Expenditure Weights for PPP Aggregations Prepared by Barbro Hexeberg, Chandrakant Patel and Thilak Ranaweera 1. Background Lack of sufficiently detailed expenditure weights of good quality is one major problem in the estimation of purchasing power parities (PPP) under the International Comparison Programme (ICP). So far, most work relating to ICP have been on the development of aggregation methods and the collection of prices, as the expenditure weights in principle should be readily available from the national accounts (NA). However, for many countries expenditures on gross domestic product (GDP) are simply not available at a sufficiently detailed level, if available at all. Thus, the aim of this paper is to look into alternative sources/methods for the derivation of expenditure weights, as the quality of the aggregated PPP will depend on the quality of the weights as well as on the quality of the price data and the aggregation methods applied. The paper describes past practice when expenditure data were not submitted by the countries, discusses problems and suggests solutions, and illustrates these problems and solutions by portraying six countries. For the ICP, GDP is compared across countries by expenditure category breakdown, that is actual consumption by households (consumption expenditures by households and nonprofit institutions serving households, plus individual consumption expenditures by government), collective consumption by government, gross fixed capital formation, changes in inventories, acquisitions less disposals of valuables, and net exports. NA expenditures need to be reported at the level of 150 to 250 basic headings or expenditure categories (the number of required basic headings varies between regions), as the weights are used to combine basic heading parities in order to arrive at PPPs for aggregated measures such as GDP. Table 1 GDP Level of required details Expenditure breakdown as required for the ICP1 Consumption exp. by households (incl. NPISH) Breakdown by purpose / product-groups (CPC or similar) 117 or more ‘basic headings’ Consumption exp. by government Breakdown by purpose (COFOG) – to separate individual and collective consumption. In addition, collective consumption should be broken down by cost: Compensation of employees; Intermediate consumption; and Consumption of fixed capital Gross fixed capital formation Breakdown by type of asset 15-20 ‘basic headings’ Changes in inventories Acquisitions of valuables, net Net exports No breakdown required No breakdown required (Not included in the 1968 SNA nor the list of expenditures needed for ICP) No breakdown required Out of the 190 (+/-) countries reporting NA statistics to the United Nations (UN), approximately 1302 countries report GDP by expenditure, while only 40+ (of which 22 are OECD countries) private final consumption expenditure by purpose (COICOP). Furthermore, the detailed breakdown in the UN database refers to two digit COICOP level (12 purposes), while the required reporting level for the ICP (basic heading level) is four digit level (app. 120 purposes) supplemented with even more detailed productinformation for certain groups.3 Therefore, national statistical offices will only be able to extract this information directly from their NA if detailed supply-use tables are part of their national accounts. Much of the same story holds for government consumption expenditures. While government expenditures by purpose (COFOG) is needed at a two digit COFOG level, no more than 35 countries (of which 10 are OECD countries) provide a breakdown by one digit COFOG. International guidelines for compiling national accounts are designed to yield internationally comparable measures by including production and of all goods and services (with a few exceptions) whether or not they are produced for the market, for own use, or provided to others free of charge. In particular, informal, illegal and subsistence 1 For a complete list of expenditure data required, see Annex I. The number of countries reporting GDP by expenditure differ slightly from year to year, 130 refers to the year 1995. 3 E.g., ‘Bread and Cereals’ should be separated into ‘Rice’; ‘Flour and other cereals’; ‘Bread’; ‘Other bakery products’; ‘Pasta products’; and ‘Other cereal products’. 2 2 should all be included. In practice, however, international comparability is hampered by the use of different international standards (1968SNA versus 1993SNA) and by differences in compilation practices, in coverage and in quality of the estimates. The latter is the most severe problem, an may result in systematic biases in the estimates; it is generally thought that GDP in developing countries is underestimated compared to that of developing countries. Nevertheless, official GDP will need to be the starting point for the ICP. 2. Past Practice in the Absence of National Accounts Data As a number of countries in the past have been unable to submit the required information, guesstimates of expenditures at basic headings level as well as aggregates have been made by World Bank staff for a number of countries.4 The estimation method started with the expenditure data available in the NA of a given country. When data were available on the broad expenditure categories of GDP, these data were used as control totals, to be distributed over their respective more detailed categories. In those cases where no expenditure data on GDP were submitted, the first option was to consult national statistical offices, and statistical publications of other international organizations for actual data, however, if no data were available, the option used was to apply the percentage distribution of a comparable country that participated in the ICP phase. The detailed components of the control totals were then obtained by first examining national and international statistical sources for actual data, such as household expenditure surveys, or if the data from the household survey was not published, use the CPI weights (based on household expenditure surveys) which could either be taken directly from the national statistical offices or from the International Labour Organizations database. In those cases where no data were available, guesstimates would be based on the expenditure structure of a comparable ICP country. 3. ICP Requirements, Statistical Sources, and Recommended Practice 3.1. Consumption The consumption concept utilized in the ICP is actual consumption, rather than final consumption expenditures which is the more commonly used concept of consumption. Actual consumption by households is defined as households final consumption expenditure plus social transfers in kind from government and non profit institutions serving households (NPISH). Examples of transfers in kind are health services and free (or sponsored) admission to cultural events. It follows that actual consumption by government (also called collective consumption) is defined as final consumption 4 Purchasing Power of Currencies, Comparing National Incomes Using ICP Data, Extracts, Technical Note and Sample Table (World Bank 1993). 3 expenditure less individual consumption (social transfers in kind). Per definition, no actual consumption is taking place in NPISH, as all their final consumption expenditures are on individual goods and services. 3.1.1. Requirements The ICP not only requires a detailed breakdown of households final consumption expenditures, but for the estimation of actual consumption by household an estimate of individual consumption by government is needed. This requires that government final consumption expenditures are classified by purpose, following the Classification of the Functions of Government (COFOG) on a two digit level.5 For collective as well as individual consumption expenditure by government, breakdown by cost is required. The list of required details can be found in Annex I. 3.1.2. Statistical sources (i) Households final consumption expenditure The estimate of households final consumption expenditure could be either independently estimated, or be the residual in the equation with GDP given from the production side. In those cases where household consumption expenditures are compiled directly, one of the three methods/sources, or a combination is usually applied: (i) household expenditure surveys; (ii) data on retail trade sales or turnover; and/or (iii) commodity flow approach. Household expenditure surveys are more commonly used in developing countries, while developed countries tend to rely more on retail trade statistics among other sources and commodity flow techniques. This difference in approach can in part be explained by the importance own produced goods play in the consumption estimates in developing countries, for which (household) surveys are the source. Furthermore, the statistical infrastructure might not be in place to produce retail trade statistics of good quality. Some other frequently used sources are VAT records, statistics on sales of alcohol and tobacco, energy statistics, special housing/rent surveys, government accounts (for fees paid etc), surveys of private health services, records on new registration of motor vehicles, and transport statistics. (ii) Government consumption The sources for government consumption expenditure are the different government units’ accounts, sometimes presented in the shape of the Government Finance Statistics (GFS) tables. The degree of detail made available to the statistical office will differ considerably between countries, and there is a fact that the availability of accounts for local government units can be scarce/uncurrent. 5 See annex III for a list of COFOG divisions/groups that benefit individual households as distinctive to those groups that benefit the society as such. 4 For more detailed data, which might be needed in particular areas such as for intermediate consumption in the production of health services, administrative records from the Ministry of Health is a potential source, or if the country primarily imports medical equipment and medicines, import statistics/trade data would be another potential one. Likewise, for a breakdown of compensation of employees by level of education services provided, administrative records from the Ministry of Education will most likely include this information. 3.1.3. Recommended practice The optimal way of deriving expenditure weights for the ICP is to extract the weights from the national accounts, as this will ensure consistency when the PPP data are used to convert national accounts aggregates. As this will not be an alternative for many countries, details from other sources more readily available, such as household surveys, should be utilized.6 (i) Weights for Households Final Consumption Expenditures As reporting on basic heading level requires even a higher degree of details than fourdigit COICOP7 provides, integrated supply-use framework on a relatively detailed level is necessary if all components are to be extracted from the SNA. Even if detailed supplyuse tables are available, there will not always be full match between purposes/products reported in the use tables and basic headings needed for the ICP weights, thus, there might be a need to go back to the sources used for the national accounts compilation. A more common situation will be that the NA includes an aggregated estimate or an aggregated breakdown by purpose of household consumption. In this situation, the NA data will need to be supplemented with detailed information from the household survey and/or other suitable sources available. An exact link between the household survey result and the NA consumption expenditure groups might not exist. Therefore, while estimating weights at the more detailed level based on the household survey, NA estimate(s) should be used as constraint(s). A simple example is given below. If no breakdown of GDP by expenditure categories is available, total household consumption expenditure as well as the detailed weights should be based on the household expenditure survey (supplemented with additional sources available). 6 The availability of household budget surveys (or similar). A quick check of nine low and middle income countries (chosen without following any statistical laws for random sampling) revealed that despite the limited existence of detailed expenditure data in SNA (two of the nine reported household expenditures by COICOP to the United Nations), all countries had carried out a household survey. 7 Consumption expenditures of households can be reported according to purpose (COICOP) on three different levels of detail: a) by division (two digits level), which requires a breakdown into 12 expenditure purposes, b) by group (three digits level), which requires a breakdown into 47 purposes, or c) by class (four digits level), which requires a breakdown into 117 purposes. Some countries develop their own classifications which are compatible with the international standard at a higher level of aggregation. COICOP classifications are listed in Annex II. 5 There are limitations to the direct use of household survey data for the estimation of expenditure weights. The coverage of the household survey data (even with nationwide coverage) is usually somewhat more limited than the coverage of household consumption expenditure in the NA. This is due to the fact that most household surveys do not cover any consumption by institutional households, e.g., orphanages and prisons. Furthermore, survey data often underestimate household spending on alcohol, tobacco and the like, as most people deliberately forget to report any (or the true) spending on such items. Table 2 Derivation of ICP weights based on aggregated expenditure data from the NA supplemented with details from the household expenditure survey. Data from the system of national accounts GDP Household consumption expenditure 01 Food and non-alcoholic beverages 02 Alcoholic beverages, tobacco and narcotics 03 Clothing and footwear …. Current price 559149 Implicit weights 1.000 278346 50190 10470 21210 0.498 0.090 0.019 0.038 Data from the household expenditure survey … 03 Clothing and footwear Clothing Men's clothing Ladies' clothing Children's and infants' clothing Clothing materials and accessories Repair and maintenance of clothing … Amounts … 19940 13150 3500 3900 4700 900 150 … Derivation of basic heading weights … 03 … Clothing and footwear Clothing Men's clothing Ladies' clothing Children's and infants' clothing ICP weights … 0.038 =(3500/19940)*(21210/559149) =(3900/19940)*(21210/559149) =(4700/19940)*(21210/559149) 0.007 0.007 0.009 … On the other hand, household surveys are better suited to include own account consumption, as information on this is missing from other statistical sources frequently 6 used to estimate household consumption expenditure in the SNA, such as retail trade or turnover data. Other common problems with survey data might be linked to sampling design – stratification and selection of units, and to grossing up survey results. Therefore, surveys might not always be representative. Nevertheless, for the derivation of weights on the most detailed level of the ICP – basic heading level, this should not pose a significant problem. It could, however, in some cases be more of a problem when aggregated data from the household survey are needed. Thus, coverage adjustments to survey data should be done both on the overall level and on details, where other sources are deemed more reliable. Recent household surveys are not always available. Because the weights in an old household survey can be non-representative due to relative price changes, the results of the most recent survey should be extrapolated with the move in component indices in the consumer price index (CPI). The weights based on the price adjusted survey results will of course not reflect changes in demand due to relative price changes or changes in taste etc. Hence, it will not represent an ideal source of data, and the need to use additional source statistics is even greater. This will be particularly important for goods and services where demand is price- and income sensitive such as restaurant visits, wine, furniture, services of hair dressers and beauty shops, and photographic equipment. 8 Albeit the above, household survey data should be considered a good source for the derivation of weights when detailed expenditure data for the households are lacking in the NA. (ii) Weights for individual and collective consumption expenditures by government For many countries, their NA data lack the details required to distinguish between individual and collective consumption expenditures by government, as they do not classify government expenditures by COFOG at such a detailed level (70 functions). However, a number of countries use a more aggregated version with a breakdown on 12 divisions, thus, previous practice has been to allocate COFOG divisions 07 Health and 09 Education to households, in order to obtain an estimate of actual consumption by households. As most of COFOG divisions 08 Recreation, Culture and Religion and 10 Social Protection are also individual, the coverage of social transfers in kind should be estimated as more than only COFOG divisions 07 and 09 even when detailed data is not available. For countries lacking this information in their NA, it is crucial to look for alternative sources. In countries where economic and functional analyses are carried out either in the Ministry of Finance, the Central Bank or in the CSO, most of the required details will be available. (These tables are comparable with the tables in the GFS). A potential restriction to the use of these tables, however, is that the coverage often are limited to 8 Change in consumption pattern due to changes in relative prices might be guesstimated with the help of price elasticities estimated for other countries, however, such a method should be used with caution. 7 central government. Thus, where health and education services are mainly carried out by local government units, it will be necessary to study the accounts for local government units in order to find the total amount spent on health, education and social protection. Furthermore, with regards to some required details on health expenditures, such as outpatient versus hospital services, reimbursements of medicines used by households versus medicines used in hospital treatment, it might be necessary to go back to the initial sources or supplement with administrative data from the Ministry of Health. For collective consumption, no further breakdown by purpose (COFOG) or product is required. However, breakdown by cost components – compensation of employees; intermediate consumption; consumption of fixed capital; net taxes on production; and fees (negative) – is required for individual as well as collective consumption. This breakdown should be available, as non-market production are valued at cost. For those countries in which an estimate of consumption of fixed capital is lacking, no adjustments for the missing estimate of compensation of fixed capital should be done, as an adjustment would impose an inconsistency with the underlying NA data. 3.2. Gross fixed capital formation For the ICP, a breakdown by 15-20 types of assets is required. If the estimate of gross fixed capital formation (GFCF) is based on supply side information, data by type of assets should be available, on the other hand, if based on industries’ or institutional sectors’ demand for capital goods, no breakdown by type of assets is necessarily available. Most commonly, a wealth of different sources such as Surveys of capital expenditures by businesses; Data on finalized and ongoing construction projects (difficult to capture small and often informal businesses); Issuance of government permits for building projects; Supply of building materials; Own account construction by households (household expenditure survey); Government accounts; Customs (import/export) data; and Motor vehicle registration records are utilized. Thus, if an estimate of GFCF is available, some data by type of asset should be available. Unfortunately, there are no easy solutions if no independent estimate of GFCF is included in a country’s NA. 3.3. Changes in inventories No breakdown required for the ICP. 3.4. Acquisition of valuables A new category of gross capital formation introduced in the 1993 SNA. No breakdown by type of assets should be necessary for the ICP. 8 3.5. Net exports No breakdown required for the ICP. 4. Revised List of Basic Headings As mentioned earlier, the breakdown of final expenditure on GDP into basic headings provides the framework for the comparison. The basic headings are the building blocks of the comparison, as it is at the level of the basic headings that expenditures are defined, products are selected and PPPs first calculated. In principle, a basic heading consists of a group of similar well defined products, for which a sample of products can be selected that are both representative of their type and of the purchases made in participating countries. In practice, it may be necessary for some countries to use data from outside the national accounts to provide the detailed data required at the basic heading level. In extreme cases, if relevant data is not available, some detailed splits may have to be based on judgment of relevant national accounts compilers. The implication of not having detailed weights is that the component PPPs below the lowest level for which a weight is available are equally weighted. As the classifications followed in the national accounts evolve, there is a need for updating the list of basic heading to align it with the latest revision of the classifications applied in the national accounts. Thus, the classification of basic headings should be clearly linked to the latest versions of the functional/purpose classifications of expenditures by households, COICOP, by government, COFOG, and by NPISHs, COPNI. Furthermore, for capital formation, there is a need to expand the list of basic headings in order to incorporate items such as mineral exploration, software and valuables. These items were not included as capital formation in the 1968 SNA, while they should be included according to the 1993 SNA.9 Also, alternative ways to classify GFCF, either by type of assets or by industry (ISIC), exist. The 1993 SNA (para. 10.34), suggests one possible breakdown by type of assets. To follow this list would be one possible solution, even though it might be preferable to include some more details, e.g., to make a distinction between different types of machinery and equipment. A revised list of basic headings based on the new classification structures has already been established by OECD and Eurostat, as part of the OECD-Eurostat PPP Programme. This list could be adopted and used in other regions of the world as well, however, allowing for regional adjustments as needed.10 Furthermore, as this list with regards to 9 There need not be necessary to identify each of them individually, as it is likely that very few countries will be able to provide relevant prices, and so a reference PPP will be applied to them in total. 10 The OECD/Eurostat list has a breakdown of GDP on 215 basic headings. This is somewhat more than the 150 proposed at the ICP workshop in February 2002. However, if household surveys are available, they are likely to include the detiled information needed for the OECD/Eurostat list with regards to houshold consumption. Thus, moving beyond the150 basic headings should not pose a particular problem. 9 gross fixed capital formation makes reference to CPA which is the European equivalent to CPC, the list will need to be slightly amended to coincide with CPC, or another alternative would be to use a detailed version of the list of type of assets given in 1993 SNA. Furthermore, a list of analytical categories should be created, where the categories are aggregations/combinations of basic headings based on (i) relevance from an economic point of view, and (ii) expected reliability of the estimates. 5. Country studies The objectives of the country studies were to get a clearer picture of what data are available, how this data can best be utilized for the estimation of required basic headings for the ICP, and suggest more specific solutions to specific problems. For the purpose of this exercise, the existing ICP classification was used as point of reference. The selection of six countries (Kenya, Senegal, Namibia, Thailand, Indonesia and Norway) reflects not only geographical diversity, but also differences in their choices of methodology and data sources. Even though all the six countries compile GDP by expenditures, Kenya and Senegal derive household consumption expenditure as a residual. Furthermore, albeit all six countries have either ongoing periodic or recently conducted household expenditure surveys, only Indonesia and Thailand have utilized the results as the main source for compiling household consumption expenditure in the NA. To estimate the same aggregate, Namibia uses the commodity flow method and Norway uses household survey and retail trade statistics in combination with the commodity flow method. All the six countries use COICOP to classify consumption expenditure in the household survey and where applicable in the NA. COFOG is most commonly used to classify government expenditure by function, and GFCF is classified by type of assets. 5.1. Kenya11 The Central Bureau of Statistics (CBS) is responsible for the preparation of the national accounts in Kenya. The accounts are estimated in accordance with the 1968 SNA. GDP is estimated mainly through the production approach, but expenditures on GDP as well as GDP by income category, are also published. 5.1.1. Household consumption expenditure In the Kenyan national accounts, household consumption expenditure is obtained as a residual, after subtracting from GDP government consumption expenditure, gross fixed capital formation, changes in inventories and net exports. Thus, the estimate has the potential to include a statistical discrepancy plus the consumption expenditure and the GFCF of the NPISHs. 11 The following description is based on information from National Accounts Statistics: Main Aggregates and Detailed Tables, 1996-97 (Part II), United Nations, New York 2000, and information gathered by an IMF missions to Kenya, October 2001. 10 There is no breakdown of household consumption expenditure, neither by product nor function (COICOP). Thus the weights for the ICP cannot be taken directly from their national accounts. However, the CBS conducted a household expenditure survey in 1993-94, which has been processed, and is about to be published (2001). The results of the household survey have not yet been implemented in the SNA, neither as a check on the total nor in order to impose a structure on the household expenditures. Nevertheless, the results of the household survey – expenditures by category on a detailed level – would be relevant as expenditure weights for the aggregation of price relatives in the ICP. Thus, even though the optimal way of deriving expenditure weights for the ICP is to extract the needed data (details) from the national accounts, a set of acceptable weights can be derived from alternative sources. In order to estimate such weights, the household survey expenditures should be extrapolated with the CPI (using details from the CPI to extrapolate the details from the survey), and supplemented with other relevant sources of statistics, e.g., statistics on retail trade, imports and production. The weights should then be derived using the household consumption figure from the NA as constraint. The quality of the weights derived in this fashion will depend on: (i) the size of the statistical discrepancy included in the household consumption estimate in the NA; (ii) the quality of the survey results; (iii) how old the household survey is, and linked to that; (iv) how price-elastic the demand is. 5.1.2. Government consumption expenditure The estimates of the final consumption expenditure of government are derived from the accounts of the central and local government, the East African Community, the relevant statutory boards, and the National Security Fund. A limited breakdown of the government’s consumption expenditure is available in the NA: General public services; Defence; Education; Health; and Social security and welfare, including Housing and community amenities and Recreational, cultural and religious affaires. This limited breakdown (less than 1 digit COFOG level) is not sufficient to divide between collective and individual consumption. For central government, a breakdown by 14 COFOG categories is published in the GFS, however, still this is not sufficient. Thus, some kind of approximations must be done, unless more information can be acquired, e.g., from source statistics. Assuming no resources are available to research for additional information, a solution would be to assume that most of Education, Health, Social security and welfare, including Housing and community amenities and Recreational, cultural and religious affaires are individual services. Any approximations (deciding what proportion should be regarded as individual) should be done by local statisticians, as they have a better knowledge about the underlying conditions. 11 Reporting collective and individual consumption by cost components requires cross classification – cost components x purpose. If this is not available, it might be helpful to use information from the production side, as the production of health and education etc by government will mainly be individual consumption, while defence, administration etc will be collective. 5.1.3. NPISH Consumption expenditure Kenya makes no explicit estimate for NPISH Consumption Expenditure. (It could be included in the household estimate.) 5.1.4. Gross capital formation A combination of commodity flow and expenditure approaches is used to estimate gross fixed capital formation. The estimate of capital formation in building and construction is derived from completions of buildings reported by municipalities and expenditure on construction undertaken by government and industries. Estimates on investment in machinery and equipment are derived through the commodity flow method. Changes in inventories are estimated for agriculture, manufacturing, building and construction, as well as retail trade. The sources of information are the large-farm census, the integrated rural survey, the annual survey of concerned industries, and the survey of distribution. As Kenya is following the 1968 SNA, they make no explicit estimate for acquisition of valuables. The ICP requires a relatively detailed breakdown of capital formation. As Kenya reports capital formation by type of assets as well as by industry, they should be capable of meeting the required breakdown. However, it will most likely involve going back to the source data to get a breakdown of transport equipment in particular. 5.1.5. Exports and imports The national account exports and imports figures are based on foreign trade reports and balance of payments data. No breakdown is required for the ICP. 12 5.2. Senegal12 The Directorate of Forecasting and Statistics, Ministry of Economic and Finance is responsible for the preparation of national accounts in Senegal. Based on the 1968 SNA, GDP is estimated mainly through the production approach, while the expenditure on GDP are calculated with household consumption as a residual. No breakdown of GDP by income components is prepared. 5.2.1. Household consumption expenditure Because the Senegalese national account’s household consumption expenditure estimate is obtained as a residual, it has the potential of including a statistical discrepancy, changes in inventories (for the preliminary accounts), and consumption expenditures of the NPISHs. Furthermore, as no source data are utilized directly in the estimation of household consumption expenditure, breakdown by product or purpose (COICOP) does not exist. Thus the expenditure weights for the ICP cannot be taken directly from their national accounts. Household survey results, on the other hand, are available. The Senegalese Household Survey (ESAM) with rural/urban coverage was conducted in 1994-95. Its main objective was to determine the level and structure of income and expenditure of households and to define a poverty profile. The Survey on Household Expenditure in the Capital (EDMC) was carried out in 1996 to determine the structure of purchases of goods and services of households in order to provide weights for the harmonized price index for all West African Economic and Monetary Union countries. It’s coverage was limited to the capital area and the Pikine suburb of Dakar. Reports on both the surveys have been published, but the results of the surveys have not yet been used for the estimation of household expenditure data in the NA, neither as a check on the total (ESAM) nor to impose a structure on the consumption expenditures in the national accounts. According to Senegal’s General Data Dissemination Standard (GDDS) comprehensive framework report, work is underway to use the results of the households surveys to provide better estimates for the consumption estimate in the NA, and a new household survey (ESAM II) is planned for 2001. Expenditure weights can be derived on the basis of the household survey data. Even though, using household survey data directly is not the optimal way to derive expenditure weights for the ICP, it will under the given circumstances be the best solution for Senegal. (Of course, if by 2003 the survey data are built into the NA, there is no reason to use the following approach.) 12 The above description is based on information provided by Senegal as a participant to the General Data Dissemination Standard, and information acquired by a joint IMF/World Bank statistics mission to Senegal, September 2001. 13 The weights should be estimated in the following way: First, household survey expenditures from the ESAM should be extrapolated with details from the CPI to make them current. Then, the ‘extrapolated’ survey expenditures should be confronted with other sources of statistics, among them the EDMS, in order to check and adjust the results where they seem unreasonable. Last, the weights should be derived using the aggregate household consumption figure from the NA as constraint. Again, as in the Kenyan case, the quality of the weights derived will depend on: (i) the size of the statistical discrepancy included in the household consumption estimate in the NA; (ii) the quality of the survey results; (iii) how old the household survey is, and linked to that; (iv) how price-elastic the demand is. 5.2.2. Government consumption expenditure The estimate of government final consumption expenditure is based on the statements of the government’s operating budget and accounting data for government units. According to the United Nations National Accounts database, a breakdown of general government consumption expenditure by one digit COFOG is available. But, as this is not sufficient for dividing between individual and collective consumption, more detailed data must be acquired, or some kind of approximation done. With regards to the breakdown by cost components, the same applies as said above for Kenya. 5.2.3. NPISH Consumption expenditure Senegal makes no explicit estimate for NPISH Consumption Expenditure, thus, it could be indirectly included in the estimate of household consumption. 5.2.4. Gross capital formation A combination of commodity flow and expenditure approaches are used to estimate gross capital formation. The estimate of fixed capital formation is based on production in the construction industry and public works, imports of capital goods, and capital expenditures as reflected in the Execution of the Consolidated State Investment Budget, the Three-Year Public Investment Program, as well as the United Nations Development Program’s (UNDP) annual report, which summarizes the participation of donors and lenders in Senegal. It is likely that Senegal can meet the required breakdown by type of asset. Senegal’s provisional accounts assumes zero changes in inventories, while the semi-final and final accounts estimates changes in inventories based on changes in the operating values of the industrial and commercial enterprises. No breakdown is needed for the ICP. 14 Because Senegal’s methodology for national accounts is based on the 1968 SNA, no explicit estimate for acquisition of valuables is included. 5.2.5. Exports and Imports Main sources for the exports and imports figures in the national accounts are the balance of payments compiled by the Central Bank of West African States (BCEAO) and the customs statistics. No breakdown is required for the ICP. 5.3 Namibia13 The Central Bureau of Statistics is responsible for the compilation of Namibia’s national accounts. The accounts are compiled according to the standards set out in the 1993 SNA. The GDP is estimated from the production and the expenditure sides. To match the two independent estimates of GDP, a statistical discrepancy is introduced on the expenditure side, as the production based GDP is considered the more reliable estimate. 5.3.1. Household consumption expenditure The estimate of the final consumption expenditures of the households is based on the commodity flow technique and detailed import statistics. A limited breakdown by COICOP category exists – Food, beverages and tobacco; Clothing and footwear; and Housing, water, electricity and fuels. All other categories of COICOP are lumped together into the two categories Other goods and Other services. In addition, adjustments for purchases abroad by residents and for purchases on the domestic market by foreigners are specified. As the breakdown by purposes is quite limited in the published national accounts, the weights for the ICP cannot be taken directly from them. Other sources will therefore need to be utilized in order to make possible the estimation of expenditure weights for the ICP. The statistical office conducted a household income and expenditure survey in 1993-94 (November – October). This survey’s results would be useful for estimating expenditure weights for the ICP. The survey results should be extrapolated with detailed price movements as measured by the detailed CPI components. This would update the survey results, but it would not take into account any changes in the pattern of purchases of goods and services due to change in taste and/or relative prices. The ‘updated’ results should be checked against available detailed commodity information used in the compilation of the national accounts, import and production data. A quick comparison of data for 1994 shows that there seems to be agreement between the two sources with regards to the relative amount spent on Food, beverages and tobacco, The following description is based on information from National Accounts 1993 – 1999, Central Bureau of Statistics / Namibia Planning Commission, 2000, and documentation of the Household survey, Central Bureau of Statistics. 13 15 and Clothing and footwear, however, for the third COICOP category Housing, water, electricity and fuels the divergence between the NA and the household expenditure survey (HES) data is quite substantial. This might be due to difference in the estimation of services of owner occupied dwellings. As there must be a separate estimation of this item in the national accounts, it should be possible to check. Table 3 Household consumption expenditures in Namibia, 1994 Household consumption expenditures Food, beverages and tobacco Clothing and footwear Housing, water, electricity and fuels Other goods and services National Accounts 1994 2314 309 858 2126 (0.41) (0.06) (0.15) (0.38) Household operations Furniture and utensils Medical care Transport and communication Education Personal care Recreation Other (1.00) HES results Nov. 93 – Oct. 94 HES results adjusteda 1994 1018 170 794 1147 (0.33) (0.05) (0.25) (0.37) 1670 192 897 1226 (0.42) (0.05) (0.23) (0.31) 121 119 42 586 85 60 63 71 (0.04) (0.04) (0.01) (0.19) (0.03) (0.02) (0.02) (0.02) 137 135 47 592 96 68 71 80 (0.03) (0.03) (0.01) (0.15) (0.02) (0.02) (0.02) (0.02) 3129 (1.00) 3985 (1.00) Total 5607 Direct purchases abroad by residents Direct purchases domestic by nonresidents 215 -691 238 Total household consumption expenditures 5130 4223 a Adjustments are made (i) for price changes, as the time period the household survey covers is slightly different; (ii) to count for institutional households; (iii) to count for probable underestimation of particular goods and services such as alcohol and tobacco etc.; (iii) to correct for those vehicles bought by households with a business. Furthermore, by using the upper limit of the 95 percent confidence interval, the data increases by some 10,5 percent. These size of the adjustments are made by the producers of the survey, however, in the table above, we have assumed that probable underestimation is most likely to be in the category Food, beverages and tobacco. The level of detail in the household survey should be more than sufficient to meet the need for making detailed weights for the ICP exercise, while the sub-totals, taken from the NA, should be used as constraints. Again, the quality of the detailed weights derived will depend on the quality of the household survey, the quality of the household estimates in the NA, the quality of the CPI components as well as on how price elastic the demand for goods and services is. 5.3.2. Government consumption expenditures The estimate of final consumption expenditure of government is derived from data for central government, including all ministries and departments under the State Revenue 16 Fund, data on other institutions, such as, the University of Namibia, and data for municipalities and other local authorities. A breakdown of central government consumption by 11 COFOG groups is available: General public services; Defence; Public order and safety; Education; Health; Social security and welfare; Housing and community amenities; Recreation, culture and religion; Agricultural, forestry and fishing, Transportation and communication; and Other economic affairs and services (including any unallocated items). No breakdown by COFOG of local government consumption expenditures exists, but it should be noted that local government consumption counted for less than 4 percent of government’s consumption expenditures. Thus, there is a lack of sufficiently detailed data and, either more details will need to be acquired, or the required data for the ICP exercise will need to be based on some kind of approximations. With regards to the breakdown by cost components, the same applies as said above for Kenya. 5.3.3 NPISH consumption expenditure A separate estimate for the consumption of non-profit institutions is included in the accounts. As the estimate is based on production of services by NPISH, the data needed for the ICP should be available, even though no breakdown by function is published. 5.3.4 Gross capital formation The Namibian national accounts contain gross fixed capital formation by industry cross classified by type of assets. Thus, even though the published breakdown by type of assets is limited to 5 major categories, much of the information needed for the estimation of ICP weights should be available in the NA, which could be supplemented with detailed import data. 5.3.5. Exports and imports The national accounts exports and imports data are identical to the balance of payments statistics, which is compiled by the Bank of Namibia. No breakdown of exports and imports are needed for the ICP. 5.4. Thailand14 The National Economic and Social Development Board is responsible for the preparation of national accounts in Thailand. GDP is estimated from the expenditure and the production sides. Commodity balances are compiled whenever possible. Furthermore, an 14 The following description is made in collaboration with Wanida Mahakit, NESDB, Thailand. 17 input-output table is estimated at an interval of five years, and ratios from the table are used to fill gaps in cases where information are missing in GDP compilation. 5.4.1. Household consumption expenditure The estimate of household consumption expenditures is based on a set of data sources, such as (i) Socio-economic surveys (SES) conducted by National Statistical office (NSO) every two years (latest available survey is for 2000), (ii) Domestic sales – quantities and values – from various agencies, and (iii) Prices of consumer goods and services obtained from the CPI compiled by the Ministry of Commerce. As the SES are conducted every second year, intervening years are interpolated or extrapolated by suitable indicators. For those items where quantity data are available, price data from the Ministry of Commerce are used to estimate values. In some cases where data are deficient, commodity flow approach is used to compile expenditure estimates, and extrapolation from a benchmark value or quantity using an appropriate indicator is also used where necessary. These benchmarks are obtained from special studies or surveys. Furthermore, in areas such as for the estimation of use of “Fruits and vegetables” where information is inadequate (lack of information with regards to “backyard” products), indirect methods of estimation are applied. A comparison of the ICP requirements and data availability reveals that many items appearing in the existing ICP classification do not figure prominently in the Thai consumption basket. This explains the difficulty of a straightforward mapping of ICP categories into the Thai national accounts. Thai national accounts experts observe that to facilitate such a direct mapping, ICP headings should be more general. 5.4.2. Government consumption expenditures The estimate of government consumption expenditures is based on data from (i) The Ministry of Finance with regards to expenditure by central government, (ii) The Ministry of Interior with regards to expenditure by the local authorities, and (iii) Accounts for a handful non-profit institutions (which should be excluded from government unless funded and controlled by government). The institutional coverage could be an issue with respect to achieving comparability of government expenditures in the region. For instance in the case of Thailand, government consumption expenditures (as well as total consumption expenditures) might be slightly exaggerated by the inclusion of non-profit institutions serving businesses. The consumption expenditures are categorized by three different dimensions, by type of expenditure (compensation of employees and purchases of goods and services form enterprises and abroad), by function (general administrative, education, health, etc.), and by level of government. 18 Publications do not show social transfers in kind from government, however, data on such transfers can be extracted from the abundance of available information in order to arrive at collective consumption by government, and actual individual consumption by households. Furthermore, it should be possible to get specific details needed for the ICP with regards to breakdown by purpose, e.g., outpatient medical services separate from hospital services etc. There is no detailed estimate of consumption of fixed capital in government. However, an aggregate for the whole Kingdom is available by type of asset. Hopefully it would be possible to make some rough estimates of consumption of fixed capital by COFOG category. 5.4.3 NPISH consumption expenditure No independent estimate of NPISH consumption is made. Some consumption expenditures by NPISHs may be included in government (see above), and some may be included in the household sector, nevertheless, there is a possibility of underestimating total consumption due to lack of an independent estimates for NPISH. 5.4.4 Gross capital formation The estimate of Gross Fixed Capital Formation is mainly based on five sources. For private construction, data on permitted and completed construction area for residential and non-residential buildings are available from the Ministry of Interior, while for government construction, data on the value of all construction is available from the Ministry of Finance (central government) and the Ministry of Interior (local authorities). In addition, data on construction costs per square meter of various type of buildinga are gathered through special surveys. For machinery and other equipment, the estimate of domestic products are obtained from various sources such as the Ministry of Industry, the Ministry of Finance (sales) and the Bank of Thailand (from surveys), while the value of imported products are from the Custom Department. Most of the data are collected on a quarterly basis, and are aggreagted to obtain the annual totals. While the data collection process enables verification of actual construction, it also facilitates appropriate adjustments for work-in-progress (particularly important for construction work). The ICP requires a relatively detailed breakdown of fixed capital formation by type of assets. Published NA data indicate that there should be few problems extracting the needed information. It would clearly be straight forward to obtain weights for residential buildings, non-residential buildings, civil engineering works, and land improvement, development of plantations and breeding stock. Yet, problems could be anticipated in the case of details required for estimates of machinery and equipment. This is because the 19 ICP detailed classification is not identical with the one used in Thailand, as Thai data are classified according to TSIC (Thai version of or ISIC) and not CPC. Then again, as the foreign trade statistics is based on the HS classification, ICP required details on imports of machinery and equipment could be compiled. Nevertheless, some estimation on a more detailed level might be needed for the domestically produced machinery and equipment. Changes in inventories (or stocks) can be taken directly from the NA as no breakdown is needed. No separate estimate for acquisition of valuables is included in the Thai NA. Table 4 Gross Capital Formation by ICP Basic Headings (Millions of Baht) Code Description 4 4.1 GROSS FIXED CAPITAL FORMATION MACHINERY AND EQUIPMENT 4.1.1 4.1.1.03.1 4.1.1.05.0 4.1.1.06.0 4.1.1.08.1 4.1.1.09.0 4.1.1.10.1 4.1.2 4.1.2.01.1 4.1.2.02.0 4.1.3 4.1.3.01.1 4.1.3.02.1 4.1.3.02.2 4.1.3.02.3 4.1.3.02.4 MACHINERY AND NON-ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT Agricultural machinery Equipment for mining and building, incl. metal structures Machinery for textile, food, chemical, paper etc. industries Office equipment and appliances Precision and optical instruments15 Other machinery ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT AND APPLIANCES Electrical equipment, including lamps Telecommunication, electronic and electrical equipment n.e.c. TRANSPORT EQUIPMENT Motor vehicles and engines Ships and boats Locomotives, wagons Aircraft Other transport equipment 4.2 CONSTRUCTION 4.2.1 4.2.1.03.1 4.2.2 4.2.2.05.1 4.2.3 4.2.3.04.1 RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS Residential buildings NON-RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS Non-residential buildings CIVIL ENGINEERING WORKS Civil engineering works 4.3 OTHER PRODUCTS 4.3.1 4.3.1.01.1 OTHER PRODUCTS Land improvement, development of plantations and breeding stock 5 5.0.0.00.0 CHANGE IN STOCKS Change in stocks 15 1999 344,438 6,197 19,697 61,788 117,778 69,993 68,985 37,890 6,224 31,666 118,748 90,183 12,773 6,851 8,941 n.a. 59,590 59,590 103,544 103,544 285,291 285,291 868 868 -6,797 -6,797 Professional & Scientific instrument 20 5.4.5. Exports and imports The major sources for the national accounts estimates of imports and exports are customs data from the Customs Department of the Ministry of Finance and the balance of payments data from the Bank of Thailand. No breakdown is required for the ICP. 5.5. Indonesia16 The national accounts in Indonesia are compiled by the Bureau of Consumption and Accumulation Accounts in the Badan Pusat Statistik (Statistics Indonesia). The accounts are compiled in accordance with the 1968 SNA. GDP is estimated by production as well as by expenditure. 5.5.1. Household consumption expenditure The main source of data for estimate of household consumption expenditure is the National Social and Economic Survey (Survei Sosial Ekonomi Nasional, SUSENAS). The SUSENAS is a nationwide survey which is conducted by the Badan Pusat Statistik (BPS), in order to gather data on social and economic aspects of the society. The survey consists of several modules, including a consumption module which serves as a basis for the compilation of household consumption expenditure. The SUSENAS is conducted every three years, and the latest consumption module refers to 1999.17 A problem in using the SUSENAS is linked to its coverage, which is limited to mid- and lower-income groups. Therefore, to arrive at the total household consumption by purpose, the estimate for food and non-food groups need to be adjusted to cover high income households as well. For intervening years, a regression based methodology is used. To give a view of how the household consumption data provided by SUSENAS, embodied in the national accounts, could be classified for ICP purposes, annex IV provides a link between SUSENAS items and ICP basic headings. Items in the SUSENAS that do not appear specifically in the ICP classification are noted as “unclassified” immediately below the ICP requirements. The Indonesian survey data is rich in detail, and most of the information needed for the ICP with regards to household consumption expenditures are readily available. However, there may be a substantial number of cases where product specifications have to be fine- 16 The following description is made in collaboration with Slamet Sutomo, BPS, Indonesia. National accounts compilers also use special surveys to estimate those elements of expenditures not covered explicitly by SUSENAS. For example, there is a special survey to determine the financial position and structure of households. This survey provides information on the interest payments, bank, and other financial services charges of households. This special survey is a non-random sampling survey of some selected households. 17 21 tuned to meet ICP requirements. In fact, it may be necessary to redefine the ICP basic headings flexibly to reflect regional specificities.18 The comparison between details in the SUSENAS and required details for the ICP (basic headings) yielded the following: In the food group, the size of the sub-groups tends to vary quite a great deal. For example, meat, vegetables, fruits, pulses, spices, and prepared foods have a large number of items included in the sub-group and these items could be perceived to be somewhat heterogeneous notwithstanding the fact that they could be considered part of the sub-group in question. A similar observation is also valid for the non-food group, especially for the sub-groups on housing facilities, miscellaneous goods and services, and durable goods. In the SUSENAS classification a doubtful item is the inclusion of “detergents” in “Clothing, footwear, and hats” sub-group. At the same time, there does not appear to be an item for “laundry”, other personal services (haircuts etc.). The comparison between the SUSENAS and ICP basic headings revealed areas where the ICP classification needs to be reviewed to take account of specific characteristics of Indonesia (and the region). Bread and cereals group, oils and fats group, fruits and vegetables group, potatoes and tubers groups, other foods group are some of the obvious candidates for re-consideration. The heterogeneity of the sub-groups has an implication to the way the ICP project needs to be implemented. If the current list is taken as a guideline, it is possible to establish an expenditure weight for each sub-group. If we think in terms of a composite price for the sub-group as a whole, it would be necessary to establish weights for individual items within a sub-group. Unfortunately, the current level of published information is inadequate to ascertain whether such a detailed weighting system could be derived from the given information in the SUSENAS. As mentioned earlier, examples of worksheets of BPS suggest that it has the information to handle this problem. Thus, even though national accounts don’t include all the details needed for the ICP, the structure could be taken from the SUSENAS, and re-classified to meet ICP requirements. It should be noted that the household consumption expenditure estimate in the Indonesian NA includes consumption expenditures by non-profit institutions. These expenditures should be specified if possible. 5.5.2. Government consumption expenditure Government consumption expenditure covers consumption expenditures of central and local governments. The estimate is based on data from the Directorate General of Budget Affairs, Ministry of Finance for central government. For local (provincial, district and village) government, data are collected directly by BPS. 18 In some cases, SUSENAS has more items than ICP requirements and it could form the basis of revision of ICP requirements, especially in the regional context. In annex VI, these items are marked under the heading “details of“ immediately below the ICP heading. 22 Breakdown by cost components should not be a problem, as consolidated economic analysis of the central government is available. Consumption of fixed capital is estimated as 5 percent of total compensation of employees. A breakdown by 14 functions is available for the central government. This could be utilized in conjunction with economic analysis to derive government individual and collective consumption. 5.5.3. Gross capital formation The commodity flow approach is used to compile gross fixed capital formation. In addition to supply side information in the NA, data on construction and domestically produced capital goods from the Directorate of Manufacturing Statistics and on imports of capital goods from the Directorate of External Trade Statistics are utilized. Fixed capital formation is classified into construction, machinery and equipment, transportation vehicles and other capital goods. Even though gross fixed capital formation in the NA are published (and produced) on a higher level of aggregation than what is needed to meet the requirements of the ICP, the requirements can be met by using at the underlying sources. Since data on inventories (stocks) are limited, changes in inventories is estimated residually. Consequently, the estimate has the potential of including a statistical discrepancy. No breakdown is needed for the ICP. As the national accounts of Indonesia follows the 1968 SNA, it does not include an estimate of acquisition of valuables. 5.5.4. Exports and imports Merchandise exports and imports are based on statistics of exports and imports (BPS) and data from the Department of Mining and Energy (exports of oil), while exports and imports on services are based on the Balance of Payments (Bank of Indonesia), supplemented by data from other agencies. No breakdown of net exports is needed for the ICP. 5.6. Norway19 Statistics Norway is responsible for the preparation of the national accounts in Norway. The accounts are prepared in accordance with the 1993 SNA/ESA 1995. GDP is estimated in a very detailed supply-use framework, ensuring consistency between the production and expenditure approach to GDP. 19 The following description is partly based on Erling Joar Fløttum, Norwegian National Accounts. Documentation of the compilation and methods applied., Statistics Norway, Norway 1996. 23 5.6.1. Household consumption expenditure In the Norwegian national accounts, household consumption expenditure is based on three classes of sources. These are household expenditure surveys, retail trade statistics and the commodity flow method following output estimates in particular. As an additional reliability test on the total level of household consumption expenditure, total theoretical non-deductible value added tax (VAT ) on household expenditures estimated in the national accounts is checked against the VAT receipts in the government’s accounts. The household final consumption expenditure estimation is detailed, specifying some 110 consumption groups, and involving a larger number of product flows. The consumption groups, following the main structure of COICOP, are partly corresponding to the expenditure classification at detailed heading level applied in the ICP. Furthermore, when a one-to-one relationship is non-existing, the required data can be found by using the details on products going into the consumption groups. Therefore, all required details with regards to household final consumption expenditure should be available from the national accounts. 5.6.2. Government consumption expenditure The estimate of final consumption expenditure of general government is based on the accounts of the central government and all local governments. Government final consumption expenditure is distinguished in 55 groups of function within the framework of 14 main groups. COFOG is applied as classification for both central and local government expenditure. All details required to make a distinction between individual and collective consumption are present, furthermore, all details needed for the individual consumption expenditures to be classified according to the ICP basic headings can also be found in the national accounts. As the consumption estimate for government are based on the cost approach, the required details – compensation of employees, intermediate consumption, consumption of fixed capital, and fees (negative) – can be reported by function. 5.6.3. NPISH consumption expenditure A separate estimate for the consumption of non-profit institutions is included in the accounts. The estimate is based on a range of sources, as no survey of non-profit organizations has been carried out. The consumption expenditure is broken down by five groups of function, however, based on the product information that is included in the national accounts, there should be no problems classifying these expenditure according to ICP basic headings. 24 5.6.4. Gross capital formation The primarily method of estimation is based on the use of industry–related sources and the expenditure approach, however, as investment estimates by kind of activity are fed into the supply-use framework, the commodity flow approach takes on a substantial role. Thus, data on foreign trade and domestic production are playing a role in the estimation. Gross fixed capital formation has two main dimensions in terms of breakdown, one by category or type of asset, and one by kind of activity. Altogether, 55 types of assets are specified, grouped into 7 main categories: Dwellings (4); Non-residential buildings (10); Other structures (16); Transport equipment (7); Other machinery and equipment (13); Cultivated assets (2); and Intangible fixed assets (3). The ICP requires a relatively detailed breakdown of capital formation, however, there should be no problem to get data on the required details and aggregates based on the NA. The estimate of changes in inventories is a residual in the Norwegian national accounts. It is made sure that products that goes into inventories are goods rather than services, however, there is no real effort to check the total against official statistics on changes in inventories. The ICP requires only a total for the estimate, which can easily be taken from the NA. A separate estimate is made for acquisition of valuables. 5.6.5 Exports and Imports The national accounts exports and imports data are identical to the balance of payments (which is also estimated in the national accounts division). External trade statistics are the major source (99/97 percent coverage) for the estimation of exports/imports of goods, while exports/imports of services are based on foreign exchange statistics in combination with maritime transport statistics, oil and gas activity statistics and some other sources. No breakdown of exports/imports is needed for the ICP. 6. Conclusions A general review as well as the country studies on the derivation of expenditure weights for PPP calculations suggest that a country must have GDP by expenditure to provide the control numbers and facilitate the calculation of PPP adjusted GDP. For the countries which derive final household consumption expenditure as a residual, it should be ascertained what other flows/items such as changes in inventories, consumption of NPISHs, statistical discrepancy are included in it and whether there is a possibility to make adjustments to achieve conceptually sound expenditure aggregate for final household consumption expenditure for control purposes. 25 If the household survey results are not used for NA compilation, then they need to be adjusted e.g. for coverage (geographical, institutional, or socio/economic groups), underor over-estimation, and changes in prices. For that recourse should be made to alternative data sources such as on commodity flows, tax statistics, import statistics, and consumer price indices. As countries use COICOP to classify consumption expenditures in the household expenditure survey and NA, the ICP should consider providing conversion keys from COICOP to ICP basic headings for the consumption goods and services. In the regions, where there is a heterogeneity of products with marked differentials in price movements, ICP may wish to consider recommending sub-weights for averaging prices. For consumption expenditure of government, ICP may wish to emphasize cross classification by functions/costs (economic) even though GFS recommends functional classification of governments’ total expenditure only. ICP’s classification of gross capital formation needs to be updated to accommodate the changes in the boundary of capital formation and the classification of non-financial (tangible and intangible) assets in the 1993 SNA. As most countries compile gross fixed capital formation by type of assets in accordance with the 1993 SNA there should be harmonization of broad ICP headings with the type of assets categories. The ICP’s further needs of details can be defined in terms of CPC as OECD/Eurostat recommends. On the whole, ICP should provide firm guidelines on the concepts, coverage and classification of expenditures and leave some room for approximations to accommodate the regional specifics and heterogeneity, lack of details, and uncurrent data. The developmental work and guidelines on expenditure weights should be closely tied to those for prices and aggregations so that the targeted PPPs are conceptually and methodologically sound and relevant to the users. 26 Annex I Expenditure Data Needed for the ICP 1 HOUSEHOLD CONSUMPTION 1.1 FOOD, BEVERAGES, TOBACCO 1.1.1 FOOD 1.1.1.01 1.1.1.01.1 1.1.1.01.2 1.1.1.01.3 1.1.1.01.4 1.1.1.01.5 1.1.1.01.6 BREAD AND CEREALS Rice Flour and other cereals Bread Other bakery products Pasta products Other cereal products 1.1.1.02 1.1.1.02.1 1.1.1.02.2 1.1.1.02.3 1.1.1.02.4 1.1.1.02.5 1.1.1.02.8 1.1.1.02.9 MEAT Beef Veal Pork Lamb, mutton and goat Poultry Other meats and edible offal Meat preparations 1.1.1.03 1.1.1.03.1 1.1.1.03.3 1.1.1.03.5 FISH Fresh, or frozen fish Fresh, or frozen seafood Dried, preserved or processed fish and seafood 1.1.1.04 1.1.1.04.1 1.1.1.04.2 1.1.1.04.3 1.1.1.04.4 1.1.1.04.5 MILK, CHEESE AND EGGS Fresh milk Preserved milk Other milk products Cheese Eggs 1.1.1.05 1.1.1.05.1 1.1.1.05.5 OILS AND FATS Butter Margarine and other edible oils and fats 1.1.1.06 1.1.1.06.1 1.1.1.06.2 1.1.1.06.3 1.1.1.06.4 FRUIT AND VEGETABLES Fresh fruit Dried fruit and nuts Frozen and preserved fruit and fruit juices Fresh vegetables 27 1.1.1.06.8 Dried, frozen, preserved vegetables 1.1.1.07 1.1.1.07.1 1.1.1.07.2 POTATOES AND TUBERS Potatoes and other tubers Potato products 1.1.1.08 1.1.1.08.1 SUGAR Raw and refined sugar 1.1.1.09 1.1.1.09.1 1.1.1.09.2 1.1.1.09.3 COFFEE, TEA AND COCOA Coffee Tea Cocoa 1.1.1.10 1.1.1.10.1 1.1.1.10.5 1.1.1.10.6 OTHER FOODS Jams, jellies, honey and syrups Salt, spices, condiments and food n.e.c. Chocolate, confectionery and ice cream 1.1.2 1.1.2.01.1 1.1.2.01.2 NON-ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES Mineral water Soft drinks 1.1.3 1.1.3.01.1 1.1.3.01.3 1.1.3.01.5 ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES Spirits and liqueurs Beer Wine and other alcoholic beverages 1.1.4 1.1.4.01.1 1.1.4.02.1 TOBACCO Cigarettes Other tobacco products 1.2 CLOTHING AND FOOTWARE 1.2.1 1.2.1.01.1 1.2.1.01.2 1.2.1.01.5 1.2.1.01.6 1.2.1.02.1 CLOTHING Men's clothing Ladies' clothing Clothing materials and accessories Children's and infants' clothing Repair and maintenance of clothing 1.2.2 1.2.2.01.1 1.2.2.01.2 1.2.2.01.3 1.2.2.02.1 FOOTWEAR Men's footwear Ladies' footwear Children's and infants' footwear Repairs to footwear 28 1.3 RENTS, FUEL AND POWER 1.3.1 1.3.1.01.0 1.3.1.02.1 GROSS RENTS AND WATER CHARGES Gross rents, incl. repair and maintenance Water charges 1.3.2 1.3.2.01.1 1.3.2.02.0 1.3.2.03.1 1.3.2.04.1 FUEL AND POWER Electricity Gas Liquid fuels for heating and lighting Coal, firewood and other fuels 1.4 FURNITURE,, HOUSEHOLD EQUIPMENT AND OPERATION 1.4.1 1.4.1.01.1 1.4.1.01.2 1.4.1.02.1 FURNITURE, FLOOR COVERINGS, INCL. REPAIRS Furniture and fixtures Floor coverings Repairs to furniture and floor coverings 1.4.2 1.4.2.01.1 1.4.2.02.1 HOUSEHOLD TEXTILES. INCL. REPAIRS Household textiles and other furnishings Repairs to household textiles 1.4.3 1.4.3.01.1 1.4.3.01.2 1.4.3.01.3 1.4.3.01.4 1.4.3.01.5 1.4.3.01.6 1.4.3.02.1 MAJOR HOUSEHOLD APPLIANCES. INCL. REPAIRS Refrigerators, freezers Washing machines, driers, dishwashers Cooking appliances Heaters and air-conditioners Vacuum cleaners, polishers etc. Other major household appliances Repairs to major household appliances 1.4.4 1.4.4.01.0 1.4.4.02.1 GLASSWARE. TABLEWARE AND UTENSILS. INCL. REPAIRS Glassware, tableware and household utensils Repairs to glassware, tableware and household utensils 1.4.5 1.4.5.01.1 1.4.5.01.2 1.4.5.02.0 HOUSEHOLD OPERATION Household cleaning and maintenance products Paper products and other non-durable household goods Laundry and other household services 1.4.6 1.4.6.01.1 DOMESTIC SERVICES Domestic services 1.5 MEDICAL CARE AND HEALTH SERVICES 29 1.5.1 1.5.1.01.1 1.5.1.02.1 MEDICAL CARE AND PHARMACEUTICAL PRODUCTS Drugs and medical preparations Other medical supplies 1.5.2 1.5.2.00.0 THERAPEUTIC APPLIANCES AND EQUIPMENT Therapeutic appliances and equipment 1.5.3 1.5.3.03.1 1.5.3.04.1 1.5.3.07.0 1.5.3.08.0 MEDICAL SERVICES OUTSIDE HOSPITALS Services of dentists Services of nurses Services of physicians Other medical services and analyses 1.5.4 1.5.4.00.0 HOSPITAL CARE Hospital care 1.6 TRANSPORT AND COMMUNICATION 1.6.1 1.6.1.01.1 1.6.1.02.1 PERSONAL TRANSPORT EQUIPMENT Passenger vehicles Motor cycles and bicycles 1.6.2 1.6.2.01.1 1.6.2.01.2 1.6.2.02.1 1.6.2.03.1 OPERATION OF TRANSPORT EQUIPMENT Tires, parts and accessories Maintenance and repair services Motor fuels and oils Other expenses related to personal transport 1.6.3 1.6.3.01.1 1.6.3.02.1 1.6.3.02.2 1.6.3.03.1 PURCHASED TRANSPORT SERVICES Local transport Long-distance transport by road and rail Long-distance transport by air and sea Other purchased transport services 1.6.4 1.6.4.01.1 1.6.4.02.1 COMMUNICATION Postal services Telephone, telegraph and telex services 1.7 RECREATION, ENTERTAINMENT AND EDUCATION 1.7.1 1.7.1.01.0 1.7.1.02.1 1.7.1.02.2 1.7.1.03.0 RECREATIONAL EQUIPMENT AND ACCESSORIES Radio, TV and audio equipment Photographic equipment Other durable recreational goods Other recreational goods 30 1.7.1.04.1 Parts and repairs to recreational goods 1.7.2 1.7.2.01.1 1.7.2.02.0 ENTERTAINMENT, RECREATIONAL AND CULTURAL SERVICES Cinemas, sports stadiums, museums, zoos etc. Recreational and sporting activities, rental and subscription 1.7.3 1.7.3.01.0 BOOKS, NEWSPAPERS AND OTHER PRINTED MATTER Books, newspapers and other printed matter 1.7.4 1.7.4.00.0 EDUCATION SERVICES Education services 1.8 MISCELLANEOUS GOODS AND SERVICES 1.8.1 1.8.1.01.1 1.8.1.02.0 PERSONAL CARE AND EFFECTS Services of hairdressers and beauty shops Toilet articles 1.8.2 1.8.2.01.1 1.8.2.02.0 1.8.2.03.1 GOODS NOT ELSEWHERE CLASSIFIED Jewellery, watches and their repair Personal accessories n.e.c. Writing and drawing supplies 1.8.3 1.8.3.01.0 1.8.3.02.1 RESTAURANTS AND HOTELS Restaurants, cafes and staff canteens Hotels and other lodging places 1.8.4 1.8.4.00.0 WELFARE SERVICES Welfare services 1.8.5 1.8.5.01.1 FINANCIAL SERVICES Charges for financial services n.e.c. 1.8.6 1.8.6.01.1 SERVICES N.E.C. Fees for other services n.e.c. 1.9 1.9.1.01.1 NET PURCHASES ABROAD BY RESIDENTS Net purchases abroad by residents 2 2.1.1.01.1 CONSUMPTION OF NON-PROFIT INSTITUTIONS Consumption of non-profit institutions n.e.c. 3 3.1.1.01.1 3.1.2.01.1 3.1.3.01.1 GOVERNMENT CONSUMPTION Compensation of employees Intermediate consumption Consumption of fixed capital 31 4 GROSS FIXED CAPITAL FORMATION 4.1 MACHINERY AND EOUIPt6EjT 4.1.1 4.1.1.03.1 4.1.1.05.0 4.1.1.06.0 4.1.1.08.1 4.1.1.09.0 4.1.1.10.1 MACHINERY AND NON-ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT Agricultural machinery Equipment for mining and building, incl. metal structures Machinery for textile, food, chemical, paper etc. industries Office equipment Precision and optical instruments Other machinery 4.1.2 4.1.2.01.1 4.1.2.02.0 ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT AND APPLIANCES Electrical equipment, including lamps Telecommunication, electronic and electrical equipment n.e.c. 4.1.3 4.1.3.01.1 4.1.3.02.1 4.1.3.02.2 4.1.3.02.3. 4.1.3.02.4 TRANSPORT EQUIPMENT Motor vehicles and engines Ships and boats Locomotives, wagons Aircraft Other transport equipment 4.2 CONSTRUCTION 4.2.1 4.2.1.03.1 RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS Residential buildings 4.2.2 4.2.2.05.1 NON-RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS Non-residential buildings 4.2.3 4.2.3.04.1 CIVIL ENGINEERING WORKS Civil engineering works 4.3 OTHER PRODUCTS 4.3.1 4.3.1.01.1 OTHER PRODUCTS Land improvement, development of plantations and breeding stock 5 5.0.0.00.0 CHANGE IN STOCKS Change in stocks 6 6.0.0.00.0 NET EXPORTS OF GOODS AND SERVICES Net exports of goods and services 32 Annex II Classification of Individual Consumption According to Purpose (COICOP)20 COICOP is used to classify both the individual consumption expenditure of households, non-profit institutions serving households and general government and the actual individual consumption of households. Some countries base their estimates of individual consumption expenditure of households in the national accounts on household budget surveys which frequently collect data according to functional groups of the kind used in COICOP. In these cases, estimates will be directly available of individual consumption expenditure by purpose, although data from such surveys usually need to be adjusted for various kinds of systematic errors and omissions. In most cases, however, estimates of consumption expenditure are built up either from statistics on retail sales or by a “commodity-flow” method in which the total supply of goods and services from domestic production and imports is allocated to intermediate and final uses. In such cases the starting point for COICOP will be a breakdown of goods and services for household consumption according to type of product or by kind of activity as an approximation to type of product. Several goods and services are multi-purpose - for example, fabrics may be used for clothing or furnishing, diesel fuel can be used for passenger vehicles or for home-heating and insurance services may be for risks relating to housing, transport or health. INDIVIDUAL CONSUMPTION EXPENDITURE OF HOUSEHOLDS 01. FOOD AND NON-ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES 01.1 01.1.1 01.1.2 01.1.3 01.1.4 01.1.5 01.1.6 01.1.7 01.1.8 01.1.9 FOOD Bread and cereals 01.1.2 Meat Fish and seafood Milk, cheese and eggs Oils and fats Fruit Vegetables Sugar, jam, honey, chocolate and confectionery Food products n.e.c. 01.2 NON-ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES 01.2.1 Coffee, tea and cocoa 01.2.2 Mineral waters, soft drinks, fruit and vegetable juices 02. ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES, TOBACCO AND NARCOTICS 02.1 ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES 02.1.1 Spirits 20 Source: Classification of Expenditure According to Purpose. United Nations, New York, 2000. 33 02.1.2 Wine 02.1.3 Beer 02.2 TOBACCO 02.2.0 Tobacco 02.3 NARCOTICS 02.3.0 Narcotics 03. CLOTHING AND FOOTWEAR 03.1 03.1.1 03.1.2 03.1.3 03.1.4 CLOTHING Clothing materials Garments Other articles of clothing and clothing accessories Cleaning, repair and hire of clothing 03.2 FOOTWEAR 03.2.1 Shoes and other footwear 03.2.2 Repair and hire of footwear 04. HOUSING, WATER, ELECTRICITY, GAS AND OTHER FUELS 04.1 ACTUAL RENTALS FOR HOUSING 04.1.1 Actual rentals paid by tenants 04.1.2 Other actual rentals 04.2 IMPUTED RENTALS FOR HOUSING 04.2.1 Imputed rentals of owner-occupiers 04.2.2 Other imputed rentals 04.3 MAINTENANCE AND REPAIR OF THE DWELLING 04.3.1 Materials for the maintenance and repair of the dwelling 04.3.2 Services for the maintenance and repair of the dwelling 04.4 04.4.1 04.4.2 04.4.3 04.4.4 WATER SUPPLY AND MISCELLANEOUS SERVICES RELATING TO THE DWELLING Water supply Refuse collection Sewerage collection Other services relating to the dwelling n.e.c. 04.5 04.5.1 04.5.2 04.5.3 ELECTRICITY, GAS AND OTHER FUELS Electricity Gas Liquid fuels 34 04.5.4 Solid fuels 04.5.5 Heat energy 05. FURNISHINGS, HOUSEHOLD EQUIPMENT AND ROUTINE HOUSEHOLD MAINTENANCE 05.1 FURNITURE AND FURNISHINGS, CARPETS AND OTHER FLOOR COVERINGS 05.1.1 Furniture and furnishings 05.1.2 Carpets and other floor coverings 05.1.3 Repair of furniture, furnishings and floor coverings 05.2 HOUSEHOLD TEXTILES 05.2.0 Household textiles 05.3 05.3.1 05.3.2 05.3.3 HOUSEHOLD APPLIANCES Major household appliances whether electric or not Small electric household appliances Repair of household appliances 05.4 GLASSWARE, TABLEWARE AND HOUSEHOLD UTENSILS 05.4.0 Glassware, tableware and household utensils 05.5 TOOLS AND EQUIPMENT FOR HOUSE AND GARDEN 05.5.1 Major tools and equipment 05.5.2 Small tools and miscellaneous accessories 05.6 GOODS AND SERVICES FOR ROUTINE HOUSEHOLD MAINTENANCE 05.6.1 Non-durable household goods 05.6.2 Domestic services and household services 06. HEALTH 06.1 06.1.1 06.1.2 06.1.3 MEDICAL PRODUCTS, APPLIANCES AND EQUIPMENT Pharmaceutical products Other medical products Therapeutic appliances and equipment 06.2 06.2.1 06.2.2 06.2.3 OUT-PATIENT SERVICES Medical services Dental services Paramedical services 06.3 HOSPITAL SERVICES 06.3.0 Hospital services 35 07. TRANSPORT 07.1 07.1.1 07.1.2 07.1.3 07.1.4 PURCHASE OF VEHICLES Motor cars Motor cycles Bicycles Animal drawn vehicles 07.2 07.2.1 07.2.2 07.2.3 07.2.4 OPERATION OF PERSONAL TRANSPORT EQUIPMENT Spare parts and accessories for personal transport equipment Fuels and lubricants for personal transport equipment Maintenance and repair of personal transport equipment Other services in respect of personal transport equipment 07.3 07.3.1 07.3.2 07.3.3 07.3.4 07.3.5 07.3.6 TRANSPORT SERVICES Passenger transport by railway Passenger transport by road Passenger transport by air Passenger transport by sea and inland waterway Combined passenger transport Other purchased transport services 08. COMMUNICATION 08.1 POSTAL SERVICES 08.1.0 Postal services 08.2 TELEPHONE AND TELEFAX EQUIPMENT 08.2.0 Telephone and telefax equipment 08.3 TELEPHONE AND TELEFAX SERVICES 08.3.0 Telephone and telefax services 09. RECREATION AND CULTURE 09.1 AUDIO-VISUAL, PHOTOGRAPHIC AND INFORMATION PROCESSING EQUIPMENT 09.1.1 Equipment for the reception, recording and reproduction of sound and pictures 09.1.2 Photographic and cinematographic equipment and optical instruments 09.1.3 Information processing equipment 09.1.4 Recording media 09.1.5 Repair of audio-visual, photographic and information processing equipment 09.2 OTHER MAJOR DURABLES FOR RECREATION AND CULTURE 09.2.1 Major durables for outdoor recreation 09.2.2 Musical instruments and major durables for indoor recreation 36 09.2.3 Maintenance and repair of other major durables for recreation and culture 09.3 PETS 09.3.1 09.3.2 09.3.3 09.3.4 09.3.5 OTHER RECREATIONAL ITEMS AND EQUIPMENT, GARDENS AND 09.4 09.4.1 09.4.2 09.4.3 RECREATIONAL AND CULTURAL SERVICES Recreational and sporting services Cultural services Games of chance 09.5 09.5.1 09.5.2 09.5.3 09.5.4 NEWSPAPERS, BOOKS AND STATIONERY Books Newspapers and periodicals Miscellaneous printed matter Stationery and drawing materials Games, toys and hobbies Equipment for sport, camping and open-air recreation Gardens, plants and flowers Pets and related products Veterinary and other services for pets 09.6 PACKAGE HOLIDAYS 09.6.0 Package holidays 10. EDUCATION 10.1 PRE-PRIMARY AND PRIMARY EDUCATION 10.1.0 Pre-primary and primary education 10.2 SECONDARY EDUCATION 10.2.0 Secondary education 10.3 POST-SECONDARY NON-TERTIARY EDUCATION 10.3.0 Post-secondary non-tertiary education 10.4 TERTIARY EDUCATION 10.4.0 Tertiary education 10.5 EDUCATION NOT DEFINABLE BY LEVEL 10.5.0 Education not definable by level 11. RESTAURANTS AND HOTELS 11.1 CATERING SERVICES 11.1.1 Restaurants, cafés and the like 11.1.2 Canteens 37 11.2 ACCOMMODATION SERVICES 11.2.0 Accommodation services 12. MISCELLANEOUS GOODS AND SERVICES 12.1 12.1.1 12.1.2 12.1.3 PERSONAL CARE Hairdressing salons and personal grooming establishments Electric appliances for personal care Other appliances, articles and products for personal care 12.2 PROSTITUTION 12.2.0 Prostitution 12.3 PERSONAL EFFECTS N.E.C. 12.3.1 Jewellery, clocks and watches 12.3.2 Other personal effects 12.4 SOCIAL PROTECTION 12.4.0 Social protection 12.5 12.5.1 12.5.2 12.5.3 12.5.4 12.5.5 INSURANCE Life insurance Insurance connected with the dwelling Insurance connected with health Insurance connected with transport Other insurance 12.6 FINANCIAL SERVICES N.E.C. 12.6.1 Financial intermediation services indirectly measured (FISIM) 12.6.2 Other financial services n.e.c. 12.7 OTHER SERVICES N.E.C. 12.7.0 Other services n.e.c. INDIVIDUAL CONSUMPTION EXPENDITURE OF NON-PROFIT INSTITUTIONS SERVING HOUSEHOLDS 13. INDIVIDUAL CONSUMPTION EXPENDITURE OF NON-PROFIT INSTITUTIONS SERVING HOUSEHOLDS (NPISHs) 13.1 HOUSING 13.1.0 Housing 13.2 HEALTH 13.2.1 Pharmaceutical products 38 13.2.2 13.2.3 13.2.4 13.2.5 13.2.6 13.2.7 13.2.8 Other medical products Therapeutic appliances and equipment Out-patient medical services Out-patient dental services Out-patient paramedical services Hospital services Other health services 13.3 RECREATION AND CULTURE 13.3.1 Recreational and sporting services 13.3.2 Cultural services 13.4 13.4.1 13.4.2 13.4.3 13.4.4 13.4.5 13.4.6 EDUCATION Pre-primary and primary education Secondary education Post-secondary non-tertiary education Tertiary education Education not definable by level Other educational services 13.5 SOCIAL PROTECTION 13.5.0 Social protection 13.6 13.6.1 13.6.2 13.6.3 13.6.4 OTHER SERVICES Religion Political parties, labour and professional organisations Environment protection Services n.e.c. INDIVIDUAL CONSUMPTION EXPENDITURE OF GENERAL GOVERNMENT 14. INDIVIDUAL CONSUMPTION EXPENDITURE OF GENERAL GOVERNMENT 14.1 HOUSING 14.1.0 Housing 14.2 14.2.1 14.2.2 14.2.3 14.2.4 14.2.5 14.2.6 14.2.7 14.2.8 HEALTH Pharmaceutical products Other medical products Therapeutic appliances and equipment Out-patient medical services Out-patient dental services Out-patient paramedical services Hospital services Public health services 39 14.3 RECREATION AND CULTURE 14.3.1 Recreational and sporting services 14.3.2 Cultural services 14.4 14.4.1 14.4.2 14.4.3 14.4.4 14.4.5 14.4.6 EDUCATION Pre-primary and primary education Secondary education Post-secondary non-tertiary education Tertiary education Education not definable by level Subsidiary services to education 14.5 SOCIAL PROTECTION 14.5.0 Social protection 40 Annex III Classification of the functions of government (COFOG)21 COFOG is designed for classifying current transactions (such as consumption expenditure, subsidies and current transfers), capital outlays (capital formation and capital transfers) and acquisition of financial assets by general government and its subsectors. Note: “CS” and “IS” denote collective services and individual services respectively. 01 GENERAL PUBLIC SERVICES 01.1 01.2 01.3 01.4 01.5 01.6 01.7 01.8 Executive and legislative organs, financial and fiscal affairs, external affairs (CS) Foreign economic aid (CS) General services (CS) Basic research (CS) R&D General public services (CS) General public services n.e.c. (CS) Public debt transactions (CS) Transfers of a general character between different levels of government (CS) 02 DEFENCE 02.1 02.2 02.3 02.4 02.5 Military defence (CS) Civil defence (CS) Foreign military aid (CS) R&D Defence (CS) Defence n.e.c. (CS) 03 PUBLIC ORDER AND SAFETY 03.1 03.2 03.3 03.4 03.5 03.6 Police services (CS) Fire-protection services (CS) Law courts (CS) Prisons (CS) R&D Public order and safety (CS) Public order and safety n.e.c. (CS) 04 ECONOMIC AFFAIRS 04.1 04.2 04.3 04.4 04.5 General economic, commercial and labour affairs (CS) Agriculture, forestry, fishing and hunting (CS) Fuel and energy (CS) Mining, manufacturing and construction (CS) Transport (CS) 21 Source: Classification of Expenditure According to Purpose. United Nations, New York, 2000. 41 04.6 04.7 04.8 04.9 Communication (CS) Other industries (CS) R&D Economic affairs (CS) Economic affairs n.e.c. (CS) 05 ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION 05.1 05.2 05.3 05.4 05.5 05.6 Waste management Waste water management Pollution abatement Protection of biodiversity and landscape R&D Environment protection Environment protection n.e.c. 06 HOUSING AND COMMUNITY AMENITIES 06.1 06.2 06.3 06.4 06.5 06.6 Housing development (CS) Community development (CS) Water supply (CS) Street lighting (CS) R&D Housing and community amenities (CS) Housing and community amenities n.e.c. (CS) 07 HEALTH 07.1 07.2 07.3 07.4 07.5 07.6 Medical products, appliances and equipment (IS) Out-patient services (IS) Hospital services (IS) Public health services (IS) R&D Health (CS) Health n.e.c. (CS) 08 RECREATION, CULTURE AND RELIGION 08.1 08.2 08.3 08.4 08.5 08.6 Recreational and sporting services (IS) Cultural services (IS) Broadcasting and publishing services (CS) Religious and other community services (CS) R&D Recreation, culture and religion (CS) Recreation, culture and religion n.e.c. (CS) 09 EDUCATION 09.1 09.2 09.3 Pre-primary and primary education (IS) Secondary education (IS) Post-secondary non-tertiary education (IS) 42 09.4 09.5 09.6 09.7 09.8 Tertiary education (IS) Education not definable by level (IS0 Subsidiary services to education (IS) R&D Education (CS) Education n.e.c. (CS) 10 SOCIAL PROTECTION 10.1 10.2 10.3 10.4 10.5 10.6 10.7 10.8 10.9 Sickness and disability (IS) Old age (IS) Survivors (IS) Family and children (IS) Unemployment (IS) Housing (IS) Social exclusion n.e.c. (CS) R&D Social protection (CS) Social protection n.e.c. (CS) 43 Annex IV Link between Indonesia’s Household Expenditure Survey (SUSENAS) and ICP Basic Headings Household Expenditure of Indonesia, 1999 (Billions of Rp) ICP Basic Headings Description Details Basic Headings Percentage of Percentage of GDP GDP 1. HOUSEHOLD CONSUMPTION 758,233.6 68.95 1.1 FOOD,BEVERAGES,TOBACCO 463,255.6 42.12 1.1.1 FOOD 419,412.4 38.14 1.1.1.01 BREAD AND CEREALS Rice (incl. Glutin. Rice; fresh corn w.husk; dry shelled corn) 135,498.5 12.32 119,645.3 10.88 1.1.1.01.1 Unclassified glutinous rice 252.4 0.02 Unclassified fresh corn with husk 367.1 0.03 Unclassified dry shelled corn 1,743.6 0.16 1.1.1.01.2 Detail of 1.1.1.01.2 Detail of 1.1.1.01.2 Detail of 1.1.1.01.2 Flour and other cereals 1.1.1.01.3 Detail of 1.1.1.01.3 Detail of 1.1.1.01.3 Bread 1.1.1.01.4 Detail of 1.1.1.01.4 Other bakery products 1.1.1.01.5 Detail of 1.1.1.01.5 Detail of 1.1.1.01.5 Pasta products 1,468.3 0.13 wheat flour 1,124.2 0.10 rice meal 298.3 0.03 corn meal 45.9 0.00 3,647.8 0.33 ordinary bread 1,284.8 0.12 other bread 2,363.1 0.21 cookies 1,583.0 1,583.0 0.14 0.14 6,745.1 0.61 wheat noodle 183.5 0.02 instant noodle 6,309.2 0.57 44 Detail of 1.1.1.01.5 Detail of 1.1.1.01.5 rice noodle 114.7 0.01 macaroni 137.7 0.01 1.1.1.01.6 Detail of 1.1.1.01.6 Other cereal products 1.1.1.02 MEAT 16,862.8 1.53 1.1.1.02.1 Beef 4,267.3 0.39 413.0 0.04 - - others 45.9 45.9 Unclassified buffalo meat - 0.00 0.00 1.1.1.02.2 Veal 1.1.1.02.3 Pork 940.6 0.09 1.1.1.02.4 Lamb, mutton and goat 298.3 0.03 1.1.1.02.5 Detail of 1.1.1.02.5 Detail of 1.1.1.02.5 Detail of 1.1.1.02.5 Poultry 9,314.6 0.85 1.1.1.02.8 Detail of 1.1.1.02.8 Detail of 1.1.1.02.8 Detail of 1.1.1.02.8 Detail of 1.1.1.02.8 Detail of 1.1.1.02.8 Detail of 1.1.1.02.8 Other meats and edible offal 1.1.1.02.9 Detail of 1.1.1.02.9 Detail of 1.1.1.02.9 Detail of 1.1.1.02.9 Detail of 1.1.1.02.9 Meat preparations broiler meat 6,102.7 0.55 local chicken meat 3,097.2 0.28 other poultry meat 114.7 0.01 1,399.5 0.13 other meats 160.6 0.01 liver 298.3 0.03 innards excluding liver 160.6 0.01 trimming 481.8 0.04 bone (untrimmed) 206.5 0.02 others 91.8 0.01 229.4 0.02 dried meat 68.8 0.01 shredded fried meat 114.7 0.01 canned meat 22.9 0.00 others 22.9 0.00 45 1.1.1.03 FISH 41,090.1 3.74 1.1.1.03.1 Detail of 1.1.1.03.1 Detail of 1.1.1.03.1 Detail of 1.1.1.03.1 Detail of 1.1.1.03.1 Detail of 1.1.1.03.1 Detail of 1.1.1.03.1 Detail of 1.1.1.03.1 Detail of 1.1.1.03.1 Detail of 1.1.1.03.1 Detail of 1.1.1.03.1 Detail of 1.1.1.03.1 Detail of 1.1.1.03.1 Detail of 1.1.1.03.1 Detail of 1.1.1.03.1 Fresh, or frozen fish 28,242.3 2.57 1.1.1.03.3 Detail of 1.1.1.03.3 Detail of 1.1.1.03.3 Detail of 1.1.1.03.3 Detail of 1.1.1.03.3 Detail of 1.1.1.03.3 Fresh, or frozen seafood 1.1.1.03.5 Detail of 1.1.1.03.5 Detail of 1.1.1.03.5 Detail of 1.1.1.03.5 Detail of 1.1.1.03.5 yellow tail/fusiliers 940.6 0.09 eastern tuna 4,175.5 0.38 mackerel 642.4 0.06 travallies 1,651.9 0.15 indian mackerel 4,175.5 0.38 anchovies 1,147.1 0.10 milk fish 2,592.5 0.24 snake head 1,812.5 0.16 mozambique tilapia 2,409.0 0.22 common carp 1,950.1 0.18 catfish 1,009.5 0.09 barramundi 298.3 0.03 marine fish ("baronang") 114.7 0.01 others 5,322.7 0.48 2,730.2 0.25 shrimp 1,789.5 0.16 common squid/cuttle fish 481.8 0.04 mud crab/ swim crab 137.7 0.01 cockle/ snail 183.5 0.02 others Dried, preserved processed fish and seafood 137.7 0.01 indian mackerel 1,124.2 0.10 mackerel 160.6 0.01 eastern tuna/skipjack tuna 825.9 0.08 anchovies 3,143.1 0.29 10,117.7 0.92 46 Detail of 1.1.1.03.5 Detail of 1.1.1.03.5 Detail of 1.1.1.03.5 Detail of 1.1.1.03.5 Detail of 1.1.1.03.5 Detail of 1.1.1.03.5 Detail of 1.1.1.03.5 Detail of 1.1.1.03.5 Detail of 1.1.1.03.5 travallies 688.3 0.06 snake skin gourame 940.6 0.09 milk fishes 275.3 0.03 snake head 321.2 0.03 canned fish 137.7 0.01 others 2,225.4 0.20 shrimps 137.7 0.01 common squids 68.8 0.01 others 68.8 0.01 1.1.1.04 MILK, CHEESE AND EGGS 21,474.2 1.95 1.1.1.04.1 Fresh milk Preserved milk (incl. sweet canned liq. milk; canned and baby powd. milk) 183.5 0.02 1.1.1.04.2 7,708.7 0.70 Unclassified sweet canned liquid milk 2,684.3 0.24 Unclassified canned powder milk 2,684.3 0.24 Unclassified baby powder milk 2,179.5 0.20 1.1.1.04.3 Other milk products 68.8 0.01 1.1.1.04.4 Cheese 45.9 0.00 1.1.1.04.5 Detail of 1.1.1.04.5 Detail of 1.1.1.04.5 Detail of 1.1.1.04.5 Detail of 1.1.1.04.5 Detail of 1.1.1.04.5 Detail of 1.1.1.04.5 Eggs 13,467.2 1.22 1.1.1.05 OILS AND FATS broiler egg 10,117.7 0.92 local chicken egg 1,858.3 0.17 duck egg 986.5 0.09 quail egg 68.8 0.01 other egg 91.8 0.01 (salted) egg 344.1 0.03 22,391.9 2.04 47 1.1.1.05.1 1.1.1.05.5 Detail of 1.1.1.05.5 Detail of 1.1.1.05.5 Detail of 1.1.1.05.5 Detail of 1.1.1.05.5 Detail of 1.1.1.05.5 Detail of 1.1.1.05.5 Butter Margarine and other edible oils and fats - - - margarine 229.4 0.02 coconut oil 7,181.0 0.65 corn oil 68.8 0.01 other frying oil 8,787.0 0.80 coconut 6,056.8 0.55 others 68.8 0.01 22,391.9 2.04 1.1.1.06 FRUIT AND VEGETABLES 63,596.6 5.78 1.1.1.06.1 Detail of 1.1.1.06.1 Detail of 1.1.1.06.1 Detail of 1.1.1.06.1 Detail of 1.1.1.06.1 Detail of 1.1.1.06.1 Detail of 1.1.1.06.1 Detail of 1.1.1.06.1 Detail of 1.1.1.06.1 Detail of 1.1.1.06.1 Detail of 1.1.1.06.1 Detail of 1.1.1.06.1 Detail of 1.1.1.06.1 Detail of 1.1.1.06.1 Detail of 1.1.1.06.1 Detail of 1.1.1.06.1 Detail of 1.1.1.06.1 Detail of Fresh fruit 15,233.8 1.39 orange 2,431.9 0.22 mango 298.3 0.03 apple 642.4 0.06 avocado 229.4 0.02 rambutan 2,156.6 0.20 lanzon 68.8 0.01 durian 298.3 0.03 zalacca 848.9 0.08 pineapple 298.3 0.03 banana ("ambon") 1,927.2 0.18 banana ("raja") 917.7 0.08 other banana 2,409.0 0.22 papaya 1,422.4 0.13 rose apple 137.7 0.01 sapodilla 91.8 0.01 carambola spanish plum 45.9 0.00 48 1.1.1.06.1 Detail of 1.1.1.06.1 Detail of 1.1.1.06.1 Detail of 1.1.1.06.1 Detail of 1.1.1.06.1 Detail of 1.1.1.06.1 1.1.1.06.2 Detail of 1.1.1.06.2 Detail of 1.1.1.06.2 Detail of 1.1.1.06.2 Detail of 1.1.1.06.2 Detail of 1.1.1.06.2 Detail of 1.1.1.06.2 1.1.1.06.3 1.1.1.06.4 Detail of 1.1.1.06.4 Detail of 1.1.1.06.4 Detail of 1.1.1.06.4 Detail of 1.1.1.06.4 Detail of 1.1.1.06.4 Detail of 1.1.1.06.4 Detail of 1.1.1.06.4 Detail of 1.1.1.06.4 Detail of 1.1.1.06.4 Detail of 1.1.1.06.4 Detail of 1.1.1.06.4 Detail of 1.1.1.06.4 Detail of 91.8 0.01 water melon 275.3 0.03 melon 68.8 0.01 jackfruit 252.4 0.02 tomato 160.6 0.01 others 160.6 0.01 Dried fruit and nuts 2,454.8 0.22 peanuts without shell 917.7 0.08 peanuts with shell 367.1 0.03 soybean 114.7 0.01 mungbean 734.2 0.07 cashew nut 45.9 0.00 other bean Frozen and preserved fruit and fruit juices 275.3 0.03 - - Fresh vegetables 45,885.0 4.17 spinach 2,202.5 0.20 swamp cabbage 2,409.0 0.22 cabbage 1,124.2 0.10 chinese cabbage 367.1 0.03 darker colored mustard greens 550.6 0.05 beans 665.3 0.06 string bean 2,730.2 0.25 tomato 1,743.6 0.16 carrot 504.7 0.05 cucumber 757.1 0.07 cassava leaf 1,766.6 0.16 aubergine bean sprout 1,170.1 0.11 49 1.1.1.06.4 Detail of 1.1.1.06.4 Detail of 1.1.1.06.4 Detail of 1.1.1.06.4 Detail of 1.1.1.06.4 Detail of 1.1.1.06.4 Detail of 1.1.1.06.4 Detail of 1.1.1.06.4 Detail of 1.1.1.06.4 Detail of 1.1.1.06.4 Detail of 1.1.1.06.4 Detail of 1.1.1.06.4 Detail of 1.1.1.06.4 Detail of 1.1.1.06.4 Detail of 1.1.1.06.4 Detail of 1.1.1.06.4 711.2 0.06 squash 390.0 0.04 unripe corn 160.6 0.01 soup/ stir-fried vegetables 1,284.8 0.12 sour vegetable soup 1,468.3 0.13 young jackfruit 596.5 0.05 unripe papaya 390.0 0.04 mushroom 114.7 0.01 petai beans 183.5 0.02 stink beans 413.0 0.04 shallot 6,951.6 0.63 garlic 2,409.0 0.22 chillies 7,112.2 0.65 green chilli 757.1 0.07 cayenne pepper 6,079.8 0.55 others 871.8 0.08 1.1.1.06.8 Detail of 1.1.1.06.8 Dried, frozen, preserved vegetables 1.1.1.07 POTATOES AND TUBERS 5,735.6 0.52 1.1.1.07.1 Detail of 1.1.1.07.1 Detail of 1.1.1.07.1 Detail of 1.1.1.07.1 Detail of 1.1.1.07.1 Detail of 1.1.1.07.1 Detail of 1.1.1.07.1 Detail of 1.1.1.07.1 Potatoes and other tubers 5,735.6 0.52 canned vegetable 22.9 22.9 0.00 0.00 potatoes 1,422.4 0.13 cassava 2,454.9 0.22 sweet potato 894.8 0.08 sago flour 275.3 0.03 taro 160.6 0.01 dried cassava 114.7 0.01 flour dried cassava 229.4 0.02 50 Detail of 1.1.1.07.1 Detail of 1.1.1.07.1 cassava flour 91.8 0.01 others 91.8 0.01 1.1.1.07.2 Potato products - 1.1.1.08 SUGAR 14,362.0 1.31 1.1.1.08.1 Detail of 1.1.1.08.1 Detail of 1.1.1.08.1 Raw and refined sugar 14,362.0 1.31 1.1.1.09 COFFEE, TEA AND COCOA 7,892.2 0.72 1.1.1.09.1 Detail of 1.1.1.09.1 Coffee 5,230.9 0.48 1.1.1.09.2 Tea 2,546.6 0.23 1.1.1.09.3 Detail of 1.1.1.09.3 Detail of 1.1.1.09.3 Cocoa 114.7 0.01 1.1.1.10 OTHER FOODS 90,508.4 8.23 1.1.1.10.1 Detail of 1.1.1.10.1 Detail of 1.1.1.10.1 Jams, jellies, honey and syrups 665.4 0.06 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 - - cane sugar/ granulate sugar 13,100.2 1.19 brown sugar/ palm sugar 1,261.8 0.11 powdered/ bean coffee 5,230.9 0.48 instant cocoa 68.8 0.01 powdered cocoa 45.9 0.00 syrup 504.7 0.05 others beverage stuff Salt, spices, condiments and food n.e.c 160.6 0.01 salt 1,560.1 0.14 monosodium glutamate 1,950.1 0.18 candle nut 1,101.2 0.10 corriander 780.0 0.07 pepper 1,101.2 0.10 tamarind 780.0 0.07 86,975.2 7.91 51 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 nutmeg 45.9 0.00 clove 22.9 0.00 soya sauce 1,812.5 0.16 chille sauce/ tomato sauce 252.4 0.02 spice 275.3 0.03 other spice 986.5 0.09 fish paste 1,445.4 0.13 tofu, soybean curd 6,401.0 0.58 fermented soybean cake 8,098.7 0.74 fermented soybean paste 68.8 0.01 fermented soya cake 160.6 0.01 others food of bean 22.9 0.00 crisps 1,904.2 0.17 fried crisps 481.8 0.04 sea weed 137.7 0.01 porridge in package 206.5 0.02 others 68.8 0.01 boil or steam cake 3,739.6 0.34 fried food 6,079.8 0.55 porridge of mungbean 894.8 0.08 kind of salad with peanut sauce a plate of rice accompanied by a mixture of dishes 3,120.2 0.28 15,073.2 1.37 fried rice 1,376.6 0.13 rice ("steamed") rice steamed in a banana leaf or coconut leaf 1,101.2 0.10 1,789.5 0.16 soup 2,569.6 0.23 roastedmeat on skewer 1,238.9 0.11 52 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 Detail of 1.1.1.10.5 1.1.1.10.6 Detail of 1.1.1.10.6 Detail of 1.1.1.10.6 noodle (with meat ball/ boiled/ fried) 10,002.9 0.91 instant noodle ("mixed") 458.9 0.04 snack for children 3,579.0 0.33 fish (fried, roasted,etc) 894.8 0.08 chicken/ meat (fried, roasted, etc) 1,124.2 0.10 other prepared food Chocolate, confectionery and ice cream 4,267.3 0.39 ice cream 413.0 0.04 other ice 2,454.9 0.22 2,867.8 0.26 1.1.2 NON-ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES 4,267.3 0.39 1.1.2.01.1 Detail of 1.1.2.01.1 Mineral water 367.1 0.03 1.1.2.01.2 Detail of 1.1.2.01.2 Detail of 1.1.2.01.2 Detail of 1.1.2.01.2 Detail of 1.1.2.01.2 Detail of 1.1.2.01.2 Soft drinks 1.1.3 ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES 390.0 0.04 1.1.3.01.1 Spirits and liqueurs - - 1.1.3.01.3 Beer 114.7 0.01 1.1.3.01.5 Detail of 1.1.3.01.5 Detail of 1.1.3.01.5 Wine and other alcoholic beverages 275.3 0.03 1.1.4 TOBACCO water in container 367.1 0.03 3,900.2 0.35 tea in container 252.4 0.02 essence of fruit in container 45.9 0.00 health drink 114.7 0.01 CO2 drink 344.1 0.03 other drinks (coffee, milk, etc) 3,143.1 0.29 wine 45.9 0.00 other alcoholic beverage 229.4 0.02 39,185.8 3.56 53 1.1.4.01.1 Cigarettes (incl. clove filter and nonfilter) 37,075.1 3.37 Unclassified clove filter cigarettes 24,823.8 2.26 Unclassified clove non filter cigarettes 9,475.3 0.86 1.1.4.02.1 Detail of 1.1.4.02.1 Detail of 1.1.4.02.1 Detail of 1.1.4.02.1 Other tobacco products 1.2 CLOTHING AND FOOTWARE 31,349.3 2.85 1.2.1 CLOTHING 24,685.8 2.24 1.2.1.01.1 Men's clothing 7,879.3 0.72 1.2.1.01.2 Ladies' clothing 8,498.8 0.77 1.2.1.01.5 Clothing materials and accessories 1,140.5 0.10 1.2.1.01.6 Children's and Infants' clothing Repair and maintenance of clothing (incl. clothes maint. material) 6,269.9 0.57 897.4 0.08 1.2.1.02.1 2,110.7 0.19 tobacco 1,284.8 0.12 betel/ areca nut 435.9 0.04 others 390.0 0.04 Unclassified clothes maintenance material 463.1 0.04 1.2.2 FOOTWEAR 6,663.5 0.61 1.2.2.01.1 Men's footwear 2,634.1 0.24 1.2.2.01.2 Ladies' footwear 2,228.9 0.20 1.2.2.01.3 Children's and Infants' footwear 1,800.5 0.16 1.2.2.02.1 Repairs to footwear - - 1.3 RENTS, FUEL AND POWER 119,630.8 10.88 81,021.8 7.37 78,034.5 7.10 1.3.1 1.3.1.01.0 Detail of 1.3.1.01.0 GROSS RENTS AND WATER CHARGES Gross rents, incl. Repair and maintenance imputed house rent 65,737.9 5.98 54 Detail of 1.3.1.01.0 Detail of 1.3.1.01.0 Detail of 1.3.1.01.0 Detail of 1.3.1.01.0 house contract 3,902.0 0.35 house rent 3,392.6 0.31 lease purchase, official rent and etc 2,587.8 0.24 house maintenance cost 2,414.2 0.22 1.3.1.02.1 Water charges 2,987.3 0.27 1.3.2 FUEL AND POWER 38,609.0 3.51 1.3.2.01.1 Electricity 13,454.4 1.22 1.3.2.02.0 Gas 75.3 0.01 1.3.2.03.1 Detail of 1.3.2.03.1 Detail of 1.3.2.03.1 Detail of 1.3.2.03.1 Detail of 1.3.2.03.1 Liquid fuels for heating and lighting 11,549.7 1.05 1.3.2.04.1 Detail of 1.3.2.04.1 Detail of 1.3.2.04.2 Detail of 1.3.2.04.3 Coal, firewood and other fuels kerosene 9,205.0 0.84 liquified pressured gas fuel (gasoline, diesel oil, kerosene) for generator 2,142.1 0.19 167.9 0.02 lubricant for generator 34.7 0.00 13,529.6 1.23 charcoal 92.6 0.01 firewood and other fuel others (battery, accu, matches, mosquito repellent, etc) 7,960.3 0.72 5,476.7 0.50 1.4 FURNITURE, HOUSEHOLD EQUIPMENT AND OPERATION 39,442.7 3.59 1.4.1 FURNITURE, FLOOR COVERINGS, INCL. REPAIRS 2,668.9 0.24 1.4.1.01.1 Furniture and fixtures 2,466.3 0.22 1.4.1.01.2 Floor coverings Repairs to furniture and floor coverings - - 202.6 0.02 665.8 0.06 665.8 0.06 1.4.1.02.1 1.4.2 1.4.2.01.1 Detail of HOUSEHOLD TEXTILES, INCL. REPAIRS Household textiles an other furnishings household furnishings - 55 1.4.2.01.1 Detail of 1.4.2.01.1 1.4.2.01.2 decoration stuff Repairs to household textiles 1.4.3 MAJOR HOUSEHOLD APPLIANCES, INCL. REPAIRS 1.4.3.01.1 532.6 0.05 133.2 0.01 1,314.1 0.12 - - - 1.4.3.01.2 Refrigerators, freezers Washing machine, driers, dishwashers - - - 1.4.3.01.3 Cooking appliances - - - 1.4.3.01.4 Heaters and air-conditioners - - - 1.4.3.01.5 Vacuum cleaners, polishers etc - - - 1.4.3.01.6 Other major household appliances Repairs to major household appliances 1,314.1 0.12 - - 2,964.1 0.27 2,964.1 0.27 1.4.3.02.1 1.4.4 1.4.4.01.0 Detail of 1.4.4.01.0 Detail of 1.4.4.01.0 1.4.4.02.1 1.4.5 1.4.5.01.1 Detail of 1.4.5.01.1 Detail of 1.4.5.01.1 Detail of 1.4.5.01.1 Detail of 1.4.5.01.1 Detail of 1.4.5.01.1 - GLASSWARE, TABLEWARE AND UTENSILS, INCL. REPAIRS Glassware, tableware and household utensils household utensils 851.0 kitchen utensils 2,113.1 Repairs to glassware, tableware and household utensils - HOUSEHOLD OPERATION Household cleaning and maintenance products 0.19 - - 27,070.9 2.46 27,070.9 2.46 laundry soap 8,961.9 0.81 toilet soap, tooth paste and shampo 10,826.1 0.98 cosmetic articles 4,990.4 0.45 care of skin, face, hair, etc 1,870.0 0.17 1.4.5.02.0 others (tissue, champor, etc) 422.6 Paper products and other non-durable household goods Laundry and other household services - 1.4.6 DOMESTIC SERVICES 1.4.5.01.2 0.08 0.04 - - - - 56 1.4.6.01.1 Detail of 1.4.6.01.1 Detail of 1.4.6.01.1 1.5 1.5.1 Domestic services 4,758.9 0.43 4,758.9 0.43 domestic servant & driver 4,000.4 0.36 other servants 758.4 0.07 MEDICAL CARE AND HEALTH SERVICES MEDICAL CARE AND PHARMACEUTICAL PRODUCTS 13,315.4 1.21 2,726.8 0.25 2,726.8 0.25 1.5.1.01.1 Detail of 1.5.1.01.1 Detail of 1.5.1.01.1 Drugs and medical preparations take medicine with recipe 978.4 self treatment/ take medicine without recipe 1,748.4 0.09 1.5.1.02.1 Other medical supplies - 0.16 - 1.5.2.00.0 THERAPEUTIC APPLIANCES AND EQUIPMENT Therapeutic appliances and equipment 1.5.3 MEDICAL SERVICES OUTSIDE HOSPITALS 3,485.1 0.32 1.5.3.03.1 Services of dentists - - 1.5.3.04.2 Services of nurses 926.3 0.08 1.5.3.07.0 Services of physicians 1,563.1 0.14 1.5.3.08.0 Detail of 1.5.3.08.0 Detail of 1.5.3.08.0 Detail of 1.5.3.08.0 Detail of 1.5.3.08.0 Detail of 1.5.3.08.0 Other medical services and analyses 995.8 0.09 1.5.4 HOSPITAL CARE Hospital care (incl. pregnancy exam up to take care of health) 1.5.2 1.5.4.00.0 Detail of 1.5.4.00.0 - - - - public health center 428.4 0.04 subsidiary public health center 173.7 0.02 clinics 115.8 0.01 weighting post/ cadre 23.2 0.00 traditional healer practitioner 254.7 0.02 public hospital 1,563.1 7,103.5 0.65 7,103.5 0.65 0.14 57 Detail of 1.5.4.00.0 private hospital 1,939.4 0.18 Unclassified pregnancy examination 243.2 0.02 Unclassified childbird cost 1,314.2 0.12 Unclassified under fives immunization cost 92.6 0.01 Unclassified contraception cost 891.6 0.08 Unclassified take care of health (vitamin, etc) 1,059.4 0.10 1.6 TRANSPORT AND COMMUNICATION 44,849.9 4.08 1.6.1 PERSONAL TRANSPORT EQUIPMENT 9,239.8 0.84 1.6.1.01.1 Passenger vehicles 9,239.8 0.84 1.6.1.02.1 Motor cycles and bicycles - - 1.6.2 OPERATION OF TRANSPORT EQUIPMENT 12,713.4 1.16 1.6.2.01.1 Tires, parts and accessories - - 1.6.2.01.2 Maintenance and repair services 1,829.4 0.17 1.6.2.02.1 Detail of 1.6.2.02.1 Detail of 1.6.2.02.1 Detail of 1.6.2.02.1 Motor fuels and oils 10,884.0 0.99 gasoline 8,383.0 0.76 diesel oil 237.4 0.02 2,263.6 0.21 1.6.2.03.1 lubricant Other expenses related to personal transport 1.6.3 PURCHASED TRANSPORT SERVICES - - 15,341.8 1.40 15,341.8 1.40 - - 1.6.3.02.2 Local transport Long-distance transport by road and rail Long-distance transport by air and sea - - 1.6.3.03.1 Other purchased transport services - - 1.6.4 COMMUNICATION 7,555.0 0.69 1.6.3.01.1 1.6.3.02.1 58 1.6.4.01.1 1.6.4.02.1 Postal services Telephone, telegraph and telex services 1.7 RECREATION, ENTERTAINMENT AND EDUCATION 22,977.9 2.09 1.7.1 RECREATIONAL EQUIPMENT AND ACCESSORIES 2,269.5 0.21 1.7.1.01.0 Radio, TV, and audio equipment 1,823.6 0.17 1.7.1.02.1 Photographic equipment - - 1.7.1.02.2 Other durable recreational goods 249.0 0.02 1.7.1.03.0 Other recreational goods Parts and repairs to recreational goods 196.9 0.02 - - 683.1 0.06 - - 683.1 0.06 5,540.4 0.50 5,540.4 0.50 1.7.1.04.1 1.7.2 1.7.2.01.1 1.7.2.02.0 1.7.3 1.7.3.01.0 Detail of 1.7.3.01.0 Detail of 1.7.3.01.0 Detail of 1.7.3.01.0 ENTERTAINMENT, RECREATIONAL AND CULTURAL SERVICES Cinemas, sport stadiums, museums, zoos etc Recreational and sporting activities, rental and subscription BOOKS, NEWSPAPERS AND OTHER PRINTED MATTER Books, newspapers and other printed matter 521.0 0.05 7,034.0 0.64 text books 2,396.8 0.22 stationery news papers, magazines, books & stationeries 1,574.7 0.14 1,568.9 0.14 1.7.4 EDUCATION SERVICES 14,484.9 1.32 1.7.4.00.0 Detail of 1.7.4.00.0 Detail of 1.7.4.00.0 Detail of 1.7.4.00.0 Detail of 1.7.4.00.0 Education Services 14,484.9 1.32 entrance fee 2,107.3 0.19 school fee 10,716.1 0.97 other school contribution 1,279.4 0.12 non formal education cost 382.1 0.03 59 1.8 MISCELLANEOUS GOODS AND SERVICES 23,412.1 2.13 - - 1.8.1.01.1 PERSONAL CARE AND EFFECTS Services of hairdressers and beauty shops - - 1.8.1.02.0 Toilet articles - - 1.8.1 GOODS NOT ELSEWHERE CLASSIFIED 5,054.1 Jewellry, watches and their repair (incl. dom. animal & plant; other dur. Goods) 3,357.8 watch, clock, camera, glasses & repair 266.3 0.02 jewelry & repair 1,777.3 0.16 Unclassified domestic animal & plant 845.2 0.08 Unclassified other durable goods 468.9 0.04 1.8.2 1.8.2.01.1 Detail of 1.8.2.01.0 Detail of 1.8.2.01.1 0.46 0.31 1.8.2.02.0 Detail of 1.8.2.02.0 Detail of 1.8.2.02.0 Detail of 1.8.2.02.0 Personal accessories n.e.c head gear for men, women & children 1,696.3 0.15 590.5 0.05 others (towel, belt, shoe polish, etc) 752.6 0.07 toys & repaire, imitation jewelry 353.1 0.03 1.8.2.03.1 Writing and drawing supplies - - 1.8.3 RESTAURANTS AND HOTELS - - 1.8.3.01.0 Restaurants, cafes and staff canteens - - 1.8.3.02.1 Hotels and other loging places - - 1.8.4 WELFARE SERVICES 11,549.7 1.05 1.8.4.00.0 Detail of 1.8.4.00.0 Detail of 1.8.4.00.0 Detail of 1.8.4.00.0 Detail of 1.8.4.00.0 Detail of Welfare services 11,549.7 1.05 wedding 2,061.0 0.19 circumcision, birthday 636.8 0.06 religious festival 5,592.5 0.51 pilgrimage cost traditional ceremony 1,881.5 0.17 60 1.8.4.00.0 Detail of 1.8.4.00.0 862.6 0.08 funeral 515.3 0.05 1.8.5 FINANCIAL SERVICES 642.6 0.06 1.8.5.01.1 Charges for finansial services n.e.c 642.6 0.06 1.8.6 SERVICES N.E.C 6,165.6 0.56 1.8.6.01.1 Detail of 1.8.6.01.1 Detail of 1.8.6.01.1 Detail of 1.8.6.01.1 Detail of 1.8.6.01.1 Detail of 1.8.6.01.1 Fee for other services n.e.c 6,165.6 0.56 maintenance/ service of generator 17.4 0.00 building & land tax 1,846.8 0.17 tax on tv, etc motor vehicle & non motor vehicle tax 972.6 0.09 2,147.8 0.20 other contributions 1,181.0 0.11 1.9 NET PURCHASES ABROAD BY RESIDENTS - - 1.9.1.01.1 Net purchases abroad by residents - - 61