EVALUATION REPORT FOR THE PROCUREMENT OF EQUIPMENT FOR SINDH
POLICE DURING FINANCIAL YEAR 2011-12.
Evaluation report of the participating firms against the Tender Notice dated 20.10.2011 &
21.10.2011 (INF-KRY No.3778/11 & SPPRA ID No.5638) for the Procurement of Equipments for Sindh Police.
2/-
The following firms participated in response to this office Tender Notice The results of Evaluation
of participated firms according to Evaluation Criteria are as under:-
1. Vehicle Identification Number Investigation System Device
S.#
1.
2.
3.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Megaplus Pakistan
M/s Global Science Co.
M/s Noor Forensics
MAKE & MODEL
Complex Model 7505 Made by Regula
Made in Belarus
Complex Model 7505 Made by Regula
Made in Belarus
Complex Model 7505 Made by Regula
Made in Belarus
REMARKS
ACCEPTED (meet to
Departmental Specification)
ACCEPTED (meet to
Departmental Specification)
ACCEPTED (meet to
Departmental Specification)
MAKE & MODEL
SPEX Forencis Model HandScope
Xenon FLS HSX-5000
Labino Trac Finder
REMARKS
ACCEPTED (meet to
Departmental Specification)
ACCEPTED (meet to
Departmental Specification)
ACCEPTED (meet to
Departmental Specification)
2. Light Sources for Crime Scene Unit
S.#
1.
2.
3.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Megaplus Pakistan
M/s Surge Enterprises
M/s Noor Forensics
FAL3000 Made by Sirchie Made in
North Carolina
3. Comparator for Handwriting Examination
1.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Megaplus Pakistan
2.
M/s Noor Forensics
S.#
3.
MAKE & MODEL
Foster Freeman Model VSC400
Model 4305 M/MH Made by Regula
Made in Belarus
M/s Forensic People Pakistan Forensic XP-4010D
REMARKS
ACCEPTED (meet to
Departmental Specification)
ACCEPTED (meet to
Departmental Specification)
ACCEPTED (meet to
Departmental Specification)
4. Document Examination Accessories
S.#
1.
2.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Global Science Co.
M/s Noor Forensics
MAKE & MODEL
Stage Surface Projectina UCM Made in
Switzerland
Stage Surface Projectina UCM Made in
Switzerland
REMARKS
ACCEPTED (meet to
Departmental Specification)
ACCEPTED (meet to
Departmental Specification)
MAKE & MODEL
REMARKS
ACCEPTED (meet to
Departmental Specification)
REJECTED (Not meet to
Departmental Specification)
REJECTED (Not meet to
Departmental Specification)
5. Explosive Detector
S.#
NAME OF FIRM
1.
M/s Shirazi Trading
2.
M/s Defence Solutions System
3.
M/s Surge Enterprises
Model Hardened Mobile Trace Made by
Morpho Detection Made in USA
Model MO-2M Made by Sibel Made in
Russia
Model HEDD1 Manual 09v1 Made by
Unival Group Made in Germany
6. Portable X-Ray Machine
S.#
1.
2.
NAME OF FIRM
MAKE & MODEL
M/s Asian Consultant &
Computer Services
M/s Defence Solutions System
Foxraylle with XR300 Made by SDS
Group Made in UK
Model SXR-150 Made by Sibel Made in
Russia
3.
M/s Surge Enterprises
Model CR 35 SEC Made by DURR
NDT Made in Germany
4.
M/s Shirazi Trading
Model 2520 with Generator XR-150 Made
by Scanna MSC Made in UK
REMARKS
ACCEPTED (meet to
Departmental Specification)
REJECTED (Not meet to
Departmental Specification)
REJECTED (Not meet to
Departmental Specification)
REJECTED (Not meet to
Departmental Specification)
7. BD Technician Response Kit
S.#
NAME OF FIRM
1.
M/s Asian Consultant
Computer Services
MAKE & MODEL
& HK-0125 IED Made in Hongkong
REMARKS
ACCEPTED (meet to
Departmental Specification)
8. Emergency Light
S.#
1.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Asian Consultant &
Computer Services
MAKE & MODEL
ACCEL Made in China
REMARKS
ACCEPTED (meet to
Departmental Specification)
9. Bomb Bin
S.#
NAME OF FIRM
1.
3.
M/s Asian Consultant &
Computer Services
M/s SIPKA Manufacturing
(Pvt) Ltd.
M/s Surge Enterprises
4.
M/s Shirazi Trading
2.
MAKE & MODEL
Suspect Postal Package Container Made
by SDS Group Made in UK
Scanna Blast Container Made by Scanna
Made in UK
Model Pluton -1 Made by Arli
Spetstechnika Made in Russia
Suspect Package Containers Made by
Scanna Made in UK
REMARKS
ACCEPTED (meet to
Departmental Specification)
REJECTED (Not meet to
Departmental Specification)
REJECTED (Not meet to
Departmental Specification)
REJECTED (Not meet to
Departmental Specification)
10. Pocket Jammer (GSM)
S.#
1.
NAME OF FIRM
MAKE & MODEL
M/s Asian Consultant &
Computer Services
M/s SIPKA Manufacturing
(Pvt) Ltd.
ACC-909SC Made in Taiwan
3.
M/s Surge Enterprises
4.
M/s Shirazi Trading
Model CPB-2000P-Plus Made by
Winpower Made in Twain
CTS 1000 HA/B
5.
M/s International Office
Suppliers
M/s Azms & Co
2.
6.
Model TG-120PRO Made by Tangreat
Technology Co. Made in China
TG-102A
GSM Jammer
REMARKS
ACCEPTED (meet to
Departmental Specification)
REJECTED (Not meet to
Departmental Specification)
REJECTED (Not meet to
Departmental Specification)
REJECTED (Not meet to
Departmental Specification)
REJECTED (Not meet to
Departmental Specification)
REJECTED (Not meet to
Departmental Specification)
11. Conference Room Jammer (GSM)
S.#
1.
3.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s SIPKA Manufacturing
(Pvt) Ltd.
M/s Asian Consultant &
Computer Services
M/s Surge Enterprises
4.
M/s Shirazi Trading
5.
M/s International Office
Suppliers
2.
MAKE & MODEL
Model TG5CA Made by Tangreat
Technology Co. Made in China
ACC-606 RJ Made in Taiwan
Model CPB-2000ATS Made by
Winpower Made in Taiwan
CTS-VIP60
TG-101A
REMARKS
REJECTED (Not meet to
Departmental Specification)
REJECTED (Not meet to
Departmental Specification)
REJECTED (Not meet to
Departmental Specification)
REJECTED (Not meet to
Departmental Specification)
ACCEPTED (meet to
Departmental Specification)
12. Portable Jammer (GSM) UHF/VHF
S.#
1.
2.
3.
4.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s International Office
Suppliers
M/s Shirazi Trading
M/s Surge Enterprises
M/s SIPKA Manufacturing
(Pvt) Ltd.
MAKE & MODEL
TG - 101A
CTS.UVX
CPB-2000 KP40
Tangreat Technology Co. / China
REMARKS
ACCEPTED (meet to
Departmental Specification)
REJECTED (Not meet to
Departmental Specification)
REJECTED (Not meet to
Departmental Specification)
REJECTED (Not meet to
Departmental Specification)
13. Generator 5-KV
S.#
NAME OF FIRM
MAKE & MODEL
1.
M/s Shirazi Trading
Aksa AAP5500E / Turkey
2.
M/s Azms & Co
Akulla AK /China
REMARKS
REJECTED (Not meet to
Departmental Specification)
REJECTED (Not meet to
Departmental Specification)
14. Prodder Small & Large
S.#
1.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Asian Consultant &
Computer Services
MAKE & MODEL
Prodder for Detecting Land Mines
Explosive Devices & Trip Wires/Pakistan
REMARKS
ACCEPTED (meet to
Departmental Specification)
15. Luminal Cell
S.#
1.
2.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Asian Consultant &
Computer Services
M/s Defence Solutions System
MAKE & MODEL
Sensor E3500 P.No.D350538 Scintrex
Trace
Scintrex Trace Corp P. NoD350548/
Canada
REMARKS
ACCEPTED (meet to
Departmental Specification)
REJECTED (Not meet to
Departmental Specification)
16. Digital Camera (14.1 Mega Pixel)
S.#
1.
2.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Gemco
M/s Azms & Co.
MAKE & MODEL
Samsung ST-65
Summey
REMARKS
ACCEPTED (meet to
Departmental Specification)
ACCEPTED (meet to
Departmental Specification)
17. Walk Through Gate
S.#
1.
2.
3.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Sage-Tech International
M/s Defence Solutions System
M/s SIPKA Manufacturing
MAKE & MODEL
HI-PE Multi Zone / PNZ/ Ceia Italy
REMARKS
ACCEPTED (meet to
Departmental Specification)
ThruScan S9 / Turkey
REJECTED (Not meet to
Departmental Specification)
ThruScan S9 / Turkey
(Pvt) Ltd.
4.
5.
M/s Shirazi Trading
M/s Asian Consultant &
Departmental Specification)
PD 6500i /USA
3/-
M/s Space Communication
REJECTED (Not meet to
Departmental Specification)
Trough Scan S9 /Turkey
Computer Services
6.
REJECTED (Not meet to
REJECTED (Not meet to
Departmental Specification)
M-Scope / USA
REJECTED (Not meet to
Departmental Specification)
Out of above firms, the following firms were declared qualified by the Evaluation
Committee for the opening of Financial Bids. Financial proposals of qualified firms were opened on
27-02-2012. Its result is as follows:1. Vehicle Identification Number Investigation System Device
S.#
1.
2.
3.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Noor Forensics
M/s Megaplus Pakistan
M/s Global Science Co.
MAKE & MODEL
Complex Model 7505 Made by Regula
Made in Belarus
Complex Model 7505 Made by Regula
Made in Belarus
Complex Model 7505 Made by Regula
Made in Belarus
Rate/Quoted
Rs. 4,698,000
Rs. 4,988,000
Rs. 5,394,000
2. Light Sources for Crime Scene Unit
S.#
1.
2.
3.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Noor Forensics
M/s Surge Enterprises
M/s Megaplus Pakistan
MAKE & MODEL
FAL3000 Made by Sirchie Made in North
Carolina
Labino Trac Finder
SPEX Forencis Model HandScope Xenon
FLS HSX-5000
Rate/Quoted
Rs. 1,189,000
Rs. 2,290,000
Rs. 3,480,000
3. Comparator for Handwriting Examination
S.#
1.
2.
3.
NAME OF FIRM
MAKE & MODEL
Model 4305 M/MH Made by Regula Made
M/s Noor Forensics
in Belarus
M/s Forensic People Pakistan Forensic XP-4010D
M/s Megaplus Pakistan
Foster Freeman Model VSC400
Rate/Quoted
Rs. 4,553,000
Rs. 5,500,000
Rs. 10,208,000
4. Document Examination Accessories
S.#
1.
2.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Noor Forensics
M/s Global Science Co.
MAKE & MODEL
Stage Surface Projectina UCM Made in
Switzerland
Stage Surface Projectina UCM Made in
Switzerland
Rate/Quoted
Rs. 3,886,000
Rs. 4,700,000
5. Explosive Detector
S.#
1.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Shirazi Trading
MAKE & MODEL
Model Hardened Mobile Trace Made by
Morpho Detection Made in USA
Rate/Quoted
Rs. 5,435,000
6. Portable X-Ray Machine
S.#
1.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Asian Consultant &
Computer Services
MAKE & MODEL
Foxraylle with XR300 Made by SDS Group
Made in UK
Rate/Quoted
Rs. 5,894,000
7. BD Technician Response Kit
S.#
1.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Asian Consultant &
Computer Services
MAKE & MODEL
HK-0125 IED Made in Hongkong
Rate/Quoted
Rs. 22,000
8. Emergency Light
S.#
1.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Asian Consultant &
Computer Services
MAKE & MODEL
ACCEL Made in China
Rate/Quoted
Rs. 2,200
9. Bomb Bin
S.#
1.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Asian Consultant &
Computer Services
MAKE & MODEL
Suspect Postal Package Container Made by
SDS Group Made in UK
Rate/Quoted
Rs.3,96,000
10. Pocket Jammer (GSM)
S.#
1.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Asian Consultant &
Computer Services
MAKE & MODEL
ACC-909SC Made in Taiwan
Rate/Quoted
Rs. 22,000
11. Conference Room Jammer (GSM)
S.#
1.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s International Office
Suppliers
MAKE & MODEL
Rate/Quoted
Rs. 66,317
MAKE & MODEL
Rate/Quoted
Rs. 2,47,183
TG-101A
12. Portable Jammer (GSM) UHF/VHF
S.#
1.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s International Office
Suppliers
TG - 101A
13. Prodder Small & Large
S.#
1.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Asian Consultant &
Computer Services
MAKE & MODEL
Prodder for Detecting Land Mines Explosive
Devices & Trip Wires/Pakistan
Rate/Quoted
Rs. 2,200
14. Luminal Cell
S.#
1.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Asian Consultant &
Computer Services
MAKE & MODEL
Sensor E3500 P.No.D350538 Scintrex Trace
Rate/Quoted
Rs. 243,000
(Per Packet)
15. Digital Camera (14.1 Mega Pixel)
S.#
1.
2.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Gemco
M/s Azms & Co.
MAKE & MODEL
Samsung ST-65
Summey
Rate/Quoted
Rs. 14,500
Rs. 19,500
MAKE & MODEL
HI-PE Multi Zone / PNZ/ Ceia Italy
Rate/Quoted
Rs. 3,34,051
16. Walk Through Gate
S.#
1.
4/-
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Sage-Tech International
In accordance with the PPRA Rules, which has been adopted by Sindh Police, The
Committee recommended to approve the first lowest offered price by the Bidders as mentioned below:1. Vehicle Identification Number Investigation System Device
S.#
1.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Noor Forensics
MAKE & MODEL
Complex Model 7505 Made by Regula
Made in Belarus
Rate/Quoted
Rs. 4,698,000
2. Light Sources for Crime Scene Unit
S.#
1.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Noor Forensics
MAKE & MODEL
FAL3000 Made by Sirchie Made in North
Carolina
Rate/Quoted
Rs. 1,189,000
3. Comparator for Handwriting Examination
S.#
1.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Noor Forensics
MAKE & MODEL
Model 4305 M/MH Made by Regula Made
in Belarus
Rate/Quoted
Rs. 4,553,000
4. Document Examination Accessories
S.#
1.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Noor Forensics
MAKE & MODEL
Stage Surface Projectina UCM Made in
Switzerland
Rate/Quoted
Rs. 3,886,000
MAKE & MODEL
Model Hardened Mobile Trace Made by
Morpho Detection Made in USA
Rate/Quoted
Rs. 5,435,000
5. Explosive Detector
S.#
1.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Shirazi Trading
6. Portable X-Ray Machine
S.#
1.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Asian Consultant &
Computer Services
MAKE & MODEL
Foxraylle with XR300 Made by SDS Group
Made in UK
Rate/Quoted
Rs. 5,894,000
7. BD Technician Response Kit
S.#
1.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Asian Consultant &
Computer Services
MAKE & MODEL
HK-0125 IED Made in Hongkong
Rate/Quoted
Rs. 22,000
8. Emergency Light
S.#
1.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Asian Consultant &
Computer Services
MAKE & MODEL
ACCEL Made in China
Rate/Quoted
Rs. 2,200
9. Bomb Bin
S.#
1.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Asian Consultant &
Computer Services
MAKE & MODEL
Suspect Postal Package Container Made by
SDS Group Made in UK
Rate/Quoted
Rs.3,96,000
10. Pocket Jammer (GSM)
S.#
1.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Asian Consultant &
Computer Services
MAKE & MODEL
ACC-909SC Made in Taiwan
Rate/Quoted
Rs. 22,000
11. Conference Room Jammer (GSM)
S.#
1.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s International Office
Suppliers
MAKE & MODEL
Rate/Quoted
Rs. 66,317
MAKE & MODEL
Rate/Quoted
Rs. 2,47,183
MAKE & MODEL
Rate/Quoted
Rs. 2,200
TG-101A
12. Portable Jammer (GSM) UHF/VHF
S.#
1.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s International Office
Suppliers
TG - 101A
13. Prodder Small & Large
S.#
1.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Asian Consultant &
Computer Services
Prodder for Detecting Land Mines Explosive
Devices & Trip Wires/Pakistan
14. Luminal Cell
S.#
1.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Asian Consultant &
Computer Services
MAKE & MODEL
Sensor E3500 P.No.D350538 Scintrex
Trace
Rate/Quoted
Rs. 243,000
(Per Packet)
15. Digital Camera (14.1 Mega Pixel)
S.#
1.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Gemco
MAKE & MODEL
Samsung ST-65
Rate/Quoted
Rs. 14,500
MAKE & MODEL
HI-PE Multi Zone / PNZ/ Ceia Italy
Rate/Quoted
Rs. 3,34,051
16. Walk Through Gate
S.#
1.
NAME OF FIRM
M/s Sage-Tech International
Sd/Addl.IGP/Special Branch Sindh
(Chairman)
Sd/DIGP/Admn. Karachi
(Member)
Sd/DIGP/HQtrs., Sindh Karachi
(Member)
Sd/DIGP/Special Branch Sindh Karachi
(Member)
Sd/AIGP /Logistics CPO Sindh Karachi
(Secretary)
Sd/Representative of Home Department
(Member)
Sd/Representative of IG Prison
(Member)