and electricity to our facilities. They work in collaboration with the health department to disseminate information on health related issues to the community at large. The district does not have private health services but receives private health services from Francistown. Large private sector areas such as the mines and some commercial farms provide health services to their employees (and dependants). This reduces the burden on the health department. Traditional Healers also provide services to patients in the district although no formal arrangement exists for referrals between traditional and conventional medical practitioners. Environmental Health issues and concerns are multi sectoral and each concern is institutionalized in different sectors of government and parastatals with distinctive values and perspectives. NonGovernmental Organizations that have interest on the environment such as Environmental Heritage Foundation Botswana, Kalahari Conservation Society and others have always supported the district on environmental issues. The North East District Council has privatized litter picking and disposal services in Tatisiding. Refuse collection by use of donkey carts is underway in different parts of the district. 10.1.4 Consultation Priorities The district is faced with a number of issues of primary health concern HIV/AIDS Pandemic - This is seriously affecting the district in all sectors and across all ages. District Multi Sectoral AIDS Committee (DMSAC), Prevention of Mother Child Transmission (PMTCT), Voluntary Counselling and Testing [VCT] and Home Based Care [HBC] are meant to address this issue TB – The number of cases has been rising due to the high prevalence of HIV/AIDS Hypertension and Diabetes – with a high proportion of old aged persons and obesity. Those diseases are quite prevalent and require attention EPI - The Expanded Programme for Immunization has not adequately covered the district targets. This has been a result of irregular supply of vaccines, reduced child welfare clinic attendance due to irregular supply of rations and severe staffing shortage. Decentralise Anti-Retroviral Drug [ARV] program in the district The district is experiencing shortage of nursing staff due to transfers, promotions, further education, resignations and deaths. The fact that the district is rural reduces the attraction to work in the area. There are also vacancies within the DHT, which makes day-to-day, function difficult. The district has a serious problem of clinical waste disposal. Currently clinical waste is disposed of at Nyangagwe Hospital. This is a temporary measure, which may be revoked at any time. The district is still awaiting the completion of the landfill, which will also accommodate clinical waste. The District Health Team has insufficient transport to carryout supporting supervisory functions. 103 Due to lack of facilities the district is faced with a serious problem of inadequate food quality monitoring. Currently there is no abattoir or slaughterhouse in the district. Meat sold to the public is not inspected and animals are slaughtered in unhygienic conditions. 10.2 NATIONAL POLICIES AND LEGISLATION 10.2.1 National Policy on HIV/AIDS The Medium Term Plan [MTP] for the prevention and control of HIV/AIDS in Botswana (I and II - 1989-93, 1997-2002 respectively), have provided policy and strategic guidance since the inception of the National AIDS Control Programme. The National policy on HIV/AIDS and MTPII define the roles and responsibilities of sectors, communities and the individual. The policies also suggest strategies that can be adopted and also mentions the rights and responsibilities of the infected and non-infected. The policies need to be updated to include the issue of Anti-retroviral Treatment and its consequences. There are new issues, which can have far reaching consequences if not well elucidated such as issues of criteria for treatment, monitoring and treatment responsibility, and improvement/upgrading of hospital facilities and services. The North East District is among the most affected districts but is not yet able to access these services. The 2002 sentinel survey shows that the rate is 38.6% for the district. Thus there is need for a review of procedure in order to enable patients from the district access these services. The district also needs to have its staff prepared (trained) to handle the patients who will need to be reviewed or who might develop complications while under treatment. Once the district is involved in the roll out of the ARV programme, issues of infrastructure development might have to be considered. This could involve expansion of the hospital laboratory or building a more advanced laboratory than the one originally envisaged in the Tati Siding clinic expansion project. 10.2.2 National Health Policy The National Health Policy is meant to guide health workers in their decision-making and make members of the public aware of Government Policy in relation to the provision of health care. The public health services, the private health services and the Non-Organisation that provide health care constitute the health system of Botswana. The main objectives of the policy is; access by all citizens of Botswana to essential health care, what ever their own financial resources or place of domicile, and the assurance of an equitable distribution of health resources and utilization of health services. The national health policy has not been reviewed since 1995. This needs to be done so that Antiretroviral Therapy (ARV) and the changing relations between Ministry of Health and Ministry of Local Government are captured. 10.2.3 Health Strategy and Plans The department of Primary Health Care in the Ministry of Health is responsible for integration e.g. preventive, promotion, rehabilitative and appropriate curative health care through the participation and involvement of community groups at all levels of the health care delivery system. Hospital Services in the Ministry covers diagnostic services, support to Primary Health Care, treatment services, research, professional standards of care and management of health services. 104 The Ministry of Local Government provides for Primary Health Care Services through the Local Government Service Management Department and the Sanitation and Waste Management Department. Both the Ministry of Health and Ministry of Local Government strategic plans have a strong basis in Performance Management System and strong links with Vision 2016. “Health remains one of the integral parts of the of the pillars of Vision 2016 because the ultimate aim of this long term vision is to have a healthy nation that is fully involved and can contribute meaningfully to development”. (MOH Strategic Plan 2001-2006). The goals of the Ministry of Health are: To improve the efficiency and cost effectiveness of health care delivery To ensure equitable distribution of health services To improve the quality of health care To train appropriate skilled personnel To strengthen Primary Health Care Programmes This is on the basis that health is an integral part of all development programmes, which constitute the Primary Health Strategy and is therefore aligned to NDP8. The key result areas (KRAs) in the Ministry of Health Strategic Plans include: Improved Health status of the nation Customer satisfaction Organizational efficiency and effectiveness Human resource management The Ministry intends to achieve the following objectives within the next four to six years: 10.2.4 Provide quality health services to Batswana in order to improve their health status To improve the life expectancy of Botswana through the implementation of PHC strategy To provide customer focused health services in order to increase customer satisfaction To improve quality service delivery through development and implementation of comprehensive health policies and standards by end of NDP 9. To enhance the Ministry of Health efficiency and effectiveness through the implementation of innovative performance management initiatives To review existing HRM health plans in order to come up with a comprehensive plan consistent with the current health needs of the country. The North East District has strategic objectives for its own attainment Environmental Health Policies and Legislations The Health Department is expected to enforce and apply the following Acts: Food Control Act, Control of Smoking Act, Public Health Act, and Waste Management Act. This requires officers to be knowledgeable of legal technicalities required. Some of these Acts do not have regulations and this makes their enforcement somewhat difficult. The Public Health Act, being the most widely used legal instrument has some loopholes, the most serious one being Regulations that are in most cases not applicable to the rural settings. The Botswana Waste Management Act 1998, was set up to help in minimizing and reducing wastes in industries, commerce and households, maximizing 105 environmentally sound waste reuse and recycling and promoting environmentally sound waste collection, treatment and disposal. According to the Act, local authorities are charged with the responsibility for the collection and disposal of domestic waste. There is still an urgent need for promulgation of policies for environmental health such as occupational health, trade licensing, food control, rural sanitation, environmental protection and management in order to comply with the requirements of Agenda 21 on sustainable development. It is imperative that these policies and/or guidelines be made and implemented so that sustainable environmental protection could be equally realized in both urban and rural areas 10.3 HEALTH 10.3.1 Environmental Health The quality of environmental health services in North East District like in other rural areas is an area of growing concern hence the importance of environmental cleanliness and protection, as well as environmental management must be given a national priority. The concept of sustainable environmental protection and development should be achieved through systematic incorporation of environmental concerns in the development policies, programmes and projects. In the North East District for instance, there is still a number of environmental health problems such as uncontrolled practices of dumping of solid waste, indiscriminate littering attitude by some members of the community, inadequacy of refuse storage receptacles, unavailability of on-site sanitary conveniences such as pit latrines, and poor food as well as water hygiene. This scenario poses serious environmental and social hazards to the residents of the area. 10.3.2 Hospital Services The district has a primary hospital based in Masunga that serves as the primary referral hospital. The hospital provides basic main functions such as laboratory services, x-ray, surgical services and dental services and has in-patient and outpatient services. Cases that cannot be handled at this level are transferred to Nyangagbwe Referral Hospital in Francistown, which is 100 km away. 10.3.3 District Health System The District Health System is based on Primary Health Care. The North East District has 36 health facilities operating under the District Council. These are eight clinics with maternity, three clinics without maternity and 25 health posts. The clinics and health posts are manned by Registered Midwives and registered nurses respectively and assisted by Family Welfare Educators (FWEs) and General Duty Assistants (GDAs). The District Health Team oversees the clinics and health posts. The District Health Team also oversees the Environmental Health Section. 10.3.4 Primary Health Care The Primary Health Care is the system of provision of health care in the district. As indicated earlier, this is through health clinics and health posts. This also includes control of the environment to prevent disease occurrence and management of any environmental health issues. This primary health care provides preventive, promotive, curative and rehabilitation services. The main areas of service provision in the district are as depicted in the table below: 106 Table 10.1: Components of Primary Health Care Program Child Welfare Clinics Maternal Health Care Family Planning General Out Patient Service Expanded Program in Immunization (EPI) Nutrition Integrated Management of Childhood Infection (IMCI) Antenatal Care Delivery Care Postnatal Care Prevention of Mother to Child Transmission (PMTCT) Sexually Transmitted Infection (STI) Tubercolousis (TB) Human Immuno-Deficiency Virus (HIV) Health Education (runs through all areas) Environmental Health Care Home Based Care With the introduction of the ARV Programme in Botswana, this district will be involved indirectly in the pilot phase due to its proximity to Francistown where some patients referred for specialized care will be recruited. Due to the high mortality caused by HIV/AIDS, the minors and elderly are becoming an increasingly large percentage of the population with the resultant burden of caring for orphans, shoulded by the erderly. 10.3.5 Control of Pandemic Disease 10.3.5.1 HIV/AIDS: The district is one of the hardest-hit in terms of HIV/AIDS prevalence in the country. The 2002 sentinel survey shows that the prevalence rate is 38.6% for the district. Its close proximity to Francistown, which has high prevalence rate, the mobility of the population and the poor economic base are all factors that contribute to the rise in the prevalence rate. Unemployment, high fertility and teenage pregnancy are also important factors. The district is implementing a number of programmes to curb the spread. These include: PMTCT Programme. Voluntary Counseling and Testing. Formation of DMSAC, sector AIDS committee and Village Aids Committees. Intensive health education and promotion activities. Planning for the ARV programme. STI prevention and treatment. 10.3.5.2 Tuberculosis: Due to the high HIV/AIDS prevalence, the number of TB cases in the district has risen. The district has fully adopted the National TB policy and is actively implementing Directly Observed Treatment for Shortcourse [DOTS]. Follow up visits are made to defaulting patients to ensure compliance. The constraints facing the program are: - delay in seeking treatment, poor compliance and default by some patients especially when they begin to feel better. Isoniazid Prevention Therapy has not been introduced into the district. Another constraint is the inability of clinics to carry out tests, as they do not have laboratories or the requisite personnel. 107 10.3.5.3 Malaria Control The North East District, though not in a malaria endemic zone, does experience cases of malaria, a number of these cases being imported from Tutume and Zimbabwe. In 2001 the district treated 34 cases of confirmed malaria and 832 of unconfirmed cases. Vector Control through indoor – spraying and environment control is conducted district wide annually, while vector spraying is done on a regular basis on request. Insecticide impregnated nets are also provided through clinics at a cost. Health education activities are also conducted to prevent infections and promote early treatment. 10.4 HEALTH SECTOR GOALS AND OBJECTIVES Table 10.2: Health Sector Goals and Objectives Goals Clinics To provide quality health services to North East District in order to improve their health status Objectives To increase immunization coverage among under fives by 50% by 2003 and by 75% by 2004 To reduce maternal morbidity by 50% by 2004 To increase CWC attendance from 70 to 90% by end of 2003 To provide customer focused health services in order to increase customer satisfaction. To reduce PMTCT decliners to half current rates by 2003 To resuscitate and strengthen District Health Services Coordinating Committee by holding 4 meetings a year Provide 24hrs clinic care in 3 clinics by 2004 and 8 clinics by 2005 Train 80% of nurses and doctors in North East District in PMTCT and 80% in ARV by 2003 Orientate and train 50% of nurses and all doctors in reproductive health by2003 To increase access to health services by the community and thus improve cost effectiveness Conduct two refresher courses for nurses/year till 2004 Upgrading of Tsamaya clinic to 24hrs by 2005 Extension of Tsamaya rehabilitation center by 2005 Construction of new health post at Patayamatebele by 2005 Upgrading of health posts in Tshesebe to clinic by 2005 Construct staff houses in Tsamaya, Tati Siding and Tshesebe by 2005 Environmental Health Improve refuse/waste collection service and management, reduce landfill and incineration cost, and reduce demand for natural resources. Establish centralized refuse transfer station at Tsamaya for collection of waste from the eastern region by 2005. To reduce the monetary and environmental costs of land filling and incineration by establishing waste recycling project at Masunga Sanitary Landfill by 2004, and at Tsamaya Refuse Transfer Station by the year 2006. To privatise waste collection service at Matsiloje, Tati-Siding and Matshelagabedi beginning of 2003\2004 financial year. To provide for effective storage and collection of waste at public places of gathering such as shopping centers, markets and Border posts by providing skips in the following villages: 108 Goals To ensure safety of all food including meat that is sold to the public in the North East District. To ensure community satisfaction through quality/ prompt service delivery throughout the entire North East District. Objectives To prevent indiscriminate disposal of human excreta through out North East District by constructing 200 Sub-Structures for On-Site Sanitary Conveniences annually throughout the Plan period (Total 1000) and waterborne public toilets at Ramokgwebana Border post by 2004, and TatiSiding by 2005. To construct Improved Slaughter Houses at Masunga by 2004 and at Tsamaya by the year 2005. To improve supervision of sanitation crews hence service delivery throughout the North East District by installing two-way radio communication in all waste management vehicles with control centers at Masunga and Tati-Siding offices by 2005. To ensure prompt service delivery to people in the southern region of the North East District by building sanitation depot at Tati-Siding by 2007 thereby bringing services closer to the residents of the area. 10.5 FRAMEWORK FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT 10.5.1 Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues With Sector Goals and Objectives Sustainable development demands an environmentally conscious nation. In the current development plan period a deliberate effort has been made to consider environmental goals in the development hierarchy. The implementation of any physical infrastructure project has a great impact on the environment. It is on account of this that any project must be both socially, economically and environmentally sustainable. All sectors involved in industrial construction would be made aware of the need for environmental preservation and conservation through public education and national policies that give direction as to how construction should be undertaken to avoid natural resource depletion. 10.5.2 Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues with Sector Goals and Objectives Table 10.3: Environmental Key Issues with Sector Goals and Objectives Goal To provide quality health services to North East District in order to improve their health status. Objectives To increase immunization coverage among under fives by 50% by 2003 and by 75% by 2004. Potential Impact Indiscriminate littering and waste disposal Mitigation measures Waste Incineration Littering Provision of sanitary facilities To reduce maternal morbidity by 50% by 2004. To increase CWC attendance from 70 to 90% by end of 2003. To provide customer focused health services in order to increase customer satisfaction. To reduce PMTCT decliners to half current rates by 2003. To resuscitate and strengthen District Health Services Coordinating Committee by holding 4 meetings a year. Provide 24hrs clinic care in 3 clinics by 2004 and 8 clinics by 2005. Train 80% of nurses and doctors in North East District in PMTCT and 80% in ARV by 2003. Orientate and train 50% of nurses and all 109 Goal Objectives doctors in reproductive health by2003. To increase access to health services by the community and thus improve cost effectiveness. Conduct two refresher courses for nurses/year till 2004. Upgrading of Tsamaya clinic to 24hrs by 2005. Extension of Tsamaya rehabilitation center by 2005. Construction of new health post at Patayamatebele by 2005. Potential Impact Mitigation measures Bush clearing. E.I.A. Sand/soil excavation. Re-planting trees/shrubs. Building creation. Rehabilitation of burrow pits. waste/rubble Soak-away construction. Increased water demand. Clearing rubble. Upgrading of health posts in Tshesebe to clinic by 2005. Increased clinical waste. Waste incineration. Gground water pollution. Construct staff houses in Tsamaya, Tati Siding and Tshesebe by 2005. To ensure safety of all food including meat sold to the public in the North East District. 10.5.3 Identification of sand collection points. To construct improved slaughter houses at Masunga by 2004 and at Tsamaya by the year 2005. Evaluation of Sector Policies and Programs Table 10.4: Evaluation Health Sector Polices and Programs Policies and Programs National Education Policy. Goals and Objectives To construct all the planned development projects before the end of District Development Plan 6. Environmental Issues Deforestation and desertification due to bush clearing during construction. Excessive extraction of river sand pit sand. Burrow pits. Loss of Biodiversity. Uncontrolled dumping of rubble. Underground water pollution. Soil Erosion. Teacher Capacity Building Program. 10.6 To promote HIV/AIDS awareness among Primary School children using TVs and VCR. Pressure on water resources. Air and noise pollution in areas where generators will be used. STRATEGIES TO ACHIEVE THE HEALTH SECTOR GOALS AND OBJECTIVES Table 10.5: Strategies to Achieve Health Sector Goals and Objectives Proposed Projects Upgrading of Tati Siding clinic to 24hrs. Potential Impacts Bush clearing. Mitigation Measures E.I.A Upgrading of clinics to include maternity wing. Sand/soil excavation. Re-planting trees/shrubs Upgrading of health posts to clinics. Building waste/rubble creation. Rehabilitation of burrow pits Increased water demand. Soak-away construction Increased clinical waste. Clearing rubble Construction of (Patayamatebele). new health post 110 Proposed Projects Extension of Tsamaya Rehabilitation Centre. Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Ground water pollution. Waste incineration Bush clearing. Identification of sand collection points. E.I.A. Sand/soil excavation. Replanting trees. Building waste/rubble. Rehabilitation of burrow pits. Abattoir waste. Identification of sand collection points. Offensive smells. Recycling of waste products such as skins, horns, hooves etc and construction of soak away for liquid waste. -Sub structures to be sealed and water tight -Frequent emptying of pits Construction of staff houses. Waste transfer station (Tsamaya). Abattoir at Masunga and Tsamaya. On Site Sanitation Ground water pollution 10.7 RESOURCE REQUIREMENTS FOR DDP6/UDP2 10.7.1 Strengths for Health Services 10.7.2 10.7.3 Availability of trained personnel. Customer focused departments. Community development. Provision of basic sanitation services. Consultation and communication with community leaders. Reaching out to grass root level. Privatization of refuse collection. Issues for Health Services Resource constraints including finance and lack of equipment Old and inadequate infrastructure Epidemics e.g. HIV/AIDS within the health profession Shortage of transport e.g. Ambulances and waste carriers Public indiscriminate littering Lack of harmonization of policies and Acts Resistance to change by external customers Poor service delivery Poor co-ordination and supervision of industrial class employees Resource constraints including finances and lack equipment Lack of information technology Performance Targets for DDP6/UDP2 The implementation of project will be phased in accordance with priority. Issues of immediate concern such as transport, radio communication, water and electrification will be done first while the processing of construction works will proceed at a slower pace because of their inherent procedural requirements. Manpower development will proceed along with these projects implementation. 111 Table 10.6: Performance Targets for DDP6 Project Primary Health Infrastructure Location District Waste Transfer Station Tsamaya Abattoir Tsamaya & Masunga Onsite Sanitation District Goal/Objective To improve access to health services by the community and thus improve cost effectiveness Improve refuse/waste collection service and management. To ensure safety of all food e.g. meat. Reduction in indiscriminate littering. Performance Indicator Completion of all proposed projects during plan period. Completion of projects by the year 2006. Completion of project during plan period. Improve refuse/waste collection service and management. 10.7.4 Plan Monitoring Programme The achievement of the goals through the objectives set out is to be monitored through site visits, project and programme reports and their evaluation. The expansion of facilities, construction of new facilities together with training/orientation of staff in various disciplines and areas will improve access, improve the quality of care and lead to a reduction in disease burden i.e. maternal morbidity and mortality, immunisable diseases and HIV transmission. 112 CHAPTER 11 11 MINISTRY OF LABOUR AND HOME AFFAIRS 11.1 INTRODUCTION The Ministry of Labour and Home Affairs is responsible for a wide range of cultural and social services that are essential for the social and economic development of the country. It provides cultural services through the National Museum and Art Gallery while social services are provided through National Registration, Prisons and Rehabilitation, Labour and Social Security, Women’s Affairs, Sports and Recreation, Industrial Court and Immigration and Citizenship. There are, however, only six departments and divisions under this Ministry, which are represented in the district namely: National Registration Division, Civil Registration and Vital Events, Immigration and Citizenship, Sports & Recreation, Labour and Social Security and Youth and Culture. The Ministry shares some of the social services responsibilities with the Ministry of Local Government, in particular the Division of Social Services. At district level, some of the social services responsibilities are undertaken by district councils, which are providing for destitute persons, orphans and home based patients. A strategic plan for the Ministry of Labour and Home Affairs exists and all line departments have drawn their plans in line with the overall strategic objectives of the Ministry. The Ministry recognizes the pivotal role that the Non-Governmental Organizations play in delivery of service and development. At the district level, there are a number of NonGovernmental Organizations (NGOs) and Community Based Organizations, which play an important role in development. Some of these are the Environmental Heritage Foundation (EHF) of Botswana and Rural Industries Promotions Company (RIPCO). There are also women’s organizations such as BCW (Botswana Council of Women), YWCA (Young Women Christian Association) and Elegant, which play an important role in development of the district. The BCW and YWCA operate projects such as Day Care Centers within the district. The vision pillar of “compassionate, just and caring nation” is achieved through provision of social welfare services. The objective of the ministry is to cater for all needy persons irrespective of their origin, gender and disability as the vision accentuates. The rehabilitation services available in the district and programmes designed for development of women through NGOs further promote the ideal of empowering women and taking them aboard in development activities. “Morality and Tolerance” may be promoted through partnership with NGOs, religious organisations, local and political leaders. Promotion of morality will be emphasized especially among the youth as they have lately shown social ill and unacceptable (deviant) behavior. Tolerance will be mostly promoted among the ill in view of the escalating proportions of the ill populace, home-based and in the hospitals. 11.1.1 Strategic Plans for Respective Ministries 11.1.1.1 Ministry of Labour and Home Affairs The mandate of the Ministry of Labour and Home Affairs is to create and maintain national harmony and to preserve and promote national culture as essential element for national unity, 113 democracy and socio-economic development of the nation. The ministry is made up of ten departments, two divisions and the Industrial Court. They are as follows: Table 11.1: Mininstry of Labour and Home Affairs Departments and Divisons Departments Ministry Management Immigration and Citizenship Prisons and Rehabilitation Culture and Youth National Museum, Monuments and Gallery Sports and Recreation National Library Services Labour and Social Security National Archives and Records Services Women’s Affairs Department Divisions National Registration Division Civil Registration and Vital Events Division Courts Industrial Court Art There are, however, only six departments and divisions under this Ministry, which are represented in the district namely: National Registration Division, Civil Registration and Vital Events, Immigration and Citizenship, Sports & Recreation, Labour and Social Security and Youth and Culture. 11.1.1.2 Ministry of Local Government The mandate of the Ministry of Local Government (in relation to Local Authorities) is to provide basic physical and social infrastructure (e.g. Water provision, primary school and clinics construction) to the community. The other core business as stipulated in the ministry strategic plan is that of ensuring efficient operation of local authorities through policy direction, capacity building, and supervision. To achieve its mandate, the ministry has set itself key results areas via: Customer satisfaction. Policy implementation effectiveness. Improved quality of life of communities. Productivity and organizational effectiveness. All the above have a direct bearing on the operations and responsibilities of local authorities as it is part of their core business hence their achievement is dependent on the full commitment of local authorities. Local authorities will therefore ensure that the overall results areas of local government are achievable through the following; Customer satisfaction To ensure customer satisfaction through timely delivery of quality service. To ensure continuous improvement in service delivery through two way communication. Policy Implementation Improve local authorities’ project implementation through timely submission of project memorandums. To ensure education, dissemination of information, and effective consultation of communities. 114 Improved quality of life of communities To undertake social mobilization and consultation with communities and provide an enabling environment for enhanced participatory development. To promote sustainable self-reliance amongst communities through programmes such as LG 1109, Community Based Natural resource Management. To improve community quality of life of Batswana by coordinating and providing basic infrastructure and services. To reduce the level of crime by adopting community policing. 11.1.1.3 Ministry of Trade, Industry, Tourism and Wildlife The Ministry developed several strategies for use in the delivery of its mandate and to provide relevant effective, efficient service to its customers and other stakeholders. The key issues that the Ministry considered in developing its core strategies are Export Development and promotion, Citizen Entrepreneurship Development, Eco-Tourism Development and Promotion, Comprehensive Problem Animal Control and Investment Promotion. To achieve its mandate, the Ministry has set itself key results areas viz; Conducive environment for sustainable economic activities established and maintained. Advocacy role played. Industrial information availability. Sustained wildlife populations and its habitats. Customer and stakeholders’ satisfaction. Ministry performance enhanced and results delivered. 11.1.1.4 Information and Broadcasting The Department of Information and Broadcasting through its divisions aims at being at the forefront of providing quality information, education and entertainment to the people of Botswana. To achieve its mandate the department has set its key results areas viz: 11.1.2 Customer satisfaction. Informed and educated nation. Motivated and skilled employees. Culture and Social Consultation Priorities Most communities have seen the values and importance of registering events. Since civil registration is done only in the district headquarters [Masunga], some communities have indicated the need for mobile visits to their villages on monthly basis. They also suggested more additional officers for civil registration, schools, banks, insurance and other institutions have started demanding birth and death certificates. 115 11.2 NATIONAL POLICIES AND LEGISLATION 11.2.1 National Child Welfare Policy In order to become a safe and secure nation a National Child Welfare Policy will be developed to provide necessary protection of the children, strengthen capacity related to child rights and facilitate public awareness of the United Nations Convention on the rights of Children (UNCRC) and the African Charter on Rights and Welfare of the Child. At district level Department of Social and Community Development [S&CD] implement acts and policies that deal with children making sure that they match the current living situations and align with the children’s conventions and declarations. 11.2.2 The National Youth Policy The Department of Culture and Youth in its endeavour to develop the youth is guided by the youth policy. The policy defines youth as people with the age range of 12 to 29 years. The policy seeks to address problems faced by the contemporary youth, which include unemployment, health, education and training, crime and violence including HIV/AIDS issues. In order for the department to implement the Youth Policy the National Action Plan for Youth has been developed. The action plan outlines the activities that need to be carried out, the timeframes of such actions as well as agencies that must act upon these. It operationalizes the youth policy and states strategies and priority area of action. The Division of Youth at district level is tasked with the responsibility of providing grants for empowerment of Youth, conducting seminars for skills training and assisting the Youth Council with aspects of youth development. 11.2.3 Disability Policies The Government of Botswana, a few years after attaining independence, began to gauge the need for helping people with disabilities. The Multi- Sectoral National policy for people with disabilities was developed to guide those parties interested in disability issues, in order to involve them in the process effectively. The policy objective is to combat the incidence of disability and to promote the quality of life for people with disabilities. Among others, the principles of National Policy for Care of People with disabilities will be: Recognition and protection of human rights and dignity of every individual To ensure that the person with disabilities has a responsibility and a right to determine his/her own well-being. To ensure that the integration of the person with disability into society is actively promoted. To ensure that equal opportunities of all members of society are aimed at, but will vary according to the needs and abilities of the individual. The district has one rehabilitation officer who is responsible for the welfare of disabled persons. There are 1309 registered people with disabilities in the district and most of them have physical disabilities. There are no special schools/centres within the district for people with disabilities. We therefore sent screened children with disabilities to appropriate schools/centres in areas where they are located. In its endeavour to implement the policy at district level, the health department [clinics] provides the following services to people with disabilities: 116 11.2.4 Screening/assessment of persons with disabilities and refer them to appropriate rehabilitation centres/specialists for advanced care and advice. Placement of children with disabilities in special schools/centres according to their disabilities. People with disabilities are supplied with appliances/mobility aids such as wheelchairs, walking frames and walking frames. Workshops and seminars are organised for people with disabilities and their families in order to sensitise and educate them on various services and programmes available in the district that are meant to benefit all persons with disabilities through out the district. Social Welfare The Revised National Policy on Destitute Persons is designed to assist the individuals within the society, who due to their lack of capabilities cannot provide for the families basic human needs such as food, shelter and clothing. Most of the beneficiaries of the destitute programme are the disabled, old people, children in need of care, drought induced people, and the mentally handicapped. The Revised Policy comes up with a number of measures ranging from the defination of destitute persons, eligibility for assistance, types of assistence, rehabilitation and many others. The department of Social and Community Development sees to it that the destitute policy is implemented in the district by assisting the genuine destitute persons to ensure their good health and welfare. 11.2.5 Women and Development Accordingly a Policy on Women in Development has been developed to improve the status of women and provide a basis for continuous review and monitoring of women’s issues in the development process. The main goal of the Policy is to achieve effective integration and empowerment of women in order to improve their status, enhance participation in decision-making and role in the development process. The department of Social and Community Development is responsible for implementation of policy on women and development. At district level the home economist unit under the department of Social and Community Development deals with empowerment of women through formation of income generating groups. The groups in question are, Shanganani candle group, Laedza piggery, Bonatla Small Stock and Tshwaragano Poultry Group. The unit also works in collaboration with the Women’s Affairs Department in organising the commemoration of international women’s day every year in March and mobilizes communities to participate in gender workshops and seminars. 11.2.6 Sports and Recreational Policy The Department of Sport and Recreation has developed a National Sport Policy that demonstrates a declaration by the Government to awaken sports consciousness in the entire citizenry and ensure mass and elite participation in sports for the attainment of physical, mental, social and moral development of the people. The purpose of the sports and recreation policy is to provide a framework for the development of an active, healthy and productive society, in line with the national long-term vision. The Department of Sports and Recreation in Masunga has been able to initiate and implement various sports development programmes as part of the ‘strategy for developing the nation on through sport’. Such initiatives are Junior Sports Development Program, District Sports Festival. The junior sports development program, which will be held in June 2003, 117 aims at developing sporting skills, promoting fun and enjoyment as well as encouraging young people to participate in sporting activities. The district sports festival, which is held annually, involves young and old generations to show their capability by playing both morden and cultural sports such as koi, mmele, morabaraba etc. These activities are held annually. 11.2.7 National Registration Act The Department of National and Civil Registration is mandated by the National Registration Act of 1986 to register all citizens aged 16 years and above for purposes of issuing them with National Identity Cards (OMANG). Embedded in the issuance and use of Omang is the security element. The Civil Registration division is responsible for administration of the Lotteries and Betting Act and the Change of Name Act. At the district level the department is responsible registration of births, deaths, marriage and issuing of identity cards. 11.2.8 Information Media Policy The functions of the Department of Information and Broadcasting were laid down in the 1969 Policy as: To interpret the policy and actions of Government to the people by continuing service of information and public relations, and campaigns and concentrated publicity on particular subjects. To encourage and assist the people of Botswana to take an increasing interest in and responsibility for the economic, cultural and political development of their country. To advice Government on public opinion and in the field of public relations. To develop and exploit media which will assist Ministries and Departments in performing their routine and extension duties. To publicise Botswana outside its borders. The Sekakangwe Hill FM Radio and TV terrestrial transmitters have been commissioned and Radio Botswana FM signal are effectively accessed on FM 91.9 meter band. Botswana television signal is clear with the help of just a roof-mounted aerial. 11.3 LABOUR, CULTURE AND SOCIAL SERVICES 11.3.1 Sports and Recreation The department of sports and Recreation is responsible for promotion and development of sports and recreation activities in the country in line with the pillars of Vision 2016. The theme for sports during NDP9 will be “Sport for National Development: Maintaining the Momentum Towards 2016”. This will be effected through the implementation of the National Sport and Recreation Policy. The department has constructed an integrated sport facility in the district. In addition it will continue to network with the Botswana National Youth Council, Botswana National Sport Council, Local Authorities, Department of Youth and Culture with a view to extending opportunities beyond the school day by encouraging these bodies to provide a range of after school activities for all pupils irrespective of their age. The mandate of the Department in Masunga is to implement various sports development initiatives as part of the ‘strategy for developing the nation on through sport’. Such initiatives are Junior Sports Development Program, District Sports Festival. The junior sports development program aims at developing sporting skills, promoting fun 118 and enjoyment as well as encouraging young people to participate in sporting activities. The district sports festival involves young and old generations to show their capability by playing both morden and old traditional games such as koi, mmele, morabaraba etc. These activities are held annually. 11.3.2 Social Welfare The Division of Social Services, which falls under the Ministry of Local Government develops, coordinates, monitors and evaluates implementation of social services programmes, with particular focus on among others, vulnerable groups such as children, destitutes, female headed households, women and people with disabilities. To fulfill its mandate, the department networks with local and international agencies. This mandate is consistent with creating a compassionate, just and caring nation. The Division, also gives financial support to NGOs that provide welfare services, such as Botswana Christian Council, Day Care Centres and several other welfare providing NGOs. In an effort to provide income maintenance to the elderly, an Old Age Pension Scheme was introduced in 1996, by the Government, which pays all Batswana over the age of 65 and above. During DDP6, the division of social services will pursue the following programmes: 11.3.3 Child Welfare Services and Protection of Children’s Rights Provide Orphan Care Services Provide Family Welfare Services which entail AIDS in the work place. Provide Community Home Based Care Programme and Casework. Home Economics and Early Childhood Education and Care Program Culture and Youth The department of Culture and Youth is charged with the responsibility to coordinate and preserve culture and to create an enabling environment for Youth and the general public to participate in cultural development in this country. The department of Culture and Youth is composed of Culture and Performing Arts, Youth and National Celebration Divisions. However, only the Division of Youth is represented in the district. Youth work was initially with the Ministry of Local Government under the Social and Community Development Department. The department was transferred to the Ministry of Labour and Home Affairs following the recommendation of the 1985 Organisation and Methos Review Exercise. Subsequently, the Youth offices were established in the district in April 2000. The Division of Youth is tasked with the responsibility of providing grants for empowerment of Youth, conducting seminars for skills training and assisting the Youth Council with aspects of youth development. To fulfil its mandate, the department is guided by the National Youth Policy, which was adopted in 1996, the National Action Plan for Youth, which was approved by Parliament in June 2001, and the National Policy on Culture, which was adopted in December 2001. 11.3.4 National Library Service The Botswana National Library Service does not have offices in the Library is planned for DDP6/NDP9. The department’s mission is information and promote its utilization for educational, research Provision of services is through a network of public, educational and District. However, Branch to provide the nation with and recreational purposes. special libraries. The North 119 East residents are currently using Francistown Library when ever they need information while still waiting for the one proposed under NDP9. The core responsibilities of the department are: To provide and manage the public library system through the establishment of branch libraries, reading rooms and mobile libraries. To advise Government, Parastatals, Non-Governmental Organisations in the development of their libraries and information centres. To collect and preserve for posterity, literacy culture of Botswana. All these activities will contribute towards the achievement of an educated and informed nation, which will in the long run translate into a prosperous, productive, innovative and accountable nation. 11.3.5 Civil and National Registration The Department of Civil and National Registration in the North East is responsible for registration of births, deaths, marriages, trade unions and employees’ organizations as well as administration of the Lotteries and Betting Act and the Change of Name Act. The Department started its operation in the district in 2003. The department is experiencing a serious problem of people not coming to collect their identity cards, birth, and death certificates. Through workshops and kgotla meetings people are encouraged to come forward and collect their certificates and identity cards. The department is mandated by the National Registration Act of 1986 to register all citizens aged 16 years and above for purposes of issuing them with National Identity Cards ‘Omang’. Embedded in the issuance and use of Omang is the security element. As such the use of Omang will in the long run facilitate, to some extent, the attainment of a safe and secure nation. The national Identity cards are also important in; 11.3.6 Providing some of the necessary data used for effective district planning and formulation of socio-economic policies. Ensure that only persons eligible for voting in the general elections do vote in the North East District. Fighting against criminal activities in the case of fraud and other fake claims in the North East District. Women and Development The Government of Botswana recognises the wide-ranging contribution of women to the socioeconomic, political and cultural development of the nation. Government further recognises that the contemporary situation of women warrants the existence of effective national machinery, at a recognizable level, to adequately articulate women’s issues and needs. Specific strategies adopted as a means to improve the status of women ensure that: Specific and sectoral policies are gender sensitive. The education sector develop specific strategies to educate and train more women, especially for employment purposes. The economic planning and employment sectors adopt programmes to eliminate/eradicate household poverty. 120 Planning system take into account women’s contribution to sustainable development [including the informal activities of women in the home, agriculture, etc]. National legislation, customs and socio-cultural values are reformed to ensure gender equality and equity as well as the advacement of women. Gender analysis and impact assessment frameworks and research are developed and continuously reviewed. At district level the home economist unit under the department of Social and Community Development deals with empowerment of women through formulation of income generating groups. There are currently four groups in Masingwaneng which, are funded by the Women’s Affairs department through Home Economist unit to undertake various projects. The groups in question are, Shanganani candle group, Laedza piggery, Bonatla small stock and Tshwaragano poultry group. 11.3.7 Museums, Monuments and Art Gallery The primary goal of the National Museum is to preserve and promote Botswana’s cultural properties for now and for prosperity. Oral traditions also form part an integral part of this process. This is achieved through: Collection of natural and cultural objects for storage and display. Information generation and dissemination to the public through available media. Research into art, natural sciences, ethnography, archaeology and education. Networking with other professional local and international organisations. Identification and establishment of cultural and natural monuments or landscapes. There is potential in the district for Community Based Natural Resource Management as there are some historical sites such as Domboshaba Ruins, Vukwi Ruins, Mambindi Ruins at Jackalas II and Rock Paintings that communities, could use for tourism. 11.3.8 Non-Governmental Organisations 11.3.8.1 Environmental Heritage Foundation [EHF] Botswana The Environmental Heritage Foundation [EHF] exists to provide an effective and efficient fund administrative and project management structure in the form of a model that serves to empower NGO’s and community based organisations (CBO’s), which implement community environmental and conservation projects. Environmental Heritage Foundation has established a Satellite Office in the city of Francistown that aims to provide services to the communities of the region more effectively and efficiently. The office shall provide services relating to environmental conservation and activism to the communities in the northern region of Botswana including the Central District, Ngamiland, Chobe and the North East District. 11.3.8.2 Rural Industries Promotions Company (Botswana) [RIPCO ( B)] Rural Industries Promotions Company [Botswana] RIPCO (B) administers special project activities in the areas of photovoltaic electricity, that provides lighting to rural settlements, and community environmental conservation that builds empowerment and capacity for communities to implement natural resources related project activities. 121 During the plan [DDP6] period RIPCO (B) would pioneer to develop a satellite office in the city of Francistown or within the surrounding areas as part of its decentralisation strategic intent. The office shall provide services to northern Botswana. This would entail a requirement for industrial and residential purposes for the company to have substantial presence in the North East district during the span of DDP6, for which a request is therefore being made. 11.4 LABOUR, CULTURE AND SOCIAL SERVICES SECTOR GOALS AND OBJECTIVES Table 11.2: Labour, Culture and Social Services Sector Goals Goals Culture and Youth To promote the participation and contribution of young women and men in Botswana’s socio – economic development. To develop a coordinated contribution and participation by all stakeholders involved in youth development programmes and activities. To promote social responsibilities amongst the youths. To fight the spread of HIV/AIDS among the youths. To promote active participation of young people in recreation sports and leisure. To recognise, and promote young peoples’ talents. Immigration/National Registration To register all qualified citizens who are eligible for registration and distribution of National Identity Card. Objectives To grant 18 out of school youths funds to start income generating projects. To conduct one (1) business management skills workshop for out of school youths every year. To conduct youth development stakeholder workshop every year. To conduct one (1) leadership workshop for out of school youths every year. To conduct one (1) peer education workshop for out of schools every year. To conduct two (2) HIV/AIDS awareness workshops for out of school youths every year. To provide six (6) youth groups recreation equipment during the plan period. To conduct two youth rallies every year. To undertake 4 field trips in the North East District to register and distribut ready identity cards annually starting 2003. To address kgotla meetings on issues affecting National Registration during the year 2004. To facilitate the formation of National Registration Act in identifying illegal immigrants. To address stake holders, councillors and chiefs during year 2004. To sensitise villagers along the boarder line of the dangers of false declaration during visits at Jackalas 1, Moroka, Mapoka, Nlapkhwane, Mbalambi and Gungwe. To inform Chiefs and community of North East District on the implication of non-citizens obtaining National Identity Cards annually starting April 2003-2006. Civil Registration To reduce number of incomplete birth, death and stillbirth forms in North East by March 2006. To reduce the number of customary letters based on assumption by headmen/sub-chiefs in the North East by March 2006. To reduce the number of pending births, deaths and stillbirths certificate in the North East by the year 2006. To promote efficiency and effectiveness among civil registration staff by March 2006 Information and Broadcasting To increase consumption of DIB products and services through continuous marketing and promotions. To increase accessibility to DIB products and services to atleast 95% of the audience. To improve working conditions within DIB within DIB for increased productivity and motivation. Sports And Recreation To promote mass participation in sport and recreation regardless of age, To correct pending birth, death and stillbirth forms in ten villages by calling informants and undertaking home visits trips in North East every year. To create awareness for Tribal Administration staff working in the North East district on the importance of registering customary marriages every year. To distribute 90 % of pending certificates in all the villages in the North East through trips by March 2003. To serve the public in an effective and efficient manner in the North East District by March 2003. To put in place a mechanism to ensure continuous research to determine audience needs and develop a training strategy to maximise utilization of available resources by the end of the plan period. To expand the reach of all DIB products and services by 2004. To adopt strategic management principles in order to achieve effective communication and develop human resources. To ensure that all Batswana are aware of the benefits of participation in 122 Goals gender and ability through community based programmes, provision of facilities and mobilisation of voluntees. Women and Development To lobby and advocate for the economic empowerment of and poverty alleviation among women, children, youth and the most vulnerable. Objectives sport and recreation and have equal opportunities to become involved in all aspects of sport and recreation. To review public policy programmes and implementation. To lobby for a comprehensive social safety net for the most vulnerable. To lobby and advocate for equal participation in leadership and decision making at the family, community, local and national level. To undertake research and develop business skillsTo advocate for strategic programmes to children and the youth. To sensitise chiefs, members of parliament and and development issues particularly on power making. and entrepreneurship target poverty among councillors on gender sharing and decision To sensitise varios stakeholders on gender and development issues particularly on power sharing and decision making. To review all education policies and programmes with a view of mainstreaming gender at all levels of the education system. To review existing policies, structures and programmes thet have an impact in the area of power sharing and decision making. To lobby and advocate for implementation for the pre-school recommendations in the National Commission on Education. To review and analyse existing NGO pre-shool programmes for gender sensitivity. To review the entry age policy. Environmental Heritage Foundation To diversify the fund management environmental financing by 2006 portfolio for sustainable To increase the investment portfolio for EHF’s sustainability in Northern Botswana by 2006 To strengthen and diversify partnerships in the North East District by 2006 11.5 To establish an endowment fund through seed capital from Government, Private Sector, Donor community and others to yield returns for environmental financing by May 2005 To enhance the institutional capacity of EHF for fund management portfolio through strengthening human resources, constructing office building, acquisition of transport facilities and development of a marketing plan by May 2004 To generate income through consultancy services, service delivery undertakings, information services in the North East District by May 2004 To increase relationships with Government, Private sector, Donors and NGOs/CBOs, in the North East District through joint consultancies and joint environmental projects by 2004. FRAMEWORK FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT Table 11.3: Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues with Sector Goals and Objectives Goals To promote participation and contribution of young women and men in socioeconomic development Register all qualified citizens who are eligible for registration and distribution National Identity Cards To reduce the number of pending births, deaths and stillborn certificates within the district To increase accessibility to Department of Information and Broadcasting products and services Objectives To conduct workshops,youth ralies and grant out of school youths with funds to start income generating projects. To address kgotla meetings, stake holders and undertake trips within the district to register and distribute identity cards. To distribute 90% of all pending certificates in all villages around the district To expand the reach of all DIB products and services by 2004 Environment Key Issues Littering Strategy Provide sanitary facilities Littering Provide sanitary facilities - - - - 123 11.5.1 Environmental Education and Awareness Creation Sustainable development demands an environmental conscious nation and in the current development plan period a deliberate effort has been put to consider environmental goals in the development hierarchy. The capacity of communities, officers, individuals and organisations in setting and executing environmental goals may need particular attention as notable from DDP 6 consultation meetings. Outcries for these incapacities have always been noted from country wide consultations through workshops, meetings and seminars conducted by EHF too. On that note EHF has laid specific programs that shall have diverse target groups so as to instil and integrate environmental activism during the plan period. The program shall include specific interventions such as: 11.5.2 Community mobilisation methodologies and campaign strategies. Training of community leaders (CBO’s , Tribal and Local authorities, and Politicians). Training of Land Board members, Technical Officers and Administrative machinery. Training of Agricultural Resource Conservation Committees. Training of District Planners and Officers on EIA and its incorporation into District Planning and implementation processes. Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) And Strategic Environmental Planning (SEP) Conserving the environment can only be realised through careful and considerate execution of economic and social goals. That requires prioritisation and multi-faceted approach to development. Methodologies such as EIAs and SEPs have been put in place to make harmoniously pursuing development objectives cognisant of environmental and ecological considerations. EHF shall provide consulting expertise in Government and Private Sector developments that may so require undertaking these crucial and critical exercises that mitigate the impact of economic and development projects. 11.5.3 Funding for Community Environmental Projects During the plan period, EHF shall continue to mobilise and effectively manage funds for community environmental management and conservation purposes. This shall entail liaison and commitment from financing and supporting partners such as Private Sector, donors and Government to continue replenishing EHF’s established and modest Trust Fund. EHF shall continue to support community projects that lay emphasis on environmental education and awareness creation, waste management, range land degradation, fuel - wood depletion, biological diversity, and pollution of water, air and soil. Some of the community projects that have been considered for initial support in the North East District are attached to this submission. 11.5.4 Dissemination of Environment and Land Related Legislations Environmental management and land resources management usually suffer a tragedy of the commons syndrome. This can only be controlled through appropriate legislation of which EHF shall take a leading role in disseminating, for assimilation into our culture, values and norms. Living examples of the information to be disseminated include waste management, overexploitation of natural resources, veld fires and others. 124 11.5.5 Review of Policies and Legislations The EHF shall continue to take part in structures and forum through which valuable ideas and inputs that relate to good governance for the sole purpose of sustainable development can be provided. Such structures shall include local, district, regional, national and international platforms where EHF would take active participation in ensuring that the necessary reviewed are generated. Table 11.4: Evaluation of Sector Policies and Programs Policies & Programs National Youth Policy Disability Policy Destitute Policy Sports & Recreation Policy National Registration Act Information Media Policy 11.6 Goals/Objectives To promote the participation and contribution of young women and men in Botswana’s socio-economic development To combat the incidence of disability and promote the quality of life for people with disability Ensures that destitute persons are provided with human basic needs like food, shelter and clothing To provide a framework for the development of active, healthy and productive society, in line with the national longterm vision Ensures that registration of eligible persons is carried out efficiently. Ensures that people have access to the services provided by the DIB Environmental Issues Indiscriminate littering Indiscriminate littering - STRATEGIES TO ACHIEVE THE LABOUR, CULTURE AND SOCIAL SERVICE SECTOR GOALS AND OBJECTIVES Table 11.5: Strategies to Achieve Labour, Culture and Social Services Goals and Objectives Proposed Projects Immigration/National Registration Workshops and Seminars Environmental Impact Mitigation Measures Resources Littering Provision of dust-bins and plastic bags. Transport Finance Provision of refuse bags Human Resource Civil Registration Home visits trips and Kgotla meetings Enlighten health personnel on the importance of correct completion of birth, death and still births forms through seminars. Seminars/Workshop Sports and Recreation District Sports Administration Workhops Littering Provide refuse bags Human resource Littering Provide refuse bags Human resource Districrt Sports Festivals Littering Provide refuse bags Human resource ie. coaches Junior Sports Programme National Library Service 125 Branch Library [Masunga Bush Clearing Re-planting trees/shrubs Sand/soil excavation Clearing rubles Building waste/rubble creation Identification collection Increased demand Culture and Youth Conduct youth rallies and workshops Community Environmental Initiatives at Tati Siding Conservation Waste Management Partnerships in Masunga and Catchment area sand water Littering Environmental Heritage Foundation [EHF] Community Empowerment for Environmental Management at Matsiloje Village Development of a Nature and Culture Preservation Site at Jackalas No.1 Village of -Land -Plant seedlings -Funds for human resourse, transport and equipment Provide refuse containers and clean the area after activity. Bush clearing Bush clearing No anticipated impacts. Finance, human and transport. Finance, human and transport. None Proper planning Undertake inventory and vegetation studies Proper selection of plant species suitable for the area E.I.A - 11.7 RESOURCE REQUIREMENTS FOR DDP6 11.7.1 Issues and Strength For Labour, Culture and Social Services Finance, human and transport. Finance, human and transport. - 11.7.1.1 Strengths The existence of a guideline in the form of the youth policy, National Action Plan, Sports and recreation policies, and other programmes. Availability of programmes and funding to address vulnerable groups. The establishment of the Botswana National Youth Awards to honour youth contribution to the country’s development is an incentive for youth to actively participate in the development of the country. 11.7.1.2 Issues 11.7.2 Lack of capacity in terms of resources, like shortage of staff and unskilled manpower. Youth issues are dealt with by different organisations and lack of a coordinated effort is a disadvantage. Inadequate empowerment of District Youth Council hampers their youth development duty. Lack of funds to undertake projects Performance Targets for DDP6 Performance targets for DDP6 will be measured in terms of the projects to be implemented each financial year of the plan. Implementation of the projects is phased in accordance with priority. 126 Table 11.6: Performance Targets for DDP6 Project Workshops, seminars, youth ralies, kgotla meetings, sports festivals Construct LA 2, Non Formal Office Location District Branch Library Masunga Development of a Nature and Cultural Preservation Site Jackalas II 11.7.3 Tsamaya Goal/Objective Facilitate active participation by all stakeholders. Reduce office accommodation backlog. To provide a conducive learning environment for everyone in the district. Preserve natural resources. Performance Indicator Conducting all intended activities during the plan period. Completion of the projects by 2006. Completion of the project by 2007. Nature and Culture site being being developed by the end of the plan period. Development Budget for DDP6 Table 11.7: Development Budget for DDP6 Component Branch Library Basic Business skills workshop Skills training Leadership courses Youth festivals 11.7.4 Location Masunga District Cost (P) 16 100 000 10 000 2003/04 2004/05 2005/06 2006/07 2007/08 2008/09 10 000 10 000 10 000 10 000 10 000 10 000 District District 15 000 10 000 15 000 10 000 15 000 10 000 15 000 10 000 15 000 10 000 15 000 10 000 15 000 10 000 District 15 000 15 000 15 000 15 000 15 000 15 000 15 000 Plan Monitoring Program To monitor implementation of projects and programmes, quarterly progress reports will be prepared and circulated to the relevant ministries and stakeholders. In addition, review of implementation will be conducted midway through the plan where recommendation will bee made on areas that need to be improved. During the DDP6, EHF shall continue to provide an efficient and effective fund administration and project management structure in the form of a partnership model that serves to empower NGO’s and community based organisations (CBO’s), which implement community environmental conservation projects. 127 CHAPTER 12 12 MINERALS, ENERGY AND WATER 12.1 INTRODUCTION This chapter main focus is on minerals, energy and water sector DDP 6 policies and programmes. Most of the policies and programmes are a continuation of the previous plan. The proposed projects and strategies are aimed at achieving vision 2016 ideals. The Ministry of Minerals, Energy and Water Resources (MMEWR) core responsibility is to coordinate, formulate and direct all national policies pertaining to water, energy and minerals. Of the seven pillars, a “Prosperous, Productive and Innovative Nation” is the one more inclined to the minerals, energy and water affairs ministry in different ways. With regard to minerals it envisages increased benefits from down stream processing of minerals and trade including diamond polishing and jewelling. In relation to energy, it recognizes that energy is a pre-requisite for successful industrialization and that Botswana must seek to develop cost effective sources of energy, and to cooperate with its neighbours to realize benefits from economies of scale in electricity generation and supply. With regard to water, the pillar refers to the development of the national and district water supply strategy that will make water affordable and accessible to all, including those who live in small and remote settlements. 12.1.1 Institutional Framework 12.1.1.1 Botswana Power Corporation (BPC) Botswana Power Corporation is a parastatal under MMEWR responsible for electricity generation and supply. 12.1.1.2 Water Affairs The Department of Water Affairs is responsible for national water resources planning and development at the national level. This is undertaken in consultations with major stakeholders such as Water Utilities Corporation, Ministry of Local Government, district councils, Ministry of Lands and Housing through Land Boards as well as the Ministry of Agriculture. The department also cooperates with District Council Health units, Ministry of Health and the National Conservation Strategic Coordinating Agency in the area of water quality. It must be noted that rural water supply and distribution is the responsibility of DWA at construction stage only, i.e. during design and construction section, later the projects are handed over to Council to operate and maintain. 12.1.1.3 Water Utilities Corporation Water Utilities Corporation, which is a parastatal within MMEWR is responsible for urban water supply and distribution hence its relevance to the North East District will not be discussed under this chapter. 128 12.1.1.4 Water and Waste Water The North East District Council Water and Waste Water Department is responsible for providing portable safe drinking water supply to 42 villages and 9 settlement areas as well as operation and maintenance of sewerage works in the District e.g Masunga, Tati Siding (still under construction) and all governmental institutions in the district. 12.1.1.5 Ministry of Agriculture The Ministry of Agriculture is responsible for agricultural water development. 12.1.2 Strategic Planning Framework 12.1.2.1 Ministry of Minnerals, Ennergy and Water Resources The Ministry of Minerals, Energy and Water Resources vision fully commits it to complete customer satisfaction in the provision of products and services in accordance with best international practice. This vision envisages an organization with employees who are fully committed to serving their customers and stakeholders well, and processes that are customer focused. The vision also envisages world-class standards in the delivery of services. The proposed projects and strategies have taken cognisance of the goals and objectives of the Ministry’s strategic plan. 12.1.2.2 Ministry of Local Government The Ministry of Local Government through Councils is responsible for provision of basic physical and social infrastructure i.e. water, health care, primary education, roads network. The other responsibility is to ensure that there is efficient operation of local authorities through policy direction, capacity building and supervision. This mandate can only be achieved if the following key result areas are achieved: Customer satisfaction, policy implementation effectiveness, improved quality of life of communities, productivity and organizational effectiveness. 12.1.3 Role of the Private Sector The private sector plays a minor role in the district with regards to minerals, energy and water sector. However the mining sector has a significant role, as there are already two mines operating in the district, these are Phoenix mine in Matsiloje and Cement mine. Prospecting is still ongoing at Mopane where gold is to be mined. Regarding the water and energy sector the private sector does not play any significant role with no developments being undertaken by it. 12.1.4 Consultation Priorities The district is seriously affected by shortages of water as currently 48% of villages are experiencing acute water shortage. Hence during consultations communities continuously complained of lack of water in their respective villages. This was found to be exacerbated by illegal livestock watering as most boreholes have dried up. Furthermore, communities indicated that the Financial Assistance Policy projects exacerbated the problem of shortage of water, as they believe that the projects increased the use of water hence water demands were difficult to meet. The other issue raised was policy conflicts affecting water provisions and agricultural development policy. Communities complained that new agricultural policies do not come up with suggestions of 129 where to draw water or identify water sources to augment already existing sources, which are already overstrained, hence create unnecessary water shortages, which could be avoided. The other issue, which was of major concern to the communities, was illegal extraction of sand especially from companies outside the district. They felt that communities through VDC’s should be given the mandate to regulate extraction of aggregates from rivers, which run across their villages’ thereby creating employment and revenue for them. 12.2 NATIONAL POLICIES AND LEGISLATION 12.2.1 Waste Management Act The Waste Management Act is meant to provide ways of managing waste generation and disposal. If this act is not enforced effectively, waste generated could be dumped haphazardly at illegal sites and pollute aquifers, wetlands and the environment at large. Even though the act states that no person shall cause or effect movement of controlled waste within the country or the trans-boundary movement of controlled waste without being registered as a waste carrier. Currently there is only one registered waste carrier with the Department of Sanitation and Waste Management in the District. The strategy during DDP 6 would be to ensure that all existing waste carriers in the District are registered. 12.2.2 Minerals Policy The main objective of the minerals policy is to maximize economic benefits for the nation from development of mineral resources. According to the Department of Mines, before independence there were more than 50 gold mines in the North East District. Silver was also produced as a byproduct. Quite a number of mines such as Tekwane, Golden Eagle, Mop East Puel Nervack and Penhaloge and Rainbow still contain unworked gold reserves. The Tati Nickel mine is currently exploiting copper and nickel ore at Selkirk and Phoenix near Matsiloje at a rate of 3.6 million tonnes. Joren (Pty) Ltd operates Somerset mine near Sechele and produces some 36 000 tonnes of gold ore annually. The old gold/silver mines that are presently closed are Bonanza-Mineral Holdings on old Matsiloje road, Rainbow Mine- Kudu mining company- Matsiloje, Golden Eagle-Monarch Goldfield on old Matsiloje road and New Zealand in Matsiloje. 12.2.3 Energy Policy The objectives of the energy policy during DDP 6 are: Economic Efficiency, Energy Security, Social Equity, Environmental Quality and Sustainability and Gender Equity. A large proportion of the District population use fuel wood for cooking and lighting. There is generally shortage of fuel wood in the District as a whole. The use of coal as a source of energy is very limited in the District. According to 1991 Housing and Population Census, there were only 5 households or less than 1% using coal in the entire District. 130 Solar energy is not widely used except in secondary schools, where it is used for heating and for electric fencing in some commercial farms. Even though the District enjoys sunshine most parts of the year, the use of this resource is very limited. 12.2.4 The National Settlement Policy The policy’s main thrust is to provide a comprehensive set of guidelines for national physical planning and to provide a framework for guiding the distribution of investment in a way that reflects the settlements size, population, economic potential, level of infrastructure and their role as service centres. The major issue of concern is the provision of water to small settlement particularly those whose population is below 250. Therefore there should be harmonisation of National Settlement Policy and Water Act during DDP 6. The North East settlement strategy that is currently in draft form will augment the National Settlement Strategy by providing guidelines for the provision of services in human settlements. Since the policy recognizes a settlement when it has 250 people and provision of water can only be done when there are 150 people, there is a conflict in these two policies as they encourage mushrooming of villages thereby increasing water demand and the need to provide water rehabilitation services which in turn increases government’s costs in bringing essential services to the communities. There is need to harmonize the two policies so that mushrooming is controlled to some extent thereby cutting unnecessary costs of providing services to many scattered small settlements. 12.2.5 Tribal Land Act The Act provide for the establishment of tribal land boards and sub – Land board. In terms of the act custody of tribal land rests with the Land Board. Generally, tribal land comprises residential, agricultural and commercial areas. Tribal land has the highest densities of livestock and human populations than free hold. As a result there is shortage of tribal land in the District due to the fact that most of the land is under freehold. Therefore there is need to acquire more land to augment the existing land. 12.2.6 National Water Master Plan [NWMP] The key objective of the NWMP during DDP 6 will continue to be providing the framework for water development. The National Water Master Plan is a guiding plan for all large water development projects. 12.2.7 Water Policy The thrust of the water policy during the entire plan period will be to undertake a study with the view of improving the operation of the major villages water supply schemes. The study will among other things cover: placing all water distribution in the country under WUC, establishment of a number of regional water distribution agencies or companies and grouping the 17 major villages and nearby smaller villages with big villages operated by District Councils and 131 establishing an agency or company to run these, while the smaller villages continue to be operated by the District Councils. The District has several streams and rivers, all of which are ephemeral. The big rivers are Shashe, Vukwi, Tati, Ntshe, Sikukwe and Ramokgwebana. The rivers store a considerable amount of water in the sub-surface layer for most of the years. This water provides most of the residents with water for human and livestock consumption. Most of the surface water is not retained due to few large dams in the District. There are only two dams that have been developed in the District being Shashe dam on Shashe River and Madabe dam on Ramokgwebana River. There are other sources of water such as boreholes, wells and pits along these rivers. More than 30% of the boreholes drilled are dry while several have saline water especially in the Makaleng area. The yields range from 1 500 to 7 000 litres per hour. There are also numerous small dams constructed by Ministry Of Agriculture, which assist small farmers. There is generally shortage of water in the district even though there are several streams. Therefore construction of Ntimbale dam and Maitengwe well fields development project will help ease the problem of water shortages in the district. 12.3 MINING, ENERGY AND WATER 12.3.1 Mining Sector There are two privately owned mining operations in Matsiloje. These are gold and cement mining activities done at small scale-supplying consumers in the North East district and other areas in the vicinity of the district. Unfortunately the cement mining is not able to meet the demand for cement in the region. The other mining activity entails mining of sand and aggregates. Of these, gravel and river sand are extensively used within the district and neighboring towns for numerous construction projects that are carried out by the private contractors, government and individuals. Though impact analysis has not been undertaken, it is evident that the adverse effects of extraction have often resulted in loss of biodiversity and poor visual quality due to lack of rehabilitation. Gallery Gold that holds a mining lease is currently not in production. It has completed prefeasibility study over Mupane gold project near Matsiloje) in early 2002. The results were encouraging and the company is proceeding with a fully-fledged feasibility study. KCL Technologies was issued with a license in 1999, it operates a lime pit for cement and soapstone products near Matsiloje. The mine produces approximately 30 000 tonnes of lime stone annually. In addition Mobile Mixing Concrete extract sand from the rivers of Tati and Ntshe for construction purposes. Quarrying activities are carried out on the east of Tati Siding by Quarries of Botswana and it produces crushed stone for building and road construction at an annual rate of about 100 000 tonnes. 132 Most of the mining activities that exist in the District were carried out before the amendment of the Mines and Minerals Act. Then, it was not requirement to submit an Environmental Impact Assessment was undertaken and one good example is the quarrying activities in Tati Siding. 12.3.2 Energy Sector As investment and population continue to grow in North East, so will the demand for energy. While some people in the primary centers of the District use gas for their domestic needs, a significant proportion of the population still use firewood in the District. From the environmental point of view, this contributes to desertification and it is associated with negative impacts. Therefore there is need for legislation that would guide consumers, especially government institutions to use alternative sources of energy. Figure 1 shows the proportion of all households that use various energy sources for lighting, cooking and gives the trend in the proportion of households using different energy sources for heating from 1981 to 2001. 12.3.2.1 Solar Energy It has been realized that there is tremendous potential for solar energy, which should be exploited for the benefit of settlements that are not within reach of the national grid. The district in effort to conserve energy has been providing solar energy in institutional housing as an alternative for electricity. Provision of solar energy has also been done in areas without electrical power. At present solar energy in the district is limited to heating, electricity generation for powering telecommunications equipment, lighting and refrigeration in homes, schools and clinics. 12.3.2.2 Wind Energy Due to the fact that the wind speed in the country is low and as a result it is hardly used in the district maybe for pumping water in commercial farms. 12.3.2.3 Wood Fuel Fuel wood is the main source of cooking energy in the District. Individuals in the vicinity of small settlements collect wood free of charge. In large settlements it is generally purchased from traders who use donkey carts and motorized transport to fetch it from surrounding areas. Fuel wood is still the cheapest cooking fuel. The most worrying some factor is the depletion of fuel wood especially in areas along highways and railway lines. There is growing habit of cutting live trees firewood, which need to be addressed during DDP 6. There is shortage of fuel wood, and the reliance on wood could have serious negative impacts, as it would lead to the depletion of the remaining woodland in the District. Government Institutions would be encouraged to use alternative sources such as coal, solar energy and electricity during the plan period. 12.3.2.4 Coal Coal is hardly used in the district except in boarding school where it is used for heating water. The use of coal is generally hampered by the unavailability of affordable coal fire equipment, as the 133 ones currently available are very expensive. The other issue of concern is the quality of coal, which needs to be upgraded. 12.3.2.5 Electricity There is a 66kv line from Francistown to Masunga to service RAC, Senior Secondary School, Primary Hospital and several commercial and residential areas. Generally, power demand has been increasing. In the past, generators were used to provide electricity to residential areas and businesses. There are a handful of people who can afford private connection in the district due to high cost of installing transformers. This is due to lack of productive activities, employment and incomes in most villages. Electricity is mostly used for lighting. The availability of electricity has not necessarily influenced many people to apply for connections due to cost implications. The Government of Botswana has taken a step to connect 13 qualifying villages during DDP 6 under the rural electrification programme. These are Matenge, Butale, Sekuke, Mambo, Masingwaneng, Kgari, Letsholathebe, Sechele, Gulubane, Jackalas 2, Gambule, Mbalambi and Masukwane. The North East district has 42 villages and 20 have electricity while 13 will be connected during DDP 6 and the network for Masunga, Moroka and other five qualifying villages will be expanded as well during the current plan period. In addition the Department of Electrical and Mechanical services provides diesel generators in government institutions/offices located in villages, which are not connected to the national grid. 12.3.2.6 Paraffin and Gas Paraffin is predominantly used for lighting particularly in small villages and the prices are controlled and Value Added Tax is not levied on this source of fuel. Whereas the use of gas for cooking and heating has tremendously increased particularly in areas where fuel wood has been depleted. The price for gas is not controlled and as such is open to possible exploitation of the consumers, particularly the poor. 12.3.2.7 Energy, Conservation and Management The District will expand the use of solar even to areas where electricity exist in order to conserve energy. In addition the street lights which will be provided during the plan period will have auto switches to switch off during day time in order to reduce energy consumption. Table 12.1 Sources of Energy used in Households in Botswana for Lighting, Cooking and Space Heating Sources of energy Paraffin Gas Coal Electricity Wood Number Of households/proportion Heating Lighting 13 217.48 (1.22) 712 877 .20 (65.80) 12 350.76 (1.14) 10 834 (0.46) 1 191.74 (0.11) 29 576,82 (2.73) 144 308.88 (13.32) 87 7012.3 (80.95) 20 692.94 (1.91) Cooking 44 852.76 (4.14) 204 979.28 (18.92) 1 625.1 (0.15) 13 650.84 (1.26) 80 7891.38 (74.57) 134 Sources of energy Solar power Total Number Of households/proportion Heating Lighting 1 408.42 (0.13) 3 250.2 (0.30) Cooking 650.04 (0.06) Source: 2001 Population and Housing Census 12.3.3 Water Sector 12.3.3.1 Water Supply and Water Demand The current water demand in the North East District is 8400 cubic meters per day. It is worth mentioning that water demand is continuously increasing as during the year 2001 the demand stood at 3916 cubic meters per day. However there is a shortfall of 484 cubic meters of water per day in the North East District. Water supply situation in the North East District is worsening since there is lack of rainfall, which causes borehole yields to drop. To address this problem the Council has resorted to bowsing in severely affected villages and completion of Maitengwe Well field project and Ntimbale Dam will help solve this serious shortage of water. The North East District Council is responsible for supplying portable water to 42 villages, 5 settlements and 3 matimela kraals. The supply is from 49 boreholes, 4 collector wells, 1 Department of Water Affairs connection and 3 Water Utilities connections. The Council buys water from Water Utilities Corporation for Masunga, Tati Siding and Matshelagabedi at high rates and then subsidies at village rates. 12.3.3.2 Water Quality All customers should be provided with adequate and good quality water to enhance quality of life and facilitate economic development. The main source of water for rural villages is ground water and the district complies with standards set by Botswana Bureau of Standards to ensure that water provided is of good quality. Currently water is being supplied from Francistown, Maitengwe/Goshwe development and underground water from boreholes in some villages. In others water is pumped from Francistown into bowsers then taken to villages with acute water shortages. The water quality in the District is generally fine except in areas which has been contaminated by pit latrines e.g. Matsiloje area. 12.3.3.3 Water Conservation and Management The sustainability of the districts development depends on the conservation and management of water sources. Attention should be paid to improve planning and administrative measures required to protect water resources from over development and deterioration in quality. This would be managed by increased education and participation by communities in natural resources conservation. The district has embarked on rainwater harvesting technique through provision of rainwater tanks in all institutional housing, schools, clinic etc. This will go a long way in conservation the muchneeded water in the district. 135 12.4 MINERALS, ENERGY AND WATER SECTOR GOALS AND OBJECTIVES Table 12.2: Minerals, Energy and Water sector Goals and Objectives Goals To improve the quality of life of communities in the North East District by providing safe, palatable and good quality water together with good sanitation and effluent disposal. Objectives To develop Maitengwe well field water transmission pipeline to 33 villages in the North East District by the year 2004/05. To rehabilitate water sources in 15 villages of the North East by the year2005/ 2006. To improve water reticulation in 17 villages in the North East by the year 2009. To rehabilitate and expand Masunga sewerage scheme, upgrade Tatisiding sewerage scheme and construct new ones in Matshelagabedi, Tshesebe and Tsamaya by the year 2008/2009. To provide adequate and affordable energy services to households and rural communities and provide a basic essential to economic development. To promote conservation and protection of mineral resources through development and implementation of effective mineral conservation, protection strategy and policies. To construct Ntimbale and Dikgathong dams and conduct a feasibility study and detailed design for Madabe dam by 2004/05 To electrify two qualifying villages per financial year effective 2004/05. To expand power lines network for six villages effective 2003/04. To provide streetlights by 2005/06. To provide a conducive environment for prospecting and new mine development by 2008/09. To identify and develop strategies for dealing with extraction of aggregates from rivers by 2008/09. To ensure environmental protection through use of environmentally friendly technologies throughout the plan period. 12.5 FRAMEWORK FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT Table 12.3: Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues with Sector Goals and Objectives Goals To improve the quality of life of communities in the North East District by providing safe, palatable and good quality water together with good sanitation and effluent disposal. Objectives To develop Maitengwe well field water transmission pipeline to 33 villages in the North East District by the year 2008/2009. Environmental Issues Disturbance of soil organisms. To rehabilitate water sources in 15 villages of the North East by the year 2005/ 2006. Improper disposal of solid and liquid waste Provision of dustbins/skips Burrow pits Burrow pits rehabilitation Cutting of trees Replanting of trees living Strategies EIA(new projects) Re- planting of trees Cutting of live trees Provide sanitary facilities To improve water reticulation in 17 villages in the North East by the year 2008/ 2009. To rehabilitate and expand Masunga sewerage scheme, upgrade Tatisiding sewerage scheme and construct new ones in Matshelagabedi, Tshesebe and Tsamaya by the year 2008/ 2009. To provide adequate and affordable energy services to households and rural communities and provide a basic essential to economic development. To construct Ntimbale and Dikgathong dams and conduct feasibility study and detailed design for Madabe dam by 2004/05. To electrify two qualifying villages per financial year effective 2004/05. To expand power lines network for six villages effective 2003/04. To provide auto switches to switch off streetlights during daytime to reduce energy consumption by 2005/06. Disturbance organisms of soil living Provision of dustbins/skips Littering 136 Table 12.4: Evaluation of Sector Policies and Programs Policies/Programs Waste Management Act Minerals Policy Energy Policy National Settlement Policy Tribal Land Act National Water Master Plan 12.6 Objectives Provide ways of managing waste generation disposal. Maximize economic benefits for the nation from development of mineral resources. Provide a least mix of supply reflecting total life cycle costs externalities such as environmental damage. Provide a comprehensive set of guidelines for national physical planning. Establishment of tribal land boards. Provide basis for water development projects. Environmental Issues Air pollution Haphazard dumping Environmental degradation Wood depletion Air pollution due to high carbon content fuel Overgrazing Soil erosion Deforestation STRATEGIES TO ACHIEVE THE MINERALS, ENERGY AND WATER SECTOR Table 12.5: Minerals, Energy and Water Sector Strategies Proposed Project Construction of Ntimbale Dam & Dikgathong Dams. Potential Impacts Cutting of trees Mitigation Measures Environmental Impact Assessment to be carried out. Land degradation Re-planting of trees where necessary. Change of land use Systematic Water Quality Monitoring Programme. Water supply rehabilitation (including tank). Migrant work force Nil Effect of machinery on environment Nil Proper waste disposal measures undertaken [provision of waste bins]. to be Cutting of trees, littering, dust. Tanks water reticulation and standpipes. Development/Extension of sewerage scheme. Purchase of pick up vehicle, water bowsers and truck with crane. Interconnect to neighbour water supply. Expand water offices and furnish them. Purchase of workshop equipment. Cutting of trees, land degradation Cutting of trees, land degradation, migrant workforce. Nil Cutting of trees Littering. Cutting of trees, harvesting of aggregates (burrow pits). Nil 12.7 RESOURCE REQUIREMENTS FOR DDP 6 12.7.1 Issues and Strengths Re-planting of trees, water sprinkling. Selective cutting of trees. Selective cutting of trees. Nil Selective cutting of trees. Provision of waste bins. Reclamation of burrow pits. Landscaping. Nil There is uncontrolled collection of sand and quarrying activities in the District, which needs serious attention as the building operations continue to increase. Therefore planning sites for such activities in the District is an urgent need. There is also a serious depletion of vegetation due to thatch collection and cutting of trees for building operations, firewood and trading purposes. This scenario is further compounded by 137 problems of overgrazing and overstocking. The District should consider preserving indigenous species of vegetation especially trees. Tree planting programmes will also be encouraged and promoted through individual effort, Community, NGO’s, Private Sector, etc. Another issue worth mentioning is shortage of water in some villages in the District. As a result some villages are bowsed from other alternative sources. The construction of Ntimbale, Dikgathong and Madabe dams will alleviate the problem. 12.7.2 Development Budget Table 12.6: Development Budget Project Name & Title LG 1110- District Water Supply and Waste Water MR 106 – Renewable, Energy and Power Development MR 301 - Water Planning and Development 12.7.3 Project Component Water Supply Rehabilitation Including tank) Tanks and water reticulation Tanks, water reticulation & standpipes Water reticulation & standpipes Development/extension of sewerage scheme Purchase Pick up vehicles Purchase of water bowsers Purchase of truck with crane Interconnect to neighbour water supply Expansion of water offices Purchase of workshop equipment Electrification of 13 villages and network expansion of 7 villages Construction of Dikgathong dam Construction of Ntimbale dam Madabe dam (Study, feasibility study & detailed design) Amount Allocated 2 300 000 1 462 000 3 875 000 6 851 000 41 312 000 700 000 1 200 000 1 000 000 15 520 000 2 000 000 380 000 530 296 000 (National) 813 341 000 173 122 000 2 735 000 Implementation Year 2004/05 – 2008/09 2004/05 2004/05 2004/5 – 2008/09 2004/05 – 2008/09 2004/05 – 2008/09 2004/05 - 2006/07 2005/06 2004/05 - 2005/06 2004/05 2004/05 - 2008/09 2004/05 - 2008/09 2004/05 2004/05 2004/05 Performance Targets and Plan Monitoring Program Table 12.7: Performance Indicators and Plan monitoring Objectives To develop Maitengwe well field and Ntimbale dam water transmission pipeline to 33 villages in the North East District by the year 2004/05. To rehabilitate water sources in 15 villages of the North East by the year 2006. Indicators Maitengwe well field and Ntimbale dam constructed by 2005/06. Water sources in 15 villages by 2005/06. To improve water reticulation in 17 villages in the North East by the year 2009. Water reticulation in 17 villages improved by 2008/09. To rehabilitate and expand Masunga sewerage scheme, upgrade Tatisiding sewerage scheme and construct new ones in Matshelagabedi, Tshesebe and Tsamaya by the year 2003/ 2004. To electrify two qualifying villages per financial year effective 2004/05. Masunga and Tati Siding sewerage schemes rehabilitated and expanded and new ones constructed in 3 villages effective 2003/04 2008/09. To expand power lines network for 6 villages effective 2003/04. -To provide streetlights by 2005/06. Monitoring Through reports to Drought relief committee, District Development Committee & Council Management. Two villages electrified effective 2004/05. Reports to Drought Relief Committee, District Development Committee and Council Management. Power network expanded for six villages by 2008/09 138 CHAPTER 13 13 WORKS, TRANSPORT AND COMMUNICATIONS 13.1 INTRODUCTION The District infrastructure development continues to be an important government framework in poverty alleviation. Programmes such as labour intensive earth roads construction have provided temporary employment to unskilled labour but despite these positive aspects limited funding and resources have hindered infrastructure development of the district. Provision of a web of road network, street-lighting, storm water drainage, culverts and drifts play a vital role for the people since it renders easier access to essential services such as health, education etc. Provision of better means of conveyance through proper road network benefit communities through time saved and less travel costs leaving a considerable amount of income at the disposal of communities. Communication through postal services and telecommunication is essential if the district is to be capacitated to compete for investors. This will go a long way in poverty alleviation as investment brings employment opportunities for rural dwellers. In an endeavor to address prosperous, productive and innovative pillar, the District will construct roads and culverts and existing ones will be rehabilitated in order to integrate the rural areas with the rest of the country. Bridges will also be constructed in strategic areas such as Shashe and Gatshwane rivers to assist the District during wet season and enable vehicles to cross without experiencing some difficulties. This will go a long way to improve road safety and communication links in District. The District has adequate telephone communication links with other major centers in the country. The strategy during DDP 6 would be to expand the existing networks in five villages. Communities will also be encouraged to establish postal agencies in order to enhance communication links. Village Road Safety Committees will be established and workshops will also be conducted for school children and the entire community to augment road safety measures that exist in the District. Safe and Secure Nation tenet will further improve road safety and driving standards, the District will continue with public education and information dissemination in order to decrease loss of life due to road accidents, etc. The District will intensify road safety measures such as roadblocks, road safety awareness campaigns at strategic points throughout the plan period. 13.1.1 Institutional Framework The Ministry of Works Transport and Communication is divided into 3 major sectors; works, transport and communications. It provides infrastructure and services through its various Departments and Parastatals. The Departments are: Architecture and Buildings Services, Civil Aviation, Electrical and Mechanical Services, Central Transport Organization, Roads Transport 139 and Safety, Meteorological Services and Roads Department. There are also the departments of Architecture and Buildings, Works and Roads within the District council under the Ministry of Local Government. These are responsible for the construction and maintenance of buildings at district level and construction of both tertiary and access roads respectively. The Parastatals are: Botswana Railways, Botswana Telecommunications Corporation, Botswana Telecommunications Authority, Air Botswana and Botswana Postal Services. 13.1.2 Strategic Plan for Ministry of Local Government The Ministry exists to improve community’s quality of life through provision of both basic social and physical infrastructure. The Ministry through the district council is able to meet its mandate. In the North East District the district council continues to undertake development of schools, clinics, road and provision of social support system to care for the local people. 13.1.3 Strategic Plan for Ministry of Transport, Works and Communications The Ministry seeks to provide efficient, cost effective, safe, reliable, sustainable and environmentally sound infrastructure services commensurate to international standards, which will support government strategies for social and economic development of Botswana. This has been exhibited by the ability of the ministry in the provision of roads linking the district villages. 13.1.3.1 Works Architecture and Buildings The Department of Architecture and Building Services (DABS) is responsible for constructing and maintaining government buildings while the Department of Electrical and Mechanical Services (DEMS) provide the necessary electrical and mechanical services. The district is served from the Francistown based office but has a sub –depot based in Masunga to assist more specifically with maintenance queries, and assist with supervision of small and medium contractors. 13.1.3.2 Transport The department of roads deals with road construction and maintenance. There is the roads unit under the district council which deals with rural roads construction as well as maintenance. The district does not have the central government based department of roads but is served from Francistown, which is the northern region regional office. The department of Civil Aviation is charged with the responsibility of monitoring, regulating air travel and ensuring its safety and efficiency. The department is based in Francistown. The Botswana Railways office is also based in Francistown. The railway line passes through some parts of the district. 13.1.3.3 Communication The Botswana Post is charged with the responsibility of ensuring that the public is served with postal services. There are 5 post offices and 6 postal agencies in the district. 140 The Telecommunication services are provided by Botswana Telecommunication Corporation. Government is committed to servicing rural areas with telecommunication services and through the Botswana Telecommunication Corporation government funds the development programme for rural areas. There is a depot based in Masunga dealing with operational maintenance as well as queries. 13.1.4 Role of the Private Sector The DABS, DEMS and Council do not have the capacity (equipment and personnel) to carry out all the planned activities and therefore resort to subletting to contractors to carry out some of the works. For council during DDP 5 a minimal amount of work was given to the private sector. It has been shown that the private sector though it is not coping as exhibited by poor workmanship and delay in the completion of projects, will in future play an important role in the implementation of projects. Monitoring and tight supervision of programmes will be initiated to get efficiency in the sector. Clerk of works will be engaged to intensify supervision of projects. The role of the private sector is more pronounced in the provision of public telephone lines. There are a considerable number of private phone booths in the district. In the transport sector there is minimal participation from the sector as demonstrated by inadequate transport in terms of timeliness, availability and coverage within and outside the district. Efforts will be made to encourage more participation in the sector. 13.1.5 Consultation Priorities During the consultations communities cited improvement to the road network as their priority. In particular, they cited construction of bridges, culvert and bituminisation of roads as their priorities in the next plan period. Of particular relevance communities raised concern on issues of road safety as it relates to drunken driving. Communities also indicated the need for additional public phones and expansion of the existing network to facilitate better means of communication. 13.2 NATIONAL POLICIES AND LEGISLATION 13.2.1 Roads Act The revised 1997 Roads Act gives the Roads Department Authority to construct and maintain primary and secondary roads. Settlements within 10 km of a new paved road will have an access road also paved to the Kgotla. Any extension beyond the Kgotla is negotiated with the Ministry of Local Government. The MWTC will during DDP 6 draft a policy guideline as a considerable amount of money has been spent on provision of access roads even in areas with low traffic volume. The main issue of concern is lack of construction and maintenance equipment for both Central Government and District Council. This is due to shortage of funds and this result in poor workmanship. It is recommended that the government should provide this sector with adequate funding in order to purchase enough equipment. 141 13.2.2 Local Government Act The Act empowers district councils to make, alter and maintain public roads other than those undertaken by Central Government Roads Department. The details are in the District Council Schedules. Although the district Council is charged with the responsibility to construct and maintain rural roads it does not have enough capacity and construction equipment to maintain and grade all the district’s roads. The other problem facing the District Council is shortage of technical staff. 13.2.3 Transport and Safety Policy The Act is meant to ensure that roads are safe, sound and can be used by all citizens. A considerable amount of roads accidents have occurred during DDP5. As conglomerated efforts to circumvent the problem of roads accidents, the District Road Safety Committee was formed. The committee continues to play a pivotal role in roads safety through public awareness campaigns and workshops. The Roads Department, as a legislative member will ensure full participation at community level so that safety becomes the number one priority. The following will form part of the objectives during the plan period: 13.2.4 Formation of Committees at Village level. Running awareness seminars for school children. Making sure issues discussed in these committees form part of implementation plan for the department. Civil Aviation Policy The policy is emphatic on provision of safe aviation in view of the number of overhead flights that use Botswana air space. It further recognizes the need for an improved communication system and the radar surveillance system to enhance safety in the use of air space. Air transport in the District is very limited. This is due to the fact that there is an international airport at Francistown. There are two airstrips at Zwenshambe and Matsiloje and quite a number of airstrips are found in private farms. Generally, almost all the airstrips in the district are neglected and overgrown with grass due to lack of maintenance. These airstrips lack the required facilities such as shelters. 13.2.5 Telecommunications Act The Act mandates the telecommunication authority to supervise and promote the provision of efficient telecommunication services entailing the emergency services, public call box service and directory information service. It further expects the services offered to the public to be within the limits of resource pricing, be of quality and satisfy the reasonable demands of consumers. BTC finances objective is to ensure that telecommunications facilities are provided to rural areas. The programme caters for areas that are not economically viable to be undertaken by BTC. Through this programme the Botswana Telecommunication Corporation has serviced all villages except for Toteng, Botalaote, Matopi, Patayamatebele and Mowana. But the villages of Botalaote, 142 Toteng and Mowana are likely to be covered under the same programme since they are within 15km radius. 13.2.6 Meteorological Services Policy In the area of Meteorological Services, Government’s role is to provide weather data and information for aviation purposes, agriculture and public weather services in general. Weather forecast is important for a large number of activities, including planning and air safety. In the District the weather information is used mainly for agriculture. Weather information indicates to farmers when to commence ploughing or whether to increase stock off-take to minimize losses in the event of a looming drought. 13.2.7 Postal Services Act The Act seeks to provide, develop, operate and manage postal services in an efficient and cost effective manner. The Act further expects the post to co-operate with local and other public authorities and consult such authorities on matters that have their interest. It is on this note that the Botswana Post undertakes market research prior to establishing a post office. The Botswana Post support and encourages community participation by assisting them to establish postal agencies. The District has five post offices and four postal agencies. The post offices are situated in Masunga, Ramokgwebana, Makaleng, Matsiloje and Tshesebe while the postal agencies are found in Zwenshambe, Nlapkhwane, Tati Siding, Mapoka and Moroka. There is a serious shortage of postal services in the District as a result people travel long distances to such facilities. The strategy during DDP 6 would be to encourage the VDC’s to build postal agencies through drought programme. The introduction of counter computerization project will enhance efficiency in the counter operations, reduce transaction time and provide up to date product information. 13.3 WORKS, TRANSPORT AND COMMUNICATION 13.3.1 Roads The responsibility of the construction and maintenance of roads is shared between Central government and district Council. The District has three types of roads being the primary, secondary (these are gazetted roads) and rural roads. The central government maintains gazetted roads while the District Council maintains rural roads. The District has a total of 637km length of roads i.e. 372km are under the District Council while 265 km are under Central Government. These comprise 196 km tarred roads, 167km gravel roads and 274km earth/sand roads. The Central government 265km length of roads comprises 193 km sealed roads, 52 gravel roads and 20 km earth roads. The North East District Council 372 km of link roads network consists 3kms of tarred roads, 115km gravel, and 254km of labour intensive maintained earth/sand roads. The District is also entrusted with maintenance of internal roads in all the villages in the District. This encompasses 17km tarred roads and about 260km earth roads. Some additional 40km tar marked roads will be introduced when the ongoing Tati Siding infrastructure development project is competed. 143 The conditions of the District roads is generally poor due to lack of maintenance and to some extent that some roads are not passable during rainy season e.g. Tshesebe – Masunga road. 13.3.2 Transport and Road Safety The District has developed a major road link with quite a number of villages through the tarred loop road from Ramokgwebana through Moroka, Mapoka, Zwenshambe, Mulambakwena, Masunga, Kalakamati, Makaleng and Sebina. Another link was created through Francistown – Matshelagabedi- Matsiloje road. The Matshelagabedi road links the eastern part of the District with the City of Francistown- Bulawayo national roads i.e. Tati siding, Tsamaya, Tshesebe, Jackalas I and Ramokgwebana. There are a few transport support facilities in the District, for instance there are only four private filling stations. Both private and public modes of transport operate in the district. The most prevalent used mode of transport is buses and mini buses. There is public transport for villages within the periphery of the district headquarters though not adequate in terms of spatial distribution, coverage and frequency of the service. Communities are not pleased with the situation; in some areas there is absolutely no public transport such that travels within and outside the district can be cumbersome. Private initiative in this sector will be encouraged during DDP6 in effort to integrate the district and make travel not a difficult venture. 13.3.3 Railways The organization has been operating at losses and will during DDP6 strategize on loss reduction and promote the use of rail transport within an integrated transport system. The north-south rail line passes through some areas in the district such as Tatisiding, Tsamaya, Tshesebe and Ramokgwebana serving as a link of the district to neighbouring Zimbabwe and the city of Francistown. Safety in the rail sub-sector will be given close attention during DDP6 particularly taking cognizance of the fact that increase in efficiency is linked and encapsulates increase in speed. The Tshesebe station is the major station in district. It was widely used as a loading centre for both goods and passengers. There are also sidings at Tati Siding, Tsamaya and Ramokgwebana that are used for embarking and disembarking by passengers. The loading facilities that exist in the district are of a very poor standard and are not frequently maintained. The passenger trains, which used to transport people between Botswana and Zimbabwe have since been discontinued and this has led to the railway to operate far below its capacity. There is also a possibility that most facilities such as waiting and tickets rooms may be vandalised or turn into ghost houses. One other area of concern is the low standard of the loading facilities at Tshesebe station due to lack of regular maintanence. The other worth mentioning point is lack of support facilities such as shelters, platforms and tickets offices. 13.3.4 Civil Aviation The Department of Civil Aviation is based in Francistown due to the fact that most of the airstrips that exist in the District are privately owned. The runway in both government and private airstrips 144 is mostly gravel. There are no proper records indicating the number of aircraft in these airstrips. These airstrips are used occasional except on emergency cases. To further enhance efficiency in the civil aviation sub-sector, during this plan period the Department of Civil Aviation will be transformed into an autonomous parastatal named Civil Aviation Authority. It will continue to further look into the use of modern accurate technology in an effort to produce accurate information and ensure that air travel is safe to use. 13.3.5 Central Transport Organisation The organization during DDP5 went through a facelift where the restructuring exercise included an overhaul of the management and the operation of the organization. The changes made were emphatic on cost-consciousness in effort to minimize cost. The strategy was disseminated to the districts to implement. The Central Transport Organization (CTO) provides central government departments with transport and is also responsible for maintenance of government fleet. There is a district based CTO which provides fuel and maintenance for the central government fleet. It should be noted that the CTO does not have the capacity to service all the vehicles on time. Therefore it is recommended that CTO should outsource their workshop to the private sector to assist in this regard. 13.3.6 Telecommunications Botswana Telecommunications Corporation has undergone a three-year transformation during DDP5 entailing fundamental management, financial and operational restructuring. This precipitated a total overhaul of the organization in terms of staffing and operational set-up. The corporation provides telecommunication through the cable and the wireless local loop, which does not only provide telephonic communication but also, facilitates the use of internet and e-mail in major villages and urban areas. Of course most peri-urban areas are covered by this facility since it operates within a given radius. It extends its services to the rural areas by providing a wire network. Though the corporation is keen to bring phones to the remote areas, cost effectiveness is one of the prime scenarios in determining the location of the telephone services. Therefore the government funds rural telecommunication development projects and for our district 38 villages are covered under this programme. These are planned for the first year of the plan. The programme is run at a cost of P125 million for the Kweneng, Southern and North East districts. Since the introduction of cellular networks in the country through two companies, Orange and Mascom, BTC has also supplied the backbone network to facilitate cellular communication. There are currently 55 pay phones in the district, 42 coin and 13 card system. It is however planned to increase these pay phones during the implementation of the rural telecommunication development projects in the 38 villages is to two (2) pay phones per village. It is however worthy of note to indicate that the private sector through cellular phones and private payphones has further strengthened accessibility to telecommunication lines. The District has telecommunications links with the City of Francistown and other major centres in the district. 145 13.3.7 Postal Services The Botswana Postal Services (BPS) is charged with the responsibility to construct post offices and mini-post offices. The postal agencies are initiated by the communities and approved by the postal service upon review of their viability. The Botswana post will support this initiative by payment of employees and also meeting other operational costs. In view of highly subsidized costs of postal agencies by big posts, BPS would rather employ its funds on expansion of and improvement of existing postal services than to construct new structures. Table 13.1: Postal Services in North East District Post Offices Masunga Matsiloje Tshesebe Ramokgwebana Makaleng Postal Agencies Kalakamati Tatisiding Moroka Mapoka Nlapkhwane Zwenshambe Source: Botswana Post, Northern Region 2003 13.3.8 Department of Architecture and Buildings The primary aim of DABS is to provide finalization of projects with clients by providing cost estimates, preparing detailed designs, tender documentation, commissioning of successful contractors and additionally maintenance of all council buildings. The department has been outsourcing some of its works in an effort to cope with the ever-increasing workload. Of recent there has been a boom in the construction industry and a sharp increase in the government building stock, which is overwhelming the capacity of available manpower. Efforts by government to reduce work force will also affect the capacity of the department. The problem of capacity constraint is further compounded by inability to retain qualified personnel by the department, exhibited by high staff turnover. 13.4 WORKS, TRANSPORT AND COMMUNICATIONS GOALS AND OBJECTIVES Table 13.2: Works, Transport and Communications Goals and Objectives Sector Works Goals Ensure efficiency in the provision of services and implementation of projects by executing works timely and within the budgeted costs. Objectives Outsourcing some of the services e.g. clerk of works, construction, etc throughout the plan period. Provision of back up facilities such as generators, etc by 2008/09. Transport Improve the quality of life of the district populace and ensure that travel is safe by encouraging community participation in road safety measures Construction of DEMS depot during the first half of the plan period. Formation of two village road safety committees per financial year. Conduct two workshops per financial year. Construction of Tshesebe –Masunga road by 2008/09. Construction of 3 bridges by 2008/09. Enforcement of drunken throughout the plan period. driving legislation 146 Sector Goals Objectives Connection of silkerk to main railway line by 2008/09. Weigh bridge constructed at Ramokgwebana border post by 2003/04. Improvement of Sebina-Ramokgwebana road by 2008/09. Bituminisation of 8km of Letsholathebe Masunga road by 2004/05 Gravelling of 339km of access roads, 148km of internal roads, construction of 21 culverts, 2 bridges and 2 drifts effective 2004/05. Communication Improving efficiency in service offered to customers through consultation with all stakeholders. Purchasing of bulldozer, grader, 3 tipper trucks during 2004/05. Provision of counter computerization project in post offices by 2003/04. Encourage communities to initiate postal agencies effective 2003/04. Provision of two way radio systems where there is no telephone services by 2005/06. 13.5 FRAMEWORK FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT General impact of the environment by the construction industry encompasses land degradation, global factors such as ozone depletion affecting the quality of the environment. The level of impact is a function of the decision made at each level right form the inception to the completion of the project. Factors of site selection and design material impacts are considered in the design of roads and buildings. In the formulation of overall goals and objectives consideration was made to ensure that they are not in conflict with the sector policies and programme and the sector policies and programmes are evaluated to ensure that their implementation will not impact on the environment. Table 13.3: Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues with Sector Goals and Objectives Goals Ensure efficiency in provision of services and implementation of project.s Improve the quality of life of district populace through provision of better road networks and maintenance. Objectives Outsourcing some of the services e.g. construction, clerk of works, etc. Environmental Issues Cutting of trees Strategy Landscaping. Land degradation Provision of sanitary facilities. Construction of DEMS depot. Burrow pits Rehabilitation of burrow pits. Improper waste disposal Indiscriminate littering. Tree planting. Cutting of live trees Rehabilitation of burrow pits. Burrow pits Provision of dustbins. Construction of Masunga road. Tshesebe- Construction of 3 bridges. Weighbridge constructed at Ramokgwebana border post by 2003/04. Land degradation Connection of silkirk to main railway line by 2008/09. Bituminisation of 8km of Letsholathebe Masunga road by 147 Goals Objectives 2004/05 Environmental Issues Strategy Gravelling of 339km of access roads, 148km of internal roads, construction of 21 culverts, 2 bridges and 2 drifts effective 2004/05. Table 13.4: Evaluation of Sector Policies and Programs Policies/programs Roads Act Objectives To construct and maintain primary, secondary and rural roads. Environmental issues Cutting of trees. Land degradation. Soil erosion. Local Government Act Empowers the district council to make, alter and maintain rural public roads. Burrow pits. Cutting of trees. Land degradation. Soil erosion. Transport and safety policy Ensure that roads are safe, sound and useable. Burrow pits. Indiscriminate littering. Civil aviation policy Provide safe aviation. Provide sanitary facilities. Noise pollution. Telecommunications Act Mandates the telecommunication authority to supervise and promote the provision of efficient telecommunication services. Cutting of trees. Soil erosion. Indiscriminate littering. 13.6 STRATEGIES TO ACHIEVE WORKS, TRANSPORT GOALS AND OBJECTIVES AND COMMUNICATIONS SECTOR Table 13.5: Works, Transport and Communications Strategies Proposed Project Potential Environmental Impacts Loss of Vegetation and tree species due to bush clearing. Mitigations Measures Environmental Impact Assessment (E.I.A) to be carried out on each major project. Dust and noise pollution. Infrastructure development Construction Projects Indiscriminate littering. Replanting trees/shrubs and consideration of inclusion of landscaping as part of each projects especially buildings. Indiscriminate digging of burrow pits. Provision of skips/dustbins. Rehabilitation of burrow pits. Indiscriminate and haphazard disposal of building rubble. Identification of sand collection points with high community participation. Proper disposal of rubble/waste at identified sites. Loss of rare vegetation/shrubs indigenous species due to clearing of bushes. Over extraction/harvesting of aggregates. Loss of water in view of limited water resources. Community policing to be incorporated. Conduct E.I.A. Replant trees/shrubs along the road. Systematic and controlled extraction of material. Consider possibility of using untreated water. 148 13.7 RESOURCE REQUIREMENTS 13.7.1 Issues and Strengths 13.7.1.1 Issues For road construction there is a problem of land since some of the roads traverse freehold farms. During DDP 5 acquisition of servitude for roads construction was difficult due to insufficient funding. All the proposed projects will not be undertaken due to inadequacy of resources. The capital allocations in terms of financial ceilings have been stringent. In the past plan there were a lot of cost overruns due to the front-loading of the plan. Efforts will be made to match the available manpower with the planned projects. In an effort to curb issues of manpower needs projects will be phased accordingly, and clerk of works and temporary staff efforts where possible will be engaged. Due to shortage of plant, equipment and machinery efficiency in the construction sector is hampered. Efforts to increase these will be pursued during DDP6. Inadequate water is another factor that causes the construction costs to go up, as water has to be fetched from far. Additionally aggregates and suitable material are also at a distance resulting in increases in the cost of construction. 13.7.2 Development Budget Table 13.6: Development Budget Project Title & Name BR 106 – Botswana Railways Finances WT 104 – MWT Facilities WT 401 – Transport Control & Road Safety WT 508 – Bitumen & Trunk Roads Improvements WT 509 – Secondary Roads Construction WT 521- Bridge Consruction Project Component Silkirk Rail Spur New Regional Depot ( DEMS & DABS) Weigh Bridge - Ramokgwebana Border Post Francistown – Ramokgwebana Amount Allocated 30 000 000 5 300 000 Implementation Year TBA 2004/05 9 645 000 2003/04 30 000 000 TBA Sebina- Ramokgwebana (Rehabilitation) Tshesebe - Masunga Shashe river( Kalakamati- Nswazi road) Gatshwane river( Butale – Tshesebe road) 38 000 000 TBA 36 000 000 TBA TBA TBA TBA TBA TBA 1 2000 000 TBA 2004/05 Purchase bull dozer, grader and 3 tipper trucks 4 800 000 2004/05 Gravelling of 339 km of access roads, 148km of internal roads, construction of 21 culverts, 2 bridges and 2 drifts 48 000 000 2004/05- 2008/09 Gatshwane river(Senyawe- Butale road) LG 1111 & 1115 – Village Infrastructure & District Roads 13.7.3 Bituminisation Masunga-8km of Letsholathebe- Perforamnce Targets 149 Table 13.7: Performance Targets for DDP 6 Sector Works Transport Communication 13.7.4 Objectives Outsourcing some of the services e.g. clerk of works, onstruction throughout the plan period. Provision of back up facilities such as generators, etc by 2008/09. Construction of DEMS depot during the first half of the plan period. Formation of two Village Road Safety Committees per financial year. Conduct two workshops per financial year. Construction of Tshesebe –Masunga road by 2008/09. Construction of 3 bridges by 2008/09. Enforcement of drunken driving legislation throughout the plan period. Connection of silkerk to main railway line by 2008/09. Construction of the weigh bridge at Matshelagabedi road by 2008/09. Improvement of Sebina-Ramokgwebana road by 2008/09. Bituminisation of 8km of Letsholathebe –Masunga road by 2004/05. Gravelling of 339km of access roads, 148km of internal roads, construction of 21 culverts, 2 bridges and 2 drifts effective 2004/05. Purchasing of bulldozer, grader, 3 tipper trucks during 2004/05. Provision of counter computerization project in post offices by 2003/04. Encourage communities to initiate postal agencies effective 2003/04. Provision of two way radio systems where there is no telephone services by 2005/06. Indicators Services outsourced to private sector throughout the plan period. Backup facilities provided by 2008/09. DEMS depot constructed by 2005/06. Two Village Road Safety Committees formed per financial year Two workshops conducted per financial year. Tshesebe – Masunga road constructed by 2008/09. Three bridges constructed by 2008/09. Drunken driving legislation enforced. Silkerk connected to main railway line by 2008/09. Weigh bridge constructed at Ramokgwebana border post by 2003/04. Sebina- Ramokgwebana road improved by 2008/09. 8km of Letsholathebe –Masunga road by 2004/05. 339km of access roads, 148km of internal roads, construction of 21 culverts, 2 bridges and 2 drifts effective 2004/05. Bull dozer, grader, 3 tipper trucks purchased by 2004/05. Counter computerization provided by 2003/04. Communities constructed postal agencies by 2008/09. Two way radio systems provided by 2005/06. Plan Monitoring Programme Projects in the plan will be implemented on yearly basis through the Annual Development Plan. These plans will be reviewed on annual basis prior to formulation of the next annual plan. Plans and plan reviews will be submitted to the District Development Committee which is the overall committee overseeing the implementation of the plan. Implementation schedules will also be formulated with tied time framework to ensure that monitoring will be a possible undertaking. 150 CHAPTER 14 14 LAW, JUSTICE AND SECURITY 14.1 INTRODUCTION This chapter covers all institutions concerned with law-making and its enforcement to ensure a stable and peaceful environment conducive for the nation’s development. These institutions are Parliament, Administration of Justice, Attorney General’s Chambers, Auditor General, Botswana Police Service, Directorate on Corruption and Economic Crime, Ombudsman, Department of Immigration and Citizenship, Prisons and Rehabilitation, Independent Electoral Commission, and Botswana Defense Force. At the district level these institutions comprise Botswana Police Service, Tribal Police, Administration of Justice, Immigration, and Independent Electoral Commission. The district has three police stations in Masunga, Tshesebe and Matsiloje. The Independent Electoral Commission began decentralizing to districts during DDP 5. The district was allocated an election officer. With regard to the judiciary, a magistrate on visiting basis services the district. The Immigration Department operates with a two border posts at Ramokgwebana and Matsiloje. These institutions aim at uphold the ideals of the vision 2016, which accentuates on a safety and security and further propels openness, democracy and accountability. The Independent Elections will ensure that there is voter education to encourage the accountability and promote democracy and voter rights, accountability of voters themselves and the incumbent leaders. It further propels ideals of democracy be ensuring that the elections are held in a peaceful and democratic way where the rights of the voters are upheld. Both the local police and the Botswana police will ensure that offenders are prosecuted; public property is protected ensuring safety of the members of the public, visitors and investors. The department of immigration will ensure that emigrants, of which potential investors may be included, have proper passage at the border posts with less hassle. The department will also work against illegal emigration and residence. These efforts are expected to boost economic development in the local economy and promote social justice. These institutions aim at uphold the ideals of the vision 2016, of making Botswana a safe and secure nation and further stresses openness, democracy and accountability. The Independent Electioral Commission will ensure that there is voter education to encourage the accountability and promote democracy and voter rights, accountability of voters themselves and the incumbent leaders. It further propels ideals of democracy be ensuring that the elections are held in a peaceful and democratic way where the rights of the voters are upheld. Both the local police and the Botswana police will ensure that offenders are prosecuted; public property is protected ensuring safety of the members of the public, visitors and investors. The department of immigration will ensure that emigrants, of which potential investors may be included, have proper passage at the border posts with less hassle. The department will also work 151 against illegal emigration and residence. These efforts are expected to boost economic development in the local economy and promote social justice. 14.1.1 Institutional Framework The district council has the unit of byelaw enforcement and the post of the district attorney. Its responsibility is to ensure that council byelaws are enforced. The strategic plan of the Law, Justice and Security exists as such development plan has been aligned with strategic objectives set in the document. To this end, the institution is committed to customer satisfaction, quality service and productivity. The key result areas, set out in the strategic plans of these institutions, are reduction of crime, customer satisfaction, prudent resource utilization, information availability, employee’s growth and development. 14.1.2 Role of the Private Sector The role of the private sector in these sectors is minimal. However the role of these sectors in ensuring full and safe participation of the private sector is of paramount importance. These institutions continue to work hard in ensuring a conducive and secure environment for investment. Immigration assists investors to settle and invest in Botswana and facilitate movement of tourists and other travellers. Concerted efforts will continue to be made to retain this environment. There is little or no participation of the private sector in this law and legal sector. Private legal advisors are mostly based in Francistown. The district has private security companies mainly dealing with the guarding of public institutions such as administration centres, schools and clinics. The need for the service has been increasing due to the increase in the level of crime. 14.1.3 Consultation Priorities Communities sighted concerns in increase in road accidents especially along the A1 road between Francistown and Ramokgwebana Road. There is need for increased highway patrols and the maintenance of the road i.e. debushing and resurfacing of the bad parts of the road. Shortage of accommodation for police officers was also sighted. Local Police are not given adequate resources to execute their function, i.e both housing and office accommodation as well as transport. Communities further raised concerns on the influx of Zimbabwean emigrants in the district which consequently leads to increase in the level of theft, robbery, assaults and rape cases. Communities called for stiffer penalties for emigrants and residents who hide, trade or employ illegal emigrants Congestion at the Ramokgwebana border post was also sighted and communities felt that there is probably need to increase staff at the border to cope with the influx of travellers. 14.2 NATIONAL POLICIES AND LEGISLATION 14.2.1 Immigration Act The Department of Immigration and Citizenship act under the guidance or strength of the Immigration Act CAP 25:02 which among others things clearly regulates the conduct of foreigners entering and leaving Botswana. The Act empowers the department to take punitive steps on illegal 152 emigrants of which more are from Zimbabwe. The clean-up campaigns and raids to locate emigrants have been ongoing. There is also a guide to Immigration Officers, for purposes of issuing passports. Acquisition of Botswana Citizenship there is a Citizenship Act No. 8 of 1998. 14.2.2 Botswana Police Act Internally, the Botswana Police Service performs its duties under the strength and the guidance of the Police Act, Cap. 21:01 and the regulations thereto. The Act is constituted under Botswana Laws passed by the Parliament. The Act was amended in 2001. It empowers the police to take legal and punitive action against offenders. The police service against the backdrop of the influx of illegal emigrants and rising crime level is doing its best to ensue that the district is a safe place to settle in. 14.2.3 Immigration and Citizenship The department regulates travellers’ movement in and out of the country. It also offers Immigration related services for citizens, residence permits for persons coming to Botswana for the purpose of work/residence being dependants and immigrants residing with their spouses or relatives, acquisition of Botswana citizenship by married spouses and acquisition of permanent residence for persons who have been resident for a continuous period of ten years or beyond (i.e. investors, employees, immigrants and dependants). The Department of Immigration and Citizenship is responsible for protecting the National Sovereignty of Botswana and protect the rights of its citizens. There is a critical need for the Department to develop positive relationship with international visitors, investors and tourists. In order for the department to achieve its goals it must have close relationship with the Ministry of Trade Industry Wildlife and Tourism. It should also have relationship with the Police, Customs, BDF, Local Police, Labour and Bye-Law Enforcement Officers. The district-based office in Ramokwebana is currently experiencing a rising problem of illegal emigrants. This emanate from the political problems the neighbouring Zimbabwe is experiencing. There is a considerable amount of movement at the Ramokgwebana border, such that the immigration, customs and excise staff at the border is overwhelmed by a lot of travellers. Travellers also congregate at the border overnight awaiting for the opening of the border. This has resultantly caused generation of waste and unsanitary conditions, as there are no toilets outside the border. The district management has met to come up with alternatives to resolve the issue. One of the issues discussed would be consultation with the department of transport to revise the schedule of departure times for buses ensuring that they will arrive and cross the border while it is still opened. There is a well-developed border post in Ramokgwebana. The Matsiloje one is still operating in porta-camps while the Zimbabwean side has fully-fledged offices. Matsiloje border does not have an all season’s bridges to allow passage of all types of vehicle but only small ones can pass. During DDP 6 the Matsiloje Bridge and Border Post will be constructed. 153 14.2.4 Botswana Police Service The Botswana Police Service is an institution wholly charged with the responsibility of enforcing all written laws of Botswana also performing some of the duties of the Attorney General Chambers, in particular, prosecution of criminal cases both at Customary and Subordinate Courts. The Department falls directly under the Ministry of Presidential Affairs and Public administration and its duties, and functions in administration of service are: To protect life and property. To prevent and detect crime. To repress internal disturbances. To maintain security and public tranquility. Apprehend offenders and bring them to justice. Enforce all written laws of Botswana. And generally maintain peace. The district has 3 police stations in Masunga, Thesebe and Matsiloje. The Tshesebe Police Station is undergoing upgrading and will have a double storey office block and additional 30 houses. Over the time the incidence of crime has increased in the district, which necessitates the increase of police services. The rising crime level has been attributed to the influx of both legal and illegal Zimbabwean emigrants. The situation emanates form the unending economic crises in the neighbouring Zimbabwe. Efforts to address the problem are ongoing, through clean-up campaigns and spot checks. Kgotla meetings have also been held to encourage and lobby for support of the community in the fight against crime exacerbated by emigrants. Residents have been encouraged to avoid purchasing goods sold by emigrants as this encourages them to keep on coming back to sell. Additionally there have been reports of rape and assaults caused by emigrants. For the past three years there has been an escalating trend of crime statistics. This calls for the need to keep on increasing the number of police officers in the district and engage strategies that will reduce crime There is a notable closer working relationship between the police and the community as exhibited by community involvement in crime prevention activities. These include neighbourhood watch committees, councilors, business community, local farms and schools. Communities have gained confidence in the police through a system which was developed to engage communities in policing entailing both consultation and partnership. The district has crime prevention committees in which there is a meaningful dialogue between the police and committees regarding expectations and problem solving. These crimes combat efforts and dialogues will be continued during the plan and dialogues will be continued during the period. 14.2.5 Customs and Exercise The department falls under the Ministry of Finance and Development Planning and directly under the division of financial affairs. It is one of the major revenue earners seconding mineral revenue. The department accrues its revenue resources from customs that is duty being imposed on imported goods and excise being a levy on locally produced goods. These duties are exercised on airports, railways and border posts. 154 The district has a department of customs and excise based at Ramokgwebana border posts, which connects to Zimbabwe. There is noticeable high level of trade exchange as the dominance/strength of the Pula currency gives the Botswana residents advantages of cheaper purchases across border. It is nevertheless disappointing that a considerable number of customers do not want to be levied on the external purchases and a such do not declare some of the goods. The department will during DDP6 intensify on reduction of smugglers in view of reducing revenue losses. 14.2.6 Local Police and Customary Court The section though under the ministry of local government also undertakes some prosecution and judicial services at the local level. They mainly deal with matters of indigenous custom and try criminal cases of certain jurisdiction. The District Commissioner reviews judgments of customary court cases. Due to its easy accessibility and being locally based its services are highly utilized as depicted by 2200 cases tried annually on average. Additionally, the language use, indigenousness and prevalence of use cultural principles and precepts make it even more accessible to local people. The district has 10 sub-chiefs, 21 headmen of record, 16 headman of arbitration and 36 headman of arbitration on allowance. The chiefs have capacity to arbitrate and try both civil and criminal cases, while the headman of arbitration only arbitrate cases, which are of civil nature only. These have capacity also, many a times they are able to handle cases and conclude them without reaching the sub-chiefs. On the local police side, the district is headed by the Senior Superintendent Police Officer based in Masunga. The district is divided into section/areas and the Assistant Superintendent heads these. The department is faced with lack of transport making it almost impossible to undertake follow-ups of court fines and compensation. Plans have been made to increase the fleet of tribal police in efforts to increase efficiency in the department. 14.2.7 Administration of Justice The department has decentralized to the district as cases are tried within the district. However, during DDP6, the department aims to constructing temporary offices so that the services become more accessible to the society. This will go along way in realization of the main aim of promoting greater access to justice through provision of appropriate infrastructure in rural and urban/periurban areas, further subscribing to the vision 2016 pillars of creating a safe and secure nation. 14.2.8 Independent Electoral Commission The Independent Electoral Commission has the responsibility of ensuring that elections are conducted efficiently, properly, freely and fairly within the requirements of the constitution of the Republic of Botswana and electoral laws generally, in that way upholding one of the national principles of Botswana, which is democracy and openess. During DDP 5 election office was established and decentralized to the district. The office continued to provide public education on voter rights. More promotional campaigns need to be undertaken. In the last elections only 14 115 people out of the eligible district population registered. Of the 14 115 people who registered, 10 549 voted denoting 78.2% representation. Although this is a common issue in the country the district will make efforts during DDP6 to increase voter registration and instil accountability as enunciated in the Vision 2016. 155 14.3 LAW JUSTICE AND SECURITY GOALS AND OBJECTIVES Table 14.1: Law, Justice and Security Goals and Objectives Department Immigration Citizenship and Goals To reduce all forms of unlawful entry/residence Objective Conduction of clean up campaigns bi-monthly Embarking on patrols along the border quarterly To keep customers/community informed on the functions of department To promote the growth development of employees Customs and Excise and Reach optimum revenue level Public education on illegal emigration in view acquiring community participation and involvement in the eradication illegal emigrants. To conduct public awareness campaigns twice a year Printing of legible and easy pamphlets on the functions of departments and how communities can benefit from the services of the department send them out quarterly Annual open-air services and open days/shows where the functions of departments will be sold to the public. To sensitize all staff on Performance Management Systems (PMS) and in particular strategic planning by 2003/2004. Provision of quality training for employees Broaden the tax payer base Increase the number of tax payers by 50% To eliminate external trade in elicit goods in partnership with stakeholders. Make the district a safe place to settle in Botswana Police Reduce revenue losses by reducing smugglers by 50% mid plan period To liaise with stakeholders regarding elicit goods on annual basis Crime reduction and improvement on crime detection strategies by 2005 Review of the existing patrol procedures to be commensurate with the complexity and frequency of crime by 2005 Independent Commission Electoral Promotion of well-structured voting culture among the communities To enhance the effectiveness of community participation and initiatives by 2005 To establish a timely effective voting mechanism by 2004 To ensure that voters are motivated to vote, informed at all times about how to vote and are officially registered to vote by 2003. Administration of Justice To promote greater access to judicial services To facilitate the creation of a political climate in which parties are free, able to communicate, campaign to the electorate so that they can make informed choices by 2003 Undertake public awareness on the services offered by the department annually Construction of magistrate court by mid plan period Reduce number of pending cases by 50% annually until the backlog is cleared 14.4 FRAMEWORK FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT The main environmental concerns with respect to developments envisaged are overexploitation of natural resources such as river sand, water, and pit sand which will impact negatively on the ecosystem, indiscriminate digging of burrow pits, destruction of natural resources. As a result, remedial measures have been proposed where a particular activity is deemed to have potential impacts on the environment. 156 The evaluation of sector goals and objectives is to ensure that these do not conflict with efforts to attempt to address environmental concerns and also to ensure that sector goals and objectives are in consonance with policies and existing pieces of legislatures. 14.4.1 Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues with Sector Goals and Objectives Table 14.1: Evaluation of Environmental Key Issues with Sector Goals and Objectives Goals and Objectives Reduce all forms of illegal emigrant/resident Environmental Key Issue Nil Public awareness campaigns on functions of different departments Reduce revenue losses – reduce illicit goods, reduce smuggling littering Promote a voting culture Promote greater access to judicial services Littering Nil 14.4.2 Strategies Intensive search Patrols and clean up campaigns Public education in lobbying for public support and participation Mounting of refuse skips, refuse bags and bins Nil Intensive search athe border Increase manpower at the boarder Spot checks Campaigns, public education, flyers and posters Public education, open air seminars Evaluation of Sector Policies and Programs Table 14.3: Evaluation Of Sector Policies and Programs Policies and Programmes Immigration Act Botswana Police Act Goals and Objectives Prevent all forms of illegal immigration and residence To protect life and property of citizens, prosecute and maintains security Prevention of illicit goods and smuggling Customs Act 14.5 STRATEGIES OBJECTIVES TO ACHIEVE LAW, JUSTICE AND Environmental Issues Littering SECURITY SECTOR GOALS AND The table below summarizes the potential impacts of the proposed activities and the mitigation measures to be put in place. Table 14.4: Proposed Projects, Potential Impacts and Mitigation Measures Proposed project/Activities Seminars Potential Impact Littering Kgotla meetings Campaigns for voter education, illegal immigration and availability of judicial services. Construction Projects viz; Magistrate court, staff houses, police offices and staff houses Mitigation measures Waste receptacles Further address communities on environmental conservation Lost of natural vegetation Conducting of an Assessment studies. Environmental Impact Indiscriminate dumping of building rubble Regulate utilization of natural resources Excessive extraction of river sand, pit sand, water and gravel Replanting of tree, extraction on agreed areas. Pollution 157 14.6 RESOURCE REQUIREMENTS 14.6.1 Issues & Strengths for Law Justice and Security 14.6.2 14.6.3 Inadequate manpower levels especially the police. This then seemingly undermines efforts to fight crime as the crime level is rapidly increasing in terms of the number of cases and complexity. Lack logistics such as transport and equipment to adequately deal with crime issues and patrols. Performance Targets Border patrols conducted atleast once a month. Clean up campaigns operations on quarterly basis. Yearly meetings/open air meetings held annually. Increased number of tax-payers by 10% midway the plan period. Reduction of smuggling by 50% by the end of the plan period. Reduce crime level by 50%. Formation of crime prevention committees in each village starting with those with higher crime statistics by 2005. Embark on intensified voter education prior to election and thereafter annually in each village. Development Budget for DDP6 The table below gives details of projects that will be implemented during the DDP6. Table 14.5: Development Budget Project Name Customs and Execise Improvement of Customs Offices Improvement of Customs Offices Administration of Justice Temporary structure Botswana Police Construction of additional offices Construction of staff houses Construction of additional offices Construction of staff houses Independent Electoral Commission Construction of Regional Offices Government Revenue Construction of Revenue Offices and staff houses 14.6.4 Location Amount Allocated Year of implementation Matsiloje Ramokwebana 4 100 000 4 100 000 2004/5 Masunga - - Masunga Masunga Matsiloje Matsiloje 14 000 000 11 000 000 9 285 000 8 798 000 2005/6 2003/4 2006/7 2004/5 Masunga 1 460 000 2005/6 Masunga 5 800 000 2005/6 Plan Monitoring Programme Projects will be implemented yearly by breaking them down into annual plans. These plans will be reviewed on annual basis prior to preparation of the next annual plan. Performance targets will be the main guiding factors to determine whether there is progress or backsliding. Plans and plan 158 reviews will be submitted to the District Development Committee which is the overall committee overseeing the implementation of the plan ad ultimately to the Full Council. Implementation schedules of relevant department will also be formulated with tied time framework to ensure that monitoring will be a possible undertaking. These will also be presented to both the Plan Management Committees and District Development Committees. 159 CHAPTER 15 15 LOCAL GOVERNMENT 15.1 INTRODUCTION The Ministry of Local Government has the primary responsibility of providing a wide range of social services through local authorities. The local government ensures participatory planning in the development process through promotion of wider community and other district based institutions participation. The overall responsibility of ensuring efficient operation of local government lies with the Ministry of Local Government. It comprises of Local Authorities, which are based in both urban and rural areas and directly responsible for administering and delivering different government policies and programmes to the communities in their areas of jurisdiction. The local government contributes towards realization of Vision 2016 pillar of open and democratic and transparent governance, though participatory bottom-up planning approach in the development planning process whereby communities’ ideas are taken into account through the consultation process. The ideal of openness and accountability is encouraged as the communities are given the projects to undertake themselves, given the latitude to elect the VDC membership they deem fit. Through the tribal police and the Kgotla, safety and security is promoted in the district. Members of the public are able to seek adjudication in matters that concern them. Cases are tried in the Kgotla and the local police have also been give powers to arrest. The participation of the community in volunteer work and caring for the needy promotes a culture of self-reliance, morality, tolerance and compassion, which are Vision 2016 ideals. 15.1.1 Institutional Framework The role of local government is important in rural areas as they give meaning to government programmes and promote bottom up planning. There are four types of local authorities in Botswana viz; District and Urban Councils, Tribal Administration, District Administration, and Land Board. In the North East District all the four local authorities are represented 15.1.2 Strategic Plans for Respective Ministries 15.1.2.1 Ministry of Local Government The mandate of the Ministry of Local Government (in relation to Local Authorities) is to provide basic physical and social infrastructure (e.g. water provision, primary school and clinics construction) to the community. The other core business as stipulated in the ministry strategic plan is that of ensuring efficient operation of local authorities through policy direction, capacity building, and supervision. To achieve its mandate, the ministry has set itself key results areas viz; Customer satisfaction, Policy implementation effectiveness, Improved quality of life of communities, Productivity and organisational effectiveness. All the above have a direct bearing on the operations and responsibilities of local authorities as it is part of their core business hence their achievement is dependent on the full commitment of local 160 authorities. Local authorities will therefore ensure that the overall results areas of local government are achievable through the following; Customer satisfaction To ensure customer satisfaction through timely delivery of quality service. To ensure continuous improvement in service delivery through two way communication. Policy Implementation Improve local authorities project implementation through timely submission of project memorandums To ensure education, dissemination of information, and effective consultation of communities Improved quality of life of communities To undertake social mobilisation and consultation with communities and provide an enabling environment for enhanced participatory development To promote sustainable self-reliance amongst communities through programmes such as LG 1109, Community Based Natural resource Management To improve community quality of life of Batswana by coordinating and providing basic infrastructure and services. To reduce the level of crime by adopting community policing. Productivity and Organisation effectiveness 15.1.3 The above local authorities recognise the need to develop departmental human resource development strategies to improve the level of productivity Tribal Administration will promote, effective understanding of Botswana of Botswana’s culture facilitating documentation of customary laws. It will also ensure coordination of departmental activities through the development and implementation of sound policies, guidelines and effective leader team. Role of Private Sector The private sector will continue to play a pivotal role in development. The government strategy is that of the private sector playing a leading role in development while government’s role being of a facilitator or that of providing an enabling environment for the sector to thrive. This is in view of the fact that government alone cannot shoulder the burden of development. However, it must be noted that, in the North East District, the sector has not fully asserted itself as expected at the beginning of this plan period. More concerted efforts will continue to be made to ensure that the sector takes its rightful place. The important role the sector is playing need not be emphasised especially in view of the ongoing privatisation drive of government. The sector is expected to play an important role in taking up activities that are currently being done by government. This is so because responsibilities are increasing and due to limited resources it may not always be possible to increase resources and manpower to match the increasing 161 responsibilities. Privatisation becomes an answer to sharing of responsibilities. The hiving-off of government duties is expected to improve efficiency in local government and other government sectors. In the North East District privatisation initiatives have been and will be undertaken in the areas of refuse collection, transport, education, day care centres etc. Presently, the sector is playing an important role in construction, as council does not have the capacity to undertake all construction and maintenance works. 15.1.4 Consultation Priorities The Communities proposed infrastructural projects and posting of the requisite staff to villages as their major priorities in the coming plan period. This is expected in view of the level of development in rural areas where public infrastructure such as roads, school and health facilities, and other public facilities are still lacking. The following is a detailed account of the North East District Priorities; Communication network; The projects proposed were bituminisation of all roads in the district and construction of culverts and bridges Public Facilities; provision of school and clinic facilities, proper offices for extension staff in villages, customary court offices, community services, and water supply development. Manpower; The communities also noted lack of manpower (extension staff) as a serious constraint to development. In particular, the communities wanted to be provided with, enough agricultural demonstrators, local police officers, social workers, and Family Welfare Officers as some villages do not have these important extension staff. Environment; The need to incorporate environmental issues at the stage of project conception was also echoed by the communities. For example, major construction works should take account of rehabilitation of burrow pits. Provision of essential services/utilities such as electricity and telephones was high in the priority list of communities. Due to the important role VDCs play in development, it was proposed that they be given a vote under council to further empower them rather than wait for LG 1109 and drought projects. 15.2 NATIONAL POLICIES AND LEGISLATION 15.2.1 Tribal Land Act The Act establishes land boards (chapter 32:02 of 1970) and mandates them to allocate land under the customary and common law. The land board remains the custodian of the land and administers the use of land in the whole district. Its boundaries are the same as those for the district. The land board faces problems of insufficient land for demarcation and consequent allocation. The other problem facing the land board is the high land demand especially in the areas of the district, which are proximal to the City of Francistown. 15.2.2 Local Police Act There are conflicts within the act, which needs to be addressed for smooth running of the department especially with respect to its application to employment of personnel. The department is composed of two cadres namely, local police and administrative cadre. Local police act is used to employ both these cadres although it does not cover the administrative cadre, which implies that the employment of these officers is illegal. For the North East District a considerable amount of 162 work is done by the local police prosecution and follow-ups the only setback is lack of transport for adequate follow-up of cases etc. 15.2.3 Waste Management Act The Act was passed in 1988 and seeks to follow principles of waste management pursuant to environmental conservation. It also empowers council to facilitate and implement policies and programmes that pursues proper management of waste. The district faces problem of indiscriminate refuse disposal and loitering. Efforts have been concerted through stakeholders, different fora and fronts to combat illegal dumping of waste and littering. The council byelaws will be formulated and strengthened to address the issue during the plan period. Through the National Rural Sanitation programme communities have been assisted with construction of toilets thereby improving the sanitation level of the district. 15.2.4 Local Government The local government at district level is constituted by the local authorities that is the district council the tribal administration and the district administration. The land board though it is a local authority, it has since been transferred to the ministry of land and housing. 15.2.5 District Councils The Districts Councils have delegated been established by the Act of Parliament from which they derive their powers and mandate. The Council has the power and discretion to allocate resources within its areas of jurisdiction. Consultation is made with local communities regarding distribution of resources for development. The power base therefore is local and the decisions reflect the aspirations of the local communities. The council is accountable to the Ministry of Local Government through which the development grants are channelled. Council receives 95% of its recurrent requirement and 100% of its capital budget from the Ministry of Local Government. The statutory responsibilities of councils are as follows; The provision of primary education facilities. The provision of basic primary health facilities. The development and maintenance of rural roads. The provision, operation and maintenance of village water supply. Social and community development. The making and enforcement of district bye-laws. There are also other responsibilities, which cover sanitation services, administering Self Help Housing Agency (SHHA), municipal abattoirs, and market stalls. Some of these functions are complemented by central government ministries and parastatals (e.g water, health, and education). Although in the district there is not much participation of the private sector and the parastatals. The major challenge facing the council is to come up with own revenue sources than to solely depend on central government for budget financing. The North East district council will during DDP6 improve in its revenue collection through improvement of its billing system for services such water and waste collection. Bills will be monthly sent to Kgotlas in different villages for payments. Additionally efforts shall be made to collect sanitation fees at source where possible. 163 Councils will make attempts to punctually bill the institutions existing in the villages for all the services rendered. Guidelines will also be formulated to bill the private commercial enterprises for waste collection. Currently servicing of industrial plots will in this plan period be undertaken in Tatisiding through the infrastructural development project currently ongoing; council shall upon completion ensure that the partial cost recovery principle is administered on such land. 15.2.6 District Administration District Administration, which is headed by the District Commissioner, has the primary responsibility of ensuring effective representation of central government in the district. It plays the overall role of development coordinator in the district through coordination, compilation and implementation of the district development plans, and annual plans. Apart from the planning responsibilities, the department also performs various legal responsibilities as stipulated in the Botswana Laws. The District Commissioner is also the chairperson of the Tribal Staff Committee performs judiciary services in certain instances, acts as a marriage, ceremonial and protocol officer and should ensure dissemination of information on different government legislations, policies and programmes to all stakeholders. The department is constrained by lack of information on development programmes. Information on the development programmes, projects and implementation schedules for projects planned for implementation in the district for ministries based in the district is not availed to the department. This cripples efforts of coordinated development in the district. For the District Commissioner to adequately perform duties of development coordination the district commissioner’s offices should be empowered to be able to control and coordinate district based staff, the ministries should also be obliged to report to the district as a standing order. 15.2.7 Tribal Administration Tribal administration, which has the Kgotla as its central organ, is one of the oldest institutions in Botswana society. It was in existence long before the introduction of the public service, which came into being during the colonial era. The main responsibility of tribal administration is the administration of justice under the system of customary law; it conducts the network of customary courts, which handles the majority of criminal and civil cases in Botswana. Apart from the administration of justice, the department has developmental duties through supporting development initiatives, particularly at the community level. This is so as the Chief is the exofficio member of the Village Development Committee, which coordinates community initiatives in the development process. The Chief is also the ex-officio member of the district council and sits in the full council meeting of the council, expected to make significant contribution in the developmental and legislative decision passed by the council. His role is the there to bridge the cultural expectation of the community as relates to the policies and the law. The chief remains the custodian of the traditional culture and belief. The district has chiefs, sub-chiefs and headmen of arbitration. These are responsible as traditional leaders in their respective villages and are expected to keep law and order through performance of arbitration in settling disputes and judiciary functions in trying both civil and criminal cases. 164 15.2.8 Land Board Tati Land Board tribal area of jurisdiction covers 3391 km2 (out of 5993km2 of the total area of the district). The tribal land is mainly for residential, commercial and agricultural uses. Other categories of land tenure are: State land covering about 33km2 (o.5%) and freehold covering an area of 2509 km2 (42.9%). The tribal land of about 3391 km2 caters for the population of about 49000 as per the population census of 2001, hence the need for the Land Board to make a Land Use plan to address a balanced development and use relating to arable agriculture, livestock keeping, mining activities, settlement location and further population growth. 15.2.9 Law and Order The local police service enhances cooperation with law enforcement agencies through appropriate consultative measures to develop effective criminal investigation strategy to improve quality of policing service through applied research. It prosecutes offenders and handles criminal cases tried at the local kgotla. The district council through the commercial affairs and byelaw enforcement unit also keeps order in the district. The byelaws enforcement unit enforces laws of payment of sanitation fees, sewerage fees, noise and nuisance, street vending and hawking and also the trade and liquor act, which is currently under revision. 15.3 LOCAL GOVERNMENT GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 15.3.1 District Council Table 15.1: District Council Goals and Objectives Goals To create a conducive learning environment for a cross-section of learners. Objectives Ttimely provision of adequate and accessible facilities To construct all the planned development projects before the end of District Development Plan 6. To improve the health status of the community. To modify certain identified existing facilities to make them accessible to children with special educational needs before the end of 2003/2004. Immunisation of all under fives Reduction of maternal morbidity by 75% To increasing access to health services. Enforcement and public education on all programmes such as PMTCT Upgrading of Tati Siding Clinic to 24 hours and purchase of specialised equipment for the clinic in 2004/2005 Extension of Tsamaya Rehabilitation Centre by 2005 Construction of 1 health post in Patayamatebele by 2008, upgrading of health posts to clinics in Gulubane, Senyawe, and Moroka during 2003/2004, 2004/2005 and 2006/2007 respectively. To improve communication and access in the North East. Upgrading of Themashanga clinic to maternity during 2006/2007 Development and regular maintenance of district roads Upgrading o existing roads Bituminisation of some 8km Letsholathebe- Masunga road by 2005. Gravelling of 339km of access roads, 148km of internal roads, construction of 21 culverts, 2 bridges, and 2 drifts during the DDP6 165 Goals Objectives To improve access to water and waste water disposal. To improve maintenance of roads during DDP6 through purchase of bulldozer, grader, and tipper trucks in 2003/2004. Provision of water and sewerage facilities in Masunga and Tatising half way through the plan period Regular operation and maintenance of sewerage networks and water supply schemes To empower the rural populace and cater or the economically weak. Upgrading of all planed water supply schemes by the end of the plan period. Improvement of social welfare services to address all the needy, improving the coverage and further decentralising services to villages Formulate programmes for rehabilitation of the needy Create a conducive investment climate. Improve access to habitable shelter through programmes such as SHHA Enforcement of bye-laws for trading and security purposes Development of the physical status of the district through infrastructural development To provide a customer focused service through provision of quality and timely service. Efficiency in the processing of licenses To train staff and increase their job knowledge and sharpen their professional skills To develop good public relations within staff through training To continue to create channels through which the council exchanges views on the quality of service for continuous improvement through organising open days and individual submissions from concerned customers To continue to create a healthy, conducive, and secure environment Create a forum for feedback from the communities Through the making and enforcement of district bye-laws. District community To improve the sanitary status Neighbourhood watch Construct refuse transfer station Privatisation of refuse collection by 2004 Provision of sanitary disposal of human waste through construction of 200 sub-structure pit latrines annually throughout Ensure safety of food through monthly inspection of shops and food outlets Construction of slaughter by 2005 15.3.2 District Administration Table 15.2: District Administration Goals and Objectives Goals Coordination of district development. Objectives Provide co-leadership in district development planning and policy coordination throughout the plan period. Presentation of annual development plans and annual development plan reviews to full council. Presentation of quarterly district evelopemtn committee reports to full council. Provide central government representation at the district or local level. Ensures that all sub-DDC committees sit and execute their functions as mandated. Conduct quarterly district leadership consultative forum. 166 Goals Provides management of the district administration department in the district. Objectives To ensure that district administration authorities are provided with adequate resources and administrative support services. To efficiently and effectively manage and resources allocated to the department. To respond effectively to food relief and deficiency needs as dictated by natural disasters and other deserving circumstances. To undertake all relevant ceremonial and statutory responsibilities. 15.3.3 Tribal Administration Table 15.3: Tribal Administartion Goals and Objectives Goals To enhance efficiency and effectiveness of service through provision of appropriate manpower and adequate infrastructure To enhance overall efficiency Objectives To construct three customary courts every financial year. Make manpower budget for all the necessary posts in the department annually and further ensure adequate resources for the department to carry out its functions. To enforce performance management principles in the work force. To old motivational talks and seminars for staff. Engage other sub-chiefs/headmen of arbitration to assist where there is backlog of cases. 15.3.4 Land Board Table 15.1: Land Board Goals and Objectives Goals To implement the Tribal Land Act (1968) and the Amendment Act (1993) in conformity with other government policies. Objective To hold Full Board meetings six times in a year, each lasting seven days. To hold Title Transfer Committee meetings eveths. To allocate land to applicants for 120 days in a year. To take services closer to the public by delivering certificates and leases to the people at least four times a year. To provide timely technical services to the customers To dispose tribal land to applicants timely. To produce 240 sketch plans in a year (40 sketch plans for every allocation trip). To reduce the allocation backlog for Tatisiding and Matshelagabedi by demarcating 600 and 300 plots respectively yearly. To prepare base maps for Masunga, Matshelagabedi and Tatisiding before the end of 2003/2004. To repossess and assess property that might be affected by village expansion in the whole district before the end of 2005/2006. To develop a human development strategy for the organisation Improvement of revenue resource base of the board To undertake individual title surveys as per request and ensure that there is no backlog. To develop an environment conducive to a healthy industrial relations, high staff morale and good quality performance starting 2003/2004. To collect revenue due to the Board and make follow up on arrears twice per annum. 167 Goals To enhance overall efficiency and effective communication through information dissemination. Objective Educate members of the public on lease payments by 2004 Kgotla meetings annually. Publishing of pamphlets on the operation of the board, its mandate and performance targets by 2004. Open air seminars annually. Development of communication strategy by 2005. 15.4 FRAMEWORK FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT Local authorities, in particular council, are tasked with the responsibility of providing communities in the rural areas with services. Their mandate, as elaborated above involve provision of basic infrastructure such as roads, primary school infrastructure, and provision of health facilities. Therefore, their undertakings have negative consequences on the environment. For example, sector goals relating to provision of infrastructure such as roads, health facilities, primary school infrastructure, and other public facilities support the national objectives of rapid economic development. However, these sector goals and objectives have potential to impact negatively on the environment. In the first place, they may put pressure on natural resources water, sand, gravel leading to excessive extraction. These cause under ground water pollution and major changes in ecosystem. Therefore, although the sector goals may be in line with the objective of rapid economic development, they are not sustainable. These problems have been identified and remedial measures will be put in place to address them and as well support the sustainable development objective. Some of these are identification of river sand, pit sand, and gravel extraction, conducting Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) studies for each project to be undertaken, and replanting of vegetation/trees after project completion. The objectives will also cause land use conflicts, as the developments will require land. There is therefore need to demarcate land for different uses and conduct EIA studies to harmonise land uses. Regarding evaluation of goals and objectives against policies and programmes, this is mainly to ensure that the set objectives are not in conflict with the policies and programmes and also attempt to identify environmental key issue 15.4.1 Evaluation of Sector Goals and Objectives against Key Environmental Issues Table 15.5: Evaluation of Sector Goals and Objectives with Key Environmental Issues Goals and Objectives Conducive learning and improve health status environment through provision of facilities. Improve communication access through road development and maintenance. Create a conducive investor climate through physical infrastructural development (sewerage, drainage, streetlights, roads etc). Improve sanitary status of the district Through provision of facilities and public education. Key Environmental Issue Land degradation, extraction aggregates and materials. Loss of vegetation and tree species through bush clearing. Strategies Landscaping and promotion of school garderns. Replanting of trees. Landscaping, planting of trees along internal roads. Development of parks. Public education on proper sanitation, development and adherence to waste management plans. 168 Goals and Objectives Promote a secure environment through enforcement of byelaws and mobilisation of communities regarding complacency to the law. Promote industrial and commercial development. Provision of co-leadership in district development planning and policy implementation coordination. Key Environmental Issue Littering. Strategies Formation of crime prevention committees and promotion of neighbourhood watch culture Conducting consultative meetings. Land degradation, air pollution, waste disposal, Ground water pollution. Nil Industries to submit waste management plans, monitoring to ensure complacency. Ensuring that there are no conflicts in policies. To provide central govt representation, undertake ceremonial and judicial activities, To dispose tribal land in an equitable way to the satisfaction of the community. To develop a well structured industrial relation strategy and human development plan. Nil Regular contact with implementing departments. Workshops and consultative meetings. Nil Land degradation. Land demarcation and prompt allocations. nil Recognising and reward for good work. Increase revenue resource base for land board and council. Insufficient financial resources to meet council and the board demands. Transparency within the organisation on issues of training, performance appraisal and reward for work. Polluter-pays principle, cost recovery on serviced land and services rendered. Efficient collection of revenues and royalties. Optimal use of Land. Pressure on land and land scarcity. Prompt billing of services. Development of land use plans, Follow up district settlement strategy and village plans. Preparation of development plans. Minimise land Use conflicts. Land use conflicts, double allocations. Provision of adequate portable water to the district populace. Water shortage. Ground water recharge problems. Acquisition of undeveloped plots, construction of high rises, purchase of freehold farms. Land Use plans, use of land overseers in allocations. Look for alternative water resources, develop a strategy for ground water protection – use sealed latrines (VIPs), public education on water conservation. Ground water pollution. Water loss through lack of conservation principles and livestock watering. 15.4.2 Water harvesting techniques, construction of rain water tanks in every development. Formulation and enforcement of byelaws on livestock watering. Alternative water sources. Evaluation of Sector Goals and Objectives Against Key Environmental Issues Policies and Programme Partial cost recovery principle Industrial development policy, CEDA, Local preference policy (reservation policy). Tribal land Act – Plot demarcation. National Water Master Plan, Botswana strategy for waste management, EIA, National Settlement Policy. Goals and Objectives Improvement of revenue resource base. Conducive environment for industrial development. Environmental Issue Land degradation. Poor waste management. Air pollution from industrial emissions. Promotion of commercial and industrial development. Optimal use and disposal of land. Provision of portable water to the district at large. Water conservation strategy. Increase in waste generated. Pressure on land and land scarcity. Groundwater pollution. Misuse of scarce (livestock watering). water resource 169 15.5 STRATEGIES TO ACHIEVE LOCAL GOVERNMENT SECTOR GOALS AND OBJECTIVES Proposed Projects Infrastructure Construction Projects Potential Impacts Loss of Vegetation and tree species due to bush clearing. Mitigation Measures Environmental Impact Assessment (E.I.A). Replanting trees/shrubs. Dust and noise pollution. Indiscriminate digging of burrow pits. Unsightly and unhealthy environment as a result of careless disposal of building rubble. Ground water pollution arising from pit latrines, abattoir waste and barrow pits. Road Construction Projects and major infrastructure development projects Loss of rare vegetation/shrubs species due to clearing of bushes. Indiscriminate digging of burrow pits and collection of river sand. Seminars & Workshops 15.6 Pollution of environment as a result of littering due to increased movement of people. Littering. Rehabilitation of burrow pits. Identification of sand collection points. Proper disposal of rubble/waste. Proper disposal of all waste. Introduction of water system toilets. Conduct E.I.A. Replant trees/shrubs. Identify areas for materials. extraction building Rehabilitation of burrow pits and sand extraction areas. Put waste receptacles in strategic areas. Provision of waste receptacles. RESOURCE REQUIREMENT FOR DDP 6 The North East district was given P213 483 000 for implementation of all local government projects. It must be noted that the amount is far below the P1.7 billion worth of projects proposed by the district. Therefore the district had to scale down a lot of the proposed projects in order to fall within the given financial ceiling. Lack of funding will therefore be one of the major factors, which will hinder achievement of local government goals and objectives 15.6.1 Issues and Strengths The main strength of Local authorities is that they are locally based hence they are nearer the communities they serve. It is in the light of this that they are able to reach out to the communities in terms of service provision. This is possible through the consultation process, which ensures constant communication with the consumers. It is against this background that local authorities can be said to have the following strengths: Resource constraints in terms of finance and manpower. Lack of access to information technology. Local authorities are not connected to Central Government data bank and other organisations. This makes access to information difficult and time consuming. 170 15.6.2 Inadequate information technology skills. Shortage of land and conflicting land uses which makes planning difficult. The increase in construction prices will seriously limit the number of projects to be implemented during the DDP6. Lack of harmonisation of policies and acts. Performance Targets Performance targets for DDP6 will be measured in terms of the projects to be implemented each financial year of the plan. These will be divided according to programmes as detailed in the following section. The summarised implementation matrix for the projects is attached at the end of the plan. 15.6.3 Development Budget (A) District Council Projects See Appendix 1 attached to this document. 15.6.4 Plan Monitoring Program In the North East District, the Plan Management Committee is made up of the District Commissioner and Council Secretary as co-managers, District Officer (Development), Senior Council Planning Officer, and other members: Tribal Secretary, Land Board Secretary, District Officer (Lands) and the Senior Physical Planner. The co-managers perform the same duties for the District Development Committee. The Senior Council Planning Officer and the District Officer (Development) have prepared and will coordinate the implementation of this District Development Plan under the direction of the comanagers. The District Development Committee and Plan Management Committee are advised by the District Land Use Planning Unit, which is composed of professional district officers conversant with land issues, chaired by the Land Board Secretary with the District Officer (Lands) as secretary. DLUPU prepares and coordinates the district land use activities and plans. The District Development Committee, which is composed of all government and district council heads of departments, coordinates the District Development Plan. Each member is responsible to the Committee and is obliged to report on the progress of his/her department. Quarterly Progress reports are sent to the Ministries of Local Government, Lands Housing and Environment, and Finance & Development Planning (Rural Development Coordination Division) with copies to all districts and Permanent Secretaries to keep all concerned up-to-date with developments in the district. The following sub-committees report to the DDC: District Extension Team, District Land Use Planning Unit, Production Development Committee and Multi-Sectoral Aids Coordinating Committee. The Senyawe and Zwenshambe Brigade Development Trusts and other district based parastatals also report to the committee. The District Extension Team serves as an important tool in the evaluation of the plan. The team organizes an annual Village Development Committee conference for planning, monitoring and evaluation of the district plan. The North East District Extension Team is co-chaired by the 171 District Officer (Development) and the Senior Council Planning Officer with the Chief Community Development Officer and District Adult Education Officers as secretaries. The functions of the District Extension Team are to prepare, monitor and ensure the implementation of the Annual District Plan. Other functions include compiling progress reports, organizing VET’s seminars, annual DDC conferences and acts as a source and reference point in all extension related matters. The strengthening of the District Extension Team is vital, since it is responsible for the smooth running of the district extension activities, which are contributory to the development of the villages. It is also necessary to develop the structure and functioning of the Village Extension Teams. 172 CHAPTER 16 16 CONTINGENCY PLANNING 16.1 INTRODUCTION Botswana is prone to various disasters, which makes disaster management an important component of planning. One of the vision 2016 pillars calls for making Botswana a “safe and secure nation”, the establishment of a well-planned system to counteract the effects on natural disasters will meet this vision objective. The most regular type of disaster in this country is drought, which has become a cyclical phenomenon. Other types of disasters such as veld fires, floods and animal diseases, although not regular need to be planned for. In the context of North East, like in the rest of the country, drought is a common phenomenon leaving a lot of rural populace dependent on agriculture and land-based resources impoverished. Veld fires often occur in some parts of the district but are not frequent. Floods also affect the district, the 2000 floods, affected the district and left a lot physical infrastructure and left a substantial amount of property affected. The district was also affected by foot and mouth disease towards the end o DDDP 5, which led to killing of a considerable amount of livestock. Disasters of this nature seriously affect the process of development hence the need for a coordinated management of drought and disaster relief. 16.1.1 Institutional Framework The Interministerial Drought Committee (IMDC) is a sub-committee of the Rural Development Council (RDC) under the Ministry of Finance and Development Planning it comprises of representaion from its minisry, MOA, MLG, MOH, MWT and MMEWA. It monitors food security situation through the early warning technical committee and advises RDC on issues of reource allocation during drought. The comiittees consults the district drought relief committees to review the agricultural situation (crops and livestock), grazing situation, food situation assessing area ploughed and planted and Nutritional level of the district. It then makes an assessment on the drought situation and makes recommendation to the RDC which advises Cabinet. The committee is also responsible for organisation of funds for drought intervention programmes and support in terms of labour intensive projects, social safety nets, nutrition, school feeding and remote area dwellers. The District Drought Relief Committee which has the chairmanship of the Council Secretary and the District Commissioner is responsible for making a preliminary assessment of the drought situation prior to submission of the report to IMDC, it also monitors the drought programme and scrutinises project proposals sent by communities for inclusion in the labour-based relief programme. The National Disaster Management Office (NDMO), which is under the office of the President, is responsible for management of disaster at national level. It is responsible for leading and coordinating disaster planning, preparedness and management, mitigation and recovery in the country. At the district level the disasters lies with the District Disaster Management Committee, 173 with the District Commissioner and the Council Secretary being the co-chairpersons of the committee. 16.1.2 Disaster Relief Sector Priorities Other types of Disasters, unlike the onsite of drought, which can be predicted with accuracy, usually occur as emergencies and their impact can be devastating. They therefore disrupt the normal way of life for people as they often result in destruction of property, and even loss of life. The 2000 floods typify this scenario as some people lost their lives and property. Veldfires also erupt in certain parts of the district especially in freehold farms. Communities have raised concerns on the issues of environmental conservation and called for strengthening of conservation committees in effort to promote sustainable development. Vision 2016 calls for efficient use of natural resources and an integrated approach towards conservation and development. The vision further calls for community involvement in the use and preservation of their resources. Communities requested for expediency when assisted during disaster. They further raised concern on the lack of fire station and fire fighting facilities. To improve the district’s disaster preparedness, management and mitigation, the committees in place will continue to be strengthened to improve efficiency. The district has hosted a workshop to strengthen the response mechanism to deal with disasters. The reporting system in the event of disaster will further be communicated to the communities in the yearly consultative meetings. 16.2 NATIONAL POLICIES AND LEGISLATION 16.2.1 National Disaster Master Plan The National Policy on Disaster Management provides the framework for the National Disaster Management Plan. Disaster management is the responsibility of every citizen and institution in the country. Integrated and coordinated management is based on the partnerships and corporation amongst all government sectors. Efficient and cost effective disaster management will be based on the mobilisation of existing government structures and resources in collaboration with communities, the private sector and non-governmental organisations. 16.2.2 National Food Security Strategy The National Food Strategy lays down the framework within which the national and household and economic security processes and activities are to be carried out. The scope of the strategy is as follows: Providing economic access to food for household by attainment of broad-based income security Assurance of household food security availability of national food imports and production Within the scope of this strategy, there will be joint responsibility reflecting the partnership of government, private sector, and household in the availability and access to nutritionally safe and adequate food. 174 16.3 CONTINGENCY PLANS 16.3.1 Drought The management of drought is the responsibility of District Drought Relief Committee. The committee comprises all stakeholder departments such as Animal Health and Production, Crop Production and Forestry, District Council, District Administration, Tribal Administration, and Tribal Land Board. Although drought relief programme is multi-sectoral, the council does its dayto-day implementation, which then reports progress to the District Drought Relief Committee. The programme is monitored and coordinated by the District Drought Relief committee under the chairmanship of the District Commissioner. The components of the drought relief programme are; The Labour Intensive Public Works Programme Supplementary feeding programme for all children under five years attending child welfare clinics Agricultural relief programme which assist livestock farmers through subsidised stock feed. The institutional arrangement and organisational structure for implementation of drought have proven their efficiency during DDP5 hence the need to maintain the existing arrangement and probably further strengthen it for efficient implementation in the DDP6. 16.3.2 Veld Fires The objective of veld fire contingency plan is to help streamline fire management and control activities in the district by each stakeholder, to effect timely management control of fire in the event of an outbreak and to develop a clear fire outbreak reporting and handling mechanism of veld fires. Consultation will be done with farm owner where the occurrence of fire outbreak is frequent. The District Commissioner and/or the Council Secretary serve as overall coordinators of veld fires control at the district level. Their role is to communicate expeditiously with departments/institutions to take up their respective roles as prescribed in the contingency plan. All stakeholders are to facilitate acquisition of fire fighting tools and resources whenever a fire outbreak has been reported. Villagers, passerbys or the causes themselves normally report veld fires to Dikgosi at village who in turn inform the police and members of the public to act accordingly. Though the district council is mandated by the Act to provide fire service emergencies, it has not been able to do so owing to requisite personnel, equipment and a station. A fully fledged fire station with requisite staff equipment has been planned in DDP6. 16.3.3 Disaster Management Disaster management in the district is the responsibility of the District Disaster Preparedness committee co-chaired by the District Commissioner and the Council Secretary. It comprises all departments responsible for implementation of disaster management and mitigation measures such the police, district administration, conservation committee, immigration, BDF and the district council. In the event of any fom of disaster the public is expected to report to either the Kgosi or the police who will accordingly take action or call for additional help if need be. 175 16.3.4 Foot and Mouth Disease Report on FMD was first stated in February 2002 in Matshelagabedi and Matsiloje areas. This led to the killing of 12 000 cattle. Another FMD disaster was reported towards the end of 2002 in the Matopi/Tseteng areas which also to the killing of 4 000 cattle. Farmers were compensated with cash and livestock and a disaster relif labour based programme was introduced to relief farmers. 16.4 FRAMEWORK FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT 16.4.1 Disaster Management Objectives 16.4.2 16.4.3 To establish and maintain optimum systems for dealing with disasters other than drought in and to integrate these systems into normal ongoing development activities within district resource capacity. To create a framework which facilitates the preparation of plans and legislation for effective implementation of disaster management and its legitimacy. To outline the responsibilities of different personnel at different levels in the implementation of the disaster management programme. To establish a set of working definitions for the disaster management programme. To ensure that the disaster management policy is consistent with policies from other sectors and the objectives of the DDP6. To formulate a well comprehensive sytem/plan for disaster management and communicate it to communities. To hold yearly consultative district forum on disaster management veldfires drought etc. Drought Management Objectives To ensure that drought occurrence is mainstreamed into district development plan and annual plans and contingency measures are instilled. To create an environment for a responsive drought-monitoring tool which will enable the district to early detect drought and prepare for it. To continually assess drought situation and make recommendations to the drought assessment committee. To ensure that all affected district populace is assisted. To ensure that project implemented through the programme are viable and sustainable and also in pursuit of the district development plan. Evaluation of Sector Goals and Objectives Table 16.1: Evaluation of Sector Goals and Objectives Goals/objectives To establish and maintain optimum systems for dealing with disasters other than drought and to integrate these systems into normal ongoing development activities within district resource capacity. Issues Uncoordinated approach in dealing with disaster management in everyday activities. Strategies Formulation of a guideline for integration into dev activities by 2005 To outline the responsibilities of different personnel at different levels in the implementation of the disaster management programme To establish a set of working definitions for the disaster management programme 176 Goals/objectives To create a framework which facilitates the preparation of plans and legislation for effective implementation of disaster management and its legitimacy. To ensure that the disaster management policy is consistent with policies from other sectors and the objectives of the DDP6. Issues Insufficient support from the political leadership and the community. Strategies Introduction of disaster management to councillors and lobby for their involvement Inadequate correlation of disaster management with existing policies and departmental plans. Scrutinising departments annual plans prior to implementation To formulate a well comprehensive system/plan for disaster management and communicate it to communities. Uncoordinated disaster management and reporting system. Uncoordinated use of resources during disasters Drought recurrence throughout the plan period. To ensure that drought occurrence is mainstreamed into district development plan and annual plans and contingency measures are instilled. To create an environment for a responsive drought-monitoring tool which will enable the district to early detect drought and prepare for it. Consultative meetings Subject plans to disaster management audit Quarterly reports from individual departments. Late response to drought disaster. Loss of resources by ploughing in drought years. Lack early response to curb against loss to livestock in drought years. To ensure that all affected district populace is assisted. Quarterly reporting Open air meetings, kgotla meetings Low coverage of the district drought responses. Quarterly reports in livestock situation, wildlife and grazing situation. Monthly water situation reports. Rainfall situation reports. Drought situation reports. Quarterly social welfare reports. Consultative meetings with VDCs. To ensure that project implemented through the programme are viable and sustainable and also in pursuit of the district development plan. Control of spread of animal disease. Low coverage of supplementary feeding of children. Implentation of substandard and unsustainable projects Uncoordinated control of animal disease. Screening of projects prior to implementation. Formulate a well coordinated strategy for disease control. Straying of animals to diseased areas. Lack of proper care of livestock by farmers. Maintenance of the erected cross border electric fence. Spot checks to prevent vandalism of fence. Proper disposal of animals killed during disease disaster. Encourage communities (farmers) to look after cattle, institute and enforce penalties for straying animals. Mobilise farmers for vaccine to vaccinate animals. 16.4.4 Evaluation of Sector Policies and Programmes 16.4.4.1 Drought and Disaster Relief Programme The implementation of the Drought Relief Programme in the District in the past years had its own pros and cons. However remedial measures have been put in place where possible. Poor coordination between the supervisors and skilled personnel: The majority of supervisors in the labour-based relief projects lack appropriate skills for the various projects they supervise. The skill is vested purely on the skilled personnel employed by the VDC. The supervisor has direct control over the labourers whilst the builder does not. These result in the works being done at snail pace. 177 Productivity: In the drought programme the issue of productivity does not exist. Most of the works are done at snail pace as a deliberate act to increase the number of workdays, because the more the number of workdays the more the earnings. Projects are often completed beyond the scheduled time and result in over expenditures. Maintenance of the completed projects (Construction Projects): The VDCs lack the capacity to maintain the structures after handover. 16.4.5 Proposed Projects/Activities Table 16.3: Proposed Projects, Potential Impacts and Mitigation Measures Proposed Project/Activity Training of disaster preparedness committee. Drafting of the district based disaster management plan/procedure. Formulation of disaster campaign schedule and implementation including consultation with freehold farmers. Disaster management to be disseminated to schools and communities. Disaster management to be included as part of the duties of VDC and be included in their training schedule. Construction and maintenance of fire breaks. Purchasing of fire fighting tools and vehicles and also construction of a fire station. Control of animal disease. 16.5 RESOURCE REQUIREMENTS 16.5.1 Issues and Strengths 16.5.2 Potential Environmental Impact Littering No correlation. Mitigation Measure Provision of waste receptacle in meeting areas. Nil Littering during meetings. Provision of waste receptacle in meeting areas. Littering during meetings. Provision of waste receptacles. Littering during meetings. Provision of waste receptacles. Land degradation. Replacement of species. Loss of species. Land degradation. Landscaping. Soil exaction. Rehabitation of burrow pits. Loss of biodiversity. Environmental pollution. Harvesting of sand in designated areas. Propoer disposal of animal vaccines and medicines. As mandated by the Act to offer fire emergency services, council should be given the requisite personnel, equipment and stations to efficiently render the service. Employment or appointment of a disaster management district based personnel, solely responsible for disasters. Funds to undertake disaster relief activities/projects to be availed promptly. Performance Targets The assistance/relief package to reach all affected members of the community. Approximately 90% coverage in disaster and drought relief intervention. Development of a well structured and coordinated approach for disaster management. Disaster management integrated in all district plans. Educated community on environmental conservation and disaster reporting system. Veld fires reduced by 90% midway plan period. Participation and Support from all stakeholders in the event of disaster. 178 16.5.3 Proposed Projects Table 16.4: Proposed Projects Project Fire station vehicles and Equipment Training of Disaster Management Committee Training of political leaders Training of VDCs Project Cost P8 000 0000 P240 000 P60 000 P100 000 Year of Implementation 2004/5 Throughout the plan period 2004/5 and 2005/6 2004/5 and 2006/7 179 CHAPTER 17 17 PLAN MONITORING AND EVALUATION 17.1 INTRODUCTION Monitoring and Review of the DDP6 will be carried out as stipulated below: To establish physical and financial progress during plan implementation. To detect implementation hassles so that corrective measures are taken while there is time. To reprioritise projects in light of changing circumstances and prevailing needs To adjudge as to what extent project implementation will lead to goal achievement. The first two aspects will be taken care of mainly through monitoring and the latter issues will be dealt with through regular review and evaluation. 17.1.1 Institutional Framework The main actors in the monitoring and review of the DPP6 will be the Council Committees, District Development Committee and Plan Management Committee. It is further expected that the pararstatals and non-government organisation will accordingly monitor implementation of their plans. Changes in the plan will be communicated to the communities through the Councillors. That is first the proposed plan amendments will be presented to the DDC, which will accordingly present to the Full Council. It is expected that Councillors as ex-officio members of the VDC will accordingly brief the VDC but where necessary the consultation process may be undertaken by the district plan management committee. 17.1.2 Review of Plan Monitoring Activities During DDP 5 Activities were carried out as follows: Annual Project Reviews were carried out in conjunction with the Ministry of Local Government, and Ministry of Lands Housing and Environment so as to determine mechanisms of improving project performance. Annual plans were prepared to guide the local authorities on the yearly implementation of projects. Council Sub-Committees and the District Development Committee were kept abreast of plan monitoring and evaluation activities through regular briefings. Quarterly financial and physical progress reports were submitted to the Ministries and the District Development Committee. A mid term review was carried out in 2000 so as to assess plan performance Planners Meetings and National District Development Conferences (N.D.D.C’s) were organized by the Ministry of Local Government so as to discuss planning and implementation constraints and the way forward. 180 17.2 ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING ACTIVITIES The district has not carried out an environmental audit exercise in during the DDP5. This is a very important exercise will help the district take stock of environmental issues. The audit will help the district to identify the potential impacts of development projects, policies and programmes on the environment. Specifically, it is aimed at examining the purview of the district development goals, objectives and projects in relation to the existing environmental policies and constraints. The audit will be undertaken at the beginning of the DDP6. It is planned that an annual environmental review will be undertaken simultaneously with the review of the development plans. These will accordingly be presented to the DDC and the Full Council. Such environment audit will enable the district to see how it is fairing as regards environmental conservation strategies. 17.3 FINANCIAL AND PERSONNEL CONSTRAINTS Funding for some of the DDP5 projects components was hardly sufficient. This emanated as an issue during the mid-term review of DDP5 and the review of the DDP5 at the end of the plan period This includes the Local Authorities Development Grants, Primary Health facilities, Primary school facilities (such as Administration Blocks, Teachers’ quarters, and school kitchens), Village infrastructure, Roads Projects, and Community Projects. In some instances, the Total Estimated Cost (TEC) was exhausted well before the second year of the plan period mainly due to cost escalations. Personnel constraints during DDP5 related to the lack of technical and professional manpower especially in the fields of roads, architecture and buildings. This impacted negatively on the implementation of projects. Thus targets were hardly met in certain instances due to lack of technical manpower. Additionally, DABS was also unable to meet the development and maintenance requirements of the district. The handing over of some of its activities to council will in the long run improve the efficiency of the department. It is expected that the department will be able to carry out all the planned activities. These constraints are likely to persist during DDP5 since the Macroeconomic Outline and Policy Framework has painted a gloomy picture about the global economic trends during the next six years. However, with the reforms in the higher education and technical training sector (including the proposed establishment of a second university) and the improvement in the terms and conditions of local government employees there is hope that the shortage of technical personnel will be overcome soon. 17.4 PROPOSED PLAN MONITORING ACTIVITIES DURING DDP6 17.4.1 Project Reviews Annual Projects Reviews will be undertaken in liaison with the relevant Government Ministries in order to assess progress and to address shortcomings. These project reviews will constitute the basis of the subsequent years annual plan. Thus proposed projects will be re-evaluated and implementation snags will be discussed at the project review meetings. 181 17.4.2 Annual Plans Based on the DDP6, annual plans will be drawn clearly specifying what has to be done. These plans will be specific i.e. planned project and activities will be specified for each vote (using the project matrices as a guide). Project Managers will then monitor physical and financial progress by submitting progress reports to DDC for forwarding to Council and the Ministry of Local Government (Quarterly by Physical and Financial Progress Reports). The Council Planning Office will be responsible for compiling the progress report for Council projects while the District Development Office will be responsible for central government projects. Implementation hassles will be highlighted in the report and major problems will be discussed by Council Committees with the objectives of taking corrective measurers. 17.4.3 Mid Term Review Halfway through DDP6 (after three years), a midterm review will be undertaken. Besides analysing implementation progress and constraints and reprioritisation of projects if need be, the midterm review will assess the extent to which the specific goals and objectives had been achieved and recommend fundamental adjustments where necessary. As a consequence of the midterm review, implementation strategies and planned projects for the remainder of the plan will be determined. 182 APPENDIX A: DISTRICT COUNCIL PROJECTS LG 104 – Local Authority Infrastructure Maintenance Council Roads Projects Qty/No/ Km Project Name Unit Cost Totals 2002/3 2003/4 2005/6 Culverts Gravelling Masukwane-Nlapkhwane 9 P76,440.00 P687,960 Siviya-Jackalas II 10.4 P76,440.00 P794,976 Bisoli-Jackalas II 8 P76,440.00 P611,520 x Tshesebe-Butale 9.3 P76,440.00 P710,892 x Tonota-Ditladi 8.4 P76,440.00 P642,096 X Kgari-Moroka 6 P76,440.00 P458,640 Masukwane-Kgari-Ramokgwebana 11.4 P871,416.00 X Themashanga-Mowana 6.2 P76,440.00 P473,928 Makaleng-Gulubane 13 P76,440.00 P993,720 x Senyawe –Siviya 6 P76,440.00 P458,640 x Moroka-Jackalas 1 4 P76,440.00 P305,760 x Mambo-Sechele 5 P76,440.00 P382,200 Mambo-Makaleng 6 P76,440.00 P458,640 Project Component Electrical Installation 1x2 C.R.B.&Staff houses 2no. 1x2 C.R.B.& Staff houses 2no. 1x2 C.R.B & Staff houses Staff houses Staff houses Staff houses Staff houses Rural Admin Centre Buildings and Architecture 58 x Teachers Quarters(LA2) 35 x T/Quarters(LA1) 135 x Classrooms 18 x Storerooms 60 x W.C toilets Pitlatrines Nurses houses Staff houses P76,440.00 Location 2003/204 Ditladi Matopi Botalaote/Toteng Gungwe Vukwi Letsholathebe Gambule Masunga 45 600.00 96 480.00 46 000.00 38 400.00 20 000.00 30 400.00 20 000.00 P15 000.00 District District District District District District District District 406,000.00 175,000.00 810,000.00 27,000.00 90,000.00 34,000.00 287,000.00 385,000.00 x X 2004/05 2005/06 406,000.00 175,000.00 810,000.00 27,000.00 90,000.00 34,000.00 287,000.00 385,000.00 406,000.00 175,000.00 810,000.00 27,000.00 90,000.00 34,000.00 287,000.00 385,000.00 LG 103 – MLG Computerisation The project is intended to facilitate the implementation capacity of local government through computerisation. During DDP5/NDP8, an information technology strategy was to be established. The programme is implemented from the ministry hence no budgetary information is available. It must, however, be noted that there is need for this information to be availed to the district. LG 104 – MLG/LA Fleet Development 183 Project Component Small Vehicles Double Cabs Trucks 2003/04 2004/05 2005/06 2006/07 2007/08 2008/09 Total 7 1 - 2 4 1 2 2 1 7 1 0 0 0 5 20 3 LG 301 – Storage and Distribution Facilities Project Component Food storage facilities Location Masunga 2003/04 3,990,000.00 2004/05 LG 1102 – Primary School Facilities The main objectives of the project is to implement the Revised National Policy of Education specifically Recommendation 14. The main aim of council during DDP5 was to provide adequate toilets to pupils, classroom accommodation to all classes and all teachers with accommodation. The district has only been able to provide close to adequate classrooms. The backlog of teachers’ accommodation is still a serious problem. The major problem that caused a backlog is the issue of cost escalations, which reduced the number of projects implemented. The other issue that contributed to the backlog is the increase in the number of classes and teachers. Planned Primary Schools Construction, 2003/2004 School/village c/r/b t/q w/c admin block kitchen sp/f sc. lab Botalaote/Toteng New school - - 1 - - - 1 - Butale - - - 1 1 - - - Ditladi - - 1 - - - 1 - Gungwe - 1 1 - - - 1 - Masukwane - - 1 - - - - - Masunga - - 2 - - - - - Matshelagabedi - - 1 - - 1 - - Matsiloje - - 1 - - - - - Mbalambi - 2 1 2 - - - - Moroka - - 1 - - - - - Mosojane - - 1 - - - 1 - Mulambakwena - - 1 2 - - - - Nlapkhwane - - 1 - - - - - Ramokgwebana - - 1 - - - 1 - Sekakangwe - - 1 - - - 1 - 184 School/village c/r/b t/q w/c admin block kitchen sp/f sc. lab Senyawe New school - - 1 1 - - - - Siviya - - 1 - - - - - Letsholathebe - - - - 1 - 1 - Tatisiding 1 6 12 12 1 1 1 1 1 9 29 18 3 2 8 1 New Tatisiding P/School TOTAL Planned Primary Schools Construction, 2004/2005 School Village C/R/B T/Q W/C Ditladi New School - Kitchen Sp/F Sc. Lab - Admin Block - - 1 - - - Jackalas II - 1 1 - 1 - - - Masunga - - 1 - - - - - Matopi - 1 - - - - 1 - Matshelagabedi - - 1 - - - - - Matsiloje - - 1 - - - 1 - Mbalambi - - 1 - - - - - Moroka - - 1 - - 1 1 - Mosojane - - 1 - - - - - Mulambakwena - - 1 1 1 - 1 - Nlaphkhwane - - 1 1 - - 1 - Ramokgwebana - - 1 - - - - - Senyawe - - 1 1 - - 1 - Siviya - - 1 1 - - 1 - Themashanga - - 1 - - - - - Tsamaya - - 1 - - - - - Zwenshambe - - 1 1 - - - - Gulubane - 1 1 - - - - - Masingwaneng - - - 1 - - - - Botalaote/Toteng - - - 1 - - - - Masunga 1 5 10 10 1 1 1 1 185 School Village New School 1 TOTAL C/R/B T/Q W/C 8 27 17 Admin Block 3 Kitchen Sp/F Sc. Lab 2 8 1 Planned Primary Schools Construction, 2005/2006 Schl/Village Crb T/Q W/C Admin Block Kitchen Sp/F Sc. Lab Butale New School - - 1 - - - 1 - Jackalas II - 1 2 - - - 1 - Kalakamati - - 1 - - - 1 - Kgari - - 1 - - 1 1 - Letsholathebe - - 1 - - - - - Mabudzane - - 1 - - - 1 - Mambo - - 1 2 - - 1 - Mapoka - - 1 2 - - - - Masingwaneng - - 1 - - - - - Matopi - 1 1 - - - - - Moroka - - 2 - - - - - Mowana - 1 2 - - - - - Pole - 1 - - - - - - Siviya - 1 - - - - - - Themashanga - - 2 - - - - - Mulambakwena - - 1 3 - - - - Nlapkhwane - - - 1 - - - - Zwenshambe - - - 1 - - - - Tatisiding - - - - 1 - - - Sechele - - - - 1 - - - Tsamaya - - - - - 1 - - Mbalambi - - - - - - 1 - - 3 17 7 2 2 7 - New Masunga P/School TOTAL Planned Primary Schools Construction, 2006/2007 186 School/Village New School Crb T/Q W/C Admin Block Kitchen Sp/F Sc. Lab Ditladi - - 2 - - - - - Makaleng - - 1 - - - - - Masunga - - 1 - - - - - Matshelagabedi - - 2 - - - 1 - Mbalambi - - 2 - - - - - Molambakwena - 1 2 - - - - - Pole - - 1 - - - 1 - Vukwi - - 2 - - - 1 - Zwenshambe - - 2 - - - 1 - Gulubane - - 1 - - - 1 - Jackalas II - - - 2 - - - - Pelotelele - - 1 - 1 1 1 - Senyawe - - - 2 - - - - Mapoka - - - 2 - - 1 - Butale - - - 1 - - - - Matenge - 1 - - - 1 - - Matsiloje - 1 - - - - - - Patayamatebele 1 2 5 5 1 - 1 - TOTAL 1 5 22 12 2 2 8 - Planned Primary Schools Construction, 2007/2008 School/Village Crb T/Q W/C Admin Block Kitchen Sp/F Jackakas I New School - - 1 - - - 1 Sc. Lab - Jackalas II - - 1 - - - - - Masunga - - 2 - - - 1 - Matenge - - 1 - - - 1 - Matsiloje - - 2 - - - - - Nlaphkhwane - 1 1 - - - - - Sekakangwe - - 1 - 1 - - - 187 School/Village Crb T/Q W/C Admin Block Kitchen Sp/F Themashanga New School - 1 2 - - - 1 Sc. Lab - Tsamaya - - 1 2 - - 1 - Vukwi - 1 - - - - - - Zwenshambe - - 1 - - - - - Gulubane - - 1 - - - 1 - Tshesebe - - - 2 - - - - Ramokgwebana - - - 3 - - - - Mosojane - - 2 - - - - - Mabudzane - - - - - 1 - - Gambule - - - - - - 1 - TOTAL - 3 16 7 1 1 7 - Planned Primary Schools Construction, 2008/2009 School/Village New School Crb T/Q W/C Admin. Block Kitchen Sp/F Sc. Lab Ditladi - 2 - - - - - - Masukwane - - 2 - - - 1 - Matshelagabedi - - 1 - - - - - Nlapkhwane - - 1 1 - - - - Ramokgwebana - - 2 - - - - - Senyawe - - 2 - - - - - Siviya - - 2 - - - - - Tatisiding - - 2 - - - - - Tsamaya - - 2 - - - - - Tshesebse - - 1 - - - - - Zwenshambe - 1 - - - - - - Gulubane - - 1 - - - - - Mbalambi - - - 1 - - - - Vukwi - - - 4 - - - - Makaleng - - - - - - 1 - Masingwaneng - - - - - - 1 - 188 School/Village New School Crb T/Q W/C Admin. Block Kitchen Sp/F Sc. Lab Mowana - - - - - - 1 - Sechele - - - - - - 1 - TOTAL 0 3 16 6 - 6 - LG 1103 – Recreation Facilities Project Development spaces Development spaces Development spaces Development spaces Development spaces Development spaces Development spaces Development spaces of open Location Masunga 2003/4 1 2004/5 of open Tati siding of open Nlapkwane of open Mapoka - of open Makaleng - 1 of open Zwenshambe - - of open Matshelagabedi of open District 2005/6 2006/7 2007/8 1 2008/9 1 1 1 1 1 1 LG 1104 – Primary Health Facilities The project provides funding for construction, equipping and furnishing health facilities for district Council. During the DDP5, the district council constructed 5 health posts, 4 clinics and 3 clinics with maternity. The district council was able to achieve 100% of all the planned projects and even implemented some of the projects, which were not funded in the plan. The project will provide health facilities in areas without, upgrade those unable to cope with the pressure for health care, nurses houses, procure equipment, and ambulances. The DDP6 targets are, 3 upgrading to clinics, 1 upgrading to maternity, 1 health post, 1 upgrading to 24-hour clinic, and 21 nurses houses. Project Upgrading of clinic to 24hrs Tati-siding Special Equipment Tati-Siding Extension of Tsamaya rehabilitation centre Hostel blocks Tsamaya Upgrading to Maternity Themashanga Uggrading of H/Post to Clinic Senyawe Tshesebe Gulubane Moroka Zwenshambe New H/Post - Patayamatebele Solar/ electrification Patayamatebele Sechele Gulubane 2003/4 - 2004/5 1 2005/6 - 2006/7 - 2007/8 - 2008/9 - - 1 - - - - 1 2 - - - - - 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 189 Project Kalakamati Matshelagabedi Radio Communication Ditladi Tati-Siding Masunga Patayamatebele Standby Generator Tati-Siding 15 Seater Combi Tsamaya Rehab DHT Masunga Ambulance Tshesebe Senyawe Moroka Tati-Siding Zwenshambe Patayamatebele Mbalambi Sechele Jackalas 2 Clinical Waste Vehicle Tati-Siding Makaleng Nurses Houses Senyawe Moroka Tati-Siding Masukwane Mambo Matenge Themashanga Gulubane Patayamatebele Tshesebe Sechele Store Room DHT Water Closets a. Nlaphwane b. Mbalambi c. Masingwneng 2003/4 1 2004/5 2005/6 2006/7 2007/8 2008/9 1 2 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 3 3 6 1 1 1 2 3 1 3 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 LG 1105 – Rural Administration Centres The project provides integrated office blocks for both Central Government and Local government departments. The continuing increase of manpower has overstretched the available office space. During DDP5, an extension of the existing RAC was planned. However, the project was not undertaken as a result of lack of funding. The project will be undertaken during DDP6. In addition, other extension areas in the district, such as Tati Siding are growing at a rapid rate and therefore exert pressure location of some offices to provide services such as collection of revenue and various social welfare services. Project Extension of RAC Extension of Supplies Ware House Block of offices – Tati Siding 2003/4 1 1 - 2004/5 1 2005/6 - 2006/7 - 2007/8 - 2008/9 - 190 LG 1107 – Labour Intensive Public Works The main aim of the project is to generate employment by using labour intensive methods and simple methods to construct and maintain public facilities. The programme was implemented at a very slow pace during DDP5. The main problems were shortage of manpower in council to supervise and monitor projects, and shortage of skilled labourers. During DDP6, the project will continue to be used to construct public facilities such as staff houses, literacy classrooms, and extension and construction of new offices in extension areas. Project Storeroom Mapoka Tribal Admin Letsholathebe Water System Toilets Letsholathebe Kalakamati Mabudzani Mowana Debushing Roads Masunga Mapoka Moroka Nlaphkwane Zwenshambe Office Block for Extension Officers Mosojane Sechele Nlaphkwane Kgari Tsamaya Themashanga Tshesebe Siviya Gulubane Shashe Bridge Electrification & Extension of S&CD Office Mapoka Mobile Stop Nlaphkwane(Malobela ward) Guard House Ramokgwebana Butale Fencing Butale Reading Room Mulambakwena Sekakangwe Tsamaya Literacy Assistant house Makaleng Ditladi Literacy Classroom Masingwaneng Makaleng Gulubane Ditladi 2003/4 2004/5 2005/6 2006/7 2007/8 2008/9 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 4 4 4 4 4 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 - - - 1 1 - 1 - 1 - - 1 - 1 - 1 - 1 - 1 - 191 LG 1108 – Rural Sanitation Programme The objectives of the project are to reduce the incidence of sanitary-related diseases by building ventilated improved pit latrines (VIPs) through a subsidised self-help scheme and to provide modern sanitary facilities such as landfills for collection and disposal of solid waste in rural areas. The problems encountered continue to be that of failure by the people to complete the substructures and to raise the P30.00 contribution. During the DDP5 366 VIP latrines, 100 dry compost latrines, and a sanitary landfill in Masunga were constructed. The target for DDP6 is 1000 pit latrines, 1 waste transfer station, 2 improved slaughter houses, and 1 sanitation depot. Vehicles and equipment will also be purchased to facilitate service delivery. Project Waste Transfer Station Tsamaya Improve Slaughter House Tsamaya Masunga 2003-04 - On site sanitation (VIP) Water borne public toilets Ramokgwebana Tati-Siding - Refuse Trucks Closed Skips Communication system Computer & Accessories Public Toilets Tati Siding Ramokgwebana Recycling Project; a. Masunga Static Skips Recycling Project; b. Tsamaya Static Skips Installation of radio communication Masunga Tatisiding 2005-06 1 2006-07 - 2007-08 - 2008-09 - 200 1 200 200 200 200 1 - 1 1 1 1 - 15 - - - - 1 - 1 1 3 - - 2 1 1 Sanitation depot Tati Siding Bailer Machines Masunga Waste oil collection receptacle Masunga Universal Load Carrier Rehabilitation of dumping site Kalakamati 2004-05 - 1 1 1 1 1 LG 1109 – Community Projects The programme’s objective is to improve the economic and social welfare of the rural people by strengthening institutions, such as VDCs and other voluntary organisations to plan and implement development activities, improving communities’ access to public services, and promoting productive and employment generating activities through the micro project. However, the major problem during DDP5 was lack of implementation or slow implementation. This was mainly a 192 cause of slowness by communities to raise their contribution. In addition, there were problems due to contribution in kind especially where communities offered free labour. This has often led to community projects suffering when other government programmes such as drought relief, and labour intensive road works, which offer wages, were ongoing. Despite this, people have indicated a willingness to continue with the programme as indicated by the proposed projects for DDP6. The target for DDP6 is 8 day care Centres, 2 community halls,5 VDC storerooms, 8 VDC Offices, and 4 pilot projects. In addition to these, courses will be conducted to empower the communities with skills. Project Location 2003/2004 2004/2005 2005/2006 2006/2007 2007/2008 2008/2009 1. Day Care Centres Moroka 1 Tshesebe 1 Ditladi 1 Matshelagabedi 1 Mbalambi 1 Masingwaneng 1 Nlaphkwane 1 1 Mosojane Botalaote/Toteng 1 2. Community Hall Mulambakwena 1 3. Electrification Mlambakwena 3 Shahse Bridge 2 Sekakangwe 1 Matsiloje Jackalas 1 1 4 Ramokgwebana 1 Senyawe 1 4. VDC storerooms Gambule 1 Matenge 1 Masukwane 1 1 Vukwi Letsholathebe 1 5. VDC Offices Matopi 1 Mowana 1 Toteng 1 Botalaote 1 Gungwe 1 Pule 1 Mabudzane Themashanga 1 1 6. LA II house 193 Project Location 2003/2004 Masunga 1 2004/2005 2005/2006 1 1 8 8 2006/2007 2007/2008 8 8 3 3 2008/2009 7. Water Closets Mapoka 8. Block Grants NED villages 8 9. Pilot Component a. Poultry Jakalas 2 1 Kgari 1 b. Face Brick Project Themashanga 1 c. Brick Moulding Masukwane 1 d. Sorghum Milling Matsiloje 1 10. Graveyard Fencing Tsamaya 1 Siviya 1 11. Vehicles – Masunga Truck 1 Twincab 1 Single Cab 1 12. Carpentry & Business Management Makaleng 1 13. Sewing Course Sourthern & Eastern Zone 1 1 14. Welding Central & Western Zone 1 15. Workshops & Seminars District 4 4 3 3 LG 1110 –Village Water Supply and Sewerage The project provides funding for rehabilitation, augmentation and expansion of rural village water supply schemes, which are constructed by the department of water affairs. In addition it provides for capacity building of councils to operate and maintain efficiently the rural water supply schemes, as well as to gradually take part in some of the augmentation activities currently done by the Department of Water Affairs. The project also aims at the operation and maintenance, rehabilitation and upgrading of existing sewerage systems in primary and secondary villages. The target for DDP6 is water rehabilitation projects and upgrading of sewerage schemes. However, note must be made that the water rehabilitation schemes rely entirely on the Department of Water Affairs initiatives to identify water sources. These initiatives include mainly, Maitengwe well fields and the Ntimbale Dam. 194 Project Location 2003/4 2004/5 Water Reticulation Improvement, Reservoir & Source Botalaote Gambule Gulubane Jackalas 2 Kalakamati Makaleng Mulambakwena 250,000 Mambo Masukwane Matshelagabedi Matenge Masunga 500,000 Mbalambi/Gungwe Nlapkhwane Mapoka Ramakgwebana Sekakangwe Shashe Bridge Siviya Themashanga Masingwaneng Zwenshambe Water Supply Rehabilitation & Source Moroka Pole Tsamaya/Mabudzane Tshesebe 10m3 Water Bowser 4x4wd Pick Up Vehicles Masunga 2006/7 2007/8 2008/9 120,000 250,000 250,000 250,000 130,000 250,000 350,000 250,000 250,000 250,000 250,000 350,000 350,000 350,000 130,000 120,000 350,000 240,000 130,000 370,000 800,000 700,000 700,000 700,000 Stand Pipes Mowana Mabudzane Truck with Crane Masunga Extension of Sewarage Scheme Masunga 2005/6 60,000 60,000 4,620,000 500,000 800,000 LG 1111 – Village Infrastructure The project provides funding for the servicing of land for residential, commercial and industrial purposes in villages designated primary and secondary centres. This is so as villages have lagged behind in terms of infrastructure and are less viable locations for investment than urban areas. This has led to lack of employment opportunities in rural areas giving rise to rural-urban migration. During DDP5, village infrastructure was done in Tati Siding. Infrastructure development is planned for Masunga and other villages during DDP6. 195 Project Component Infrastructure Development Project Location Culverts Internal Mosojane Mulambakwena Sekakangwe Nlapkhwane Pole Masukwane Siviya Moroka Mapoka Shashe-Bridge Location Masunga 2003/4 No./Km 2004/5 No./Km 2004/2005 49,000,000 2005/6 No./Km 2005/2006 0 2006/7 No./Km Total 79,000,000 2007/8 No./Km 2008/9 No./Km 2 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 Internal Roads Cross Over Slabs [Plots Access] Masunga Drifts Internal Vukwi Themashanga Letsholathebe Gravelling Mulambakwena Mosojane Mapoka Pole Gungwe Siviya Vukwi Letsholathebe Matsiloje Kalakamati Sekakangwe Mbalambi Matenge Masukwane Senyawe Mabudzane Ditladi Gulubane Makaleng Butale Jackalas 1 Jackalas 2 Kgari Masingwaneng Matsiloje Mambo Sechele Shashe-Bridge Matselagabedi Ramokgwebana 2003/204 30,000,000 10 10 10 1 2 2 1 2 5 8 5 3 6 8 6 5 4 5 5 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 196 LG 1112 – Municipal Services Project Component Mechanical Workshop Mini Fire Station Location 2003/04 Masunga 1 2004/05 Masunga 2005/06 2006/07 2007/08 2008/09 1 LG 1115 – District Roads The main aim of the project is to construct and maintain low traffic feeder and access roads in rural areas and as well construct remote area roads through labour intensive methods to ensure a reasonable degree of access to the dwellers of these areas at the lowest possible costs. The target for DDP6 is to gravel 339Km of access roads, 148km of internal roads, and bituminisation of 8km of gravel road, Construction of 2 culverts, 2 bridges, and 2 drifts. No/Km 2003/4 No/Km 2004/5 No/km 2005/6 No/km 2006/7 No/km 2007/8 No/km 2008/9 Labour Intensive Construction Ditladi-Patayamatebele – Matsiloje 10 X 17 x Ramokgwebana-Jakalas1 Themashanga-Mobile Stop 10 X 3 23 x 10 x x 8 x x Matshelagabedi-Sekokwe Gambule-Vukwi 20 8 x Gambule-Sekakangwe 1 x Tshesebe-Senyawe 1 x Culverts Mulambakwena-Gambule(Ntoba) Mulambakwena-Nlaphkwane 1 x 1 x Matsiloje-Matopi Mapoka-Kgari (Gugulamoseki) 1 x Nlaphkwane-Masukwane 1 x Siviya-Mabudzani Gavelling Monarch-Letsholathebe 29 x Mabudzani-Siviya 5 x Letsholathebe-Tshesebe 5 x 10 x Tshesebe-Senyawe 10 x Gambule-Sekakangwe 9 x Gambule-Mulambakwena 11 x Tonota- Ditladi 9 x 8 x Mabudzane-Tsamaya Mulambakwena-Nlaphkwane 10 x Mowana-Senyawe Masunga-Gumbule-Gungwe Matsiloje-Matopi 12 19 x 5 x x 197 No/Km 2003/4 No/Km 2004/5 No/km 2005/6 No/km 2006/7 No/km 2007/8 No/km 2008/9 Makaleng-Mambo 7 x 11 x Mosojane-Masukwane 7 x Masukwane-Kgari-Ramokgwebana 10 Masingwaneng-Mambo-Sechele-Letsholathebe 20 x Gulubane-Makaleng Matenge-Sebina Junction 6 13 x 10 x x Makaleng-Sechele Masingwaneng-Matenge Nlapkwane-Masukwane 4 x 5 x Kalakamati-Nzwazwi 5 x Kgari-Mapoka 5 x 5 x 9 x Mbalambi-Goshwe 6 x Mabudzani-F/Town Road Bisoli-Jack 2-Siviya-Senyawe-Butale 25 x Siviya-Tsamaya Tshesebe-Butale 20 x 5 x Internal Gravelling Tsamaya 7 x 7 x Tshesebe Moroka 7 Zwenshambe Nlapkwane 7 x Themashanga 4 x 3 x 8 x Bituminisation Letsholathebe-Masunga Bridges Ntshe At Moroka 1 x Ntshe At Kgari Machinery & Vehicles 1 x Pickup Vehicles 1 x 1 x 1 x Tipper Trucks 1 x 1 x 1 x Front-End Loader Grader 1 x 1 x Road Marker 1 x Water Bowser 15000 L 1 x 1 x 1 x Cube Crusher (Concrete Strength Testing) Smooth Roller Lowbed Truck 1 x 198 Tribal Administration Projects LG 901 – Customary Courts The project provides funding for construction of offices, purchase of requisite furniture, equipment, and transport for customary courts. Customary courts handle more than 80% of cases. However, there is still a shortage of customary offices in the District. Out of the planned 12 customary courts to be constructed, only 8 were constructed during DDP5. The target for DDP 6 is 11 customary courts in the following villages; sekakangwe, Ditladi, Shashe Bridge, Senywawe, Gulubane, Masingwaneng, Sechele, Butale, Letsholathebe, Kgari, and Masukwane. Project Location Type I Offices Sekakangwe Ditladi Shashe Bridge Senyawe Gulubane Masingwaneng Sechele Butale Letsholathebe Kgari Masukwane Mambo Electrification Matsiloje Makaleng Tsamaya Mosojane Mapoka Matshelagabedi Jackalas 1 Themashanga Kalakamati Jackalas II Mbalambi 2003/4 2004/5 2005/6 2006/7 2007/8 2008/9 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 199