Scuba Diving Industry Analysis Candice Reid & Lindsay Lyster Section Seven Environmental Considerations 1 Scuba Diving Industry Analysis Candice Reid & Lindsay Lyster Introduction Before discussing the environmental impacts of the SCUBA diving industry, we must first identify the environment with which it takes place in. To begin, all environments are directly related to each other, through wind and water. This being said, what affects one continent, can adversely affect another. This has been noted throughout history, when adverse weather on one side of the globe, affects the tides and ocean currents on the other side. To continue, SCUBA diving takes place in the water. However, the manufacture of equipment does not. Manufacturing takes place on land, and the equipment is then distributed all over the world via train, truck, and plane. The equipment is then housed in stores, where the consumers can access it via vehicle, and purchase it for their own use. In order to use the equipment, divers must access a dive location, either by train, vehicle, or plane. This then takes them to lodging which provides food, shelter and accommodations. That being said, the diver’s still need to reach the dive site. This means they must once again travel, this time more likely by boat, to their destination. Once in the water, divers are directly in contact with a variety of very delicate animal and plant species, which react harshly to abrupt or dramatic changes to their ecosystem1. Although most regular divers have ways of limiting their impact while in the water, many tourists do not know, or respect these rules. There are serious impacts on the reef ecosystems from people who do not respect the boundaries of recreational SCUBA diving. Matter of fact, deliberate removal of specimens is the most damaging impact humans have on coral reefs. Once the dive is completed, divers must retrace their steps, all the way home. In most cases, equipment is not sold second hand, it is used until it no longer functions to the desired purpose, and then disposed of. This results in excess wastes associated with dive equipment, which is deposited in landfills, and such to spend decades decomposing. Although most of the associated impacts of diving are minimal, the realistic impact of the industry as a whole is large and diverse. 1 Ecosystem: a system involving the interactions between a community of living organisms in a particular area and its nonliving environment (Collinsdictionary.com) 2 Scuba Diving Industry Analysis Candice Reid & Lindsay Lyster Humans are above all a very destructive species. They consume a large amount of resources and excrete a large amount of wastes. This overall has had an impressive impact on our planet, in a large variety of ways. Listed below are some of the various products of humanity, which impact our planet, and can be related to SCUBA diving. They are connected to each other in somewhat of a cyclical process, and are necessary for the function of many of our modern day comforts. However, in this report they are highlighted for their involvement in the SCUBA diving industry in particular. • Air traffic associated with tourism • Boat traffic associated with tourism • Advertising (pamphlets, coupons, brochures, etc.) • Lodging and accommodations • Marine waste (boat fuel, garbage, emissions, general waste etc.) • Food production and waste associated with airlines • Food production and waste associated with lodging • Equipment manufacturer’s consumption of resources (wood, minerals, oil etc.) • Factory waste and emissions • Distribution and delivery emissions, wastes, and consumptions • Cross contamination2from bodies of water • Invasive species3 and species disturbance • Souvenir collecting • Land use (coastal development, and irrigation drainage etc.) • Waste disposal • Pipelines, drilling, and mineral mining • Clear cutting4, logging 2 The transfer of living organisms between one location and another Invasive Species: An alien species whose introduction does or is likely to cause economic or environmental harm or harm to human health (Invasivespecies.org) 4 Clear Cutting: Removal of all the trees in a stand of timber (Merriam-webster.com) 3 3 Scuba Diving Industry Analysis Candice Reid & Lindsay Lyster Figure 38: Total Human Impact on World’s Oceans, Mapped for The First Time (B. S. Halpern, www.Guardian.co.uk) Environmental Issues Pollution, fishing, and climate change have all left a permanent mark on all of the world’s oceans. The above map represents the impact humans have had on many of the world’s bodies of water. To make the map, scientists compiled global data on the impacts of 17 human activities including fishing, coastal development, fertilizer runoff and pollution from shipping traffic. More than 40% of the oceans have been heavily affected. As seen above, the most severe impact is on the North Sea, the South and East Chinese Seas, the Caribbean, the Mediterranean, the Red Sea, the Gulf, the Bering Sea, along the eastern coast of North America and in much of the western Pacific. The oceans at either end of the poles are one of the least impacted, however due to the 4 Scuba Diving Industry Analysis Candice Reid & Lindsay Lyster melting of the ice sheets they too will soon become more vulnerable. When this study was taking placed scientists noticed that almost half of the world’s coral reefs have been extremely damaged, other concerns are seagrass beds5, mangrove forests6, seamounts7, rocky reefs8 and continental shelves9. Pollution Pollution levels of the Earth have begun to reach beyond our planet’s carrying capacity. This has been caused by the increase in human population, as well as our interactions with the varying ecosystems with which we live in. Two thirds of major cities worldwide are located along coasts, and millions of people vacation along shorelines, it is because of this that pollution from these developed areas that causes waste to drain into oceans and kill marine life, not to mention threaten human health. As a result this also causes toxic algae to bloom, forcing beaches to close. This pollution also destroys coral reefs and coastal habitats, which are extremely crucial for breeding, food, and shelter. Ocean currents themselves can carry these pollutants far from the source of entry, which also can cause major declines in species due to consumption of these pollutants, threatening the planets’ ecological stability, which is our species life support. Carbon Emissions10 are polluting the ocean, and depleting the ozone layer causing global warming and destruction of species. Carbon emissions come from the burning of fossil fuels11, which have caused an increase in acidity in our oceans over the last two decades. Due to this it could potentially affect the ability of the ocean to absorb greenhouse gases12. “Ocean acidification has already increased the acidity of the world's oceans to a ‘level that is 5 Seagrass beds: Sandy bays often have extensive mats of seagrass (Ask.com) Mangrove Forest: Mangroves are trees and shrubs that grow in saline coastal habitats in the tropics and subtropics (Wikipedia.com) 7 Seamounts: A submarine mountain (Wikipedia.com) 8 Rocky Reefs: Fascinating habitats that are rich in life. Many marine animals and plants need to attach themselves to something solid for their survival (Mesa.edu.au) 9 Continental Shelves: The area of seabed around a large landmass where the sea is relatively shallow compared with the open ocean. (Wikipedia.com) 10 Carbon Emissions: the release of carbon into the atmosphere (Ecolife.com) 11 Fossil Fuels: Are formed over the course of millions of years from organic matter as they decay, are compressed, and heated and then trapped underground where they have remained. Once discovered they are mined or pumped out to the earth’s surface and used as a source of fuel such as coal, oil, and natural gas (Ecolife.com) 12 Greenhouse Gases: Is a gas that absorbs and releases radiation within our atmosphere (Ecolife.com) 6 5 Scuba Diving Industry Analysis Candice Reid & Lindsay Lyster irreversible in our lifetimes.’” (eco-pros, www.eco-pros.com). Statistics Canada completed studies on human activity and the environment from 2007 to 2008. These studies show how our species has inadvertently damaged our world, through water transport, air transport, and the consumption of petroleum products, and their associated emissions. Canada alone is responsible for transporting over 590 billion people, by ferry, between 1989 and 2004. In Canada alone, an average 32.7 million people a year, travel by ferry. Between the 1988 and 2006, Canada was responsible for transporting an average 40.2 million people via air travel every year, over 760 billion people throughout nineteen years. This information may not seem so daunting, until you review the statistics for consumption of refined petroleum products by the transportation industry, between 1992, and 2006. Marine traffic was responsible for a total of 38,867 cubic metres of refined petroleum products, which is approximately 2,657.8 cubic metres per year. Airlines were responsible for a staggering total of 75, 871 cubic metres of refined petroleum products, approximately 5,058 cubic metres, per year. Statistics Canada also included a study of air contaminate emissions for 2005. This study shows emissions which fall into two categories, VOC’s (volatile organic compounds) and PM’s (particulate matter, made up of solid and liquid particles, fewer than 100 micrometres in diameter). Air transit emitted 10,076 VOC’s and, 1,022PM102 in 2005, and marine transit, emitted 5,820PM102, and 8,0356 VOC’s. Overall, domestic greenhouse gas emissions has increased by 27.5% since 1990, and domestic aviation has increased by 35.9%. All these signs do not bode well for the environmentally friendly image which SCUBA diving has maintained over the years. With the ozone layer slowly depleting, this can cause a serious decline in the worlds oceanic plankton, which are tiny organisms which are the first main source in which providing the marine and sea life with food. Decreases in plankton would severely impact all aquatic and marine wildlife, and break the aquatic food chain. Fishing Fishing and its associated activities has always been one of our species main methods of sustenance. For centuries humans have fished the world’s bodies of water, and for centuries this habit was sustainable. However, after the industrial revolution, and throughout the increase in the human population, fishing has developed into more and more of an unsustainable food 6 Scuba Diving Industry Analysis Candice Reid & Lindsay Lyster harvesting technique. Beginning with the mass harpoon hunting of whales and seals, and followed by the overfishing of the Cod, humans have consistently developed a greater and greater advantage over the marine environment. Listed below, are a variety of ways with which humans have increased their advantage over marine life, and developed their fishing techniques to continue to sustain our ever growing population. Trawling and dredging: Trawlers are like vacuum cleaners that pass through the ocean drag heavy nets, chains and gear along the bottom of the ocean, destroying all life forms and habitats and many ecosystems. The seafloor is tremendously important to maintain biodiversity13 in the ocean. By dragging along this equipment, marine ecosystems become ripped up, crushed, exposed and buried. When thinking of this we must keep in mind that some of these organisms took hundreds of years, may have taken some thousands to develop. For instance, sea corals provide critical habitats for fish and other organisms in marine ecosystems. Of the sea life that gets “scraped” up, approximately 70% of that is not used. “According to the Food and Agriculture Organization of the U.N., indiscriminate fishing practices kill and waste between 18 and 40 million metric tons of "unwanted" fish, seabirds, sea turtles, marine mammals, and other ocean life annually - fully one-third of the world catch” (eco-pros, www.eco-pros.com). Climate Change One of the most debilitating effects humans are having on the world, is our impact on the climate. It may not be easy to see in our everyday activities, yet it is undoubtedly there. Through the development of land, and river ways, to pollution in the oceans, humans are adversely affecting the world’s global climate. Humans are constantly developing the land, tearing down forests and digging up meadows. We destroy natural habitats to build homes for ourselves, and stores to shop in. This is an all too well known process to most people. However, what most people do not know, or do not think about, is the fact that these rivers are a network across our country, other species rely on this land for food, shelter and water, the very same 13 Biodiversity: the essential variety on our planet, including all organisms and species and their individual genetic variations and how they assemble themselves into harmonized biomes and ecosystems (Ecolife.com) 7 Scuba Diving Industry Analysis Candice Reid & Lindsay Lyster things we ignorantly demand for ourselves. It is the first step that we as a species took, towards affecting the climate around the world. With the industrial revolution, humans began to tip the scales in the atmosphere. It was no longer possible for the ocean and the atmosphere to recycle the gases we were pumping out of our homes and factories. Not so long afterwards, these very same gases, after being cycled through the atmosphere all over the world, were being dumped back into our oceans and forest. These same oceans were already chock full of garbage and wastes, which they carried all across the world, until years later they would be dumped outside of British Columbia, and California, in humanities greatest creation; an entire landmass made of garbage. Still to this day, we are constantly dumping refuse into the ecosystems of our planet, and these greenhouse gases and volatile emissions 14are beyond being recycled. The ozone is being depleted, and with the loss of protection, our planet is slowly cooking under the intense heat of the sun. The polar ice caps are melting, dumping more freshwater into the oceans, upsetting the balance that marine life depends upon for survival. The major ocean currents as seen in Figure 39 are transporting these freshly melted waters across the globe, affecting even the entire water network. Adverse weather is becoming a problem, as the atmosphere becomes more and more unstable, affecting places all around the world. To summarize, it is the initial ignorance of our species, combined with our innate greed, which has brought our world to the state it resides in today. It is only through knowledge and hard work, that we will be able to preserve and stabilize our planet for future inhabitants. Figure 39: Ocean Currents 14 Volatile Emissions: easily evaporated emissions 8 Scuba Diving Industry Analysis Candice Reid & Lindsay Lyster (Ocean Currents. www.kidsgeo.com) Land Management and Conflicts The ocean is one of Earth's most valuable natural resources. It provides food in the form of fish and shellfish—about 200 billion pounds are caught each year. It's used for transportation—both travel and shipping. It provides a treasured source of recreation for humans. It is mined for minerals (salt, sand, gravel, and some manganese, copper, nickel, iron, and cobalt can be found in the deep sea) and drilled for crude oil. The ocean plays a critical role in removing carbon from the atmosphere and providing oxygen and it regulates the Earth's climate. The ocean is an increasingly important source of biomedical organisms15 with enormous potential for fighting disease. Fisheries provide about 16% of the world’s protein, making them extremely important to the economy. The number of fish caught in a year varies however; the numbers have dropped significantly over the years potentially due to over fishing. Fish are caught in a variety of ways, 15 Biomedical Organisms: organisms relating to both biology and medicine 9 Scuba Diving Industry Analysis Candice Reid & Lindsay Lyster including one-man casting nets, huge trawlers, seining, drift netting, handlining, longlining, gillnetting and diving which all have a huge impact on the destruction of the underwater ecosystems. There are a variety of ships which are used for transportation purposes. Some of which are Steam turbine plants or diesel engines, however there are wind-powered ships that are also used. Naval ships are the most common type used to transport goods. Other ships include container ships, tankers, crude oil ships, product ships, chemical ships, bulk carriers, cable layers, general cargo ships, offshore supply vessels, dynamically-positioned ships, ferries, gas and car carriers, tugboats, barges and dredgers. Shipping things across the oceans can have a low impact in the long run on the environment however, it is serious oil spills, dumping of wastes into the ocean, chemical accidents at sea and inevitable air and water pollution that can instantly have a huge impact on the environment and cause serious damage to the underwater ecology. Ships release sulphur dioxide16, nitrogen oxides17, carbon dioxide18, hydrocarbons19 and carbon monoxide20. Chemicals dumped in the ocean from ships include chemicals from the ship itself, cleaning chemicals for machine parts, and cleaning supplies for living quarters. Large amounts of chemicals are often spilled into the ocean and sewage is not always treated properly or treated at all. Alien species riding in the ballast water of ships arrive in great numbers to crash native ecosystems and garbage is dumped over the side of many vessels. Dangerous industrial waste and harmful substances like halogenated hydrocarbons21, water treatment chemicals, and antifouling paints22 are also dumped frequently. Ships and other watercraft with engines disturb 16 Sulphur Dioxide: a colorless toxic gas (SO2) that occurs in the gases from volcanoes (Wikipedia.com) Nitrogen Oxide: any of several oxides of nitrogen formed by the action of nitric acid on oxidizable materials (Wikipedia.com) 18 Carbon Dioxide: A colorless, odorless gas, CO2, produced by burning carbon and organic compounds and by respiration and absorbed by plants (Wikipedia.com) 19 Hydrocarbons: A compound of hydrogen and carbon, such as any of those that are the chief components of petroleum and natural gas (Wikipedia.com) 20 Carbon Monoxide: A colorless, odorless, toxic flammable gas, CO, formed by incomplete combustion of carbon (Wikipedia.com) 21 Halogenated Hydrocarbons: a hydrocarbon that contains one or more halogen atoms (Chemistry.about.com) 22 Antifouling Paints: A paint used to protect against the accumulation of barnacles etc. on underwater surfaces (Wikipedia.com) 17 10 Scuba Diving Industry Analysis Candice Reid & Lindsay Lyster the natural environment with loud noises, large waves, frequently striking and killing animals like manatees and dolphins. The tourism industry is based on the natural resources available in a specific country, and the available consumption rate of these resources. Sustainable tourism is one of the only tourism efforts that actually promote conservation of a specific environment. Looking at the negative effects of tourism, which originate from the development of coastal habitats, results in the extermination of entire ecosystems such as coral reefs, mangroves, wetlands and estuaries23. Garbage and sewage increases, with the number of tourists, and end up in the waters. Ecosystems must deal and cope with the loss of oxygen and sunlight in the water, due to the excess waste being dumped, and algae bloom and disease epidemics24 often occur. Other problems include overexploitation of local seafood, destruction of local habitats, through careless SCUBA diving or snorkeling, and dropping anchors on underwater features. Under water mining has been going on for several decades in order to try and find diamonds, gold, silver, and metal ores. Diamonds are actually found in greater numbers and better quality in the ocean then on land, they are just harder to mine. With this in mind, every time diamonds are mined, the ocean floor is dug up to sift through the sediment in order to find these valuable gems. Sediment is not easy to bring to the surface, the process of which requires very specific equipment, which requires a variation in the mining technology. This all has to be transported to the mining locations, across oceans, in order to utilize for the mining process. All of this added equipment and the process of mining in general has very heavy and negative impacts on the surrounding ecosystems, mainly those below the surface. Metal compounds, gravels, sands, and gas hydrates25 are also mined in the ocean. Mining of manganese nodules which contain nickel, copper and cobalt are known to be located in the shallow waters in Papua New Guinea. Although there are mass quantities in the shallow waters, the expense of bringing 23 Estuaries: The tidal mouth of a river, where the tide meets the stream (Merriam-webster.com) Epidemics: A widespread occurrence of an infectious disease in a community at a particular time (Wikipedia.com) 25 Gas hydrates: Natural methane hydrate deposits 24 11 Scuba Diving Industry Analysis Candice Reid & Lindsay Lyster the ore up to the surface was extensive. Sands and gravels are often mined for in the United States and are used to protect beaches and reduce the effects of erosion26. When the ocean floor is mined, a cloud of sediment rises up in the water, interfering with photosynthetic processes27 of phytoplankton28 and other marine life, in addition to introducing previously benign heavy metals into the food chain. In respect to coral reefs, this means serious degradation of their ecosystems. Coral reefs, are incredibly sensitive to water temperature, (21 degrees Celsius or above), and are intolerant of sediment. They require shallow waters, and with the effects that mining have on the sediment of the ocean floor, many coral ecosystems are dying. As minerals found on land are exploited and used up, mining of the ocean floor will increase. The oceans innate ability to collect, drive and mix water, heat and carbon dioxide, makes it a huge player in the world’s climate control, even more so than the atmosphere. Because the ocean can store so much heat, seasons occur much later than usual, and the air above the ocean is warmed. With the heat being stored in the water, this can affect an entire season to follow. Many chemical cycles occur between the ocean and the atmosphere, which influence the climate by controlling the amount of radiation released into ecosystems and our environment. The atmosphere directly above the ocean does not absorb much heat by itself, so in order for it to warm up, the temperature of the ocean has to rise first. The two other ways for the atmosphere to warm near the ocean are by reflection of light off of the surface, or by the evaporation of water from the ocean. The temperature of the ocean controls the climate in the lower part of the atmosphere, so for most areas of the Earth the ocean temperature is responsible for the air temperature. The main forms of climate buffering caused by the ocean are the transport of heat through ocean currents that travel across huge basins. An example of this is the tropics, which end up being cooled and higher latitudes are then warmed because of this ocean effect. Circulations of heat in the ocean help regulate the world’s air temperature. Due to the high 26 Erosion: The process of eroding or being eroded by wind, water, or other natural agents (Wikipedia.com) Photosynthetic processes: process used by plants and other organisms to convert the light energy captured from the sun into chemical energy that can be used to fuel the organism's activities 28 Phytoplankton: Plankton consisting of microscopic plants (Wikipedia.com) 27 12 Scuba Diving Industry Analysis Candice Reid & Lindsay Lyster density of the seawater, the ocean has the ability to buffer what heat gets stored and what is released. Evaporation is what helps cool the atmosphere and the water. The water cycle dissolves a series of gases in the atmosphere such as carbon, nitrogen, sulfur and oxygen. These gases are crucial to all ecosystems and biological processes, which originally came from inside the earth’s layers. This process is what helps control the rate in which oxygen flows; which helps the metabolism29 of organisms such as prokaryotes30 and bacteria. Prokaryotes have been around since the beginning of the earth, evolving with the ability to use chemical energy, which has allowed them to create organic matter. Phytoplankton on the other hand, account for possibly 90% of the world's oxygen production, because water covers about 70% of the Earth and phytoplankton are abundant in the photic zone of the surface layers. Some of the oxygen produced by phytoplankton is absorbed by the ocean, however most flows into the atmosphere where it becomes available for oxygen dependent life forms. Environmental Mitigation Strategies and Contributions There are many ways with which divers are trying to mitigate the impact that SCUBA diving is having on the environment. There are developments in place, such as low impact tourism, (Ecotourism, Cultural Tourism) that respect the local cultures and ecosystems, and help prevent further destruction from occurring. Fiorenza Micheli, an associate professor of biology at Stanford University, said "by seeing where different activities occur and whether they occur in sensitive ecosystems, we can design management strategies aimed at shifting activities away from the most sensitive areas” (www.guardian.co.uk). One way to prevent pollution is to use sewage as reclaimed water, which can help treat lawns and avoid having fertilizers and pesticides seeping into the ocean. Shipping lanes have been re-routed in the past to avoid sensitive ocean ecology, and no fishing zones have been established to create safe havens for marine life. Divers are constantly developing new means for people to interact with the 29 Metabolism: The chemical processes that occur within a living organism in order to maintain life (Wikipedia.com) Prokaryotes: a group of organisms whose cells lack a cell nucleus (karyon), or any other membrane-bound organelles 30 13 Scuba Diving Industry Analysis Candice Reid & Lindsay Lyster environment in a positive and safe way, as well as promoting education and conservation methods of all oceanography31. This is likely one of the industries greatest contributions to the environment, and the way society interacts with it. After all knowledge is power. There are organizations out there, which work to protect our oceans, and marine life, and have spent decades trying to correct the damage that has been done. Some of these organizations are listed below. Project AWARE Foundation “Global Movement of Divers - mobilizing to protect our ocean planet in more than 180 countries and territories” (www. projectaware.org). Project AWARE was established just over 20 years ago, and began as an effort by PADI (Professional Association of Diving Instructors) to educate divers on the environmental impacts of diving. They urged divers to become involved in the ocean conservation efforts and assist in the protection of our marine wildlife. Today they have expanded their efforts to include new cleanup and conservation programs using the internet to provide networking for members. Project AWARE is one of the better known efforts, and as such they have a large impact on the mitigation strategies for the oceans. Green Diver Initiative This initiative was formed by NAUI Worldwide, and the DWCF (Disney Worldwide Conservation Fund), and is an online network which dedicated their time and resources to the Green Diver P.A.C.T. (Practicing Aquatic Conservation Together). NAUI hosts a variety of events to help promote the green diver initiative, such as the Trashy Diver contest, where people record the number of pieces of garbage they have retrieved from the ocean, as well as this years “Save the Manatee” youth poster contest. Ocean Conservancy 31 Oceanography: The branch of science that deals with the physical and biological properties and phenomena of the sea (Wikipedia.com) 14 Scuba Diving Industry Analysis Candice Reid & Lindsay Lyster This is an initiative to help reduce the amount of trash harming our environments. This initiative focuses not just on the actual ocean, but the coastlines as well. They run a program called the International Coastal Cleanup, where people join together and clean a length of coastline, helping to create cleaner water and a healthier ocean for everyone. They will be hosting their 27th International Coastal Clean-up in September of 2012. Ethical Ocean This is a website that provides people with an opportunity to purchase Economically Friendly goods, posts news updates on relevant environmental topics, animals and human Rights. Marine Cleanup Initiative This is a not for profit organization which presses the need to cleanup and protect our world’s waterways for the generations to come. They also focus on improving the quality of our seafood, and the quality of life for aquatic and airborne creatures. They believe that through educating the public on the impact we’re having on the aquatic and shoreline environments, we can minimize damages and improve our conservation efforts. MarineBio Is an organization committed to the conservation of the ocean and its marine life. They believe that humans take the ocean for granted and the ocean may be more vulnerable than other environments to impacts from the human species. Sea Shepherd Conservation Society (SSCS) Is an international not for profit agency geared towards marine wildlife conservation. They work towards ending habitat destruction and killing of marine wildlife, while conserving and protecting ecosystems and species. They use their resources towards investigations, and documentation to expose illegal activities revolving around the ocean, and marine wildlife. Living Oceans Society 15 Scuba Diving Industry Analysis Candice Reid & Lindsay Lyster Canada’s largest marine conservation organization, Living Oceans Society, works towards influencing policies and practices which impact our oceans. They fight to keep oil rigs off the coasts, and working to reform salmon farming. They also work to identify marine protected areas, and have been helping to create a new approach to oceans management, through conservation-based plans. They have also completed the most thorough analyses of coral reefs to date. 16