The little handbook of disaster and climate change networked governance structure in Vanuatu Astrid Vachette1 A. Vachette, 2015 1 PhD Candidate at the Centre for Disaster Studies, James Cook University, Australia. This handbook gives a brief overview of a part of Vachette’s PhD research. It includes a description of the Vanuatu DRR and CCA governance system existing in 2015, and reflects the point of view of 90 participants in a survey conducted in 2014. This research was funded by the Centre for Disaster Studies of James Cook University and Vanuatu SPC/GIZ Coping with Climate Change in the Pacific Island Region program, with the endorsement of the National Advisory Board on Climate Change and Disaster Risk Reduction. Map on cover: Social Networking between 85 organisations working on Disaster and Climate Change related projects in Vanuatu How to cite this document: Vachette, A. 2015. The Little Handbook of Disaster and Climate Change Networked Governance in Vanuatu. Centre for Disaster Studies of James Cook University, Secretariat of the Pacific Community (SPC) & Deutsche Gesellshaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit GmbH (GIZ). Acknowledgements: The author would like to particularly thank the Vanuatu NAB/PMU, Oxfam Vanuatu, and Vanuatu SPC/GIZ CCCPIR for their great input in this study. Foreword Disaster and climate change governance of Vanuatu is a complex system, which has recently been structured to better promote cooperation. The legal and institutional system is described and mapped in several documents, some of them being referenced at the end of this handbook. This handbook’s purpose is not to give a comprehensive description of the disaster and climate change governance structure; it aims to start building understanding of the role and position of key networks supporting institutional cooperation. The data provided in this handbook are to be utilized as sources of information on forums where stakeholders may be able to meet various stakeholders currently involved in disaster and climate change resilience building in Vanuatu. These forums are critical resources: to get information on what is happening in the country in specific sectors, to build collaborative relations with other experts already involved in the country, to share information, knowledge and resources, to avoid duplications and identify niches, and to participate in discussions and decision-making. All these networks cover a wide range of sectors, and all have specific social capital, cooperation mechanisms and an understanding of the governance system from their own perspective; these inputs are critical to build effective and efficient projects. Background snapshot: an intense inclusive and integrated networked system Figures 1 and 2 map the social networking process between 260 stakeholders working in Vanuatu on disaster risk and/or climate change projects (For more detailed information CF A. Vachette, 2014). Figure 1. Interaction between different types of organizations Figure 1 shows the cooperation pathways that exist among the different types of organization (Government agencies, NGOs and Red Cross Societies, Civil Society, Regional and United Nations Organizations, Private sector, International donors and Tertiary Education and Research Institutes – TERI). Each node (map dot) is a stakeholder and each tie (map line) is showing a relationship between two stakeholders. Vanuatu DRR and CCA Governance is characterized by discussions and decision-making for CCA, DRR and DRM that are supported by a strong bilateral influence of government and non-government stakeholders’ collaboration. The inclusiveness of non-government actors in the policy process (from discussions to implementation) is widely recognized on the legal and institutional levels. The involvement of the private sector is slowly increasing, more specifically for the telecommunications and tourism. Connections are also very strong in terms of on-ground, project level, collaboration. Connections among governmental agencies and NGO with Regional and UN organizations, donors and TERI are also well defined. This means that discussions and decision-making are well supported by international and regional input (with the Regional and UN organizations), research advancements (with the TERI), and funding opportunities (with the donors). Figure 2. Interaction between different sectors Figure 2 shows a very strong cross-sectoral networking in Vanuatu in discussions, policy-making and project implementation in the domains of DRR and CCA. The networks system is particularly characterized by very strong connections between ‘Community Development’, ‘Climate Change Adaptation’, ‘Disaster Risk Reduction and Management’ and ‘Policy and Public Administration’ with each other and with the rest of the network. Results have shown that policy stakeholders are leading an all-inclusive and all-integrated approach. Several critical domains remain slightly disconnected from the rest of the network, despite their critical role in CCA and DRR in Vanuatu: Traditional Culture and Knowledge, Energy and Health. Capacities in Protection of People with Disabilities are inexistent in the perceived network for CCA and DRR. Networked Governance System Key cooperative bodies Following are short descriptions of key cooperative bodies supporting the disaster and climate change networked governance structure in Vanuatu: NAB: The National Advisory Board on Climate Change and Disaster Risk Reduction (NAB) is the focal point for all matters related to DRR and CCA in the country. This committee, established in 2012, is co-chaired by the NDMO (National Disaster Management Office) and the VMGD (Vanuatu Meteorology and Geo-Hazards Department), and is composed of the Directors-General the line Ministries linked to CCA and DRR matters and representatives of key non-government actors. The NAB develops and endorses all national policies, strategies and positions on DRR and CCA. Programs, projects and initiatives related to DRR and CCA are to be endorsed by the NAB to be conducted in the country. Given its position, the NAB is a critical focal point to get and disseminate disaster and climate change information, and to support coordination. CCDRR/PMU: The Project Management Unit (CCDRR PMU) supports the NAB agenda by giving technical advice on the development and implementation of national regulations, positions and endorsed programs. The NAB/PMU is in charge of supervising that all CCA and DRR projects are well developed and implemented, through: o Monitoring and Evaluation of all organizations, which projects have been endorsed by the NAB. o Endorsement process of projects, to avoid duplication and stimulate cooperation between organizations involved in similar projects o Endorsement process of Information, Education and Communication (EIC) materials, to ensure harmonization, context adaptation and dissemination of resources on DRR and CCA VHT: The Vanuatu Humanitarian Team (VHT) is a non-government network, loosely based on the UN Humanitarian Cluster approach, composed of humanitarian organizations involved in disaster risk management. The difficult management of both cyclones Vania and Atu in 2011 highlighted the great need for more coordination and cooperation between all agencies, and triggered the discussion around the need for a flexible cooperative body. The VHT was therefore established late 2011 to support the NDMO in his mandated authority to coordinate humanitarian aid and overlook services delivery during response and recovery. The VHT is in constant progress, from 10 members in 2011 to around 50 in 2014; bringing together national government (ex. the NAB), national nongovernment (ex. Vanuatu Family Health), INGOs (ex. Care International), Red Cross societies (ex. Vanuatu Red Cross), and donors (ex. UNICEF). The main goal of the VHT is to limit time and resources waste during disaster management operations, as well as to ensure appropriate assistance for the affected communities. To achieve these objectives, the VHT and the NDMO work together in implementing preparedness activities in Port Vila and the provinces, and in promoting cross-sectoral knowledge sharing. The VHT has proved its potential for cooperation support during cyclones Jasmine (2012), Lusi (2014) and Pam (2015). VCAN: The Vanuatu Climate Action Network (VCAN), established in 2012, (named Vanuatu Climate Adaptation Network until 2014) aims to bring together all international, regional, national and local NGOs involved in climate change resilience building projects in Vanuatu. The main goal of VCAN is to ensure coordination, information and knowledge sharing, as well as cooperation towards resilience building of communities to climate change in Vanuatu. The VCAN objectives are to increase resilience through better adaptability to climate change, more efficient decision-making and more adapted policy development. In order to achieve this, VCAN facilitates lessons sharing and good practice between more than 20 non-government and government stakeholders that participate to meetings, which happen monthly or as needed. The involvement of government stakeholders in VCAN has been very a significant support in the inclusiveness process. As VCAN motivates NGOs to communicate more with the NAB, PMU and donors inviting them at meetings, there is an increasingly awareness of roles between government agencies and NGOs and a better understanding of each other functioning. In order to promote even better cooperation and coordination, the VHT and VCAN decided to have common meetings with each other and with the Climate Change and Disaster Risk Reduction Working Group (CCDRR WG). VANGO: The Vanuatu Association of NGOs (VANGO) is an umbrella organization established in 1991, and currently counts around 45 NGO members, and covers more than 90 affiliated civil societies. In 2004, VANGO and the Vanuatu government signed a Memorandum of Understanding, under which, VANGO members have an easier access to donors funding, such as the European Union Non State Actors program. Bringing together a large number of the national and local NGOs, and linking the national with the provincial and local levels, VANGO is considered as a great asset for government/non-government cooperation, as well as for raising the voice of local networks. VANGO is part of the Vatu Mauri Consortium, which is a crucial focal point to link with small local associations and NGOs in the provinces. Networked governance the key cooperative bodies within the whole disaster and climate change governance system Figures 3, 4 and 5 are simplified diagrams illustrating the ties linking the key cooperative bodies presented above within the whole disaster governance system of Vanuatu. This aims to give a snapshot of pathways enabled by the central positions of these government and non-government cooperative bodies. Figure 3. Disaster and Climate Change Governance structure Figures 3 presents the general structure of disaster and climate change governance in Vanuatu, at the local, provincial and national levels, bringing together key government and non-government bodies. Figure 4. NAB focused network Figure 4 presents the networking process within the NAB. All line ministries of Vanuatu are members of the NAB, and participate in the NAB meetings as a committee to proceed with endorsements. A change of cochair of the NAB is being discussed, which might position the DGs of the Ministry of Climate Change and Prime Minister Office as replacement of the DGs of the NDMO and VMGD. The CCDRR NAB/PMU is acting as current secretariat of the NAB, in addition to its project management tasks. A separated unit is in process to be established as NAB secretariat. The needed composition of the future secretariat was discussed by a task force made of government and non-government members. Figure 5. Vanuatu Humanitarian Team focused network Sectoral Networks involved in the Vanuatu Disaster and Climate Change Governance System Vanuatu benefits from the existence of many sectoral smaller networks, more or less formal and active. These satellite sectoral networks are real assets to allow people from the same sectors or domains of expertise to share information and open opportunities for collaboration. Although some of these sectoral networks are not well positioned in the whole disaster and climate change governance system to directly influence decision-making, they are all linked through their members to the NAB, VHT, VCAN and/or VANGO, which means that they all have established pathways to disseminate their information, discussion conclusions and positions. Following is a non-exhaustive list of the networks acting in Vanuatu. Most of these networks are nationally based; others are regional and/or virtual. The contacts provided are leaders or members of the networks, who will be able to give detailed information on the meeting schedule and current discussions. NETWORK CONTACT CCDRR focused government committees National Advisory Board on Climate Change and Disaster Risk NAB Secretariat Reduction (NAB) CCDRR PMU National Disaster Committee (NDC) NDMO National Climate Change Committee (NCCC) NDMO National Disaster Recovery Committee (NDRC) NDMO Provincial Disaster and Climate Change Committee (PDC) Provincial councils Area Council Disaster Climate Change Committee (ACDCCC) Provincial councils Municipal Disaster Climate Change Committee (MDCCC) Provincial councils Community Disaster Climate Change Committee (CDC) Provincial councils Disaster Management focused networks Vanuatu Humanitarian Team (VHT) Oxfam Logistic cluster NDMO Food security Cluster Ministry of Agriculture Shelter Cluster Public Works Department WASH Cluster Department of Rural Water Supply Gender and Protection Cluster Ministry of Justice Health Cluster Ministry of Health Education Cluster Ministry of Education Pacific Humanitarian Team (PHT) UN OCHA FRANZ agreement DFAT NZFAT French Embassy Pacific Disaster Risk Management Partnership Network SPC Meteo- and Geo-hazards focused Vanuatu Rainfall Network VMGD National Seismic and Volcanic Monitoring Network VMGD Cooperative Tsunami Warning Systems for Vanuatu and New VMGD Caledonia Melanesian Volcano Network (MVN) VMGD Climate Change focused Vanuatu Climate Action Network (VCAN) Oxfam Vanuatu NGO Climate Change Adaptation Consortium Oxfam 350 Vanuatu SPC/GIZ National Youth Symposium on Climate Change SPC/GIZ Vanuatu Environment Advocacy Network (VEAN) VEAN National REDD + Technical Committee Department of Forestry Development Partners for Climate Change UN Habitat Climate Action Network Pacific Islands (PICAN) Oxfam Vanuatu Asia Pacific Adaptation Network (APAN) APAN Cities and Climate Change Initiatives for Asia Pacific UN Habitat Pacific Climate Change Roundtable SPREP General cooperative resilience building focused Vanuatu Association of NGO (VANGO) VANGO Education Partner Group Save the Children Vatu Mauri Consortium VANGO/VCC/VPAC Pacific Local Government Association NZFAT Pacific Solution Exchange (PSE) SPC Small Aid Donor Committee UNDP Thursday NGO Kava National NGOs and INGOs Program Quality Network Oxfam Alliance of Small Island States (AOSIS) SPREP Vanuatu Christian Council (VCC) VCC Australian Volunteers Network Australian Red Cross Vulnerable groups focused networks Vanuatu Civil Society Disability Network Oxfam Vanuatu Youth Livelihoods Network Oxfam Gender Partner Group CARE International Permanent Disaster and Climate Change Working Groups Climate Change Disaster Risk Reduction Working Group (CCDRR NDMO WG) / IEC WG PMU Red Cross Community Based Disaster Risk Reduction Standardization NDMO Working Group (CBDRR WG) COP Working Group NAB/PMU Foreign Affairs Traditional Knowledge Working Group VMGD (Climate division) Samples of Acronyms used in Vanuatu Disaster Plans and Policies Acronym Signification ADCCC Area Council Disaster Climate Change Committee CBDRR WG Community Based Disaster Risk Reduction Standardization Working Group CAAV Civil Aviation Authority of Vanuatu CBO Community Based Organizations CCA Climate Change Adaptation CCDRR WG Climate Change Disaster Risk Reduction Working Group CDC or CDCCC Community Disaster Climate Change Committee COM Council of Ministers DARD Department of Agriculture and Rural Development DLA Department of Local Authorities DRR Disaster Risk Reduction DSPPAC Department of Strategic Planning, Programming and Aid Coordination EM Emergency Management FRANZ Agreement between France, Australia and New Zealand GLA Governance, Leadership and Advocacy Program M&E Monitoring and Evaluation MCC Ministry of Climate Change, Meteorology, Geo-Hazards, Environment, Energy and Disaster Management MDCCC Municipal Disaster Climate Change Committee MVN Melanesian Volcano Network NAB National Advisory Board on Climate Change and Disaster Risk Reduction NAP National Action Plan NAPA National Adaptation Plan of Action NCCC National Climate Change Committee NDC National Disaster Committee NDMO National Disaster Management Office NDRC National Disaster Recovery Committee NGO Non-governmental Organisation PAA Priorities and Action Agenda PDC or PDCCC Provincial Disaster and Climate Change Committee or PDMCC PHT Pacific Humanitarian Team PICAN Climate Action Network Pacific Islands PMD Ports and Marine Department PMO Prime Minister Office PMU Project Management Unit PQN Program Quality Network PWD Public Works Department REDD Reducing emissions from deforestation and forest degradation in developing countries TAC Technical Advisory Commission TK WG Traditional Knowledge Working Group VANGO Vanuatu Association of Non-Governmental Organisations VCAN Vanuatu Climate Action Network VCC Vanuatu Council of Churches VEAN Vanuatu Environment Advocacy Network VHT Vanuatu Humanitarian Team VMGD Vanuatu Meteorology and Geo-Hazards Department VRN Vanuatu Rainfall Network WASH Water, Sanitation and Hygiene Further readings