Energy Efficient Buildings Psychrometrics Introduction The air around us is mixture of dry air and water vapor, and can be modeled as a mixture of these two ideal gasses. The study of moist air is called psychrometry. The properties of moist air at a given pressure are displayed on a psychrometric chart. The psychrometric chart contains a rich density of information, and learning to visualize air heating and cooling properties as they occur on the psychrometric chart is very useful. The two cardinal dimensions on the psychrometric chart are dry bulb temperature, T (F), on the horizontal axis and specific humidity, w (lbw/lba), on the vertical axis. Extensive properties, such as enthalpy and volume are expressed in terms of pounds of dry air. The enthalpy of air increases with both temperature and humidity. The relative humidity of air is the faction of water vapor the air can hold at a given temperature. The relative humidity of air is bounded at 100% along the left side of the psychrometric chart. The specific volume of air is the reciprocal of the density, and increases with temperature. Any two independent properties fix the state. 1 For many years, the most common method for measuring humidity was by using a “sling psychrometer”. A sling psychrometer has two thermometers attached to a handle so that the thermometers can rotate around the handle. The bulb of one thermometer is wrapped in wet cloth and is called the wet bulb. The other bulb is called the dry bulb. The temperature of the web bulb thermometer will decrease due to evaporation as the thermometers are swung about. The quantity of evaporation depends on the humidity of the air; thus the difference between wet and dry bulb temperatures is a measure of ambient humidity. Wet Dry Conceptually, the wet-bulb temperature is the same as the adiabatic saturation temperature, which is the exit temperature of air traveling over water through an infinitely long chamber. Because the evaporation process occurs at constant enthalpy, lines of constant enthalpy on the psychrometric chart are essentially parallel to lines of constant wet-bulb temperature. Twb Tadiabatic saturation Adiab Sat Chamber T1 Tad,sat<T1 Constant h Tw=C Cooling The total heat removed from air during a cooling process can be calculated from mass and energy balances on a system in which air enters and leaves a cooling chamber and heat is removed from the chamber. Qtot ma1 ma2 Conservation of mass on a control volume states that the sum of all the mass flows in minus the sum of all mass flows out equals the change in mass stored in the system. At 2 steady state conditions, no mass is accumulated in the cooling chamber. Thus, for this system, conservation of mass gives: Min - Mout = Mstored ma1 – ma2 = 0 ma1 = ma2 where ma1 and ma2 are the mass flow rates of moist air entering and leaving the chamber. Conservation of energy on a control volume states that the sum of all energy flows in minus the sum of all energy flows out equals the change in energy stored in the system. At steady state conditions, no energy is accumulated in the cooling chamber. The energy of non-reacting mass flows is the sum of the kinetic, potential and internal flow energies. In most cooling applications, the change in velocity (V) and elevation (z) between the entrance and outlet of the chamber are negligible. Thus, for this system, conservation of energy gives: Ein - Eout = Estored ma1 (V12/2 + gz1 + h1) – ma2 (V22/2 + gz2 + h2) – Qtot = 0 Qtot = ma1 (h1 – h2) where Qtot is the total heat removed from the moist air and h1 and h2 are the enthalpies of moist air entering and leaving the chamber. Sensible Cooling When warm air is cooled as it passes over a cooling coil, the temperature begins to decrease. As the temperature decreases, the air can hold less moisture before becoming 100% saturated. If the air leaves the coil before becoming saturated, then no condensation occurs. On a psychrometric chart, the exiting air is at a lower temperature than the incoming air, while the humidity ratio remains constant since no moisture is condensed from the air. Reducing the temperature of air without changing the quantity of water in the air is called sensible cooling, Qsen, and is shown schematically below. Qtot 2 ma1 1 Δω 0 ma2 3 Example 20,000 cfm of air is sensibly cooled from a temperature of 90 F and a relative humidity of 60% to a temperature of 75 F. Determine the total heat removed from air. V 1 20,000 cfm from T = 90°F, φ = 60% to T = 75°F ft 3 Btu lbw v 14.26 w 1 .01827 1 lba lba lba 1: T 90F φ 60% h1 41.74 2: T 75F w 1 w 2 h2 38.02 Btu lba M-balance: a1 m a2 m a1 and m V 1 v1 Note V 1 V 2 because v 1 v 2 E-balance: a1 h1 Q tot m a2 h2 0 (SS) m ft 3 V 1 lba min Btu a1 h1 h2 1 h1 h2 20,000 Q tot m 41.74 38.02 60 3 v1 hr 14.26 ft lba min Btu 313,705 hr Sensible cooling can also be calculated from the change in air temperature, rather than the change in air enthalpy. Specific heat at constant pressure is defined as: dh cp dT p Thus the change in enthalpy is then given by the following differential equation. dh c dT p Most cooling operations occur at constant pressure. At atmospheric conditions, the specific heat of water is about 1.0 Btu/lb-F and the specific heat of dry air is about 0.24 Btu/lb-F. In sensible cooling applications, the quantity of water in the air does not change. Further, the change in temperature during the cooling process is small enough that the specific heats are nearly constant. Thus, the specific heat of moist air can be 4 assumed to be constant, and can be taken outside the integral. Thus, in the case of sensible cooling, the change in enthalpy is: h2 h1 cp T2 T1 The specific heat, cp, of moist air is approximately 0.26 Btu/lb-F. The density, p, of moist air is approximately 0.075 lb/ft3. Thus, the product of the density and specific heat of moist air, pcp, is approximately 0.018 Btu/ft3-F. Using this approximation, sensible cooling, Qsen, in which the quantity of water in the air is unchanged, can be calculated from the volume flow rate of air and the change in air temperature. Qsen = V1 pcp (T1 – T2) Example 20,000 cfm of air is sensibly cooled from a temperature of 90 F and a relative humidity of 60% to a temperature of 75 F. Determine the sensible cooling using the approximation that pcp = 0.018 Btu/ft3-F. Also determine the error between the enthalpy-based calculation and this approximate method. V a h1 h2 m c p T1 T2 c p T1 T2 V ρcp T1 T2 Q sen m v 3 ft min Btu Btu 20,000 .018 3 90 75 F 324,000 60 hr ft F hr min The error between the exact and approximate methods 324,000 313,705 3.3% 313,705 Sensible and Latent Cooling The dew point temperature Tdewpoint is the temperature when air is 100% saturated and water begins to condense out of the air. When air is cooled below the dew point temperature, Tdewpoint, condensation occurs and moisture leaves the air stream. The exiting air stream is at a lower temperature and humidity ratio than the incoming air stream. This process is shown in the figure below. The cooling to reduce the temperature of the air is called sensible cooling. The cooling to condense water from the air is called latent cooling. Thus, this process includes both sensible and latent cooling. The total cooling, Qtot, is the sum of the latent cooling, Qlat, and the sensible cooling, Qsen. 5 Q tot h1 h2' 1 2 h2 1 2 Q lat 2p T2 Tdp T2 T1 Q sen T1 Qtot = ma (h1 – h2) = ma (h1 – h2p) + ma (h2p – h2) = Qlat + Qsen The water removed from the air is: mw = ma (w1 – w2) Example Determine the total, sensible and latent cooling required to cool 20,000 cfm of air from a temperature of 90 F and a relative humidity of 60% to a temperature of 55 F and 100% relative humidity. Also determine the mass flow rate of water removed from the air. Q tot h1 h2' 1 h2 2 Q lat 2p T2 Q sen T1 Cooling 20,000cfm from 90F, φ 60% to 55F, φ 100% ft 3 Btu lbw v 14.26 w 1 .01827 1 lba lba lba 1: T1 90F φ1 60% h1 41.74 Btu lbw w 2 .009186 lba lba 2: T2 55F φ2 100% h2 23.2 6 a1 h1 Q tot m ah2 0 (SS) m V a h1 h2 1 h1 h2 Q tot m v1 20,000 60 ft3 lba min Btu kBtu Q tot 41.74 23.20 1,560 3 14.26 lba hr min ft hr V a h1 h2p 1 h1 h2p' Q lat m v1 20,000 60 ft3 lba min Btu kBtu Q lat 41.74 31.74 841.3 3 14.26 lba hr min ft hr V a h2p h2 1 h2p h2' Q sen m v1 20,000 60 ft3 lba min Btu kBtu Q sen 31.74 23 . 20 719.2 3 14.26 lba hr min ft hr w m a w 1 w 2 m V 1 w 1 w 2 20,000 v1 14.26 ft 3 lba lbw min lbw .01827 .009186 60 764.1 3 lba hr hr min ft Latent cooling can also be calculated from the volume flow rate of air, V, and the enthalpy of evaporation of water. The density, p, of moist air is approximately 0.075 lb/ft3. The enthalpy of evaporation (condensation) of water, hfg, at atmospheric pressure is approximately 1,075 Btu/lbw. Using these approximations, latent cooling, Qlat, can be calculated as: Qlat = V p (w1-w2) hfg Example Determine the latent cooling using the enthalpy of evaporation of water and an approximate value of air density required to cool 20,000 cfm of air from a temperature of 90 F and a relative humidity of 60% to a temperature of 55 F and 100% relative humidity. Also determine the error between the enthalpy-based calculation and this approximate method. 7 Q lat V ρ w 1 w 2 h fg ft 3 min lba lbw Btu 20,000 60 .075 3 .01827 .009186 1,075 hr ft lba lbw min kBtu 878.8 hr Error 878.8 841.3 4.4% 841.3 Cooling Done by Cooling Coil In HVAC systems, air is typically cooled by passing it over a cooling coil. Most cooling coils are finned-tube heat exchangers in which cool water or refrigerant flows through tubes, and the tubes have external fins to increase heat transfer area. If the air is cooled below the dewpoint temperature, water will condense and must be drained from the bottom of the cooling coil. A schematic of a cooling coil is shown below. (1) Warm wet air (2) Cool dry air In this situation, Qc is that part of the total heat cooling (Qtot) that leaves with coolant in the cooling coil. Qw is that part of the total cooling (Qtot) that leaves with condensate draining from the bottom of the cooling coil. Thus, Qtot = Qc + Qw The energy carried away by the condensing water is equal to product of the the mass flow rate of the condensing water, mw, and the enthalpy of the saturated water, hw. The enthalpy of the saturated water is the enthalpy or air at 100% RH at the temperature of the cooling coil. The process is shown schematically below. 8 Qc ma2 mω 2 ma1 mω1 1 2 mω T2 Tdp T1 The process can be modeled using mass balances on the air and water, and an energy balance on the entire process. The steady state mass and energy balances are shown below. M-balance (air): a1 m a2 m M-balance (water): w1 m w2 m w m w m w1 m w2 m a1 w 1 m a2 w 2 m a w 1 w 2 m E-balance: a1h1 Q c m ah2 m whw 0 (SS) m a h1 h2 m whw Q c m Example Determine the energy removed by the cooling coil and condensate when cooling 20,000 cfm of air from a temperature of 90 F and a relative humidity of 60% to a temperature of 55 F and 100% relative humidity. The fluid inside the cooling coil is at 55 F. Q tot 1 2 T2 Q sen Q lat T1 Cooling 20,000cfm from 90F, φ 60% to 55F, φ 100% 9 ft 3 Btu lbw v 14.26 w 1 .01827 1 lba lba lba 1: T1 90F φ1 60% h1 41.74 2: T2 55F φ2 100% h2 23.2 Btu lbw w 2 .009186 lba lba Btu w: hw Tc 55 F, φ2 100% 23.2 lba Mass balance: w m a w 1 w 2 m V 1 w 1 w 2 20,000 v1 14.26 ft 3 lba lbw min lbw .0183 .0092 60 764.1 3 lba hr hr min ft Energy balance: a h1 h2 m whw Q c m 20,000 60 ft 3 lba min Btu lbw Btu Q c 41.74 23.2 764.1 23.2 3 14.26 lba hr lbw min ft hr kBtu kBtu kBtu Q c 1,560 - 17.73 1,543 hr hr hr Note that the energy carried away by the condensate (17.73 kBtu/hr) is much less than the total latent cooling (841.3 kBtu/hr). Most of the latent cooling is done by the cooling coil. Because the energy removed by the condensate is typically very small compared to the energy removed by the cooling coil, the energy transferred to the cooling coil, Qc, is frequently approximated as the total cooling, Qtot. Bypass Factor In most cooling applications, the air leaving the cooling coil is not entirely saturated since some air does not come in contact with the cooling coil. The fraction of air that misses the coil is called the bypass factor, BF. The bypass factor can be determined from the temperature of water supplied to the cooling coil and from the states of incoming and exiting air. For example, consider the cooling process shown below. 10 Tcooling coil 1 1 2 3 2 Tcc T2 T1 The bypass factor, BF, can be determined from the temperatures of water supplied to the cooling coil and the incoming and exiting air temperatures as: BF T2 Tcc T1 Tcc Example Air enters a cooling coil at 90F , 60% , while the coil is at 55°F and the BF = 0.2. What is the leaving air temperature? 1 3 2 Tcc=55 T2=62 BF T1=90 T2 Tcc T1 Tcc T2 BFT1 Tcc Tcc .290 55 55 62F Adiabatic Mixing Air streams at different conditions are frequently mixed together. The condition of the exiting air stream can be determined from the conditions of incoming streams by applying mass and energy balances to the system. In most cases, heat loss from the system is negligible and the system can be modeled at adiabatic. On a psychrometric chart, the condition of the exiting air stream must be on the line connecting the incoming air streams. The distance along that line is determined by the ratio of the mass flow rates of the incoming streams. 11 1 1 3 3 2 2 Air Mass Balance 1 m 2 m 3 m V 1 /v 1 V 2 /v 2 V 3 /v 3 Total Energy Balance: 1h 1 m 2h 2 m 3h 3 m h m 2h 2 m h3 1 1 1 m 2 m V h V 2h2 if ρ 1 ρ 2 h3 1 V 1 V 2 Sensible Energy Balance: 1 c p T1 m 2 c p T2 m 3 c p T3 m 1 T1 m 2 T2 m 1 m 2 m V T V 2 T2 if ρ1 ρ 2 T3 1 1 V 1 V 2 T3 Sensible Heat Ratio, Latent Cooling and Air Flow Rate The sensible heat ratio, SHR, is the ratio of sensible cooling to total cooling. SHR Q sen Q sen . Q tot Q sen Q lat On a psychrometric chart, the total cooling line can be decomposed into sensible and latent cooling lines, as shown below. 12 1 2 A Example Determine the sensible heat ratio for cooling 20,000 cfm of air from a temperature of 90 F and a relative humidity of 60% to a temperature of 55 F and 100% relative humidity. a h1 hA m a h A h2 Q tot ma h1 h2 m Q lat Q sen SHR h h2 h A h2 31.74 23.2 Q sen m a A 46% a h1 h2 h1 h2 41.74 23.2 Q tot m For a given cooling coil, SHR varies with the volume of air flowing across it, V cc . As V cc increases, the total cooling capacity, Q tot , increases. However, the increased volume flow rate of air also increases the quantity of moist air that does not come in contact with the cooling coil; which increases the bypass factor, BF. The increased bypass factor, BF, causes latent cooling, Q lat , to increase less than total cooling, Q tot . The net result is that latent cooling decreases with higher air flow rates. Thus, for dehumidification, it is advantageous to run air conditioners with low air flow rates for longer periods of time. It also follows that oversized air conditioning systems that meet total cooling loads by cycling on for short periods with high air flows and then remaining off for long periods are less able to provide adequate dehumidification than properly sized units which run more continuously. 13 Example Performance specifications from an air conditioning system are shown below. Consider the case when the condenser temperature is 120 F and the evaporator air wet bulb temperature is 72 F. Determine the SHR of the evaporator coil when operating with 9,000 cfm and 15,000 cfm of air across the evaporator. Note that the SHR increases, and latent cooling decreases. Cond Temp (F) 9,000 / 0.15 Evap Air cfm / BF 12,000 / 0.18 15,000 / 0.21 Evap Air Entering Wet BulbTemp (F) 62 72 67 62 72 67 320.6 410.7 374.9 340.1 424.4 388.0 280.0 213.9 270.6 325.9 233.0 301.2 28.5 30.7 30.0 29.0 31.0 30.2 403.6 499.7 461.7 424.5 514.1 475.7 305.9 391.5 356.8 323.6 404.1 368.6 273.0 206.7 263.3 316.2 226.2 293.8 30.7 33.3 32.4 31.4 33.6 32.8 395.2 488.0 450.8 414.7 501.3 463.6 284.7 365.1 332.1 300.7 376.2 342.8 263.1 197.8 253.7 299.5 216.6 283.9 32.9 36.1 34.9 33.7 36.5 35.3 380.2 468.5 431.6 398.4 481.5 443.0 270.8 345.8 315.3 285.4 355.6 324.8 257.0 190.9 246.9 285.4 209.8 277.1 35.0 38.5 37.2 35.9 38.9 37.6 372.3 457.5 423.0 389.5 468.3 433.7 261.2 335.3 304.9 274.8 344.7 314.2 252.7 187.3 243.0 274.8 206.1 273.2 35.9 39.7 38.1 36.7 40.1 38.6 365.7 450.2 381.2 381.2 460.8 426.0 72 67 62 TC 389.8 354.2 353.1 SHC 192.5 236.8 353.1 110 KW 30.3 29.5 29.4 THR 477.6 439.7 438.5 TC 372.1 338.1 335.5 SHC 185.6 229.9 335.5 120 KW 32.9 31.9 31.8 THR 467.3 430.6 427.8 TC 348.0 315.6 311.2 SHC 176.8 220.6 311.2 130 KW 35.5 34.3 34.1 THR 448.8 414.6 409.9 TC 330.9 300.3 294.9 SHC 170.5 214.3 294.9 140 KW 37.9 36.5 36.3 THR 440.7 406.3 400.3 TC 320.9 290.2 283.8 SHC 167.0 210.4 283.8 145 KW 39.0 37.5 37.1 THR 433.7 398.7 391.4 TC - Total Cooling (KBtu / hr) SHC - Sensible Cooling (KBtu / hr) KW - Electric Power Input (KW); Electric Power Input = Compressor Power + Evaporator Fan Power THR - Total Heat Rejected (KBtu / hr) Qtot Qsen Qlat SHR = Qsen/Qtot V=9,000 cfm 372.1 185.6 186.5 0.50 V=15,000 cfm 404.1 226.2 177.9 0.56 14