AOA, LIFT, DRAG, STALL, cL vs. α, MANEUVERING Aerodynamic Force By Bernoulli’s Principle, the difference between static pressure on the lower and upper wing surfaces creates a force known as the aerodynamic force (AF) is the angle of attack (AOA), the angle between the wing chord line and the relative wind The component of AF o perpendicular to the flight path (relative wind) is lift (L) o parallel to the flight path is drag (D) Lift Equation—Airspeed in TAS L = (cL V2 S) / (295.37) (#) o cL is the coefficient of lift (dimensionless) o is density ratio (dimensionless) o V is TAS (nm / hr) o S is wing planform area (ft2)---constant for fixed configuration Lift Equation—Airspeed in EAS V = TAS = EAS/ EAS2 = V2 L = (cL V2 S) / (295.37) L = (cL EAS2 S) / (295.37) EAS (perfect IAS) and cL alone determine o how much L an airplane develops o how the airplane responds to control inputs However, low air density at high density altitudes causes an airplane to be more sensitive to pitch and roll control input at high altitude than at low altitude 1 cL as a Function of AOA / Stall cL increases linearly with AOA from low and moderate-to-high at very high (assuming G > 0) o airflow over the upper wing surface begins to separate o cL increases more slowly at the critical AOA CRIT, cL is maximum [cL)MAX]d at AOAs above CRIT o cL decreases o lift decreases o however, the wing still produces lift does not “stop producing lift” CRIT is also called the stall angle of attack Since L = (cL EAS2 S) / (295.37), at CRIT o L is maximum for fixed EAS o the wing is NOT stalled definition of stall: > CRIT Drag Parasite drag DP o Due largely to ram air pressure q = V2 /2 o Consists mostly of pressure drag (profile drag) and skin-friction drag o Increases exponentially as q increases Induced drag DI o Due to AOA o Increases as AOA increases Total Drag DT = DP + DI 2 Drag Equations D = (cD V2 S) / (295.37) D = (cD EAS2 S) / (295.37) cD is the coefficient of drag—depends on EAS and AOA Caveat about Lift and Drag Equations L = (cL EAS2 S) / (295.37) D = (cD EAS2 S) / (295.37) From an engineering /aircraft design point of view, these equations o are simplifications o suffice, nevertheless, for what pilots need to know to understand how an airplane flies. Unbalanced Lift Is Required to Maneuver Example—Steady-State Constant Altitude Banked Turn Aircraft flying away from viewer Right wing down is the bank angle L cos supports weight W L sin is the unbalanced force causing the airplane to turn right (clockwise) If you can’t create unbalanced lift you can’t maneuver Since L = (cL EAS2 S) / (295.37), to change L without changing aircraft configuration, a pilot has two options and only two options: o Change EAS Use throttle to change thrust Dive to increase airspeed or climb to reduce airspeed; i.e. convert altitude to airspeed or airspeed to altitude o Change cL Increase AOA to increase cL Decrease AOA to decrease cL Works only if cL ≤ (cL)MAX o When AOA ≥ αCRIT (in any attitude at any airspeed) any attempt to increase L by increasing AOA will fail; cL will decrease and thus L will decrease if AOA = αCRIT the only way to increase L without changing aircraft configuration is to increase EAS 3 G Force / Accelerated Stalls G = L / W (W is weight in #) o W fixed at any flight moment o Thus G is proportional to L being developed at that moment Accelerated stall o a stall that occurs when G > 1.0 o “accelerated” refers to the increased G or acceleration force imposed when an airplane is being maneuvered o VS is the 1 G stall speed for fixed W o VAS is the symbol we will use for accelerated stall speed Effect of G force on stall speed o VAS = VS G o An airplane’s stall speed is directly proportional to the square root of the G force being developed o Example: VS = 53 KEAS; (VAS)4G = VS G = 53 4 = 106 KEAS Stall Recovery and Prevention At stall speed (regardless of G force) o = CRIT o cL = (cL)MAX o any attempt to increase G force will result in a stall will increase cL will decrease L will decrease If the stall is a high G accelerated stall, a departure from controlled flight may result For fixed configuration, an airplane always stalls at the same angle of attack, regardless of airspeed, altitude, or attitude The only way to recover from a stall is to reduce AOA to or below CRIT Stall prevention in any attitude at airspeeds below Vs o The wing will not stall at 0 G, because no lift is being created o When airspeed is low or rapidly decreasing—as in a very nose high attitude going to 0 G will assure a stall cannot occur to achieve 0 G, AOA must be set so that cL = 0, resulting in L=0 to achieve 0 G, use forward yoke/stick until you feel weightless in the seat 4 EFFECT OF WEIGHT, BANK ANGLE, CONFIGURATION, G, AND ALTITUDE CHANGES ON VS, VBG (BEST GLIDE), VBR (BEST RANGE), VBE (BEST ENDURANCE), &c. Use the Equation TAS or EAS V2 V1 W2 W1 cos 1 cos 2 W: weight changes : level flight bank angle changes CL: configuration changes G: G force changes : density altitude changes cL 1 cL 2 TAS ONLY G2 1 G1 2 These four parameters affect both EAS and TAS changes Affects TAS changes ONLY NOTE!!!: Do NOT use the equation to calculate the effect of altitude change on EAS, because EAS is independent of altitude changes. How to use the Equation 1. To write the equation as you will use it, determine which parameters have changed. Eliminate from the equation those terms where a parameter has not changed. For example, if only weight and G force have changed, eliminate the terms containing , cL, and ; keep the terms for W and G. The result will be V2 V1 W2 W1 G2 G1 2. Determine the original situation and the changed situation. Symbols with subscript 1 are variables that define the initial flight condition. Variables with subscript 2 are variables that define the changed flight condition. 3. Substitute values for variables in the equation. For example, if the 1 G stall speed is 95 KEAS and weight has changed from 2000# to 2500# and G force has changed from 1 G to 3 Gs, then V1 = 95 KEAS, W1 = 2000 #, G1= 1, W2 = 2500 #, and G2 = 3. The changed stall speed is given by V2 V1 W2 W1 G2 2500 3 . 95 G1 2000 1 4. Solve the equation: V2 V1 W2 W1 G2 2500 3 95 183.9667091 KEAS G1 2000 1 5 Example 1. VS = 140 KEAS (any altitude) @ 300,000# gross. At 400,000# gross: V1 = 140 KEAS; W1 = 300,000 #; W2 = 400,000 # V2 = V1 (W2/W1) = 140 (400,000/300,000) = 161.6580753 KEAS stall speed at 400,000 # (also KTAS at SL in SA, since TAS = EAS at SL in SA) At 2.5 Gs and 300,000 #: V1 = 140 KEAS; G1 = 1.0; G2 = 2.5 V2 = V1 (G2/G1) = 140 (2.5/1.0) = 221.3594362 KEAS accelerated stall speed at 2.5 Gs (also KTAS at SL in SA, since TAS = EAS at SL in SA) Note how G force drastically affects stall speed. Example 2. VBG = 255 KTAS @ 820,000# gross, SL in SA At 600,000 #: V1 = 255 KTAS; W1 = 820,000 #; W2 = 600,000 # V2 = 255 (600,000/820,000) = 218.1267253 KTAS best glide speed at 600,000# (also KEAS at SL in SA) At FL300 and 820,000# in SA: 1 = SL = 1.0; 2 = FL300 = 0.37413: V2 = V1 (1/2) = 255 (1.0/0.37413) = 356.6133625 KTAS best glide speed (but 218.1267253 KEAS since EAS is invariant with altitude) The TAS value is of little interest to a pilot, since the airspeed indicator reads IAS (or EAS if IAS is corrected for pitot static system error and compressibility error) Note; VBG at FL300 of 218 KEAS corresponds to approximately 225 KCAS because of compressibility effect. Example 3 (Light Airplane). VS = 53 KCAS dirty configuration, (CL)MAX = 8.2 dirty, (CL)MAX = 6.1 clean, SL in SA Find stall speed VS clean in KEAS: V1 = 53 KEAS since there is no compressibility error at SL in SA; (CL)1 = 8.2; (CL)2 = 6.1 V2 = V1 [(CL)1 / (CL)2] = 53 (8.2/6.1) = 61.44943278 KEAS (stall speed in clean configuration (also KCAS in SA since compressibility correction at SL is zero 6 Example 4 .VS = 100 KEAS @ 14,000#. Find stall speed @ 12,000# in a constant altitude 30O bank: V1 = 100 KEAS; W1 = 14,000; W2 = 12000; 1 = 0O (because VS is 1G wings-level stall speed); 2 = 30O: V2 = V1 W2/W1) (cos 1/ cos 2) = 100 (12,000/14,000) (cos 0/cos 30) = 99.48584416 KEAS Note: V2 = V1 (W2/W1) = 100 (12,000/14,000 = 92.5820110 KEAS—effect of weight change. V3 = V2(cos 1 cos 2) = 92.5820110(cos 0/cos 30) = 99.48584416 KEAS—effect of bank angle change added to effect of weight change. BUT DON’T ROUND THE INTERMEDIATE RESULT 92.5820110!!! 7