Alaska Sustainable Salmon Fund Statement of Work I. Project Title: Chinook Salmon Growth and Survival II. Project Number: 44902 III. Principal Investigator Trent Sutton, Professor University of Alaska Fairbanks (UAF) School of Fisheries and Ocean Sciences (SFOS) 905 N. Koyukuk Drive Fairbanks, AK 99775 Phone: (907) 474-7285 Email: tmsutton@alaska.edu Co-Principal Investigators Milo Adkison, Professor UAF, SFOS 905 N. Koyukuk Drive Fairbanks, AK 99775 Phone: (907) 474-1811 Email: mdadkison@alaska.edu Philip Richards, Fishery Biologist III Alaska Department of Fish and Game (ADF&G) Division of Sport Fish (SF) P.O. Box 110024 Douglas, AK 99811 Phone: (907) 465-8114 Email: philip.richards@alaska.gov Troy Jaecks, Fishery Biologist II ADF&G, SF P.O. Box 110024 Douglas, AK 99811 Phone: (907) 465-4271 Email: troy.jaecks@alaska.gov IV. Project Period: 3/1/14 – 11/30/16 V. AKSSF Objective: 2A-4 VI. Project Description 1. Synopsis Chinook Salmon Growth and Survival 44902 PCSRF Objective: RM&E Page 1 of 8 2/8/2016 Chinook salmon runs in the Chilkat and Stikine rivers support subsistence fisheries in Southeast Alaska. This project will examine the importance of freshwater and marine processes on Southeast Alaska female Chinook salmon recruitment to reproductive age in these systems using a combination of long-term scale archive samples, adult abundance estimates, and smolt data sets. These evaluations will allow for the assessment of growth and survival on recruitment within individual stocks by following cohorts from freshwater through marine residence until they return to their natal river as reproductively mature adults. Project results will allow the development of more accurate and reliable forecasts for making management decisions on subsistence salmon Chinook salmon stock status and escapement goals in Southeast Alaska. 2. Introduction Chinook salmon support important and diverse subsistence, commercial, recreational, and personal use fisheries throughout Alaska. Highly variable recruitment, coupled with statewide declines in productivity and abundance, has created social and economic hardships for many communities in rural and urban Alaska. As a result, there is a clear need to more precisely characterize productivity and abundance trends for Chinook salmon stocks, collect information to understand the causal mechanisms for these widespread declines, and develop more accurate tracking and forecasting of future population trends. In Southeast Alaska, Chinook salmon abundance declined in the 1970s in many tributaries, including transboundary rivers, relative to historical levels of production. In response, the Alaska Department of Fish and Game (ADF&G) and the Canada Department of Fisheries and Oceans (DFO) initiated concurrent programs to facilitate stock recovery. Both programs were incorporated into an inclusive coast-wide rebuilding program in 1985 via the U.S./Canada Pacific Salmon Treaty which required the annual monitoring of escapement trends in 11 index tributaries. Two of these tributaries, the Stikine River (a transboundary river) and the Chilkat River, are glacial systems that annually produce the first or second and third or fourth largest populations of Chinook salmon, respectively, in Southeast Alaska. These fish are primarily caught in marine troll, commercial drift gillnet, and recreational fisheries as well as subsistence fisheries in U.S. waters, and in in-river commercial, aboriginal gillnet, and recreational fisheries in Canada. While Chinook salmon escapements rebounded in the Stikine River post-1985, adult spawner returns continued to decline in the Chilkat River. As a result, restrictive regulations for recreational and commercial fisheries were implemented in 2007. While increases in marine harvest contributed to both stock declines, the potential role of environmental factors on Chinook salmon recruitment is not clear. For this research, the importance of freshwater and marine processes on Chinook salmon recruitment to spawning age will be examined in the Stikine and Chilkat rivers using long-term scale archive samples, adult abundance estimates, and smolt data sets collected by ADF&G. Analyses will be conducted at the system scale which will allow assessment of pre-smolt, smolt, and post-smolt growth and survival on recruitment within individual stocks by following cohorts (i.e., broods) from Chinook Salmon Growth and Survival 44902 Page 2 of 8 2/8/2016 freshwater through marine residence until they return to their natal river as reproductively mature adults. Examining rate-dynamic functions separately in freshwater and marine systems, and coupling these findings within the context of large-scale environmental drivers, should lend insights into the factors that limit recruitment. This evaluation will allow the development of more accurate and reliable forecasts for making management decisions on Chinook salmon stock status and escapement goals in these rivers. Further, this research will augment similar analyses being conducted by the investigators on the role of freshwater and marine processes on Chinook salmon growth, survival, and recruitment in the Taku and Unuk rivers in Southeast Alaska. 3. Location Site: Chilkat River Latitude: 59.2659 N Longitude: 135.608196 W Site: Stikine River Latitude: 56.747440 Longitude: -131.785469 VII. Objectives Objective 1: Using archived scale samples, conduct a retrospective analysis of the relationships of freshwater and marine growth to survival to the age of reproduction for female Chinook salmon by brood year Objective 2: Evaluate past and current influences of biological and environmental factors on Chinook salmon smolt migration run timing by brood year Objective 3: Assess the relationship between Chinook salmon smolt biological attributes, smolt migration run timing characteristics, and environmental factors on female survival to the age of reproductive maturity by brood year VIII. Methods Archived Scale Growth Analysis (Objective 1) A time series of freshwater and marine growth patterns for Chinook salmon from the Stikine River (1996-2012) and the Chilkat River (1991-2012) will be constructed using archived scales previously collected by ADF&G. Scale acetate impressions for female Chinook salmon will be digitized and an image analysis routine will be used that follows ADF&G methods. A sample size of at least 25 females per age class per year for each river will be chosen for this study. Scale circuli increment widths will be measured to allow assessment of the importance of freshwater (pre-smolt and smolt) and marine (postsmolt) processes on survival and recruitment for each brood year in both rivers. Scale measurements will include the length of the freshwater zone (freshwater increment width) and measurement of intercirculi pair spacing of the marine zone from the end of the freshwater zone to the margin of the scale (marine increment width). Post-smolt growth will be characterized by the number of circuli pairs laid down during the first and post-smolt stage, which will be divided by the months at sea before the first winter. Estimates of river-specific sex ratio, age structure, size-at-age, smolt body size, freshwater and marine survival, and recruitment and data on size-fecundity relationships will be obtained and used to estimate the number of female spawners and the number of eggs spawned in each brood year for each river. Freshwater and marine growth Chinook Salmon Growth and Survival 44902 Page 3 of 8 2/8/2016 increments, along with proportional monthly marine growth indices, will be correlated to the aforementioned series of recruitment benchmarks. To examine the relationship between smolt body size and female survival to the age of reproductive maturity, lengthfrequency distributions will be examined for each brood year. Female brood return will be estimated and used to determine if correlations exist separately between freshwater and marine growth and the number of female Chinook salmon returning to spawn. Correlations will be examined between freshwater growth and female spawner size-atage to determine if different age classes display different freshwater growth values. Female brood returns will be used to determine if a correlation exists between the size and number of females and the freshwater and marine growth of their offspring. Smolt Run Timing (Objective 2) An evaluation will be conducted for Chinook salmon from the Stikine and Chilkat rivers in Southeast Alaska using a time series of smolt downstream migration (Stikine River: 1998-2007; Chilkat River: 1998-2007) and adult female spawner return data (Stikine River: 1996-2012; Chilkat River: 1991-2012) collected by ADF&G. The mean duration of the downstream smolt migration and range of Julian dates, as well as Chinook salmon smolt body size, condition, and age, and the mean and range of water temperature, water depth/water level, and discharge for each river, will be determined from previously collected data for each year. The role of biological and environmental variables on the timing and rate of the smolt run will be examined using multivariate analyses for each river. In a second set of multiple regression analyses, daily smolt catch will be replaced by the total cumulative smolt catch. The daily recorded smolt catch over the outmigration period in each river, as well as smolt body size, condition, and age and changes in river temperature, depth, and discharge will be modeled to characterize smolt run timing. For this evaluation, it is likely that a polynomial model or models will be used; however, the exact type of model will not be determined until a more thorough examination of the predictor variables is completed. The probability estimated from the model will represent the predicted probability of outmigration for smolts that remain in the river, which will be transformed into the population fraction predicted to migrate each day. Predictions will be compared to the estimated ratio of the number of smolts captured on a given day to the number of smolts captured that season. The association between post-smolt survival to reproductive age and the age at reproductive maturity, and adult spawning run characteristics to annual smolt attributes, smolt migration run timing characteristics, and environmental conditions will also be examined annually using a series of linear regression analyses. Smolt and Environmental Characteristic Influences on Female Survival (Objective 3) The synergistic role of biological and environmental variables on the marine survival of post-smolt Chinook salmon will also be examined for the Stikine and Chilkat rivers. Multiple linear regression models will be used to examine relationships between postsmolt marine survival and the aforementioned biological and environmental variables. IX. Benefits Chinook Salmon Growth and Survival 44902 Page 4 of 8 2/8/2016 This project will examine the importance of freshwater and marine processes on Chinook salmon recruitment to reproductive age in the Stikine and the Chilkat rivers, both of which support important subsistence fisheries. This information will have practical value both in improving forecasts of Chinook salmon returns and in providing insight into the causes of past fluctuations in productivity. Further, identifying the impact of freshwater and marine environmental factors on recruitment variation will allow for the identification of crucial phases in the life history of these Chinook salmon. X. Products, Milestones, and Timelines March – May 2014: Convene annual project planning meeting with ADF&G personnel; obtain scale samples from ADF&G; compile adult spawner return and smolt data May – June 2014: Assist ADF&G personnel with adult spawner and smolt sampling and data collections at the Stikine and Chilkat field sites (graduate student) May – December 2014: Prepare and digitize ADF&G scale samples May 2014 – February 2015: Analyze adult spawner return and smolt data January – December 2015: Analyze ADF&G scale data May 2015: Attend annual project planning meeting with ADF&G personnel; present and discuss analyses and results to date October 2015: Present preliminary study results at the annual meeting of the Alaska Chapter of the American Fisheries Society (AK-AFS; PI and graduate student registration and travel costs separately funded) January 2016: Present preliminary study results at the annual meeting of the Alaska Marine Science Symposium (AMSS) January – September 2016: Complete data analyses and thesis writing May 2016: Attend annual project planning meeting with ADF&G personnel; present and discuss analyses and results to date September 2016: Present final study results at the national annual meeting of the American Fisheries Society (AFS) October 2016: Defend and revise graduate student thesis; present final study results at the annual meeting of the AK-AFS (PI and graduate student registration and travel costs separately funded) November 2016: Prepare and submit manuscripts to journals for peer review; submit final formal project report and other publications to AKSSF XI. Budget UAF Budget 100 Personnel 200 Travel 300 Contractual 400 Supplies 500 Equipment Subtotal Expenses subject to indirect Chinook Salmon Growth and Survival 44902 Total $126,332 $11,345 $27,650 $0 $0 $165,327 $138,677 Page 5 of 8 2/8/2016 600 Indirect @ 25% Total $34,669 $199,996 UAF Budget Narrative: Line 100: Personnel ($126,332) Dr. Trent Sutton, Professor, UAF School of Fisheries and Ocean Sciences, will mentor the graduate student; directly supervise the research technician; assist with sample processing, data analyses, and research presentations; and review project progress reports, the graduate student's thesis, the final project completion report, and peer-reviewed manuscripts: Salary: 217.5 hours @ $60.42/hour base rate plus leave reserve = $14,046 Fringe benefits: $4,382 Dr. Milo Adkison, Professor, UAF School of Fisheries and Ocean Sciences, will serve on the graduate student's committee, assist with data analyses, and review project progress reports, the graduate student thesis, the final project completion report, and peer-reviewed manuscripts: Salary: 217.5 hours @ $58.50/hour base rate plus leave reserve = $13,600 Fringe benefits: $4,244 Nicholas Smith, Technician, will oversee all activities associated with Objectives 2 and 3 including data analyses, paper and poster presentations, and project report and peer-reviewed manuscript writing: Salary: 582.8 hours @ $22.01/hour base rate plus leave reserve = $15,948 Fringe benefits: $8,037 An M.S. graduate student (to be determined) will conduct research associated with Objective 1. The graduate student will also be responsible for data analysis, paper and poster presentations, and project report and peer-reviewed manuscript writing associated with Objective 1 as well as field work in the first year of the project including assisting ADF&G with adult spawner and smolt sampling and data collections at the Stikine and Chilkat rivers. Salary: o Year 1: 696 hours @ $19.67/hour base rate plus leave reserve = $13,690 o Year 2: 1,392 hours @ $21.34/hour base rate plus leave reserve = $29,706 o Year 3: 696 hours @ $21.34/hour base rate plus leave reserve = $14,852 Fringe benefits: $7,827 Line 200: Travel ($11,345) This project includes domestic travel to field sites, to meetings with ADF&G project partners, and for AFS (national) and AMSS conference travel for dissemination and discussion of project findings. Chinook Salmon Growth and Survival 44902 Page 6 of 8 2/8/2016 The graduate student will travel from Fairbanks to Juneau in the first, second, and third years of the project for project planning, discussion of data analyses and research findings, and for data collection with ADF&G partners (first year only); Dr. Sutton will join the graduate student in the third year of the project: Airfare: $600 + $660 + 2 tickets @ $726/ticket = $2,712 Local Transportation: $100 + $110 + $242 = $452 Lodging: 12 nights @ $149/night = $1,788 Per diem: 16 days @ $60/day = $960 The graduate student will travel from Fairbanks to Anchorage in the third year of the project to present research/project results at the 2016 AMSS conference: Airfare: $363 Local transportation: $121 Lodging: 1 night at $99/night = $99 Per diem: 1 day @ $60/day = $60 The graduate student and Dr. Sutton will travel from Fairbanks to Kansas City, Missouri, in the third year of the project to present project research and results at the 2016 AFS national annual meeting: Airfare: 2 tickets @ $1,573/ticket = $3,146 Local transportation: $242 Lodging: 4 nights @ $99/night x 2 persons = $792 Per diem: 5 days @ $61/day x 2 persons = $610 Line 300: Contractual ($27,650) Conference registration fee (AFS 2016 Kansas City national annual meeting): 2 fees @ $500/fee = $1,000 Graduate student tuition: $26,650 Line 600: Indirect ($34,669) UAF’s federally negotiated indirect rates through June 30, 2014, range from 35% to 49.5% excluding (among other costs) equipment, tuition, and subgrants and contracts over the first $25,000; however, indirect will be recovered at a reduced rate of 25% for this project. XII. Match Budget UAF Match Budget (35%) 100 Personnel 200 Travel 300 Contractual 400 Supplies 500 Equipment Chinook Salmon Growth and Survival 44902 Page 7 of 8 Total $55,999 $0 $0 $0 $0 2/8/2016 Subtotal Expenses subject to indirect 600 Indirect @ 25% Total $55,999 $55,999 $14,000 $69,999 UAF Match Budget Narrative: Line 100: Personnel ($55,999) Dr. Trent Sutton, Professor, UAF School of Fisheries and Ocean Sciences, will mentor the graduate student; directly supervise the research technician; assist with sample processing, data analyses, and research presentations; and review project progress reports, the graduate student's thesis, the final project completion report, and peer-reviewed manuscripts: Salary: 217.5 hours @ $60.42/hour base rate plus leave reserve = $14,047 Fringe benefits: $4,382 Dr. Milo Adkison, Professor, UAF School of Fisheries and Ocean Sciences, will serve on the graduate student's committee, assist with data analyses, and review project progress reports, the graduate student thesis, the final project completion report, and peer-reviewed manuscripts. Salary: 217.5 hours @ $58.50/hour base rate plus leave reserve = $13,600 Fringe benefits: $4,244 Nicholas Smith, Technician, will conduct scale compilation and preparation for Objective 1 and data compilation for Objectives 1-3. Salary: 464 hours @ $22.01/hour base rate plus leave reserve = $13,116 Fringe benefits: $6,610 Line 600: Indirect ($14,000) UAF’s federally negotiated indirect rates through June 30, 2014, range from 35% to 49.5% excluding (among other costs) equipment, tuition, and subgrants and contracts over the first $25,000; however, indirect will be recovered at a reduced rate of 25% for this project. Chinook Salmon Growth and Survival 44902 Page 8 of 8 2/8/2016