Board of Trustees Meeting January 28, 2010 Trustee Finance and Planning Committee Action Item: Budget Assumptions for 2010-11 Fiscal Year Background: At the December 10, 2009 meeting, the committee reviewed information pertaining to enrollment, salaries, consumer price and higher education price indices, and other related factors. Rationale: Revenue and expenditure budget assumptions for the 2010-11 fiscal year were based upon various factors which included: Actual Fall 2009 Enrollment Enrollment Projections for Fall 2010 The analysis of tuition and fees to other comparable institutions Other factors Recommendation: The committee members approved and recommend the 2010-2011 Budget Assumptions on the attachment. Impact on Policy: [X] No impact on policy [ ] New policy [ ] Change in policy: __________ From reading: To read: Impact on Board Bylaw(s): [ X ] No impact [ ] Impact to Date of Implementation: Approved _____ Not Approved _____ Date_____ Board of Trustees Meeting January 28, 2010 Trustee Finance and Planning Committee Action Item: Budget Assumptions for 2010-11 Fiscal Year Background: At the December 10, 2009 meeting, the committee reviewed information pertaining to enrollment, salaries, consumer price and higher education price indices, and other related factors. Rationale: Revenue and expenditure budget assumptions for the 2010-11 fiscal year were based upon various factors which included: Actual Fall 2009 Enrollment Enrollment Projections for Fall 2010 The analysis of tuition and fees to other comparable institutions Other factors Recommendation: The committee members approved and recommend the 2010-2011 Budget Assumptions on the attachment. Impact on Policy: [X] No impact on policy [ ] New policy [ ] Change in policy: __________ From reading: To read: Impact on Board Bylaw(s): [ X ] No impact [ ] Impact to Date of Implementation: Approved _X____ Not Approved _____ Date__01-28-2010___ Our Lady of the Lake University Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees Mission Statement The mission of Our Lady of the Lake University, an independent, Catholic institution sponsored by the Congregation of Divine Providence, is: To provide excellent teaching through traditional and innovative educational programs; To develop its diverse, intercultural student bodies in Christian, person-centered learning communities; and To graduate individuals who are competent and committed to service. AGENDA (Tab 1) January 28, 2010 Providence Blue Room 10:00 a.m. to 12:30 p.m. 10:00 - 10:01 a.m. 1. Call meeting to order – Michael Edelmann, Chair 10:01 - 10:02 a.m. 2. Invocation – Sr. Jane Ann Slater 10:02 - 10:05 a.m. 4. Approval of Minutes of October 29, 2009 meeting – Mike Edelmann (Tab 2) 10:05 - 10:20 a.m. 5. Key Points from Board Committee meetings in a.m. – Committee Chairs (Minutes from previous meetings in Tab 3) 10:20 – 11:20 a.m. 6. Discussion and Action Items (Tab 4) 6.1 Tuition and Fee Increases/Budget Assumptions – Sr. Imelda Gonzalez 6.2 Enrollment Growth Plan update – Dr. David Estes 6.3 Budget Equilibrium Process update – Dr. David Estes 11:20 - 11:45 a.m. 7. Questions on Reports (Tabs 5, 6 and 7) 7.1 President’s Report (Tab 5) 7.2 Executive Vice President’s Report (Tab 5) 7.3 Fact Book (at Board Web site) (Tab 6) 7.4 Metrics for University Priorities 2009-2010 (Tab 6) 7.5 Alumni (Tab 7) 7.6 Faculty Assembly (Tab 7) 7.7 Staff Advisory (Tab 7) 7.8 Student Government Association (Tab 7) 11:45 – 11:50 a.m. 9. Key Dates (Tab 8) 11:50 - 12:00 p.m. 10. Plus/Delta 12:00 p.m. 11. Adjourn Business Meeting 12:00 – 12:30 p.m. 12. Trustee Executive Session 12:30 – 1:30 p.m. Streubert Lunch Presentation: Program Enhancements – Dr. Helen 13. The University Vision Statement Inspired by Catholic values and the heritage of the founding Congregation of Divine Providence, Our Lady of the Lake University is a community called to transform individuals as they discover their purpose in life. We aspire to be nationally recognized for our distinctive programs, our expertise in Mexican American culture, and our diverse graduates who lead and serve with faith and wisdom to improve the world. Board of Trustees Board Meeting Our Lady of the Lake University Providence Blue Room Thursday, January 28, 2010 Minutes (DRAFT) Present: Michael Edelmann (Chair), Sr. Jane Ann Slater, Sr. Imelda Gonzalez, Tessa Martinez Pollack (President), Bruce Flohr, Calvin Michelson, Jennita Poston, Roy Terracina, Ed Cross, Paul Olivier, Sr. Madonna Sangalli, Martha Landsman, Sr. Pearl Ceasar, Rev. Robert Jemerson, Scott Mullen, Mitch Meyer, Sr. Charlene Wedelich, Cynthia Rocha (called-in), Jose Sena, Yolanda Molina and Jacob Garza. Absent: Jim Shelley, Michele Hoskins, Lisa Andrade, Ruth Piña, and Ted Terrazas. Guests/Representatives: Michael Acosta, David Estes, Jack Hank, Allen Klaus, Susan Schleicher, Helen Streubert, Gloria Urrabazo, Dan Yoxall, Rocky Kettering, Joan Biever, Monica Lopez and Carlos Gonzalez. Recording Secretary: M. J. Oliveira The meeting was called to order at 10:00 a.m. Opening Prayer: Sr. Jane Ann Slater gave the invocation. Minutes Approval: The October 28, 2009 Board Meeting Minutes – Approved as written Key Points from Board Committee Meetings: Institutional Advancement Committee – Cal Michelson complimented the work being done by Rocky Kettering and his staff and Dan Yoxall and his staff. Audit Committee – Nothing to report. Board Chair Nominating Committee – Committee has met twice. Will make recommendation to the Board at the March 2010 meeting. Academic Affairs, Student Life and Mission Ministry Committee: Mission and Ministry presented a nice briefing; same with Student Life. Other topics discussed will be reflected in the minutes. Finance and Planning: Committee discussed budget assumptions and enrollment projections, control operating report, margin and capacity contribution analysis, cash flow analysis, and financial aid matrix. Discussion and Action Items: Tuition and Fee Increases/Budget Assumptions: The Board approved the tuition and fee increases and salary equalization and merit budgets as recommended by the Finance and Planning Committee. In October 2010 the Board will consider possible across the board salary increases dependent on actual fall enrollment, to begin January 1, 2011. Enrollment Growth Plan: Dr. Estes highlighted the major initiatives in process and strategic growth initiatives planned for the next two years. Budget Equilibrium Process Update: Dr. Estes reported that the Administration is aggressively pursuing multi-year revenue and expenditure strategies that when fully developed will be presented to the Finance and Planning Committee. President’s Report: OLLU's federal agenda is being shaped with lobbyists around three possible projects: 1) Nursing RN-BSN and RN-MSN; 2) Center for Math and Science Education; and 3) CISS. We are at various stages of vetting several Trustee candidates. Eight Trustees, including CDPs, have pledged $590,000 toward a campaign goal of $1 million. The 2015 Committee will be chaired by Henry Cisneros. Trustees Garza, Michelson, and Terracina plan to attend the GGTS Conference in Chigago. Main Building drawings are being finalized to pursue naming opportunities. Alumni giving has been increasing over the last few months thanks to the phone-a-thon and personal calls from students. A multi-layered system of stewardship development has been implemented that will ensure proper acknowledgements and sustained engagement of donors. Executive Vice-President’s Report: No discussion. Alumni Report: No discussion. Faculty Report: A committee has been established consisting of faculty and administration to address faculty concerns. Staff Report: No discussion. SGA Report: Carlos Gonzalez graduates in May 2010. A new SGA president will be named in the spring. Key Dates: Mike thanked trustees for attending Commencement. He encouraged them to continue to do so. Meeting adjourned at 11:40 a.m. and went into executive session. Respectfully submitted, Mario J. Oliveira Recording Secretary Board of Trustees Board Meeting Our Lady of the Lake University Providence Blue Room Thursday, October 29, 2009 Minutes (APPROVED) Present: Michael Edelmann (Chair), Sr. Jane Ann Slater, Sr. Imelda Gonzalez, Tessa Martinez Pollack (President)(called-in), Bruce Flohr, Calvin Michelson, Jennita Poston, Ed Cross, Paul Olivier, Sr. Madonna Sangalli, Martha Landsman, Sr. Pearl Ceasar, Rev. Robert Jemerson, Michele Hoskins, , Lisa Andrade, Sr. Charlene Wedelich and Jacob Garza. Absent: Jim Shelley, Cynthia Rocha, Jose Sena, Ruth Piña, Scott Mullen, Roy Terracina, Ted Terrazas, Mitch Meyer and Yolanda Molina. Guests/Representatives: Michael Acosta, David Estes, Jack Hank, Allen Klaus, Susan Schleicher, Helen Streubert, Gloria Urrabazo, Dan Yoxall, Rocky Kettering, Joan Biever and Carlos Gonzalez. Recording Secretary: M. J. Oliveira The meeting was called to order at 10:00 a.m. Opening Prayer: Sr. Jane Ann Slater gave the invocation. Minutes Approval: The September 24, 2009 Board Retreat Minutes – Approved as written Joaquin Lopez, a McNair Scholar student, presented a briefing on the correlation between spirituality and health. Key Points from Board Committee Meetings: Audit Committee – Bruce Flohr summarized the results of the most recent audit. It was a clean opinion with minor comments. Full reports are available upon request. Academic Affairs, Student Life and Mission Ministry Committee: Its minutes were approved with a minor change referring to commencement locations being at Municipal Auditorium. Dan Yoxall presented a briefing on a market study for expanding programs in San Antonio, Houston and Rio Grande Valley. Gloria Urrabazo highlighted the latest events in Mission and Ministry. Jack Hank briefed on the sports teams. Dr. Streubert emphasized the importance of faculty advising in engaging students in a discussion of degree planning with faculty. The Faculty Handbook and Faculty Assembly bylaws are being revised. Institutional Advancement Committee: Minutes from previous meeting were approved as written. Rocky Kettering presented a briefing on Institutional Advancement plans. Finance and Planning: The Sep 23, 2009 minutes were approved with a minor change. Current budget was discussed identifying a potential $2.6 mil deficit. Administration is asked to provide a report to the Committee in Dec 2009 on plans to address the shortfall. Discussion Items: Enrollment Report and Budget Implications: An overview of enrollment status and trends was provided. Although enrollment increased over last year, enrollment fell short of projections. There is an expected budget shortfall because the projected enrollment increases were reflected in the budget. Administration is developing plans to address the shortfall and financial aid budgeting process. The Finance Committee will report plans in the January Board meeting. Master Facilities Plan: It is a big picture document identifying concepts to guide campus development and identifying different phases of growth. It will begin with 24th street modifications going from a two-lane both directions to a one-lane both directions with a wide median. The different phases of construction are identified in pages 64 through 70. The Master Facilities Plan was approved by the Board as submitted with the understanding that projects may be moved between phases as details and needs become more evident. Trustee Candidate Attributes: Document will be provided to each individual being considered to serve on the Board. Its attributes also apply to current trustees. Trustee Candidate Attributes were approved as submitted. Board Chair Selection: Sr. Jane Ann Slater provided background on past board chair selection procedures which has been a reserved power of the CDP Council. The new procedure provides for board input. Dr. Pollack noted possible SACS compliance issues with Item 6 of the procedure as it is written. The Board approved the Board Chair Selection procedures as written so that the process of selection may begin. Further changes will be considered as we go through the process. Mike Edelmann asked for trustee volunteers to serve on the nominating committee and they are: Bruce Flohr (chair), Sr. Jane Ann Slater, Sr. Pearl Ceasar, Ed Cross, and Jennita Poston. Questions on Reports: President’s Report: None Executive Vice President: Dr. Estes briefly discussed the newly selected roof color and roof color history. The color iron oxide was selected based on its historical significance. Capital Campaign Report: As of date, Phonethon has been going on for six evenings. Every alumnus is to be contacted. The Congregation has pledged to raise $1 million, some of which has already been pledged and donated. Throughout November, trustees will be contacted regarding their contribution to the Capital Campaign. Control Metrics Dashboard: None Metrics for University Priorities 2009-2010: None Alumni: None Faculty Assembly: None Staff Advisory: None Student Government Association: None Trustee Disclosure Form for IRS Form 990: Trustees were encouraged to complete their forms at their seating areas. Forms need to be turned in by COB Friday, November 6, 2009. Plus/Delta: Teleconference equipment is still not performing well for Trustees calling in; attendees cannot hear conversations and have connection and disconnection issues. More thorough discussion on enrollment is necessary. Trustees were encouraged to read Monk Malloy’s book. There was discussion on Main Building insurance claims. Insurance company will pay for replacement costs only. Upgrades such as double windows will not be covered by the insurance company. However, code compliance improvements will be permitted up to a cap of $2.5.million. The University is in negotiations with the insurance company on these matters. Meeting adjourned at 11:50 a.m. and went into executive session. Respectfully submitted, Mario J. Oliveira Recording Secretary Action Plan Strategic Goal 5 “Develop a long-term comprehensive financial plan that guides institutional progress” 5.2 "Implement multi-year revenue and expenditure strategies" RESPONSIBILITY Through its Mission and Vision, the OLLU community seeks to provide high quality education to its students. Guided by Strategic Goals approved by the Board of Trustees in 2009, our community is called to demonstrate fiscal responsibility in order to best educate our students and act in the long-term best interests of the University. BUDGET STRATEGIES TASK FORCE -A working committee of the UPBC -Membership: EVP, VPAA, VPFF, VPSL -Charge: To review all university budgets and propose to the president strategic adjustments for the current and next two years’ budgets to achieve budget equilibrium. To consult with UPBC regularly as the task force develops budget recommendations. PRINCIPLES FOR ACHIEVING STRATEGIC GOAL 5.2 Achieve Our Envisioned Future -Make necessary fundamental changes in programs and operations to support our continual improvement as a university -Become a model for other colleges and universities Focus on Results -Build strategically on institutional strengths -Fund priorities consistent with the strategic plan Use Data -Employ quality, productivity, and financial benchmark metrics -Monitor demand and pricing indicators -Make rational and objective decisions -Avoid across-the-board reductions -Develop assessment strategies for funded activities Include OLLU Community Input -Invite suggestions from faculty, staff, and students -Communicate regularly -Educate ourselves about the complexity of the issues -Value our heritage Academic Affairs, Student Life, Mission and Ministry Committee Board of Trustees Our Lady of the Lake University October 29, 2009 SEAS Library Community Room Meeting Summary (DRAFT) Present: Paul Olivier (Chair), Sr. Jane Ann Slater, Sr. Pearl Ceasar, Sr. Madonna Sangalli Absent: Yolanda Molina, Jennita Poston, Roy Terracina, Ruth Piña, Mitch Meyer Representatives and Guests: Helen J. Streubert, Gloria Urrabazo, Jack Hank, Jerrie Jackson, Joan Biever, Dan Yoxall, Kim McNutt, Anne Gomez Paul Olivier called the meeting to order at 8:10 a.m. The summary from the May 28, 2009 meeting was reviewed and accepted. Mission and Ministry: Gloria Urrabazo presented updates on events in Mission and Ministry. Ms. Urrabazo said that Fr. Ron Rolheiser, OMI, President of Oblate School of Theology spoke on “Providence and Catholic Higher Education” to about 60 OLLU attendees and will be sending a DVD for anyone who would like to review. She distributed brochures outlining such events as Heritage Week - November 2-6, and the Queretaro, Mexico Pilgrimage - December, 17-20. Mission and Ministry is also working on a student booklet called OLLU: Providence stories in the lives of our students and The Providence Heritage Booklet. On January 8, 2010 The Texas Catholic Universities workshop will be hosted by OLLU. Topic: “Keeping it Real” Principles of Good Practice for Student Affairs presented by Dr. Sandra Estanek, Associate Professor/Graduate Education & Leadership Studies, Canisius College. On February 19, 2010, Dr. Patrick McCormick, Professor of Religious Studies, Gonzaga University will be presenting “Through the Lens of Catholic Social Teaching-How to be a Welcoming Community”. Dan Yoxall and Kim McNutt gave a marketing presentation outlining the need for expansion into the Houston and Rio Grande Valley locations. Presently, Phoenix University’s online courses are very competitive in these areas. Kim McNutt presented some of the guiding principles for future expansion. These include attention to mission and assuring quality programming. He would like to start an advisory board for local business professionals. Mr. McNutt also mentioned the fast growing population in Northeast San Antonio including Live Oak and Schertz and said that ACCD will be providing space to offer classes in that area. We are in conversations to be one of the initial institutions to be included. Dan Yoxall expressed the growing need for healthcare education as San Antonio is the center for military medical training. He said that one in seven adults in San Antonio are involved in healthcare and the biomedical sciences. Mr. Yoxall also said that cyber security is very much in demand. Houston – Our Houston campus (North Harris) has been there for 20 years offering undergrad and grad programs. Hewlett Packard Corporation headquarters has been purchased by Lonestar College System. (LSC Park) There are opportunities for OLLU at that site for those on MENTC track and professional certifications. Will develop programs that award college credit. Consideration is being given to whether we keep undergraduate programs at N. Harris College. This area has grown 28% between 1990 and 2000 and will move graduate programs to the HP Center. Rio Grande – The PhD in Leadership Studies has been very successful. There are about 80 fortune 500 companies in this area. OLLU is considering the Masters in Education program in this area. A private Catholic university would be welcomed in Harlingen, especially one that provides a doctorate degree. Sr. Jane Ann Slater said that emphasis must be placed on writing and math skills of new students because today’s high school students are not always competent in these areas. Dr. Helen J. Streubert talked about the opportunities in autism. This is a problem that is across a spectrum of disciplines including but not limited to psychology, education and social work. A certificate or minor are being considered. Dr. Steve Blanchard is very well versed in this area. Our undergraduate population is similar to that at other universities in the area. We can’t compete with a lower price point with some of the MBA programs in Houston. Our future is in expansion. We need to revitalize our adult programming on a regular basis. We need to show value added. Sr. Jane Ann Slater said that students need to be taught how to look towards their future not to just get a degree. Historically, Mexican/American students don’t plan for the future. Updating student advising is crucial and has to have a personal interest. Dr. Helen J. Streubert said the faculty advising week has been successful. Twice as many students registered during this week than in the Spring. Advising has moved to faculty and students are being reminded to meet with faculty. Paul Olivier said that our student interaction with faculty makes us competitive. Jack Hank said the dorms had been decorated for tonight’s Boo Bash for children to attend. Mr. Hank said the H1N1 vaccine should be here in November. He also said that OLLU is required to make sure all resident students receive a meningitis vaccination. Letters will be sent to parents before Thanksgiving informing them that students may receive the vaccination either on campus or from their personal doctor. The men’s basketball game is scheduled for November 4 at 7:00 p.m. Dr. Helen Streubert gave the following changes to the Handbook. September 1st is the deadline for a sabbatical request, summer pay would be based on the rank of the faculty member, phasedretirement has been changed from 5 to 3 years. Dr. Streubert said that a group of faculty and administrators are working on the faculty grievance program. The Shared Governance Task Group meets every other week. Dr. Streubert said the faculty has been exceptional on their work with students. They are also working on learning outcomes. A SACS timeline was distributed. We have requested approval from SACS to offer: BAS in CISS and a BAS in Kinesiology. We will also be submitting a proposal for a change in our accounting program. The meeting was adjourned at 9:45 a.m. Respectfully submitted, Barbara F. Naecker Our Lady of the Lake University Finance and Planning Committee of the Board of Trustees Thursday, October 29, 2009 8:00 a.m. International Folk Culture Center Present: Sr. Imelda Gonzalez, Chairperson, Mike Edelmann, Bruce Flohr, Ed Cross, Tessa Pollack, and Allen R. Klaus. Absent: Scott Mullen, Jim Shelley Guests/Representatives: David Estes, Mike Acosta, John Swiger and Blaise Bender, Faculty Representatives; Elissa McClain, Staff Representative; Ann DeBarros, Karen Reed, Luis Rodriguez, Susan Schleicher. Recording Secretary: Luis Rodriguez The meeting was called to order at 9:00 a.m. Sr. Imelda said the opening prayer. 1. Item: Minutes from the meeting on September 23, 2009. Discussion: The minutes of the meeting were approved with one amendment. 2. Item: Enrollment Discussion: Mike Acosta presented and explained the model, which is based on a 5 year average, used to project enrollment growth. The model also assumed the same number of programs now in place along with the same economic climate. Using Fall 2010 as the base year, enrollment was projected at a 3% growth rate from fall to fall. Growth rates in all categories reflected increased enrollment with the exception of retention. Mike Edelmann requested an updated comprehensive enrollment growth plan for the next meeting. Several committee members expressed concern on the effect enrollment projections would have on the budget. Ed Cross stated he would be “hard pressed to vote for a budget based on any enrollment increase”. And “for the record” he felt a mistake was made approving a 2% salary increase. 3. Item: 2009-2010 Budget Discussion: The Adjusted 2009-10 Budget reflects a $2.6MM shortfall partly due to an increase in financial aid and lower enrollment. The question was raised as to how financial aid could be over budget by so much especially in light of lower enrollment. Allen Klaus explained that there is no cap on the various discounts given to students. Also the new matrix for athletic scholarships, which didn’t go through the budget process, increased significantly. Sister Imelda felt there are two issues to be addressed; 1) How much is being awarded on discounts and scholarships and, 2) The budget procedures. Sister Imelda asked for a list of the various discounts and the amounts. For the next meeting, Ed Cross asked for a presentation on staffing levels at peer universities and a cash flow projection through fiscal year end. Allen Klaus also briefed the committee regarding the Kenedy Trust which sometimes has a significant impact on the budget. Based on the most recent quarterly distribution, revenue received from the Kenedy Trust should be close to budget. It was recommended that the Adjusted Budget not be taken to the Board of Trustees but the deficit be reported to them. They should be informed that if needed, funds will be taken from other sources to cover the deficit and that there is more action to follow. 4. Item: Audit Report Discussion: Bruce Flohr informed the committee that the audit is complete and the university received an unqualified opinion. 5. Item: NMTC Discussion: Allen Klaus updated the committee on the status of the NMTC. The benefit to the university will be approximately $3.7MM. The tentative closing date is the first or second week in December. No other business was discussed. The next meeting is scheduled for December 10, 2009 at 10:00 a.m. The meeting was adjourned at 9:35 a.m. Respectfully submitted, Luis Rodriguez Our Lady of the Lake University Finance and Planning Committee of the Board of Trustees Thursday, December 10, 2009 10:00 a.m. Providence East Social Room Present: Sr. Imelda Gonzalez, Chairperson, Mike Edelmann, Bruce Flohr, Ed Cross, Scott Mullen. Absent: Sr. Pearl Ceasar, Jim Shelley Guests/Representatives: Tessa Pollack, Allen R. Klaus, David Estes, John Swiger and Joan Biever, Faculty Representatives; Elissa McClain, Staff Representative; Mike Acosta, Ann DeBarros, Luis Rodriguez, Susan Schleicher, Helen Streubert. Recording Secretary: Luis Rodriguez The meeting was called to order at 10:05 a.m. Sr. Imelda said the opening prayer. 1. Item: Minutes from the meeting on October 29, 2009. Discussion: The minutes of the meeting were approved as presented. 6. Item: Budget Assumptions Discussion: David Estes presented an overview of what the university is trying to achieve regarding the 2010-11 budget. Allen Klaus discussed the tuition comparisons which reflected OLLU’s tuition rate is below the average of the comparative group. A discussion of tuition discounts and how they are determined ensued. Ed Cross requested a presentation of the discount matrix at a future meeting. This should include; where the majority of the discounts are allocated and how they are determined. He encouraged driving enrollment through discounts. Mike Edelmann requested the number of employees receiving Employee Grant in Aid. It was recommended including the number of students receiving tuition discounts be added to future reports. The committee approved and recommended the following 2010-11 Budget Assumptions: $538 increase in banded tuition rate $31 increase in hourly undergraduate rate $15 increase in hourly graduate rate $5 increase in hourly doctoral rate $23 increase in hourly Houston Fast Track rate $75 increase in residence hall rates $75 increase in meal plan rates for Plans B –D $65 increase in Late Registration Fee $50,000 staff and faculty salary equalization budget $40,000 staff merit pay budget $25,000 faculty merit pay budget Note: The committee decided to wait until a later date to look at an additional $80,000 in faculty equalization budget. The decision was made to wait until the January meeting to make a recommendation regarding salary increases. 7. Item: Budget Equilibrium Discussion: David Estes updated the committee on the budget equilibrium process. He informed the committee that the University Planning and Budgeting Council has been advising with the Administrative Council to put our budget into equilibrium. The committee discussed how the revenue from the Kenedy trust should be used, the additional savings process, and the presentation of the 2010-11 budget. He indicated that the university will not have across the board cuts but will look at each unit’s budget compared to their strategic goals, and that we have benchmarked this type of plan with other institutions. 8. Item: Financial Aid Discounts Discussion: Tuition discount information was presented to the committee. Mike Acosta indicated that approximately 98% of traditional undergraduate students received aid. The committee discussed the percentage of aid received by various categories. David Estes mentioned $1.2 million in student wages not included in this information. There is approximately $2.2 million in University Scholarship Matrix. Mike Acosta informed the committee that a formula is used to determine the matrix amount awarded to each student based upon need and student quality. Discussion followed. Ed Cross stated that he feels discounts are pivotal to increasing enrollment and that he encourages the University to drive enrollment off the discounts mechanism. Ed Cross referred to an article about the percentage of students and the amount of their debt. He stated that according to the article, the University does a good job in helping manage debt for students. Mike Edelmann shared a concern with the committee regarding institutional aid for freshmen and their aid for future years. Mike Acosta informed the committee that when a student receives an institutional award, that award follows them throughout their four years. The only time it will change is if they earn additional merit awards or if their family income changes. The committee discussed other points such as the number of employees on grant-in-aid, and the application of the athletic scholarships. The committee requested additional student head count information and a presentation on the matrix at a future meeting. 9. Item: Cost of Programs (Delaware National Study of Institutional Costs and Productivity) Discussion: Helen Streubert presented a model of instructional costs and productivity known as the “Delaware Study.” Approximately 500 colleges and universities participate. The Delaware Study is used for comparative analysis of faculty teaching loads, direct institutional costs, and other activity at academic discipline level. Helen Streubert indicated we would use the study to benchmark ourselves against our peer institutions. Helen Streubert indicated that the next steps would be for staff to input data and to separate budgets at the discipline levels. Limited data will be available to the committee in March. 10. Item: Cash Flow Statement Discussion: Ann DeBarros presented a monthly cash flow and projection for cash that flows through the operating account. Actual figures were used for June through October with estimated amounts for the remainder of the fiscal year. Discussion followed. An updated cash flow statement will be presented at the next meeting. 11. Item: New Markets Tax Credit Discussion: Allen Klaus informed the committee that the closing date is scheduled for December 11th but would probably not happen until next week. He indicated that the University, at Crescents recommendation, incorporated some fees which will result in a total net benefit of approximately over $3.9 million. A new issue arose regarding the transfer of the main building by survey of the land as opposed to plat. It would be a legal transfer for the ownership, but it triggered future questions that are currently being examined. The question is with the city of San Antonio and the certificate of occupancy. Allen Klaus restated to the committee the university is borrowing money because the University has to front the $21 million for the transaction. Some of the borrowed money will be paid off at the day of closing, but approximately $7 million will not be paid until the insurance settlement is received. The University is fronting $2.5 million in advance of pledges coming in for the capital campaign and also another $400,000 for future insurance claims. 12. Agenda Items for Future Meeting Discussion: The tentative agenda for the January 2010 through May 2010 meetings was presented. 13. Other Business No other business was discussed. The next meeting is scheduled for January 28, 2010 at 8:00 a.m. The meeting was adjourned at 1:05 p.m. Respectfully submitted, Luis Rodriguez Unapproved Minutes Institutional Advancement & Board Development Committee of the Board of Trustees Thursday, October 29, 2009 8:50 a.m. – 9:45 a.m. Library 104 Present: Jacob Garza, Rocky Kettering, Martha Landsman, Cal Michelson, and Sr. Charlene Wedelich, CDP, Absent: Lisa Andrade, Rev. Robert Jemerson, Cynthia Rocha, Jose Sena, and Ted Terrazzas Representatives/Guests: Staff Advisory Council Representative John Sanchez, Vice President for Marketing & Communications Dan Yoxall Recording Secretary: Alex Garcia The meeting was called to order by Cal Michelson at 8:50 a.m. Prayer lead by Sr. Charlene Wedelich. Approved minutes from May 28, 2009. 1. Item: Revise Charter Discussion: The Institutional Advancement and Board Development Committee will no longer approve new board members. This process will be done by the Executive Committee of the Board of Trustees; therefore, this is committee is now called Institutional Advancement. 2. Item: Institutional Advancement Readiness Discussion: Dr. Kettering is here to help board to realize vision. Institutional Advancement is restructuring and there is a new organizational chart. In the future, IA will need fundraisers to complete more face-to-face solicitations. Each fundraiser is currently carrying a portfolio of 125 pre-qualified prospects. With Dr. Kettering, Noah Almanza, and Lindsay Wilson, that is only 375 prospects. Tessa has an additional 125 in her portfolio, bringing the total number of prospects currently in the moves management system to 500. As a point of reference, we have over 22,500 alumni. IA has empowered other people (Deans, faculty, and selected staff) to help raise funds. We have created and implemented a campus-wide prospect management plan for all empowered fundraisers. Advancement Services has a system in place for whom fundraisers have contacted and can work with academic committee and the Board of Trustees. There was no stewardship anywhere is the IA division; therefore, the Office of Stewardship and Constituent Relations was created. IA was not consciously stewarding our donors and stewardship needs to be a major component in IA. IA needs to visit donors and show return on investment and create an annual report. IA is making changes and is working closely with Communications & Marketing toward this end. 3. Item: Capital Campaign Update Discussion: This campaign started the day after fire. The goal is 13.5M for the silent phase of the campaign. Advancement is currently focusing on Main, Scholarships and Annual Fund, Program of Impact and NCHEMA. 10% of alums have given to the campaign which includes Annual Fund. There have been more non-alums giving to the campaign than alums. 4. Item: Communications and Marketing Discussion: Vice President for Marketing and Communications, Dan Yoxall, reported on the successful launch of the new website which occurred September 1st. He noted that OLLU is associated with 12 different social networking sites which keep us connected with alumni and students. C&M is working with clear channel communications to do “drive time” and the commercials we currently have running are bilingual. C&M is using direct mail pieces with success stories of graduates and students to help with the retention effort. The meeting was adjourned at 9:41 am by Cal Michelson. Respectfully submitted, Alex Garcia STEWARDSHIP PLAN 2010- soft launch LEVELS OF DONORS: $1,000.00 + (Receipt + confirmation letter) Signed by Rocky- 2 touch personal letter signed by President Pollack $250.00-$999.00-(Receipt + confirmation letter) Signed by Rocky-2 touch personal letter signed by Director of Leadership Giving $1.00-$249.00-(Receipt + confirmation letter) Signed by Rocky (scanned signature)-2 touch personal letter signed by Annual Giving Director STEWARDSHIP: · Donors will receive a letter from SCR that lets them know what benefits they will receive as a donor. This will be signed by SCR Director or the Director of Corporate Sponsorships depending on what “donor-type”- this may be a welcome/packet (in design stages) · Student Thank you handwritten note on a note-card that has a student story and face- C & M (in draft form currently) 2 PHONE CALLS: 1. Thank-a-thon conducted by students after the phone-a-thon in the spring and fall 2. A thank you phone call made by a work-study student to the donor will happen a week after the thank you note has dropped. COLLATERAL/E-BLAST DEADLINES & EVENTS CALENDAR SPRING 2010 Jan 13 E-Blast: San Antonio Tailgate Luau Weekly E-blast Reminder-OUT Jan 22 E-Blast: Alumni E-Newsletter –To be sent Jan 22 COLLATERAL: Student Thank You Note card- for stewardship plan- DESIGN DUE Jan 22 COLLATERAL: Welcome to Philanthropy piece- for stewardship plan- CONCEPT DUE Jan 28 E-Blast: San Antonio Tailgate Luau Weekly E-blast Reminder- To be sent EVENT: Jan 30 LOCATION: San Antonio EVENT: SA Tailgate- Texas Wesley TIME: 12:30 PM and runs until 6:30 PM GAME TIME: Girls @ 2:00, Boys @ 4:00PM VENUE: Outside of UWAC TYPE OF EVENT: Family/Spirit/Alumni EVENT: Feb 16 LOCATION: Dallas EVENT: Mardi Gras Mixer TIME: 6:30-8:30 PM VENUE: TBD- doing site visits next week TYPE OF EVENT: Alumni/networking March 4 COLLATERAL: Post Phone-a-thon Mail Piece Annual Fund- To be designed and sent March 12 COLLATERAL: Post Phone-a-thon E-Mail Piece Annual Fund- To be sent March 15 E-Blast: Alumni E-Newsletter –To be designed and sent March 22 E-Blast: Post Phone-a-thon E-Mail Piece reminder April 12 COLLATERAL: End of Fiscal Year E-blast Annual Fund- To be designed and mailed EVENT: April 15 LOCATION: San Antonio EVENT: SA Mixer TIME: 5:30-7:30 pm VENUE: OLLU TYPE OF EVENT: Alumni/Networking Possible Fundraising event April 19 E-Blast: Alumni E-Newsletter May 17 E-Blast: Alumni E-Newsletter June 14 E-Blast: Alumni E-Newsletter July 19 E-Blast: Alumni E-Newsletter CONSTITUENCY REPORT Board of Trustees Meeting of January 28, 2010 Submitted by Joan L. Biever, General Secretary of the Faculty Assembly, Faculty Representative I. Faculty Assembly Activities A. The resolution regarding the Student Academic Grievance Procedures was passed at the October 28 meeting of the Faculty Assembly. B. Faculty who teach general education courses and the General Education Council have has developed student learning outcomes (SLO’s) for the general education curriculum and for each of the seven skills and values. C. The Faculty Welfare Committee work group examining the Five Year Tenure Review has developed a proposal to replace the current review process with a triggered review. D. The Shared Governance Workgroup and the Faculty Assembly Bylaws Revision Task Force had a productive meeting with consultant Dr. Zeddie Bowen in November. Dr. Bowen has reviewed the shared governance document and we will be working to incorporate his suggestions. II. Faculty Accomplishments during the Fall 2009 semester include: A. Grants 1. Robbie Kourie, M.S. (Physical Science/Mathematics) received a five year $2.43 million Title V grant from the Department of Education for the Science and Mathematics Renovation, Research and Retention Project. 2. Jerrie Jackson, PhD (Education) concluded the 3.7 million CoMeT-R grant ; this grant provided tuition for more than 140 teachers to become certified in high needs areas including math, science, special education and bilingual. B. Publications 1. Tom Gadsden, EdD (Physical Sciences) published two chapters, Nature of Light and Chemical Reactions, in the SciPaks published online by the National Science Teachers Association. He also co-authored a course, Electrical and Magnetic for that same series. 2. Pablo Martinez, MFA (English) published two poems, Imprint and Yours, Sally Hemings in the Gay and Lesbian Review and North American Review, respectively. 3. Sarah Volk (Biology) co-authored a paper, Epistatic Roles of E2 Glycoprotein Mutations in Adaption of Chikungunya Virus to Aedes Albopictus and Ae. Aegypti Mosquitoes, in the online journal, PLos ONE. 4. Antoinette Winstead, MFA (Communication Arts) published a short story, Next, published in Voices de la Luna. 5. Yvette Benevides, MA (English) published a short story, Joy Sometimes, an essay, Writing points to Joy, and two poems, Autistic Mystic and Sunken, in The Langdon Review of the Arts in Texas. 6. Ruth Fernandez, PhD (Communication Disorders) co-authored a chapter, Publications, in the Handbook of Latinos and Education: Theory, Research and Practice. Joan Biever, PhD (psychology) and PsyD alumna Susana Verdinelli co-authored two articles, Experiences of Spanish/English Bilingual Supervisees published in Psychotherapy and Spanish-English Bilingual Psychotherapists: Personal and Professional Language Development and Use published in Cultural Diversity and Ethnic Minority Psychology. 8. Jiletta Kubena, PhD (Applied Social and Cultural Sciences) published book reviews in International Criminal Justice Review and Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice. 9. Oswald John Nira, PhD (Religious Studies) authored four entries, Buddhism, Numerology, The Trinity and The U.S. Catholic Conference of Bishops, in the encyclopedia, Hispanic American Religious Cultures. 10. Hamid Khan, PhD (Business) authored an article, Use of general purpose system simulation (GPSS) for competitive recruitment, retention and optimal enrollment management in the International Journal of Business, Management and Decision Science. 11. Belinda Treviño Schouten, PhD (Education) co-authored two chapters, Higher Education and Libraries/Galleries/Museums, in the Handbook of Latinos and Education: Theory, Research & Practice. 12. Sr. Ann Petrus, CDP, PhD (Mathematics) published an article, Teaching with the Tablet PC in MAA Focus, the Newsmagazine of the Mathematical Association of America. 13. Leah Larson, PhD (English) published an article, Breast Cancer and the ‘Unnatural Woman’ in Edgeworth’s Belinda in The Explicator. 14. Mark Green, PhD, Phyllis Duncan, PhD, Diana Garza-Ortiz, PhD, and Esther Chavez, PhD (Leadership Studies) published an article, Assessing The Leadership Style Of Paul And Cultural Congruence Of The Christian Community At Corinth Using Project Globe Constructs, in the Journal of Biblical Perspectives in Leadership. C. Conference Presentations 1. Jane Grovijahn (Religious Studies) present a paper, Visionaries of Justice in Creation: Three Lives of Theological Sustainability, at the International Gathering of the European Conference of Catholic Theology 2. Catherine Rainwater, PhD (Biology) presented Understanding Environmental Systems and Cycles—Making Connections to the Texas Conference for the Advancement of Science Teaching. 3. Ruth Fernandez, PhD (Communication Disorders) made presentations on Voice and the Effects of Smoking and Educational Team Decisions and Student Outcomes, at the 2009 conference of the American Speech and Hearing Association. 4. Jiletta Kubena, PhD (Applied Social and Cultural Sciences) presented a paper, Getting the Message Across: An Examination of Interdisciplinary Approaches in Teaching, at the National Conference of The American Society of Criminology. 5. Bernadette Solórzano, PsyD, Carrie Castañeda-Sound, PhD, Ezequiel Peña, PhD, Joan Biever, PhD , & Monte Bobele, PhD (Psychology) presented a workshop, Preparing Multiculturally Competent Psychologists in the 21st Century, to the Annual Convention of the Texas Psychological Association. 7. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. Leonard Bohanon, PhD (Psychology) co-presented a paper, A Collaborative Learning Community in Action: Early Research Findings, to the Annual Convention of the Texas Psychological Association. Carrie Castañeda-Sound, PhD (Psychology) co-presented a workshop, The Importance of Latino Psychology in Training Culturally Competent Clinicians, to the Annual Convention of the Texas Psychological Association. Monte Bobele, PhD (Psychology) co-presented a paper, Walk-In Single Session Therapy: A Systemic Response to Disaster Relief to the annual conference of the American Family Therapy Academy, and a workshop, When All You Have Is an Hour: Single Session Therapy at the annual conference of the American Association for Marriage and Family Therapy. Hamid Khan, PhD (Business) presented the following papers: Measuring Impact of Authentic Leadership On Humanity By *B.E.S.T Measures—Indelible Footprints on the Sands of Time at the American Society for Competitiveness conference, Online MBA Boot Camp Provides Sustainable Competitive Advantage in 12-week, Trimester presented at the 25th Anniversary of Distance Learning, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Measuring the Learning Outcomes of an Ethics Course presented at the Frontiers in Education conference. Cullen Grinnan, PhD (Education) co-presented the following papers, University, Business, and Community Partnerships: Targeting Hispanic Middle School Students and Their Families to Develop a College-Attending Culture at the 24th Annual Conference of the Hispanic Association of Colleges and Universities (HACU), Beyond Traditional Modes of Supervising Countertransference: Using Emogram to Uncover a Deeper Understanding at the Texas Counseling Association Professional Growth Conference. Jerrie Jackson, PhD (Education) presented a paper, Enhancing Teacher Preparation through Collaboration with School Districts and Community Partners, at the annual conference of the Association of Teacher Educators. Leah Larson, PhD (English) presented a papge, Thow doost brynge sexy bak’: Fan Response and the BBC Robin Hood at the International Association of Robin Hood Scholars conference at the University of Rochester. Mark Green, PhD, Meghan Carmody-Bubb, PhD, and Esther Chavez, PhD (Leadership Studies) were co-authors a paper, The Relationship between children’s self-esteem and views of their leadership ability, at the 5th International Conference on Civic Education Mark Green, PhD, Malcolm Ree, PhD, and Esther Chavez, PhD (Leadership Studies) were co-authors a paper, The Relationship between children’s body satisfaction leadership attitudes, presented at the 5th International Conference on Civic Education in Nashville. Mark Green, PhD, Malcolm Ree, PhD, and Diana Garza-Ortiz, PhD (Leadership Studies) co-authored a paper, The Relationship between leadership style and the gender of the workforce lead, at the 11th Annual Global Conference of the International Leadership. Mark Green, PhD, Meghan Carmody-Bubb, PhD, and Malcolm Ree, PhD (Leadership Studies) co-authored a paper, Leaders’ Talk – How Transformational Leaders Speak, at the 8th International Conference on Studying Leadership. 17. Mark Green, PhD and Phyllis Duncan, PhD (Leadership Studies) co-authored a paper, Leadership Preferences of Generation Y, X and Baby Boomers, presented at the 5th European Conference on Management Leadership and Governance. 18. Mark Green, PhD and Phyllis Duncan, PhD (Leadership Studies) co-authored a paper Virtual Communication, Transformational Leadership, Personality, and the Apparent Holographic Constructs of Implicit Leadership presented at the 68TH Annual Midwest Political Science Conference. 19. Harlene Anderson (Psychology) gave the keynote addresses at two conferences: The Power of Collaborating and the Philosophical Stance at the Constructing Worlds Conference in Copenhagen, Denmark and Challenging Clients-Challenged Therapists: A Postmodern Collaborative Approach to Working with Violence at the Poland Psychiatric Society Annual Conference. She also presented workshops on Collaborative Therapy for the Workshop for Postgraduate Certificate Program in Systemic Therapies in Leipzig, Germany, the Medical Division of Jagiellon University (Poland), and the Universidad de Mayab in Merida, Mexico. 20. Cynthia Medina, MSW (Social Work) co-presented a paper, Service Learning with a Latino Context: The Barrio as a Site for Learning, at the Council on Social Work Education Annual Meeting and presented a paper, In a Bad Economy, Searching for the Good: Empowering Communities through Engagement, at the President's Peace Commission Annual Conference, St. Mary's University. D. Productions 1. Martha Fabrique, DMA (Music) gave an on-campus recital entitled Flute Fantastique with symphony harpist Rachel Ferris and pianist Dr. Mark Alexander; she also performed with the Musical Offerings chamber ensemble at the San Antonio Museum of Art and gave a lecture recital at Texas State University entitled Japanese Shakuhachi. 2. Sr. Madlyn Pape, CDP, directed the OLLU Chorus in their performance of the GLORIA by Vivaldi. 3. Antoinette Winstead, MFA (Communication Arts) authored a short play, Doctor’s Secret Remedy, which is currently in production at the Cellar as part of the SAT Playwright’s Playfest. E. Community & Professional Organization Involvement 1. Catherine Rainwater, PhD (Biology) serves as the OLLU representative on the Westside Creeks Restoration Oversight Committee, and as chair of the Apache Creek Subcommittee of that body. 2. Ruth Fernandez, PhD (Communication Disorders) is working with the Texas Organization of Multicultural and Multilingual Speech-Pathologists and Audiologists (TOMMAS) a non-profit organization dedicated to recruiting and promoting professionals for service to CLD populations. 3. Jane Grovijahn, PhD (Religious Studies) serves on the CRS Southwest Regional Office consortium of Catholic Colleges and Universities. 16. Belinda Treviño Schouten, PhD (Education) serves as the co-chair for the Language Policy Special Interest Group for the National Association for Bilingual Education 5. Blaise Bender, J.D. (Business) was appointed to the Supervisory Committee of the San 4. Antonio Credit Union (SACU) and the Executive Board of the Texas Society of CPAs. Cora Le-Doux, PhD (Social Work) was elected to serve as President-elect of the National Association of Latino Social Work Educators F. Honors 1. Pablo Martinez, MFA (English) received the Robert L.B. Tobin Award for Artistic Excellence, the Literary Arts Award from the Artist Foundation of San Antonio, and is a Semi-Finalist for the Phillip Levine Prize in Poetry. He was also included in San Antonio Express-News article, “More San Antonians poised to make a difference in 2010” 2. Victor Treviño, MFA (Drama) was selected as the Distinguished Performance Artist for Tom McSweeney Productions in Sydney, Australia. The role of a Distinguished Performance Artist is to act as teacher/mentor for those pursing a professional life in theater, film or television. It also allows Victor the opportunity to act as casting director for major feature films and television series in Europe. 6. III. Faculty Concerns Approximately 70 faculty members representing all schools/colleges and academic ranks met informally on December 11, 2009 to discuss our growing concerns about the current state and direction of the University. A letter to the EVP and a supporting document will be delivered to the EVP during the week of January 18. CONSTITUENCY REPORT Board of Trustees Meeting of January 28, 2010 Submitted by Carlos Gonzalez , Constituency Representative I. Leadership Priorities for 2009 – 2010: Green Initiatives At the end of the Fall 2009 semester the Student Government Association was glad to learn that we had been approved for a strategic initiative grant for the start up costs and first initial year of a recycling program at OLLU. The proposal was submitted in conjunction with the office of Physical Plant, Students in Free Enterprise, and the Health Occupations Students of America. This grant will enable and empower students, faculty, staff, administration and our adjoining community to do our part in the recycling effort around the world and help preserve our environment by reducing the amount of waste that we produce. We hope the start of this program will showcase the caring nature of OLLU towards our world and environment and will be the first of other initiatives to become “green.” As part of our recycling effort SGA, SIFE, and HOSA participated in the city coordinated “Texas Recycles Day” at Woodlawn Lake Park. This event provided us with the opportunity to mingle with companies that recycle various products along with other universities with an existing recycling program. Smoking Resolution At the beginning of the 2008 spring semester students brought a concern to SGA that put smoking on our campus in focus. Through various meetings between smoking and non-smoking students and various committees a resolution was brought to the Student Voice Assembly which was passed at the end of the Fall 2009 semester. This resolution strongly recommends that the Vice President for Finance and Facilities implement an appropriate number of designated smoking areas that are safe, weather proofed, clean, fitted with proper receptacles and ash trays, are in accordance with the previously passed resolution and that it shall be applied to all university students, faculty, staff, and visitors for the improvement and enhancement of our campus community. Hunger and Homelessness Awareness Week The Student Government Association hosted its 9th annual Hunger and Homelessness Awareness Week this fall in conjunction with the Center for Service-Learning & Volunteerism (CSLV), the University Programming Council (UPC) and the Campus Ministry Office. The events held through out the week helped the OLLU community learn more about the different faces of homelessness and the different ways that we as a community can give back to those in need. The events ranged from service projects, hunger simulations, food drives, clothing drives, tours of the San Antonio Food Bank and the Haven for Hope. II. For Board Consideration: It’s been shared by a few dedicated students that they would like to attend meetings of the Board of Trustees strictly as spectators. Some of these students are involved heavily with Student Government, other organizations, and academics programs that wish to see how decisions are made at a higher level of our institution. To follow their request I have included it in this report for board consideration to have an additional seat or two for other spectators who would qualify to be in the room during a board meeting. Student Government understands that we have the privilege to already have a seat at board meetings but would like other students to share in the experience. III. New Activities: Public Safety Committee Staff members at OLLU are working with SGA to organize a group/initiative that is dedicated to promoting safety on campus by reviewing services provided by different departments. The Student Government Association has provided help by inviting this group to join with our existing Public Safety Committee to expand the views and range of perspective to this group which currently only meets with the university Chief of Police. Cafeteria Redesign As the voice of the students SGA has been asked to be of assistance in the refurnishing of the dining room areas through its existing Food Committee. This committee is being asked to meet with the director of dining services and architects in charge of the redesign of the dining areas to provide feedback on furniture and seating arrangements. IV. For Future Reports: A Greener OLLU In the future we will report on other proposals to make our campus greener. This will include some new technologies that are being researched to allow our campus to use technology to reduce our use of natural resources. CONSTITUENCY REPORT Board of Trustees Meeting, January 28, 2010 Submitted by Elissa McClain, Staff Advisory Council President I. Leadership Priorities: Staff Advisory Council continues to work on staff development and activities that will visibly bring the staff together. This spring the Advisory Council will hold an open meeting in February or March that will allow staff to sit in. There’s also plans to hold a brown bag luncheon that is a meet and greet to allow new staff to become familiar with the council member that represents their division. II. For Board Consideration: As a follow up from the last report—the search for a new Chief Technology Officer (CTO) for the university is complete. Joseph Deck from Wittenberg University in Springfield, Ohio is on board and is expected on campus soon after the MLK holiday. Customer service continues to be an important focus on campus and Staff Advisory Council will keep on with our efforts to implement new ways to promote and support training sessions and/or workshops. III. New Activities: The Staff Advisory Council had the opportunity to provide feedback on a document regarding shared governance within the university. Dr. Biever has been working with a committee of peers to develop an overview of shared governance as related to the university. It should also be noted that the Staff is working diligently within their departments to provide information to the various committees and task teams as needed for various reports to the Board of Trustees. The general attitude on campus is to continue on as a team to ensure student success and retention. The Staff Advisory Council’s website is in the works. Lizette Yanes has been patiently working with the Council to post information that will benefit and inform staff of our current projects and activities. IV. For Future Reports: The next report will hopefully be written by the newly elected Staff Constituency Representative. The council has been unsuccessful in obtaining three willing candidates for the election but our hopes are that a new search we will be more productive. This will occur before the next Board of Trustees meeting. IV. Other: The Rosemary Saenz Staff of Excellence Awards, funded by Board Chairman Edelmann, was presented on December 16th to four exemplary staff members during our Holiday Luncheon. Nominations were reviewed by a group of impartial judges including two faculty, two CDP’s, two students, and two administrators. The honorees were: Kimberly Gibson, TLTC Mary Parra, Communications & Marketing Daniel Perez, Academic Affairs Diana Ramos, Human Resources The awards were named in honor of the late Rosemary Saenz, OLLU’s switchboard operator for 25 years. Executive Vice President’s Report Our Lady of the Lake University Board of Trustees January 28, 2010 Attached to this report is my annual January letter to faculty and staff updating them on operations and planning. Particularly note in it the update on Main and other facilities and the description of the budget equilibrium process we are following to develop a balanced budget for 2010-11. This report is, as customarily, organized in alignment with the University’s five Strategic Goals. Key New Hire Joseph G. Deck is OLLU's new chief technology officer (CTO). Joe holds a BA from Indiana State University, an MA from Wesleyan University, and has completed the Harvard Management Development Program. He comes to OLLU from Wittenberg University in Springfield, OH where he has led the information technology division since 1997. Improve the quality of programs and support services. OLLU is one of ten universities selected to join the Council of Independent Colleges (CIC) / Collegiate Learning Assessment (CLA) Consortium project : Creating Pathways to Educational and Economic Opportunity in Urban Colleges and Universities. The project will consist of a study of the learning outcomes of students in urban institutions, and then the group will develop approaches for improving student learning particularly for underrepresented and at-risk undergraduates. Nick Lockard, assistant vice president of academic affairs, initiated the application and will be OLLU’s lead representative. The office of Campus Ministry has been renamed University Ministry in line with the strategic goal of expanding initiatives that further our Catholic identity. To promote Catholic identity, the Office of Mission and Ministry will host a presentation by Dr. Pat McCormick, Professor of Religious studies at Gonzaga University, on the topic “Creating a Welcoming Community by Practicing Jesus’ Table Manners.” Join us on February 19 at 8:30 a.m. More details on the website. Advising Week was initiated in the fall and will occur each semester. Faculty and staff advisors assist students in selecting courses for the next semester, reviewing their progress toward degree, and discussing career plans. Advising Week significantly increased the number of graduate and undergraduate students who had completed registration by the end of the semester. This process allows for greater efficiency in the scheduling of course, in addition to the personal relationships it fosters between faculty and students. Academic Affairs and Enrollment Management are developing an expanded support program for at risk students that will be a distinctive feature of our advising program. The Student Services Improvement Team, consisting of individuals from registrar, financial aid, administrative computing, and student business offices, is nearing completion of a year-long initiative that will reduce the complexity of managing our multiple course delivery time lines and administrative units. The results will include improved customer service in this areas and greater efficiency in such recurring processes as awarding financial aid, student billing, awarding refunds, and course scheduling. During fall semester the Student Emergency Response Plan was reviewed and revised to include the use of the OLLU Emergency Alert System. H1N1 vaccines were received in December and 100 vaccines were administered before Christmas break. Fortunately, fewer than 40 individuals with H1N1 or seasonal flu combined have come to Health Services for treatment this academic year. In response to a new Texas law and OLLU policy requiring all students living in campus housing to show proof of meningitis inoculation by January, we achieved 100% compliance. According to the national Project on Student Debt, OLLU graduates have the lowest debt average of any San Antonio university -- $18,169. Data from the same report show that figure is lower than the average debt of UTSA graduates ($20,815), whose tuition is subsidized with tax dollars. Increase engagement in learning, work, and service. Academic Council reviewed data on class periods and moved forward a revised plan for fall 2010 creating “community time” in the middle of the day five days a week and stretching our offerings more fully across the day. College/school faculty meet twice each month now, rather than just once to allow more opportunity for dialog, communication, and transparency. The Shared Governance Task Force continues its work on refining a shared governance document. As a complement to this work, the Faculty Assembly Bylaws Task Force and the Shared Governance Task Force met with Dr. Zeddie Bowen to further understand the interdependent nature of our work as faculty, administrators, staff and students. The first-ever workshop of Texas Catholic university student life and ministry personnel was hosted by OLLU in January. Sandra Estanek of Canisius University in Buffalo, NY focused on principles of good practice in student affairs at Catholic colleges. Over ninety attended. University Ministry will be hosting a series of retreats at OLLU for St. Gerard’s High School this winter. The staff will include OLLU’s young adult peer ministers. Our distinctive Leadership Institute for Freshmen Excellence (LIFE) fall program provided leadership training and mentorship to 35 students this year. Among our achievements in athletics, cross country runner Miriam Vazquez became the first OLLU student to compete in NAIA national championship competition. Men’s golf is ranked 20th in the nation. Expand, initiate, and modify academic programs to meet local and regional needs. OLLU is one of 25 models of “effective practices” for increasing the number of Hispanics with undergraduate degrees in STEM fields (science, technology, engineering and mathematics), according to the University of Southern California's Center for Urban Education. At OLLU, 78.2 percent of STEM degrees were awarded to Hispanics in 2005-06. That percentage ranked fourth among the 25 Hispanic Serving Institutions (HSI’s) cited in the report. We are in the process of planning adult programming in Northeast San Antonio and have signed a preliminary agreement to offer courses in that neighborhood through the Alamo Colleges University Center, which will open in 2010. We have begun recruiting for our site in Harlingen for the BAS degree in CISS. Students will transfer from Texas State Technical College, which has a strong two-year program in this field. Faculty in CISS have put the master’s program on line so that it will be more attractive to active duty military personnel. If deployed prior to completing the program in San Antonio, they will be able to continue their studies without any interruption. Enhance facilities and technology to improve learning. The current status of Main and 24th Street projects are detailed in my letter to the campus (attached). The new sound system has been installed in Thiry Auditorium. Computer labs in Metz and smart classroom upgrades in the library have been completed in time for the spring semester. Athletic games are being simulcast on the web, and social media is taking off at OLLU thanks to collaborations among IT, Communications and Marketing, and Academic Affairs. Develop a long-term comprehensive financial plan that guides institutional progress. The financial equilibrium process being used to prepare a balanced budget for 2010-11 is described in my letter to the campus (attached). In order to use endowed scholarship revenue more strategically, Enrollment Management and Institutional Advancement staff are collaborating on revising the awarding process. Dear Faculty, Staff, and Administrative Colleagues, Welcome back for the spring 2010 semester. Thank you for your efforts in the fall as we seek ways to improve the quality of education and services we provide to our students. This year promises to be a significant one in the life of Our Lady of the Lake University. The completion of Main Building represents more than the renovation of a historic building. At the same time workers are engaged in rebuilding, we are similarly engaged in enhancing educational programs and services for current and future students. What we accomplish now will strengthen the University and position us for growth. We are blessed to be members of this great University at a pivotal moment when significant changes are necessary to secure its future. We have the opportunity to be as important in shaping its history as those who taught and studied in Main during the formative decades prior to World War II when Our Lady of the Lake matured and developed the distinctive character that we prize today. As has been my custom, I wish to provide you with a mid-year report on University operations and planning. I will continue to update you on these matters, and others, in my weekly remarks carried in eCurrents. ACHIEVING BUDGET EQUILIBRIUM In accordance with the Strategic Goals of the University <LINK>, the University Planning and Budgeting Council (UPBC) has endorsed an action plan <LINK> to “develop a long-term comprehensive financial plan that guides institutional progress.” After a 6.5 percent drop in enrollment the occurred in fall 2007, the Board charged the administration with increasing enrollment and balancing the budget in three years. As enrollment slightly increased over the past two years, we are at the point where we complete this charge with a better understanding of our expected tuition income. The process to achieve a secure financial future for OLLU requires matching the services we provide to a sustainable level of income from tuition, auxiliary operations, gifts, and contributions from the endowment. This semester we will develop and present to the Board of Trustees a balanced budget for 2010-11. Last semester the UPBC reviewed the University’s reliance on revenue from the Kenedy Trust to support the annual operating budget. Over the past decade, while enrollment decreased, the University received steadily increasing revenue <LINK to KENEDY CHART> generated by our share in the Trust, which is comprised primarily of oil and natural gas assets and is managed by Frost Bank. This year, however, the Trust is projected to pay out approximately $2,000,000 less than last year, and profits are not expected to rebound to the previous high levels in the near future. The University’s long-term financial plan needs to address both the level of reliance on the Kenedy Trust to meet operating expenses as well as the significant reduction in the annual disbursement. To begin putting revenues and expenditures into balance, in December a thorough review of operating budgets was conducted by division heads. Based on the knowledge that overall, many budgets have not been completely expended in previous years, approximately $950,000 of savings in the 2009-10 budget have been identified. In addition, previously unbudgeted contributions totaling approximately $400,000 for scholarships have been credited to this year’s budget. These changes reduce by approximately fortyfive percent the projected shortfall that resulted from not meeting the fall enrollment target. Higher than projected enrollments for the rest of the year can positively affect the total. As of today, spring 2010 enrollments are running slightly ahead of last year, and we are developing new recruitment strategies to exceed targets for the May summer session of WEC. To reduce the chance of such a shortfall in the future, the University will base the 2010-11 budget on the same enrollment we had in Fall 2009 rather than on a stretch goal. If we are fortunate and exceed the budget enrollment, producing additional revenue, a process will be in place to fund new projects in the fall. During the next several months, each division head, working collaboratively with others on the Administrative Council, will use a modified zero-based budgeting process in developing next year’s budget. The widely-recognized benefits of this process include: linking operational budgets to strategic goals, investing in programs and services that have the greatest positive influence on recruitment and retention, focusing on value, identifying cost-effective ways to improve operations, and eliminating waste. Along with other Universities, we must invest in our core competencies, continually improve effectiveness, and focus on demonstrable results. By doing so, we will strengthen the University and ensure its future viability. In these economic times, such measures are prudent and among the best practices in higher education. As the 2010-11 budget is developed over the next several months, all departments and offices will be engaged in determining their essential and less critical functions and prioritizing the projects that they intend to accomplish in line with the University’s strategic goals and their division and unit strategic plans. This work will challenge all of us to define our purpose more clearly, make strategic changes, and act in the long-term best interests of the University. The UPBC will play a key role in assessing potential budgetary priorities that emerge from the divisions in this process and, at the end of the process, in recommending a budget to President Pollack for Board approval. I invite all of you to contribute ideas to an electronic suggestion box<LINK to eComments>. Your ideas will help us identify new sources of revenue and potential cost savings. All of your comments will be reviewed by the Strategic Budgeting Task Force (comprised of the Vice Presidents for Academic Affairs, Finance and Facilities, Student Life, and myself), which is responsible for this year’s budget process. RECONSTRUCTION OF MAIN BUILDING We remain on schedule for fall opening of Main Building. Our architect and contractors are working on a tight schedule to coordinate the arrival of While unforeseen complications may arise because of the delivery of materials and the awarding of ciiy permits, for example, they are hopeful that the project will be completed so classes can start in August in Main. The work of campus focus groups the summer after the fire is coming to life inside the building. In the next several weeks we will receive the interior design recommendations from the architect. You have noticed exterior progress on the roof and dormers. When we know the date of the new spire being set in place, we will celebrate that symbolic moment. Moving back into Main will involve planning and coordination. In the coming months you can expect a sequenced move-in plan for Main. OTHER FACILITIES Space modifications in the Sister Annie B and Gold Dining Rooms I, II, and III were made over the break in order to install HVAC capabilities in the spring. We can expect further enhancements over the summer as we prepare to reopen Main. During the fall semester two classrooms were completed in St. Martin Hall annex. In the near future space for library cataloging and for the IT Help Desk will be completed. Renovations are nearly complete at the TLTC that will improve the use of that space for instructional purposes. Proposals for renovating biology and chemistry laboratories are being received. The work on these will begin later this semester and continue over three years thanks to funding awarded to Professor Robbie Kouri in a Title V grant from the Department of Education. During the spring semester we will be seeking proposals from architectural firms for renovations to Walter Center to house those IT units that were displaced because of the fire in Main. ENHANCING 24th STREET Improvements to 24th Street have received approval from relevant city departments, and a contract for the project will be approved by the City Council in the next several weeks. These changes include reducing traffic to one lane in each direction, adding bike lanes and a median, burying power cables, and replacing water and sewer lines. In addition to the $2.4 million in city funds dedicated to this project, SAWS will install new water and sewer lines for a cost still to be determined. Over the coming months, a timetable for the work will be determined. RECOGNIZING ACHIEVEMENTS This year we continue to advance our five Strategic Goals through the efforts of each division. 1. Quality of programs and support services is better because of improvements in teach, advising, and co-curricular activities, and greater efficiency of many processes. 2. All of us are more engage in learning, work, and service, as many of you have commented to me during the fall semester. There is a new energy on campus that has not been felt in some time, you have remarked. 3. We are expanding and initiating programs that meet local and regional needs. This work has involved both graduate and undergraduate faculty, and students have expressed their satisfaction. 4. Facilities and technology have been enhanced in ways I have described above. 5. We are developing a long-term comprehensive financial plan. The budget process initiated this spring will link planning, assessment, and budgeting more closely than in previous years. Thank you all for being engaged in the life of the University, especially this coming semester when we have much important work to do that will affect our future. Because of your wisdom and resolve, I am confident about our future. Sincerely, OUR LADY OF THE LAKE UNIVERSITY BOARD OF TRUSTEES KEY DATES (January 28, 2010) __________________________________________________________________ EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE MEETINGS Date Time Location January 07, 2010 04:00 P.M. – 05:30 P.M. Moye 106 March 04, 2010 04:00 P.M. – 05:30 P.M. Moye 106 May 06, 2010 04:00 P.M. – 05:30 P.M. Moye 106 ____________________________________________________________________ BOARD OF TRUSTEES MEETINGS January 28, 2010 March 25, 2010 May 27, 2010 10:00 A.M. – 01:30 P.M. 10:00 A.M. – 01:30 P.M. 10:00 A.M. – 01:30 P.M. PWSR/Prov Blue Room Library Community Room PWSR/Prov Blue Room *Note: Board committees meet sometime between 08:00 A.M. and 09:45 A.M. _____________________________________________________________________________ INSTITUTIONAL ADVANCEMENT & BOARD DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE January 28, 2010 08:30 A.M. – 09:45 A.M. Library Room 104 FINANCE AND PLANNING COMMITTEE January 28, 2010 08:00 A.M. – 09:45 A.M. IFCC ACADEMIC, STUDENT LIFE, AND MISSION MINISTRY COMMITTEE January 28, 2010 TBD UWAC 104 ______________________________________________________________________ COMMENCEMENTS May 8, 2010 11:00 A.M. - 12:00 P.M. Municipal Auditorium Dec 11, 2010 11:00 A.M. – 12:00 P.M. Municipal Auditorium _______________________________________________________________________ President’s Report Board of Trustees Meeting January 28, 2010 Overview This report of non-exhaustive achievements spans the period since the last report in October, 2009 and is categorized by: 1) the University Priorities for 2009-2010; 2) the Capital Campaign and Other Fundraising; and 3) Partnership-Building and Government Relations. University Priorities for 2009-2010 Significant work has been done on revision of the University’s Mission Statement in anticipation of the upcoming SACS accreditation visit. Comments from faculty, staff, and students will be solicited in January with approval by the Board of Trustees in March. Work toward our goal of recruiting five new Trustees is progressing well with some promising choices who can add to our Board team. We are currently at a variety of stages in vetting candidates; names will be shared within the appropriate process. We debriefed with the following individuals on respective special projects that will bring new synergy and opportunities to OLLU: Henry Munoz, Chair of the VIA Metropolitan Transit Board RE: Plans by VIA’s Intra-city Rail and Streetcar Commission to have a streetcar system connecting north and south (Hildebrand and Broadway to the missions) and east and west (ATT Center to General McMullen). Urban designer, Gabriel Velasquez and Jesse Trevino, renowned artist RE: Plans and fundraising on the Hispanic Veterans Memorial at Elmendorf Park; Colleen Sorenson, tile ceramicist, RE: Desire to contribute distinctive signage in the area; and Michael Tejeda, Chief of Staff for City Councilman David Medina, District 5 RE: Councilman Medina’s support for proposed improvements around the University. Trustee Mitch Meyer facilitated an opportunity for me to give a state of the university address and students on the Speech and Debate Team to share a reading at his breakfast club. Marketing and Communications continues to provide media support for presentations and interviews that I am conducting related to (by example): The Hispanic Outlook on Higher Education The San Antonio Business Journal The $2.4 million science lab grant George Gervin’s participation in pre-game ceremonies of the first basketball game OLLU Annual Donation (in lieu of cards): Children’s Shelter, 2009 Recipient Capital Campaign and Other Fundraising Henry Cisneros, PhD, the first Hispanic Mayor of a major US city and former US Secretary of Housing and Urban Development, will chair the University’s Capital Campaign. The University had its most successful “Builders of our Future” (formerly called Founder’s Day) luncheon in recent history for more than 300 donors and special guests. The event also kicked off a series of alumni week events that attracted more than 300 alumni. We plan format changes next year to better leverage our costs and realize greater fundraising impact from combining constituencies and events. Our monthly meetings with Gonzer, Gerber, Tinker, and Stuhr (GGTS) are intense, productive, and focused to meet goals: 1) to attain the $13.5 fundraising goal; and 2) most importantly, to position the University for a longterm fundraising culture and capacity. Progress to impact the four Fundraising Priorities includes: Main Space is being identified, and drawings are being completed to create a “menu” of naming opportunities. Proposals are being prepared for presentation to individuals and corporations. Scholarships and Annual Fund We have received $595,000 in gifts and pledges from eight board members, the CDP’s, and the President. From December 21 to the end of 2009 (10 days), we recorded 147 gifts in the amount of $68,076. Alumni Giving The percentage of alumni giving increased from 1% to 6% since the October Board Meeting. Leadership is employing a new phonathon solicitation methodology that utilizes electronic calling equipment for automated dialing and professional training of students. Every member in our alumni database of 22,593 received a personal phone call during this year’s phonathon. The two weeks of Fall phonathon yielded $47,930 in gifts and pledges from 736 alumni with an average gift of $61. A second phonathon is scheduled for February. Institutional Advancement and Marketing and Communications have reached significantly improved coordination for prospect management, cultivation, fundraising, and stewardship efforts. The work of leadership and staff in these two areas leads to high quality messaging for important cultivation and solicitation efforts like the “phonathon,” the alumni newsletter, the year-end email appeal, collateral material for the campaign, induction and orientation of the Committee of 2015 (the official name of the OLLU campaign cabinet), VIP tours, and special events. Slow and steady progress is being made on the National Center for the Higher Education of Mexican Americans (NCHEMA), one of the funding priorities in our capital campaign. The NCHEMA priority reads as follows in campaign material: NATIONAL RESOURCE Become a national resource to higher education, cities, and corporations seeking effective Mexican American graduates in business, education, social services, and healthcare across America Goal: $1 million Our biggest challenge is prioritizing fundraising to attract dollars that will fund a planning process. As funding priorities currently stand, fundraising for the visionary NCHEMA must compete with other components in the campaign that immediately impact budget (e.g., scholarship). For now, we will fund a modified planning process for NCHEMA as a robust plan is an essential antecedent to attract external funding support. Additionally, leadership is in discussions with the Council of Independent Colleges, a national organization of independent peer institutions, and other member colleges and universities for a consortium effort to advance this effort. We have numerous programs and recognitions in place that position us to make a claim as a national resource on one of the most critical issues facing the country. Our most recent is this month’s notice that OLLU is one of 25 universities in the nation with effective practices for increasing the number of Latino recipients of bachelor’s degrees in the STEM (science, technology, engineering, and mathematics fields), according to a national study by the University of Southern California’s Center (USC) for Urban Education. OLLU has an overall Hispanic undergraduate enrollment of 77.1 percent, an 80.1 percent Hispanic enrollment in STEM majors, and 78.2 percent of STEM degrees awarded to Hispanics. Nationally, data shows that only about eight percent of bachelor’s degrees in STEM fields are awarded to Hispanics. Coincidentally, the San Antonio Hispanic Chamber has invited OLLU’s participation in the Chamber’s grant-funded program to promote higher education, particularly in the STEM career fields. Prospect and relationship management is the most critical process of successful fundraising. A new record-keeping system developed and implemented this fall tracks leadership and staff efforts to move donors and potential donors through multiple cultivation stages toward major gift and campaign commitments. By example, status on more than 60 individuals in the President’s personal contact list is reviewed weekly; cultivation strategies are developed or refined; desired outcomes are set; and progress on each prospect is noted to define the next move. The list contains highly confidential donor information and, for that reason, is not disseminated in this report. This process is reiterated by every staff member in Institutional Advancement who has a prospect portfolio. Partnership-Building and Government Comprehensive Development Plan Relations Instrumental to a OLLU’s 2011 Legislative Agenda identifies three proposals in the amount of $2.9 million for advancement by Washington DC lobbyists Marilyn Thompson and Ryan Haaker; proposals are: Cyber Security Program - to provide students on-line access to research networks and security labs that will simulate the demands and challenges of the workplace and provide a platform for research in Industrial Control System networks ($1.257 million) RN-Bachelor’s of Science in Nursing (BSN) and RN-Master’s of Science in Nursing (MSN) Programs - to provide pathways for registered nurses to earn higher education degrees and meet the critical shortage of nurse educators ($650,000) Expansion of the Center for Science and Mathematics Success Program – to add resources and two new labs for the improvement of teachers’ understanding of Energy and Earth Science and to provide tuition assistance for 60 graduate level science teachers ($1 million) OLLU senior, Alicia Aguilar, has been selected by Congressman Charlie Gonzalez to serve a spring internship in his San Antonio Office. Alicia will track the University’s 2011 Legislative Agenda through the House budget process; become familiar with projects, events, and issues in Congressional District 20 that impact the University; and assist Congressman Gonzalez’ staff to serve the needs of District 20 constituents. Alicia will graduate in May and is applying to law school. In the cause of advancing internships, OLLU and the new First National Bank on Buena Vista are carving out an effort to place University students as interns in the bank and as well as to provide our students with financial literacy skills.