DRAFT ESTUARY MANAGEMENT PLAN For Wallagoot Lake And Bournda Lagoon Prepared By: Bournda Environmental Education Centre (BEEC) And Sulisit Consulting Contributors: Members of Wallagoot Landcare DOCUMENT SUMMARY Major Funding Body: Caring For Our Coasts Via –Southern Rivers Catchment Management Authority (SRCMA) Funded Project: The Two gems project Local Government Area: Bega Valley Shire Council, Australia Catchment Management Area: Southern Rivers CMA Prepared By: Bournda EEC - Doug Reckord and Luke Brown (Project Officer) Co-Authors: Sulisit Consulting, 24 Connells Close, Mossy Point, NSW, 2537 Contributors: Jan Lynch, Bournda Environmental Education Centre Members of Wallagoot Landcare ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Students and teachers who supported project activities. Community members who participated in meetings, water quality testing and other events The Traditional Owners are acknowledged, in particular, members of the Local Aboriginal Community. Southern Rivers CMA – Kirsti Sampson, Helen Davies and Don McPhee Bega Valley Shire Council – Derek Van Bracht Mr Rob High – for permission to access his lands in the Wallagoot catchment Grant Brewer – Ranger – Bournda National Park Illustration on front page: Bega High School student investigating biodiversity during the Landcare camp Contents Contents.................................................................................................................................................................................................. 0 List of Figures ......................................................................................................................................................................................... 1 List of Plates ........................................................................................................................................................................................... 2 Draft Estuary Management Plan for Wallagoot Lake and Bournda Lagoon ........................................................................................... 1 Executive Summary ................................................................................................................................................................................ 1 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Introduction.................................................................................................................................................................................... 4 1.1. Importance of Study Area .................................................................................................................................... 6 1.2. Location of Study Area ........................................................................................................................................ 6 1.3 Community Uses of the Catchments ................................................................................................................... 7 1.4 Cultural Values .................................................................................................................................................... 8 1.5 Identification of Key Stakeholders ....................................................................................................................... 8 1.6 Community and Stakeholder Consultation ........................................................................................................ 10 Estuary Health ............................................................................................................................................................................. 11 2.1 Physical characteristics ..................................................................................................................................... 11 2.2 Estuary Biodiversity ........................................................................................................................................... 13 2.2 Threatened Species .......................................................................................................................................... 17 Ecosystem Health and Stressors ................................................................................................................................................ 17 3.1 Estuary Health Pressures and Stressors ........................................................................................................... 17 3.2 Coastal Risks – Climate Change - Overview ..................................................................................................... 20 Ecosystem Health Assessment and Plans .................................................................................................................................. 22 4.1 Estuary Health Assessment............................................................................................................................... 22 4.2 Ecosystem Health Experimental Design............................................................................................................ 22 Ecosystem Health and Water Quality Status .............................................................................................................................. 23 5.1 Data collected .................................................................................................................................................... 23 5.2 Estuary Health Status ........................................................................................................................................ 24 5.3 Data management ............................................................................................................................................. 25 5.4 Estuary seagrass and habitat monitoring .......................................................................................................... 27 Conclusions (including potential management actions) .............................................................................................................. 28 APPENDIX A ........................................................................................................................................................................................ 31 APPENDIX B ........................................................................................................................................................................................ 33 References............................................................................................................................................................................................ 36 Two Gems Draft Catchment Management Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 List of Tables Table 1 Land-use comparison................................................................................................................................. 7 Table 2: Management stakeholders identified ........................................................................................................ 9 Table 3: Estuary Characteristics of Wallagoot and Bournda ................................................................................. 12 Table 4 Species diversity and abundance in Wallagoot, compiled by Luke Brown (Bournda EEC)...................... 16 Table 5 Recovery Plans Relevant to Wallagoot Lake ........................................................................................... 17 Table 6 Table Classification of Coastal Lakes – Summary of Data. Independent public inquiry into Coastal Lakes – Final Report 2002............................................................................................................................................... 18 Table 7 Multiple Scale Estuary Health .................................................................................................................. 19 Table 8 Bournda-Wallagoot Waterwatch Group/Wallagoot Landcare ................................................................... 27 Table 9 Threatened Species List – Bournda Lagoon/Wallagoot Lake Catchments .............................................. 31 Table 10 Comparison of Attributes of the Wallagoot Lake/Bournda Lagoon Catchments .................................... 33 List of Figures Figure 1 Location map - Wallagoot catchment - red; Bournda Lagoon catchment - mustard ................................. 6 Figure 2 Wallagoot Lake - Caulerpa zone............................................................................................................... 7 Figure 3 Aquatic vegetation communities in Wallagoot Lake, 2009. ..................................................................... 14 Figure 4 Trend in Annual Total Rainfall 1970-2011 – Bureau of Meteorology ...................................................... 20 Figure 5 Trend in Mean Temperature 1970-2011 – Bureau of Meteorology ......................................................... 20 Figure 6 Wallagoot Lake – Coastal Risk mapping based on BVSC 2010 LEP mapping –See GIS Folder 3 ........ 21 Figure 7 Bournda Lagoon Coastal Risk Mapping – BVSC 2010 – See GIS – Folder 3 ........................................ 21 Figure 8 Salinity, expressed as electrical conductivity – units are micro Siemens per centimetre. ....................... 23 Figure 9 Dissolved Oxygen Levels, Wallagoot Lake, Jan 2011-May 2012 ........................................................... 24 Figure 10 Adaptive Management Model (Resilience Alliance and Santa Fe Institute, 2004): ............................... 26 Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 List of Plates Plate 1 Bournda Road after heavy rain ................................................................................................................... 2 Plate 2 Bournda Lagoon in flood, entrance closed 29 Jan 2009 ............................................................................. 3 Plate 3 Screenshot from GIS showing drainage network and Wallagoot catchment boundary. ............................. 5 Plate 4 Panoramic view of the open Wallagoot Lake, March 2012. Photo by: Tony Hastings WLBC ..................... 8 Plate 5 Quadrat/Transect study of seagrass – Zostera spp. ................................................................................. 11 Plate 6 Bournda Lagoon – Sept 2007, Note algal blooms. ................................................................................... 13 Plate 7 Wallagoot Lake – Entrance – in open condition, 13th June 2012 ............................................................. 15 Plate 8 4Feb 2010 Flood event – turbid water in Moncks Creek ........................................................................... 18 Plate 9 Wallagoot Lake during the drought, with seagrass beds exposed (January, 2009, Bournda EEC) .......... 27 Plate 10 The future of Landcare - Participants -Two Gems Landcare Camp 2011 ............................................... 35 Plate 1 Bournda Road after heavy rain Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Two Gems Draft Catchment Management Plan Page |1 Draft Estuary Management Plan for Wallagoot Lake and Bournda Lagoon Executive Summary The “Two Gems”, Wallagoot Lake and Bournda Lagoon, are intermittently closing and opening estuarine lakes or lagoons (ICOLL) located between Tathra and Merimbula, in the Bega Valley Shire. Water quality monitoring indicates that surface water quality in both estuaries is good. The Rapid Catchment Assessment has identified priority sites where riparian vegetation has been damaged, removed or is in poor condition. There are areas where stock access tributaries of the estuaries. Both main tributaries (Moncks Creek and Sandy Beach Creek) have large sediment slugs which require management to protect the estuaries. Expert assessment of these sites is recommended. Landholders, whose properties are included in the Rapid Catchment Assessment process, are willing to discuss on-ground rehabilitation works but have made no commitments beyond that. There is excellent potential for erosion control, revegetation and fencing works to improve the catchment condition. Both estuaries are listed as medium priority for estuary management works by SRCMA. In Wallagoot Lake seagrass species are recolonising areas exposed by drought conditions in 2006-2010 No Caulerpa was found during the monitoring period and no control measures were required. Community input to the draft catchment management plan indicates a high level of support for catchment management that protects the natural values and water quality of both estuaries. A community geographic information system, or GIS, has been established using Google Earth and captures a range of information useful to the management of these catchments. The GIS should be considered as a set of electronic appendices to this document and contains a rich set of data about the study area. The catchments contain a stunning diversity of flora and fauna, including many threatened and vulnerable species. The catchments have formally identified as suitable for significant (Wallagoot) and comprehensive protection.(Bournda) (NSW HRC, 2002) Both estuaries need protection from eutrophication, sedimentation and habitat disturbance and there are concerns that excessive and/or poorly managed development will compromise the Two Gems Draft Catchment Management Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief Page |2 high conservation status of both estuaries. Bournda Lagoon is particularly vulnerable due to its small water volume. Land clearing and construction of roads and batters on erodible soils are leading to land degradation processes that put these estuaries at risk. There is intense interest in the management of these estuaries from a wide range of user and interest groups While this combined Draft Estuary Management Plan provides important information on estuary processes and community input, there is a need to provide resources for a more comprehensive estuary management process. Key recommendations include: Bournda EEC and Wallagoot Landcare host a workshop with the BVSC Coastal Planning and Management Committee to discuss the project’s findings and scope work towards completing a comprehensive Estuary Management Process for each estuary. Bournda EEC, NPWS, Southern Rivers CMA and other relevant stakeholders, including the Aboriginal community, work through the BVSC CPMC to develop separate Draft Estuary Management Plans for Wallagoot Lake and Bournda Lagoon Begin negotiations with willing landholders for rehabilitation of riparian vegetation, control of erosion and management of sediment plugs. Form an Estuary Management Committee for each catchment: Under the auspices of the BVSC Coastal Planning and Management Committee with Aboriginal community membership. Assemble Existing Data and: Identify additional resources and more comprehensively collate existing studies and information on baseline estuary processes, including input from community members. Collate key research data on water quality and biodiversity into individual catchment databases. Conduct an audit to determine if the BVSC Comprehensive Local Environment Plan is consistent with the coastal lakes sustainability assessments, in accordance with Dept. of Planning guidelines Carry Out an Estuary Process Study and: Provide resources to assemble the baseline estuary process data from existing sources. Provide support for ongoing water quality monitoring in both catchments. Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief Page |3 Carry Out an Estuary Management Study and: Further investigate suitable management of erosion prone landscapes including soil erosion risk mapping. Plate 2 Bournda Lagoon in flood, entrance closed 29 Jan 2009 Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief Page |4 1. Introduction This draft estuary management plan will: provide a brief outline of information about Wallagoot Lake and Bournda Lagoon, identify key issues and pressures in both catchments and provide recommendations for catchment action, future monitoring and estuary health assessment. Illustrate key information using a Community GIS developed with Google Earth. The Community GIS developed for this project can be considered as a set of electronic appendices to this document. The purpose of the resource is to make information about the catchment readily available to community members. . The GIS contains the following folders: Folder -1 Catchment Tours – these simulated catchment “fly-overs” give information about the location of the study area and some basic catchment characteristics. Folder -2 Rapid Catchment Assessment - A Rapid Catchment Assessment (RCA) was conducted in both catchments using the “Matrix Criteria for Determining River Rehabilitation Priorities” SRCMA Coastal Catchments, Version 5. The data for the RCA can be accessed by downloading a spreadsheet from using the link within the GIS Folder 3 - Estuary Health - Water Quality Data collected from the project can be downloaded in spreadsheet form from within this folder. Some additional information on water quality during the major rainfall event of March 8th 2012 is shown for both catchments. Coastal risk mapping - Climate change - The BVSC Comprehensive Local Environment Plan contains coastal risk planning maps based on projections for sea-level rise. These maps are provided for illustrative purposes only and should not be relied on for any other purpose. Any person wishing to find further information about this mapping should contact Bega Valley Shire Council. Folder 4 - Natural Environment - A range of information useful for understanding the natural resources of the catchments is available in this folder including: Catchment Boundaries mapping - Drawn using the “path” tool in Google Earth Streams – utilising data supplied under licence to Bournda EEC by the Office of Environment and Heritage for educational purposes. Vegetation – computer predictions of extant vegetation. An exciting feature of the mapping is a photographic resource on vegetation types being prepared by a community volunteer, Steve Burrows. Clicking on vegetation types will link to the Bournda Digital Herbarium to aid in an understanding of the major species within each unit. This component is still being prepared but will help educate the community about threatened species and endangered ecological communities within the catchment areas. Soils – Soil mapping using a digital overlay of mapping by DLWC(Tulau, 1997). Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief Page |5 Geology Folder 5 - Aerial Photographs - Map overlays of older aerial photographs give an indication of changes within the catchments. Most of the aerial photographs focus on Wallagoot Lake and there is one image that covers the eastern portion of the Bournda Lagoon catchment. Folder 6 - Administrative Data including SEPP 71, SEPP 14 and SEPP26 mapping and NPWS Estate. Folder 7 - Community Stakeholder Consultation Folder 8 - Management Options Plate 3 Screenshot from GIS showing drainage network and Wallagoot catchment boundary. Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief Page |6 1.1. Importance of Study Area Both Wallagoot Lake and Bournda Lagoon are iconic South Coast beauty spots which are valued highly by local residents and visitors for their recreational and conservation values. From an aquatic biodiversity perspective, the NSW Far South Coast ICOLLs and small estuaries are critical aquatic habitat for 70% of species on the Eastern Australian seaboard at some stage in their life cycle. Wallagoot is particularly important because it of its unique hydrology, with a very low opening frequency. Both estuaries’ catchments are home to a number of species listed under the NSW Threatened Species Conservation Act (1995) including Potoroo, Powerful Owl, Yellow-bellied Glider; and Hooded Plover. Significant parts of both catchments are protected in Bournda National Park and Bournda Nature Reserve. - See Table 9 1.2. Location of Study Area Wallagoot Lake and Bournda Lagoon are located on the far south coast of NSW between the townships of Merimbula and Tathra, see Figure 1. Figure 1 Location map - Wallagoot catchment - red; Bournda Lagoon catchment - mustard Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief Page |7 Bournda EEC Existing Caulerpa netting closure area Figure 2 Wallagoot Lake - Caulerpa zone 1.3 Public access at Wallagoot Lake Boat Ramp Community Uses of the Catchments There is a low density of settlement in both catchments with limited infrastructure. Wallagoot Lake Road becomes inundated during infrequent flood events triggering the need for artificial opening of the lake by BVSC. Wallagoot Lake and Bournda Lagoon catchments have approximately 4400ha of National Park and Nature Reserve; 1900 ha of these catchments is other Crown Land and Freehold Land. Limited numbers of stock are found in both catchments including beef and dairy cattle, horses and goats. In some places there is unrestricted stock access to the lake and tributaries, which has a detrimental impact on riparian zones. Most of Wallagoot Lake however, is protected from stock and Bournda Lagoon is in the National Park. Wallagoot Lake Bournda Lagoon 30.12 33.16 Park/Nature 20.52 23.42 Area (km2) National Reserve Other Crown freehold land, 9.6 % National Park/Nature 68 Reserve 9.74 71 Table 1 Land-use comparison The catchment area values in Table 1 were calculated using ArcMap with estimated catchment boundaries. There are some differences between previously reported figures for Wallagoot Lake with the catchment areas Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief Page |8 varying between 26km2 and 35km2.Both reserves are covered by a Plan of Management (NSW National Parks and Wildlife Service, 2000). Bournda National Park is a very popular destination for tourists and local residents. Recreational facilities include the Wallagoot Lake Boat Ramp, the Wallagoot Lake Boat Club and a range of visitor facilities provided by NPWS. Toilet facilities at the camping ground have recently been converted to pump-outs so there is low risk to the estuaries from sewerage related to park visitation. Recreational uses of the area include sailing, kayaking, water-skiing, swimming, fishing, bushwalking, camping, bike-riding and bird-watching. Excellent water quality is an important to participants particularly where primary contact is involved. The recreational and natural attractions of the National Park make the area ideal for environmental education programs. Bournda Environmental Education Centre (EEC) has been running programs in both catchments since 1976 and the high level of interest in education and research is reflected in participation in catchment education events coordinated by the EEC. Wallagoot Lake is closed to commercial fishing for part of the year (1st May- 31st October) with prescriptions on the types of nets allowed; there is only one commercial operator. Bournda Lagoon is not open to commercial fishing and netting is prohibited. 1.4 Cultural Values There is a rich history of cultural heritage in the region with archaeological evidence of several thousand years of indigenous occupation. Both catchments contain Aboriginal Land managed by the Bega Local Aboriginal Lands Council. Plate 4 Panoramic view of the open Wallagoot Lake, March 2012. Photo by: Tony Hastings WLBC 1.5 Identification of Key Stakeholders A number of key stakeholders are involved in the management and use of these catchments and are listed in Table 2 below Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief Page |9 Table 2: Management stakeholders identified Stakeholder Area NSW National Parks and Wildlife Service, Office of Environment and Heritage Bega Local Aboriginal Land Council, NSW National Parks and Wildlife Service, Bega Valley Shire Council Bournda National Park Bournda Nature Reserve Comments and Legislated under the National Parks and Wildlife Act 1974, management of catchment area, Plan of Management 2000 Aboriginal lands within the Legislated under the National Parks and Wallagoot and Bournda Wildlife Act 1974, Aboriginal Land Rights Act catchments; Aboriginal sites 1983, management of Aboriginal sites Rural freehold and residential Planning and development laws impact ecosystem health and resilience, BVSC CLEP adopted 2012 Southern Rivers Catchment Management of catchment issues Ability to develop on ground works to reduce Authority such as erosion and sediment catchment issues control Department of Primary Industry Management of marine Research activities, manage NSW Fisheries ecosystem from the low tide mark Commercial and recreational fishers impact on fish numbers and diversity. Fisheries Management Act 1994. Local community Both estuaries and surrounding Continued recreational use of area for beach and dune system swimming, boating and fishing, appreciation of conservation values Local businesses Recreational areas attract tourism Access to recreational, natural and cultural values Educational Institutions Ecological significant habitats Access to scientific, natural and cultural such as seagrass beds, values for educational and research threatened or endangered biota purposes., Bournda EEC operates within and EEC’s Bournda National Park NSW Office of Water Water Licenses Water Management Act 2000 NSW Government Policy and strategy Coastal Policy 1997, State Rivers and Estuaries Policy 1993, Estuary Management Policy 1992 and Diffuse Source Water Pollution Strategy 2009. Other State legislation; Native Vegetation Act 2003, Species Conservation Act 1995, Protection of the Environment Operations Act 1997, Environment Planning and Assessments Act 1979. Local landholders Management of freehold land Possible rehabilitation sites located on private property, management of native vegetation. Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief 1.6 P a g e | 10 Community and Stakeholder Consultation Listed below are the values, management issues and priority actions identified at a community catchment event on 24th June 2011. Values –What do we value about Wallagoot Lake and Bournda Lagoon Catchments? Important habitat for wildlife. Lack of human footprint. Visual aesthetics. Natural vegetation. Educational values and opportunities at Bournda EEC Science and research values. Recreational opportunities. Nice place to live. Quiet and peaceful. Lack of development Unique values of particular habitats or environments E.g. ICOLLs, dune lakes etc. Nesting site for threatened and endangered shorebirds Community concerns/Management Issues Limit development pressures within the catchment. Control invasive species including Caulerpa, Fire weed and rabbits. Prevent algal blooms and protect water quality (waste water- septic leaching). Identification of erosion sources. Fencing off stock from creeks and re-vegetating riparian vegetation. Improve baseline data relating to vegetation, water quality and biodiversity. Impacts of climate change. Illegal activities within the catchment, rubbish dumping, motor bikes, etc. Manage fishing pressures. Reductions in biodiversity including commercial and recreational fishing species. Increased jellyfish populations resulting in reduced visitor numbers/tourists. Issues associated with the closure of Wallagoot Lake entrance. Issues associated with manually opening the lake entrance. Lack of information/education about impacts of entrance opening with regard to water quality and the ecological role of ICOLLs in coastal ecosystems. Need to identify entrance opening “triggers”. Access for equipment required for entrance opening and protection of Aboriginal sites. Priority for Actions Identification of sediment sources/erosion hotspots. Collection of baseline data including vegetation, water quality and biodiversity. Sealing of the road on the northern side of Wallagoot Lake to reduce erosion and improve water quality. Investigate options for reducing illegal activities such as rubbish dumping along Red Hill road. Ensure communication between various agencies involved in the management of Wallagoot Lake and Bournda Lagoon catchments. Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief 2. P a g e | 11 Continued publicity of the project to ensure key landholders are involved including Aboriginal Land Council. Promote the values of ICOLLs such Wallagoot Lake and Bournda Lagoon. Explore funding opportunities and costs required to undertake some of the actions identified within the Rapid Catchment Assessment. Estuary Health Coastal Lakes and ICOLLs in southern NSW have a number of different pressures on them. Increased development of catchments means increased stormwater and effluent management issues. Increased recreational usage also increases pressures on coastal lakes; with boating having a big impact on seagrass meadows. The Wallagoot Lake entrance has been open from March – June 2012 and the influx of marine waters will potentially lead to an abundant prawn harvest later in the year. A high level of prawning activity has the potential to have a significant impact on seagrass beds. With increased activity there is a continued need for the Wallagoot Caulerpa Response Group to remain active in community education about the risks of aquatic weeds. 2.1 Physical characteristics According to the ANZECC classification system (ANZECC, 2000) Wallagoot Lake and Bournda lagoon are tidal and wave dominated estuarine systems, when open to the ocean. Wallagoot Lake is the only estuary in the region that remained closed during the Feb-March 2010 and Feb 2011 Flood Events. It has been closed for approximately 13 years. It was artificially opened on 2 nd March 2012 and remains open at the time of writing of this report (June 2012) .Bournda opens 2-3 times per year, but is generally closed. Plate 5 Quadrat/Transect study of seagrass – Zostera spp. Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief P a g e | 12 Table 3: Estuary Characteristics of Wallagoot and Bournda Estuary Characteristics Water body Wallagoot Bournda Entrance location Latitude (ºS) -36.79 -36.92 Longitude (ºE) 149.96 149.94 Catchment area (km2)1 26.5** 34.5 Estuary area (km2)1,2 4.0 0.1 Estuary volume (Ml)3 5342.4 26.7 Average depth (m)4 1.4 0.3 Roy et al. (2001) classification5 IV/8/B IV/8/B Entrance condition6 I I Notes: Derived from DECCW (2010) NSW estuaries and coastal catchments spatial database. Includes area mapped as open water (see note 1), mangrove and saltmarsh areas (Creese R. G., Glasby T. M., West G. and Gallen C. (2009) Mapping the habitats of NSW estuaries. Industry & Investment NSW Fisheries Final Report Series 113. Port Stephens, NSW, Australia. Based on areas at 0.6 m AHD (Roper T., Creese B., Scanes P., Stephens K., Williams R., Dela-Cruz J., Coade G. and Coates B. (2011) Assessing the condition of estuaries and coastal lake ecosystems in NSW. Office of Environment and Heritage, Sydney). Estimated by dividing the total volume at 0.6 m AHD by the total surface area of the estuary including mangrove areas but excluding saltmarsh (Roper et al., 2011) Estuary group: I = oceanic embayment, II = tide dominated estuary, III = wave dominated estuary, IV = intermittently closed estuary V = freshwater bodies Estuary type: 1 = ocean embayments, 3 = drowned valley estuary, 5 = barrier estuary, 6 = barrier lagoon, 7 = interbarrier estuary, 8 = saline coastal lagoon, 9 = small coastal creeks, 11 = brackish barrier lake. Evolution stage: A=youthful, B=intermediate, C=semi-mature, D=mature. (P. S. Roy, R. J. Williams, A. R. Jones, I. Yassini, P. J. Gibbs, B. Coates, R. J. West, P. R. Scanes, J. P. Hudson and S. Nichol (2001) Structure and Function of South-east Australian Estuaries. Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science 53, 351-384) Entrance conditions: O = open, T = trained, I = intermittent.**Catchment area for Wallagoot Lake appears to be an underestimate. A comparison of catchment characteristics is given in Appendix B Due to their small catchments, lower rainfall and wave dominated environments, these estuaries are particularly sensitive to human activity as all catchment inputs are captured and held when the entrances are closed. Bournda Lagoon has a small volume and a relatively large catchment, and is particularly susceptible to disturbance, taking several months to process inputs and establish a healthy ecosystem balance. During the last severe drought period from 2005-2010 Bournda Lagoon experienced episodes of macro-algal blooms which affected water quality and recreational use. This indicates the sensitivity of the estuary to extreme events and its vulnerability to catchment disturbances. Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief P a g e | 13 Plate 6 Bournda Lagoon – Sept 2007, Note algal blooms. 2.2 Estuary Biodiversity Wallagoot Lake has seagrass beds which cover most of the lake’s boundary area. The drought, which ended in February 2010, caused the area of seagrass meadow to shrink. Following the lake filling in February 2010 the seagrass meadows have begun recolonisation of these edge areas. The beds start 10-15m in from the edge of the waterbody. The February 2010 floods failed to open the entrance, but deposited a large load of silt on the beds, which also further diminished the seagrass area and productivity. Species identified include; Zostera, Ruppia megacarpa and Halophila australis. Saltmarsh is listed as present around Wallagoot Lake but was not assessed by this study. Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief P a g e | 14 Figure 3 Aquatic vegetation communities in Wallagoot Lake, 2009. Image courtesy of Trevor Daley, Department of Primary Industries Genetic biodiversity of Eastern Australia’s oceanic species is enhanced by the action of these ICOLLs. As populations are closed off for differing lengths of time and then released into marine waters as entrances are opened, biodiversity is maintained. Wallagoot Lake is unique in its offering to the genetic pool simply because it is closed for longer than any of the other lakes nearby. Recruitment of aquatic species and, providing habitat for development of juveniles into adults is a key role of NSW South Coast ICOLLs, including Wallagoot and Bournda. Each lake in the series of ICOLLs has different catchment hydrology, rates of sediment movement, riparian zone biodiversity and estuarine hydraulics, which result in differing times of opening and, a wide range of habitat types and aquatic species that utilise them. Department of Primary Industries (DPI) are currently conducting research on Wallagoot Lake, comparing fish species and assemblages with Durras Lake, another South Coast lake North of Batemans Bay, that was recently artificially opened (NSW DPI, Pending). Research on stocking Wallagoot Lake with King Prawn spat for recreational fishing was conducted by UNSW Researchers and DPI in 2008-09 (Suthers, Iain University of NSW, 2008) NPWS Merimbula has identified over 70 species of birds just in the Wallagoot Lake surrounds. A Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief P a g e | 15 herbarium, compiled by botanist Dane Wimbush is now available online due to the work of volunteer Steve Burrows. The herbarium includes over 340 species of plants from the Wallagoot Lake and Bournda Lagoon catchments; more specimens are still to be added. (Bournda EEC, 2012) Plate 7 Wallagoot Lake – Entrance – in open condition, 13th June 2012 Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief P a g e | 16 Table 4 Species diversity and abundance in Wallagoot, compiled by Luke Brown (Bournda EEC) Species Scientific Name Common name Abundance/ location Girella tricuspidata Acanthopagrus australis Acanthopagrus butcheri Rhombosolea tapirina Atherinidae Platycephalus fuscus Arenigobius bifrenatus Pagarus auratus Arenigobius sp. Pomatomus saltrix Hyporhamphus regularis Syngnathidae Mugliadae cephulus Anguilla australis Anguilla reinhardtii Luderick/Blackfish Yellowfin Bream Black Bream Flounder Hardy Heads Dusky Flathead Bridled Goby Snapper Goby sp. Tailor River Garfish Pipe Fish Sea Mullet Short finned Eel Long finned Eel Upper estuary & fresh Lower estuary Upper estuary Lower estuary Lower estuary Lower/Upper estuary Lower estuary Lower estuary Lower estuary Lower estuary Upper estuary & fresh Lower estuary Upper estuary & fresh Upper estuary & fresh Upper estuary & fresh Haliaeetus leucogaster Haematopus fuliginosus Haematopus longirostris Alcedo asurea White Bellied Sea Eagle Sooty Oyster Catcher Pied Oyster Catcher Azure Kingfisher Anas castanea Hirundo neoxena Ardeola ibis Chestnut Teal Welcome Swallow Cattle Egret Lower estuary & coastal Lower estuary & coastal Lower estuary Upper & lower estuary & fresh Upper estuary & fresh Upper estuary & fresh Coastal Paridotea ungulata Amphipoda Sp Palaemon intermedius Penaeus plebejus Sea Centipede Beach Hopper Red spotted Shrimp King Prawns Lower estuary Lower estuary Lower estuary Lower estuary Catostylus mosaicus Aurelia aurita Mosaic Jelly Moon jelly Anadara trapezia Austrocochlea porcata Soletellina Sp Buccinidae Sp Batillaria australis Trochidae Sp Tellinidae Sp Idiosepius notoides Euprymna tasmanica Anadara trapezia Laternula marilina Polinices sordidus Pyrazus ebeninus Sydney cockle Zebra winkle Sunset Shell Little Whelk Southern mudwhelk Top Shell Tellin Shell Pygmy Squid Dumpling Squid Bimbula Fragile Bivalve Leaden moon snail Hercules club whelk Lower estuary Lower estuary Lower estuary Lower estuary Lower estuary Lower estuary Lower estuary Lower estuary Lower estuary Lower estuary Lower estuary Lower estuary Lower estuary Lower estuary Lower estuary Lower estuary Ascidia sydneiensis Sydney Ascidian NSW or Federal listed Fish Avian (Birds) Crustaceans Jellyfish/Cnidaria Molluscs Ascidians Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Vulnerable Endangered Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief 2.2 P a g e | 17 Threatened Species Wallagoot and Bournda Lake catchments are host to a number of rare and endangered species, as per the Threatened Species listings, put out by NSW Office of Environment and Heritage (see full listing in Appendix A) Listings and the EPBC Listings (Federal). Most of the vulnerable species have Recovery Plans, or Action Plans. See Table below: According to NPWS the reference to Wallagoot Lake in the Koala Recovery plan refers to sightings from several decades ago and that almost certainly, if accurate, was a dispersing animal, possibly from a long way away. (Pers.comm. Chris Allen, NPWS, 18th June 2012) Table 5 Recovery Plans Relevant to Wallagoot Lake Species Southern Giant Petrel (Macronectes halli & giganteus) Grey-headed flying fox (Pteropus poliocephalus) Koala (Phascolarctos cinereus) Little Tern (Sterna albifrons) Pied and Sooty Oystercatchers Hooded Plover Green and Golden Bell Frog Barking Owl Bush Stone Curlew Yellow bellied glider Plan National recovery plan for Albatrosses and Giant-petrels 2011-2016 (2001) Draft National Recovery Plan for the Grey-headed Flying Fox (Pteropus poliocephalus) 2009 Recovery Plan for the Koala (Phascolarctos cinereus) 2008 Little Tern (Sterna albifrons) Recovery Plan 2003 and South Coast Shorebird Recovery Program 2008-09 Breeding Season South Coast Shorebird Recovery Program 2008-09 Breeding Season South Coast Shorebird Recovery Program 2008-09 Breeding Season Green & Golden Bell Frog Litoria aurea (Lesson 1829) Recovery Plan 2005 Recovery Plan for the Barking Owl Ninox connivens 2003 Recovery Plan for the Bush Stone-curlew Burhinus grallarius 2006 Recovery Plan for The Yellow-bellied Glider (Petaurus australis) 2003 3. Ecosystem Health and Stressors 3.1 Estuary Health Pressures and Stressors The following pressures on estuary health were identified as affecting Wallagoot Lake and Bournda Lagoon Rural Development and possible loss of critical riparian habitat Catchment run-off from agricultural land with increase nutrient inputs Unrestricted livestock access to tributaries Recreation and tourism pressures including impact of prawning on seagrass beds in Wallagoot Lake Land clearing for further development and road construction with increased soil loss. Impact of aquatic weeds including Caulerpa taxifolia Other risks to ecosystem health include high intensity wildfires (as mentioned above); natural climatic events such as floods and extended droughts, particularly when coupled with a closed entrance; high nutrients and low water levels could lead to eutrophication and ecosystem damage. Wallagoot Lake was assessed having a moderately low vulnerability with current catchment usage, which is very good compared to similar reference sites within the state (DLWC, 2000). Bournda Lagoon, despite being Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief P a g e | 18 within the boundaries of National park, was rated as highly vulnerable due to a combination of catchment land-use, a large catchment area and a small lagoon. The State of the Catchments (SOC) 2010 pressure indicator scores for Wallagoot and Bournda of 4.4 and 4.6 respectively are rated as very low with a trend index of unknown (NSW DECC, 2010). Given proposals for developments in both catchments, and changes under the BVSC Comprehensive Local Environment Plan (BVSC, 2010), that trend would appear to be certain to become one of increasing pressure. Long-term closure of the entrance with a developed and rural catchment is a key stressor as all run-off is captured and held in the main basin. The Healthy Rivers Commission Independent Inquiry into Coastal Lakes (NSW HRC, 2002) assessed Wallagoot and Bournda as shown in the table below: Coastal Lake Natural Sensitivity Wallagoot Very High Bournda Extreme Existing (Stress) Catchment Condition Largely unmodified Condition Recognis ed conservat Lake ion value condition Slightly Moderate affected Near Pristine Pristine Moderate Significant other factors Lake Classification Existing patterns of regional settlement, natural resources use, recreation and tourism and their sustainability Existing patterns of regional settlement, natural resources use, recreation and tourism and their sustainability Significant protection Comprehensiv e Protection Table 6 Table Classification of Coastal Lakes – Summary of Data. Independent public inquiry into Coastal Lakes – Final Report 2002 Plate 8 4Feb 2010 Flood event – turbid water in Moncks Creek Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief P a g e | 19 Table 7 below outlines the multiple scale characteristics linked to the lakes’ systems, which was adapted from the Resilience Alliance Practitioners Workbook. Table 7 Multiple Scale Estuary Health Domain Scale Larger Large Description of Scale and Factor Global climate change with localised higher risk of prolonged regional drought and more frequent floods, sea surges and storm events. Catchment health including management of fire, native vegetation and riparian zone clearing; Entrance intermittently open. Prolonged local droughts. Focal Water quality, tidal flows, sedimentation, cultural values and impacts on flora and fauna of the lake Small Water quality of vulnerable areas such as smaller arms/tributaries Conservation of individual species such as the Pied Oystercatcher Ecological Smaller Larger Large Focal Social Small Global Environmental Legislation and Policy State and federal legislation Urban development and public education, maintenance of cultural significance of lake and health of community Sewerage systems and stormwater runoff Smaller Urban gardens and awareness of impact on catchment Large Commercial fishing Focal Tourism and recreational fishing Small Infrastructure and amenities (roads, bridges, easements, walking tracks) local community amenity Smaller Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Processes that influence Estuary Health Decreased flows into lake, with occasional destructive high flows leads to decreased oxygen levels, increased algal blooms and Eutrophication. High rainfall events further increase nutrient loads into lake system. A full flush occurs when a flood event opens the mouth; but floods threaten infrastructure and aquatic habitat. Catchment health impacts on water quality from runoff and status of riparian zones affects aquatic ecosystem health. Small mosaic fire regimes within Bournda National Park & nearby rural/forested property decreases wild fire intensity & habitat loss; helps native germinations; drought severely impacts on ecosystems. Water quality impacts on overall ecosystem health and resilience of lake system, water inflows are essential for health of whole ecosystem, tidal flows encourage exchange of nutrients with oceanic waters and recruitment of species into the lake Highly influenced by agricultural runoff and status of riparian areas. Through active community involvement in monitoring and health assessment, they are able to undertake management actions on their properties to improve habitat and protect species; control of domestic animals and stock also helps. Federal and State policy influenced by global policy Local Councils must comply with State and Federal policy such as Planning and Development Local planning laws and educational material on human impacts on ecosystem. Access to employment, health and education. Community awareness. Demographic changes. Conversion to systems which won't impact on water quality (sewerage upgrades). Being aware of stormwater impacts on water quality through project participation and communication. Planting local, native plants for wildlife, removal exotic pest species, decrease in green waste dumping, decrease in use of chemicals on garden and sweep up debris and dispose of properly. Overexploitation or destructive harvesting methods can lead to species or habitat loss Impacts on habitats and water quality (motorised boating and recreation impacts to seagrass beds, walking on bird nests, not aware of what fish species can be taken and at what age/size). Possibility of exotic species introduced. tourism impacts can be moderated by signage and pamphlets Increased infrastructure increases the impact of human activities fishing, walking, boating and swimming Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief 3.2 P a g e | 20 Coastal Risks – Climate Change - Overview Climate Change Impacts - Overview The potential impacts of climate change on the far south coast of NSW are high with vulnerability to frequency and intensity of drought, severe storms (greater soil erosion), bushfire events and extreme temperatures. It has also been projected by DWE that a decrease in mean annual rain runoff of between 0-20% will have consequences for water quality on the South Coast. (DWE, 2008) Figure 4 Trend in Annual Total Rainfall 1970-2011 – Bureau of Meteorology (BOM, 2012) Figure 5 Trend in Mean Temperature 1970-2011 – Bureau of Meteorology (BOM, 2012) Figure 4 and Figure 5confirm a pattern of decreasing rainfall and increasing temperature for the region. Climate Change Risks Specific to Wallagoot Lake and Bournda Lagoon Floods and storms are predicted to increase, which will put pressure on the small amount of infrastructure around the lake. Wallagoot Lake Road, the Wallagoot Lake Boat Club and nearby houses are most at risk. Flooding of Wallagoot Lake Road during infrequent flood events is the trigger for artificial opening of the lake by BVSC. A sea level rise of 40-80cm by 2100, now the standard accepted risk for the South Coast of NSW according to the NSW Department of Planning, would make this infrastructure more vulnerable to Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief P a g e | 21 extreme events. In the short to medium term the impacts have the potential to be quite detrimental; decreased rainfall is likely to increase the duration of entrance closure with increased vulnerability to eutrophication. Long term sea level rise, coupled with higher intensity storms and floods could have a positive impact on ecosystem health in the lake, as the entrance could widen allowing exchange in some of the back waters that rarely experience tidal flushing. Figure 6 Wallagoot Lake – Coastal Risk mapping based on BVSC 2010 LEP mapping –See GIS Folder 3 Figure 7 Bournda Lagoon Coastal Risk Mapping – BVSC 2010 – See GIS – Folder 3 Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief 4. P a g e | 22 Ecosystem Health Assessment and Plans 4.1 Estuary Health Assessment Ecosystem health was assessed via regular (monthly) and event water quality monitoring, combined with habitat assessment at three sites. The NSW State of the Catchments Report (NSW DECC, 2010) stated that the following parameters are to be used in assessing estuarine condition and the Two Gems project collected information on those in bold type: 4.2 Eutrophication; microalgae, chlorophyll a and turbidity levels Habitat changes; seagrass, saltmarsh and mangrove extent Fish assemblages; diversity, abundance, function as a nursery and integrity of food web Ecosystem Health Experimental Design Water Quality Testing Regular water quality testing of parameters such as temperature, pH, turbidity, faecal coliforms, electrical conductivity (salinity), dissolved oxygen and available phosphate were undertaken by Bournda EEC staff, members of the Wallagoot Landcare Group (WLG), community members and visiting school students. Parameters were collected using well established sampling procedures under the supervision of a water quality consultant. Three sites were monitored; two at Wallagoot Lake and one at Bournda Lagoon. Ad-hoc testing was done at other sites during major events. Other information contributing to an understanding of estuary health was collected during: Biodiversity surveys to evaluate species presence and abundance – see Table 4 Rapid Catchment Assessment surveys (See GIS resource) Monitoring seagrass health Monitoring and control of Caulerpa taxifolia Caulerpa taxifolia is highly invasive, introduced seaweed. Once it is established within estuaries, Caulerpa can impact upon native species including seagrass, fish and invertebrates and may reduce the health and diversity of the aquatic environment. Caulerpa taxifolia was first discovered in Wallagoot Lake in 2007 and control efforts have been successful in preventing the spread of the weed. This weed is very difficult to control and can regenerate quickly from small fragments. The control program has seen the area affected by the Caulerpa reduced from hundreds of square metres to zero through a combination of salt application and hand weeding. The positive situation at Wallagoot Lake has been due to the sustained efforts (2007-2010) of the Wallagoot Caulerpa Response Group (WCRG), made up of staff from Bega Valley Shire Council, Bournda Environmental Education Centre, National Parks and Wildlife, Southern Rivers Catchment Management Authority and local Fisheries Officers, coordinated by the Dept of Industry and Investment Aquatic Biosecurity Unit. Local community members have assisted with survey work and reporting of sightings. An ongoing community education program is essential to help protect other catchments from Caulerpa. (NSW DPI, 2011) Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief P a g e | 23 Sampling Methods Water samples are collected from the edge of the waterway, using an extendable long-handle pole, to allow collection approximately 2-3m in from the bank; at a depth of 20-25cm. Temperature is taken immediately after collection and a DO sample collected in a separate bottle from the same site. DO analysis is via the Modified Winkler Titration. Samples are filtered before conducting analysis of orthophosphate. A filtered blank of sample water is used for comparison of all reacted samples by the La Motte SMART 2 Colorimeter. Sites were selected in 2011 by scientific officers to measure catchment inputs, collect 12 months of baseline data and assess ecosystem health changes over a 12 month period. 5. Ecosystem Health and Water Quality Status 5.1 Data collected Faecal coliforms, pH and available phosphate levels are all within the parameters for estuary health (ANZECC, 2000). In some cases dissolved oxygen levels tested were lower than expected and continued monitoring would necessary to investigate this issue further. Turbidity levels were generally low but as expected higher turbidity levels were recorded during flooding events and periods of heavy rain. Temperature and conductivity levels naturally fluctuated with seasonal and tidal variation and hydrological changes associated with the opening and closing of the estuary mouths. Bournda Lagoon Conductivity. µS/cm 60000 50000 40000 30000 20000 10000 0 Figure 8 Salinity, expressed as electrical conductivity – units are micro Siemens per centimetre. Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief P a g e | 24 Wallagoot Lake Dissolved O₂ mg/L 10 8 6 4 2 0 Figure 9 Dissolved Oxygen Levels, Wallagoot Lake, Jan 2011-May 2012 5.2 Estuary Health Status Water Quality testing within Bournda Lagoon and Wallagoot Lake indicates water quality within both water bodies is considered to be in good condition and in line with standards outlined by the Australian and New Zealand Guidelines of Fresh and Marine Water quality (ANZECC). The findings for Wallagoot are generally consistent with recent unpublished studies by Bega Valley Shire Council (Yee, Nick Elgin Associates, 2010) and the State of the Catchment 2010 condition indicator score of 4.6 which is rated in the best condition category (NSW DECC, 2010). The studies on water quality for Wallagoot is also consistent with previous studies done by ANU students in recent years (Claydon, 2010) however no data for Bournda Lagoon is indicated in the 2010 State of the Catchment report. Stratification of Wallagoot Lake has been confirmed (Claydon, 2010) (Yee, Nick Elgin Associates, 2010) and this may have important implications for entrance opening. Wallagoot Lake’s health according to the physiochemical and biological monitoring data was assessed as being slightly to moderately disturbed (ANZECC, 2000) The level of protection for slightly to moderately disturbed ecosystems is for maintenance of biodiversity to be set as the key management goal and this is consistent with proposals for restoration of riparian vegetation. DO% is influenced by temperature and impacted by algal-bloom fuelling nutrient loads, particularly dissolved phosphate (orthophosphate) and dissolved nitrogen (nitrate and ammonia). Possible sources of nutrients in the catchment of Wallagoot Lake are non-point sources from agricultural production (stock grazing), possible septic tank leakages and natural sources such as clay soils, which usually have higher levels of Phosphate, Iron and Manganese. The biggest impact at the local scale appears to be from dissolved nutrients entering the lake system, particularly orthophosphate, which attaches readily to fine clay particles that are carried in with catchment run-off. The Rapid Catchment Assessments identified areas in both catchments where removal of riparian vegetation has resulted in bank erosion leading to higher levels of turbidity than in undisturbed sections of the catchment. With the catchments being managed by multiple institutions, summarised in Table 1, adaptive Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief P a g e | 25 management strategies could be usefully applied, refer to Figure 10 5.3 Data management As water quality data is captured it is stored on the NSW Waterwatch Online Database. Bournda Environmental Education Centre is the only group currently set up to do this in the Bega Valley Shire. The results are available online at www.waterwatch.nsw.gov.au Regular/Quarterly Quality Assurance assessments are conducted by Water Scientist, Suzzanne Gray. Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Two Gems Draft Catchment Management Plan P a g e | 26 Experimental Design - Adaptive Management Model for Wallagoot Lake Biological surveys undertaken by education institutions, marine centre, community groups or interested stakeholders Ongoing community physiochemical monitoring Marine, fauna and flora surveys to monitor changes in abundance, diversity and health Include new research into management plan Revaluate priority rankings annually Evaluate and Monitor Outcome maintain and enhance water quality and ecosystem health Review and adjust Rank priorities in order of ecological and conservation value (high, medium or low) Rank in order of achievability Priorities and Implement Define strategies in line with funding or resourcing constraints Continually develop community and educational institutional relationship to deliver programs Establish Measures Review monitoring of water quality and species diversity and abundance Review priorities are appropriate as system changes or impacts change Define strategies Develop objectives Figure 10 Adaptive Management Model (Resilience Alliance and Santa Fe Institute, 2004): Two Gems Draft Catchment Management Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Species abundance, habitat and diversity Resilience to perturbations such as climate change or visitor use Nursery ground for surrounding locations supporting commercial and recreational fishers Ability to support a diversity of species including rare or endangered species and endangered ecological communities Improve water quality values Protection of habitat Educate community and visitors of the value of estuarine habitats particularly seagrass beds Share knowledge with wider community particularly local schools Collaborate with stakeholders Include Aboriginal knowledge, skills and culture Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief 5.4 P a g e | 27 Estuary seagrass and habitat monitoring Seagrass habitat monitoring consisted of a survey of presence or absence of mapped species in a range of sites. More rigorous assessment of the seagrass extent and health proved to be problematic with several planned events being cancelled due to poor visibility due to high turbidity levels from flood events and windy conditions. Plate 9 Wallagoot Lake during the drought, with seagrass beds exposed (January, 2009, Bournda EEC) Table 8 Bournda-Wallagoot Waterwatch Group/Wallagoot Landcare Group Members as at June 2011 Doug Reckord (Bournda EEC) Luke Brown Bob Harris Jan Lynch Ed and Viv Wildsoet (Residents) Neil Fisher (Residents) Suzzanne Gray (Water Quality Consultant) Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief P a g e | 28 6. Conclusions (including potential management actions) Wallagoot Lake and Bournda Lagoon are two very special estuaries in the Southern Rivers Catchment Management Area. Current indications are that estuary health is in good, if slightly disturbed condition but that there are increasing pressures on these wonderful natural areas which are so highly valued by the community for a multiplicity of purposes The Rapid Catchment Assessment proved to be an excellent tool for considering some of the key pressures on the estuaries and was effective in identifying sites where riparian vegetation has been removed or is in poor condition. There are areas where stock access tributaries of the estuaries and discussions need to take place with the relevant landholders on fencing. Both main tributaries (Moncks Creek and Sandy Beach Creek) have large sediment slugs which require management to protect the lower estuaries but it is not clear what strategies would be best applied in these settings. It is possible that extraction of sediment in the past occurred at different sites but an expert assessment of these sites is recommended. Landholders, whose properties were included in the Rapid Catchment Assessment process, are willing to discuss on-ground rehabilitation works but have made no commitments beyond that. There is excellent potential for erosion control, revegetation and fencing works to improve the catchment condition. (See GIS Folder 2) The engagement of community in estuary monitoring promotes learning and a greater awareness of human impacts, thereby building in ecosystem resilience, which is crucial to long-term estuary health. The assistance provided by this project has allowed consistent monthly monitoring of water quality parameters which is important for understanding estuary processes. One conclusion from the water monitoring project is to shift the sampling focus, from the relatively stable mid-estuary sites on Wallagoot Lake, to sites in the upper estuary and tributaries, including Moncks Creek. This will give a better indication of impacts of damaging activities in the catchment as the large volume of the lake buffers the response at the sample sites. There are limitations to this however, as Moncks Creek only flows intermittently. (See GIS Folder 3) In Wallagoot Lake seagrass species are recolonising areas exposed by drought conditions in 2006-2010 however further efforts need to made to establish systematic monitoring of seagrass extent and health. During these surveys there was no evidence of any further Caulerpa taxifolia infestation and no control measures were required. If no further sightings are made by February 2012, NSW DPI will move to have the lake declared Caulerpa free which will be a considerable achievement by the Wallagoot Caulerpa Response Group. (NSW DPI, 2011) Community input to the draft estuary management plan indicates a high level of support for catchment management that protects the natural values and water quality of both estuaries. The catchments contain a stunning diversity of flora and fauna, including many threatened and vulnerable species, and have been formally identified as vulnerable and suitable for significant (Wallagoot) and comprehensive protection (Bournda) (NSW HRC, 2002) Protection of these natural heritage and conservation values was identified by community participants as a major reason for contributing to monitoring and research efforts.(GIS Folder 4) A community geographic information system, or GIS, has been established using Google Earth and captures a range of information useful to the management of these catchments. The use of a freely available GIS platform means that information can be shared with community members for them to explore and study. There is intense interest in the management of these estuaries from a wide range of user and interest groups and it makes sense to use a range of technologies to enhance communication about estuary Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief P a g e | 29 processes and management. An exciting development during the project has been to map major vegetation types and link that data with the Bournda Online Herbarium which contains over 340 specimens. It is hoped that this will be a useful resource for the management of native vegetation by landholders. Mapping of erosion risk and important habitat are also planned. These maps will be developed from existing resources available from various agencies. The key to maintaining the health of Wallagoot Lake and Bournda Lagoon is limiting detrimental development, encouraging best practices for agricultural and rural-residential activities within the catchments; and ensuring multiple stakeholders are adequately resourced to implement adaptive management approaches. The challenge facing land managers and the community is to identify a set of management outcomes that prevent poorly considered development and ad-hoc catchment management that results in degraded estuarine environments. Information on planning policies applying to different parts of the catchments can be viewed in GIS Folder 5 Both estuaries need protection from eutrophication, sedimentation and habitat disturbance and there are concerns that excessive and/or poorly managed development will compromise the high conservation status of both estuaries. The presence of erodible soil types in the catchment mean that land clearing and erosion of roads and road side batters on leading to land degradation processes that put these estuaries at risk. Plate 1 clearly illustrates the threats from clearing and development and the need for good road and drainage design. Further examples can be found in GIS Folder 2. Estuary Management Process While this combined Draft Estuary Management Plan provides some valuable information on estuary processes and community input, there is a need to establish for a more comprehensive estuary management process. The Estuary Management Process can be considered as 8 distinct steps, although in some cases these steps can be combined especially for small estuary systems (NSW DNR). 1. Form an Estuary Management Committee 2. Assemble Existing Data 3. Carry Out an Estuary Process Study 4. Carry Out an Estuary Management Study 5. Prepare a Draft Estuary Management Plan 6. Review Draft Estuary Management Plan 7. Adopt and Implement the Estuary Management Plan 8. Monitor and Review This report, while carrying the title of “Draft Estuary Management Plan” may be more correctly called a draft of a Draft Estuary Management Plan or an Interim Draft Estuary Management Plan as key elements are not fully completed and were outside the scope of the Two Gems project. Looking at the 8 step process above, it is clear that some parts of Steps 2, 3, 4 and 5 have been achieved while none of the steps could be considered complete. In particular there is a need for a collaborative effort to identify recommended management options, schedules and costings. Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief P a g e | 30 There are a large number of environmental studies, in both catchments, including those from Council road works, the BVSC Estuary Management Process, NPWS fire management and university research that need to be assembled into a coherent and useful form. There is a significant opportunity here for an integrated approach with Bournda EEC, NPWS, Bega Valley Shire Council and SRCMA working together on this strategic task in close consultation with the local community. Key recommendations: Bournda EEC and Wallagoot Landcare host a workshop with the BVSC Coastal Planning and Management Committee to discuss the project’s findings and discuss completing a comprehensive Estuary Management Process for each estuary. Bournda EEC, NPWS, Southern Rivers CMA and other relevant stakeholders, including the Aboriginal community, work through the BVSC CPMC to develop separate Draft Estuary Management Plans for Wallagoot Lake and Bournda Lagoon Begin negotiations with willing landholders for rehabilitation of riparian vegetation, control of erosion and management of sediment plugs. Identify additional resources to more effectively collate existing studies and information on baseline estuary processes, including input from community members. Collate key research data on water quality and biodiversity into individual catchment databases. Provide support for ongoing water quality monitoring in both catchments. Further investigate suitable management of erosion prone landscapes including identifying soil erosion risk mapping. Conduct an audit to determine if the BVSC Local Environment Plan is consistent with the coastal lakes sustainability assessments, in accordance with Dept. of Planning guidelines (NSW DNR, 2006) Provide support for ongoing water quality monitoring in both catchments. Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief P a g e | 31 APPENDIX A Table 9 Threatened Species List – Bournda Lagoon/Wallagoot Lake Catchments Threatened Species Amphibia Giant Burrowing Frog Green and Golden Bell Frog Littlejohn’s tree frog Avian Terrestrial Barking Owl Brown treecreeper Bush Stone Curlew Eastern Ground Parrot Flame Robin Gang-gang Cockatoo Glossy Black Cockatoo Little Eagle Little Lorikeet Masked Owl Powerful Owl Olive Whistler Regent Honeyeater Scarlet Robin Sooty Owl Spotted Harrier Square-tailed kite Superb Fruit Dove Swift Parrot Varied Sittella White fronted Chat Sea and Shore Birds Australasian Bittern Black Bittern Black Browed Albatross Black-tailed Godwit Comb-crested Jacana Gibson’s Albatross Great Knot Hooded Plover Little Tern Masked Booby Northern Giant Petrel Osprey Pied Oystercatcher Providence Petrel Shy Albatross Sooty Oystercatcher Southern Giant Petrel Varied Sittella Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Scientific Name Heleioporus australiacus Litoria aurea Litoria littlejohni Legal NSW Status Vulnerable Endangered Vulnerable Ninox connivens Climacteris picumnus Burhinus grallarius Pezoporus wallicus wallicus Petroica phoenicea Callocephalon fimbriatum Calptorhynchus lathami Hieraaetus morphnoides Glossopsitta pusilla Tyto novaehollandiae Ninox strenua Pachycephala olivacea Xanthomyza phyrgia Petroica boodang Tyto tenebricosa Circus assimilis Lophoictinia isura Ptilinopus superbus Lathamus discolour Daphoenositta chrysoptera Epthianura albifrons Vulnerable Vulnerable Endangered Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Critically Endangered Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Endangered Vulnerable Vulnerable Botaurus poiciloptilus Ixobrychus flavicollis Thalassarche melanophris Limosa limosa Irediparra gallinacean Diomedea gibsoni Calidris tenuirostris Thinornis rubricollis Sterna albifrons Sula dactylatra Macronectes halli Pandion haliaetus Haematopus longirostris Pterodroma solandri Thalassarche cauta Haematopus fuliginosus Macronectes giganteus Daphoenositta chrysoptera Endangered Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Critically Endangered Endangered Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Endangered Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Legal Federal Status Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Endangered Endangered Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Endangered Vulnerable Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief Wandering Albatross Mammalia Australian Fur Seal Eastern Bentwing Bat Eastern False Pipistrelle Eastern Free-tail-Bat Grey Headed Flying Fox Golden Tipped Bat Greater Broad-Nosed Bat Southern Right Whale Humpback Whale Marsupials Brush tailed Phascogale Eastern Pygmy Possum Koala Long nosed Potoroo Squirrel Glider Spotted tailed Quoll Southern Brown Bandicoot Yellow bellied glider Plants Australian Saltgrass Narrow-leafed Wilsonia Matted Bush-pea Square Raspwort Threatened Ecological Communities Coastal salt marsh Baumea juncea, Juncus krausii, Sarcocornia quinqueflora, Sporobolus virginicus, Triglochin striata, Isolepis nodosa, Samolus repens, Selliera radicans, Suaeda australis and Zoysia macrantha. Freshwater wetlands on coastal floodplains P a g e | 32 Diomedea exulans Endangered Arctocephalus pusillus doriferus Miniopterus schreibersii oceanensis Falsistrellus tasmaniensis Mormopterus norfolkensis Pteropus poliocephalus Kerivoula papuensis Scoteanax rueppellii Eubalaena australis Megaptera novaengliae Vulnerable Phascogale tapoatafa Cercartetus nanus Phascolarctos cinereus Potorous tridactylus Petaurus norfolcensis Dasyurus maculates Isodon obesulus obesulus Petaurus australis Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Endangered Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Vulnerable Distichlis distichophylla Wilsonia Backhousei Pultenaea pedunculata Haloragis exalata subsp. exalata Haloragis exalata subsp. exalata var. exalata Endangered Vulnerable Endangered Vulnerable Located in the intertidal zone on the shores of estuaries and lagoons that are permanently or intermittently open to the sea. Endangered Ecological Community Endangered Vulnerable Vulnerable Endangered Vulnerable Vulnerable Associated with coastal areas Endangered subject to periodic flooding Ecological Community and in which standing fresh water persists for at least part of the year in most years. Source: NSW Department of Environment and Climate Change, NSW National Parks and Wildlife Search, Wildlife Atlas. Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief P a g e | 33 APPENDIX B Table 10 Comparison of Attributes of the Wallagoot Lake/Bournda Lagoon Catchments Characteristic Wallagoot Bournda Lagoon Forest (km2) 22.9 32.7 % 86 95 Rural(km2) 3.8 1.8 % 14 5 Urban(km2) 0 0 % 0 0 Land Total (km2) 26.7 34.6 Water-way (km2) 3.79 0.06 Entrance condition I I Berm Height (m) 2.83 2.07 Type 4 4 Evolution B B Depth (average – m) 2.0 0.35 Ratio of Catchment to Estuary Surface Area 7.07 577 Ratio of Catchment Surface Area to Estuary Volume (km2/km3) 3522.427 1647619 Water Level Rise from 100mm rain – forested (m) 0.3 5 Ratio of runoff volume from 100mm rain to estuary volume forested <40 1520 Average Estuary Flushing Time from freshwater inflows – forested (Weeks) 64 <1 Average Estuary Flushing Time from freshwater inflows and tides – forested (Weeks) 29 <1 Annual Areal Load of Total Phosphorus – Forested (tonnes/yr/ km 2) <0.2 6.2 (high risk) Annual Areal Load of Total Nitrogen - Forested (tonnes/yr/ km2) <1 62 (high risk) Vulnerability Score - Forested (low-robust, high-vulnerable) 13 (mod. Low) 17 (mod high) Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief P a g e | 34 Characteristic Wallagoot Bournda Lagoon Vulnerability Score – Current Land Uses (low-robust, highvulnerable) 13 18 Chlorophyll-a concentration (ug/l) - current 5 19 Rainfall (Ml) 32128 36519 Runoff (Ml) 6170 2871 Coefficient 0.192 0.079 Annual Catchment Runoff Only Rainfall (Ml) 28127 36460 Runoff (Ml) 2169 2812 Coefficient 0.077 0.077 Entrance Closure (Weeks) 13 4 Tidal Prism P (Ml) 758 11 Beach Type Straight-SE Zeta Opening Location North South Annual Drift High Low Drift Rate M (m 3/yr) 20000 5000 Entrance stability (P/M ratio) <20 unstable 38 2 Breakouts 1944-1999 8 49 % Time open 4 8.6 0.18 1.10 Mean 291 47 Min 73 6 Max 769 209 Annual Runoff Including Direct Rainfall Released 782 2824 Total 6170 2871 % Retained 87.3 1.6 Annual Catchment Runoff Only Released 502 2807 Total 2169 2812 % Retained 76.9 0.2 Rainfall Runoff for undisturbed catchment Annual Runoff Including Direct Rainfall Opening Freq. Per Year Period between (wks) Trapping Efficiency - undisturbed Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief P a g e | 35 Characteristic Wallagoot Bournda Lagoon 32128 36519 Runoff (Ml) 6450 3007 Coefficient 0.201 0.082 Annual Catchment Runoff Only Rainfall (Ml) 28127 36460 Runoff (Ml) 2449 2948 Coefficient 0.087 0.081 8 56 % Time open 4.5 0.18 1.25 Mean 291 42 Min 78 5 Max 764 209 Annual Runoff Including Direct Rainfall Released 966 2930 Total 6450 3007 % Retained 85 2.5 Annual Catchment Runoff Only Released 612 2911 Total 2449 2948 % Retained 75 1.3 Per Yr T (wks) Opening Freq Breakouts 1944-1999 Trapping Efficiency for Current Land Uses Rainfall (Ml) Breakout and Trapping Eff – Current Land use Rainfall runoff for current land uses Annual Runoff Including Direct Rainfall Data from Vulnerability Assessment of Estuaries in the Eurobodalla and Bega Valley Shires, DLWC 2000 Plate 10 The future of Landcare - Participants -Two Gems Two Gems Draft Landcare CampCatchment 2011 Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief P a g e | 36 References 1. Allen, C. (2012, June). (D. Reckord, Interviewer) 2. ANZECC. (2000). Australian and New Zealand Guidelines for Fresh and Marine Water Quality (Vol.1). . Australian Government Department of the Environment, Water, Heritage and the Arts. 3. BOM. (2012). Climate variability and change - Trend Maps 1970-2011. Retrieved June 2012, from Bureau of Meteorology: http://www.bom.gov.au/cgibin/climate/change/trendmaps.cgi?map=tmean&area=nsw&season=0112&period=1970 4. Bournda EEC. (2011, April). Caring for our Coasts - Funding Application. Two Gems on the Sapphire Coast . Bournda EEC. 5. Bournda EEC. (2012). Digital Online Herbarium. Retrieved from Bournda EEC: http://www.bourndae.schools.nsw.edu.au/ecosystems/terrestrial/ 6. Bournda EEC NSW Dept of Education and Communities. (2012). Community GIS. Bournda, NSW. 7. BVSC. (2010). Bega Valley Local Environment Plan. Retrieved 2012, from Bega Valley Shire Council: http://www.begavalley.nsw.gov.au/CLEP_info/maps.htm 8. CEN. (n.d.). Community Environment Network Seagrass Manual. Retrieved 2012, from Seagrass Watch: http://www.seagrasswatch.org/Methods/Manuals/CEN_Seagrass_Manual.pdf 9. Claydon, N. (2010). The Hydrodynamic Properties Associated with the Recovery of an ICOLL after flood conditions. Honours thesis . Canberra: ANU. 10. DECCW, NPWS. (n.d.). Wildlife Atlas. Retrieved June 2012, from NSW Dept of Environment and Climate Change, NSW National Parks & Wildlife Search: http://wildlifeatlas.nationalparks.nsw.gov.au/wildlifeatlas/watlasSpecies.jsp 11. Department of Water and Energy. (2008). Future Climate and Runoff Projections (2030) for NSW and ACT. Retrieved 2012, from www.water.nsw.gov.au/.../monitor_climate_climate_runoff_projections_nsw_act[1].pdf 12. DLWC. (2000). Vulnerability Assessment ofEstuaries in the Eurobodalla and Bega Shires. SSC Region: Department of Land & Water Conservation. 13. Global Water. (n.d.). La Motte Smart 2 Operators Manual. Retrieved 2012, from Global Water: http://www.globalw.com/downloads/WQ/SMART2.pdf Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief P a g e | 37 14. NSW DECC now OEH. (2010). NSW Waterwatch Manuals. Parramatta: Dept of Environment & Climate Change, Office of Environment and Heritage. 15. NSW DECC. (2010). State of the Catchments - Southern Rivers. Sydney: NSW Department of Environment and Climate Change. 16. NSW DNR. (2006). Preparation of Sustainability Assessments of Coastal Lakes. Retrieved June 2012, from Project Summary Sheet CCA24: http://www.planning.nsw.gov.au/plansforaction/pdf/cca24_131106v3.pdf 17. NSW DNR. (n.d.). The Estuary Management Process. Retrieved from Estuaries in NSW: http://test.dnr.nsw.gov.au/estuaries/process.shtml 18. NSW DPI. (2009). Estuarine Habitat Maps. Retrieved from http://www.dpi.nsw.gov.au/research/areas/aquaticecosystems/estuarine-habitats-maps/IINSW_EstMac_map61.pdf. 19. NSW DPI. (2011). Wallagoot Case Study. Retrieved from Department of Primary Industries, Fisheries and Aquaculture: http://www.dpi.nsw.gov.au/fisheries/pests-diseases/marine-pests/nsw/caulerpa-taxifolia/wallagootlake 20. NSW DPI. (Pending). Wallagoot Fish Survey - Durras Comparison study. Sydney: Department of Primary Industries NSW. 21. NSW HRC. (2002). Independent Inquiry into Coastal Lakes. Sydney: Healthy Rivers Commission of NSW. 22. NSW National Parks and Wildlife Service. (2000). Bournda National Park and Bournda Nature Reserve. Sydney: NPWS. 23. Resilience Alliance. (2007, June). Assessing and Managing resilience in social-ecological systems: Vol 2 Supplementary notes to the practitioner's workbook, Version 1.0,. Retrieved from Resilience Alliance: http://www.resalliance.org/3871.php. 24. SRCMA. (2007, January). Catchment Action Plan. Retrieved June 2012, from Southern Rivers CMA: http://www.southern.cma.nsw.gov.au/news_publications-annual_reports.php. 25. Suthers, Iain University of NSW. (2008). Environmental impacts and techniques for stocking the eastern king prawn into recruitment limited recreational fishing havens (Multi-Species). 26. Tulau, M. (1997). Soil Landscapes of the Bega-Goalen Point 1:100000 Sheet. Sydney: Department of Land & Water Conservation. 27. Wetlands Australia. (2009). Wetlands Assessment Techniques Manual. 28. Yee, Nick Elgin Associates. (2010). Environmental monitoring in coastal lakes and lagoons of the Bega Valley Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 Wallagoot/Bournda Estuary Health Brief Shire Council region. Bega: Unpublished. Two Gems Draft Catchment Action Plan Sulisit Consulting 2012 P a g e | 38