Access For Disabled People Guidance on the Preparation of an Access Statement TORBAY BUILDING CONTROL CONSULTANCY Spatial Planning Torbay Council 2nd Floor Electric House Torquay TQ1 3DR Page 1 General Introduction In March 2003 the Office of the Deputy Prime Minister, (ODPM), issued "Planning and Access for Disabled People: A Good Practice Guide" which aims to promote a more inclusive approach to the design of the environment, focusing on disabled people and the Planning system (please see the ODPM website for further details www.odpm.gov.uk). A key new feature is the preparation of Access Statements. The Good Practice Note states. "(The submission of a Statement) … would demonstrate the designer's commitment to take the issue of inclusive design seriously at the earliest stages." (Para 7.5.1) Access Statements also form a part of the revised Approved Document Part M 2003 of the Building Regulations, (Paragraph 0.20). Purpose Access Statements will be required to assist with the assessment of the issues relating to disabled people, setting out how provision will be made in the proposed development. It is envisaged that it will act as a core, definitive document, providing an important degree of co-ordination for designers, regulatory staff and construction services. The circumstances in which one will be required are set out in the next section. It will form a part of the documentation for the assessment of an application in the same way any plans might. It is not an informative, general statement of intent, which applicants can choose whether or not they wish to prepare. The document will run with the development and not be solely applicable to one application. Hence, it may begin life as an explanatory statement in pre-planning application discussions and go on to be developed as Building Regulations and Licensing submissions are prepared. Where details are approved as a part of a consent or a condition, it will be necessary to carry this forward to any subsequent design work in the same way any other detail shown on a plan or in a letter will form a part of a consent. Bear in mind that if subsequent design work, eg under the Building Regulations, changes any feature approved as a part of a Planning consent, it may require the approval of the Local Planning Authority. Its written style should not focus solely on one area, e.g. Planning, at the expense of topics or issues that will impact on other legislation. This will ensure that all regulatory bodies have common information and, importantly, a common awareness of the design issues. This will ensure abortive work is avoided. It will require updating from time to time during the design and construction process, with plans substituted or written details Page 2 added. A common point in time will be when new applications are submitted, such as for Building Regulation consent, when planning or licensing conditions are approved or when details become known following agreements with tenants. It is important that the Statement identifies which parts of any scheme are to be dealt with under what area of legislation. This will ensure both regulatory staff and applicants are clear what is being dealt with at which stage in the application process and what is being given consent. The next section on Format of Statement outlines this key procedural issue in detail. Overall, an Access Statement will assist with the assessment of buildings or uses in the context of compliance with the Disability Discrimination Act 1995, contributing to audit work and usability tests. Status of Statement in Determination of a Development Application Paragraph 7.5.4 of the aforementioned advice note suggests that Local Planning Authorities might reject a Planning Application and refuse to register it unless a Statement is submitted. "If an access statement is not submitted, local authorities might reject registration of an application until such time as an adequate statement is submitted. This will overcome the problem of access delaying the 8-week deadline, as applicants will have to have addressed the issues before the application is made. This will also be a great incentive for applicants to consider access from the outset." Philosophy of Statement The aim should be to adopt an inclusive approach, i.e. not to segregate people but seek to meet the needs of all potential users of an environment rather than a specific user group. But inclusive does not mean treat the same – people have different needs whilst wanting to have the same opportunities to access goods and services. The appropriate means of access should be provided for that type of building or activity. For example, automated opening equipment for doors or simply a high and low section to a bar or reception desk in order that differing needs can be met. In addition, paragraph 3.2.3 of the Good Practice Note states. "…it is not only disabled people who benefit from inclusive design. There are currently a further 18 million people who would directly or indirectly benefit from inclusive access to buildings and public spaces. These include the elderly, families with children under the age of five, carers and the friends and relatives who accompany people with disabilities. Indeed it is fair to say that all members of society would benefit to some degree from intelligent, logical and accessible design." It further goes on to say in paragraph 3.3.3. "Developments designed to be inclusive are likely to have an enhanced market value as occupiers and other purchasers of property become increasingly aware of the economic disadvantage of excluding such a substantial percentage of the population… Page 3 It is significantly more cost-effective to provide for inclusive access at the design stage than to make retrospective adjustments during the construction phase or after occupation. Additional costs can be marginalised or eliminated if inclusive design is considered at an early stage. If a development is inclusively designed from the earliest concept stages, an application for planning consent is unlikely to be refused or delayed on the grounds that it does not meet appropriate access standards. This minimises the potential for delay, with obvious commercial benefits." Format of Statement Your Statement should take the form of a written submission together with any appropriate plans. You should follow the headings given in the Appendix One Checklist that will provide guidance on what works are dealt with by which legislative areas. A model Statement is available separately for both minor and major proposals. The exact media for your submission will depend on the size and character of the application, as outlined below. An Access Statement is required for any development application falling within the following categories1 where the public have access, or the scheme is for residential development subject to Adopted Torbay Local Plan (1995-2011) Policy H9 relates to the layout, design and community aspects of new residential development. Policy H2 provides criteria for the consideration of new housing on unidentified sites. Policy BE1 relates to the design of all new development. Policy TS sets out the Landuse transportation Strategy and Policy T1 deals with development accessibility. In addition Policy T2 sets out the transport hierarchy. When major developments are planned it is even more important that they are discussed fully with the applicant and the developer before the application is submitted. In some exceptional cases the application will be so significant that the Secretary of State will designate it as a “major infrastructure project”. ‘Minor’ access proposals A Statement is required in the following four cases if an existing public access point to the building is affected, or it forms a part of the feature or works that are being applied for. Changes of use. Alterations and extensions to licensed premises, including outdoor seating areas Small scale extensions to buildings to which the public have access, (including any commercial premises which have a reception). Temporary uses regardless of size are not exempt if an application is required; for example, mobile offices, a retail outlet for a time limited event, etc. 1 N.B. This should not be confused with the Secretary of State definition of, developments are considered to form ‘major’ planning applications. Page 4 In these sorts of cases applicants may wish to make use of the application plans and simply highlight any key features with appropriate notes. They must still follow the same criteria of looking at the whole building or use and not a single application or the feature they wish to alter. This may require more detail to be shown on plans than otherwise would previously have been considered, using a clear set of identifiable notation, relating to the Access Statement. ‘Major’ access proposals These will require separate plans and written documentation to clearly illustrate the features relevant to the working of the scheme. Examples would include: New licensed premises or major alterations and extensions to existing licensed premises (E.g.: liquor, gaming, sports grounds, public entertainment) The provision of any new housing, which will require a detailed Statement in order to show how Policy H9 relates to the layout, design and community aspects of new residential development. Major commercial developments, eg hotels, offices etc. New community facilities, schools, health centres, sports halls etc. Content Key Issues in Scheme The Statement must describe, through the use of text and supporting plans, how disabled people will access the building or its facilities. The accompanying checklist works through the way a building would be used, highlighting the relevant questions. For example: Proximity of car parking or accessible public transport, Entrance and door design, Types of materials or Means of escape. Sources of Design Information It will be important in any Statement to show what sources of information have been used, particularly if a particular planning policy is being complied with E.g.CF1 Provision of new and improved community facilities or CF15 Accomodation for people in need of care. These are examples of some key ones. 1. Adopted Torbay Local Plan (1995-2011). 2. Please note: The Government has introduced major changes to the town planning system. These will result in the gradual replacement of Local Plans and Structure Plans by Local Development Frameworks (LDFs) and Regional Spatial Strategies Page 5 (RSSs). Work has started on the Torbay LDF, which will provide guidance on development and conservation in the area up to 2016. 3. Council’s access design information contained in: The Local Transport Plan 2006 – 2011 (LTP2) (www.torbay.gov.uk/transportplan ) 4. 5. 6. 7. The emerging Torbay Local Development Framework Supplementary Planning Document relating to Urban Design. Building Regulations 2004 Approved Document Part M and other relevant Approved Documents. South Devon Magistrates Policy on Licensed Premises. British Standard, BS8300 on Access for Disabled People. A comprehensive set of nationally approved guidelines, available from the British Standards Institute or to view at reference section of the Library, Lymington Road, Torquay. The Knowledge Map Reading University have produced this important bibliography of access guidance on behalf of DPTAC It can be found on the Internet at: www.dptac.gov.uk/kmnotes.htm Where there is a deviation from a quoted standard, which may occur in works to a Listed Building, there must be a full explanation of the design solution. Disability Discrimination Act Applicants’ attention is drawn to the requirements of the Disability Discrimination Act 1995. In devising any works you are advised to ensure that your proposals for the building or site comply fully with the appropriate Codes of Practice so ensuring a complete and proper package is formulated. This will avoid the need to make any further applications for consent for subsequent alterations (see the Disability Rights Commission website for further information: www.drc-gb.org/thelaw/index.asp) Other Useful info and contacts: Disability Rights Commission website- http://www.drc-gb.org/ Planning & Access for disabled people: A good practice guide www.odpm.gov.uk Adopted Torbay Local Plan (1995-2011) Strategic Planning Group, Environmental Policy, Planning, Development and Policy Business Unit, Community Services, Torbay Council, Roebuck House, Abbey Road,Torquay,TQ2 5TF Tel: 01803 208804 Fax: 01803 208882 e-mail:strategic.planning@torbay.gov.uk Web site: www.torbay.gov.uk/localplan Please Note: The Government has introduced major changes to the town planning system. These will result in the gradual replacement of Local Plans and Structure Plans by Local Page 6 Development Frameworks (LDFs) and Regional Spatial Strategies (RSSs). Work has started on the Torbay LDF, which will provide guidance on development and conservation in the area up to 2016. In particular the Supplementary Planning Document on Urban Design may be of interest. The LDF will affect everyone – residents, visitors and hose who work in Torbay. Find out more by contacting the Strategic Planning Group on 01803 208804 or by visiting www.torbay.gov.uk/ldf The Torbay Environment Access Meeting (TEAM) . This is a group of people with disabilities and Council Officers who meet monthly to discuss access issues. They can be contacted in writing via the Chair: Mrs C. Morgan, 26 Tramways, Torquay, TQ1 4RZ or you can e-mail andy.young@torbay.gov.uk . Torbay Building Control Consultancy, contact details. Page 7 APPENDIX 1: Key Features Checklist Introduction Your approach to this Statement should be to place yourself in the position of any visitor or members of staff and to run through how they will arrive at the site or building and use all its facilities. The Checklist indicates in broad terms the areas of legislation refer to which group of issues. Checklist All issues are subject in some form to the Disability Discrimination Act 1995. Section 1 Travel to Site Section 4 Means of escape Subject to Planning, Highways & Building Regulations Car parking, Drop off points, Taxis. Tram and bus stops. Routes to stops. Subject to Building Regulations Design for independent means of escape. Provide facilities for physical evacuation, e.g: places of refuge, staff training, audio-visual alarm systems. Section 2 Building Environs Subject to Planning, Highways & Building Control Locations and orientation of entrances. Hard and soft landscaping. Width/Gradients to footways. Lighting. Section 5 Signs and Wayfinding Subject to Building Regulations Type and position of signs. The use of differing tactile materials. The layout of the building. Internal décor. Section 3 Building or Structures Subject to Planning & Building Regulations Materials 1. Construction – walls, doors etc. 2. Internal floor surfaces. Entrances 1. Approach. 2. Steps and ramps. 3. Door design. Subject to Building Regulations. Where proposal is a housing scheme Planning would also apply. See separate Mobility Housing guidance. Page 8 Movement within building 1. Provision of lifts. 2. Stairs. 3. Corridor design – widths, changes in level 4. Reproduction of key facilities on each floor eg toilets. Key features of activity or building use 1. Receptions 2. Specialist equipment. (Fitness equipment, pool hoists) 3. Activities, e.g. counters in shops, dance floors in clubs, or changing areas in sports facilities. 4. Staff rooms. Page 9 APPENDIX 2: Definition of Public Access Members of the public are defined as those people who are not the staff of a business, or those who run a facility, i.e. are there for the purpose of the occupier. Members of the public therefore are likely to be those people who have the opportunity to freely access a building e.g. a shop or use it by invitation e.g. an office with a public reception area. The definition of public includes most activities known as “public services” such as those provided by a local authority e.g. a library or a tourist information office. On the other hand a local authority residential home for the elderly would not be included unless there is a specific area for general access by the community e.g. for a luncheon club open to anyone on the day. Shops, restaurants hospitals, places of worship, schools and colleges are all public buildings though they all will have some areas to a greater or lesser degree which may have restricted access for only employees. Equally any reception in an office where visitors would arrive and be met without direct access to a general office or industrial area would be described as having public access. ______________________________________________________ Page 10 APPENDIX 3: Extract Adopted Torbay Local Plan (1995-2011) Policies BE1 Design of new development Proposals for new development which have an impact on the townscape or landscape should be designed to take account of their wider context in terms of scale, density, massing, height, landscaping, layout and access and the promotion of safety and security. Positive enhancement of the built environment will be sought, in particular in Conservation Areas. H2 New housing on unidentified sites Proposals for new, and the renewal of existing, permissions for new housing on unidentified sites, will be determined by the following considerations, in the interests of promoting sustainable development:(1) the need to prevent significant over or under completion in relation to the Structure Plan provision of 6200 new dwellings in Torbay over the Plan period; (2) the contribution made to the provision of a full range of house types and needs, including the need for affordable housing; (3) the sequential approach to maximising re-used urban land as outlined in Policy HS; (4) maximisation of densities, especially at places with good public transport accessibility and which enjoy good pedestrian access to shops, schools and other community facilities; (5) ensuring good access to adequate physical and social infrastructure, including community provision, which has sufficient capacity to accommodate the proposed development satisfactorily; (6) the need to avoid physical and environmental constraints, including poor ground conditions, and areas at risk from instability, flooding and coastal erosion; and (7) promotion of good design and a high quality ‘green’ residential environment, incorporating open space and providing for community safety, crime prevention and energy efficient dwellings. T1 Development accessibility New non-residential development will only be permitted where it is possible for more than 50% of the potential users to gain access by foot, cycle or public transport. Provision must be made to encourage the use of walking, cycling and public transport, and to reduce the level of traffic generation. Adequate means of access for non-car traffic and facilities for changing and bicycle parking should be provided. Developers of larger sites will be expected to prepare and implement a travel plan which will address these conditions. Residential development should be located so that residents have adequate shopping facilities, primary and junior schools, community and healthcare facilities, and other frequently used attractions within easy and safe walking distance. All other less frequently used facilities should be conveniently accessible by bus and cycle route. The design and layout of residential areas should allow bus penetration to within 400 metres of each dwelling. T2 Transport hierarchy All new development should promote the most sustainable and environmentally acceptable modes of transport, having regard to the following hierarchy, which prioritises the most sustainable means of transport:(1) walking; (2) cycling; Page 11 (3) public transport; and (4) private transport. CF1 Provision of new and improved community facilities New and improved community facilities, such as schools, pre-school play groups, health centres, places of worship, community centres, community sports halls, libraries and the use of schools for community benefit, will be permitted where they:(1) would be readily accessible to the local community including pedestrians and enjoy good access to public transport; (2) would not impact adversely on adjacent properties and surrounding neighbourhood; and (3) would not cause serious congestion or a road safety hazard. Page 12