64 Lye Valley Oxford OX3 7ER 17th February 2014 Dear Google, I am writing regarding an ongoing matter regarding LIBELLOUS CONTENT ON BLOGS: I request that the following three sites be *permanently* removed, for several reasons www.djh-graphics.blogspot.com www.djh-graphics.blogspot.co.uk http://daniel-hart-commits-crimes-in-secret.blogspot.co.uk 1) The websites are obviously hateful, malicious and damaging. The allegations made on the above blogs have no basis in fact. Their content, however, is defamatory against my person. 2) Impersonation / Intellectual Property. There is a deliberate, and effective attempt to discredit and damage me through the use of my company name – the same for my actual name which has been recently brought to my attention by no less than three individuals. 3) Intellectual Property Unauthorised use of my artwork – a life drawing that has been stolen from a flickr account and posted there. Although the legal team I consulted felt I had a very strong case, unfortunately I am in no position to spend money on this. What I can say is that, several times in the past few months, I have been asked about it – from business contacts as well as friends and dates, because, obviously, people google my name and it comes up with this, and there will be years of unprovable damage as a result. I request that you to take this matter seriously and spare me future embarrassments and subsequent loss of income. I have since changed my company name to www.inspiragraphics.com but it is to no avail. I received yet another response from your “legal team” two days ago (see at bottom*), which is identical to the correspondence I have had in years past. FULL CORRESPONDENCE SUBMITTED BY ME, DANIEL JAMES HART, TO WILLIAMS, POWELL & ASSOCIATES (INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY LEGAL FIRM): ************** Having extensively researched various suitable lawyers, I am writing to seek legal advice regarding a solution to online defamation. My hope is to have the single pages listed removed; I have no intention to sue or seek damages, although I request your advice on the matter. I must cap legal expenses, so this enquiry must also serve as a quote based on your expertise and experience. To give a little context, it concerns a woman (Felicity Jane Lowde) who was convicted for harassment – three times since about 1998, and that’s only to my knowledge. The last time was in 2006, for six months, at Holloway Prison, at which I was present at Bow Magistrates Court and saw her for the first time in my life – she was sentenced and led away. Thankfully, I haven’t experienced any escalation or change of trouble since then. But it remains a problem. Although I am only writing about myself, I’d like it clear that I am one of well over 20 other individuals who became the subject of her “hate blogs” (many others still exist – see below) – whilst it was incredibly distressing for me, it was reported by many national newspapers, and I had the full support of senior people at Oxford Police Station. I should also say here that their own requests to Google went unaided, which angers and upsets me; I can only imagine what even more serious cases must entail. Despite Google having removed many offending blogs relating to her at the time, they refuse to remove the ones that really matter for me – those that reference my business, a search of which has seen it rise from around page 4 to number 2, page 1, despite inactivity to the blog/page. Their original argument was that they could not prove “authorship” unlike the other blogs, but I argued that it didn’t matter who wrote it – the content was clearly unprovable (rapist /murderer) and quite blatantly defamatory. They then pointed me to the Blogger terms and told me to take it up with the “author”. I cannot and will not correspond with the subject, who is “of no fixed address” as far as anyone knows, as well as being mentally ill and dangerous. I’m frightened she may become aware of their removal, although I accept that possibility. Ultimately, it is important that she not be contacted, or in any way know beyond her own checking, because I doubt she would even realise. My name as you know, is “Daniel Hart” and my web design business, “djh-graphics” – URL being www.djh-graphics.com. I only want these three sites to be removed. www.djh-graphics.blogspot.com www.djh-graphics.blogspot.co.uk http://daniel-hart-commits-crimes-in-secret.blogspot.co.uk However, if given your expertise, you feel that anything else might be relevant (such as other websites that will affect either/both my name “Daniel Hart” or business “djh-graphics” then please let me know. I’d welcome that advice - but again, must ask that your fee be capped dependent on your impression of my case. I believe Google should have dealt with it themselves, given their immediate response to other definable “hate blogs” that might be say, anti-semitic, racist, homophobic and so on. I cannot see how this is different. Let alone use of my artwork, company name and so on. Let alone the court order. So many angles I’m asking your expertise on. I even agreed to give an interview to Radio 1 Xtra at my house, such was the media interest. This was spliced with various other “cyber-issues” and is terribly tacky, but I don’t feel I was misrepresented. www.djh-graphics.com/1xtra3.mp3 - interview 10m 15s in. I could provide testimonials (that of Colin Brooker, an Oxford Police Superintendent who is familiar with the matter) –here is a Court Document. Although the Court conditions are recently expired, the sites/blogs (a page, really - untouched since 2006 and still hosted by Blogger (owned by Google), remain extant. The page-rank has only risen up the charts since then, as I said – making number two the kind of ranking I cannot prove has affected my business – but feel it will have done. So here’s one of my many (I’d estimate about ten) fruitless emails to Blogger / Google – not to mention online applications via Blogger. ********** Dear Google / Blogger Team, This relates to two severely damaging "blogger" sites that have been set up that are still damaging my reputation, despite them being dormant since 2006. I had a response relating to this distressing issue back in May, but feel it was not correctly addressed. See below. I find it very hard to write this, and try to ignore it as much as possible - but the fact is, two extremely nasty blogs exist that remain highly ranked in google. I have attempted to explain why this is a problem before, but will explain again. Here are the two blogs in question http://daniel-hart-commits-crimes-in-secret.blogspot.co.uk (note DANIELHARTMURDERQUESTION in "about me") http://djh-graphics.blogspot.co.uk AND http://djh-graphics.blogspot.com - using my company name. (note DanielHartknownpschostalker in "About me") My arguments are as follows 1) This is clearly malicious - defamatory and entirely unfounded. 2) She is making unauthorised use of my company name (djh-graphics) and artwork. 3) Crucially, she is a known, dangerous serial harasser, who has been imprisoned three times for harassment, and with certain orders placed against her (18 separate ASBOS and a restraining order), as my attached court order document will illustrate (the five year term covers the period under which these blogs have existed) Court Order is http://www.djh-graphics.com/court-doc.jpg 4) As said, this is damaging my business, because number 2 in a google search for "djh-graphics" displays this blog. 5) I had numerous blogs removed around 2007 (about 8?) that were also related to me, by the same author - so why not these two after so long? Here are articles that relate to her, if any further information is required http://www.heraldseries.co.uk/news/1982342.cyberstalker_owes_us_money/ http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-461450/Bloggers-help-track-cyberstalker-harassed-7-7survivor.html http://www.oxfordmail.co.uk/news/1433245.internet_hunt_for_cyber_stalker/ http://www.theregister.co.uk/2007/06/08/cyberstalker_in_custody/ http://www.metro.co.uk/news/55079-prison-for-july-7-survivor-s-stalker http://www.oxfordmail.co.uk/news/1456078.cyberstalker_caught/ http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/london/6249594.stm http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-466761/Raped-blown--Then-stalked-maniac--remarkable-7-7survivor-all.html ************** Here are just a few other "hate" blogs all set up by her, that still exist - again, just for context or background checks - but I am sure that the subjects would be glad of their removal too. http://rachel-north-liar-and-charletane.blogspot.co.uk/ http://clairwil-goes-nuts-again.blogspot.co.uk/ http://rachel-north-london-vendetta-queen.blogspot.co.uk/ http://tosin-vixen-ugly-malicious-liar.blogspot.co.uk/ http://philip-hutchinson-liar-and-thief.blogspot.co.uk/ http://alan-sharp-ripperologist-loser-liar.blogspot.co.uk/ http://bob-hinton-corrupt-magistrate.blogspot.co.uk/ http://stan-russo-author-and-maniac.blogspot.co.uk/ I have had this problem for so many years now, and it reduces me to tears whenever I attempt to confront it. I want to know what you are going to do about it. Please, take action and remove them for the benefit of myself and the business I am attempting to run. Regards, Daniel Hart www.djh-graphics.com ----------End of Google email. Their response, most recently September 2012 (after about five such emails) was - Re: [#1016349089] FWD: [0-56028331] Fwd: Re: Your Request to Google Hello, Thanks for reaching out to us. If you believe you have found defamatory content on one of Google's products, please follow the prompts at this page to submit your request: www.google.com/support/go/legal. Thank you for your cooperation in this matter. Regards, The Google Team **** END OF SUBMISSION BY ME, DANIEL JAMES HART, TO WILLIAMS, POWELL & ASSOCIATES (LEGAL FIRM) Your due consideration and urgent attention to my request to have these damaging websites removed would be much appreciated. Regards, and many thanks, Daniel Hart www.inspiragraphics.com FORMERLY www.djh-graphics.com 07739 725710 01865 751426 MOST RECENT REPLY FROM GOOGLE, 14th FEBRUARY 2014. * Hello, Thanks for reaching out to us. In order to evaluate your complaint for content removal, we will require additional information. For the URL(s) in question, please explain in as much detail as possible what statements you believe to be false and/or defamatory and the specific reasons why these statements could be considered false and/or defamatory in the context of the page as a whole. If possible please identify the reason you believe the text or content violates your rights or is illegal under applicable law. It would be helpful if you could cite the specific law(s) of your country you believe to be applicable to the content in question. In the event we do not receive further information from you as requested above, we will be unable to take any further action on your removal request. As always, we encourage you to resolve any disputes with the author of the content in question before directing any complaint to Google. Regards, The Google Team On 01/28/14 08:21:40 hello@inspiragraphics.com wrote: country_residence: GB full_name: Daniel Hart companyname: inspiragraphics (formerly djh-graphics) representedrightsholder: contact_email_noprefill: hello@inspiragraphics.com hidden_product: blogger url_box3: http://www.djh-graphics.blogspot.co.uk url_box3: http://daniel-hart-commits-crimes-in-secret.blogspot.co.uk url_box3: http://www.djh-graphics.blogspot.com legalother_explain: legalother_quote_commonwealth: Totally false claims from a known criminal please see below. If you respond to say that you cannot identify the author as Felicity Jane Lowde, please consider that this is extremely damaging material regardless, and obviously malicious. PLEASE help me now. It ihas been SEVEN years this material has stayed up, and I still get people asking why, when they google my name, this is what appears. It has affected me in untold ways, and I have no money for lawyers. I am desperate now. legalother_quote: legalother_explain_commonwealth: You need to refer to www.inspiragraphics.com/fjl-legal.docx for full info - there are multiple instances, and the description is really extensive. legal_consent_statement: agree signature_date: 1/28/14 signature: Daniel Hart hidden_category: hidden_country: hidden_ctx: subject_lr_legalother: Your Request to Google geolocation: GB :---- Automatically added fields ----: Language: en IIILanguage: en auto-helpcenter-id: 1647639 auto-helpcenter-name: legal auto-internal-helpcenter-name: legal auto-full-url: https://support.google.com/legal/contact/lr_legalother?product=blogger auto-user-logged-in: true auto-user-was-internal: false IssueType: lr_legalother form-id: lr_legalother form: lr_legalother subject-line-field-id: subject_lr_legalother body-text-field-id: AutoDetectedBrowser: Firefox 26.0 AutoDetectedOS: Desktop Windows NT 6.1