Achieving a healthy, wealthy and culturally strong MG community Yawoorroong Miriuwung Gajerrong Yirrgeb Noong Dawang Aboriginal Corporation (MG Corp) ABN 79 270 210 553 Office: (08) 9166 4800 Email: j.hughes@mgcorp.com.au PO BOX 2110, Kununurra WA 6743 admin@mgcorp.com.au www.mgcorp.com.au 31 December 2013 Mr Andrew Forrest Chairman Indigenous Jobs and Training Review SUBMISSION FROM MIRIUWUNG GAJERRONG CORPORATION (EAST KIMBERLEY) MG Corporation represents the Miriuwung and Gajerrong (MG) people, the acknowledged native title holders of land in the East Kimberley and neighbouring areas, including Kununurra township. Pursuant to the Ord Final Agreement 2005 with the State of Western Australia and others (OFA), large areas of MG land are being made available for irrigated agriculture, with MG Corporation taking a key role in East Kimberley’s economic development, which has involved significant Commonwealth, State and private sector investment in the expanding agricultural industry. The OFA provided native title payments which the MG people have used to design and to fund coordinated and in many cases innovative responses to education, employment, health, housing and other priority social issues over more than seven years, working with local community people, government and NGO partners. As an example, MG Corporation recently completed a project with WA LandCorp and Leighton Contractors to capture the full employment potential of the recently completed Ord Stage II agricultural earthworks major project, which achieved an Aboriginal employment rate of 35% at the peak of construction activity. Through numerous projects MG Corporation is building a reputation for social welfare leadership as well as economic leadership. Nevertheless, overall sustained progress for MG people remains slow and is undermined by poor human and social capital (education, work-readiness, cultural break-down, substance abuse), counterproductive policy settings (welfare and housing), and misaligned and uncoordinated service delivery (education, training and employment, youth services). MG Corporation welcomes this important review as an opportunity to work with the Australian Government towards a sustainable working future for MG people and the broader East Kimberley community. Opportunities for Real Change in the East Kimberley The three pillars of change should be Education, Housing and Employment. In support of these three pillars, the prevailing approach of government must be transformed to reflect the following principles: Incentives and opportunities for people to do right for themselves, and their families Support that is focussed and coordinated to help them be successful in this, and Sanctions so people know there are consequences for not taking responsibility. Housing should be an incentive for participation, not a barrier MG Corporation believes appropriate and affordable housing is a key barrier to our people achieving good outcomes in education and employment. Approximately 80% of Aboriginal people in our region depend on some form of government-provided housing, and there are fundamental problems with overcrowding, income eligibility thresholds, and the affordability gap between public housing and the private market. MG Corporation achieved employment success – and insight into this area of housing – when arranging accommodation for local Aboriginal workers at the Ord Stage II FIFO workers’ camp. Housing stock is inadequate, a barrier to employment. The private market in Kununurra, like most northern centres, does not provide realistic housing options for families embarking on a working future. We need housing policies that help people work around the failed private housing market, which move beyond dependence on traditional public housing. Recommendation 1: Prioritise capital investment for new accommodation options that support and encourage people to transition to and succeed in employment, such as single workers accommodation and increased housing availability. Recommendation 2: Change the eligibility and prioritisation rules for public and community housing to remove disincentives for people to take up job opportunities. This includes allowing employed people to remain in public housing as their income increases, with rent increasing up to the market level, and consideration of “rent insurance” to reduce housing risk when a job is lost or seasonal. Recommendation 3: Design and implement measures to encourage people to invest in home ownership, including shared equity arrangements that reflect local market realities and not just “one size fits all”. Support services should be focused, effective, and aligned to help people succeed Services which aim to help Aboriginal people succeed are often poorly coordinated, fragmented and misaligned, and prone to duplication and gaps, bringing confusion and reducing effectiveness. This brings a lack of accountability in two ways: on the part of service delivery agencies with impaired transparency; and among uncomprehending welfare recipients for whom drifting opportunism can become more effective than personal drive and dedication. Responsiveness to local needs is an ongoing challenge. Where a reform principle is adopted, all local services must align to it, so that they do not undermine each other: for example, a basketball program rewarding school attendance should not be undermined by a youth-engagement basketball program focused on inclusion and diversion. Some important services operate on an assumption of low participation: for example, low rates of school attendance and long housing waiting lists are mirrored by service provision at a level which could not cope with improved school or work participation. Key services and supports must be “reform-ready”. Particularly important in this regard is the readiness of schools to absorb and deliver effective teaching and transition support (similar to that recently announced by the Commonwealth) to children with a poor past attendance record. “Reform-ready” services will need to be resourced to meet higher demand as participation increases (ie. not just to meet the current poor levels of participation), and provide innovative responses to support people as they transition to sustainable participation. Services need to be rationalised to reduce duplication. They should be coordinated to focus unambiguously on moving people forward in a clearly agreed direction. Service delivery must link strongly to the intent and nature of the reforms proposed. Recommendation 4: Ensure that the resourcing, capacity, and coordination of existing services and supports are “reform-ready”, are consistent with the reform principles, and can properly support the intent and nature of the desired changes. (NB: this recommendation is closely linked to Recommendation 8 – Local Leadership, which should provide the local knowledge and ownership to ensure the effectiveness of preparations for reforms). 2 Sanctions, so people know there are consequences for not taking responsibility In MG Corporation’s extensive experience, programmes of support to MG people and families are undermined by lack of incentives and opportunities for improvement, and where there is no sanction or consequence when people don’t make responsible choices. Recommendation 5: Parents and Carers should be subject to the expectation (from our Community) and the obligation (from Government) that kids must be at school and “fit-to-learn”. Parenting and Family payments should be conditional on children attending school. Recommendation 6: Adults who are capable should be expected to take up reasonable employment opportunities. Newstart payments should be withheld or subjected to Compulsory Income Management where relevant job opportunities exist and the recipient has accommodation compatible with holding a job. NB: Kinship obligations amongst family members (“demand-sharing”) may undermine the impact of financial sanctions on the individual (by transferring the burden to the extended family). Sanctions must be supported by effective and culturally competent communication and family case management. MG Corporation has a special role to play in supporting MG families to adjust to the new arrangements. Alcohol must be addressed or it will undermine any changes Alcohol and drugs continue to cause major impacts on our families and community, including the debilitating and irreversible effects of Foetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder (FASD). MG Corporation believes the best way to tackle this is to get more people into work, and to tighten the administration of welfare payments so people have less spare time and money to spend getting into trouble. These are the focus of earlier recommendations. Given the high levels of alcohol abuse, MG Corporation also supports practical measures to manage the supply of alcohol, and continues to support the Kununurra and Wyndham Alcohol Accord, and previous proposals for a Takeaway Alcohol Management System. Recommendation 7: Prioritise the introduction of a Takeaway Alcohol Management System in Kununurra and Wyndham to help limit the supply of alcohol to those without self-restraint, as previously proposed by the Shire and the Alcohol Accord. Local leadership is critical for effective change MG Corporation considers that the necessary changes to welfare, housing and service delivery should be jointly designed and implemented between the local community and governments. This will encourage local ownership and commitment to changes which are seen to match local needs. A strong local focus will help to cut through bureaucratic silos. As traditional owners of the Kununurra area, Miriuwung and Gajerrong people have a special responsibility to provide strong leadership in this regard. Recommendation 8: Establish a tripartite Leadership Group, including the local community, WA and Australian governments, jointly-empowered to design and to oversee the implementation of changes which improve employment and other social outcomes for Aboriginal people in the East Kimberley. Membership should include leaders drawn from senior traditional owners, the broader Kununurra community, and the WA and Australian Governments. Members must bring a high level of commitment, authority and influence, including direct access to political authority. 3