How you can approach an 8m essay Note: You should NOT merely memorise everything here because 1) it is a mere guide and not what you all like to call a “model” answer 2) understanding and practice is the only way to write a good essay 3) not all the information you need is inside, you have to value-add with your own knowledge There are a few types of essays that can come out: 1. Discussion on impacts in which case you have to assess whether a certain situation results in more negative impacts or positive impacts and make a judgement 2. Discussion on the measures taken to tackle the problems brought about by a certain situation which thus requires you to describe each measure, its effectiveness and its limitations An essay in geography will always be two-sided in nature. In this week’s class test, since it covers Weather and Climate as well as Natural Vegetation, the essay could possibly be on the… 1. Positive and negative impacts of Weather and Climate (a question that you have already attempted in your mock test’s mini 5m essay) 2. Reasons to conserve and reasons not to conserve the rainforests 3. Positive and negative impacts of deforestation 4. Measures to solve the problem of deforestation Many of you have yet to realise that #4 is the MOST COMMON type of question for an 8m essay!!! It is definitely IMPORTANT, please don’t neglect it. Also, many others are confused between #2 and #3. #2 sounds as if they require you to give the benefits of the rainforest (why benefits? Since there are benefits, we have to conserve them, see the link?) and the reasons why people clear them (things like getting land space to carry out various activities, etc.) On the other hand, #3 just seems to want the consequences. However, if you think about it, content for #2 and #3 do overlap! Let me give you an example: One of the “positive/good” points for #2: One of the reasons why we should conserve our rainforests is due to them being habitats for flora and fauna. Similarly for #3, one of the “negative/not good” points: Deforestation can negatively impact our environment by causing large-scale loss of flora and fauna because they are habitats for numerous plant and animal species. SEE! The same content can be used after manipulating it to suit the question The opposite is also true: One of the “negative/not good” points for #2: Yet, to some, failing to conserve our rainforest may not be disastrous because it can create land space for the government to house the growing population in houses. One of the “positive/good” points for #3 that shares the same idea: Deforestation may bring advantages such as the availability of more land space to house the growing population in houses. Do you see the pattern now? Now that we have clarified this, let’s move on to how you should approach an 8m essay for the various questions we have listed above. Since #1 and #3 are both questions on impacts, we can explain them in unison: Let’s say the question something like this: “Deforestation only results in negative consequences to a country.” How far do you agree with this statement? Discuss with reference to detailed examples. Introduction Define key words: Deforestation is the permanent clearing and destruction of forests by human activities for purposes such as creating land for agriculture settlement, transport and industry. State your stand: I agree with this statement to a certain degree Briefly explain your stand (if you want, you can list the points you are going to go through in your essay): as although deforestation can bring about numerous problems to the people and environment, for instance, the loss of habitat to indigenous people and soil erosion, there are benefits that come along with clearing the forests as well such as the availability of more land for housing and agriculture. Body paragraphs Number of points: Since for a 5m mini essay you had to write at least 3 points (2 for supporting your stand, whatever your stand may be, and 1 balance point), for an 8m essay, it is only natural that it should demand at least 4 points. Time management: You should take about 5 minutes to complete each paragraph Use of case studies: The question requires you to use detailed examples, so please DO SO. Structure: You need your PEEL structure and you can write in either a 3-1 format or 2-2 format. We will accept the 3-1 structure for now since all of you are still inexperienced in the writing of good conclusions that can weigh effectively. But this does NOT mean that your conclusions can just be weak one-liners. All of you have to try weighing your points. PLEASE TAKE NOTE: You have to memorise, memorise, MEMORISE. We cannot emphasise this enough. Honestly, in a geography essay, all you have to do is vomit all the information you have memorised out and don’t stop writing till you do! The notes we have provided have given you very good elaborations and examples. So, please do not over summarise your textbooks’/notes’ elaboration and examples because it is very wholesome and will help you!!! Getting rid of any one point in an attempt to write more points/ save time may sabotage your elaboration and cause you to have “gaps” and logical leaps! We love quality over quantity (but your quantity cannot be too little as well). The fact that you must accept is that you have to write a lot without sacrificing content. Hence, you have to learn to write very fast. Also, your Point should naturally be, straight to the point: One problem brought about by deforestation is that of soil erosion. (Short, sweet and straight to the point) Conclusion Conclusion should not be too long, probably about 3-4 sentences will do. Use concluding transitional words: In all, All in all, In conclusion, Hence, Therefore, Thus, In conclusion, etc. Round up/short summary: Deforestation can bring about both negative and positive impacts as despite the loss of habitats for indigenous people and soil erosion which harms both people and environment, it does, admittedly, help to provide more land area to house the growing population and to grow more crops to feed this growing number of people and demand. (Can you see how your points that you elaborated on in your essay is reinforced here again?) Weighing of your points: It is in my opinion that deforestation provides more positive consequences than negative ones as the problems can be mitigated using measures. In the face of the growing population, it might be necessary and important to clear the forests so as to get land to house and support them. It is hard to source for land outside the forested areas especially if the country is less economically developed and cannot engage in the expensive project of land reclamation. Furthermore, the indigenous people can possibly be convinced to resettle to other plots of the forest and soil erosion can be managed with engineering methods. (Note: This is way too long, so please cut it down to maybe 1-2 sentences. It is just to give you some idea on what weighing could be like. The ones is bold are probably more important) Let us now analyse the method to doing a #4 type of question. There are two types here as well. 1. Given the question: Discuss the effectiveness of the measures taken to mitigate the hazards brought about by deforestation using detailed examples. Introduction Define key words: o Deforestation is the permanent clearing and destruction of forests by human activities for purposes such as creating land for agriculture settlement, transport and industry. o The hazards associated with it include soil erosion, loss of habitats for flora and fauna, loss of plants with medical value amongst others. Introduce the measures you will be covering in your essay + stand: In order to tackle these problems, affected countries have engaged in several policies such as reforestation, controlled logging, conservation and controlling forest fires but they are only effective to a certain extent. (This is your balanced stand) Each Body Paragraph Short, sweet and straightforward Point: One of the measures taken to solve the problems brought about by deforestation is that of reforestation. Elaboration: o Detailed o MUST include the description of the measures Examples: Bring in your case studies at this point HERE, ADD IN YOUR LIMITATIONS TO THE MEASURE o Do not link back first o This will be your attempt at BALANCING in the essay o You should write this is in a new paragraph so that the paragraph does not seem too long and draggy and hence boring to the examiner! Link + JUDGEMENT: o Since (your limitation such as maybe the rate of deforestation outpaces the rate of reforestation), this measure may not be very effective. Conclusion Use concluding transitional words: In all, All in all, In conclusion, Hence, Therefore, Thus, In conclusion, etc. Round up/short summary: the methods of … can be used to manage the hazards of deforestation. However, they are only successful to a certain extent as shown above. Decide which measure is most likely to be effective for different situations + how we can resolve the limitations o (Let’s take the example of conservation. The limitation is that illegal logging can still take place because there is a lack of manpower to monitor the area) o It could go something along these lines: Yet, despite conservation being limited in effectiveness, it is possibly the most effective method since it prevents destruction at the very get go. The problem of the lack of manpower can be mitigated through the use of incentives which can be offered to the locals to get them to help. 2. Given the question: “Controlled logging is most successful in tackling the problems associated with deforestation.” To what extent would you agree with this statement? Discuss this with reference to specific examples. The only thing setting this question and #1 apart is that they have already provided you with a solution out of the 4 you have learnt So, your first body paragraph HAS TO ADDRESS this given measure, the three following paragraphs would then be your other measures in any order you please In your introduction, you must mention the given measure in relation to the rest as well. What does this mean? Here: Controlled logging may be effective in mitigating the negative effects of deforestation but there are other measures such as … as well. They are, however, all limited in success. In fact, if you want to, you can state clearly whether you agree or disagree that controlled logging is the most effective like so: I agree that controlled logging is the most successful approach, however, it does have its limitations and there are other measures like … that are successful as well. In your conclusion, you then have to re-emphasise your “stand” with proper reasoning