SCIENTIFIC DISCUSSION Duramune DAPPi I. Zoetis UK Limited INTRODUCTION Duramune DAPPi is a live vaccine for the protection of dogs from diseases caused by: canine distemper virus (CDV) – which causes canine distemper, a serious, sometimes fatal disease that mostly affects young dogs; it causes a wide range of clinical signs including fever, diarrhoea, dullness, loss of appetite, discharge from the eyes and nose, hardening of the paw pads and neurological signs such as twitching, unco-ordination and fits; canine adenovirus (CAV) – which may cause infectious canine hepatitis (CAV type 1), another potentially fatal disease; and kennel cough, a less serious, but distressing and debilitating disease (CAV types1 and 2); canine parvovirus (CPV) - which can cause a serious and possibly fatal gastro-enteritis in dogs, with vomiting, diarrhoea, a marked reduction in numbers of white blood cells and sometimes fever; canine parainfluenza virus (CPi) – which is another cause of kennel cough. There is no cure for any of these diseases and vaccination is therefore necessary. A vaccine that is effective against several diseases is clearly advantageous as it reduces the number of injections needed to provide adequate protection. Duramune DAPPi contains antigens from attenuated* forms of the four viruses: CDV (strain Onderstepoort), CAV type 2 (strain V197), CPV (strain SAH) and CPi (strain FDL). It is supplied in single dose vials of freeze dried viral fraction, and single dose vials of diluent. The vaccine is intended for subcutaneous injection in dogs from 6 weeks old onwards. It is designed to produce active immunisation to prevent mortality and disease caused by CDV and CPV; to prevent mortality and reduce clinical signs due to CAV-1, to reduce clinical signs and infection caused by CAV-2, and to reduce clinical signs and shedding caused by infection with CPi. The initial vaccination programme consists of 2 doses of vaccine with an interval of 2 - 4 weeks. In puppies first vaccinated between 6 and 8 weeks, the second vaccination should be given after the puppy has reached 10 weeks old. Booster vaccination is recommended at intervals of between one and three years. II. QUALITY ASPECTS Product Development and Composition Duramune DAPPi has been developed as one of a “family” of vaccines which contain different numbers of antigens to protect dogs from a range of common diseases. Duramune DAPPi contains antigens from four different viruses, as indicated below. Others members of the family may contain more or fewer antigens and this ensures that animals can be given the most appropriate vaccine for the diseases they are likely to be exposed to. * An attenuated virus is one that has been treated so that it no longer causes disease (i.e. it is not virulent), but it can still stimulate immunity. Page 1 of 11 Date created: 02/03/2006 SCIENTIFIC DISCUSSION Duramune DAPPi Zoetis UK Limited Duramune DAPPi has two main components: 1. Freeze dried component: Active ingredients: Canine Distemper virus, strain Onderstepoort Canine Adenovirus type 2, strain V197 Canine Parainfluenza virus, Strain FDL Canine Parvovirus, strain SAH Other ingredients: Sucrose Gelatin Bactopeptone Potassium phosphate dibasic Potassium phosphate monobasic Potassium hydroxide Eagle’s Earle’s medium with HEPES May contain HCl or NaOH for pH correction. 2. Sterile Solvent: Sterilised Water for injections Active Ingredients The production and, where appropriate, purification of the antigens has been described by the applicant. The information provided included a detailed description of the manufacturing process. Each of the four viruses is grown in separate cell monolayers using standard techniques for the preparation of the cells and the production of the viruses. When the viruses have grown to the required extent, as evidenced by changes in the cells, they are collected and stored frozen ready for later use. Quality control of these antigens has been described, with testing in accordance with the relevant guidelines. Data provided show freedom from relevant extraneous agents (i.e. unwanted viruses, bacteria, etc). Other Ingredients Certificates of Analysis were provided where appropriate, and reference made to the appropriate pharmacopoeia. Packaging Materials The freeze-dried component and the diluent are each presented in 3 ml glass vials. The containers and stoppers are sterile, made of standard materials and comply with the European Pharmacopoeia where necessary. Page 2 of 11 Date created: 02/03/2006 SCIENTIFIC DISCUSSION Duramune DAPPi Zoetis UK Limited Manufacture of the Product All production steps are performed according to GMP*. equipment and materials are sterile. Where applicable, conditions, The required amounts of the antigens are prepared for production, appropriate quantities determined, and the blending diluent quantity calculated. The final product is then prepared under sterile conditions. The product may be produced in different batch sizes depending on the amount needed at the time. Final production steps are the filling of 3 ml vials with a target volume of 1.2 ml, freezedrying, and capping, followed by quality control. Validation data were provided for multiple batches of viruses, as was information to show that production variables did not adversely affect these viruses. Data were also provided on the stability of the viral antigen stock. The live virus assay was validated, and showed that a satisfactory batch could be distinguished from a minimum or sub-potent batch, as well as a concentrated vaccine, thus satisfying consistency requirements. The assays were repeatable, accurate, precise and showed a log-linear relationship between the quantity of virus present and potency. The assays described were therefore considered satisfactory for potency determination of batches. Validation data were also provided for sterilisation processes. The validation data were considered satisfactory, and demonstrated efficiency and consistency of manufacture. In-process control tests were described in detail, and included tests for sterility, mycoplasma and viral content and identity, and absence of contaminating viruses. The components of the product were demonstrated to comply with relevant guidance on minimising the risk of transmitting animal spongiform encephalopathy agents via veterinary medicines. Finished Product Control Standard tests (visual tests, pH, sterility, extraneous agents, etc) are applied to the finished product. Each viral component is identified by fluorescent antibody, and quantified, under virus-specific conditions, to confirm the amount of virus is within the range required. Batch safety tests are carried out in the target species. The specifications for all tests are appropriate to control the quality of the product. Results of the analysis of consecutive production runs of finished vaccine were presented, and show consistency of production. Stability Stability of bulk antigen Satisfactory stability data for storage of the bulk antigen were provided. Stability of finished product * GMP = Good Manufacturing Practice Page 3 of 11 Date created: 02/03/2006 SCIENTIFIC DISCUSSION Duramune DAPPi Zoetis UK Limited Stability data for several batches of the finished product were provided. Based on this information a shelf life of 24 months was approved for the freeze-dried fraction, and 12 months for the diluent. Stability of the reconstituted product The reconstituted product is intended to be used immediately on reconstitution, so information on the stability of the reconstituted product is not relevant. CONCLUSIONS ON QUALITY The analytical part of the dossier included satisfactory descriptions of the production and quality control procedures, including appropriate diagrams. The method of manufacture was well described, and the in-process controls detailed in full. Starting materials of animal origin were shown to be compliant with legislative requirements. The finished product tests, including the potency test and batch safety test, ensure an efficacious, safe and consistent product. The stability data provided shows that shelf lives of 24 months for the freeze-dried fraction and 12 months for the diluent are justified when stored at 2 – 8° C, protected from light. III. SAFETY ASPECTS Introduction The vaccine is intended for dogs from the age of six weeks, and a primary course consists of two vaccinations, 2 - 4 weeks apart, the second of which must occur after the pup is 10 weeks old. Booster vaccination is recommended at intervals of between one and three years. The vaccine is administered subcutaneously in a volume of 1 ml. Details of the batches of Duramune DAPPi used in the laboratory safety trials were provided. The antigen component was the same as the antigen component of the final authorised product. The diluent used in the studies contained three additional inactivated antigens, rather than just water. This is considered acceptable, as any safety issues would be worse in the presence of additional antigens. Maximum potency batches of product were used in the studies so that safety of the product could be demonstrated at high potency. Details of the batches used in the field safety trials were also provided. The batches were essentially identical to the final licensed product, although again the more complex diluent was used. Batches of mid - low potency were used, as is usual for such trials. No studies were performed to investigate safety of the product for pregnant or lactating animals and the product is therefore not recommended for use in pregnant and lactating animals. Page 4 of 11 Date created: 02/03/2006 SCIENTIFIC DISCUSSION Duramune DAPPi Zoetis UK Limited Laboratory Tests Laboratory safety studies were carried out in accordance with GLP*, as is required. The applicant carried out a combined study into the potential side effects of a single dose, a single overdose (10 times the normal dose) and a repeated dose of the vaccine (3 doses at two-week intervals). The animals had no antibodies to the antigens of interest at the beginning of the study. Safety was assessed clinically, over an appropriate time course, through observation, physical examination, and body temperature determinations. The adverse effects seen following administration of an overdose and repeated single doses in healthy animals of the minimum age for which the vaccine is recommended were minor, transient and resolved within an acceptable time frame. Details are given in the SPC: Following the first vaccination, up to 80% of puppies develop a small visible swelling (<2 cm) lasting for generally only two days. Following the second vaccination, occasionally a small visible swelling (up to 5 cm) may be seen at the injection site, which may last for up to five days. The swelling may be painful for 1 to 2 days. In most cases these small and transient injection site reactions resolve with no need for treatment. Overdose: Some puppies may exhibit a transient lethargy by 4 hours post vaccination but recover by two days post vaccination. Occasionally a small visible swelling (<2 cm) may be seen at the injection site, which may last for up to 17 days. Special Requirements for Live Vaccines Further compulsory tests were carried out on each of the four viruses in the vaccine, to determine the potential for spread and dissemination of the vaccine constituents, and any tendency to revert to virulence*. The studies were designed to demonstrate compliance with the relevant European Pharmacopoeial monographs. To investigate the properties of CDV, young dogs which had no antibodies to CDV were inoculated with a suitable amount of the CDV strain used in Duramune DAPPi. No CDV could be found in nasal swabs or in samples of various tissues collected from these dogs although, as expected, the dogs did show an antibody response to the virus. Untreated dogs that were in contact with the treated ones did not have an antibody response to CDV and this showed that the virus had not spread to these animals. None of the animals showed any signs of disease. Similar studies were done using the CAV-2 strain that is used in Duramune DAPPi, but in this case, virus was found in nasal swabs and tissue samples from treated dogs. The virus was extracted from these samples and administered to other young dogs. This process was repeated five more times and at each stage, animals were checked for signs of disease that could have been caused by CAV-2 if it had reverted to virulence, for example, raised temperature, discharge from the eyes or nose, sneezing, coughing or retching. No such * * Good Laboratory Practice If a virus reverts to virulence, it regains the ability to cause disease. Page 5 of 11 Date created: 02/03/2006 SCIENTIFIC DISCUSSION Duramune DAPPi Zoetis UK Limited signs were observed, showing that the virus had not reverted to virulence. All the treated dogs developed antibodies to CAV-2. Untreated dogs that were in contact with the treated ones also had an antibody response to CAV-2 and this showed that the virus had spread to these animals, although none of them had any signs of disease. In the case of CPV, a similar experiment was also done. In this case, CPV was found in samples of faeces collected from the treated animals. The virus found in the faeces was extracted and administered to other young dogs. This process was repeated four times and at each stage, animals were checked for signs of CPV-related disease, such as a reduction in the number of white blood cells and effects on the intestine. All dogs developed antibodies to CPV but there were no signs of disease. Two additional studies were specifically aimed at investigating possible effects of CPV on the thymus as this gland may be targeted by CPV. No evidence of damage was found. To complete the additional information required for live vaccines, CPi was tested in a similar way, with virus being extracted from nasal swabs from the treated animals. This virus was then administered to more dogs as in the other studies and the process was repeated five more times. All the dogs (i.e. treated and untreated ones) developed antibodies to CPi, showing that the virus had spread. However, there were no signs of disease in any animal, showing that the virus had not reverted to virulence. To summarise the results of these studies, none of the viruses showed any reversion to virulence. Specific adverse biological effects of the viruses present in Duramune DAPPi for example adverse effects on the nervous system (CDV) and enteritis or thymic atrophy* (CPV), were not observed in any of the studies. The studies also demonstrated that dissemination within the vaccinated animal was negligible and that CDV does not spread to animals which are in contact with the vaccinated animals. Although the other viruses did spread to in-contact animals, animals are not at risk of disease from this spread because the viruses do not revert to virulence. The SPC reflects this situation: The live vaccine strains may spread to unvaccinated animals, but do not cause disease. Field studies Two field studies were conducted using vaccine that had been manufactured and tested in accordance with the dossier. These studies were appropriately controlled and fully documented. They investigated both the safety and the efficacy of the vaccine. Dogs of a variety of breeds, aged 6 - 8 weeks old, were examined before entry into the trial. They were then randomly assigned to one of two groups. One group received the vaccine while the other group received either a vaccine that was already approved or a placebo (sterile saline), depending on the trial. The first dose of vaccine was given at 7 - 8 weeks of age and a second 4 weeks later. The safety of the vaccine in these young dogs was determined through observation and the measurement of body temperatures. No animal showed any fever. Reactions at the injection site were observed, with a maximum dimension of 5 cm. Pain (lasting less than 24 hours) was detected in ⅓ of the vaccinated animals after the first injection, and in ½ after the second injection. These results were similar to the results of the laboratory studies. * Thymic atrophy means that the size of thymus gland (which is an important part of the immune system) is reduced. Page 6 of 11 Date created: 02/03/2006 SCIENTIFIC DISCUSSION Duramune DAPPi Zoetis UK Limited Environmental Safety The applicant provided a phase 1 environmental risk assessment in compliance with the relevant guideline. Ecotoxicity was adequately addressed, and the risk to the environment is considered negligible. Therefore no further assessment is required. Warnings and precautions are listed in the SPC, and are adequate to ensure safety to the environment when the product is used as directed. Dispose of waste by boiling, incineration or immersion in an appropriate disinfectant approved for use by the competent authorities. CONCLUSIONS ON THE SAFETY ASPECTS The safety part of the dossier fulfils the legislative requirements, and provides adequate information to assess the safety of the product. The vaccine often produces local reactions in dogs when used, and these are explained in the SPC. The safety of the product, including biological properties, excretion, spread and reversion to virulence has been demonstrated by the laboratory studies carried out. The vaccine was shown to be safe when used in a variety of dog breeds in a normal “field” situation. The vaccine contains no ingredients that represent a significant hazard to people administering the product. Since the product is for use in dogs only, there are no concerns regarding consumer safety.* In summary, this product has been shown to be safe when used according to the directions for use, and the SPC adequately reflects the likelihood and severity of any reaction that may be seen. IV. EFFICACY ASPECTS Introduction The vaccine is intended for dogs from the age of 6 weeks. A primary course consists of two vaccinations, 2 - 4 weeks apart, with the second being given when the animal is at least 10 weeks old. Booster vaccination is recommended at intervals of between one and three years. The vaccine is administered subcutaneously in a volume of 1 ml. Information on the composition of batches used in the laboratory efficacy trials was provided. In cases where the composition differed from that of the authorised product, data were provided to show that the studies were relevant to Duramune DAPPi. * Consumer safety relates to consumers of food derived from treated animals, and is thus only applicable to food-producing animals such as cattle, sheep, fish and poultry. Page 7 of 11 Date created: 02/03/2006 SCIENTIFIC DISCUSSION Duramune DAPPi Zoetis UK Limited Information on the composition of batches used in the field efficacy trials was also provided. The batches were essentially identical to the final licensed product. Batches were generally produced in order to be at minimum or low potency in order to investigate if the product is efficacious even at low potency levels. Laboratory trials Laboratory trials were carried out to show short-term efficacy of two doses, duration of immunity, efficacy of a single booster, and effect of maternal antibody on efficacy for each of the viral components. Also, as supporting data, the applicant provided information on the efficacy of a single dose of CDV and of CAV. Canine Distemper Virus Young dogs which had no antibodies to CDV were inoculated with complete vaccine on two occasions, with an interval of 3 weeks. Three weeks after the second vaccination, the animals were exposed to virulent CDV. Blood samples from the vaccinated animals showed a strong antibody response to the first vaccination, and antibodies reached protective levels two weeks after the second vaccination. Vaccinated animals were generally protected against fever, and showed virtually no clinical signs following exposure to virulent CDV. The CDV component of the vaccine was shown to be in compliance with the European Pharmacopoeia monograph. In two further studies, animals vaccinated twice at 3-week intervals were exposed to virulent CDV after one or three years. It was shown that antibody levels remained elevated for at least a year after the course of vaccination and when the animals were exposed to virulent CDV, there was a strong “memory response”, with protective levels of antibodies being attained quickly. Animals exposed to virulent CDV one year after vaccination showed no signs of disease and animals exposed three years after vaccination showed either minimal or no signs of disease. These data therefore demonstrated a 3-year duration of immunity. The company also provided data demonstrating protection from virulent CDV three weeks after the administration of a single injection of the complex vaccine. These data, combined with the results of a study in which antibody levels were measured following a single booster dose given one year after the initial two-dose course of vaccination, indicate that a single booster dose will be sufficient to provide protection. Studies were conducted to investigate whether the vaccine was efficacious in dogs with maternal antibodies to CDV. When two doses of vaccine were given, 2 - 4 weeks apart, to animals with low or moderate levels of maternal antibodies to CDV, the vaccine did provide protection against CDV, although the protection was not as effective as when the vaccine was given to animals with no maternal antibodies. It was therefore concluded that the presence of maternal antibody could affect the performance of the vaccine. The SPC contains a warning of the potential for interference from maternal antibody and a statement on the efficacy of the product in the face of low to moderate levels of maternal antibody. Page 8 of 11 Date created: 02/03/2006 SCIENTIFIC DISCUSSION Duramune DAPPi Zoetis UK Limited Canine Adenovirus Young dogs which did not have antibodies to CAV were inoculated with complete vaccine on two occasions, with an interval of 3 weeks. Three weeks after the second vaccination, one group of animals was exposed to virulent CAV-1 by intravenous injection to check for protection against hepatitis and another group of animals was exposed to virulent CAV-2 via an aerosol to check for protection against respiratory infection. Vaccinated animals showed a strong antibody response to the vaccine, with protective levels occurring two weeks after the second inoculation, and antibody levels remained high until the animals were exposed to virulent CAV-1 or CAV-2. In addition, the vaccinated animals exposed to virulent CAV-1 showed virtually no signs of hepatitis. In animals exposed to CAV-2, virus was detected less frequently in nasal swabs from vaccinated animals than in nasal swabs from unvaccinated animals. The results also demonstrated that the clinical signs of CAV-2 respiratory infection were significantly reduced following vaccination. The CAV component of the vaccine complies with the requirements of the European Pharmacopoeia monograph. In two further studies, vaccinated animals were exposed to virulent CAV-1 or CAV-2 one year after the initial course of vaccination. These studies demonstrated that the protection against both CAV-1 and CAV-2 which was seen in the earlier studies lasted for at least a year after the initial course of vaccination. In another study, animals were observed over a 3-year period and protective levels of antibodies to both CAV-1 and CAV-2 were found in vaccinated animals throughout the study, demonstrating that protection lasts for three years. This conclusion was supported by data showing that vaccinated animals exposed to virulent CAV-1 three years after vaccination had only minimal signs of disease. Additional data showed that protection from CAV-1 occurred three weeks after the administration of only one vaccination with the complex vaccine, and this indicates that a single booster dose will be sufficient to provide protection. As in the case of CDV, these data were supplemented by a study in which antibody levels were measured following a single booster given one year after the initial course of vaccination. In experiments to address efficacy in the presence of maternal immunity, when two doses of vaccine were given, 4 weeks apart, to animals with moderate levels of maternal antibodies to CAV-1, the vaccine provided some protection against exposure to virulent CAV-1. The antibody response and degree of protection was less than it was when the vaccine was given to animals without maternal antibodies. It was therefore concluded that the presence of maternal antibody could affect the performance of the vaccine. The SPC contains a warning of the potential for interference from maternal antibody and a statement on the efficacy of the product in the face of low to moderate levels of maternal antibody. Canine Parvovirus Young dogs which had no antibodies to CPV were inoculated with complete vaccine on two occasions, with an interval of 3 weeks. Three weeks after the second vaccination, the animals were exposed to virulent strains of CPV. Blood samples from vaccinated animals showed a strong antibody response to the CPV components of the vaccine from two weeks after the second vaccination. Vaccinated animals were protected against fever and leucopenia*, showed virtually no signs of disease and only one excreted virus following exposure to the virulent virus. The vaccine was shown to protect against virulent CPV. * Leucopenia is a reduction in the number of white blood cells. Page 9 of 11 Date created: 02/03/2006 SCIENTIFIC DISCUSSION Duramune DAPPi Zoetis UK Limited In another study, animals vaccinated twice at 3-week intervals, were exposed to virulent CPV after one year. This study demonstrated that immunity continued for at least one year after the initial vaccination programme. A similar study in which vaccinated animals were exposed to virulent CPV three years later showed that antibody levels remained high throughout the study and vaccinated animals had few signs of disease when exposed to virulent CPV. Further data were submitted that showed that, when given on one occasion, the vaccine protected animals from oral and intranasal exposure to virulent CPV at 3 weeks after vaccination. Blood samples from vaccinated animals showed a strong antibody response to CPV, and antibody levels remained high until the animals were exposed to virulent CPV. Vaccinated animals were relatively protected against CPV infection. This indicates that the CPV component of the vaccine is efficacious and indicates that a single booster dose will be sufficient. Full compliance of CPV with the European Pharmacopoeia monograph was shown in this study. The company also provided data from a study in which antibody levels were measured following a single booster one year after the initial course of vaccination, and these data supported the conclusion that a single booster dose is appropriate. When two doses of vaccine were given, 2 - 4 weeks apart, to animals with low or moderate levels of maternal antibodies to CPV, the vaccine could provide protection against CPV. The protection was not as effective as when the vaccine was given to animals without maternal antibodies. It was therefore concluded that the presence of maternal antibody could affect the performance of the vaccine. The SPC contains a warning of the potential for interference from maternal antibody and a statement on the efficacy of the product in the face of low to moderate levels of maternal antibody. Canine Parainfluenza Virus Young dogs which had no antibodies to CPi were inoculated with complete vaccine on two occasions, with an interval of 3 weeks. Three weeks later the animals were exposed to a virulent CPi. Blood samples from vaccinated animals showed little or no antibody response to the first vaccination, followed by a weak response to the second vaccination; no antibodies could be detected in the blood of unvaccinated dogs. Although the initial antibody response was weak, vaccinated animals showed a strong antibody response when exposed to virulent CPi. Signs of disease were not significantly different between vaccinated and unvaccinated controls. Excretion of virus occurred more often in unvaccinated animals than in vaccinated ones. On the basis of this finding, it can be concluded that the vaccine has a beneficial effect against CPi. The CPi component of the vaccine complies with the requirements of the European Pharmacopoeia monograph. Exposure to virulent CPi was also carried out one year after vaccination, on a further group of animals. Antibody levels had dropped by one year, although a strong “memory” response was seen at challenge. Initial studies indicated that it was not possible to demonstrate the efficacy of these antibodies because unvaccinated dogs showed few signs of illness when exposed to virulent CPi. Recently further data have been provided which demonstrate d that immunity continued for at least one year after the initial vaccination programme. As was the case with the other viruses, data were submitted for dogs given the final vaccine on two occasions 3 weeks apart, followed by a single booster a year later. Antibody responses obtained at 7 and 14 days after the booster were higher than those after the second vaccination. The vaccine was therefore shown to be efficacious for a year after a single booster dose given 12 months after the initial vaccination. Page 10 of 11 Date created: 02/03/2006 SCIENTIFIC DISCUSSION Duramune DAPPi Zoetis UK Limited As can be seen from these experiments, infection with CPi is not characterised by a significant antibody response, so maternal antibody levels are generally low. However, when two doses of vaccine were given, 4 weeks apart, to animals with low levels of maternal antibodies to CPi, there was a significantly higher antibody response in the vaccinated animals after exposure to virulent CPi two weeks after vaccination. It can be concluded that the vaccine had the desired effect, despite the presence of maternal antibody. Field Trials The antibody responses observed in the laboratory studies were confirmed in two field studies which were controlled and fully documented, one in Germany, and one in the UK, using young dogs of various breeds. These studies investigated both the safety and efficacy of the product, and the safety aspects have already been discussed in Part III of this report. CONCLUSIONS ON CLINICAL ASPECTS The data provided on efficacy fulfils the legislative requirements, and allows adequate assessment of the product. Each of the viral antigens in the product stimulates an immune response in the susceptible target animal, and this has been shown to provide protection in each case. The protection afforded by the CDV, CAV and CPV components has been shown to last three years, whereas the CPi component provides a 1-year, duration of immunity. An annual booster has been shown to provide protection. In the presence of high levels of maternal antibody, a beneficial effect is still obtained, although the vaccine is not as efficacious as when used in animals without maternal antibodies. This situation is adequately reflected by the warning in the SPC. V. OVERALL CONCLUSION ON THE PRODUCT The data submitted in the dossier demonstrate that when the product is used in accordance with the Summary of Product Characteristics, the risk benefit profile for the target species is favourable and the quality and safety of the product for man and the environment is acceptable. Page 11 of 11 Date created: 02/03/2006