Menstrual hygiene in emergencies – MHM ToT for emergency WASH trainers – 5 April 2013 Start-up kit of training materials and visual aids Start-up kit of training and visual aids contents Item Description No 1 Bag for kit 1 2 CD of resource materials 2 Hard copy of Menstrual Hygiene Matters 1 3 Notes See the table which follows for the contents. Main CD with most of the training materials Second CD will a few MHM related videos Source: Developed by a team at WaterAid with contributions from a wide range of people from around the world. Co-published by 18 organisations and reviewed by 21 individuals and / or teams. Background resource for trainers – covering the following in module and associated toolkits: 1. Menstrual hygiene - the basics 2. Menstrual hygiene - getting started 3. Menstrual hygiene – sanitary protection materials and disposal 4. Working with communities on menstrual hygiene 5. Working with schools on menstrual hygiene 6. Menstrual hygiene in emergencies 7. Supporting women and girls in vulnerable, marginalised or special circumstances 8. Menstrual hygiene in the workplace 9. Research, monitoring and advocacy 4 MHM for schoolgirls in low income countries flyer 2 Source: WEDC, Loughborough University Flyer on menstrual hygiene management for schools girls in low income contexts. Covers: Problems faced by menstruating schoolgirls; Cultural and religious restrictions; and practical considerations. wedc.lboro.ac.uk/resources/factsheets/FS007_MHM_A4_Pages.pdf Hardcopies of girls books 5 Girls book – Ghana 1 Source: Developed by T. Nana Mokoah Ackatia-Armah and Dr Marni Sommer of Know and Grow, Inc. http://www.growandknow.org/Grow_and_Know/about_us.html Book for girls in Tanzania to learn about growing up and menstruation. Includes the basics, case studies by other girls and information on busting myths and looking after herself during menses. Also provided on the CD. 6 Girls book – Tanzania 1 Source: Developed by Dr Marni Sommer of Know and Grow, Inc. http://www.growandknow.org/Grow_and_Know/about_us.html As above – but for girls in Tanzania Also provided on the CD. 7 Girls book Cambodia 1 Source: Developed by Dr Marni Sommer of Know and Grow, Inc. and Susan Connolly http://www.growandknow.org/Grow_and_Know/about_us.html 1 As above – but for girls in Cambodia. Also provided on the CD. Laminated cards 8 Card 1 Emergency latrine –A 1 Source: Picture by D. Makamba/UNICEF A latrine constructed by people displaced due to flooding in Tanzania: 9 10 Card 2 Emergency latrine –B Card 3 Emergency latrine –C 1 No privacy, difficult to manage menstruation from this latrine Source: Picture by D. Makamba/UNICEF A latrine in a camp for displaced people due to flooding in Tanzania: 1 Better than A as has privacy within the individual units and has a tippy tap for hand-washing (but with no drainage or soap) But the block is for both men and women (half indicated for each) and the hand-washing facility is for both men and women, which a woman or girl may be reticent to use if she has blood on her hands during her menstrual period Source: Picture by S. Raza/OXFAM-GB A latrine and shower unit block for women displaced by an earthquake in Pakistan – the latrine and shower units are in a single block with screening to make entrance more private and a hand-washing unit inside before the user exits the screened area. Both men and women’s units were designed the same way. In addition in some blocks in strategic locations (not in all blocks) an extra unit was included to include a private laundry slab inside another screen (see the silver screen in the top left hand corner of the block). This is so that women or girls can if they want wash their menstrual cloths or other private items in a private setting. 11 Card 4 Emergency latrine –D 1 Source: Picture by N. Villeminot/ACF France This block was constructed for people displaced by the earthquake in Pakistan. It has latrines and shower units and a communal laundry area and the whole block is screened. Hot water is provided inside and a small fee is paid for use. Both men and women’s blocks were designed in the same way, but located separately. 12 13 This is better than A and B as it provides a private place for undertaking personal hygiene, but in this case it was located a bit near to a bank and hence the wall height had to be increased a bit to prevent seeing inside the screen. See also cards 5 and 6. Card 5 - Screened block with handwashing inside 1 Card 6 - Private washing slab plus drying line 1 This is better than A, B and C – as it provides a private location for personal hygiene, with hot water, a roof and also has solid walls for additional privacy. Source: Picture by S. House/OXFAM-GB This is a similar block to that shown in card 3 but on another site in Pakistan. This block does not have the internal washing slab, but shows the hand-washing container inside the screen and the screened area. Source: Picture by S House/OXFAM-GB This shows the inside of the private laundry unit / washing slab within the toilet and shower blocks, as shown in card 3. The small laundry slab drained away inside the unit and a drying line was included above the slab. In one camp the slabs were used and feedback was positive. In this camp 2 the units were located inside the blocks as they were larger and there was space to include them. In another camp the units were located on the outside of the screened blocks but with a door inside, as these screened blocks were smaller. But in this second site the women reported not using them. When asked why it was noted that the men became curious of the extra units on the outside of some blocks (as there were not the same attached to the men’s blocks) and started poking holes in the plastic sheets to see what was inside. A lesson from the experiences of the units identified in cards 3 and 6, and from other experiences elsewhere, is that the provision for a laundry area or a space for the management of menstrual hygiene materials or washing during menses should be discrete (essential) and something that can be used also at other times. This is because women and girls do not like other women and girls as well as men and boys knowing that they have their menses. It may be that having shower units with drainage that keeps any blood stained water from the public eye would be enough. If so, designing in extra space in some units with a small seat or concrete block that women and girls can sit on to do their laundry, or for people with mobility limitations, will make the showers easier for use for managing menses. 14 Card 7 - End disposal options 1 Source: Various – see card This card shows some options for end disposal of sanitary materials: Open pit for burning; Temporary incinerator; In a pit latrine pit; Burying; Small incinerator attached to a latrine block. None of the end disposal options are perfect and will need to be established based on the context. The critical considerations are: 15 Card 8 - Waste disposal bin design 1 How will the MHM materials be collected or taken to the disposal point discretely and without anyone knowing that is what is happening? If disposed of in a latrine pit, the pit will fill up quicker, and will be more difficult if it is to be emptied by suction tanker. Materials cannot be disposed of in a pour flush latrine because they can cause blockages. There will be some chemicals / fumes produced from burning or incineration in anything other than a high temperature incinerator. However, for small volumes, or for temporary periods, or in areas where there is space and hence more dilution for smoke / fumes such (such as outside of high density areas), burning or incineration may still be the best option. More research is still needed in this area. Source: Pictures by the Government of Tanzania / Rashid Mbago These pictures show some simple designs of bins which could be used for the collection of menstrual hygiene sanitary protection material wastes. The issues to look at when comparing containers are: Are they washable? Do they have a lid and hence can keep in the smell? Are they easy to carry to dispose of? Are they available in the local area (where possible?) 3 Just including a collection container in a latrine unit is however not enough. There also needs to be a system for the continued collection and emptying of the containers and the end disposal of the materials. If the emergency is likely to last for some time the system must be sustainable for this period of time. 16 17 Card 9 – Shower design Card 10 – Plastic pants 1 Source: Picture from the WASH Visual Aids Library This card shows a shower unit under construction in an emergency context. The card is useful to ask the question is this design appropriate for women and girls to use for showing in a camp situation? 1 The positive design features of this unit are: the solid walls; the piped water; the concrete slab and presumably the drainage (which can’t be seen). Presuming that the door will be fixed on with a lock inside this would also be a positive design feature for women and girls. The design features which are not good are: the gap around the bottom is not good for women and girls for a shower unit as men or boys could look underneath and see the woman or girl inside. If the woman or girl is menstruating then also the blood may also be seen which may also prevent the use of the unit. Also the lack of a roof may not always be ideal (depending on the location and context). In one instance men were climbing a water tower located nearby a shower block which did not have a roof. This allowed them to see into the units when women were showering. Source: Part of a set of IEC cards developed by USAID/Hygiene Improvement Project, Plan International, UWASANET, Ministry of Health, Republic of Uganda, 2010 – This guidance was first developed by the USAID Hygiene Improvement Project (HIP). WASHplus, the follow on project to HIP, continues to build on the evidence base and growing body of experience integrating WASH into care and support activities for PLWHA. For information and more materials visit: www.washplus.org These plastic pants can be used for a woman or girl who is bed bound or incontinent. They can be made locally from a plastic bag and elastic. Further examples of these training materials are included on the CD. 18 Card 11 – Care of women with HIV – menstrual period management 1 Source: From the same set of materials as 17. An IEC card for using with people being trained in home based care for people with HIV. On good practices when caring for women and girls who are menstruating. Note that when women and girls are very sick their period may stop, but with the wider availability of Anti Retro Virals women and girls with HIV are now starting to menstruate more. For information and more materials visit: www.washplus.org 19 Card 12 – Care of women with HIV – disposal or cleaning of menstrual blood soaked material 1 Source: From the same set of materials as 17. An IEC card for using with people being trained in home based care for people with HIV. On good practices for handing or disposing of menstrual blood when caring for women and girls with HIV. Note that when women and girls are very sick their period may stop, but with the wider availability of Anti Retro Virals women and girls with HIV are now starting to menstruate more. For information and more materials visit: www.washplus.org 20 Card 13 – AFRIpads care instruction card 1 Source: AFRIpads Ltd, Uganda IEC instruction card for use and care of AFRIpad re-usable pads. Includes step by step instructions and dos and don’ts. 4 www.afripads.com 21 Card 14 – Girl with a disability at the entrance to a latrine 1 Source: By Rod Shaw of WEDC, Loughborough University The picture is useful to highlight the additional challenges that women with disabilities have when accessing WASH facilities and in particular latrines. This also poses challenges for managing their menstruation. This card highlights the importance of considering the needs of women and girls with mobility limitations when designing facilities. Refer to Module and Toolkit 7 of the MHM resource for more information. http://wedc.lboro.ac.uk/resources/factsheets/FS007_MHM_A4_Pages.pdf 22 Card 15 – Woman drying her menstrual cloths in the sun 1 Source: From UNICEF Afghanistan Example of an IEC card to promote discussion on good practice with MHM. Other examples are on the CD. Samples of sanitary protection materials Note: The following are only samples of sanitary materials available – a wide range is available of similar and different types and brands. 23 MakaPads pack + samples 1 95% biodegradable pads made from papyrus and waste paper. Made in Uganda by small businesses of people who are living in poverty, have HIV, or were previously abductees of the Lord’s Resistance Army. Developed by Technology for Tomorrow, Makerere University in Uganda. www.t4tafrica.co The pads come in various designs: normal absorbance; higher absorbance; with wings; without wings. See page 256 in the MHM resource for more background on the design and manufacture of these pads and a case study of one of the production units making the pads on page 168. 24 AFRIpads set of reusable pads 1 Set of sanitary pads, holders and plastic storage pouches developed by AFRIpads (U) Ltd in Uganda and made by workshops of women in rural areas in Uganda. www.afripads.com A set lasts for around one year for multiple times of re-use, but probably can be used for longer. This pack has: 2 pad holders which clip onto underwear / panties; 5 winged pads; 3 straight pads; and 2 plastic bags for storing the pads when soiled before washing. A lot of thought has gone into the design of these pads and testing and feedback by women in Uganda who prioritised that the pads would dry quickly over absorbency. Hence the material used is not cotton but a synthetic fabric, as cotton takes longer to dry. The pads come in different colours, so that for families with more than one girl, each girl can know which her own set of pads are. See page 353 in the MHM resource for more background on the design of these pads. A laminated IEC card for instructing how to use, wash and dry the pads is also available – see the laminated card 13 in this set. 25 Menstruation belt 1 This is a commercially produced elastic belt for use with pads with loops to hold in place the sanitary pad. Local versions are sometimes be made. 26 Pad with loops 1 This is a commercially produced pad with loops to be used with the belt above. Similar designs are sometimes made locally. 27 Pad for slight 1 It is possible to buy commercially available sanitary pads that can be used 5 incontinence for menstruation but also for incontinence. This is one example for a woman or girl will slight incontinence. Other sizes and absorbencies are available as well as pads for feacal incontinence and for men. These pads are all of higher absorbency than sanitary pads for menstruation, as the volume of liquid from urine is higher than for menstruation. 28 Panti liners (small) 2 A range of panti liners are available commercially. These are used for regular discharge in-between periods and can also be useful at the start of a period to catch the first drops of blood before changing over to higher absorbency pads for the higher flow days. 29 Disposal pads (medium) 1 A wide range of sanitary pads are available commercially – of different designs, thickness, absorbency, with perfume or without perfume etc. This is one example of a standard pack of disposable sanitary pads. Disposable sanitary pads are also made locally in some contexts using cotton cloth and cotton wool as the absorbent. 30 Dark cloth (soft texture) 1 This is an example of some dark coloured cloth (cotton Jersey) with a soft texture. 31 Light cloth (medium texture) 1 This is an example of some light coloured cloth (cotton Calico) with a medium texture. 32 Light cloth (soft texture) 1 This is an example of some light coloured cloth (cotton) with a soft texture. 33 Towelling (rough texture) 1 This is an example of some dark coloured cloth with a rough texture. This is an absorbent fabric, but too rough for using alone. It can however be wrapped in a softer cloth which would then be next to the skin. 34 Tampon with applicator 1 This is an example of a tampon which is inserted into the vagina to catch the menstrual flow. The cord remains outside of the body and is used to pull it out when it needs changing. When inside the body the tampon expands with the liquid from the blood forming a seal to prevent the blood from coming out of the vagina. This version has an applicator which is used to insert the tampon without putting fingers inside the body. The applicator would need to be disposed of. 35 Tampon without applicator 1 This is the same as the above in 34 but does not have an applicator for insertion. Insertion is done by the finger of the user. Hygiene is very important when inserting anything inside the vagina. 36 Panties / underwear / knickers 1 This is one sample of panties / underwear / knickers. Different girls and women will need different sizes. For most pads and cloth a pair of panties will be needed to keep them in place. Low cost locally made panties can sometimes suffer from weak elastic which wears out in a short period of time. If this happens the panties will not stay up. Women and girls would need several pairs to be able to wash and dry them and still be able to wear a pair at the same time. 37 Photocopies of sanitary product packages 1 set Photocopies have been included of the packages of the samples which are included but not in their original packaging. A photocopy is also included of a set of pads for mothers who have just given birth. These are much larger than standard pads because the flow of blood can be much higher for several days after child birth. 6 Main CD contents Folder 1 Menstrual hygiene matters Notes Menstrual hygiene matters; A resource for improving menstrual hygiene around the world: In high resolution – complete In high resolution – by module and toolkit In low resolution – complete In low resolution – by module and toolkit www.wateraid.org/mhm 2 MHM TOT for emergency WASH trainers Agenda Start-up toolkit list including CD contents Feedback form Session contents: Session plans PPTs Exercise handouts and facilitator notes Session folders also include – handouts: 3 PowerPoint presentations & Other example session plans 4 IEC & photographs IFRC – MHM trial, Burundi – Info sheet Hayden, T / UNICEF – ‘FGD Guide’ and ‘Summary of Findings’ table (extracted from the full report located in folder 7) House, S (2013) Sanitary protection for emergency responses – overview of considerations for selection of sanitary protection materials and examples / case studies of current practices by humanitarian organisations Additional PPT presentation (in addition to those in section 2 above): MHM training and awareness raising Other example session plans: 2 hr session integrated into 2 day learning event AusRC & RedR – 1 hr stand alone MHM session in HP training RedR & UNHCR – MHM integrated into WASH facilities for hygiene session RedR & UNHCR – MHM integrated into NFI session MHM - IEC - Afghanistan (UNICEF) MHM - IEC - Bangladesh (SHEWA-B) Photos - Sanitary products Photos - WASH facilities This resource publication (pp352) includes the basics on MHM and modules and toolkits on a range of different areas including MHM in emergencies and sanitary protection areas. Useful as background reading for trainers or to use for reference to answer specific questions. Training materials as used in the MHM ToT for emergency WASH trainers on the 5 April 2013 in the RedR offices, London. Supported by: WaterAid RedR SHARE Sarah House A series of short PPTs which can be adapted or combined as required. Note that these have been adapted for the set of PPTs included in folder 2 as used for the 5 April ToT training day. These provide examples of IEC materials used for discussing menstrual hygiene. These photographs and pictures can be used for 7 Photos - Awareness raising training materials. Please credit the photo or picture as indicated when using them. 5 Girls and teachers MHM booklets Afghanistan (girls and teachers) – The Government of Afghanistan and UNICEF Cambodia (girls) – Dr Marni Sommer and Susan Connolly Ghana (girls) – T. Nana Mokoah Ackatia-Armah and Dr Marni Sommer These are examples of girls MHM booklets or teachers training materials from a number of countries that are either available on the web or where permission has been given for inclusion. Tanzania (girls and teachers training materials) – Dr Marni Sommer Others exist including in local languages. http://www.growandknow.org/Grow_and_Know/about_ us.html Tanzania – teachers sensitisation materials for using girls MHM book – Sommer, M / UNICEF India (girls) – The Government of India and UNICEF indiasanitationportal.org/sites/default/files/MHM_Book. pdf Sierra Leone (girls) - The Government of Sierra Leone and UNICEF Zimbabwe (girls – English, Ndebele, Shona) – Anna Kayemba / Aquamour http://www.ecosanres.org/index.htm 6 Laminated cards in startup kit See the table above for the listing and associated descriptions. These cards have been included in the trainers start up kit. 7 Supporting papers and presentations MHM and HIV Various materials from WASHplus / HIP in Uganda WASHplus presentation at UNC, 2012 For more info on the HIV virus in menstrual blood refer to: http://www.aidsmap.com/Viral-load-in-vaginalfluid/page/1322891/ These materials have been developed to train carers of people with HIV in safe WASH practices. The elements which relate to MHM have been included here but a link via the WASHplus website has been provided on the document entitled ‘Please read this document first’. A PPT also included which provides an overview of the issues in relation to the safe handling of menstrual blood for women and girls who have HIV. MHM in emergencies ACF warm bathing shelter design, Pakistan Hayden, T (2012) MHM in emergencies – research on UNICEF and partners emergency responses Two papers from WEDC conferences relating to MHM in emergencies (Pakistan, Uganda) - This folder includes three papers and four presentations which include case studies or elements relating to MHM in emergencies. 8 http://wedc.lboro.ac.uk/knowledge/conference_sea rch.html One paper from South Asia Hygiene Practitioners Workshop relating to MHM in emergencies (Sri Lanka) Four presentations from the EEHF, 2012 with MHM elements (Somalia, Bangladesh, UNICEF, training) http://www.shareresearch.org/NewsAndEvents/Det ail/eehf_2012_schedule Paper by Sommer, M on menstrual hygiene in humanitarian emergencies – not included in the CD: MHM in schools in emergencies http://www.washinschools.info/docsearch/title/1787 09 UNICEF WASH in schools in emergencies teachers manual and flash cards: http://www.unicef.org/wash/schools/ Inter-Agency Network for Education in Emergencies: a) Pocket guide to gender http://toolkit.ineesite.org/toolkit/Toolkit.php?PostID =1059 Socio-cultural, gender, disability & WASH Inter-Agency Network for Education in Emergencies: b) Gender responsive school, water, sanitation and hygiene http://toolkit.ineesite.org/toolkit/Toolkit.php?PostID =1071 WEDC MHM for schoolgirls fact sheet wedc.lboro.ac.uk/resources/factsheets/FS007_MH M_A4_Pages.pdf Inclusive School, Sanitation & Hygiene Education (SSHE) manual – Government of India http://indiasanitationportal.org/16376 (has designs of school latrines which are accessible with integrated shoots feeding to incinerators for menstrual hygiene materials) Two technical briefs (OXFAM) – one on sanitation for people with physical disabilities and one on socio-cultural considerations for public health engineering in emergencies - http://policypractice.oxfam.org.uk/our-work/water-healtheducation/wash-technical-briefs Accessibility features with sizes (CCBRT) Gender and WASH handbook (IASC) – http://www.humanitarianresponse.info/clusters/wat er-sanitationhygiene/resources?field_document_type_tid=All&fi eld_clusters_tid=All&field_locations_tid=All&field_o rganizations_tid=All&title=&page=1 Gender and WASH checklist / tip sheet (IASC) http://www.humanitarianresponse.info/document/ia sc-gender-wash-checklist Two of the documents in this folder relate to WASH in schools in emergencies and include content relating to menstrual hygiene. The WEDC fact sheet does not relate specifically to emergency contexts but is still of use as it brings together the range of issues for MHM for schoolgirls in a few pages. The inclusive WASH manual from the Government of India has some latrine designs for schools which have integrated incinerators and water within the latrine units. A few simple notes and checklists with guidance on improving accessibility of WASH facilities in emergencies and for considering gender issues. 9 MHM in WASH Cluster – HP project Accountability The booklet developed by the HP Project under the WASH Cluster on accountability. http://www.humanitarianresponse.info/document/hapwash-accountability-handbook Particularly useful because it documents ways of obtaining feedback on WASH needs and services which is essential when considering MHM in emergencies. Second CD - Videos Fold er 1 Vide os Notes Kotex series of videos of girls straight talking about menstrual hygiene from the US context: A series of short videos – the first being an overview and then 4 in more detail, with young women straight talking about menstruation. Introduction Spread the Word (3.35n) Good ice breaker. Humorous in style. Useful for highlighting how taboo the issue is around the world in all countries. Break the silence: Take action with generation know (3.23) The following clips from these videos work well as an introduction to the subject: Bust a myth: Take action with generation know (3.27) Change the message: Take action with generation know (3.27) Break the silence – 0 to 1.17 min Bust a myth – 0 to 2.49 min Change the message – 0 t0 2.35 min http://www.adweek.com/news/advertisingbranding/straight-talk-menstruation-adthats-causing-quite-stir-147501 TED Series talk: By Mr Muruganantham on how he designed and tested low costs pads and a machine for making them http://www.ted.com/talks/arunachalam_mur uganantham_how_i_started_a_sanitary_na pkin_revolution.html Wonderful amusing and inspiring video of a TED talk by Mr Muruganantham explaining the process he went through to develop the machine for which he gives the blue print free. Not related to emergencies but an inspiring video that participants would enjoy watching. Has various lessons included within it about menstrual hygiene. 10