8. Functions of a Complex Variable
8.1. Revision of Complex Numbers
A complex number is a number of the form z
a
ib where a , b
R and i
2
1 vector space of complex numbers. a is the real part of z , written a = Re z , b is the imaginary part of z , written b =
Im z . Sometimes z
a
ib is written as the ordered pair ( a , b ). a
0 i
( a , 0 ) is a real number
0
bi
( 0 , b ) is an imaginary number
0
i 0
( 0 , 0 ) is the complex number zero a
ib is the complex conjugate of z
a
ib denoted by z
If
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv) z
1 z z z
1
1 z
z a
1
2
z
2
a
2
( ib z
1
z
2
iff
a a
1
1
1
, and
b a
2
1 ib a
1
- a
2
)( a z
a
2
2
2 i (
b
1 a
2
and
ib
2
b
1 ib b
2
)
)
real number
2 a z
1
then, b a
2
2 z
b
1 b
2
i ( a
1 b
2
2 a
2 Re z
a
2 b
1
)
- a real number
(v) z
z
2 ib
2 i Im z - an imaginary number
(vi) z
1 z
2
z
1 z
2 z
2 z
2
a
1 a
2 a
2
2
b
1 b
2 b
2
2
i b
1 a
2 a
2
2
a
1 b
2 b
2
2
A complex number z
a
ib
( a , b ) can be represented geometrically by a point in the z -plane or the Argand diagram
Im z b
r
a
jb
z
Re z
A complex number may also be written in polar form using polar coordinates ( r ,
) , in the complex plane z
a
jb
r r cos
jr
cos
j sin sin
where r
a
2 b
2 z z is called the modulus of z and denoted by z and
, satisfying cos
a / r , sin
b / r is called the argument of z and denoted by arg z .
1
Note that z lying in
2 k
for k
0 ,
1 ,
2 , ....
all represent the same complex number. The value of arg
is known as the principal value of arg z .
The following properties hold:
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv) z
z , z
1 z
2 z
1
z
1
z
2 z
2 z
1
arg z
2
, z
arg
z
1 arg z
2
z
z
1
z
2 z
1
z
2 arg z
1
arg z
2
Euler’s formula is
(i)
(ii) e i
e
i
1 cos
e i
j sin
cos
i sin
giving
and which allows the polar form of z to be written as z
re i
or z
re i (
2 k )
, k
0 ,
1 ,
2 , ...
and gives De Moivre’s theorem z n
r
cos
j sin
n r n
cos n
j sin n
which holds for all rational numbers n . This theorem allows us to find the nth roots of a complex number z . z
1 n
r
r
1 n
cos
cos
j sin
2 k
1 n
n j sin
n
2 k
for k = 0, 1, 2, … , n1 giving n different values for z
1 / n
.
Remark:
By Taylor’s Theorem, we have e i
1
i
1 !
( i
2 !
)
2
( i
3 !
)
3
( i
)
4
4 !
1
i
1 !
2 !
2
i
3
3 !
4
4 !
4 k
( 4 k )!
i
( 4 k
( i
)
4 k
( 4 k )!
4 k
1
1 )!
( i
( 4 k
)
4 k
1
1 )!
( 4 k
4 k
2
2 )!
( i
( 4 k
)
4 k
2
2 )!
i
( 4 k
4 k
3
3 )!
( i
( 4 k
)
4 k
3
3 )!
1
2 !
2
cos
4
4 !
i sin
4 k
( 4 k )!
4 k
2
( 4 k
2 )!
i
1 !
3 !
3
( 4 k
4 k
1
1 )!
( 4 k
4 k
3
3 )!
As we learned that by Taylor’s Theorem, we have cos
sin
1
2 !
2
1 !
3
3 !
4 !
4
( 4
k
4 k
( 4 k )!
4 k
1
1 )!
( 4
4 k
2 k
2 )!
( 4
4 k
3 k
3 )!
8.2. Curves and Regions in the Complex Plane
2
If x and y are real variables, then z
x
iy is complex variable. Curves and regions in the complex plane may be represented by equations and inequalities involving z .
Example
If z
0
x
0
iy
0
is a fixed complex number, z
z
0
is the distance between z and z
O
, and z
z
0
= r is the equation of a circle centered at z with radius r .
0
Im z r z o
Re
Re z z
z
0
r describes any point inside the circle and specifies an open circular disc. z
z
0
r includes points on the circle and is a closed circular disc. z
z
0
r is the region exterior to the circle. Similarly, r
1
z
z
0
r
2
describes an open annulus
Im z r
1 z o r
2
Re
Re z
Example
(i) arg z
1 half line
3
Im z
Im arg z
Re z
(ii) y > 0 upper half plane y < 0 lower half plane x > 0 right half plane x < 0 let half plane
(iii)
2
Im z
5 a strip of width 3
Im z
5
2
Re z
0
Example
Determine the locus of z
2
z
3
Sol:
Geometrically: z must be equi-distant from the points –2 and –3, i.e. the locus is the line x = 5/2.
“Mathematically” : Let z=x+jy , then
x
2
x
2
jy y
2
1 2
2
x x
3
jy
2
y
3
2
1 2
Im z x
2
4 x
4
y
2 x
x
2
5
6 x
2
9
y
2
Re z
3
5
2
2 0
8.3. Functions of a Complex Variable
4
If, to each value of a complex number z in some region of the complex plane there corresponds a unique value of another complex variable w , then w is a function of z , i.e. a function of complex variable, written w
f ( z ) . Let u and v be the real and imaginary parts of w , then since z
x
iy , u and v will in general be functions of x and y and we write w = u ( x , y ) + jv ( x , y )
Example w
z
2 z is defined for all z
C .
Since w
( x
j y )
2
( x
j y )
( x
2 y
2 x )
j(2 xy
y ) we have u ( x , y )
v ( x , y )
x
2
2 xy
y y
2 x
For example, f (3+2j) = 2+10j
Example and f ( 4
w
3 z
3 ( x
z jy )
( x
4 x
u ( x ,
2 jy y )
j )
16
2 j jy )
4 x , v ( x , y )
2 y
In order to plot a “graph” of the function w
f ( z ) we use two separate Argand diagrams, one for the z-plane and one for the w-plane.
Example w
z
2
( x
j y )
2
x
2 y
2
2 j xy
u
x
2 y
2 and v
2 xy or in terms of polar coordinates, if z
re j
, w
r
2 e
2 j
w
r
2 and arg w
2
5
v y w z z -plane
r w -plane
2
r
2 x u
A region R in the z -plane will be mapped into a region R
’ in the w -plane. For example if R is the first quadrant of the z -plane R : 0
r
, 0
2
then its image R ’ in the w -plane will be the upper half plane. y v x zplane w -plane
R : O
r
R
: O
r
,
,
2
2
maps to
A curve C in the z -plane will map to a curve C
’ in the w -plane.
For example:
(i) C : y = x maps to C
’: u = 0
(ii) C : y = x + 1 maps to
C
u v
x
2
2 x
x
1
2
x
1
2 x
2
2 x
1
2 x
Eliminating x gives u
2
2 v
1 -a parabola
(iii) C : y = a maps to
C
: u
x
2 v
2 xa
v
2
4 a
2 a
2
u
a
2
- a parabola
Hence: u
6
B y
P a
A v
2
2 a A
’
a
O a x
P ’ a
2 u z -plane w -plane
2 a
2
B
’ x -axis
positive u -axis
0 P
0’ P
’
(
a , a )
( 0 ,
2 a
2
)
8.4. Analytic Functions
We need to define the concepts of limit, continuity and differentiability for functions of a complex variable. A function f ( z ) has the limit as z
z
0
, if for any real
0 ,
real
0 such that for all z
z
0
such that z
z
0
, f ( z )
, we write lim z
z
0 f ( z )
or f ( z )
as z
z
0
Geometrically, this means that f ( z ) must lie within an open disc with centre and arbitrary small radius
whenever z lies within an open disc of radius
and with centre z
0 y
z z
O v
f ( z ) z -plane x wplane u
Note that z may approach definition for a function z from any direction and is hence more restrictive than the equivalent
0 f ( x ) of a real variable. Indeed it is closely related to the definition for a function of two real variables.
Example y
Find z lim
3
j
( z
2 z ) along the 3 paths shown.
( c )
( b )
1
Proof:
(a) z = x +j 0
3
( a ) x
7
z
2 z
( x
j )
2
( x
j)
x
2 x
1
j ( 2 x
1 )
5
5 j as z
3
j i.e.
x
3
(b) z =3+j y z 2 z
( 3
j y ) 2
( 3
j y )
6
y
2
5 y j
5
5 j as y
1
(c) z = k (3 + j), k -real z
2 z
k
2
( 8
6 j )
5
5 j as k k ( 3
1 j )
In each case the limit is the same.
Example
Find lim z
0 z z
along (a) the real axis, (b) the imaginary axis.
Sol:
(a) z
x , z
x
z z
1 and the limit is 1
(b) z
j y , z
j y
z z
1 and the limit is –1
More generally if z
e j
, z
re
j
and z / z
e
2 j
which will give different limits for every different straight line to the origin. Hence lim z
0 z z
does not exist.
If f ( z ) and g ( z ) each possess a limit at z
z
0
, the usual rules for the limit of the sum, difference, product and quotient function apply.
A function f(z) is continuous at z
z
0
if (i) f ( z
0
) exists (ii) z lim
z
0 f ( z ) exists and equals f ( z
0
) .
8
Example z lim
1
j
( z
2 z 2
1 )( z
z
1 j)
[( 1
j )
2
1 ][ 1
j
z lim
1
z j
( z
2 lim
1
j
(
1 z 2
)
z lim
1
j
( z z
1 )
j]/[(1
j)
2
( 1
j)
1] j)
8
j
f
13
( 1
j)
continuous at z
1
j
Example f ( z )
z
2 z
4
is continuous everywhere except at z
2 j where the function is not defined.
If fg f ( z ) and g ( z ) are continuous in so e region (i.e. at all points of the region) then so are
and f / g (if g
0 ). f
g ,
A function limit f ( z ) is differentiable at some point f ' ( z
0
)
lim
z
0
f ( z
0
z )
z
z
z
0
if the f ( z
0
)
exists. This limit is then the derivative of f ( z ) at z
0
.
Example f ( z )
z
2
is differentiable for all z and f ' ( z )
2 z since f ' ( z )
( lim
z
0 lim
z
0
2 z z
z )
z
z
2
2 z z
2
All the usual rules of differentiation for functions for a real variable (sum, difference, product, quotient, chain rule etc) hold for functions of a complex variable.
If f ( z ) is differentiable at z , it is also continuous at
0 z . However there are many simple functions
0 which do not possess a derivative.
Example f ( z )
z
x
j y
Consider
9
f ( z
x x
z )
z
j
y j
y f ( z )
x
x
j ( y
x
y )
j
y
( x
j y )
Along the path parallel to the x -axis,
Along the path parallel to the y -axis,
y
0 and the limit is 1.
x
0 and the limit is –1.
Hence z is not differentiable at any point z . y
1 z
1 x
O
A function f ( z ) is said to be analytic in a region R if it is differentiable at all points of R . A function is analytic at a point z
z
0
. If it is analytic in a small region surrounding z
0
. The terms regular and holomorphic are sometimes used for analytic.
If a function f ( z ) is analytic except at a finite number of points, these points are called singularities.
Example
(i) 1 , z , z
2
, z
3
etc and more generally the polynomial f
a
O
a
1 z
a
2 z
2 a n z n
are analytic everywhere.
(ii)
(iii) f ( z )
1
1
z is analytic everywhere except at z =1 which is a singularity. f ( z )
z is analytic nowhere.
Example
Show that f ( z )
z
2 is differentiable at 0 but not analytic at 0.
Proof:
We have f ( 0 )
0 . And
10
z lim
0 lim z
0 f ( z )
( 0 )
x z
2
0 y
2
(
x f
2 y x
2
z lim
0 yi ) z z
2
z lim
0
z lim
0
( x
x
2 x
y yi
2 yi )
z lim
0 lim x
0
( x y
0
x
2 y
2
(
( x
yi )( x x
yi ) yi ) yi )
0
For z
0
x
0 f ( z )
z
f z
0
( z
0
)
y
0 i
0 , consider
x
2 x
y x
0
2
x
0
2
y
y y
i
0
0
2
x
2 x
x
0 x
0
2
y
2
y
y y
i
0
0
2
Along the line y
y
0
m ( x
x
0
) y
y
0 z lim
z
0
m ( x
x
0
)
x lim
x
0 x
2 f ( z
x
0
2
)
f ( z
0
) z
z
0
2 y
0 m ( x
( x
x
0
lim x
x
0 x
2 x
x
0 x
0
2
x
0
)( 1
)
mi ) m
2
( x
y y
0
0 x
0
)
2
m ( x m ( x
x
0 x
0
)
)
2
lim x
x
0 x
x
0
y
0 y
i
0
2
2 y
0 m
1
mi m
2
( x
x
0
)
2 x
0
1
2 y
0 m mi
As we can see, the limit of the above depends on the slope of the line given so different slopes will give different limits. So f ( z )
z
2 is not differentiable at any z
0
x
0
y
0 i
0 .
Thus, although f ( z ) is differentiable at z = 0, f ( z ) is not analytic at z = 0.
8.5. The Cauchy-Riemann Equations
We shall now obtain conditions on u and v where f (z) = u +j v for f ( z ) to be analytic.
Assume f ( z ) is analytic at z , then
f ' ( z )
lim
z
0 f ( z
z )
z
lim
z
0
u ( x
x , y
y )
f ( z ) j v ( x
x
x ,
y j
y
y )
u ( x , y )
j v ( x , y )
and this limit is independent of the path.
(i)
Suppose
y
0 i.e. a path parallel to the xaxis f ' ( z )
lim
x
0
u ( x
x , y lim
x
0
u (
u
x
j
v
x x
x ,
f x y )
x
)
u j v ( x
( x , y
x ,
x
)
y )
u ( x , y )
j v ( x
x , y
x
) j v ( x , y )
v ( x , y )
(ii)
Now suppose
x
0 i.e. a path parallel to the y -axis
11
f ' ( z )
lim j
y
0
u ( x , y
y )
j v ( x , y
j
y y )
u ( x , y )
j v ( x , y )
lim
j
0
u ( x , y
y )
u ( x , y ) j
y
v ( x , y
y )
y
v ( x , y )
1
j
u
y
v
y
u j
y
v
y
1 j
f
y
These two expressions must be the same if imaginary parts to give
u
x
v
y
and
v
x f ( z ) is analytic and so we may equate real and
u
y
. These conditions are known as the
Cauchy-Riemann equations.
We have proved that these conditions are necessary for f ( z ) to be analytic. Although we shall not give a proof here, sufficient conditions for f ( z ) to be analytic are that u , v , u x
, u y
, v x and v y
are continuous and that u and v satisfy the C-R equations.
Example
Show that f ( z )
z Re z is differentiable at z = 0 and nowhere analytic.
Proof: f ( z )
u ( x , y ) z
Re z
( x
x
2
, v ( x , y )
yi ) x
xy x
2 xyi then u ( x , y )
x
2
, v ( x , y )
are differentiable everywhere. xy . It is obvious that
In addition, u x
2 x , u
Y
0 , v x
y , v
Y
x . So at (0, 0) we have
u u y x
(
( 0 , 0 )
0 , 0 )
v v y x
( 0 , 0 )
( 0 , 0 )
.
Therefore f ( z )
z Re z is differentiable at z = 0. However, for z
0
x
0
y
0 i
0 , u x
v y or u y
v x
, thus, f ( z )
z Re z is not differentiable at z
0 . It follows that f ( z )
z Re z is analytic nowhere.
Example (optional)
Given f ( z )
u
vi where u ( x , y )
x
2 xy
2 y
2 if
0 if
( x
(
, x , y ) y )
( 0 , 0 )
(0,0)
and u ( x , y ), v ( x , y ) satisfy the Cauchy-Riemann condition at z = 0 but v ( x , y )
0 , show that f ( z )
u
vi is not differentiable at z
= 0.
Proof:
12
u
x
( 0 , 0 )
lim x
0 u ( x , 0 ) x
u (
0
0 , 0 )
lim x
0
0 x
0
0
0 ;
u
y
( 0 , 0 )
lim y
0 u ( 0 , y ) y
u (
0
0 , 0 )
lim y
0
0 y
0
0
0
Therefore,
u u y x
v y
v x
0
0
In addition, we know that u ( x , y ) is not differentiable at ( 0 , 0 ) .
Along the line y=x , z lim
0 y
x f ( z z
)
0 f ( 0 )
lim z
0 y
x xy
2 x
2 x
y yi
2 x
3
x lim
0 x
2 x
2 xi
1
2 ( 1
i )
.
However, along y= 0, z lim
0 y
0 f ( z ) z
f
0
( 0 )
z lim
0 y
0 xy
2 x
2 x
y yi
2
x lim
0
0
x
0
Example
(i) f ( z )
u z
2
x
2 x
2
y
2 y
2
2 j xy v
2 xy
u
x
u
y
2 x ,
2 y ,
v
y
v
y
2
x
2 y
Both equations are satisfied
x , y and hence f ( z )
z
2
is analytic everywhere
(ii) f ( z )
z
x
j y u
u
x
u
y
x
1
0 v
y
v
y
v
x
1
0
13
The first C-R equation is not satisfied anywhere and hence f ( z )
z is not analytic anywhere.
(iii) f ( z )
z z
z
2 z
2 y
2 u
u
x
u
y
x
2
2 x
2 y y
2 v
0
v
y
v
x
0
0
The C-R equations are only satisfied at z = 0 and hence f ' ( z ) exists only at z = 0 (when f ' ( z )
0 ). However f ( z ) is not analytic anywhere – why? Note that f ( z )
z
2
is continuous everywhere.
In polar form, if f ( z )
u ( r ,
)
jv ( r ,
) the C-R equations become
u
r
1 r
v
and
v
r
1
u r
Example
Suppose that u , v are the real part and imaginary part of the function that u , v are expressed in polar coordinates r ,
w
f ( z )
u
iv . Suppose
. Find the Cauchy-Riemann condition in polar coordinates.
Sol:
Suppose z
As we know
0 , i.e.
r x y
r sin
0 r cos
.
, then
u
r
v
u
x
x
r
u
y
y
r
u
x cos
u
y sin
( 1 )
v
x
x
u
y
y
v
x
(
r sin
)
v
y
( r cos
)
1 r
v
v
x sin
v
y cos
( 2 )
From (1) & (2), we have
u
r
1 r
v
u
x
v
y
cos
u
y
v
x
sin
Also
14
u
1 r
u
x
u
x
u
x
u
y sin
y
u
y
u
x
(
r sin cos
( 3 )
)
u
y
( r cos
)
v
r
v
x
x
r
v
y
y
r
v
x cos
v
y sin
( 4 )
From (3) & (4), we have
1 r
u
v
r
u
x
v
y
sin
u
y
v
x
cos
u x u x
v
y v y
cos sin
u y u y
v
x v x
sin cos
u
r
1 r
1
u r
v
v
r
cos
sin
sin
cos
u
x u
y
v
y v
x
u
r
1 r
1
u r
v
v r
u
x u
y
v
y v
x
cos
sin
sin
cos
1
u
r
1 r
1
u r
v
v r
We see that if u , v satisfy the Cauchy-Riemann condition in Cartisian coordinates, that is,
u x
y
u
v y
v x
then we have
u
r
1 r
v
0 and
1 r
u
v
r
0 , that is,
u
r
1 r
u
1
v r
v
r
Similarly, if u , v satisfy the Cauchy-Riemann condition in polar coordinates, that is,
u
r
1 r
u
1
v r
v
r then we have
u x
y
u
v y
v x
We note that it can be shown that if f ( z ) is analytic in a region then it possesses derivatives of all orders in that region.
If w
u
iv may be written as a function of z only then w
f ( z ) will be analytic. If however z appears in the expression, w will not be analytic (Exercise).
15
8.6 Harmonic Functions
If we have an analytic function f ( z ) = u ( x , y ) + jv ( x , y ), then the C-R equations are
u
x
v
y
u
y
v
x
Differentiating again gives
2 u
x
2
2 v
x
y and
2 u
y
2
2 v
y
x and so
2 u
x
2
2 u
y
2
0 . Similarly
2 v
x
2
2 v
y
2
0
Hence the real and imaginary parts of a analytic complex function satisfy Laplace’s equation
2
2
x
2
2
y
2
0
A solution of this equation having continuous second order partial derivatives is called a harmonic function. Hence u and v above are harmonic functions.
If two harmonic functions u and v satisfy the C-R equations, i.e. they are the real and imaginary parts of some analytic complex function f ( z ) , they are said to be conjugate harmonic functions.
Example
Show that u ( x , y )
x ( 1
y ) is harmonic and find its conjugate harmonic function v ( x , y ). Write u ( x , y )+ iv ( x , y ) as f ( z ) .
Proof: u
x
l
y
2 u
x
2
2 u
y
2
0
u x u xx
l
0 , y , u yy u y
0
x and u is harmonic. To find v we use the C-R equations
(1)
v y
u
x
1
y and (2)
v x
u y
x
Integrating (1) gives v
y
1
2 y
2 g and equating with (2) gives
16
v
x
g
x
g
1
2 x
2 c c -c o n s t a n t
v
y
1
2 y
2
1
2 x
2 c
f ( z )
u
j v
x
xy
j ( y
1
2 y
2
1
2 x
2
)
j c f ( z )
z
1
2 j z
2 j c
(either by inspection or x
1
( z
z ), y
1
( z
z ) ).
2 2 j
If u and v are conjugate harmonic functions, the level curves of u and v are orthogonal at points where f ' ( z )
0 .
Consider two level curves u
u o
, v
Using the chain rule
v o
0
u
x
dy dx dy dx u u
u
y u y dy dx
u x
dy dx v
u
0
u x
u y dy
v y
dx
v v x
v
x
v x
v y
v
y
1 dy dx v and the curves are orthogonal.
8.7. Standard Functions
(a) Polynomials
The functions f ( z )
z n
, n
= 0,1,2,….are analytic everywhere in the complex plane (such functions are sometimes called entire functions) and hence so is the polynomial of degree n , f
a
O
a
1 z
a
2 z
2 a n z n where a
0
, a
1
,....., a n
are complex constants with a n
0 . Such a function had n roots (not necessarily distinct). If all the coefficients are real and z = a +j b is root then the complex conjugate z
a
j b is also a root.
(b) The exponential function
We define e z e x
jy e x
(cos y
j sin y ) which is analytic everywhere (check the C-R equations are satisfied). It is easy to show that,
17
( i) e z e x
( ii) arg e z
(iii) e
(z
2k
j)
y
e z k
1,
2,
3,....
(iv) d dz e z e z
(c) Trigonometric Functions
We define cos z
e j z
2 e
-j z
, sin z
e j z e
-j z
, which we both analytic everywhere.
2 j
It is easy to show that,
(i)
(ii)
(iii) d cos dz sin cos
2
z z
1
z
cos z
2
2
sin
1 z , cos d dz z
1 sin z cos z
2
cos z
sin z
1 sin z
2
Indeed all the real trigonmetric identities carry over in the complex case.
(iv) cos( x
j y )
cos x cos j y
sin x sin j y , sin( x
j y )
sin x cos j y
cos x sin
(v)
(vi) cos j y cos( x
cosh j y )
y , sin j y cos cosh y
j sinh j sin y x sinh y , sin( x
j y )
sin x cosh y
j y j cos x sinh y
Similarly other trigonometric functions may be defined e.g. tan z
sin z cos z
, sec z
1 cos z
with d dz tan z
sec
2 z etc.
(d) Hyperbolic Functions
We define cosh z
e z e
z
, sinh z
2
e z e
z
2 which are analytic everywhere. All the real variable results are true for complex variables also.
(e) Logarithm
The natural logarithm of z , log z , is defined as the inverse of the exponential function, i.e. w =log z , for z
0 , satisfies
Let w
u
iv , z
e w re i
z .
, then giving e u r and e i v e i
.
Thus u
log r
log z and v
arg z so that
j arg z
However, although we usually have
arg z
, all values
2 k
, k
0 ,
1 ,
2 , .....
give the same complex number z , but different values for the logarithm i.e. log z is a multi-valued function.
18
log z
log z
j (
2 k
) . Taking k = 0 gives the principal value of log z denoted by Log z . Then log z
Log z
2 k
j
Example
(i) log( 1
j)
log 2
j (
/ 4
2 k
)
(ii) Log(1
j)
log 2
j
/ 4
Log z is analytic for z
0 and arg z
(where Log z is not continuous) and d dz
Log z
1
(z z
0, arg z
)
The usual rules of logarithms
(i)
(ii) log log
z
1 z
1 z
2 z
2
log
log z
1 z
1
log log z
2 z
2 do not hold for principal values but do hold if the arguments are suitably adjusted by multiples of
Example
Take z
1
3 z
2
2 j then z
1 z
2
6 j
Log
But, z
Log
1
z
1
Log log
3
Log z
j, Log z
2
log 6
3
j
2
2
z
1 z
2
log 6
2 j log 2
j
/ 2
However these values only differ by 2 k
j with k = 1.
19