Growing our science Met Office Academic Partnership The Met Office Academic Partnership is the Met Office, the University of Exeter, the University of Leeds, the University of Reading and the University of Oxford Met Office Academic Partnership What is it? The Met Office Academic Partnership is a cluster of research excellence. It brings together the Met Office with the leading UK universities in weather and climate science (University of Exeter, University of Leeds, University of Reading and University of Oxford) through a formal collaboration to advance the science and skill of weather and climate prediction. What are its aims? • To draw together world-class expertise around a focused programme of joint research to tackle key challenges in weather and climate science and prediction. • To maximise return on the UK’s investment in research and development in its leading institutions, to provide society with the best possible advice. • To combine our strengths to secure the UK’s position in leading the world in weather forecasting and climate prediction. • To build a cluster of research excellence that is instrumental in determining priorities for future funding and influencing the European Union Framework agenda. • To provide an outstanding environment to develop the science leaders of tomorrow in this very challenging area of research and delivery. Dr Jon Petch Jon is the head of Met Office Science Partnerships. He is responsible for the Met Office's national and international relationships with other science organisations, including the Unified Model partnerships, relationship with NERC through the JWCRP and with the academic partnerships. Jon also continues to carry out research in areas related to atmospheric processes and parametrizations. For further information please contact: www.metoffice.gov.uk/research/partnership or email chiara.piccolo@metoffice.gov.uk or pip.gilbert@metoffice.gov.uk Challenges in Weather and Climate Prediction The atmosphere and ocean are complex physical, chemical and biological systems which need to be modelled to make predictions. The challenge we set our academic partners is to help us to understand these systems in order to determine how best to model them in the future, especially on computers with very large numbers of processors. For short range (local) weather forecasting (up to ~36 hours) the main challenges are to understand predictability at convective scales and to determine how complex the representation of chemical and microphysical processes needs to be in order to make forecasts of weather parameters and air quality. Initialisation (data assimilation) at these convection permitting scales (~1km) is also a considerable challenge, being a relatively new and undeveloped field of endeavour. Data assimilation and ensemble prediction at such scales also require that the model simulations be unbiased and provide realistic distributions of weather parameters. The global weather and climate predictions of the next decade will be made at horizontal resolutions approaching 10km, at which the most difficult challenge in atmospheric prediction remains the representation of organised convection. We will also need to determine how best to couple convective, microphysical and radiative processes together so that the atmospheric component of the model is as realistic as possible and does not cause drifts away from reality when coupled to the ocean and land surface, nor when used as a component in data assimilation. For us to be able to run global forecast models (both weather and climate) at these increasingly high resolutions, the models will need to be able to exploit the power of the next generation of massively parallel supercomputers. As a result the GungHo project was initiated two years ago to deliver a step change in the scalability of the UM by moving away from the current latitude-longitude grid to a more globally uniform grid. This is an exciting five-year collaborative project between the Met Office, NERC (via various of our academic partners) and STFC. Improving Projections of Climate. Our ability to make projections of how future climate will evolve is limited by the accuracy of climate models and our understanding of feedbacks in the climate system. We constantly improve climate models but it is possible to advance our understanding by attempting to quantify uncertainties in projections. This quantification relies on looking at multiple climate models and evaluating their ability to reproduce present-day and past climate, variability and change, with a focus is on processes which relate to the uncertainty in projections. More Accurate Weather and Climate Predictions. Weather is a dynamical phenomena and dramatic changes in weather can happen over a matter of hours. At the heart of any weather forecast model is a component which solves approximations to the dynamical equations of motion of the atmosphere. The challenge is to both improve the accuracy of the numerical techniques that are used to solve those equations and to make most efficient use of current and future supercomputing power. Scale interactions in weather and climate. Our models encapsulate our very mature understanding of physical and dynamical processes in the earth system. However, their performance is at their weakest when the interaction between processes, often at very different scales, produces organised behaviour, relatively long-lived, behaviour. Examples include very short range forecasting of intense, organised convection to the global-scale organisation of the MJO, which have a profound impact on regional weather and climate. It is imperative that we improve our understanding of these processes and develop model representations of processes which interact more accurately. Data assimilation in complex models. We make use of very sophisticated techniques to incorporate observations into our atmospheric weather forecast systems. However, the success of these depends a great deal on the close relationship between variables such as wind and temperature at large scales. We have entered an era where we need to develop data assimilation techniques for much more challenging systems, from very small-scale weather (thunderstorms, fog), to coupled ocean/atmosphere/chemistry/land-surface and even spaceweather models. Clouds and the water cycle. Clouds and water vapour lead to climate feedbacks which are very large relative to anthropogenic forcing. We need to quantify these feedbacks, particularly for the tropics and subtropics where rainfall is critical to the livelihoods of a large fraction of the world’s population. Atmospheric aerosols have an influence on regional climates and high-impact weather patterns by modifying different kinds of cloud and precipitation, with cloud ice being particularly uncertain. Progress demands new laboratory, field, theoretical and modelling studies. Cold weather, low-level clouds and fog. Travel disruption due to icy roads or poor visibility at airports is very costly to the UK economy. Better field measurements and theoretical understanding of the boundary layer are required in order to deliver reliable local forecasts of low cloud, fog and temperatures on scales of a few kilometres. Probabilistic prediction of weather and climate. A quantitative appreciation of the uncertainties involved in weather and climate prediction is essential if rational decision-making is to be based on such predictions. Communicating and interpreting probabilistic information to users and decision-makers must also be done with care and clarity. Ensemble modelling methods provide a possible way of estimating uncertainties, but only if model variability represents the true variability of the climate system. Stochastic parameterization techniques may help to improve the ability of models to represent climate variability more faithfully. Oceans and Climate. The oceans play a major role in the climate system, storing and transporting heat across the planet but also sequestering carbon in complex, biogeochemical cycles. Modelling these processes and predicting their response to changing climate forcings pose major challenges to both modellers and observers because of the immense range of scales active within the oceans and the complex nonlinear interactions between the oceans, atmosphere and cryosphere. University of Leeds Professor Doug Parker Doug is a meteorologist who conducts research into the behaviour of severe storms, including those affecting the UK and Northwest Europe and those which occur in Africa. His research combines mathematical theory, computer models and novel field measurements to understand these weather systems and improve their prediction. Achievements of the partnership The University of Leeds has a continuing history of leading major observational activities jointly with the Met Office, over more than 2 decades. This programme includes a long-term commitment to UK field measurements, as well as leadership of international observing campaigns. Together, we have successfully used observations to develop theoretical understanding of the atmosphere, and to develop the next generation of weather and climate prediction models. Examples of such activities include a series of mountain-wave experiments conducted in Scotland and the North of England since the early 1990s, the Arctic Summer Cloud Ocean Study (ASCOS) in 2008, and the recent COLPEX experiment measuring night-time cold air in the valleys of Shropshire. An important theme in our partnership is the development of cutting-edge models for atmospheric composition. Our small-scale research models are capable of representing the interactions of aerosols and chemical tracers with individual clouds, while our global models are able to scale such effects up to the Earth’s climate system. We are conducting new research into the assessment of uncertainty in such models of composition – analysis of uncertainty is necessary for the use of model results in decision-making. Weather and climate models have real problems to make accurate forecasts for many parts of Africa. The University of Leeds is a centre for the study of the dynamics of weather and climate over Africa. With the Met Office, we are using field observations from major international field experiments such as the African Monsoon Multidisciplinary Analysis (AMMA), to challenge and improve the models. Our results are having benefits for various areas of the human environment in Africa, including the distribution and intensity of rainfall, its impact on crops, and the lifting of desert dust. Future directions for Leeds – Met Office We will continue to lead and contribute to national and international observational programmes, and use these to challenge our mathematical theory and our predictive models. We are making a major strategic effort to advance our understanding and modelling of cloud-aerosol interactions, from the cloud scale to the global scale. We are embarking on a major joint effort in regard to the improved understanding and modelling of tropical continental water cycles. Met Office Lead for Leeds: Simon Vosper University of Exeter Professor Mat Collins Mat is a climate scientist with interests in climate modeling, climate variability and projections of future climate change. His research uses climate models to understand the climate system and to project its future under scenarios of greenhouse gas changes. Prior to joining the University of Exeter, Mat was a scientist and manager in the Climate Prediction group of the Met Office Hadley Centre. Professor John Thuburn John’s main research interest is in numerical methods; how can we solve the equations governing the behaviour of the atmosphere as efficiently and accurately as possible? For about ten years he has been collaborating with the Met Office on a project to develop an improved ‘dynamical core’ for the Met Office’s weather and climate prediction model. Achievements of the partnership A major focus of the Exeter-Met Office partnership so far has been in the development of numerical techniques to improve weather and climate prediction. The ENDGame dynamical core of the Unified Model improves on the previous one in several ways: the optional use of a conservative transport scheme for mass and tracers; the use of a more stable time scheme based on an iterative approach; and the consistent inclusion of several switchable options for the geometric and dynamical approximations. ENDGame improves the model's numerical accuracy, robustness and scalability and it is anticipated to become operational in 2013/14. Weather and Climate Predictions are imperfect and there is a constant effort to verify, calibrate and utilize information from prediction systems. Exeter has considerable expertise in environmental statistics that has been applied to quantify uncertainty in predictions with emphasis on rare and extreme events. A current focus is on extratropical windstorms. A team from the University and the Met Office are currently putting together a catalogue of extratropical extreme wind storms which will be of great use to researchers and to industrial collaborators. Under scenarios of future increases in greenhouse gases, both physical and biogeochemical processes drive feedbacks in the system that may result in changes that have significant impact on society. The possibility of ‘tipping points’, where there response of the system is very much faster than the applied forcing, has been a feature of the Exeter-Met Office collaboration. A recent success has provided a constraint on Amazon dieback based on the ability of models to reproduce interannual fluxes of CO 2 suggesting that previous scenarios of Amazon collapse and associated carbon cycle feedback are less likely than previously thought. Future directions for Exeter – Met Office The partnership will continue to aid in climate model development and to enhance our understanding of climate change using mathematical and statistical techniques. The concept of ‘process-based emergent constraints’; finding metrics of climate model processes that are correlated with future projections of different variables, will be further developed. Exeter University will provide training for Met Office staff in numerical modeling techniques, climate science, environmental statistics and scientific writing. Met Office Lead for Exeter: Nigel Wood University of Reading Professor Peter Clark Peter is a physicist and is particularly interested in the science behind the short-range forecasting of high impact weather. His research is primarily focussed on how we represent complex turbulent flows, such as in thunderstorms and around urban areas, in mathematical models. Achievements of the partnership The Meteorology Department of the University of Reading has had a close relationship with the Met Office since its inception in 1965. It has a long history developing fundamental understanding of the dynamics of weather and climate through observation and fundamental theory, and now also includes a large group devoted to the assimilation of observations into models. It is closely joined to the Department of Mathematics, which undertakes research in the mathematics of numerical methods in fluid dynamical modelling, data assimilation and dynamical systems. Together, we have a long history of developing and using high-resolution versions of the Met Office’s climate models, in particular the HiGEM model. The objective is not just to produce more detailed predictions but also to find out if deficiencies in models arise from our inability to properly resolve large-scale processes (such as Rossby or Kelvin waves) or the way we represent small-scale processes such as convection. This has been combined, in the CASCADE project, with studies of large cloud systems using extremely high-resolution models. This built on the experience gained by the development and assessment of high-resolution weather forecast models which now form the basis of short-range weather forecasting over the UK. Our understanding of the physics of urban areas has improved considerably in recent years. The combination of laboratory and field measurements at Reading led to the development of a new parametrization of urban surface exchange (MORUSES) which has been incorporated into the Joint UK Land Surface model (JULES) and thence into the Unified model and is being used both to improve weather forecasts in the urban environment and to investigate future urban climate. Future directions for Reading – Met Office We shall continue to improve the representation of basic processes in weather and climate models and to establish the role of small-scale processes in modifying largescale weather and climate. We shall develop advanced methods to assimilate data and hence improve our ability to forecast from hours to seasons and beyond, and will extend our models to forecast 'Space Weather'. We are determining the role of anthropogenic emissions and natural processes in climate change and variability and continue to develop strategies for adaptation and mitigation. Met Office Lead for Reading: Mark Ringer University of Oxford Professor Peter Read Peter is a climate physicist with research interests in the fundamental fluid dynamical processes in atmospheres and oceans that govern long range transport and predictability. This entails the study of complex turbulent motions in observations, numerical models and laboratory analogues of atmospheric circulation which he applies not only to the Earth's atmosphere but also to the atmospheres of other planets. He began his career as a research scientist in geophysical fluid dynamics at the Met Office before moving to Oxford. The three examples below highlight the interdisciplinary approach used to address key research areas such as ocean modelling and the interactions between weather, climate and climate change interactions. Representing uncertainty in weather and climate models We are researching stochastic parametrisation schemes to represent uncertainty in weather and climate models. Work ranges from proof-of-concept experiments in simple dynamical systems, to investigating new stochastic schemes for use in ocean models, to using global numerical weather prediction models to test improved stochastic parametrisations of convection. An exciting new research theme, involving collaboration between the Physics and Mathematics departments, explores the use of energy efficient stochastic computer hardware for use in atmospheric modelling. RMS Error-Spread for different representations of convective uncertainty. a) 3 year average SSH variance (2005-2007) from AVISO altimeter data. b) 3 year average SSH variance (2005-2007) from ORCA025. c) 3 year average SSH variance (2005-2007) from ORCA0083. Bias correction in ocean modelling Researchers in the University’s Oceanography Group have worked with the Met Office to provide them with access to a wealth of detailed understanding of Southern Ocean circulation and dynamics. This allowed for the Met Office to better account for the large warm SST model bias in the Southern Ocean which was having an adverse impact on climate simulations, and in particular the representation of the globally significant heat/carbon uptakes that are known to occur in the Southern Ocean. Climate-weather interactions At the heart of existing collaborations on weather-climate interactions is understanding the weather as a chaotic system whose statistics, or the "shape of the chaotic attractor", can be affected by external drivers like our changing sun, changing patterns of aerosol load in the atmosphere and rising greenhouse gas levels. Understanding and responding to changes in weather-related risks is at the heart of the new science of climate services and is greatly enhanced using our distributed Extreme weather risks for African infrastructure computing network climateprediction.net. Future directions for Oxford – Met Office Continue to lead and contribute to advanced remote sensing methods to obtain key observations of atmospheric composition, clouds and aerosols. Develop a quantitative, multidisciplinary approach to model complex climate interactions between the atmosphere, ocean, cryosphere and land surface. Develop innovative ways of applying probabilistic and stochastic approaches to the prediction of weather and climate: used for attribution studies and assessment of the risks to water resources, ecosystems and infrastructure. Met Office Lead for Oxford: John Eyre Met Office FitzRoy Road, Exeter Devon, EX1 3PB United Kingdom Tel: 0870 900 0100 Produced by the Met Office Fax: 0870 900 5050 enquiries@metoffice.gov.uk www.metoffice.gov.uk © Crown copyright 2013 10/0340 Met Office and the Met Office logo