MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE
TRIBUNAL : NAGPUR BENCH
:
NAGPUR
BEFORE THE HON’BLE SHRI B. MAJUMDAR : VICE CHAIRMAN AND
DIVISION BENCH
HON’BLE JUSTICE SHRI M.N.GILANI : MEMBER (J)
( COURT HALL “A”)
(Time:-11:00 A.M.)
DATE – 01.09.2014.
PRONOUNCEMENT OF ORDERS
1
O.A.565/03
D.P.Sonone
Adv.D.G.Patil,S.V.Ingole,J.S.Wankhede
S.J. Khandalkar,R.N.Meshram
State & ors.
P.O.
2
O.A.581/13
N.S.Barapatre
Adv.B.M.Kharkate
State & ors
p.o
ORDER MATTERS
1
MCA 11/14
MCA 12/14 in
O.A.471/02
Capt. D.N. Tatwawadi
Adv.M.R.Parkhi,M.K.Deshpande
Kirti Satpute ,A.P.Narad
2
C.A.276/14
in O.A. 569/08
P.A.Chauhan
Adv. S.P.Palshikar
Mrs,
State & Ors.
P.O.
For cond of
delay
For restoration
State & Ors
P.O.
For
hearing
early
Adv. S.U.Nemade,R.R.
Rathod,R.J.Shinde
for R-4
3
O.A.248/14
Smt. Alka M. Gaikwad
Adv.P.V.Thakre, A. Pannase
State & Ors
P.O.
Reply not filed
by p.o
4
O.A.282/14
Miss. Shubhangi S. Gurve
Adv.V.S.Kukday,Miss. Mukta P.
Thakre
State & Ors.
P.O.
Reply not filed
by p.o
5
C.A.338/14 in
O.A.463/14
D.M.Holi
Adv.G.N.Khanzode,Mrs. Prachi T.Joshi
State & Ors.
P.O.
For Interim
Direction
O.A.18/14
J.M.Kawade
Adv.V.N.,D.V. & M.D.Mahajan
State & Ors.
p.o
Reply not filed
by P.O.
P.V.Shirbhate
Adv.A.C.Dharmadhikari ,R.V.Shiralkar
V.Bhise,D.Pathak
State & Ors.
P.O.
.
6
ADMISSION MATTERS
1
O.A.498/11
2
O.A.828/12
G.K.Kshirsagar
Adv.S.O.Ahmed
State & ors
p.o
3
O.A.759/13
S.D.Aglave
Adv.R.V.Shiralkar
State n& ors
p.o
Adv.P.S.Patil for R-3 &
C.A.Joshi,M.S.Sambre,
S.C.Joshi for R-4
Reply of R-4 not
filed.
4
O.A.67/14
D.K.Deshpande
In person
State & Ors.
P.O.
5
O.A.197/14
with
R.R.Gathe
Adv.S.D. Dhongde(Aurangabad)
State & ors
P.O.
6
O.A.227/14
N.B.Pali
Adv. S.D. Dhongde (Aurangabad)
State & Ors.
P.O.
7
O.A.439/14
with
R.H.Naiknaware
Adv.S.U.Bhuyar
State & ors.
P.O.
8
O.A.440/14
with
M.M.Rathod
Adv.S.U.Bhuyar
State & ors.
p.o
O.A.441/14
P.N.Chavan
Adsv.S.U.Bhuyar
State & ors
p.o
9
10
O.A.520/14
A.S.Dandge
Adv.V.A.Kothale
State & ors.
11
O.A.521/14
With
C.R.Awasthi
Adv.R.S.Khobragade,Mrs.
S.R.Khobragade
Sheikh Juned Akhtar
Adv.R.S.Khobragade,Mrs.
S.R.Khobragade
Deepak O. Dhande
Adv.R.S.Khobragade,Mrs.S.R.
Khobragade
A.V.Shiwale
Adv.
R.S.Khobragade,Mrs.
Khobragade
D.A. Thakur
Adv.N.Phadnis, K.Nalamwar
State & ors
p.o
12
O.A.522/14
With
13
O.A.523/14
With
14
O.A.524/14
15
O.A.525/14
State & ors
p.o
State & ors
- p.o
State & ors
S.R. p.o
State & ors.
p.o
CONNECTED MATTER FROM Sr. No. 16 to 50.
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
O.A.86/14
With
O.A. 87/14
O.A. 88/14
O.A. 89/14
O.A. 90/14
O.A.91/14
O.A.92/14
O.A. 93/14
O.A. 94/14
O.A.95/14
O.A. 96/14
O.A. 97/14
O.A.98/14
O.A.99/14
S.R.Pachpor
State & Ors.
Adv..J.R.Kidilay
P.O.
H.N.Ranotkar
P.G. Mathurkar
Ms. U.S.Rase
M.B.Sawarkar
R.G.Bilolikar
M.K.Kulkarni
P.F.Dorlikar
N.V.Dorlikar
Adv.J.R.Kidilay
S.R.Patil
S.M. Kathoye
Miss, V.V.Kadu
S.P.Soge
V.B. Khobragade
Reply not filed
by P.O.
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
O.A.100/14
O.A.101/14
O.A.102/14
O.A.103/14
O.A.104/14
O.A.105/14
O.A. 106/14
O.A.107/14
O.A. 108/14
O.A.109/14
O.A.110/14
O.A. 111/14
O.A. 112/14
O.A.113/14
O.A.114/14
O.A.115/14
O.A. 116/14
O.A.117/14
O.A. 118/14
O.A.263/14
O.A.341/14
O.A.462/14
50
P.P.Dhakulkar
P.R.Holey
Y.V.Lahane
A.V.Abhayankar
S.S.Kamble
M.M.Ghulaxe
S.P.Thakre
A.B.Tatte
R.K.Kolhapure
S.S.Dohe
M.V.Lande
S.V.Bahale
T.G.Dhanake
S.S..D.Ambade
S.M.Bante
A.N.Wankhede
G.R.Sawant
L.N.Raut
R.P.Badole
P.D.Kadam
S.V.Kulkarni
Adv.S.P.Palshikar
A.S.Bhagat
Adv.R.V.Shiralkar
State & Ors.
P.O.
not
P.O.
Reply
filed by
HEARING PARTIES MATTERS
1
O.A.578/13
R.R.Mallewar
Adv.Kirti Satpute,Atul Bhavsar
State & ors
p.o
2
O.A.627/07
P.T.Shinde
Adv.V.G. & S.V.Wankhede,S.N.Gaikwad
State & ors
p.o
3
O.A.41/10
With C.A.123/11
All India Adiwasi Employees Federation
Adv.N.R.Saboo
State & ors
p.o
4
O.A.157/11
M.S.Pakhale
Adv.V.A.Kothale
State & ors
p.o
Adv.S.G.Jagtap,
S.S.Godbole for R-3
5
O.A.336/11
R.G.Kumbhare
Adv.Menaxi Iyer
State & ors
p.o
O.A.645/12
J.S.Meshram
Adv. Prashant Thakre,Smt. Vijaya Thakre
State & ors
p.o
O.A.971/12
T.K.Sorte
Adv.S.W.Sambre,M.V.Raut
R.S.Suryawanshi
6
7
State & ors
& p.o
Direction
8
O.A.201/13
with
M.S.Rahangdale & 3 ors
Adv.Kirti Satpute,Atul Bhawsar
State & ors.
Adv.A.A.Madiwale for
R-5 to 9.
9
O.A.231/13
With
G.R.Nagpure
Adv.Kirti Satpute,Atul Bhawsar
State & ors.
Adv.A.A.Madiwale for
R-4 to 8
O.A.232/13
N.M.Vedi
Adv.Atul Bhawsar
State & ors
p.o
Adv. A.A. Madiwale for
R -5 to 8
K.S.Rahangdale
Adv.P.K.Mishra
State & ors
p.o
10
11
O.A.589/13
Note- After this board, matters from weekly hearing board may be called.
SRG
Dy. Registrar,
Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal,
Nagpur.
MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE
TRIBUNAL : NAGPUR BENCH
NAGPUR
BEFORE THE HON’BLE SHRI S.S.HINGNE : MEMBER (J)
SINGLE BENCH
(Time :- 11:00 A.M.)
DATE– 01.09.2014.
( COURT HALL “B”)
ORDER MATTERS.
1
O.A.191/13
M.A.Kruplani
Adv.G.K.Bhusari,T.R.Agrawal
State & Ors.
P.O.
Reply not
filed by p.o
2
O.A.764/13
Mazahar Ahemad Walid Jammer Khan
Adv.R.J.Mirza,S.O.
Ahemed,D.R.Kharat,J.A. Malnas
State & ors
p. o
Reply not filed by p.o
3
Rev. No. 06/14
O.A. 74/14
With C.A.313/14
Prakash U.Wadhai
Adv.N.B.Bargat,M.N.Jogi,
N.Pradnyakar
State & Ors.
P.O.
R-3 await service
4
C.A. 142/14 in
O.A.St. 546/14
P.R.Chavhan
Adv.P.S.Wathore,K.P.Wathore
State & Ors.
P.O.
Reply to the C.A. not
filed
5
O.A.247/14
V.H.Kale
Adv.A.S.Dhore
State & Ors.
P.O.
Rejoinder not filed
6
O.A.28/14
Neeta D.Pise
Adv.R.V.Shiralkar
State & Ors.
P.O.
7
O.A.346/14
Haji M. Abdul Wahab
Adv.G.G.Bade,S.K.Thengri,P.P. Khaparde
State & Ors.
P.O.
8
O.A.355/14
K.G.Meshram
Adv. P.V.Thakre
State & Ors.
P.O.
9
O.A.505/14
K.R.Chungde
Adv.G.N. Khanzode
State & Ors.
P.O.
Reply not filed by p.o
10
O.A.567/14
R.B.Nimbekar
Adv.G.G.Bade,S.K.Thengri,P.P.Khaparde
State & ors
p.o
Adv.D.M.Kakani for
R-1 to 3.
R-2 to 4 await service
ADDMISSION MATERS
1
O.A.373/14 M.V.Akotkar
with
Adv.M.I.Dhatrak,S.A.Sahu
2
O.A.374/14
With
3
O.A.375/14
State & Ors.
P.O.
S.L.Panzade
Adv.M.I.Dhatrak.S.Sahu
State & Ors.
P.O.
V.A. Deolikar
State & Ors.
Adv.M.I.Dhatrak, Sahu
P.O
Reply not filed
by p.o
R-2 to 5 await service
Reply not filed by p.o
4
5
O.A.396/14
O.A.400/14
D.M.Paikrao
State & Ors.
Adv.S.S.Dhengle
P.O.
D.K.Bobade
Adv.N.S. Bhelkar ,V.G. Bhamburkar
Mrs.S.P.Kulkarni
State & Ors.
P.O.
Adv.N.A.Gawande
for R-3
6
O.A.437/14
Smt. Savita A. Kutekar
Adv.P.B.Patil
State & Ors.
P.O.
7
O.A.456/14
B.G.Kendre
Adv.S.N.Gaikwad
State & Ors.
P.O.
8
O.A.469/14
K.R.Singh
State & Ors.
P.O.
Adv.S.Z.Sonbhadre,A.S.Meshram
9
O.A.528/14
Adv.M.I.Dhatrak A.Sahu
State & Ors.
P.O.
M.M.Madavi
10
O.A.536/14
C.K. Sharnagat
Adv. P.V.Thakre
State & Ors.
P.O.
11
O.A.560/14
S.N.Khadse
State & Ors.
P.O.
Adv.H.D.Dangre,G.Dipwani,N. Autkar
HEARING PARTIES MATTERS
1
2
O.A.883/12
With
S.D.Chandawar
Adv.G.G.Bade
State & Ors.
P.O.
O.A.906/12
A.B.Makalwar
Adv.G.G.Bade
State & Ors.
P.O.
3
O.A.773/11
G.B.Pawar
Adv.S.P.Palshikar
State & Ors.
P.O.
4
O.A.330/12
S.P.Mahalkar
Adv. K.K.Pathak,S.Pathak
State & Ors.
P.O.
5
O.A.624/12
V.J.Bhole
Adv. P.N.Warjurkar
State & Ors.
P.O.
6
O.A.07/13
R.B.Suradkar
Adv.M.V.Mohokar
State & Ors.
P.O.
7
O.A.67/13
T.L.Mankar
Adv.R.N. & M.R.Patil
State & Ors.
P.O.
P.H.
7-A
O.A.124/13
O.K.Patre
Adv.K.S.Motwani & G.R.Agrawal
State & Ors.
P.O.
Adv.S.A.Radke,V.D.
Raut,N.B.Gaikwad,
M.S.Bhevgate for
R-4.
8
O.A.298/13
S.K.Alone
Adv.S.Y.Deopujari C.U.Deopujari
State & Ors.
P.O.
9
O.A.306/13
Dr.H.T.thorat & 2 ors
Adv.R.V.Shiralkar
State & Ors.
P.O.
10
O.A.365/13
B.S. Birajdar
Adv.S.P.Palshikar
State & Ors.
P.O.
11
O.A.443/13
G.T.Jadhao
Adv.N.S. KadamS.R.BhongadeA.K.Mahav
State & Ors.
P.O.
12
O.A.517/13
B.H.Bibe
Adv.Bharat Kulkarni
State & Ors.
P.O.
13
O.A.35/14
Ku.M.S. Bhoskar
Adv. Shashikant Borkar ,K.Deshmukh
State & Ors.
P.O.
14
O.A.191/14
G.N.Yadav
Adv.S.P.Palshikar
15
16
SRG
O.A.213/14
A.S.Khandare
Adv.S.P.Palshikar,, N.S.Warulkar
State & Ors.
P.O.
State & Ors.
P.O.
O.A.256/14
R.V.Yewale
Adv. J.Y.Ghurde, V.B.Bhise
State & Ors.
P.O.
Reply not filed by P.O.
Reply not filed by P.O.
Dy. Registrar,
Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal,
Nagpur.
MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL : NAGPUR BENCH
: NAGPUR
BEFORE THE HON’BLE REGISTRAR
( OBJECTION BOARD)
DATE – 01.09.2014.
(Time 11.00 A.M. to 2.00 P.M.)
OBJECTION MATTERS
1
C.A.326/14 in
O.A.460/14
2
C.A.336/14 in V.T.Tare
O.A.St.
Adv.J.B.Gandhi
1325/14
3
O.A.263/13
The Association of Sub-ordinate State & Ors.
service Engg.
P.O.
Adv.N.R.Saboo
R-4,6,& 10 await service
4
O.A.42/14
D.K.Gajbhiye
State & Ors.
Adv.Mrs. Swati Paunikar ,Mrs. P.O.
S.A. Vyas
R-2 & 3 await service
5
O.A.190/14
Satar Khan Mumtaj Khan
Adv.R.S.Sirpurkar, N.B.Jawade
State & ors.
P.O.
R-2 await service
6
O.A.216/14
K.A.Deshmukh
Adv.G.G.Bade,P.P.Khaparde
State & Ors.
P.O.
R-2 to 4 await service
7
O.A.258/14
V.S.,Kolhe
Adv.H.Marathe,G.P. Belsare
State & ors
P.O.
R-2 to 4 await service
8
O.A.318/14
A.D.Mangrulkar
Adv.P.C.Marpakwar,S.M.Khan
State & ors
P.O.
Reply not filed by p.o
SRG
M.H.Gaikwad
Adv. D.M.Kakani,G.K.Bhusari
State & Ors.
P.O.
Amendment not carried
State & Ors.
P.O.
Office objection not
removed
Dy. Registrar,
Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal,
Nagpur.
MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE
TRIBUNAL : NAGPUR BENCH
:
NAGPUR
BEFORE THE HON’BLE SHRI B. MAJUMDAR : VICE CHAIRMAN AND
DIVISION BENCH
HON’BLE JUSTICE SHRI M.N.GILANI : MEMBER (J)
( COURT HALL “A”)
DATE – (01.09.2014.-
06.09.2014)
(WEEKLY HEARING BOARD)
HEARING PARTIES MATTERS
1
O.A.705/99
With C.A.342/14
WITH
Maharashtra Sashan Dugdha Tantradnya
Sanghatna
Adv.D.L. & R.Dharmadhikari,Miss.Mrinal
Hiwase & L.Thawkar
J.J.Pise & 11 Ors.
Adv.K.L.Dharmadhikari,Mrs.M.P.Kathalay
State & Ors.
P.O.
2
O.A.564/00
3
O.A.216/02
With C.A.739/03
Dr.S.N.Gumble
Adv.Smt.S.W.Deshpande
State & Ors.
P.O.
4
O.A.91/03
P.S.Patil & 3 Ors.
Adv.V.D.Raut & M.D.Chikhale
State & Ors.
P.O.
5
O.A.259/03
Dr.M.G.Deo
Adv.Shrikant Deo & S.Ghate
State & Ors.
P.O.
S.K.Burkul
Adv.D.T.Shinde
(Leave upto 12/09/2014)
State & Ors.
P.O.
6
O.A.550/03
With C.A.283/14
State & Ors.
P.O.
7
O.A.580/03
D.K.Panchbhai
Adv.N.S.Badhe & Shabana Karim
State & Ors.
P.O.
Adv.P.B.Patil
&
S.P.Pawar,
A.D.Dongre for R-2.
8
O.A.591/03
R.C.Singh
Adv.D.T.Shinde
(Leave upto 12/09/2014)
State & Ors.
P.O.
9
O.A.617/03
WITH
A.K.Khamborkar
Adv.G.N.Khanzode
State & Ors.
P.O.
Adv.Govind Mishra,
Miss.Jyotsna
Shendey for R-4.
Kishorsingh R.Chungade & Another
Adv.G.N.Khanzode
State & Ors.
P.O.
S.G.Vighe
Adv.G.N.Khanzode
State & Ors.
P.O.
S.G.Narwade
Adv.G.N.Khanzode
State & Ors.
P.O.
10
O.A.618/03
WITH
11
O.A.119/04
WITH
O.A.186/04
12
(High Court
Direction)
For
Documents.
For Direction.
For
Amendment.
O.A.249/04
S.M.Shami & Another
Adv.G.N.Khanzode
State & Ors
P.O.
Adv.M.I.Dhatrak
for R-6
A.C.Dharmadhikari
,
R.V.Shiralkar,
V.B.Gosewade &
P.Gode for R-5
O.A.268/04
W.A. s/o A.Siddiqui
Adv.S.S.Adkar & F.Mirza
State & Ors
P.O.
15
With
O.A.213/05
W.A. s/o A.Siddiqui
Adv.S.Adkar, M.R.Khan & K.R.Sheikh
State & Ors
P.O.
16
O.A.278/04
Pravin U. Ambhore & 36 Ors.
Adv.A.B.Bambal & G.P.Bhave
State & Ors.
P.O.
17
O.A.405/04
V.S.Dongre & 2 Ors.
Adv.A.M.Tayde, S.M.Bhagde,
Smt.G.S.Bhagde
State & Ors
P.O.
18
O.A.452/04
Dr.S.M.Mamidwar
Adv.A.S.Jaiswal & M.P.Rajkondawar
State & Ors
P.O.
Adv.P.A.Shendre,
P.I. Choube &
V.Deotare for R-3
19
O.A.511/04
M.K.Aatram
Adv.A.C.Dharmadhikari,R.V.Shiralkar
,P.Gode,N.A. Gaikwad
State & Ors.
P.O.
20
O.A.525/04
R.Singh I.Singh Rajput
Adv.J.B.Kasal, Sau. S.J.Kasat &
V.Dahat
State & Ors
P.O.
21
O.A.550/04
V.R.Chavhan
Adv.A.C.Dharmadhikari, R.V.Shiralkar
T.N.Udeshi & N.A.Gaikwad
State & Ors.
P.O.
Adv.A.Joshi
&
R.Deo for R-14
P.C.Marpakwar &
T.B.Golhar for R-18
22
O.A.560/04
With
H.T.Bohide
Adv.V.R.Choudhari, R.Modkholkar &
R.A.Ponwatkar
State & Ors.
P.O.
Adv.S.P.Palshikar
for Intervener
23
O.A.217/08
With
C.A.271/14
R.V.Bhaskare
Adv.S.P.Palshikar
State & Ors.
P.O.
For Direction
24
O.A.571/04
U.T.Raut & 4 Ors.
Adv.S.A.Gordey
State & Ors.
P.O.
Intimation Notice
served to applicants
13
14
25
O.A.597/04
S.N.Nakhale
Adv. N.Raut, P.S.Patil
State & Ors.
P.O.
26
O.A.633/04
S.M. Waradpande
Adv.S.B.Ninawe.V.Y.Kaole,C.S. Paunikar
State & Ors.
P.O.
27
O.A.49/05
M.A.Sheikh Daulat
Adv.S.P.Hedaoo & S.S.Hedao
State & Ors.
P.O.
28
O.A.72/05
K.N.Nikhade
Adv.M.L.Bhure, A.Z.Jibhkate &
S.Tambulkar
State & Ors.
P.O.
Adv.I.L.Badade,
G.G.Mishra,
S.R.Gaikee, M.Patil
& S.Majid for R-3
29
O.A.95/05
G.D.Anjankar
Adv.S.Bhandarkar, R.G.Hingnekar,
Ms.A.Patwardhan & R.V.Shiralkar
State & Ors.
P.O.
V.R.Chicholkar
Adv.B.G.Kulkarni,R.V.Shiralkar,
Vipul Bhise,Anand Parchure,
S.S.Khandekar
State & Ors.
P.O.
R.L.Mayur
Adv.S.R.Narnaware
State & Ors.
P.O.
Adv.A.Deshpande
for
R-3
&
N.B.Kalwaghe for
R-2
30
31
APS.
O.A.158/05
O.A.564/05
Dy. Registrar,
Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal,
Nagpur.