DGD12-044 Standard Operating Procedure Consent and Treatment Purpose This standard operating procedure (SOP) outlines the process for Health Directorate staff to follow to gain valid informed consent from consumers prior to all clinical activities, treatments or procedures, with the exception of medical treatment given in an emergency to save the consumer’s life or prevent serious harm. Scope This SOP provides all Health Directorate staff with information and support to assist in meeting legal obligations to gain valid informed consent. It is to be read in association with the Health Directorate Consent and Treatment Policy and associated SOPs: Consent and Treatment: Children or Young People SOP Consent and Treatment: Capacity and Substitute Decision Makers SOP. Procedure 1. Treatment in an emergency 1.1 Where urgent medical treatment is required to save a consumer’s life or prevent serious harm and the consumer is not able to provide consent to the required treatment at the time through a lack of capacity, (e.g. because the consumer is unconscious) medical treatment can be given, provided that: The treatment is a necessity There is no written: o Health directive, or o Not For Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation Order (NFCPR) by the consumer to the contrary, and Consent cannot be sought from a substitute decision maker due to urgency of the treatment. Note: Unless consumers are unconscious or otherwise severely incapacitated, they are potentially still able to understand the treatment process and may still be able to give consent, depending on the nature of the emergency. 1.2 The circumstances that comprise the emergency and the consumer’s lack of capacity to consent must be documented in the clinical record. Doc Number DGD12-044 Version 2.0 Issued October 2012 Review Date October 2015 Area Responsible QSU Page 1 of 12 DGD12-044 1.3 In accordance with their duty of care, when health professionals identify serious or potentially life-threatening clinical issues for consumers in the community setting they MUST telephone for an ambulance to convey the consumer to hospital. The consumer must be informed that: An ambulance will be called, and Their right to refuse treatment and/or transport by the ambulance service. Refer to Section 8 - Refusal of clinical treatment and withdrawal of consent for further information. The health professional will inform the consumer’s General Practitioner and Treating Medical Officer of the request for ambulance transport. 1.4 When a consumer arrives in the operating theatre without consent If a consumer arrives in the operating theatre holding bay without valid or documented consent, the operating team must first determine whether the consumer requires emergency treatment. If emergency treatment is necessary and must be provided without delay, the consumer is deemed by law to have consented to the treatment, e.g. to save the life of the consumer. All other cases of consumers arriving in the operating theatre holding bay without valid or documented consent (where it is not an emergency): Must not proceed to the operating theatre or treatment area, and Must be reported to a relevant Clinical Nurse Manager, Medical or Surgical Director and other relevant health service administrators. Surgery must be postponed or cancelled until valid informed consent is obtained. A standard consent form must be used. Each case must also be: Documented in the consumer’s clinical record Reported as a clinical incident on the RiskMan incident management system, and Investigated in accordance with the Health Directorate RiskMan Incident Reporting Policy. 2. Written consent Written consent is where the consumer signs a document (e.g. a consent form completed on admission as an inpatient or on entering a program) to confirm their agreement to a clinical activity, treatment or procedure. Written consent is advisable for: Any healthcare which carries significant risks to the patient, and Where a consumer doesn’t have the capacity to consent and a substitute decision maker provides consent. Students and interns may not be delegated to gain consent for treatment or procedures that require written consent. Where a document relating to consent is not signed by the consumer, staff should assume that the consent has not been given (see also ‘Consumers with communication and/or cognitive difficulties’ below). Doc Number DGD12-044 Version 2.0 Issued October 2012 Review Date October 2015 Area Responsible QSU Page 2 of 12 DGD12-044 2.1 In the Health Directorate, written consent must be obtained for: Invasive or non-invasive treatments or procedures where there are significant risks or complications, e.g. surgery. Electroconvulsive therapy Unapproved therapeutic goods accessed via the Special Access Scheme Oral health procedures on children and young people under the age of 18 years Immunisations on children and young people under the age of 18 years Male and female sterilisation Medications with high risk complications or new or unusual medications, and Participation in clinical trials of a particular medicine, treatment or procedure and medical research. Written consent should also be considered for treatments or procedures that require general, intravenous sedation, or regional anaesthesia. Areas need to make their own assessments whether, in addition to those listed in Item 2.1, written consent is needed for specific clinical activities, treatments or procedures performed in their area and ensure their staff are aware of requirements. Furthermore, health professionals may choose to obtain written consent whenever they consider it important to document consent in this way. 2.2 Responsibility for obtaining written consent Where written consent is required the health professional responsible for the clinical activity, treatment or procedure is responsible for ensuring valid informed consent is obtained from the consumer, either by gaining consent themselves or delegating this responsibility. If a health professional delegates the task of gaining consent, they remain responsible for ensuring: The health professional delegated the task: o Is able to do so within their scope of practice, and o Understands and is capable of informing the consumer of all relevant information including the risks and benefits, and The consent documentation is properly completed. When the treating health professional is not the health professional who obtained consent the treating health professional must ensure consent has been gained before proceeding with any treatment or procedure. 2.3 Documenting written consent Health Directorate staff must use a form endorsed for use by the Health Directorate, signed by the consumer and incorporated into the clinical record to document written consent. Information about the process used to gain consent must be recorded as required, either on the consent form or in the clinical record and as a minimum include: Doc Number DGD12-044 Version 2.0 Issued October 2012 Review Date October 2015 Area Responsible QSU Page 3 of 12 DGD12-044 The consumer’s core identifiers (full name, date of birth and Health Directorate medical record number if available). To avoid transcription errors, a Health Directorate approved patient identification label must be used to document core identifiers where possible. Labels from facilities outside of the Health Directorate must not be used. How any communication barriers were addressed Any substitute decision maker used if the consumer doesn’t have the capacity to consent, (Refer to: Health Directorate Consent: Capacity and Substitute Decision Maker SOP for information on how to assess consumer capacity to consent) The presence of a Health Directive or revocation Space to record the relevant risks, benefits and alternatives Any tools used to support decision-making, e.g. information sheets The consumer’s specific wishes or any concerns they may have regarding the proposed clinical activity, treatment or procedure Who will perform the treatment or procedure Date and time when the consent was given, and The full name, title and signature of the health professional obtaining the consent. Abbreviations are not to be used on consent documents due to the potential for misinterpretation or misunderstanding. 3. Verbal consent Verbal consent is where the consumer orally states their agreement to a clinical activity, treatment or procedure but does not sign a document. ‘Non-verbal’ consent refers to situations where a consumer cannot or does not give signed written consent or consent by spoken word. 3.1 Procedures requiring verbal consent Verbal consent is considered adequate for treatments or procedures such as: Blood or blood products Suture of minor lacerations Insertion of chest drains, and Local anaesthetic (e.g. for a consumer needing suturing). 3.2 Responsibility for obtaining verbal consent If verbal consent is adequate for the treatment or procedure it is the responsibility of the health professional performing the treatment or procedure to ensure valid informed consent is obtained and documented in the clinical record. Students and Allied Health Assistants Verbal consent must be sought from the consumer for any clinical activity, treatment or procedure to be undertaken by a student health professional or Allied Health Assistant (AHA). The supervisor of the student is responsible for ensuring valid informed consent is obtained and recorded in the clinical record. Doc Number DGD12-044 Version 2.0 Issued October 2012 Review Date October 2015 Area Responsible QSU Page 4 of 12 DGD12-044 3.3 Documenting verbal consent Information about the process of obtaining consent must be documented in the clinical record and should include as a minimum the points listed in Item 2.3. However, the consumer does not need to sign a document, e.g. a consent form. 4. Implied consent Implied consent is another type of consent where the consumer indicates their agreement through their actions or by cooperating with the health professional’s instructions. For example when a consumer: Extends their arm to provide a routine blood sample for testing Takes and swallows medication that is provided, or Attends an appointment for the purpose of receiving information or advice regarding management of their condition. Implied consent is adequate for routine non-invasive procedures and is not required to be documented in the clinical record. 5. Obtaining single consent for multiple procedures or treatment programs Where a planned program of treatment involves a number of stages or treatments, a single consent process, written or verbal as appropriate, may be followed. In this situation, the health professional is to outline the elements of the program, including the consequences of withdrawal at a future date and the right of the consumer to do so, and document it in the clinical record. If any aspects of the treatment program change, additional written or verbal consent is required. 6. Communication and consent Consumers must be able to understand the information likely to influence their decision about whether to consent to health care or not. The amount of information or time required to gain informed consent will vary according to the consumer and their individual needs. The National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC) Guidelines for Medical Practitioners on Providing Information to Patients 2004 and Communicating with Patients: Advice for Medical Practitioners provide valuable resources for staff. The guidelines are available at www.nhrmc.gov.au. 6.1 Culturally and linguistically diverse consumers Staff should be aware of the consumer’s cultural and linguistic background so that information can be provided in a form and manner that is understood. Ways to achieve this may include: Being aware of different culture’s ways of engaging in the health system Contacting the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Liaison Service for advice and support as required Doc Number DGD12-044 Version 2.0 Issued October 2012 Review Date October 2015 Area Responsible QSU Page 5 of 12 DGD12-044 Use of an interpreter if English is not the consumer’s first language. Every attempt should be made to obtain an accredited interpreter before using family or friends to interpret. Interpreters must sign the relevant request or consent form to identify that they have acted as an interpreter for the consumer during the consent process (verbal or written), and Using non-verbal tools, e.g. use of communication boards, to facilitate the consumer’s understanding. 6.2 Consumers with communication and or/cognitive difficulties Consumers who rely on non-verbal means of communication must be given every opportunity to express their consent decision. The standard consent documentation may be used to acknowledge written consent by writing ‘Consumer unable to sign’ in the space for the signature, and signed by the health professional and a witness. When a consumer cannot communicate with staff using verbal or non-verbal means, for health professionals to be sure valid informed consent can be gained, the substitute decision making process should be followed. The reasons why the consumer cannot provide consent must be documented in the clinical record. Refer to: Health Directorate Consent to Treatment: Capacity and Substitute Decision Maker SOP. 6.3 Key points to communicate When obtaining consent it is necessary to communicate the following key points: The consumer’s rights, for example: Consumers have the right to refuse treatment, and withdraw their consent at any time. The diagnosis or condition to be treated, for example: The nature and seriousness of the consumer’s condition. Specifics of the treatment, for example: What the proposed treatment or procedure involves, and Who will perform the treatment or procedure. Possible risks and benefits, for example: The expected benefits (including the possibility the benefit may not be achieved) Anticipated recovery implications Common side effects and related risks Any significant long term physical, emotional, mental, social, sexual or other expected effects, and The time and cost involved including any out‐of‐pocket expenses, if appropriate. Uncertainty, for example: The degree of uncertainty of the diagnosis and any therapeutic outcomes, and Whether the treatment or procedure is conventional or experimental. Doc Number DGD12-044 Version 2.0 Issued October 2012 Review Date October 2015 Area Responsible QSU Page 6 of 12 DGD12-044 Alternative courses of action, for example: Other options for diagnosis and treatment, and The likely outcome of not having the proposed treatment or procedure, or of not having any treatment or procedure at all. Financial information including: The cost of the treatment or procedure, and any out of pocket expenses the consumer will incur. In order to make an informed decision, consumers must be given sufficient time to consider and understand the information and the implications of their decision. Consumers shouldn’t feel rushed into any decision and should be given the opportunity to contact staff when they feel they have arrived at an appropriate decision. 6.4 Pre-prepared information Where available, health professionals may provide appropriate written or audiovisual information resource materials to supplement their discussion of the benefits and risks of a proposed treatment or procedure. Any information resources developed for use must be appropriately endorsed to ensure accuracy and relevance to consumer needs. Appropriate processes should be maintained to ensure resources are continually reviewed and updated to ensure currency. Consumers need to be provided with the opportunity to ask questions after they have looked at any information resource materials provided. 6.5 Responding to, and documenting the consumer’s concerns Where necessary health professionals need to clarify information and respond to consumer concerns. Where a consumer raises concerns about adverse outcomes, a record of the discussions held and the decision reached should be fully documented in the clinical record. 7. When a consumer refuses information Health professionals have a legal duty to disclose information to the consumer. However, common law recognises that information need not be given where doing so would be damaging to a consumer’s physical or mental health. Information regarding a treatment or procedure may not be provided in circumstances when: A consumer expressly asks not to be given information, e.g. doesn’t want to see graphic pictures or hear explicit detail. Consumers have the right to say they don’t want to receive information, or A health professional judges, and is able to justify, that disclosure may harm the consumer. Doc Number DGD12-044 Version 2.0 Issued October 2012 Review Date October 2015 Area Responsible QSU Page 7 of 12 DGD12-044 Any decision to withhold information, whether at the consumer’s request or the health practitioner’s judgement must be carefully considered and the reasons clearly documented in the clinical record. 8. Refusal of clinical treatment and withdrawal of consent 8.1 A consumer can refuse all or part of any care and may withdraw previously given consent at any time, even when this decision differs from health professional recommendations and where the decision to decline care may result in decline in their health or their death. In this situation the health professional must discuss the implications of not receiving the recommended care with the consumer to ensure the consumer has all the relevant information to make a considered decision. Refusal may be written, verbal or by any form of communication possible This decision must be documented in the clinical record by the treating health professional and confirmed in writing by a second health professional If there is any concern about the capacity of the consumer to give valid consent Refer to: Health Directorate Consent to Treatment: Capacity and Substitute Decision Maker SOP. 8.2 With consideration of the consumer’s wishes the plan of recommended care should be revised and consumer consent obtained. 8.3 Where the consumer continues to refuse recommended care the issue must be reported and escalated through line management. With advice from clinical and legal experts as necessary, the Health Directorate Executive will provide direction to the relevant health professionals and treating teams regarding any further actions to be taken. Consumers should be encouraged to develop an Advance Care Plan to document their wishes about future health care. Refer to SOP: Consent and Treatment: Capacity and Substitute Decision Maker for further information. 8.4 The consumer’s General Practitioner and Treating Medical Officer must be kept informed at all times. Evaluation Outcome Measures Consumers provide valid informed consent wherever it is required. All forms used to document written consent are endorsed for use by the Health Directorate and comply with this policy and associated SOPs. Method Documentation of consent audits overseen by the Governance Health Service Standard Group. Related Legislation, Policies and Standards Doc Number DGD12-044 Version 2.0 Issued October 2012 Review Date October 2015 Area Responsible QSU Page 8 of 12 DGD12-044 Legislation Age of Majority Act 1974 Children and Young People Act 2008 Civil Law (Wrongs) Act 2002 Guardianship and Management of Property Act 1991 Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (ACT) Act 2010 Health Records (Privacy and Access) Act 1997 Health Regulation (Maternal Health Information) Act 1998 Medical Treatment (Health Directions) Act 2006 Medicare Australia Act 2005 Mental Health (Treatment and Care) Act 1994 Powers of Attorney Act 2006 Public Advocate Act 2005 Road Transport (Alcohol and Drugs) Act 1977 Transplantation and Anatomy Act 1978 (2.2, 2.3, 2.5) Policy Clinical Record Management Policy Clinical Record Documentation SOP Release or Sharing of Clinical Records or Personal Health Information SOP Consent and Treatment Policy Consent and Treatment: Children or Young People SOP Consent and Treatment: Capacity and Substitute Decision Makers SOP Guidelines for Assessment of Decision Making Capacity by ACRS Psychologists SOP Consumer and Carer Participation Framework Consumer Feedback Standards: Listening and Learning Patient Identification: Correct Patient, Correct Site, Correct Procedure Policy Patient Identification: Correct Patient, Correct Site, Correct Procedure SOP Standards ACHS EQuIP 5: 1.1 Consumers/patients are provided with high quality care throughout the care delivery process. 1.1.3 Consumers/patients are informed of the consent process, and they understand and provide consent for their health care. 1.6 The governing body is committed to consumer participation. 1.6.2 Consumers/patients are informed of their rights and responsibilities. 3.1.5 Documented corporate and clinical policies and procedures assist the organisation to provide quality, safe health care. National Safety and Quality Health Service (NSQHS) Standards: Governance for Safety and Quality in Health Service Organisations Partnering with Consumers Patient Identification and Procedure Matching Doc Number DGD12-044 Version 2.0 Issued October 2012 Review Date October 2015 Area Responsible QSU Page 9 of 12 DGD12-044 Definition of Terms Capacity The term capacity is used in this document to mean a person is capable of: Understanding the nature and effect of decisions about consent and communicating the understanding verbally or non-verbally Freely and voluntarily making decisions about consent Communicating the decisions verbally or non-verbally, and Retaining the information, their decision and their consent. The type of assessment required to determine someone’s capacity will vary depending on the type of decision being made. Clinical Activity Clinical activities improve, maintain or assess the health of a person in a clinical situation and may include invasive and non-invasive procedures (including those performed in settings other than the operating room). Some examples are: • Invasive - taking a specimen of blood - giving medication via an intravenous, intramuscular or subcutaneous route - inserting intravenous access, or - performing a surgical procedure, including a procedure performed in medical imaging. • Non-invasive - interventions such as evaluating, advising, planning (E.g. dietary education, physiotherapy assessment, crisis intervention, bereavement counselling, a procedure in medical imaging) and giving medication. Common law (Also known as case law) Law developed by judges through decisions of courts/tribunals rather than through legislation. Consumer In this document the term ‘consumer’ refers to patients, consumers and clients under the care of the Health Directorate. Health Directive – ACT A Health Directive contains instructions that consent to, or refuse, specified medical treatment or treatment which may occur in the future. Health Directives become effective in situations where the consumer doesn’t have the capacity to make health care decisions for themselves. A Health directive is legally binding and must be followed. It doesn’t apply where the consumer has or regains capacity to consent. (Medical Treatment (Health Directions) Act 2006) Health Professional Doc Number DGD12-044 Version 2.0 Issued October 2012 Review Date October 2015 Area Responsible QSU Page 10 of 12 DGD12-044 There are two Acts which define ‘health professionals’: the Medical Treatment (Health Directions) Act 2006 (ACT) and the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (ACT) Act 2010. For the purpose of this document a ‘health professional’ includes all doctors, dentists, nurses and allied health professionals engaged the Health Directorate to care for consumers. Informed consent A person gives consent based upon an appreciation and understanding of the facts and implications of an action. The person must be given the relevant information and have the capacity to understand it. Valid consent is based on the fundamental legal principle that the law protects the integrity and autonomy of the person. Consent for a procedure or treatment is valid if: The consumer has the capacity to give consent Full information on risks, benefits and alternatives has been provided and understood, with understanding demonstrated The consent is given freely, and The consent is specific to the procedure. Substitute Decision Maker Where it has been identified that an adult consumer does not have the decision-making capacity to provide consent to treatment or procedures themselves the following substitute decision makers can provide consent: Health Attorney The Attorney, under an Enduring Power of Attorney Guardian, if approved Public Advocate of the ACT if appointed guardian, and the Chief Psychiatrist or Community Care Coordinator (where there are issues relating to mental health or mental dysfunction and the consumer is under a Mental Health Order). Treatment Medical or surgical management of a consumer (including any medical or surgical procedure, operation, examination and any prophylactic, palliative or rehabilitative care) normally carried out by, or under the supervision of a Health Professional. Treating medical officer Medical officer who is delegated responsibility for all or part of the care of a consumer. The treating medical officer may be a junior medical officer or senior medical officer and may not be the admitting senior medical officer. Treating Team The treating team includes all service providers (located within, or external to the ACT) who provide a service for the ACT Government Health Directorate involved in diagnosis, care or treatment for the purpose of improving or maintaining the consumer’s health for a particular episode of care (Health Records (Privacy and Access) Act 1997). Doc Number DGD12-044 Version 2.0 Issued October 2012 Review Date October 2015 Area Responsible QSU Page 11 of 12 DGD12-044 References Guidelines for Health Care Professionals Including Medical Practitioners and Dentists. (1999) Office of the Public Advocate of the ACT Australian Capital Territory Government Informed Consent for Health Care Treatment. (1999). Office of the Public Advocate of the ACT. Australian Capital Territory Government Guide to Informed Decision-making in Healthcare. (2011) Queensland Health. Queensland Government Guidelines for Medical Practitioners on Providing Information to Patients. (2004) National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC) (www. nhmrc.gov.au) Associated SOPs Consent and Treatment: Children or Young People SOP Consent and Treatment: Capacity and Substitute Decision Makers SOP Disclaimer: This document has been developed by Health Directorate, specifically for its own use. Use of this document and any reliance on the information contained therein by any third party is at his or her own risk and Health Directorate assumes no responsibility whatsoever. Doc Number DGD12-044 Version 2.0 Issued October 2012 Review Date October 2015 Area Responsible QSU Page 12 of 12