Pediatric Oncology Recreational Therapy Survey Pediatric Oncology Assessment Tool for Recreation Therapy Rebekah J. Plavnick Florida International University 1 Pediatric Oncology Recreational Therapy Survey 2 Abstract Recreation therapy is a therapeutic modality that utilizes the intervention of activity participation, therapeutic recreation, and leisure education to improve, maintain and/or develop physical, cognitive, emotional, and social skills in patients. Patients who are pediatric age in an oncology unit experience various stressors related to their treatment. “The psychological effect of extended isolation in a protected environment is of concern to health care professionals on the pediatric oncology unit at the National Institutes of Health” (O’Connell, 1984). The Children’s Health Journal announced that “…the development of a comprehensive therapeutic recreation program designed to address these issues as well as meet individual leisure needs of the isolated patient, is seen as an essential component of patient care” (O’Connell, 1984). This report will present a new way to assess the needs of pediatric oncology patients as they pertain to recreational therapy by using an in house assessment tool called, the Pediatric Oncology Recreational Therapy Survey (PORTS). This tool will facilitate the CTRS or LRT with formulating an individualized treatment plan to meet set goals and objectives aimed at increasing overall health. Pediatric Oncology Recreational Therapy Survey 3 Table of Contents Cover Page………………………………………………………………………………………...1 Abstract…………………………………………………………………………………………....2 Table of Contents………………………………………………………………………………….3 Introduction to PORTS………...………………………………………………………………….4 Instrument Description.............................................................................................................…...4 Population…………………………………………………………………………………5 Target Domains……………………………………………………………………………7 Response Mode……………………………………………………………………………8 Administrative Guidelines………………………………………………………………...9 Boundaries and Codependency…………………………………………………………..10 Instrument Development & Trial………………………………………………………………...11 Summary & Conclusions………………………………………………………………………...11 Assessment Report Form………………………………………………………………………...13 References………………………………………………………………………………………..18 Pediatric Oncology Recreational Therapy Survey 4 Introduction to PORTS The Pediatric Oncology Recreational Therapy Survey (PORTS) is an in house assessment aimed to provide the qualified therapeutic recreation specialist with information necessary to create an individualized treatment plan to increase patient’s overall health. “In addition to providing the patient with much needed play/leisure experiences, the RT has the opportunity to aid in reducing the effects of isolation” (O’Connell, 1984). In the Assessment Tools for Recreational Therapy and Related Fields textbook there are six main interpretations of assessments they are: confirming the diagnosis, establishing intervention baselines, measuring client progress, discharge feasibility, program evaluation, and determining loss of function and/or earning capacity (Burlingame, 2010). The PORTS assessment tool focuses on establishing intervention baselines and program evaluation. Instrument Description Upon admission of a patient to a pediatric oncology unit the recreation therapist will attend treatment team meeting and prepare to meet the patient. The patient should be administered the Pediatric Oncology Therapy Survey as soon as possible to ensure quality, effective care is delivered. The therapist is responsible for the administration and interpretation of the PORTS assessment tool. The assessment is composed of a rating scale portion as well as a free response portion. There is ample room to encourage notes from the therapist (i.e. showed increased signs of grief when discussing sports 2 not being able to participate anymore). The results derived from the survey will be presented to the treatment team along with the recreational therapist’s one on one intervention plan. The treatment plan will be carried out and routinely evaluated concerning therapist competencies, patient compliance, patient treatment outcomes, and facility integration of program. Pediatric Oncology Recreational Therapy Survey 5 Population. The population to be administered the PORTS assessment tool is anyone admitted to a pediatric oncology hospital or unit. As depicted by Burlingame the basic characteristics of the population that influence the assessment tool include: age, typical cognition, social, and physical skills, and the course of treatment (2010, p.113). The population’s age parameters for the PORTS is 5-18, in some cases the PORTS can be administered up to age 21. Cases that the PORTS is administered until age 21 would include: the patient is admitted into the pediatric unit, the patient’s cognition level is low, there are only recreational therapy opportunities in the pediatric unit, and/or the treating physician or team prescribed recreational therapy as a therapeutic modality. The cognition level necessary to complete the PORTS assessment is adaptable. The way the test is intended to be administered is by the therapist reading or allowing the patient to read the questions and choose the appropriate answer. The free-response portion of the assessment requires increased cognition where the patient will have to formulate complete thoughts that deliver coherent responses. If necessary the therapist can provide verbal cues as presented on the assessment report. It is recommended that the patient is not accompanied by guardian or adult in order to not taint patient responses or physical affect. Social skills necessary to complete this assessment begins with the ability to be in a room with the therapist and communicate. Because this is assessment is meant for the pediatric age group some children may be shy and unwilling to be left alone with a therapist. If this is the case, the therapist can talk with the guardian or parent and have the parent and therapist be together with the child to explain the process. The parent will need to leave the room during the actual assessment. Social skills are an important aspect that is being recorded in the PORTS and it is Pediatric Oncology Recreational Therapy Survey 6 important to gather an accurate measure to then assess activity limitations for the recreational therapy treatment plan. Physical skills should not be a major factor when administrating the Pediatric Oncology Recreational Therapy Survey. Activity limitations that are affected by physical capability will be evaluated by physical therapists or physicians and then relayed to the recreation therapy professional. The patient will however need to be able to communicate, sit, and/or lay for an extended amount of time while being administered the assessment. If the patient needs to switch between laying and sitting that is permissible. When administering an assessment the course of treatment for the population being served is an important factor affecting the necessity of the tool. Some questions the therapist may ask himself include: “what inherent problems will the client face as a result of treatment that the use of leisure activities may help mitigate” (Burlingame, 2010, p.113), and what are typical precautions for this diagnostic group? Some miscellaneous issues that arise at time of diagnosis, during treatment, or after cessation of treatment may be education, palliative care, finances, advocacy, employment, complementary and alternative therapies, and cancer prevention (Labotka, 2006). In 2011, the Journal for Pain and Symptom Management released a feedback report that evaluated the Pediatric Quality-of-Life of Symptoms Technology (PediQuest). PediQuest is a “…random controlled trial in children with advanced cancer to determine the effect of providing families and providers feedback about patient-reported quality of life and symptoms” (Dussel, 2011). The results from PediQuest conclude that the study showed new information concerning psychosocial issues and more decisions from providers and parents to involve psychosocial (56%), pain (34%), social work (33%), or palliative care (29%) consult Pediatric Oncology Recreational Therapy Survey 7 (Dussel, 2011). Recreation therapy is among these initiatives used to alleviate the stressors of diagnosis, treatment, and discharge in pediatric oncology patients. Target Domains. The recreational therapist’s scope of practice on a pediatric oncology unit is important and concise. The scope includes: opportunity of play, social interaction, escape from treatment reality and leisure education. The PORTS assessment tool provides the therapist with information to better provide these domains as treatment to the patient. Information gathered concerning “opportunity of play” involves, what that patient enjoyed/enjoys doing, what the patient enjoyed/enjoys watching? The information gathered about the patient’s social interaction level is important because of the increased levels of isolation that result from pediatric oncology treatment. Information gathered includes: where the patient feels the safest, how the patient perceives his peers, does the patient like to play with others? The course of treatment as previously discussed is a very daunting journey that most kids are unequipped to handle. Information that facilitates the therapist’s understanding of what helps the child to feel less treated and more living includes answers to questions like, does the patient understand his diagnosis, how does the patient perceive treatment? “Therapeutic recreation is a profession committed to helping people with illnesses and disabilities develop and maintain appropriate leisure lifestyles and to provide recreation resources and opportunities in order to improve health and well-being” (Datillo, 2011). Leisure Education is essential to the longevity of therapeutic recreation. Information about the patient’s leisure education status can be retrieved through questions like, what activities does the patient show interest in, what was the patient working on before onset of illness, what is available to the patient through family? Pediatric Oncology Recreational Therapy Survey 8 The target domains for the Pediatric Oncology Recreational Therapy Survey are as stated above, play, social interaction, escape of treatment reality, and leisure education. These are essential components within the scope of recreational therapy that will improve the quality of life and overall health and treatment of patients. Response Mode. The response mode affects the statistical analysis of the assessment which ultimately provides the overall information needed to obtain critical indicators. This assessment is composed of two sections a rating scale and a free-response section. The rating scale will be able to be quantified while the free-response section will not be easily analyzed. The freeresponse section will provide the therapist with subjective un-basis patient information to be considered in the formation of the treatment plan. The competences related to effective response analysis directly effects quality assurance (Burlingame, 2010, p. 139). There are many types of scales, because the PORTS assessment is aimed at determining attitudes and opinions it incorporates a nominal scale. Burlingame states that nominal scale are ideal for the determining trends or demographic information as well as asking about attitudes and opinions (2010, p. 182). The patient will be presented a phrase or question and asked to give the option that fits them the most (i.e. I like to participate in activities with others, strongly agree/ agree/ indifferent/ disagree/ strongly disagree). This will allow the patient to be placed in a nominal group of other patients who enjoying playing in groups, are in the same amount of pain, etc. The PORTS will not test for all information needed to create an individualized treatment plan, some information will be incorporated from other professional assessments delivered by the appropriate professional. This information includes body functions and body structures. When delivering the PORTS assessment there are many professional considerations to be made not just the structure of questions, response mode, population, and target domains. Pediatric Oncology Recreational Therapy Survey 9 Administrative Guidelines. The most important guideline when delivering an assessment is professional competence. “Most of the competencies related to assessment address procedures, process, and base knowledge” (Burlingame, 2010, p. 136). The Pediatric Oncology Recreational Therapy Survey has a specific procedure that will be outlined here and also on the assessment report form. A procedure is defined by Burlingame as, “the act of following a predetermined sequence of actions to cause the purposeful manipulation of specific conditions” (2010, p.136). The procedure for the PORTS is as follows: 1. introduce self to patient, 2. record and confirm patient identity, 3. measure and record blood pressure, heart rate, and pain level, 4. Begin and follow specific procedure for each section of the PORTS while recording specific outlined information. The five basic competencies required to follow a procedure is ability to observe patient behaviors, ability to interview patient, ability to assess patient functional skills, ability to administer a specific leisure assessment, and ability to administer other inventories and questionnaires (Burlingame, 2010, p.136). The process for the PORTS addresses the general guidelines by which the procedure should be enacted. The process is adaptable by professional judgement (i.e. the patient cannot leave his bed, the patient is unable to communicate effectively without aide). The process is concerned with the ability to obtain satisfactory information by use of procedure. The PORTS assessment contains cues and guidelines to address need for adaptations in procedures. The therapist should be aware of this alternative process and prepared to deliver the outlined adaptations when necessary. The PORTS assessment is to be delivered in a confidential area and require substantial time to complete the tool within one meeting. The base knowledge necessary to effectively administer the PORTS can be described as social assessment, affective assessment, and leisure assessment (Burlingame, 2010, p. 137). The Pediatric Oncology Recreational Therapy Survey 10 therapist should have a basic knowledge of how to assess the patient’s social, affective and leisure skills and interests. Other issues related to reliability of test results include client cooperation and cultural issues (Burlingame, 2010, p. 144-145). Cooperation of the patient is important to ensure that the therapist can report a true picture. Culture is defined as, shared beliefs and mannerisms that bond a group together (Burlingame, 2010, p. 145). It is crucial that the therapist consider the culture of the patient when reporting on the PORTS assessment. Boundaries and Codependency. There are specific boundaries involved when administering assessment tools. Boundaries affect reliability of test scores and patient vulnerability when violated (Burlingame, 2010, p.140). The PORTS assessment is delivered immediately when the patient is admitted to the oncology unit and therefore sets the initial therapist/patient relationship. The therapist should be careful to set appropriate boundaries and limitations to ensure quality future therapist/patient involvement. The recreation therapist is an important healthcare provider entrusted with the treatment of patients as related to leisure and recreation. Codependency can ultimately create a loss of function, decreased quality of life, and failed treatment initiatives. Codependency is referred to by Burlingame as a relationship between two individuals who become emotionally dependent on one another to meet a need. This relationship is unhealthy for one or both of the involved individuals (2010, p. 141). It is important for the therapist to consider and be aware of codependency as an issue in assessment and treatment. Pediatric Oncology Recreational Therapy Survey 11 Instrument Development and Trial Recreational therapy and other healthcare domains more often than not construct their assessments on theory as an effort to prove a theory valid or null. The PORTS assessment is set out to gather information using a scale and free-response format to provide an effective treatment plan. The measurement aspect of the PORTS is not concerned with the overall completion of the assessment but rather the individual responses to each individual question, this is considered the item-response theory. The PORTS involves a criterion-referenced test structure because the patient’s scores will not be compared to other individuals, there is no pass or fail, and the assessment is based on task analysis (Burlingame, 2010, p.136). The development of the PORTS assessment tool was based on available therapeutic recreation opportunities within a pediatric oncology unit or hospital. By answering the questions within the assessment tool the therapist will have a clear view of what recreation/leisure programs to provide the patient. Summary and Conclusions The importance of recreation therapy in pediatric oncology can be supported by the essential necessity of leisure and recreation during the pediatric age frame. O’Connell stresses the importance in recreation therapy within a protected environment such as a hospital. It is crucial that the recreation therapy department offer a variety of games, activities, holiday events, and special events while also incorporating new recreational therapy techniques daily to alter the monotonous daily routine many patients are subjected to (O’Connell, 1984, p. 120). Play is a normal component to children. There are several theories used to support the increased well-being through therapeutic play. The theories include the developmental theory of Piaget, Erickson’s psychosocial theory, and Vygotsky’s sociocultural theory. Datillo concludes Pediatric Oncology Recreational Therapy Survey 12 that “Children who have benefited from use of play as a therapeutic medium include those with physical and cognitive impairments, behavior and emotional problems, and children who have experienced abuse or chronic illness (2011, p. 513). The PORTS tool gathers information about the patient’s desire to learn more about leisure and recreation and perceived barriers. This component of recreational therapy is addressed by leisure education. “Leisure education is particularly suited to the task of helping individuals in that it addresses the challenges to enjoyable leisure experiences that are often faced by people with a variety of disabilities” (Datillo, 2011, p. 187). Upon the conclusion of the Pediatric Oncology Recreational Therapy Survey the therapist will have the appropriate information to form a balanced treatment plan equipped to address leisure needs, leisure education, and recreation participation. The results of the plan will be assessable to all members of the patient’s healthcare team. Pediatric Oncology Recreational Therapy Survey 13 PEDIATRIC ONCOLOGY (PORTS) In-house assessment tool for recreational Therapy PATIENT NAME & DATE: ___________________________________________________ Patient Basic Information Cont. Date of Birth: ___________________________ Known Allergies: _________________________ Date of Onset: ___________________________ Precautions: _________________________ Date of Admission: ___________________________ Physician Orders: _________________________ Diagnosis: ___________________________ Activity Limitations: ________________________ NOTES: BP: ______ HR: ______ Pain Level: ______ About Our Pediatric Oncology RT Assessment This assessment will give the therapist a clear view of the patient’s interests and how they can be incorporated into their individualized treatment plan. RT is a therapeutic modality that utilizes leisure education, activity participation, and therapeutic recreation. This assessment contains a rating scale portion and a free response portion complimented with therapist account of patient affect during assessment. Administrative Guidelines Follow outlined procedure per section and question. Consider cultural issues before, during and after administration of the PORTS assessment. Allow sufficient time 30-60 minutes in a confidential area Consider adverse effects of therapist/patient relationship by establishing boundaries and avoiding codependency. Pediatric Oncology Recreational Therapy Survey 14 SECTION I: LEISURE INTEREST [BY CATEGORY] PROCEDURE: Ask patient to communicate their amount of interest in these leisure/recreation activities by choosing one response that is closest to their interest level. Circle response. Record any substantial information pertaining to patient affect in the notes section at the end of section I. Allow 15-30 minutes. 1. INDIVIDUAL ACTIVITY 1a. Painting Very Interested Somewhat Interested Indifferent Not Interested Never Interested Somewhat Interested Indifferent Not Interested Never Interested Somewhat Interested Indifferent Not Interested Never Interested Somewhat Interested Indifferent Not Interested Never Interested Somewhat Interested Indifferent Not Interested Never Interested Somewhat Interested Indifferent Not Interested Never Interested Somewhat Interested Indifferent Not Interested Never Interested Somewhat Interested Indifferent Not Interested Never Interested Somewhat Interested Indifferent Not Interested Never Interested Somewhat Interested Indifferent Not Interested Never Interested Somewhat Interested Indifferent Not Interested Never Interested 1b. Cooking Very Interested 1c. Gardening Very Interested 1d. Exercising Very Interested 1e. Caring for animals Very Interested 1f. Crafts Very Interested 1g. Aquatics Very Interested 1h. Reading Very Interested 1i. Collecting Very Interested 1j. Dance Very Interested 1k. Singing Very Interested Notes:________________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________________ Pediatric Oncology Recreational Therapy Survey 15 2. GROUP ACTIVITY 2a. Team Work Very Interested Somewhat Interested Indifferent Not Interested Never Interested Not Interested Never Interested 2b. Group Sports (soccer, football, hockey, cheerleading) Very Interested Somewhat Interested Indifferent 2c. Group Performance (plays, dance, music) Very Interested Somewhat Interested Indifferent Not Interested Never Interested Somewhat Interested Indifferent Not Interested Never Interested Somewhat Interested Indifferent Not Interested Never Interested Somewhat Interested Indifferent Not Interested Never Interested Somewhat Interested Indifferent Not Interested Never Interested 2d. Group Discussion Very Interested 2e. Group Crafts Very Interested 2f. Book Clubs Very Interested 2g. Exercise Very Interested Notes:________________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________________ SECTION II: FREE-RESPONSE PROCEDURE: Ask patient to answer the following question to the best of his ability. Explain there is no right or wrong answer. Record patient answers in the indicated areas. Do not leave any answers blank. Use provided cues if necessary. Allow 30-45 minutes. 1. What physical barriers stop you from participating in leisure or recreation activities? CUES: Physical barriers are for example, your IV bag stand, the hospital, your wheelchair. _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ 2. What emotional/attitudinal barriers stop you from participating in leisure or recreation activities? CUES: Emotional barriers are for example, you feel sad when playing with friends. Attitudinal barriers are for example, people think you are incapable of participation. Pediatric Oncology Recreational Therapy Survey 16 _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ 3. What activities would you like to learn more about? CUES: examples include do you want to become a painter, soccer goalie, etc. _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ 4. What activities did you participate in the most before coming here? CUES: examples include did you go to siblings games, were you a part of a book club, etc. _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ 5. What activities do you participate in now? CUES: examples include, reading, watching TV, etc. _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ 6. What is your favorite holiday, why? CUES: examples include, Cinco De Mayo because my family all gets together and cooks a big feast. _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ 7. How do you perceive the environment of this hospital? CUES: examples include, the nurses are nice, it is very white, the grass is very green, and/or there are a lot of people. _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ 8. How do you feel about spending some time here? CUES: Ask, are you excited to meet new people? Are you scared to be here? _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ Pediatric Oncology Recreational Therapy Survey SCORE SHEET Retrieval of rating scores PROCEDURE: A score of 5 indicates highest possible interest and a score of 0 indicates lowest possible interest Individual Activity Painting = ______ Cooking = ______ Gardening = ______ Exercising = ______ Caring for Animals = ______ Crafts = ______ Aquatics = ______ Reading = ______ Collecting = ______ Dance = ______ Singing = ______ Group Activity Team Work = ______ Group Sports = ______ Group Performance = ______ Group Discussion = ______ Group Crafts = ______ Book Clubs = ______ Exercise = ______ Therapist Name Printed: ______________________________________ Therapist Signature: ______________________________________ Date of Assessment: ______________________________________ 17 Pediatric Oncology Recreational Therapy Survey 18 References Burlingame, J., & Blaschko, T. (2010). Assessment Tools for Recreational Therapy and Related Fields (Fourth ed., pp. 1-707). WA, Ravensdale: Idyll Arbor. Dattilo, J., & McKenney, A. (2011). Leisure Education. In Facilitation techniques in therapeutic recreation (2nd ed., pp. 187-220). State College, PA: Venture Pub. Dussel, V., Neville, B., Chen, K., Cook, E., Geyer, R., Kang, T., . . . Wolfe, J. (2011). Routine Feedback of Patient-Reported Distress in Children With Advanced Cancer: Provider and Family Satisfaction With the Pediatric Quality of Life and Evaluation of Symptoms Technology (PediQUEST) System (311-B). Journal of Pain and Symptom Management, 41(1), 187-188. doi:10.1016/j.jpainsymman.2010.10.043 Labotka, R. (2006). Pediatric Oncology. The Journal of the American Medical Association, 296(4), 450-450. doi:10.1001/jama.296.4.452-b O'connell, S. (1984). Recreation Therapy: Reducing the Effects of Isolation for the Patient in a Protected Environment. Children's Health Care, 12(3), 118-121. doi:10.1207/s15326888chc1203_3 Savino F, Vagliano L, Ceratto S, Viviani F, Miniero R, Ricceri F. (2013) Pain assessment in children undergoing venipuncture: the Wong–Baker faces scale versus skin conductance fluctuations. PeerJ 1:e37 https://dx.doi.org/10.7717/peerj.37