Psychology IB Test Summary—by Daniel Smarda 2014 graduate Biological Level Eric Kandel: Aplysia Classically conditioned Aplysia snail to retract tail in response to a squirt of water Looks at neurons b/c Aplysia only has a few number of large neurons Number of neurotransmitters increases, as does number of synapses (long-term potentiation) Shows localization of function, structural plasticity, long term-potentiation Ecological Validity/generalizability, experiment, causational Gottesman (Schizophrenia) Schizophrenia runs in families, family and twins show that more likely to be diagnosed if more closely related to someone, adopted children more likely to develop if either of biological parents have it, by studying families with high rate of schizo, find families with certain genetic factors, Unethical, might induce schizophrenia and stress, Correlational, deterministic Richard F. Thompson: Rats/maze/air puff/classical conditioning Clasically conditioned rabbits to blink in response to a tone by puffing air at same time, cut out cerebellum and blinking in response to tone disappeared, but still blinked in response to puff so reflex hadn’t disappeared Localization of function for simple behaviors Ecological validity, ethicality, empirical evidence, causational Karl Lashley: rats running through maze, cut different parts, inconclusive Had rats run a maze, over 30 yrs, cut out different parts of cerebral cortex, rats could all rerun maze Memories not localized but distributed (false) Together with Thompson, shows complex memories are distributed, simple are localized Ethicality, generalizability, reductionist, experiment Berthold Castrated 6 roosters, 3 groups (castrated left castrated no male aggression) (castrated and then other rooster testicles added, not resestablish nerve connections, but still showed male aggression) (reimplanted testes, same as 2 nd group) Proves testosterone is a thing Ethicality, small group, only roosters, empirical, Milner and Corkin: H.M. H.M. had anterograde amnesia (can’t form new memories), ’53 was 27 yrs had epileptic seizures, removed medial temporal lobe and hippocampus. Severity/frequency reduced. Can remember from before 16yrs (when seizures started). Can’t do episodic or semantic but can form procedural (implicit memory) Hippocampus important for forming new memories, especially semantic and episodic Advantage of catastrophe, only one patient (but other similar studies have happened), can’t be ethically replicated, lacks generalizability, LOTS of qualitative data, little quantitative data Roger Sperry: Split-Brain Picked subjects that had had split-brain operations done Task 1: flashed image to right eye, patient could verbally say what it is. Task 2: flashed image to left eye, patient verbally says he didn’t see anything. Task 3: image flashed to left eye, patient could pick up with hand Showed left was more language, right was visual-spatial, needed connection between different halves of the brain Only 11 split brain patients, no control group, taking control of tragedy, has practical application, can’t be easily replicated because animals use different parts (ex. Anterior commissure in monkeys can send visual info, similar results as Wernicke/Broca McClintock: pheromones Made woman fill out 2 hours worth of questionnaire. Then exposed women to male and female steroid, women were more able to get through questionnaire. PET scans also showed that when women were exposed to steroids, more brain activity in emotion and attention (cerebellum, amygdala, prefontal cortex) Human steroids excite females, not good for males Only college students, qualitative and quantitative data between PET scans and surveys Loewi: Heart and frog Removed beating heart of freshly killed frog w/ vagus nerve attached to it, put in solution of salt water, stimulated vagus nerve, dropped another heart into the water, other heart beat slower Stimulation of vagus nerve released acetylcholine, neurotransmitters Ethicality, generalizability, ecological validity, reductionist, objective, no control groups, can’t be replicated on humans Peter Eriksson and Fred Gage: Cancer patients Five adult cancer patients, 50s-70s, given drug that colors newly dividing cells, perform autopsy hours after patients die, hundreds of neurons being generated Showed that adults continue to develop new neurons, contrary to common belief Taking advantage of tragedy, small sample size, objective data, generalizability Draganski 24 young adults (21 women, 3 men) taken basic MRI scans. Assigned to either “jugglers” or “non-jugglers”, three months later more MRIs, showed 3-4% increase in gray matter in areas of brain with perceiving, remembering, jugglers stop juggling, three months later remeasured with MRI, gray matter decreased 1-2% Brains are dynamic, adapting Objective evidence, no ethical breaches, small sample size, all young adults, replicable Phineas Gage, Harlow, Damasios Rod goes through head, previously sociable, now angry, movement and speech and memory not impaired Frontal lobe has to do with decision-making and personality Qualitative Evidence, taking advantage of tragedy, not replicable, lots of data, lines up with other research on similar topics, lack of generalizability Hans Selye: rats/stressors Exposed rats to prolonged stressors such as shock, heat/cold, exercise. Adrenal glands enlarged, weight loss, stomach ulcers, shrinkage of thymus and lymph glands Alarm stage produced by adrenal medulla, resistance stage (body tries to resist or adjust to situation), exhaustion stage, all known as general adaptation syndrome Ethicality, reductionist, experiments, objective data Bouchard and McGue: Raised twins apart or together Compared twins that were raised together to twins that were raised separately Twins completed 50 hours of interviewing and IQ testing, found that intelligence based 70% on genetics, 30% on other factors cross-cultural, deterministic, IQ tests can be considered flawed, generalizable because lots of participants, Ethical concerns with ways twins were reunited Schachter and Singer All injected with epinephrine, caused sympathetic nervous system, one group was told it was caused by epinephrine, one group wasn’t, exposed to irritating or humorous situation, less emotional reaction for people that were told Martinez and Kesner Had rats run maze, on group gets scoplamin (blocks acetylcholine), some get physostimine (neuron can’t return to resting state), some get no injection, physostimine rats have best record/memory Neurotransmitters (esp acetylcholine) plays function in memory Generalizability, ethicality, causational relationship, objective data Cognitive Level Atkinson and Schriffin – Stage Model of Memory Sensory, Working/Short-term, and long-term Logical, deterministic, other studies show maintenance is worse than elaborative, that working disappears, theories, they didn’t run an experiment, but others did Tolman – latent learning Three groups of rats put in same maze once a day for several days, when food awaited, performance increased, no food = more errors, group 3 get food after 11 days Reward not necessary for learning; latent learning Empirical, Only rats, Ebbinghaus – forgetting curve Memorized a list of 13 nonsense syllables, recorded how much he could remember over time, created forgetting curve We forget a lot really quickly and stability of remaining information He was his only test subject, applicable to real world, ecological validity George Sperling Letters displayed on screen for 1/20 of second, tone sounds If tone w/in 1/3, can remember, if greater than 1/3, decreased dramatically Sensory memory lasts about 1/3 to ½ second Experiment, objective data, little ethical concerns, ecological validity, only visual Bartlett and “War of the Ghosts” 20 English participants read 330-word traditional Native American tale, serial reproduction, by 6th person, reduced to 180 words (leveling), made story more consistent with own culture (assimilation), changed some terms like “boat” to “canoe” to make it line up with own cultural backround (sharpening) Memory recall is influenced by our own preexisting schema, which is influenced by our culture Qualitative, small sample size, cross-cultural validity, call reliability of memory into question Loftus and Car Crash 45 American students (opportunity sample), independent measures, asked if they how fast cars were going when smashed/contacted and if there was glass. Smashed = 41mph, contacted = 32 mph. Most students that heard “smashed” said there was broken glass Misinformation effect – question can influence memory Shows how inaccurate eyewitness testimonies are, lacks cross-cultural validity, 3241mph isn’t a significant difference. Eich – State-dependent retrieval Two groups of people, some were high, some sober, had to memorize 2 words from 24 categories, high people remember more when high State-dependent retrieval Objective, experiment, unethical, ecological validity Simon and Chabris: selective attention Harvard University students, watch video where white and black tshirt people pass basketball, asked to count # of passes made by one team or # of aerial vs bounce passes, 50% see gorilla People selectively attend to what they expect Little participant variability, ethical, reliable, can be replicated, objective, ecologically valid Roediger and McDermott: sleep schema 20 students in intro psychology class in exchange for credit, read words with nonrepresented associates (e.g. bed, rest, pillow, awake tired), 40-50% say they remember unstated word People have schemas, memories are unreliable Ecologically Valid, Bad participants, not generalizable, not really voluntary Brewer and Treyens: office schema Participants stay in room for 35-60s, asked to recall what they remembered, average 29/30 “office items”, 8/30 “non-office items”, 30% recall falsely seeing books We have schemas Emperical, numerical data, ethical Neisser and Harsch: challenger explosion Asked participants questionnaire day after Challenger explosion about how they heard news (where they were, what they were doing, who told them, etc.), then asked again 3yrs later, 106 opportunity people found just after explosion, Of 220 potential “facts”, completely or partially wrong on 150, were more confident in their new answer and denied old answer Flashbulb memories are consistent about event but blurry about details surrounding it Objective data, ecologically valid, taking advantage of tragedy, not replicable, ethicality for forcing to recall accident Talarico and Reuben Duke Unversity students do questionnaire about 9/11 the day after like “where were you” “what were you doing” “who was present”, also asked about some other ordinary, everyday event Randomly assigned to follow-up 1, 6, or 36 weeks later, asked to recall details and evaluate accuracy and vividness, also a year later Accuracy and consistency of flashbulb no different from regular event, but differed in confidence and emotional involvement Both vividness and confidence more accurate than regular memories Godden and Baddely – context effect 18 participants in university diving club asked to learn list of 38 unrelated 2 or 3 syllable words, randomly assigned to one of four conditions (learn on land/in water and recall on land/in water), repeated measures b/c everyone experienced all conditions, @least 24hrs between conditions Environment is contextual clue for recall Ecological validity, small sample population, all university students, confounding variables from day to day, empirical data, not ethically harmful Socio-cultural Lee: Game show Randomly assigned college students as audience, participant, host (asked to write own questions), everybody evaluates others’ intelligences Everybody knew that everyone was assigned roles, but everyone ranked host as most intelligence, audience as least intelligent Fundamental attribution error – attribute behavior of others to internal characteristics while ignoring/underestimating effects of external, situational factor Ecological validity, limited participant population, students knowing each other could be a confounding variable, ethical, objective data, random assignment Peng and Morris: newspapers Compare Chinese-language and English-language newspapers for mass-murders, one is Chinese grad student @ American university, one is US postal worker (real murderers), US newspapers attribute internal, personal attributions, Chinese papers blame external factors/problems w/ US society How we account for successes and failures and for behavior of others depends on cultural context Cross-cultural validity, replicable, ecological validity, qualitative/not empirical, confounding variables, correlational not causational Milgram – obedience/shock 40 males age 20-50, recruited through ads in mail and newspaper, subject feels 45 volts to know it’s not fake 26/40 went full 450 V, nobody stopped before 300 Obedience to authority Replicated with 40 women, same results (cross-gender validity), empirical data, unethical, lacks cross-cultural validity, numbers are deceiving because qualitative results showed obvious discomfort, undue stress Darley and Latane – diffusion of responsibility Opportunity sample of college students, students have over-the-phone conversation with up to 4 other people, listen to recording of someone having epileptic seizure, 85% leave if they are only one in room, 31% leave if with others. When questioned, claim that others have no effect on own behavior In another study, smoke starts to fill room. When by themselves, subjects report smoke. When with others, take interferes w/ breathing after 4 minutes, stay at least 6 minutes before telling someone Bystander effect/diffusion of responsibility Ethicality (deception, health risk w/ smoke), replicable, ecological validity Asch: conformity 5 confederates and 1 subject in a room, subject had to disagree on 12/18 trials. 76% conformed on at least one of the critical trials, overall conformity 37% (control group alone 99% We like to conform to the group Deception, Not terribly unethical, control group, experiment, all university students Sheriff: Robbers’ Cave 11 boys taken to camp, either “rattlers” or “eagles,” fierce rivalry developed, only came to be friends when had to work together All white, young, Christian males Ecological validity, poor sample population, informed consent on part of boys? Zimbardo and Grasshoppers Cognitive Dissonance Ecological validity (eating grasshoppers), only students, could have caused stress, experiment/empirical Aronson and Steele: stereotype threat African American and European Americans given difficult 30-minute verbal test, African Americans did much worse when told it was about verbal abilities than if it was about problem solving Mathematically-gifted women did worse on a math test when told that the test showed gender differences Stereotypes influence performance Empirical, cross-cultural, reliable, ecologically valid Zimbardo: Stanford Prison 24 mostly white males randomly assigned to guard or prisoner groups, originally supposed to be 2 weeks but ended after 6 days, emotional prisoner within 36 hours Obedience to authority Unethical, Ecologically valid, limited population, qualitative data Kempe: ventral striatum Subjects look at 40 photos of faces w/ direct eye contact or not, hooked up to fMRI, activity in ventral striatum increases w/ eye contact, People like social interaction Empirical, lacks cross-cultural validity Bandura and Bobo Doll One group shown adult beating up Bobo doll, one shown adult assembling toys, one not shown video, boys more physically aggressive, girls more verbally aggressive, Social learning theory Empirical, only children, ecological validity, unethical, demand characteristics?, qualitative Festinger and Carlsmith – PEGS 71 male students do tedious task, paid $1 or $20 to tell someone else it was fun, attitudes of $1 actually changed when later interviewed Cognitive dissonance objective, large population, all male students, slightly unethical w/ deception Rizzolatti, Peng and Kitayama, Ekman, Bond and Smith, gotsman Ekman – Faces Found expressions are universal by going to different countries (Japan, South America, Europe) and also went to New Guinea and made them make up a story Happiness, Sadness, Anger, Disgust, Fear, Surprise are unviversal Cross-Cultural, subjective, no empirical evidence, universal Peng and Kitayam Collectivistic and individualistic culture, showed video of fish leaving group and asked person to explain why left group, individuals said wanted to be separate from group, collectivistic was ostracized Collectivistic place emphasis on individual Cross-cultural, empirical evidence, ethical Bond and Smith Meta-analysis of 133 Aschesque studies, 17 different countries, more conformity in collectivistic cultures Collectivistic cultures like conformity to reduce conflict Ethical, cross-cultural, same problems as Asch Rizzolatti: electrodes on cortex Electrodes on ventral premotor cortex of macaque monkey, Mirror neurons: if I see you do something, similar neurons fire as when I’m actually doing ot Only monkeys, empirical Aronson: Jigsaw classroom Developmental Ainsworth: Strange Situation Baby and mom enter room, stranger enters, mom leaves and comes back Infants 1-2yrs old, securely attached and insecurely attached and ambivalent, put Securely: periodically returns, use them as “secure base”, insecure: doesn’t explore env, ignore or avoid mothers. When returned to mom, hard to soothe, resist mom attempts to comfort them Insecure, Secure, ambivalent Reliable, ecological validity, undue stress, qualitative, reductionist Piaget, state theory of development Sensorimotor (0-2yrs; explain world via senses), preoperational (2-7yrs; symbolic thought, egocentrism, irreversibility, lack of conservation, centration), concrete operational (7-12yrs; reversibility, logic limited to tangible materials), formal operational (12+yrs; abstract/hypotheticals) Used his own kids, correlational, Baillargeon, DeVos Piaget thought couldn’t have object permanence until 9 months Expected event (short carrot), then unexpected (tall carrot disappears), watch for surprise, look longer, infants as young as 2.5 months show object permanence, shows event-specific expectations Infants have object permanence as early as 2.5 months Could just be staring, bad population, quantitative, looking doesn’t necessarily mean object permanence Vygotsky Piaget underestimated social and cultural factors, from longitudinal study with children from the USSR Zone of proximal development: difference between what children can accomplish on own and what can accomplish w/ help of others Just a theory, less determinism, more environment Chomsky Children have innate predisposition to learn language, children use bad grammar but we don’t use bad grammar so it’s not like we’ve taught them it Erikson: Social Stages Teens: identity vs role confusion, certain sex role identity, active interest in opposite sex, plans for future, challenging authority, tends to be self accepting, bad if overly obedient All subjective, “overly obedient?” Bem: gender schema theory Gender schemas influence how people think, rated people based on his own test into masculine men and feminine females, in free recall test, gender-schematic people more likely to group words like bull, etc. reaction time indicated that genderschematic people respond more quickly to schema-consistent attributes Gender schema theory Rated people based on her own test (subjective?), also had objective evidence from the times, ethical, cross-gender validity, cross-cultural validity Harlow: monkeys New-born monkey put in cage with two wire monkeys, spent up to 22 hours a day on terry cloth and not much on one with food We attach to things that are comforting We’re not monkeys, nor do we live in cages. Ethicality, if put back at early age can adapt to be normal Vandell and Corasiniti 236 middle-class 8-year old white male kids, 72% double-parent, 28% single-parent, ask parents how often kids go to day care, More extensive day care = worse report cards and behavior grades Bad generalizability, large sample size, only school performance, ways to judge cognitive development, deterministic, correlation Curtiss’ Genie (feral child) Grew up in isolation for 10 years, lots of difficulty in language Language has a critical period of development (before puberty) Assuming genie would have been fine, case study, lack of generalizability, Beal: boys and girls seem to create own “social worlds” boys make more boy friends, girls make more girl friends, girls maintain relationships through compromise, conciliation, verbal conflict resolution Social Worlds Theory, naturalistic obvservation, reductionist, ecological validity Fagot and Hagan Naturally observed mothers and fathers interacting with children in homes, for 18-moold, found males more rewarded for associating with other boys and being aggressive, females more rewarded for trying to communicate Men and women rewarded for different things Observational, cross-cultural, ecologically valid Mead: New Guinea tribes Arapesh: men and women share food preparation and child-raising; Mundugumor men and women both arrogant, uninterested in children, Tchambuli: women responsible for food production and men gossip about appearances Gender roles can very culture to culture Cultural validity, observational, Adler: inferiority/superiority complex Kagan: low and high reactive 4 month old kids for Ainsworth strange situation, argued that changes were due to different innate temperaments, Stress, informed consent, empirical, randomly selected, generalizable Chugani: PET scans on babies PET scans on glucose metabolism in babies, Little activity in cerebral cortex (associated with higher-level thinking), high activity in brainstem and thalamus and amygdala, Led to exploring newborn brains like Bachevalier lesioning monkey brains for effect on social activity Bowlby: 44 thieves 44 Thieves study, 44 adolescents in child protection program in London, 44 other control kids who have emotional problems but not commit crimes More than half of juvenile thieves separated for at least 6 months from mom in first five years, control group only has two, 32% experimental group “emotionless psychopaths”, none in control group Mother is positive for development Experimenter bias from diagnosing psychopathy, undue stress from recalling memories Giedd: different parts of brain maturing Longitudinal, normal students, MRIs every 2nd year, 95% of brain formed by 5 or 6, growth spurt in prefrontal cortex and synapses, different parts mature @ different times (frontal not done until 20) Ecological validity, anonymity, much data, confidentiality, correlation, no relationship between behavior and brain Money: Circumcision David Reimer burnt off penis, so doctor suggest give him hormones and name him Brenda, identified himself as male and once found out, removed breasts and readded penis, but killed himself Nature triumphs when it comes to gender Unethical, human, ecologically valid Martin and Halvorson: pictures of boy and girl activities Age 5-6, showed boys and girls general-role schematic and aschematic pictures, changed memories to ones that would adhere to gender roles People have activities associated with gender roles Only 5/6 year olds, can’t explain how and why gender roles form the way they do, social/cultural factors not taken into account Werner: Longitudinal 698 infants studied until four years old, 2/3 that experience risk factors have learning/behavior problems by age 10 and mental/crime problems by 18 Early learning has influence on later life Cross-cultural, large sample size, some died and were thrown out of data, deterministic Caetano: meeting/video 77 students, 36 psychatrists, either told were volunteers or patients, more clinical experience was more likely to be persuaded by info Labeling theory: behavior is not most important aspect of diagnosing Could have had underlying problem Rosenhan: mental hospitals 5 men, three women, varying occupations, all labeled with schizophrenia, stayed for average of 19 days, longest was 52 days, all released with “schizo in remission” Inability to tell difference between normal/abnormal behavior Mostly subjective, some objective Nicholls: Great Ormond Street Hospital Population of 81 children w/ eating disorders, two practicioners asked to diagnose w/ DSM-IV (.36), ICD-10 (.636), GOS(.879) Certain books are better than others Too few children Jenkins-Hall and Senko: More Depressed black women European American theorists watch video of depressed or healthy European women or African American woman, diagnose black woman as more depressed and less socially competent Stereotyping in diagnosing Confounding variables