Elvira Dimas Language Arts: Context Clues Objectives The student will be able to use next-door clues by highlighting helpful context in a sentence to determine meaning of unfamiliar words. SOL: 3.4 The student will expand vocabulary when reading. d) Use context to clarify meaning of unfamiliar words. ACEI Standards 2.1 Reading, Writing, and Oral Language-Candidates demonstrate a high level of competence in use of English language arts and they know, understand, and use concepts from reading, language and child development, to teach reading, writing, speaking, viewing, listening, and thinking skills and to help students successfully apply their developing skills to many different situations, materials, and ideas. I meet this standard by assessing the students’ literacy development of context clues. From that assessment I gear my instruction to teach reading skills they can apply outside of language arts. I connect the idea of using context clues to find meaning of unfamiliar words by modeling with nonsense words to have students recognize that even when there is not real definition, next-door clues are available to help make meaning that makes sense. Materials Paper Reading Passages Poster board Markers Highlighters Preassessment I will assess the students in the lowest reading levels. I will give each of them a worksheet with a reading passage with unfamiliar vocabulary words underlined. These words will be defined by the readers as they read through the passages. Throughout the passages there will be sentences in which next-door clues and in the neighborhood clues will be used to understand the meaning of the unfamiliar words. Before they read the passage, they will be told to use next-door clues and in the neighborhood clues to find the meaning of the underlined words. They will also be told to use highlighters or pencils to help them in any way they need. They will read the passages and define the unfamiliar underlined words as they go along. As I grade the worksheet, I will be looking for those who used highlighter or pencil to define the underlined, unfamiliar words using next-door clues and in the neighborhood clues. Those who do not use context clues ineffectively to correctly define the underlined words will become my focus group for the context clues lesson. Data Student A (in the neighborhood clues) Defined the underlined word correctly Used highlighters or pencil to find helpful words Found relevant helpful word to find meaning of unfamiliar words Student A (next door clues) Defined the underlined word correctly Used highlighters or pencil to find helpful words Found relevant helpful word to find meaning of unfamiliar words Student B (in the neighborhood clues) Defined the underlined word correctly Used highlighters or pencil to find helpful words Found relevant helpful word to find meaning of unfamiliar words Student B (next door clues) Defined the underlined word correctly Used highlighters or pencil to find helpful words Found relevant helpful word to find meaning of unfamiliar words Student C (in the neighborhood clues) Defined the underlined word correctly Used highlighters or pencil to find helpful words Found relevant helpful word to find meaning of unfamiliar words Student C (next door clues) Defined the underlined word correctly Used highlighters or pencil to find helpful words Found relevant helpful word to find meaning of unfamiliar words Student D (in the neighborhood clues) Defined the underlined word correctly Used highlighters or pencil to find helpful words Found relevant helpful word to find meaning of unfamiliar words Student D (next door clues) Defined the underlined word correctly ✓ ✓ X ✓ ✓ ✓ X ✓ X X ✓ X ✓ ✓ ✓ X ✓ X ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ Used highlighters or pencil to find helpful words Found relevant helpful word to find meaning of unfamiliar words ✓ X With this preassessment, I learned that these students have misconceptions on what helpful words mean. Though I explained that helpful words are words that are useful in trying to understand the meaning of unfamiliar word, Student B, C, and D circled and listed helpful words that were not relevant in finding the meaning of the unfamiliar word. For example, Student A and B listed movie as a helpful word when trying to understand the meaning of favorable. For his credit, Student B’s meaning of the word favorable was a summary of the sentences, he wrote “the movie was funny”. Student B did the same thing when trying to find the meaning of timid in the next door clues example. Though Student A did find a relevant word to help him understand timid, he did not apply it to comprehend the sentences. Students C and D did well with in the neighborhood clues, but struggle with next door clues. Student C simply repeated timid as the meaning and listed class as a helpful word. Student D correctly defined timid as thinking quietly but he listed his helpful word as kept. Introduction Good morning! If you brought your noggin to think this morning, raise your snooble! I will wait until someone raises their hand. If no one does, I will raise my hand. That was strange wording, wasn’t it? Raise your hand if you understand what was I saying? I will call on someone raising their hand. You wanted us to raise our hand if we brought our head to think today. Right! How did you know that was it? I will call on someone raising their hand. Well you said ‘if we brought our noggin to think, I figured that was your brain or head because that’s what we use to think. You said raise your snooble and we always raise our hand in class so I guessed it was hand. Very good! You know what you all used right now? Context clues! Instruction and Activities Today we will be learning about specific a context clue that are useful when reading passages with words that we are not familiar with. With these context clues, we will begin our jobs as context detectives! Oooooh! Our first clue we will look for as context detectives is called next-door clue. Instead of giving you the definition of this clue, I will show you a sentence with an unfamiliar word underlined, on a loose leaf sheet of paper I want you to write what the underlined word means and what word or words from the sentence helped you find the meaning. I will have the following sentence on a big poster board/white board for the group to see: The big yellow school gleek pulled to a stop at the corner. Once students are done writing: I’m going to think aloud to try to understand this sentence. Sentence: The big, yellow, school gleek pulled to a stop at the corner. I’ve never heard of gleek before, well not in this context anyways. Hmmm, whatever this gleek thing is, it is big and yellow, I’m going to highlight these words because they seem helpful. Then it says it stopped at the corner. When I think of stop, I think of the traffic sign stop, so I think gleek is some type of transportation. It describes it as big and yellow so that type of ride must be a bus! The words I used to make meaning of gleek were right next to it. Who can raise their hand to share their thought process for this sentence? I will call on someone raising their hand. It said the big, yellow school... BUS is what it means. Those words describes gleek and those words are used to describe buses too! You got it detective! Did anyone have other words down as a clue for the meaning of gleek? I will hear other answers, if they differ from the ones shared already. Gleek is a nonsense word, but you used the words surrounding it, or words next door, as clues to find the meaning. When you read and come across an unfamiliar word, the next step is to look next door of that word and look for any words that can help you understand the meaning. In your own words, I want you to write a short definition for next-door clues. I will give them a few minutes to write down a definition. Then we will go around and share our definition. Let’s make one definition that includes the key words we all came up with. On the back of the poster board with the example sentence, I will write down a definition using the key words my group of students used to define next-door clues. I will hand out the passage that follows the sentence we worked on together. In groups, (which I assign), I want you to figure out the meaning of the rest of these words. Read the sentences. You will see that there are unfamiliar words underlined already. After you come across an underlined word, you will use next-door clues to highlight the word or words that helped you make meaning of the unfamiliar word. I want you to think aloud so you and your partner can share ideas that may not always be the same. For example, I could use the words ‘big, yellow school’ to understand that gleek is a bus but my partner may have thought of something that stops on a corner, like a city bus. It is important to try to find all words that make it helpful to make meaning of new words. Students will work with their partners to finish the worksheet. Closure Words like gleek and norjot are not used in everyday language but we got a sense of how important it is to be great context detectives to find meaning to all words! The more we understand words, the better readers we become! Together, let’s make a Next-Door clue list of steps for using next-door clues so we can refer to them again tomorrow. I will expect them to state steps like: 1. Read the whole sentence. 2. Underline unfamiliar word. 3. Highlight word(s) that are helpful next-door clues. 4. Use highlighted word to make meaning of the underlined word. We will create a group list of steps using the key words the students used in their lists. These steps will be written on a poster board for visuals. Later, I will make a bookmark with these steps for their use during reading. Accommodations Student A will have a question within his worksheet asking him a comprehension question about the passage. Student B will be paired with Student A for comprehension support. Assessment Their assessment will be an exit slip with two sentences. These words will be everyday vocabulary words that are not familiar to them. They will underline the unfamiliar word and highlight the helpful, next-door clues, just like the steps we listed. I will collect them as they return to the rest of the class. Exit Slip The monkeys' vociferous chatter made me wish I had earplugs. Meat eaters, or carnivores, are at the top of the food chain. Evaluation As my first time working with a middle grade, I will work to strengthen my classroom management. Because I do not know them well as student, I plan to set rules before starting my lesson. Rules such as: raise your hand before you speak and listen to me and others when they are speaking. Because I am working with third graders I will monitor the language used. I need to recognize that they are not kindergartners and I can use for complex language because they have more prior knowledge. With that being said, I will monitor the examples I use help them understand next door clues. As students with low reading levels, I should not use words in language or writing that they may not understand because I am evaluating their use of context values not the definition of words that are not the ones I am using for context clues. Unlike last lesson, where I had too many activities set up for my class to do, I have two sentences the group will work on after I have modeled two by thinking aloud. I want to focus on quality of using next door clues, not quantity. Lastly, I want to make sure my students know what they are learning about so I will repeat the concept of the lesson numerous times and also have they tell me numerous times. Learning Evidence The learning objective is that students will be able to use next-door clues by highlighting helpful context in a sentence to determine meaning of unfamiliar words. To achieve this objective, I gave students an exit slip with the task of using next door clues by highlighting helpful words and then write a meaning of the unfamiliar word. Main Goals Highlighted next door, helpful words to find meaning Used helpful words to make acceptable meaning to unfamiliar word Student A Highlighted next door, helpful words to find meaning Used helpful words to make acceptable meaning to unfamiliar word Student B Highlighted next door, helpful words to find meaning Used helpful words to make acceptable meaning to unfamiliar word Student C Highlighted next door, helpful words to find meaning Used helpful words to make acceptable meaning to unfamiliar word Student D Highlighted next door, helpful words to find meaning Used helpful words to make acceptable meaning to unfamiliar word ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ According to the data, all my students were able to use next-door clues. They showed me by highlighting helpful words in the sentence and find meaning for the unfamiliar word. To make the connection that words around the unfamiliar word are helpful in finding the meaning, I modeled next-door clues using nonsense words. I explained how helpful, next-door clues can help find meaning for words that are nonsense. As a group we made up a definition and list of steps for next-door clues. Then I had them apply the same skills to words they have never seen or have little idea what it means but that have real meanings. I chose two sentences as their exit slip that reinforce the idea that helpful words are around and next door to the unfamiliar word. To accomplish the task, the students read the whole sentence and highlighted words that may help understand the meaning of the unfamiliar word. For the first sentence: “The monkey’s vociferous chatter made me wish I had earplugs”, all students highlighted helpful words to understand vociferous. They all had accurate meaning of vociferous. The only concern I had with Student A was that his helpful word was monkey. During my lesson, I did explain helpful words were ones that were related to the unfamiliar word. Student A’s choice of monkey was not too helpful. He understood vociferous, but I would need to ask him how monkey helped him or if any other words were helpful that he did not highlight. For the second sentence: “Meat eaters, or carnivores, are at the top of the food chain”, all students highlighted helpful words, except Student D. Student D wrote “no idea”. I would encourage this student to reread the sentence and find any words that may seem helpful to understand carnivores. Students A, B, and C highlighted and had a meaning for carnivores. They all highlighted meat eaters as helpful words, but Student A thought that carnivores were plant eaters. For this student, it would be best to teach him comma clues, so that he understands that sometimes the text defines unfamiliar words right in the sentence. Reflection Unlike my prior lesson, I emphasized the concepts the students were learning about that lesson. Along with repeating next-door clues, I created a visual that hung behind me while I taught the lesson. Numerous times, I asked the students what we were learning about and if they didn’t remember, they would look behind me and know: next-door clues! It was great to listen students know and understand what the lesson was about and why we were learning it. I also think the examples and the passages made the lesson a success. I tried to connect student’s confusion with new vocabulary words by using nonsense words as my examples. I thought aloud and emphasized how I was also confused and had no idea the meaning of the words but how useful the words next door were to find the meaning of the unfamiliar word. Because of the small group environment, I think the students were very engaged. During modeling, I had the sentences written big on a poster board that I placed on the c-shaped table we sat at. I had them write helpful words and meanings on their loose-leaf papers. They were able to share their responses in the whole group. Working in pairs was also engaging, especially when I picked the groups according to how well they could work together and according to learning levels. Aside from working with partners, I shared my time observing and questioning the students so I was aware of their learning process and any misconceptions they may have. I made sure to communicate with each student to know how well they grasping the material. The students interacted well with each other and with me. My voice was not too loud but not soft. I think I could have been a little louder, but I think I felt comfortable with a small group that I didn’t find the need to raise my voice because they could all hear me clearly. As a personal idiosyncrasies, I would change my demeanor as in how professional I act. Like I mentioned, I was very comfortable with the small group, but because it was my first time with them I should have been a bit more strict or serious. A serious persona is needed to establish a respectful relationship with students. Now if I had taught my own students, my lax persona would have been acceptable because I have already establish a respectful relationship. The persona change would only be to have better classroom management. Because it was their first time working with me, they were a bit chatty and shared ideas irrelevant to the lesson. Those side conversations had some of them lose focus of the lesson. That is one rule I should have set from the beginning: no side conversations unless it is about next-door clues or reading. With that rule, conversations would revolve only around the lesson. The questions and responses I received from the students let me know if they were grasping the concept of next-door clues. When they told me the helpful words they highlighted, I would ask them why they choose that word and what meaning came from it. The learning objective is that students will be able to use next-door clues by highlighting helpful context in a sentence to determine meaning of unfamiliar words. To achieve this objective, I gave students an exit slip with the task of using next door clues by highlighting helpful words and then write a meaning of the unfamiliar word. As evidence, I collected all their work: the notes they made in response to the sentences I modeled, the passage they worked in groups, and their exit slip. It was important that they highlighted their helpful words so that I knew that they learned to find meaning of unfamiliar word from next-door clues and they were successful in meeting the objective. I had one student highlight helpful words, but he did not use those words to help him make an accurate meaning of the unfamiliar word. For this student, it would be best to teach him comma clues, so that he understands that sometimes the text defines unfamiliar words right in the sentence. I think I achieved my goal of having students know exactly what they are learning about and why it is important. I repeated myself a lot and they repeated the concept a lot too. I’m glad I made a visual they could clearly see and read to remind themselves what they will be learning and practicing that day. I did choose passages that they found comfortable in reading and to practice next-door clues. Again, classroom management was not perfect, but I have learned that setting all expectations and rules are important before teaching a lesson, especially with a group I am working with for the first time. I did a better job at choosing a smaller amount of activities for them to compete. The activities were developmentally appropriate for them to learn effectively. For the future, I would keep track of time better. To attain this goal, I could use a timer that can help me pace my lesson accordingly. If I timer gets distracting for my students, I could simply have reminder to watch the clock to keep track of how much more time I have left. I spent more time than I planned, it wasn’t a problem because the lesson took place outside of their classroom, but it is important for lessons to be in schedule. Another goal I would like to reach next time is to let the student know what the objective of the day is. I think I did well with letting them know what concept they will be learning, but if I told them the objective of the day, they can learn the concept with the application in mind. To achieve this goal, I may have a visual like I did with this lesson, but I will also repeat the objectives for the students to know exactly what they are expected to learn that day. If I taught a lesson like this again, I would also use more examples. For this, I would have at least three models. The first time they would just listen and I will do all the think aloud on my own. The second time they can help out a little more, such as answering one question. The last time they could help me step by step with think aloud. There can never be enough modeling!