Name: ______________________________ Date: ________________ APES Block: _____ LAB - Measuring Primary Productivity in Grass Plants (adapted from Dr. Angela C. Morrow, University of Northern Colorado and Molnar, Laboratory Investigations for AP Environmental Science) Abstract Grass plants grown over a one week period in the classroom are used to calculate productivity rates using two methods of collection. The concepts of net productivity, respiration rates, gross productivity, and standing biomass are introduced in this laboratory. Objectives Measure net primary productivity (NPP) of rye grass, comparing NPP measurement methods for reliability Explain the concepts of standing biomass, net productivity versus gross productivity, and the importance of dry versus wet weight Apply the NPP concept to problems of crop growth and higher trophic level support Introduction to Laboratory Net primary productivity (NPP) is defined as the amount of carbon from the atmosphere that gets added to green plants per unit time. It is a rate, the quantity of new vegetable matter added per unit area, per day, per week, or per year. NPP is usually expressed as grams of carbon per square meter per year (gC/m2/year). NPP is calculated as the total gain of biomass from photosynthesis minus the losses due to plant respiration. It is this net gain that is available to other organisms as food. The higher the NPP is in a region the higher the overall biomass and diversity. During the growing seasons tropical and temperate regions receive approximately 8,000 to 10,000 kcal/m2 each day. Of this energy, only a small amount (about 1-3 percent in the most productive zones) will be trapped by green plants through the process of photosynthesis. 6CO2 + 6H2O + light energy => C6H12O6 + 6O2 Photosynthesis results in the production of glucose which can later be converted into other products in the plant and provide for the growth of the plant. This results in an increase in biomass. Another term, which is used to describe this process more quantitatively, is gross primary productivity (GPP) – the amount of biomass produced by photosynthesis per unit area over a specific time period. Gross productivity can be measured indirectly using grass plants. Why indirectly? The answer is due to the metabolic needs of the plant itself. That is, as the plant is producing glucose through photosynthesis at least one-half of this glucose is used to meet the plants own energy needs (cell respiration). So what is directly measured in this laboratory exercise is the net primary productivity (NPP). In order to establish the GPP, another quantity must be determined – that is the respiration rate of the plants. 1 You will measure the new primary productivity (NPP) as an increase in dry weight over a one week period. Materials Flats (approximately 20 x 40 cm) for each laboratory group Flats should be sown with grass seeds and grown to approximately 2-3 cm (about 2 weeks) in height before the experiment. Grass should be watered thoroughly at least one hour before each data collecting session Potting soil Grass seed Balances Scissors Fertilizer (?) Light Sources Water Drying oven Aluminum foil Spoons or indoor garden spades to remove grass plants Procedure Your assigned task is to calculate the net primary productivity of one week of grass growth using two methods: (A) complete plant removal and (B) clipped grass. The basic instructions for each method are listed below. Note that classroom experimentation will prevent your group from collecting all the grass in a 1m2 plot, therefore, the data you collect will need to be converted. Your raw data will be in units of grams of carbon from a few plants over a few days; this data will need to be converted into units of gC/m2/year. A. Complete Plant Removal (CPR) Method 1. Trim your grass plots to approximately 2-3 cm. Discard the grass clippings. 2. Take five complete plants, roots and all, from the soil, removing as much soil as possible. 3. Place the plants on an open container made from aluminum foil, and put it in the drying oven for 48 hours at a temperature between 90C and 95C 4. In the section of the tray from which you took the samples, count the number of plants in a 5 cm by 5 cm area. Record this count in your lab notebook. 5. After the plants are dry, weigh and record the mass. This is the starting dry mass. Record this measurement in your lab notebook. 6. Allow the remaining grass to grow for one week more, watering when necessary. 7. Remove five more plants and repeat the drying and weighing procedure. This is the final dry mass. Record this measurement in your lab notebook. 8. Find the difference in dry mass. Record this measurement in your lab notebook. This number is in grams of added carbon per five plants. Scale this value up by using the number of plants growing in 25 cm2. Then convert units of cm2 to m2 and convert the number of days between samples to years. Use your lab notebook to record and calculate these values. 2 9. Calculate the net primary productivity in units of gC/m2/year. Record this value in your lab notebook. A. Clipped Plant (CP) Method 1. Trim your grass plots to approximately 2-3 cm. Discard the grass clippings. 2. Harvest 15 plants, all from the same area in the tray, by cutting the plants 0.5 cm above the soil. 3. Place the plants on an open container made from aluminum foil, and put it in the drying oven for 48 hours at a temperature between 90C and 95C 4. In the section of the tray from which you took the samples, count the number of plants in a 5 cm by 5 cm area. Record this count in your lab notebook. 5. After the plants are dry, weigh and record the mass. This is the starting dry mass. Record this measurement in your lab notebook. 6. Allow the remaining grass to grow for one week more, watering when necessary. 7. Harvest an additional 15 plants by clipping the plants to 0.5 cm above the soil. Repeat the drying and weighing procedure. This is the final dry mass. Record this measurement in your lab notebook. 8. Find the difference in dry mass. Record this measurement in your lab notebook. This number is in grams of added carbon per 15 plants. Scale this value up by using the number of plants growing in 25 cm2. Then convert units of cm2 to m2 and convert the number of days between samples to years. Use your lab notebook to record and calculate these values. 9. Calculate the net primary productivity in units of gC/m2/year. Record this value in your lab notebook. Data and Observations Data will consist of: 1. Measurements 2. Calculations 3. Graph or tables 4. Written description of the data Introduction, Analysis/Discussion & Conclusions Questions The following questions will help with your introduction as well as the analysis/discussion & conclusions: 1. What is the definition of net primary productivity? Why is this rate such an important piece of information for ecologists? (Introduction) 2. Compare the NPP figures from the entire plant method to those of the clipped plant method. Explain why the figures are the way they are. Are they as you would expect? Why or why not? (Discussion) 3. Which method appears to give the most reliable data? Why? How could you find a valid way to compare data from the two methods? (Discussion) 3 4. Why are the results expressed as net productivity instead of gross productivity? What is gross productivity? (Introduction &Discussion) 5. Grass seed could have been replanted on the plot from which the grass was removed in the CPR method and the amount of new plant growth compared and recorded as productivity. Comment on the reliability of such data. (Discussion) 6. Suppose the rye grass plants continued to grow at the same rate over a six month growing season. What would be the net productivity for a field that is 1 km 2? (Conclusions) 7. Comment on the availability of energy from the plant, is if is consumed by herbivores after the six month growing season. Explain how energy availability affects the timing of farmers’ harvest of their grain crops. (Conclusions) 8. In the eastern United States, in particular from Massachusetts to Virginia, climax hardwood forests are being rapidly replaced with large, single-family homes and townhouse complexes. Based on the outcome of this investigation, explain one reason why the deer herds in those states have drastically increased. (Conclusions) 9. Design an experiment by which you could measure the net primary productivity of a field in nature. Describe the experiment. (Conclusions) a. How could NPP be used to determine the number of herbivores that could be supported by the field? For example, how many cows could feed there? b. How would you estimate the number of trophic levels that could be sustained in the field? 10. Describe how remote sensing could be used to determine the NPP of an area. (Conclusions) 11. Standing biomass is the organic matter of the living organisms in an area. Due to the movement of animals, this term is most often just associated with the plants of an area. The terms net productivity and standing biomass are often mistakenly used interchangeably. Why would these terms not be interchangeable? Background research information links PhysicalGeography.net: Primary Productivity of Plants http://www.physicalgeography.net/fundamentals/9l.html Additional Reading Sources Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) Distributed Active Archive Center’s (DAAC) http://www-eosdis.ornl.gov/ Net Primary Productivity Estimation Using Remote Sensing http://wiki.landscapetoolbox.org/doku.php/remote_sensing_methods:net_primary_productivity Net Primary Productivity Database http://www-eosdis.ornl.gov/NPP/npp_home.html 4