Introduction to Rhetoric EN 1007 – Fall 2009 – Carol Poster Lecture

advertisement

Introduction to Rhetoric

EN 1007

– Fall 2009 – Carol Poster

Lecture 2 – Orality/Literacy – Sept 21

- Constantly surrounded by literate symbols. [Everyday life can’t go on without them].

- Illiterate = defective = primitive = savages.

- Homer; bible; colonialism o Events described in Homer happened several hundred years before composed. o Folktales/folkculture [homer] o Tremendous efforts to collect tales. [homer]

 [bible] divinity, religion.

 Priest goes to divinity school to become a priest.

Religion, religious studies [text; nature of].

 Historical problem of the time gap between the events described.

 Obvious variation from the old testament on different accounts.

Different details.

 Oral transmission.

 Homer & bible look familiar.

[colonialism] writing did not exist.

Discover that people that were non-literate [primary orality] were telling stories similar to Homer and the bible.

- What cultures were like before writing was invented, and how they differ from literate cultures before technologies were used? o Primary orality

– culture that has no relation with writing. o Non-Literate – people outside literate cultures. o Chirographic – culture that has writing. o Hyperliterate [people who write endlessly and casually]/Scribal [small route of professional scribes/higher class].

- 3500-3000 BCE

- Tally sticks [Shepard counting his sheep]

- Tokens, seals [identify something as your property/specific commercial problem]

- Earliest writing systems pictographs/ideographs. One symbol stands for one idea/thing. Symbols of tokens.

- Egyptian hieroglyphic [priestly writing].

- Chinese characters

- Syllabary

– 1 symbol = 1 syllable [dog-ma = dogman = phonetic representation]. o Syllabary and alphabet o Symbol means sound o Sound means thing o Alphabet.

- Changes in amount of lit and the kinds of lit develop different kinds of consciousness.

- Great divide theories vs. more nuanced theories of spectrum from orality to literacy.

- Technological determinism.

- Oral expression circulates in a culture where you have no backwards scan.

- Primary oral culture moves one way.

- Repetitive and additive.

- Subordinative clauses

– whole with parts – categories and subcategories.

- Genesis I – one detail after another – no summary.

1. Expression is additive rather than subordinative. a. Whole with parts – categories and subcategories.

2. Aggregative rather than analytic a. Pile up examples rather than analyze time to process.

3. Redundant or copious a. Tell them three times.

4. There is a tendency for it to be conservative a.

Traditional story stable and significant clichés are good.

5. Close to the human life world – ‘primary oral culture is little concerned with preserving knowledge of skills as an abstract, selfsubsistent corpus.’ a. Narrative.

6. Agonistically tones – ‘orality situates knowledge within a context of struggle’. a. Flat characters.

7. Empathetic and participatory rather than objectively distanced. a. Responsive to audiences.

8. Homeostatic – ‘oral societies live very much in the present which keeps itself in equilibrium or homeostasis by sloughing off memories which no longer have present relevance’. a. History is a product of writing. b. Folklore and technical manuals.

9. Situation rather than abstract

– people in oral cultures tend to think more about the situation – the here and now – rather than the abstract hypotherical.

Oral Derived Text

- Orality in composition, performance, and transmission.

- Oral traditional composition and its role in cultural memory.

- Formal qualities of oral composition. o How do you compose something that is an hour or two long without writing that is in poetic form. o Building blocks for story, scene and line. o Epithets

– wine dark sea. o Referentiality. o Repetition.

- Analysis of theogony and Genesis.

- Brief analysis of modern cosmogonies.

- Varying levels of literacy – both cultural and individual within culture.

- Origin and evolution of writing.

- Preview: background to Gorgias (origins of Greek literacy)

Download