Conference Committee Phone Conversation10/26/2011 3:01:00 PM Participants: Carol Eliel, LACMA, AAMC President Julian Cox, Fine Art Museums of San Francisco Daniel Finamore, Peabody Essex Museum Rita Freed, Museum of Fine Art, Boston Jack Hinton, Philadelphia Museum of Art Norman Kleeblatt, Jewish Museum Marina Pacini, Memphis Brooks Museum, co-chair David Rubin, San Antonio Museum of Art Jennifer Tonkovich, Morgan Library Sylvia Yount, Virginia Museum of Fine Arts, co-chair Unavailable: Cynthia Burlingham, Hammer Museum, AAMC VP, Programs Helen Molesworth, Institute for Contemporary Art, Boston 11th ANNUAL CONFERENCE - Boston May 13 – 15 2012 Still determining welcome location on Sunday 13 evening Possible member reception venues under consideration o Museum other than MFA, Gardner or ICA o Collectors home o Tavern Club Monday: MFA Boston Tuesday: Gardner & ICA Sally: need well rounded agenda that speaks to many people Keynote ideas: Comments: SY and MP—better to focus on sessions first, then back-into selection of keynote speaker Norman – keynote needs to present critical eye to field, less self serving Suggestions: Malcolm Rogers, MFA João Ribas A person from an “alternative” art space (Ask Helen Molesworth) Harvard thinkers OTHER TOPICS: Julian – think about 3 possibilities with the various institution hosts (given that they are so different), each Boston venue could frame a different discussion Rita – blend of old and new spaces In lieu of all of the new museum addition (ie. the MFA) how to make old spaces interesting with limited budgets: Gardner Museum Re-installation at Williams College New Museums of the 21st Century – (focus on non-contemporary) Alice Walton and Crystal Bridges Abu Dhabi and Arab Emirates museums Artists Estates (see tab section 2 for notes on this topic) Overly specialized topic What aspect is curatorial? Sylvia—possibly as break-out/simultaneous session? Expand to include curatorial perspective Curatorial Slam Sally – call for proposals from the membership have been successful but it is difficult to vet speaks, important to offer opportunity, slam would be experimental but stringent in format Carol- this would be too hard to manage Rita – need a very strong moderator, guidelines Julian – has a template to share that has been used in Atlanta initiative, a slam would help with networking Norman – need a focus to get good result, “thinking outside of box” is a better way to frame the talks Jack – call for papers – top 10? Dan – good opp. For a more dynamic conversational feel Sylvia—organize by topic, i.e., exhibitions or acquisitions Crisis and Disaster David – museums have no preparation for crisis, could be an opportunity to share stories, NOMA, Phoenix Administrative side of Curatorial work Blending of responsibilities o Julian--Project management o Delegating o Sylvia--Time management Technology Integration into galleries, how do you develop with limited funds High level of interest from audience Choose specific aspect Shifting collection boundaries Sylvia--Divisions between curatorial departments are shifting (eg., American, Mod/Con, 21stc, Photography, Sculpture/Dec Arts); how do we define gallery and acquisition parameters (MFA Art of Americas Wing one model)? Is fluidity vs. demarcation a virtue? Sally – would be a very important topic, want best speakers, draw a diverse grouping, need to include a small museum here Dan – want success stories Past Meeting Notes & Member Ideas 10/26/2011 3:01:00 PM AAMC Program Committee Meeting New York Conference, May 17, 2011 in attendance: Marina Pacini, Memphis Brooks Museum of Art Jordana Pomeroy, National Museum of Women in the Arts Jennifer Tonkovich, Morgan Library & Museum Jason Busch, Carnegie Museum of Art Lori J. Durante, Museum of Lifestyles & Fashion History Jon Stuhlman, Mint Museum David Rubin, San Antonio Museum of Art Rita Freed, MFA Boston Katharine Lochnan, Art Gallery of Ontario Catherine Whitney, Philbrook Museum of Art Dan Finamore, Peabody Essex Museum Preamble: It is noteworthy that all the curators who attended the program committee meeting work at small to mid-size museums. There was a general consensus that the AAMC conference panels (as well as publication/exhibition awards) have been weighted toward large museums— or museums with sizeable budgets. A greater balance has to be felt in AAMC programming among museums with varying budgets and resources. General thoughts: --including educators on some of the panels --consideration of game theory [jp notes: I have seen a presentation of this at AAM and was completely unimpressed! It’s very trendy but not convincing] --alternate publications panel with technology panel; do we need to do publications every year? --panels need to be more nuts and bolts that focus on how project done and what the results were (good and bad), responding to funders demand for outcomes. --more smaller sessions/break out sessions that allow for cross-disciplinary discussion, the conservation groups got high praise as a model. --during awards ceremony, present PowerPoint of cover of book/article, or installation shots to make the awards more visually interesting. --the panels should all fulfill the mission statement: how will this impact the curator? Possible topics: Engaging the community: --how to use new technologies while encouraging engagement with object --supporting experience of seeing vs. looking --visitor surveys and focus groups --are museums competing with Disney World? integrating art with contemporary pop culture to make it more relevant to non-traditional museum visitors. --how do you take a serious exhibition and make it popular? --how to enlist the local arts community, gain confidence of artists New/Other Roles for Curators: --curators being proactive in other areas such as audience development, marketing, education etc. --visitor surveys and focus groups Technology panel: --does it support or detract from viewer experience? --what’s new? --Milwaukee Art Museum: American Furniture / googled, http://www.mam.org/exhibitions/details/americanFurniture.php --funding costs and level of impact, what is possible and what is effective Preparing for disasters: --natural disasters --controversies “All Art Was Once Contemporary”: --ways to address contemporary connection to art of the past --Aphrodite exhibition in fall with x rated materials Censorship vs. Self Censorship: Canned Exhibitions / Exhibitions for Profit: --do we work with them? --what if your museum wants to do one? --bring in one of the organizers of these kinds of shows. Publications panel: --is there scholarship without a publication? How Do You Save the Integrity of Project if Your Budget is Cut? Case Studies of Successful Downsizing of Museum Exhibitions: Strength in Numbers: Successful Collaborating with Other Institutions: New Member-generated ideas: CURATORIAL “SLAM” Members are given 5-7 minutes to present an exhibition, acquisition or new curatorial project that they are working on. No discussion. Strict adherence to the time. Allows curators to get a quick look at what is going on around the country. ARTIST ESTATE TOPIC (from new independent curator member Davira Taragin) As you may know, over the past year and a half I have served as curatorial consultant to the Dennis Gallagher Estate after serving as curator at the Detroit Institute of Arts and the Toledo Museum of Art and director of exhibitions at the Racine Art Museum. My current work on this estate as well as past work with the Artists' Legacy Foundation which handles the estate of Viola Frey has made me aware of the paucity of information available to assist with decision-making about the various approaches to artists' estates. The panel could address the practical issues facing artists' estates and foundations and answer basic questions such as: --Which format is the most appropriate for the artist, an estate of a foundation? --What do those administering the estate or foundation do to regularly maintain a balance between building the artist's legacy in the marketplace and maintaining his reputation in the museum world? In fact, is such a balance continually necessary? -- What should be the five-, ten-, fifteen-year, and longterm goals of the estate? the foundation? My colleague at the Gallagher Estate, Patricia "Trish" Bransten, the artist's widow, has started to develop a list of the best individuals to contact to constitute the panel. At this point we envision a panel consisting of an economist who could discuss the short and long term requirements of an artist's estate which is, by nature, a limited resource; a representative from a leading auction house; a lawyer knowledgeable in the pros and cons of establishing a foundation vs. an estate, and advisors/board members representing one artist's estate as well as one foundation. At this time, Patterson Sims who is a board member of the Joan Mitchell Foundation and former member of the Artists' Legacy Foundation has expressed interest in serving on the panel. We have identified three economists involved in the art market, all of whom would be well-equipped to address these issues. Finally, Christie's has agreed to have a member of its staff serve as a panelist and provide financial assistance to the endeavor where appropriate. I possibly could serve as moderator. I hope that the AAMC might seriously consider hosting this project. I also have just written to Andrew Perchuck, Deputy Director of the Getty Research Institute, to see if his institution would be interested in such a program since another audience that we believe critical to this discussion is, of course, the artist community. ART HANDLING (from Nadine Orenstein at the Met) As I said when I gave my comments at the recent AAMC open session, there seems to be an idea circulating among registrars (and as a result among other museum staff) that curators do not know how to handle art. A Print Council colleague recently spoke with a friend of hers at a major museum where the curators have to go through the registrar to access their collection and that registrar made the following preposterous and frightening remarks which I think reflects the thinking of many registrars: “She said that the curators really didn't want to go searching for the prints and then have to put them back. And anyway, a curator can't be trusted to put the prints away correctly or in the correct place. She also said that curators don't know how to handle art and that we like to be served. She likes to have control over where the works go and when they are put away.” It occurred to me that to get on top of this issue and to follow in the AAMC path of professional development, it might be useful to have some classes on handling art at the next AAMC meeting or at a regional meeting. Member Suggested Topics Held over from 2011: Keynote Ideas: Curators Rita Freed, MFA (ancient art) Malcolm Warner, Kimbell Sheila Canby – MMA Islamic Dept Denise Allen –Frick Mike Hearn, MMA, Chinese Thom Kren, Getty, Manuscripts and new Assoc. Director Jen Mergel, MFA (contemporary) Maria Lind –http://www.e-flux.com/shows/view/6285 Lori Waxman –http://60wrdmin.org/news.html Paul Chaat Smith – http://www.paulchaatsmith.com/ Journalists Jerry Saltz Nina Simon, author, The Participatory Museum. http://museumtwo.tumblr.com/ Ariana Huffington Anthony Huberman Directors Ann Pasternak Dealers Sam Fogg Jay Jopling (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jay_Jopling) David Zwirner (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Zwirner_Gallery) Karston Shubert (http://www.wordiq.com/definition/Karsten_Schubert) Others Rita Ahoun-Abdo http://www.symposiumgreatexpectations.com/speakersaoun-abdo.html Lawrence Weschler (http://nyih.as.nyu.edu/object/LawrenceWeschler.html) Laurence des Cars (http://www.archimuse.com/ichim2001/bios/au_155012603.html) Jeffery Hamburger (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeffrey_F._Hamburger) Richard Sandell, head of the museum studies program at the University or Leicester (http://www.le.ac.uk/ms/contactus/richardsandell.html) Selma Holo, Director of the USC International Museum Institute for Advanced Studies and Practice: (http://www.usc.edu/about/people/holo.html) Edward Sullivan (http://as.nyu.edu/object/EdwardSullivan.html) Panel Ideas: Crisis Management natural disaster and national controversy Potential Speakers and/or Moderators: Valerie Leeds Jackie Sullivan (NOLA response to natural disasters) Norton Museum to speak to natural disaster Jim Ballinger – Phoenix Art Museum – Old Glory controversy Exhibition planning process how museums choose what they choose, is it fundable? What are your contingency plans? How to trim the shows budgets ,dealing with loan negotiations & fees, staffing Disenfranchisement of curators who now may be managed by other departments (conservators, etc.) The perception that the curator is “the other” or “difficult to understand” How do we begin to build bridges and reduce feeling of alienation? How do we work together? Add conservators to this discussion Investing in new territories for GLOBAL museum interaction. How do you engage in curatorial collaborations that may not be exhibition driven? How do you help people in other countries who need training (and also helps you in loan negotiations). SPECIFIC IDEAS: MoMA example of penetrating different cultures. Fluxes in Central Europe and Japan. A session on exchanges between art, peers, helping people, etc. An Open Call to AAMC members might work the best for this. Also the Terra Foundation. A panel on Independent Curators. How they work? Get a good crosssection of new members. How many people are independent by choice? How do independents support themselves? You might want to see if Mark Rosenthal would be willing to talk since he's gone back and forth in those worlds. You could also think about incorporating an artist who has served as a curator. Jeff Koons? Panel of retired directors/curators Skills-based workshops or sessions Negotiating loans – targeting younger curators who might be interested in this topic Especially in hard-to-reach areas (Russia, etc.). How do curators help one another in this process? Turn the “Reinvigorating the Permanent Collection” into a more brainstorming/skills-based session. Create break-out sessions. Past Keynote Speakers (solo): Philippe de Montebello (2001) Maxwell Anderson (2003) Michael Kimmelman (2004) Axel Rüger (2007) Michael Brand (2008) Kathy Halbreich (2009) David C. Hilliard (2010) Past Keynote Panelists: James Cuno Anne d’Harnoncourt (2002) Glenn Lowery (2002) Philippe de Montebello (2002) John Walsh (2002) James N. Wood (2002) Agnes Gund (2002 & 2005) Susan Paine (2005) Leonard Lauder (2005) Elizabeth Sackler (2005) Neil Rudenstine (2005) Michael Horvitz (2005) George Shackelford (2006) Lowery Sims (2006) Cindi Strauss (2006) Paola Antonelli (2011) Anthony Appiah (2011) Linda Shearer (2011) Past Panel Topics (by year): Curators Roundtable (2002) The Role of the Curator in Museums Today (2002) Cultural Heritage in Iraq (2003) Animating the Permanent Collection (2003) The Curator and Scholarship (2004) The Curator and the Architect (2004) Trustees and the Curator (2005) The Curator and Society (2005) The Curator and the Audience (2005) The State of the Curator (2006) Met Museum Curatorial Forum: Lessons Learned (2006) The Junior Curator (2006) Deaccessioning: The Philosophical Issues (2006) Training the Next Generation (2007) The Artist and the Curator (2007) Creating a Legacy (on Legacy Museums) (2007) Fundraising Collaborations: Lessons Learned (2007) Dynamic Duos: Teaming up with Education to Create Dynamic Exhibitions (2007) Views from Outside the Curatorial Profession (2008) Curatorial Longevity (2008) Conservation, Reconstruction and Question of Intent (2008) Whither the Collections Catalogue (2008) Curatorial Advocacy (2008) The University Art Museum Curator (2008) The Curator and the Art Market (2009) Collaborative Curating (2009) Exhibition Planning (2009) The Exhibition Catalogue (2009) Negotiation (facilitated by Columbia Business School faculty) (2009) Curatorial Practice and the Geopolitical Landscape (2010) International Dateline: A Primer for Partnerships (2010) Reinvigorating the Permanent Collection (2010) Museums and the Academy: Career Choices (2010) Career Transitions: What you should know (2010) The Future of Museum Publishing (2010) Looking forward 10 years: What is the museum of 2021? (2011) Innovative Conservation (2011) Cultural Property: Where are we now? (2011) Collaborative Curating (2011) Developing Donor Cultivation Confidence/Donor Support Groups (2011) Publishing in the Digital Age (2011) Clifford Ackley Maryan Ainsworth Selma Al-Radi Darsie Alexander Daniel Ames Jeff Anderson Lee Ann Daffner Michael Auping Colin Bailey Hilary Ballon Andrea Bayer Kathleen Berrin Kathleen Bickford Berzock Barbara Bloemink Graham Boettcher David Brenneman Richard Burger Cynthia Burlingham Teresa Carbone Stefano Carboni Bertha Cea Julien Chapuis Alan Chong Robin Clark John Coffey Arthur Cohen Philip Conisbee Sharon Cott Elizabeth Cropper Malcolm Daniel Lisa Dennison Leah Dickerman Douglas Druick Elizabeth Easton John Elderfield Carol Eliel Adrian Ellis Margaret Ellis Geoff Emberling Helen Evans Charlotte Eyerman Kathleen Foster Kate Fowle Rita Freed Peter Galassi Dan Giles Christine Giviskos Richard Gluckman Thelma Golden Michael Govan Alison Greene Vivien Greene Gloria Groom Rui Guerra Stephen H. Goddard Lynda Hartigan Maxwell Hearn Nik Honeysett Wu Hung Chiyo Ishikawa Colta Ives Joseph Jacobs Sarah James Paul Johnson Barbara Jones Sarah Kianovsky Kara Kirk Norman Kleeblatt Christopher Knight Kinda Komaroff Christine Kondoleon Dorothy Kosinski Gloria Kury Shelley Langdale Patrice Marandel Max Marmor Ed Marquand Edgar Marx Andrew McClellan Jenny McComas James McKean Judy Metro Lisa MIddag Charles Moffett Mary Morton Linda Muehlig Alexandra Munroe Larry Nichols Robin Nicholson Phil Nowlen Jeannine O’Grody Kim Orcutt Saul Ostrow James Peck Marilyn Perry Joanna Phillips Lari Pittman Larry Price Andriana Proser Emily Pulitzer Richard Rand David Rau John Ravenal Carrie Rebora Barratt Terence Riley Joe Rishel Malcolm Rogers Angelica Rudenstine William Rudolph Jennifer Russell Lynne Rutkin Pauline Saliga Laurent Salomé Tom Savage Mark Scala Scott Schaefer Paul Schimmel Sarah Scroth Franklin Sirmans Joaneath Spicer Ron Spronk Jill Sterrett Robert Storr Donna Sutton Ann Temkin Gary Tinterow Nancy Troy Georgiana Uhlyarik Kristina Van Dyke Karin Victoria Kara Walker Malcolm Warner Joan Weinstein Mariet Westermann Ray Williams Kim Kanatani Sylvia Wolf Joan Young Margaret YoungSanchez Lynn Zelevansky 10/26/2011 3:01:00 PM Past CAA Topics or non-AAMC conference topics: Managing Change (St. Louis, 2008) Museum Expansion (St. Louis, 2008) Curricular Connection: The College Art Museum As Site for Teaching and Learning (2006) The Curator of the 21st Century (2006) Curators' War IV: The Return to the Object (2007) What makes a Collector a Philanthropist: Lessons Learned from the Miracle in Dallas (2008) The Gallery and the Classroom (2008) Historicizing the Present: Scholarship in Contemporary Art (2009) Contemporary Art in the Global Age: Challenges for the Curator (2009) Expanding Museums: Spaces and Choices (2010) The Museum as Career: Identifying New Talent and Broadening the Field (2011) Inspiration and Opportunity: Art History Reflects on its Past to Determine its Future (2011) Mapping Cultural Authority: Revisionism, Provincialism, Marginalization (will be 2012)