Mathematics and Statistics Campus Learning Outcomes Assessment Plan 1. Program Mission The department of mathematics and statistics has a many–sided mission. It offers bachelor's and master's degrees in applied mathematics, a bachelor's degree emphasis area leading to teacher certification in mathematics and a master of science for teachers degree, and the doctorate in mathematics, with various emphases, including statistics. As a doctoral level department, it must contribute to the growth and creation of knowledge in mathematics and statistics through research conducted by faculty and graduate students. As an undergraduate and master's level department, it must continue to train people for both the teaching profession and a wide variety of business and industrial employers. As a provider of essential courses for science and engineering programs, it has a responsibility to build a critical foundation for the education of nearly every S&T student. The department of mathematics and statistics not only must encourage and support research in all areas of the mathematical sciences, but also must be an available and dependable resource for faculty and students in other disciplines. Finally, it must provide public service as appropriate for a state land–grant institution. 2. Learning Outcomes for Applied Mathematics Majors Learning Outcomes The Department of Mathematics and Statistics expects its undergraduate majors to gain the following skills and abilities during their undergraduate academic career, especially through the coursework required for majoring in applied mathematics: (1) an ability to communicate effectively both orally and in writing. (2) an ability to think critically and analyze effectively. (3) an ability to apply disciplinary knowledge and skills in solving critical problems. (4) an ability to function in diverse learning and working environments. (5) an understanding of professional and ethical responsibility. (6) an awareness of national and global contemporary issues. (7) a recognition of the need for, and an ability to engage in, life-long learning. 1 Performance Criteria for Assessing Learning Outcomes Learning Outcome (1): Communications The Department of Mathematics & Statistics will demonstrate that its graduates have the ability to communicate effectively both orally and in writing by using the following performance criteria: 1.1 Communicates effectively in individual oral presentations. 1.2 Communicates effectively in group oral presentations. 1.3 Communicates effectively in written technical reports. 1.4 Communicates effectively during oral presentations of logical/mathematical arguments required for proving or disproving conjectures. 1.5 Communicates effectively in writing when presenting logical/mathematical arguments and required for proving or disproving conjectures. Rubric Categories for Performance Criterion 1.1 Organization: Presents material in a logical sequence and makes points clearly. Visual Presentation: Makes effective use of graphs, figures, tables, and presentation aides. Vocal Delivery: Maintains clear voice, good pace and expression. Relating to Audience: Engages audience; uses appropriate eye contact and adjusts presentation to audience. Rubric Categories for Performance Criterion 1.2 Organization: Presents material in a logical sequence and makes points clearly. Visual Presentation: Makes effective use of graphs, figures, tables, and presentation aides. Vocal Delivery: Maintains clear voice, good pace and expression. Relating to Audience: Engages audience; uses appropriate eye contact and adjusts presentation to audience. Teamwork: Material is logically divided among group members and all share in presentation appropriately. Transitions: Transitions between speakers are smooth. Rubric Categories for Performance Criterion 1.3 Organization: Presents material in a logical sequence and makes points clearly. Mechanics: Articulates ideas well using proper spelling and grammar. Uses professional style of writing. 2 Visual presentations: Uses tables, graphs and figures to enhance understanding and support arguments. Rubric Categories for Performance Criterion 1.4 Organization: Makes arguments or proofs with well reasoned steps that form a cohesive and mathematically consistent sequence of statements. Visual presentations: Makes use of graphs, tables, and figures that synthesizes and highlights the essence of the arguments made and/or supports such arguments. Mechanics: maintains clear voice, good pace and expression. Relating to Audience: Engages audience; uses appropriate eye contact and adjusts presentation to audience. Clarifies and explains salient points through good examples. Rubric Categories for Performance Criterion 1.5 Organization: Makes arguments or proofs with well reasoned out steps that form a cohesive and mathematically consistent sequence of statements. Visual presentations: Makes use of graphs, tables, and figures that synthesizes and highlights the essence of the arguments made and/or supports such arguments. Mechanics: Articulates ideas well using proper spelling and grammar. Uses professional style of writing. Relating to Readers: Clarifies and explains salient points through good examples. Style of writing is appropriate for the targeted audience. Performance Criteria for Learning Outcome (2): Critical Thinking The Department of Mathematics & Statistics will demonstrate that its graduates have the ability to think critically by using the following performance criteria: Performance Criteria 2.1 Ability to follow and synthesize the main points of a logical sequence of oral or written arguments used by someone else in analyzing/solving a problem. 2.2 Ability to decompose a complex problem into component parts to facilitate the use of logical reasoning and subject matter knowledge to find a solution. 2.3 Ability to differentiate between mathematically and/or statistically correct arguments from those that are fallacious . 2.4 Ability to critique writing or publications outside of discipline. 3 Rubric Categories for Performance Criterion 2.11 Identification: Identifies and summarizes the problem Context: Identifies and considers the influence of context and assumptions Reasoning: Follows the reasoning given by the presenter/author and identifies the main arguments and the logical flow of such arguments. Understanding and synthesis: Summarizes the arguments in own words and/or adopts arguments for solving a related problem. Data analysis: Understands the appropriateness of the data analysis methods used and the underlying rationale behind these techniques. Conclusions: Identifies and assesses conclusions, implications and consequences. Rubric Categories for Performance Criterion 2.2 Identification: Identifies and summarizes the problem. Context: Identifies and considers the influence of context and assumptions Critical Analysis: Develops an innate understanding of the problem and decompose the problem into interrelated components. Planning: Lays out a logical plan for solving the problem. Data analysis: Identifies appropriate statistical methodology for solving the problem. Conclusions: Identifies the implications and consequences of potential solutions. Rubric Categories for Performance Criterion 2.3 Identification: Identifies and summarizes the main arguments. Context: Identifies and considers the influence of context and assumptions Critical Analysis: Identifies correct arguments from those that are false. Data analysis: Identifies the appropriateness of statistical methods proposed for analyzing the data. Conclusions: Identifies and assesses conclusions, implications and consequences. Rubric Categories for Performance Criterion 2.4 Identification: Identifies and summarizes the main arguments. Context: Identifies and considers the influence of context and assumptions Own Perspective: Develops and communicates own perspective, hypothesis or position. Data Analysis: Assesses the appropriateness of the data analytic techniques used and how the results support the conclusions. 1 Adapted from Washington State University Guide to Rating Integrative and Critical Thinking, www.wsuctproject.wsu.edu/ctr.htm 4 Conclusions: Identifies and assesses conclusions, implications, and consequences. Performance Criteria for Learning Outcome (3): Problem Solving The Department of Mathematics & Statistics will demonstrate that its graduates have the ability to apply disciplinary knowledge and skills in solving critical problems by using the following performance criteria. Performance Criteria2 3.1 Solves problem within discipline using skills and knowledge gained through the program. 3.2 Solves problems that are related to the discipline but have multi-disciplinary implications. 3.3 Designs statistical experiments and conducts data analysis to answer a scientific question ot test a hypothesis. Rubric Categories for Performance Criterion 3.1 Identification: Identifies problem Knowledge: Applies previous knowledge Information: Identifies additional information to solve problem Analysis: Analyzes various components of problem Interpretation: Interprets results to draw conclusion Rubric Categories for Performance Criterion 3.2 Identification: Identifies problem Knowledge: Applies previous knowledge Information: Identifies additional information to solve problem Analysis: Analyzes various components of problem Interpretation: Interprets results to draw conclusion Rubric Categories for Performance Criterion 3.3 Identification: Identifies problem. Knowledge: Applies previous knowledge. Design: Designs a statistically valid experiment that will generate data appropriate for answering the question or testing the hypothesis. Application: Conducts experiment. 2 Adapted from Chemical Engineering CRCD Project, Iowa State University, www3.cbe.iastate.edu/CRCD/rubric-problem-solving.doc 5 Analysis: Analyzes data using appropriate methods. Interpretation: Interprets results to draw conclusion. Learning Outcome (4): Diverse Environments/Teamwork. The Department of Mathematics & Statistics will demonstrate that its graduates have the ability to function in diverse learning and working environments by using the following performance criteria. Performance Criteria (Choose at least one and preferably two or three, or add your own) 4.1 Functions as team player. 4.2 Conducts effective and efficient meetings. Rubric Categories for Performance Criterion 4.1 Role: Demonstrates understanding of role on team by fulfilling appropriate duties. Duty: Fulfills duty to team by sharing equally in workload. Communication: Communicates well with teammates and resolves conflict. Altruism: Takes initiation in areas as needed to promote team effectiveness. Understanding: Understands advantage of a team approach to a problem. Discernment: Distinguishes when a problem is better suited to solution by individual or team. Recognition: Recognizes the advantage of diversity in forming teams. Utilization: Uses the diverse skills and experiences of team members in solving problems. Rubric Categories for Performance Criterion 4.2 Decision: Recognizes when to call a meeting and when to work one-on-one or in small groups. Agenda: Invites appropriate individuals, prepares effective agenda and provides pre-work as necessary. Logistics: Proceeds through agenda in a timely manner, allowing appropriate amount of time for each agenda item. Engaging team: Engages all attendees in meeting and utilizes the strengths of the individuals to achieve optimal results. Note that while it is not advisable to have all assessments of a learning outcome performed by students, it may be appropriate at times to have students assess one another in situations where the instructor does not participate in an activity. 6 Learning Outcome (5): Professional and Ethical Responsibility. The Department of Mathematics & Statistics will demonstrate that its graduates have an understanding of professional and ethical responsibility by using the following performance criteria. 5.1 Demonstrates knowledge of code of ethics and applies code to case studies. 5.2 Understands ethical models and applies appropriate model to ethical dilemma. 5.3 Understands, purpose, privileges and responsibilities associated with being a mathematician or statistician. 5.4 Assumes responsibility for actions. Rubric Categories for Performance Criterion 5.1 Knowledge: Demonstrates knowledge of code of ethics related to profession. Identification of Dilemma: Identifies situations in case study that are relevant to code. Application and Recommendation: Considers various aspects of case, makes recommendations based on code, and defends recommendations. Rubric Categories for Performance Criterion 5.2 Knowledge: Describes ethical models. Identification of Dilemma: Identifies ethical dilemma and chooses appropriate model for application. Application and Recommendation: Considers various aspects of case, makes recommendations based on model, and defends recommendations. Rubric Categories for Performance Criterion 5.3 Purpose: Understands the role played by mathematicians and statisticians in society. Comprehension of responsibilities: Explains responsibilities and limitations associated with position in profession. Rubric Categories for Performance Criterion 5.4 Class attendance: Is attentive in class and arrives on time. Performance: Turns in assignments on time. Takes pride in work. Independence and collaboration: understands situations where independent work is required and where collaboration is encouraged. Responsibility for Actions: Recognizes weaknesses in performance and takes action for improvement. 7 Learning Outcome (6): Contemporary Issues. The Department of Mathematics & Statistics will demonstrate that its graduates awareness of national and global contemporary issues. Performance Criteria 6.1 Identifies national contemporary issues related to discipline. 6.2 Identifies global contemporary issues related to discipline. 6.3 Understands the role mathematicians and statisticians can play in contemporary issues. Rubric Categories for Performance Criterion 6.1 Knowledge: Identifies national contemporary issues related to discipline and reads articles or attends presentations that address issues. Comprehension: Discusses or writes thoughtful essay about articles or presentations. Rubric Categories for Performance Criterion 6.2 Knowledge: Identifies global contemporary issues related to discipline and reads articles or attends presentations that address issues. Comprehension: Discusses or writes thoughtful essay about articles or presentations. Rubric Categories for Performance Criterion 6.3 Knowledge: Identifies the key roles mathematicians and statisticians can play in contemporary issues. Comprehension: Discusses or writes thoughtful essay about the role of mathematicians and statisticians can play in contemporary issues to the betterment of society. A suggestion for addressing this learning outcome is to convene a group of faculty at the beginning of the fall semester to discuss and identify contemporary issues related to your program. Identify three courses, preferably at the sophomore, junior and senior levels, in which reading assignments can be given related to the identified issues. Have the students identify and read articles (or the instructor can assign them) and write an essay on the topic. This same assignment could be used to assess Learning Outcome (1) Communication. The essay could be assessed for written communication skills. An additional assessment of oral communication could be performed if the students were asked to make a presentation on their essays. 8 Learning Outcome (7): Lifelong Learning. The Department of Mathematics & Statistics will demonstrate that its graduates have a recognition of the need for, and an ability to engage in, life-long learning. Performance Criteria 7.1 Demonstrates competence in mathematics and statistics skills that are fundamental to the ability to engage in life-long learning. 7.2 Participates in professional and service activities. 7.3 Reads professional publications and discipline related articles. 7.4 Attends seminars and presentations significant to the profession. Rubric Categories for Performance Criterion 7.1 Preparation: Takes core mathematics and statistics courses. Competence: Performs satisfactorily in core mathematics and statistics courses. Application: Takes courses outside the discipline that requires competence in core mathematics/statistics topics. Rubric Categories for Performance Criterion 7.2 Professional and Service Societies: Participates in student chapter of professional society. Citizenship: Participates in service activities of student or community organization. Personal Development: Engages in activities to promote personal, physical and/or spiritual growth. Rubric Categories for Performance Criterion 7.3 Exposure: Reads articles related to profession or has a discipline specific component. Comprehension: Writes essay or engages in thoughtful discussion about article. Rubric Categories for Performance Criterion 7.4 Exposure: Attends presentation. Comprehension: Writes essay or engages in thoughtful discussion about presentation. 9 2. Mapping of Courses Used For Assessment to Campus Learning Outcomes Table 1. Curriculum and Student Learning Outcome Map Course Outcome I Outcome II Outcome III Outcome IV Math 1 P Math 8, 21, 22 P P P Math 204 P P P I Math 208 P P I Math 209 Stat 215, 217, 343 P P R P P P I I P P Math 309, 311 Math 361, 371, 381(4) Math 305, 306, 307, 308 (2) P P R R P P I P P P P P R I P Math 315, 330, 351, 385 (2) Math 302, 303, 322, 325, 351, 383 (2) Stat 343, 344, 346, 353 (2) CSc 228, 328, 329, Math 303, Stat 346, Econ 321 (2) (3) P P R I P P P R I P P P R P I P P P R P I P P P Outcome V Outcome VI Outcome VII P P P I (1) P P (1) One of these courses is required to fulfill the Statistics Requirement (2) Mathematics Elective group requirement – students must choose two of the five groups and then six hours from each chosen group (3) Learning outcomes for courses not in the department are not considered (4) Departmental capstone courses 10 Learning Outcome (1): Ability to communicate effectively Performance Criteria Class Achievement Activity Assessment Method 1.1 Math 1 Class discussion of discipline specific topics Numerical score or qualitative assessment 1.3 Math 1 Essays on discipline specific topics Numerical score 1.4 Math 1 Presenting Solutions to problems Numerical score or qualitative assessment 1.5 Math 1 Written solutions to problems Numerical score 1.4 Math 8, 21, 22 Class discussion of problems (recitations) Qualitative assessment 1.5 Math 8, 21, 22 Written solutions to problems Numerical score 1.5 Math 204 Written solutions to problems Numerical score 1.3 Math 208 Short report on applications Numerical score 1.5 Math 208 Written solutions to problems Numerical score Learning Outcome (1) Continued: Ability to communicate effectively Performance Criteria Class Achievement Activity Assessment Method 1.1 Math 209 Class discussion of problems and their solution Qualitative assessment 11 1.4 Math 209 Oral presentation of proofs/counterexamples Numerical score or qualitative assessment 1.5 Math 209 Written solutions to problems Numerical score 1.3 Stat 215, 217, 343 Short report on an application Numerical score 1.5 Stat 215, 217, 343 Written solution to problems Numerical score 1.4 Math 309, 311 Oral presentation of proofs/counterexamples Numerical score 1.5 Math 309, 311 Written solution to problems Numerical score 1.3 Math 208 Written solutions to problems Numerical score 1.1 Math 361, 371, 381 Oral presentation on a discipline specific topic Numerical score or qualitative assessment 1.3 Math 361, 371, 381 Short written report on a selected topic Numerical score 1.4 Math 361, 371, 381 Oral presentation of solutions to a problem Numerical score or qualitative assessment 1.5 Math 361, 371, 381 Written solutions to problems Numerical score Learning Outcome (1) Continued: Ability to communicate effectively Performance Criteria Class Achievement Activity Assessment Method 1.1 Math 305, 306, 307, 308 Class discussion of applications Qualitative assessment 12 1.5 Math 305, 306, 307, 308 Written solutions to problems Numerical score 1.4 Math 315, 330, 351, 385 Oral presentation of proofs/counterexamples Numerical score or qualitative assessment 1.5 Math 315, 330, 351, 385 Written solutions to problems Numerical score 1.5 Math 302, 303, 322, 325, 351, 383 Written solution to problems Numerical score 1.4 Math 309, 311 Oral presentation of proofs/counterexamples Numerical score 1.2 Stat 343, 344, 346, 353 Group presentation of class project Qualitative assessment 1.3 Stat 343, 344, 346, 353 Written project reports Numerical score 1.5 Stat 343, 344, 346, 353 Written solution to problems Numerical score 1.2 CSc 228, 328, 329, Math 303, Stat 346, Econ 321 Group presentation of class project Numerical score 1.3 CSc 228, 328, 329, Math 303, Stat 346, Econ 321 Written project reports Numerical score 1.5 CSc 228, 328, 329, Math 303, Stat 346, Econ 321 Written solution to problems Numerical score Learning Outcome (2) Continued: Ability to think critically and analyze effectively Performance Criteria Class Achievement Activity Assessment Method 2.1 Math 8, 21, 22 Class reading assignments Numerical score or qualitative assessment 13 2.2 Math 8, 21, 22 Written solution to problems Numerical score 2.3 Math 8, 21, 22 Class assignments Numerical score 2.1 Math 204 Class reading assignments Numerical score or qualitative assessment 2.2 Math 204 Written solution to problems Numerical score 2.3 Math 204 Class assignments Numerical score 2.1 Math 208 Class reading assignments Numerical score or qualitative assessment 2.2 Math 208 Written solution to problems Numerical score 2.3 Math 208 Class assignments Numerical score 2.1 Math 209 Class reading assignments Numerical score or qualitative assessment 2.2 Math 209 Written solution to problems Numerical score 2.3 Math 209 Class assignments Numerical score 2.1 Stat 215, 217, 343 Class reading assignments Numerical score 2.2 Stat 215, 217, 343 Written solution to problems Numerical score 2.3 Stat 215, 217, 343 Class assignments Numerical score Learning Outcome (2) Continued: Ability to think critically and analyze effectively Performance Criteria Class Achievement Activity Assessment Method 2.1 Math 309, 311 Class reading assignments Numerical score 2.2 Math 309, 311 Written solution to Numerical score 14 problems 2.3 Math 309, 311 Class assignments Numerical score 2.1 Math 361, 371, 381 Class reading assignments Numerical score or qualitative assessment 2.2 Math 361, 371, 381 Written solution to problems Numerical score 2.3 Math 361, 371, 381 Class assignments Numerical score 2.4 Math 361, 371, 381 Class assignments Numerical score 2.1 Math 305, 306, 307, 308 Class reading assignment Numerical score 2.2 Math 305, 306, 307, 308 Written solution to problems Numerical score 2.3 Math 305, 306, 307, 308 Class assignments Numerical score 2.1 Math 315, 330, 351, 385 Class reading assignment Numerical score 2.2 Math 315, 330, 351, 385 Written solution to problems Numerical score 2.3 Math 315, 330, 351, 385 Class assignments Numerical score 2.3 Math 309, 311 Class assignments Numerical score Learning Outcome (2) Continued: Ability to think critically and analyze effectively Performance Criteria Class Achievement Activity Assessment Method 2.1 Math 302, 303, 322, 325, 351, 383 Class reading assignments Numerical score 2.2 Math 302, 303, Written solution to Numerical score 15 322, 325, 351, 383 problems 2.3 Math 302, 303, 322, 325, 351, 383 Class assignments Numerical score 2.1 Stat 343, 344, 346, 353 Class reading assignments Numerical score 2.2 Stat 343, 344, 346, 353 Written solution to problems Numerical score 2.3 Stat 343, 344, 346, 353 Class assignments Numerical score 2.4 Stat 343, 344, 346, 353 Class assignments Numerical score 2.1 CSc 228, 328, 329, Math 303, Stat 346, Econ 321 Class reading assignment Numerical score 2.2 CSc 228, 328, 329, Math 303, Stat 346, Econ 321 Written solution to problems Numerical score 2.3 CSc 228, 328, 329, Math 303, Stat 346, Econ 321 Class assignments Numerical score 2.4 CSc 228, 328, 329, Math 303, Stat 346, Econ 321 Class reading assignment Numerical score Learning Outcome (3): Problem Solving Performance Criteria Class Achievement Activity Assessment Method 3.1 Math 1 Class assignments Numerical score or qualitative assessment 3.2 Math 1 Class assignments Numerical score or qualitative 16 assessment 3,1 Math 8, 21, 22 Written solution to problems Numerical score 3.2 Math 8, 21, 22 Written solutions to problems Numerical score 3.1 Math 204 Written solution to problems Numerical score 3.2 Math 204 Written solutions to problems Numerical score 3.1 Math 208 Written solutions to problems Numerical score 3.2 Math 208 Short report on applications Numerical score 3.1 Math 209 Class assignments Numerical score 3.2 Math 209 Class assignments Numerical score 3.1 Stat 215, 217, 343 Written solution to problems Numerical score 3.2 Stat 215, 217, 343 Written solution to problems Numerical score 3.1 Math 309, 311 Written solution to problems Numerical score 3.2 Math 309, 311 Written solution to problems Numerical score Learning Outcome (3) Continued: Problem Solving Performance Criteria Class Achievement Activity Assessment Method 3.1 Math 361, 371, 381 Class assignments Numerical score or qualitative assessment 3.2 Math 361, 371, 381 Class assignments Numerical score or qualitative 17 assessment 3.1 Math 305, 306, 307, 308 Written solution to problems Numerical score 3.2 Math 305, 306, 307, 308 Written solution to problems Numerical score 3.1 Math 315, 330, 351, 385 Written solution to problems Numerical score 3.2 Math 315, 330, 351, 385 Written solution to problems Numerical score 3.1 Math 302, 303, 322, 325, 351, 383 Written solutions to problems Numerical score 3.2 Math 302, 303, 322, 325, 351, 383 Written solutions to problems Numerical score 3.1 Stat 343, 344, 346, 353 Class assignments Numerical score 3.2 Stat 343, 344, 346, 353 Class assignments Numerical score 3.3 Stat 343, 344, 346, 353 Class assignments and projects Numerical score 3.1 CSc 228, 328, 329, Math 303, Stat 346, Econ 321 Written solution to problems Numerical score 3.2 CSc 228, 328, 329, Math 303, Stat 346, Econ 321 Written solution to problems Numerical score Learning Outcome (4): Diverse Environments/Teamwork Performance Criteria Class Achievement Activity Assessment Method 4.1 Math 8, 21, 22 LEAD sessions Observation and level of participation 4.1 Math 361, 371, Group work in problem Observation/Numerical score 18 381 solving 4.1 Stat 343, 344, 346, 353 Group projects and presentations Numerical score and qualitative assessment 4.1 Stat 343, 344, 346, 353 Group projects and presentations Numerical score and qualitative assessment Learning Outcome (5): Professional and Ethical Responsibility Performance Criteria Class Achievement Activity Assessment Method 5.1 Math 1 Class discussions/case studies Qualitative assessment 5.3 Math 1 Class discussions Qualitative assessment 5.4 Math 1 Timeliness with attendance and assignments, academic honesty Numerical score 5.4 Math 8, 21, 22 Timeliness with attendance and assignments, academic honesty Numerical score 5.4 Math 204 Timeliness with attendance and assignments, academic honesty Numerical score Learning Outcome (5) Continued: Professional and Ethical Responsibility Performance Criteria Class Achievement Activity Assessment Method 5.4 Math 208 Timeliness with attendance and assignments, academic honesty Numerical score 19 5.4 Math 209 Timeliness with attendance and assignments, academic honesty Numerical score 5.4 Stat 215, 217, 343 Timeliness with attendance and assignments, academic honesty Numerical score 5.4 Math 309, 311 Timeliness with attendance and assignments, academic honesty Numerical score 5.1 Math 361, 371, 381 Class discussions/case studies Numerical score or qualitative assessment 5.2 Math 361, 371, 381 Class discussions/case studies Numerical score or qualitative assessment 5.3 Math 361, 371, 381 Class discussions/case studies Numerical score or qualitative assessment 5.4 Math 361, 371, 381 Timeliness with attendance and assignments, academic honesty Numerical score 5.4 Math 305, 306, 307, 308 Timeliness with attendance and assignments, academic honesty Numerical score Learning Outcome (5) Continued: Professional and Ethical Responsibility Performance Criteria Class Achievement Activity Assessment Method 5.4 Math 315, 330, 351, 385 Timeliness with attendance and assignments, academic honesty Numerical score 20 5.4 Math 302, 303, 322, 325, 351, 383 Timeliness with attendance and assignments, academic honesty Numerical score 5.1 Stat 343, 344, 346, 353 Case studies Qualitative assessment 5.3 Stat 343, 344, 346, 353 Class discussion and assignments Numerical score or qualitative assessment 5.4 CSc 228, 328, 329, Math 303, Stat 346, Econ 321 Timeliness with attendance and assignments, academic honesty Numerical score Learning Outcome (6): Awareness of National and Global Contemporary Issues Performance Criteria Class Achievement Activity Assessment Method 6.1 Math 1 Class discussions, reading assignments Numerical score or qualitative assessment 6.2 Math 1 Class discussions, reading assignments Numerical score or qualitative assessment 6.3 Math 1 Class discussions, reading assignments Numerical score or qualitative assessment 6.3 Math 361, 371, 381 Class discussions, reading assignments Numerical score or qualitative assessment Learning Outcome (7): Lifelong Learning Performance Criteria Class Achievement Activity Assessment Method 7.4 Math 1 Class reading assignments Numerical score or qualitative assessment 7.1 Math 209 Solving problems Numerical score 21 7.1 Stat 215, 217 343 Solving problems Numerical score 7.1 Math 309, 311 Solving problems Numerical score 7.2 Math 309, 311 Participation in professional organizations Level of participation 7.3 Math 309, 311 Reading assignments Qualitative assessment 7.4 Math 309, 311 Student seminars Level of participation 7.1 Math 361, 371, 381 Solving problems Numerical score 7.3 Math 361, 371, 381 Reading assignments Numerical score or qualitative assessment 7.4 Math 361, 371, 381 Student seminars Level of participation 7.1 Math 305, 306, 307, 308 Solving problems Numerical score 7.1 Math 315, 330, 351, 385 Solving problems Numerical score 7.3 Math 315, 330, 351, 385 Reading assignments Numerical score or qualitative assessment 7.4 Math 315, 330, 351, 385 Student seminars Level of participation Learning Outcome (7) Continued: Lifelong Learning Performance Criteria Class Achievement Activity Assessment Method 7.1 Math 302, 303, 322, 325, 351, 383 Solving problems Numerical score 22 7.1 Stat 343, 344, 346, 353 Solving problems Numerical score 7.3 Stat 343, 344, 346, 353 Reading assignments Numerical score or qualitative assessment 7.4 Stat 343, 344, 346, 353 Student seminars Level of attendence 7.1 CSc 228, 328, 329, Math 303, Stat 346, Econ 321 Solving problems Numerical score 23