Table S2. Mineralogy and properties of rock samples used in experiments. Sample name Stainton B St. Bees #1 St. Bees #2 Doddington Origin Sandstone outcrop at Stainton, Durham, U.K. Sandstone outcrop at St. Bees, Cumbria, U.K. Sandstone outcrop at St. Bees, Cumbria, U.K. Sandstone outcrop at Doddington, UK Age Carboniferous Triassic Triassic Carboniferous Depositional environment Fluvial Aeolian/fluvial reworked Aeolian/fluvial reworked Fluvial Porosity 13±0.5% 19±0.7% 19±0.7% 18±0.7% Grain size 60-200m 60-200m 60-200m 100-200m Liquid permeability 2±0.05mD 70±2mD 30±1mD 850±5mD Mineralogy 80% quartz 10% quartz cement 5% clay and feldspar <5% white mica <5% calcite cement 80% quartz 10% quartz cement 5% white mica 5% clay 80% quartz 10% quartz cement 5% white mica 5% clay 97% quartz 2% feldspar <0.5% clay <1% others Formation factor 45±0.5 18±0.5 21.5±0.5 10±0.3 Dimensions 7.58cm length 3.58cm diameter 7.76cm length 3.71cm diameter 7.6cm length 3.7cm diameter 7.03cm length 3.78cm diameter 1