PROJECT MANAGEMENT OFFICE World University of Florida Maternal-Fetal Medicine Telemedicine Pilot Project Version – 1.0 Last Updated – 9/25/2010 Date Version Description Author 9/26/2010 1.0 Draft Initial Project Management Plan Group 1 Consulting 1 of 11 World University of Florida Hospital Project Management Plan 9/25/10 Table of Contents Project Overview 3 Estimated Costs and Funding 4 Stakeholders 5 Project Scope 5 Workflow and Process Integration Management of Vendor Solution Implementation Regulatory Compliance Staff Augmentation Training EHR Modification to Manage Telemedicine Patient Records Community Outreach Project Management 5 6 7 8 8 9 9 9 Organizational Goals & Objectives 2 of 11 World University of Florida Hospital 10 Project Management Plan 9/25/10 Project Overview The World University of Florida Hospital (WUFH) Division of Obstetrics and Maternal-Fetal Medicine (DOMFM) has partnered with regional health departments to expand access to prenatal care and improve birth outcomes in underserved counties in Florida. The initiative is modeled on a successful program at the University of Arkansas Medical Center called ANGELS (Antenatal and Neonatal Guidelines, Education and Learning System). The DOMFM provides obstetric care to patients with high-risk pregnancies, with the goal of ensuring the best possible outcome for the mother and infant. One barrier to providing this service is the distance patients have to travel to the University Hospital. A component of this project is the creation and implementation of a prenatal telemedicine practice for the purpose of providing ultrasound screenings to high-risk patients in underserved areas who would not otherwise have direct access to equipment and specialists able to monitor high-risk pregnancies. Through telemedicine, the reach of the Department can be expanded to underserved rural counties in Florida. This project has the specific aim of developing a working telemedicine pilot program in four of the eight counties WUFH currently partners with through the counties’ respective health departments. The health departments will be able to provide a live fetal-maternal medicine consult with our faculty in the Department of Obstetrics. The first four listed counties (Columbia, Dixie, Gilchrist, Hamilton) will be in the pilot with the goal of expanding to the latter four (Lafayette, Levy, Marion and Suwannee) at a later time. Their combined population is approximately 500,000 with the majority in Marion County (330,000). With an approximate birth rate of 11/1000, this population produces 5500 live births annually. These counties have been identified as rural with high infant mortality rates, and a lack of Obstetricians and other specialists to provide prenatal care. Other components of the Maternal-Fetal Medicine program outside the scope of the telemedicine project are: 24 hour patient call center staffed with RNs and NPs who have access to patient records, development of evidence-based guidelines, grand rounds, and community education components. Florida Maternal and Fetal Medicine Data & Statistics Overall, women in Florida fall short of the Healthy People 2010 National Target of 90% with only 75.9% of women receiving first trimester prenatal care. 15.7% of women did not have access to prenatal care due to lack of money or insurance. 48.5% of women in Florida were uninsured before pregnancy, and 33.6% of women who tried to get Medicaid had difficulty in getting Medicaid during pregnancy. Florida has 7.2 infant deaths (younger than 28 days) per 1,000 (infant mortality rate). This is 22nd among the 50 states. 49.6% of Florida births are Medicaid births, which is above the national average of 41%. In the 8 target counties, the percentage of woman who do not receive early (1st trimester) prenatal care ranges from a high of 36% to a low of 22%, and the infant mortality rate ranges from 5.8 to 24.5 per 1000 infants. The rate of underweight births (<2500g) ranges from 10.8% to 13.3%. 3 of 11 World University of Florida Hospital Project Management Plan 9/25/10 The CDC has reported that preterm birth is the strongest risk factor for infant mortality. In addition there is a strong correlation between lack of early prenatal care and preterm birth. Consequently, one of the best strategies to lower infant mortality is to improve access to early prenatal care. The infant mortality rate for those who do not receive early prenatal care is 40% higher than in those who do (Mathews, T.J.; Macdorman, M.F., 2008). Project Goals This program will enhance the existing outreach programs by the county health departments. This pilot will provide the means to identify high-risk pregnancies early, provide appropriate interventions in the most convenient location and determine which patients require a higher level of care. It will allow for early planning for the most appropriate place for delivery and what services the infant may require at birth (e.g level 1 NICU, Pediatric Surgery etc.) Some patients are expected to need delivery at our University Hospital, and thus the project should expand the referral base of the University Hospital. However, the telemedicine consults will also allow for deliveries by local obstetricians supported by our subspecialists which otherwise would have required emergent transfer of the expectant high-risk patient. Thus, the program may lead to lower overall healthcare costs as well as more convenience to patients. The overall goal of this pilot will be to improve the quality of early prenatal care and improve the birth outcomes in the areas served. We are hopeful that telemedicine will prove to be a cost effective method to expand access to underserved populations. The success of the pilot project will prompt state officials and private insurers to offer appropriate reimbursement for telemedicine opening up the opportunity to expand the concept to all underserved areas. Specifically, we will measure improvements by the: Number of prenatal telemedicine MFM and MD (non-MFM) consultations Increase in telemedicine consults from Year 0 to Year 5. Number of telemedicine consultations as a percentage of total high-risk consultations from rural counties Number of referrals from pilot health departments Increase in number of successful high-risk deliveries from rural counties Estimated Costs and Funding This pilot project is an ideal candidate for a federal grant in that it addresses clearly identified health care goals currently emphasized by the federal government. The program is an ideal candidate for comparative effectiveness research as prenatal care and infant mortality both show wide disparities among ethnic groups. In addition, it is an example of leveraging information technology to improve health outcomes and improve efficiency in delivery of care. There is considerable federal funding available for both comparative effectiveness research and IT pilot programs. The program is also an example of patient-centered care, and focuses on population health. The full costs of the program are yet to be determined at this time. The intent is to apply for and receive federal grant funding to cover the cost of the equipment and training. State health 4 of 11 World University of Florida Hospital Project Management Plan 9/25/10 department funding will cover the ongoing clinical costs for the individual health departments. An application to the state for a waiver to provide reimbursement for Medicaid patients is underway. Negotiations with private insurers have also been started. The University Hospital will receive reimbursement for professional services from these efforts. Stakeholders The internal stakeholders for the telemedicine project include: WUF Hospital Board of Directors WUF College of Medicine WUFH Department of Obstetrics and Maternal-Fetal Medicine WUFH Department of Pediatrics WUFH CIO WUFH CMIO WUFH CFO Chief of Maternal-Fetal Medicine Director of information Technology CNP Rural Outreach Coordinator Department of Medical Informatics and Biostatistics Director of Health Information Management External stakeholders include: Patients and medical community from rural counties Florida Department of Health Medical Directors for Columbia, Dixie, Gilchrist, and Hamilton county health departments Florida Medicaid Community representatives Project Scope Workflow and Process Integration The pilot project will require careful consideration of existing workflows and processes before the introduction of new workflows to accommodate the telemedicine component. The planned telemedicine workflow will allow all health care providers in the region to make a referral to the program by contacting the University Hospital. This will include patients cared for at the health departments themselves as well as private physicians offices. Accepted patients will be scheduled for a preliminary visit to the appropriate health department where additional clinical and demographic information will be collected and sent electronically to WUFH, where a patient record will be created in the EMR. Additional clinical records will be collected by the RN associate coordinator including all relevant old medical records and ultrasounds, laboratory tests etc. and added to the patient’s EMR record. 5 of 11 World University of Florida Hospital Project Management Plan 9/25/10 The Clinical Coordinator will review the records and set up an appointment with the appropriate physician. Additional instructions for preparation for the consult will be communicated directly to the patient from the University Hospital. Reminder notices will be sent to the patient by the University Hospital. The University Hospital will notify the referring physician of the pending consult. A phone call the day prior to the appointment will be made by the health department clinical coordinator. The patient will be greeted on the appointment day by the clinical coordinator and prepped for the consult. At the time of the consult, two–way video conferencing will start between the specialist at the University Hospital and the patient, who will be accompanied by the health department physician/midwife and/or the referring private doctor (at their request only). A physical exam, ultrasound, fetal tracings and colposcopy exam will be performed as indicated by the local provider with real time electronic transfer of images/tracing to the specialist. The specialist will then communicate orders for any additional lab studies to be completed. The local clinical coordinator will arrange for any lab studies at the conclusion of the visit. Two way video-conferencing will again take place for the specialist to provide any initial assessments and recommendations to the patient. A comprehensive treatment plan will be completed after the consult and sent to the patient’s provider. If the consult recommendations include additional telemedicine visits or travel to the main campus arrangements will be made. Management of Vendor Solution Implementation The telemedicine component of the project is involved with the vendor relations for telemedicine equipment and connectivity, system installation at the University of Florida hospital and health departments in the four pilot counties, as well as training and staff augmentation. Cisco HealthPresence has been chosen as a suitable vendor for telemedicine equipment through grant funding for antenatal and neonatal screenings and consultations. Cisco HealthPresence combines high-definition video and advanced audio for almost as real face-toface experience over the network. Cisco also provides fixed-price planning, design, and optimization services to help increase business value and return on investment. The vendor also promises the affordable maintenance and upgrade on their equipment and communication systems. The project involves managing the relationship with Cisco and oversight of telemedicine equipment selection and installation, including: Documenting technological and bandwidth requirements for selected equipment Allocating staff and resources for vendor relationship management 6 of 11 World University of Florida Hospital Project Management Plan 9/25/10 Placing orders for equipment Assuring site preparedness including availability of utilities and facilities (power, broadband connectivity, telephony, generator back-up, telemedicine consult room availability, etc.) Applying for required permissions for connectivity and other allied requirements Monitoring progress of readiness at site Carrying out any necessary software customizations Carrying out testing, integration and fitness certification of hardware and software Integrating and 'Hot' testing the complete application through connectivity available in the central office Ensuring the availability and adequacy of connectivity between WUF and county health departments Debugging any issues that may arise Testing security protocols Dismantling and packing equipment for transportation after initial testing Stationing one team member at site during implementation phase to assist and advice the client, and certify readiness of the TMC Certifying that each site is ready for implementation Collecting necessary documents and permissions for delivery of material to the client site Determining availability and delivery schedule of hardware Transporting equipment to each health department location Regulatory Compliance Medicaid The Medicaid guidelines state that reimbursement must meet standards of improved “efficiency, economy, and quality of care”. States are given flexibility in determining a reimbursement rate for services via telemedicine. At the present time, most states with established Medicaid reimbursement for telemedicine reimburse a consultation fee for the hub site while reimbursing for an office visit for the spoke site. States may also reimburse for technical costs (i.e. tech support, on-line costs) if they can show it meets the requirements for improved “efficiency, economy, and quality of care”. Private payer insurance tends to reimburse fully for consultations, however a little over half do not reimbursement a facility fee. BCBS of Georgia has developed a joint program with the state of Georgia to provide grants to rural areas to buy and implement telemedicine technology with the belief that it will provide better healthcare at a lower cost, and it is possible that we could use this project as a model. So far the number of HMOs that provide telemedicine is extremely small. HMOs could be encouraged to develop telehealth with tax breaks or block grants from the state. Telemedicine Telemedicine guidelines are still very broad. The main issues today are licensure of clinicians and privacy. Each clinician at a facility must have the proper license and certification to conduct telemedicine consults according to state law. Furthermore, guidelines must be established to make sure only those clinicians who are authorized are viewing the telemedicine 7 of 11 World University of Florida Hospital Project Management Plan 9/25/10 presentation. The state of Florida statute indicates that “physicians who order, perform, or interpret diagnostic imaging tests or procedures are responsible for the appropriateness and quality of the non-invasive diagnostic procedure, interpretation of the results, diagnosis, and either maintenance of medical records or provision of the results of the test to the referring physician.” Staff Augmentation This project will require additional staff or new roles and responsibilities for existing staff, or a combination of both. Information Technology Staff Full-time telemedicine IT Director plus 1-2 additional help desk staff for support and maintenance. The IT Department will further evaluate staffing needs as part of this project) Available technical support on site during telemedicine consult days (2 days/week) One IT liaison at each health department who with central IT backup can provide local support during consults. Clinical Staff at WUFH Obstetrics and Maternal-Fetal Medicine Faculty (4) and one fellow. These staff members will be chosen from existing faculty. Clinical Coordinator: an RN or Nurse Practitioner at WUF full-time for the duration of the initiative. Fifty percent of the Clinical Coordinator’s time will be for the telemedicine component and fifty percent for the other components of the program, such as training, development of evidence-based guidelines, coordination of community outreach, etc. Associate clinical coordinator (RN): one full-time employee for the telemedicine project. This person’s role will involve travel to the health departments to assist with program development and publicity in early phases. Pediatric cardiologist, Neonatologist, and Geneticist as needed for specialty consults and weekly case review Clinical Staff at County Health Departments Health Department Medical Directors and Clinical Staff Health Department Clinical Liaisons: a current health department employee (medical assistant or other staff) utilized at twenty-five percent to schedule bi-weekly clinics for each health department, including appointment scheduling and assistance during consults. Administrative Staff Secretary/Billing personnel: 4 full-time employees at University Hospital Patient records and documentation assistant at the University Hospital: 1 full-time employee utilized at fifty percent 8 of 11 World University of Florida Hospital Project Management Plan 9/25/10 Training Training for WUF staff as well as health department staff will be essential for the initiative to run smoothly. Training tasks include: Training WUF telemedicine staff on Cisco HealthPresence. Planning and preparing training materials including lesson plans, manuals, and the creation of a staff-accessible training web site with library to how-to videos, forum, and live technical support chat. Training health department staff in the field on telemedicine, advising patients on the use of telemedicine, and Cisco HealthPresence software and hardware. Training health department staff on the use of the WUF EMR. EHR Modification to Manage Telemedicine Patient Records WUF’s EMR system will contain a patient record for each telemedicine consult patient, even if the patient has never been to WUF before. Considerations must be made for Providing a mechanism for initial assessment and patient history as it pertains to telemedicine, as well as a vehicle for importing CCDs and scanning paper records from rural facilities. Providing the ability for health departments to access patient records in the WUF EMR remotely through a web interface Community Outreach The telemedicine project seeks to expand its reach outside the realm of WUF and the pilot health departments by conducting grand rounds and providing continuing education opportunities to providers in the greater community. Video artifacts of teleconsults can be used for educational purposes as well as for weekly case reviews. Measurement of Patient Satisfaction The telemedicine project will design and field patient satisfaction surveys at all participating health departments to better understand patient feedback and gauge the success of the project from a patient standpoint. Project Management Overall project management needs for the telemedicine project are: Creating and communicating with the project team on a regular basis Establishing a steering committee Providing a document repository for information for all project stakeholders Documenting the responsibilities of WUF, Cisco, and each county health department and communicating those responsibilities to interested parties Creating a project work breakdown structure and Gantt chart, and sharing that document in such a way that the latest version is always available Creating a risk mitigation plan 9 of 11 World University of Florida Hospital Project Management Plan 9/25/10 Determining project governance and planning accordingly Create a human resources plan Finalizing the project budget and specific hardware and software deliverables from Cisco Planning for delays and exigencies Testing equipment, connectivity, software, workflow, and processes Planning for training of staff (users) Planning for operational management where necessary Backup planning for system outages, failures, etc. Organizational Goals & Objectives The pilot is consistent with the mission statement to be on the leading edge of health care delivery. Academic Medical Centers have the advantage of having the most highly specialized physicians but the disadvantage of relatively high costs. As the market share has shrunk due to restrictions by insurance companies, the survival of such centers is contingent upon patient referrals. Any model that would expand our referral base and provide more cost effective and patient centered care will maintain our position as a leader in health care. Moreover, while telemedicine reimbursement is limited now it is expected that changes are rapidly approaching and positioning ourselves as leaders in telemedicine early will be a strategic advantage consistent with our strategic business and clinical goals. This pilot covers a single clinical need but the lessons learned and equipment purchased will lay the foundation for expansion of telemedicine into virtually all clinical subspecialties. We have a number of negative perceptions to overcome in the implementation of the telemedicine project. First is an internal concern over acceptance of telemedicine technology and workflow changes by Florida rural providers and patients. There is also concern by providers who have practiced face-to-face consults for many years that it will be difficult to adapt to teleconsult and new technology. We have heard from providers at local health departments that there is a fear that the telemedicine project will divert patients from rural hospitals and practices to University Hospital, resulting in closure or loss of revenue to these facilities. In addition, there is concern about legal risk in treating high-risk pregnancies from rural provider perspective. Finally, we face resistance from Florida Medicaid to reimburse for teleconsults. However, a number of positive factors exist. The WUF medical and IT staff are dedicated to using technology to improve care. The project has a clear vision and leadership stakeholders who are passionate about the project and potential benefits. These staff members have a desire for outreach within Florida and beyond, as well as a desire to build a model program including evidence-based practices to share both within the state and with other states. The WUF staff also wishes to expand the telemedicine network to clinical areas outside Obstetrics and Gynecology. From an infrastructure standpoint, we have the ability to use the existing Florida Department of Health bioterrorism network (T1) for broadband connectivity with every acute care and critical 10 of 11 World University of Florida Hospital Project Management Plan 9/25/10 access hospital in the state, as well as every health department. We feel confident about the availability of grant funds to purchase telemedicine equipment. In addition, WUF possesses a seasoned technology and training team equipped to simplify the use of technology and provide technical support to remote teams. Our existing IT infrastructure includes an EMR system that can be extended to include telemedicine records including video files of consults. We also have the ability and expertise to create a web interface to allow health departments to view these records. WUF stands to benefit from the telemedicine project in ways that extend beyond improved outcomes. These include: The ability to provide evidence-based guidelines and build upon these as a public resource The ability to conduct grand rounds and continuing education courses through the teleconference equipment The creation of a video library of case studies for educational purposes The ability to conduct a telemedicine forum with interested parties around the state and later, around the US The ability to assist other states in replicating telemedicine projects The prospect of state and national recognition and press The ability to deploy telemedicine programs for other specialties The potential to become thought leaders and industry experts in telemedicine care References Florida Commission on the Status of Women and the Florida Department of Health (2009). Florida Department of Health Women's Health Data Report (pp. 90-96). Lavanian, D., Indian Space Research Organization: How to setup a Telemedicine center & Telemedicine Devices and Equipment . Retrieved on 20 September 26, 2010 from: http://laico.org/v2020resource/files/setup_tele_center_devices.htm Mathews, T.J.; Macdorman, M.F. (2008, 30-July). National Vital Statistics Reports: Infant Mortality Statistics from the 2005 Period Linked Birth/death data set. National Vital Statistics Data Report , 57 (2), p. 5. The Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation (2010). Medicaid/CCHIP Eligibility. Retrieved on 23 September, 2010 from http://www.statehealthfacts.org/profileind.jsp?cat=4&rgn=11 11 of 11 World University of Florida Hospital Project Management Plan 9/25/10