PHILIPPINES 2013 Philippines Development Forum Marco Polo Hotel, Davao City, Philippines February 4-5, 2013 Summary of Event Background 1. The 2013 Philippines Development Forum (PDF) was held at the Marco Polo Hotel, Davao City, Philippines on February 4-5, 2013. The PDF is a multi-stakeholder forum that serves as the Government’s main mechanism to facilitate substantive policy dialogue on the country’s development agenda among participants from national and local government units, civil society, academia, private sector, and the international development partners. 2. As in past PDFs, the Government of the Philippines, led by the Department of Finance, organized and hosted the 2013 PDF with support from the Bank. Finance Secretary Cesar Purisima served as the Chair of the meeting. Mr. Motoo Konishi, World Bank Country Director for the Philippines, served as Co-Chair for the meeting. President Simeon Benigno Aquino delivered the closing remarks. Government representatives at the meeting included 12 Cabinet secretaries and other high-level officials from various Government agencies. Seventeen delegations1from multilateral and bilateral partners and agencies were represented. Representatives from a variety of national and international civil society organizations (CSOs), private sector, chambers of commerce, and other branches of Government attended. In total, about 320 participants attended. 3. The first PDF under the Aquino administration was held two years ago in February 2011 with the theme of “Implementing President Aquino’s Social Contract to Achieve Inclusive Growth”. The forum then discussed the President’s Social Contract with the Filipino People2 the draft 2011-2016 Philippines Development Plan (PDP), and the Government’s priorities under the Aquino administration. Overview of Agenda and Plenary Presentations 4. The overall theme of the 2013 PDF was “President Aquino’s Social Contract: Moving Forward in Achieving Inclusive Growth and Good Governance”. As the second PDF event under the Aquino administration, this forum served as a “report back” on the progress under the Social Contract and a discussion of the remaining challenges for the remaining 3 years or so under the current administration. The 2013 PDF also had a special focus on Mindanao in order to 1 Included delegations from Australia, Canada, China, France, Germany, Japan, Korea, New Zealand, Spain, United Kingdom and the United States of America. International organizations which participated in the forum included the Asian Development, European Union, International Monetary Fund, Saudi Fund for Development, various United Nations agencies and the World Bank Group. 2 President Benigno S. Aquino III’s Social Contract with the Filipino People is the Administration’s platform for its term until 2016. It envisions a country that has achieved inclusive growth and is characterized by rapid, sustained, and broad-based economic growth that is focused on creating more jobs and new opportunities to achieve full employment, and on significantly reducing poverty. The Social Contract outlines 16 priority areas, and is further translated into a more detailed blueprint in the Philippine Development Plan 2016. 2013 Philippines Development Forum Summary of Event integrate into the discussions the development challenges of the region which is critical to the country’s overall development. This topic was particularly important in light of the breakthrough signing of a Framework Agreement on Bangsamoro in October 2012, which is a major step towards a peace agreement for Mindanao. 5. The Government re-structured the program for the 2013 PDF to make it as interactive as possible. Reading of statements by delegations was strongly discouraged and instead, written statements were allowed to be distributed at the event3. A panel set-up was used for the first topic on the macroeconomic developments. This allowed one representative each from civil society, private sector, and academe to share their reactions to the presentations, so that the voices and views from these groups of stakeholders were heard upfront. After the panelists, other stakeholders, including development partners were also given a chance to react and raise questions on the topic. Break-out sessions were organized by “clustered” working groups to align with the Government’s Cabinet cluster themes. (See attached program.) 6. The Chair and Co-Chair delivered the welcome remarks and opening statements respectively to open the Forum and set the stage for the meeting. The Government presentations and discussions at the first plenary session focused on two main themes: the country’s macroeconomic, budget and fiscal performance; and, Mindanao. Economic Planning Secretary Arsenio Balisacan highlighted the Philippines’ growth of 6.6% for the full year, noting that this growth was broad-based with almost all sectors significantly contributing to the output, and close to the 7 to 8-percent growth target set in the Philippine Development Plan. He reported that the country had been commended for its sound macroeconomic fundamentals, with low and stable inflation, favorable interest rates, sustainable fiscal and external position, a strong financial sector, and an improvement in the Philippines’ global competitiveness ranking. Secretary Balisacan recognized that more needs to be done in terms of attaining inclusive growth. While noting that official data on poverty for 2012 was not yet available, Secretary Balisacan observed that indicators on self-rated poverty and severe hunger were on the decline. 7. On public expenditure management, Budget Secretary Florencio Abad reported that the Government has been able to improve the pace and quality of public spending which was a key contributor to the country’s strong GDP growth last year. He reported on key indicators such as increased disbursements, infrastructure spending, government final consumption expenditures, and public construction which have provided the country with the needed momentum to face key development challenges in the remaining three-and-a-half years of the Administration, particularly in terms of ensuring inclusive economic growth and poverty reduction through creation of more jobs and livelihood opportunities. 8. On fiscal management, Finance Secretary Cesar Purisima (Chair of the PDF) zeroed in on the Government’s rationalization of the ODA process through a new financing framework for national projects. Secretary Purisima reported that under the Aquino administration from July 2010 to June 2013, 60 projects totaling 568 billion pesos would have been implemented, bidded out, or appraised. Under the new framework, projects would be developed and approved and the 3 Written statements were provided by the European Union, United States, United Nations Country Team, Joint Foreign Chambers of the Philippines, and the Official Development Assistance – Gender and Development Network, which are now posted at the PDF website: pdf.ph. 2 2013 Philippines Development Forum Summary of Event funding source would subsequently be identified by the DoF independent of the financing for project preparation. Secretary Purisima enjoined the country’s international development partners and other stakeholders to provide continued support and cooperation to these reforms. Secretary Prusima also noted the country’ improved revenue collections, particularly the expected benefits from the new Sin Tax Law, and noted the need to build similar capacity in the ARMM to improve revenue collections there. Panel reactors for this topic consisted of Professor Cielito Habito (from academe), Ms. Milwida Guevarra (from civil society), and Mr. Senen Bacani (from private sector). 9. On the topic of Mindanao,Secretary Luwalhati Antonino, Chair of the Mindanao Development Authority (MinDA), reported on the current state of Mindanao, noting that the country's positive environment of strong business confidence and brighter economic growth prospects, and the major reforms instituted by the national government have been mirrored in Mindanao. Secretary Teresita Deles, Presidential Advisor on the Peace Process, focused her presentation on the Framework Agreement on the Bangsamoro and its potential effects on the political, economic and social landscape of Mindanao. 10. Mr. Mohammad Amin, Secretary of the Moro Islamic Liberation Front (MILF) Central Committee delivered MILF Chair’s Ibrahim Murad’s written speech. MILF expressed its gratitude for being invited to the PDF. It recognized the importance of development partners in contributing to the Bangsamoro transitional process and in the development of Mindanao, which would contribute to the overall stability in the Southeast Asian region. MILF noted that savings generated by the Philippine Government in the absence of war can be utilized to increase the budget for social, infrastructure and other projects. The statement noted that the MILF will be awaiting for the formation of the Bangsamoro government in rebuilding the its economy and hopefully sustain its growth. Meantime, MILF expressed need for assistance for former combatants in terms of livelihood, education, protection against flooding, among other things. Key Messages and Recommendations 11. The main objective of the 2013 PDF was to generate consensus from multi-stakeholder discussions on key policy recommendation that the Government should consider in order to help achieve its targets under the Social Contract in the remaining three years under the Aquino Administration. Hence, the key messages at the PDF are best captured in the recommendations from each of the six cluster/sub-cluster groups. 12. On Economic Development, the key message was that since the country has made strides in expanding the productive capacity of its economy, focus should now be given towards making it more inclusive, by ensuring that more and better quality jobs are created. The challenge of providing good jobs to the projected 14.6 million unemployed and under-employed Filipinos in 2016 was highlighted, and urgency of addressing this was stressed given the opportunities to benefit from the rebalancing that is taking place in the region. 13. The need to continue to improve the environment for the private sector to generate jobs in the next 3 years was recommended, especially in agriculture and tourism given the strong forward and backward linkages in these sectors. It was suggested that the cost of doing business be reduced through simplification and streamlining of business regulation and processes (such as 3 2013 Philippines Development Forum Summary of Event national single window, business entry and licensing). The need to urgently remove barriers to entry for private businesses, especially in the areas of inter-island shipping, which would help ease the pressure on food prices was also stressed. In that regard, now that the country had achieved increased palay production, the need to look at crops in which the Philippines has comparative advantage was pointed out. To further support this agenda, critical laws such as the National Land Use Code, the Competition Policy Law and the Cabotage Law were recommended to be enacted or revisited. All of these would have country- wide impacts, but more so in Mindanao, which was recognized as the food basket of the country and where inclusive growth would make the greatest difference in people's lives. 14. The importance of better infrastructure to more inclusive development was discussed, noting that infrastructure spending by government needed to increase from 2.6 percent to 5 percent of the GDP by 2016. A coherent and efficient intermodal transport roadmap with backbone links to growth areas was suggested for adoption through close coordination of line agencies (Departments of Transportation and Communication, and Public Works and Highways). And, for Mindanao, the need to augment the stimulus funds for infrastructure development (power, roads, and ports) was noted as essential to reap the dividends of peace and stability. To sustainably finance this and other planned increases in public spending, the discussions highlighted the need to pass the Fiscal Incentives Bill, which was expected to help in leveling the playing field and provide support to strategic, job-creating, economic activities. 15. On Human Development and Poverty Reduction, expanding the access and improving the quality of the flagship programs in health, education and social protection -- including the conditional cash transfer program – was noted as essential for the inclusive growth agenda. Rigorous monitoring and impact evaluation of these programs and the availability of credible, frequent and disaggregated data, was recommended. In addition, the need for the government’s programs to be increasingly integrated and converged at the national, regional, and local levels, was stressed, with a particular focus of programs on disadvantaged groups, including out-ofschool youth, indigenous peoples, persons with disabilities, and drop-outs. Finally, in the interest of better jobs, it was suggested that public-private partnerships be strengthened to better address the skills mismatch, and re-alignment of the curriculum to better meet labor market needs. 16. On Justice and Peace, the key challenge that was articulated was to re-establish trust in the justice system which could be achieved by addressing outdated laws, clearing the large backlogs in court cases, decongesting jails, and removing inefficiency and corruption. Recommendations focused on strengthening information systems and linking budget to performance for state institutions, based on clearly defined targets. At the same time the need to improve economic justice and support community-based traditional systems of justice that handle the vast majority of disputes was recommended. Problems with traditional justice mechanisms at the barangay level were also identified, particularly for groups marginalized from local power structures, including women and children. The need for better interface between state and non-state justice institutions was discussed, particularly in Mindanao and the Bangsamoro, where traditional systems remain the predominant forum for dispute resolution. Support for the Shari'a justice system was also identified as an important priority in the context of the Framework Agreement on the Bangsamoro. 4 2013 Philippines Development Forum Summary of Event 17. On Climate Change Adaptation and Mitigation, it was noted that climate change and disaster risks are issues critical to sustainable development and national security issues, and that the Government has developed a comprehensive, innovative and much welcome climate change and disaster reform agenda. It was noted that Government's challenge in the next 3 years is to complete the reforms, address bottlenecks, and speed up implementation, which would require convergence of government agencies, local government units and development partners; fast tracking the consolidation of vulnerability and risk assessments; continuing to improve disaster risk management; and mobilizing effectively the needed resources in technology, capacity and financing. In Mindanao, it was suggested that the government could consider adopting an ecosystem-based "reef to ridge" approach, whereby upstream (watershed), midstream, and downstream (coastal areas) areas are considered in an integrated manner. 18. On Good Governance and Anti-Corruption, it was agreed that while the government has made significant gains in the areas of public financial management, procurement and anticorruption reforms, much remains to be done to ensure the sustainability of the reform momentum. Further strengthening the links between government’s planning, budgeting and performance management systems was recommended to ensure that citizens feel the immediate and direct benefits of good governance. Strengthening the bureaucracy’s capacity to more meaningfully engage with citizens, civil society, business, and other stakeholders in open, transparent and accountable manner was also recommended, while recognizing that reform stakeholders also face capacity and resource constraints in effectively engaging both national and local government processes. Three broad areas for action in helping sustain reforms were recommended: build and empower constituencies for reform that will demand for and support good governance; strengthen monitoring and evaluation mechanisms, especially those related to public financial management and performance management systems; and give special attention to governance reform and institution building efforts in Mindanao within the framework of the President’s Social Contract, taking into consideration its development, humanitarian and peace building context. Conclusion 19. It was agreed that Mr. Konishi as Co-Chair of the PDF deliver the Highlights of the PDF prepared jointly by the DOF and the World Bank. He summarized the recommendations from the cluster/sub-cluster discussions. On overall messages, the Co-Chair reported that based on what was heard from many stakeholders at the forum, the Philippines should be commended for its sound and stable macroeconomic fundamentals, improving fiscal situation, determined fight against corruption, and transparency in various levels of government. As a result, the Co-Chair reported, there was consensus at the PDF that this Administration’s commitment to good governance was genuine, and this has contributed to a breakthrough in the peace negotiations in Mindanao, higher confidence in the prospects for the country, and an upsurge in the country’s economic growth. 20. The Co-Chair noted that the Administration has demonstrated that good governance is good economics. The Government was urged to accelerate and sustain the reform agenda, and strengthen implementation through sharper focus, better selectivity, through drive for results, and through coalitions for reform—coalitions drawn from the private sector, labor, NGOs, civil 5 2013 Philippines Development Forum Summary of Event society, academe and us, the development partners. It was noted that not only would those coalitions help implement the reforms, they would also ensure that these reforms would become irreversible and promote good governance. The Co-Chair noted the participants’ shared view that if the Government and all its stakeholders continue to work together in accelerating the existing reform agenda, with a renewed sense of urgency, then this Administration would leave an irreversible and lasting legacy: the legacy of inclusive growth. So he urged the Government and all its stakeholders to work together in bending the arc of history towards achieving this legacy. 21. In his closing remarks, President Aquino noted that the past couple of years had been historic for the country’s macroeconomic performance, citing the full year growth for 2012 at 6.6 percent. The President noted that indicators point to increased private sector activity and capacity, signaling his view that growth had become more sustainable, and that improved consumption capacity of Filipinos meant that the growth had benefited households as well. However, the President acknowledged that in moving forward, the challenge would be how to ensure that the gains are inclusive, and can be even more inclusive. 22. President Aquino also pointed out that in large part, the gains in the past two years resulted from the Government’s commitment to good governance—to ensuring that integrity, transparency, and accountability guide government operations, not only in national agencies but in local government units as well. President Aquino noted that the Filipino people were the country’s strongest competitive advantage, and the reason why the Government continues to invest heavily in them through increased budget for the Pantawid Pamilyang Pilipino Program, (or the Conditional Cash Transfer Program), expansion of the PhilHealth program to provide healthcare coverage for the poorest of the Filipino people, as well as in basic education through the launch of the “K to 12 program” that would help bring Philippine education up to international standards. 23. The President observed the increased confidence of the international community, and expressed appreciation for their continued support, particularly to Mindanao. He cited the signing last year of the Framework Agreement on the Bangsamoro which he hopes would bring an end to the decades-long insurgency, and bring a final, enduring peace to Mindanao. President Aquino acknowledged the need for the reforms to extend beyond 2016, and affirmed through the PDF the necessity of positive participation: not merely to point out the problems, but more importantly, he said, for everyone to become part of the solution. 24. President Aquino ended his closing speech by saying, “It is my hope that the partnerships that have been forged here, together with the practices of collaboration and of open dialogue, extend beyond this day—that you continue to embody the spirit of cooperation and service, and become an inspiration to others. In this way, we will be able to realize fully the commitments we made to each other and the Filipino people, and walk along the straight path together to the fulfillment of our dreams for the Philippines.” 25. All statements, presentations, and other documentation on the 2013PDF are posted on the PDF website: pdf.ph. 6 2013 Philippines Development Forum Summary of Event 2013 PHILIPPINES DEVELOPMENT FORUM February 4-5, 2013 Marco Polo Hotel, Davao City PROGRAM Theme: President Aquino’s Social Contract: Moving Forward in Achieving Inclusive Growth and Good Governance February 3 6:00 p.m. - 7:30 p.m. Cocktails hosted by World Bank Group for Heads of Delegation (plus one), Cabinet Secretaries, and Special Guests at the pool area, Marco Polo Hotel, Davao City February 4 (Note: All plenary sessions will be held at the Grand Ballroom, Marco Polo Hotel) 9:00 a.m. - 9:15 a.m. Opening Session (Grand Ballroom) Welcome by the Chairperson Opening Statement by the Co-Chairperson 9:15 a.m. – 12:30 p.m. Session I: Plenary Session on Overall Developments 9:15 a.m. - 10:45 a.m. Presentation and Panel Discussion on overall progress under the Social Contract and Macroeconomic and Fiscal Developments, to be followed by General Discussions GOP: DOF Secretary Cesar V. Purisima DBM Secretary Florecio B. Abad NEDA Secretary Arsenio M. Balisan Panelists: Professor Cielito F. Habito, Ateneo de Manila University Ms. Milwida M. Guevarra, Synergeia Mr. Senen Bacani, La Frutera, Inc. 10:45 a.m. -11:00 a.m. ***Coffee break to transition to next panel discussion.*** 11:00 a.m.-12:30 p.m. Government presentation on Mindanao, to be followed by General Discussions Secretary Luwalhati Antonino – Mindanao Development Authority Secretary Teresita Q. Deles – Office of the Presidential Adviser on the Peace Process 7 2013 Philippines Development Forum Summary of Event 12:30 pm – 1:30 p.m. Lunch (Café Marco) 1:30 p.m. - 5:30 p.m. Session II: Two Sets of Parallel Break-Out Sessions by Cabinet Clusters/Sub-cluster: Addressing the challenges in achieving the Social Contract targets in the medium-term in the following areas: First Set: 1:30 p.m.3:30 pm. Convenors: A. Good Governance and Anti-Corruption DBM Secretary Florencio B. Abad B. Human Development and Poverty Reduction DSWD Secretary Corazon J. Soliman C. Infrastructure (sub-cluster) NEDA Secretary Arsenio M. Balisacan Second Set: 3:30 p.m. 5:30 p.m. D. Justice and Peace (sub-cluster) DOJ Secretary Leila De Lima / designate E. Climate Change Adaptation and Mitigation CCC Secretary Mary Anne Lucille L. Sering F. Economic Development NEDA Secretary Arsenio M. Balisacan 6:00 p.m. – 9:00 p.m. Note: Mindanao Working Group members are expected to spread out among break-out sessions to provide a Mindanao perspective to the discussions. Informal heavy cocktails hosted by the Philippine Government for all delegates at the Rosa Santos Munda Events Center, PWC, Davao City February 5 9:00 a.m. – 11:00 a.m. Session III: Plenary Session – Reporting Back 11:00 a.m. – 11:30 a.m. 11:30 a.m. - 12:30 p.m. Coffee break (and re-set-up of stage) Final Session 12:30 p.m. - 1:30 pm Summary and Recommendations from each break-out session General Discussions Opening of the Final Session by the Chairperson Highlights of Proceedings by the CoChairperson Closing Statement by the President of the Republic of the Philippines Lunch (Café Marco) ************************ Meeting officially ends. ******************************** A joint press conference by the Chair and Co-Chair with Cluster Working Group Convenors will be held from 1:30 - 2:00 p.m. at the Borneo Room of the Marco Polo Hotel (optional for delegates). Chairperson: Secretary Cesar V. Purisima, Department of Finance, Philippines Co-Chairperson: Mr. Motoo Konishi, World Bank Country Director, Philippines Moderator: Mr. Guillermo Luz, National Competitiveness Council, Philippines 8