guidance, exemplars, templates for solution oriented meetings with colleagues, children and young people, parents Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 CONTENTS Page 1. 2. 3. 4. Introduction Why Taking A Solution Oriented Approach In Meetings Works Purpose, Core Conditions, Structure of A Solution Oriented Meeting Core Conditions for A Solution Oriented Meeting Exemplified i) ii) The Principles Which Underpin Solution Oriented Thinking and Working. The Tools Which Support Solution Oriented Thinking and Working. 5. Facilitating A Solution Oriented Meeting Planning Setting the Core Conditions 6. Meeting Formats and Structures[see also Exemplifications, Templates and Prompt Script] 4 5 6 7 7 8-9 10 11 12-17 Meetings With Colleagues 7 Step Solution Oriented Meeting [1] : Problem Solving Meeting Generic Solution Oriented Meeting Professional Review and Development Meeting Improvement Planning Meeting Coaching Meeting 12 13 13 14 15 Meetings With Children, Young People, Parents Pupil Progress / Review Meeting Pupil Progress [Coaching] [2 versions] 7 Step Solution Oriented Meeting [2]: Problem Solving Meeting. 16 16 17 7. Exemplifications (scripted examples) 7 Step Meeting Colleagues / Pupil Council Generic Solution Oriented Meeting Colleagues / Pupil Council 7 Step Meeting Pupils 8. Templates Meetings With Colleagues 7 Step Solution Oriented Meeting [1] : Problem Solving Meeting Generic Solution Oriented Meeting Professional Review and Development Meeting Improvement Planning Meeting with solution oriented questions Improvement Planning Meeting Coaching Meeting Meetings With Children, Young People, Parents Pupil Progress / Review Meeting Pupil Progress [Coaching] Format 1 Pupil Progress [Coaching] Format 2 18-27 18-21 22-23 24-27 28 -31 32 -34 35 36-37 38-39 40-41 42 43-44 45-46 2 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 7 Step Solution Oriented Meeting [2]: Problem Solving Meeting. Evaluation of Meeting Planning and Preparation Prompt / Checklist Prompt for Keeping Meetings On Track (develop your own “script”) 47-50 51 52 53-55 3 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 1. Introduction The purpose of this guidance is: to show how effectively a solution oriented meeting can move any kind of “problem”, “challenge”, “issue” or “task” forward. to provide an overview of what makes a solution oriented meeting work; to provide formats for structuring a range of solution oriented meetings with colleagues, pupils, parents; to provide practical tools for holding effective solution oriented meetings including: - scripted exemplifications of solution oriented meetings; - templates for solution oriented meetings which can be adapted; - a checklist for planning and preparation; - a prompt “script” for meetings which can be customised. Back to Contents 4 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 2. Why Taking A Solution Oriented Approach In Meetings Works. It makes better use of time Approximately 80% of time is spent on strengths, goals and solution-building and 20% on problem discussion. It provides consistency Our thinking and work are underpinned by a set of ten principles. Everyone uses solution-building language. It focuses on what works An emphasis on strengths, resources, successes, when things are better. A focus on what people can do – not what they can’t. It focuses on future goals Acknowledges the problem and sees beyond it. Emphasis on preferred future and possibilities. It is collaborative Everyone is involved in goal-setting and solution-building. It focuses on solutions The problem is the problem, not the person. [*Sycol] *Sycol Ltd – Solution Oriented consulting, training and delivery services to the public sector. Back to Contents 5 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 3. Purpose, Core Conditions and Structure of a Solution Oriented Meeting It is important that all participants know beforehand what the purpose, structure and core conditions of a solution oriented meeting are. Purpose the purpose of a solution oriented meeting is collaborative solutionbuilding. Core Conditions the 10 principles of solution oriented thinking and practice will underpin working together; solution oriented tools will help focus participants on strengths, what works, progress, exceptions and goals; all participants will have an input in finding solutions; collaboration is at the heart of the process. Structure the main part of the meeting [approximately 80% of the time] will be spent on solution-building. Back to Contents 6 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 4. Core Conditions of a Solution Oriented Meeting Exemplified (i) The 10 Key Principles of Solution Oriented Practice 1. Listen to the person, listen for the possibility. 2. People have the necessary resources to make changes. [Sycol] 3. Everyone has their own way of solving problems. 4. No sign-up, no change. Collaboration enhances change. [Sycol] 5. Language shapes and moulds how we make sense of the world. 6. A focus on future possibilities and solutions enhances change. [Sycol] 7. There are always exceptions to the problem. 8. Small changes can lead to bigger changes. 9. If it works do more of it; if it doesn’t, do something different. [Sycol] 10. The problem is the problem, not the person. [Sycol] Back to Contents 7 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 4(ii) The Tools Which Support Solution Oriented Thinking and Working • • • • • • Listen, accept, acknowledge and agree the core message Identify skills and strengths Look for exceptions Build on what works Highlight progress [scaling] Goal setting, envisaging a better future [preferred future] Listening: Helpful Stance and Agree the “Core Message” Listening with a solution oriented ‘stance’ involves developing the ability to ‘not know’ about what the person is talking about. In other words, it is vital to set aside pre-conceived ideas about what the person is saying and listen with an ‘empty head’. The next stance is to have abundant and genuine curiosity about what the person is saying. Let the person teach you what it is like to be in their situation. As this happens, at all times be hopeful and affirming, assume cooperation and be ready to compliment at all times eg “It must have been difficult, how did you cope so well?” The listener then feeds back what is heard to be the core message and checks with the speaker for agreement. Identify Skills and Strengths, Focus on Resources and Problem Free Talk Positive change can emerge by describing, detailing and attending to strengths – in a person, organisation or situation. Taking a strengths based approach, naturally leads to profiling skills and competencies rather than deficits. What resources do people have that they might not think (or know) they have? It is in identifying such competence that the beginnings of change arise. Exception Finding Looking for times when things are going well. Identifying times when the problem is less of an issue. “In any situation, no matter how difficult, there will be times when things aren’t quite so bad, or when things are just a little bit better. These times, known as ‘exceptions’ to the problem, should be explored in an attempt to identify the possible solution pathways which will be the keys to effective problem resolution.” [1] Build on What Works “Very often, in problem-dominated situations, the task is to help restore personal agency to the person [team etc]. Personal agency is one’s capability to initiate and control one’s own actions for given purposes. Restoring personal agency encourages the notion of, “positive blame” where the person takes active responsibility for any small signs of success, rather than explaining these by recourse to external factors. Focus on: what works; current successes; small signs of progress; personal agency; “positive blame”; if it works do more of it.” [2] 8 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 Highlight Progress [Scaling] and Evidence-Based Feedback Use of scaling technique to monitor progress Evidence-based feedback – what have others noticed? “The use of scaling questions may lead to the identification of small, well defined steps which may be taken towards a solution, and may also identify further differences and exceptions. Eg On a scale of 1 to 10, with 1 being the worst that things could ever be in your life, and 10 being how you want things to be, where are you today? What makes you a 4 and not a 3? It is important to compliment the other person on all those things that have been noticed that are contributing to the desired changes which will lead to the solution. It is essential that they have an ‘evidence base’, in other words that the compliments given reflect actual strengths and capabilities.” [3] Goal Setting, Envisage a better future [preferred future] Imagining a preferred future [miracle question – if you wake up in the morning and the problem doesn’t exist, what will be different? What will you see, hear, feel? What will others notice?] Using goal identification conversations One of the central activities in solution oriented approaches is the development of a detailed description of the person’s goals, what they would like to see different. This process can be described as ‘future pull’, where a clear vision of a success or a preferred future can have the effect of ‘pulling’ the person or organisation through difficult times. Detailed descriptions of the future without the problem may lead to descriptions of times when small parts of what needs to happen are already happening or have happened in the past (exceptions). Descriptions of Goals should be: positive, observable, detailed, multi-perspective, small-step. What will be a first step towards achieving your preferred future? What will take you one point up the scale? Minimalist Summary of Solution Oriented Practice If you want to know what someone wants, ask the miracle question. If you want to know what they can do about what they want, ask about exceptions. If you want to know how they are getting on getting what they want, ask a scaling question. Steve De Schazer Notes 1,2 and 3: Text taken and adapted from “Empowering Change” Michael E Harker and Bernadette Cairns Back to Contents 9 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 5. Facilitating A Solution Oriented Meeting Facilitating a solution oriented meeting requires a range of actions by the facilitator/chair before, at the start of, during and after the meeting. Action Action Plan and co-ordinate the arrangements for the meeting. Set the tone and core conditions of the meeting. Structure the meeting. Before At The Start During Ensure all participants are included, engaged and involved in the meeting. Ensure the outcomes/actions are agreed, recorded and disseminated. Review progress of the outcomes/actions. After Areas / Ideas To Reflect On Planning and Co-ordination of the Arrangements What is the purpose of the meeting? What are the outcomes which need to be achieved? What is/are the problem(s) / “task” which need(s) to be solved? What are the priorities? Can any of the issues or agenda items be dealt with outside the meeting? Are the right people invited and coming to the meeting? What format of solution oriented meeting is best suited for the meeting/agenda items? eg 7 step meeting, review meeting, solution-building, generic? Back to Contents 10 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 Areas / Ideas To Reflect On continued Setting the Core Conditions Agenda Does the agenda make clear that this is a solution oriented meeting? Does pre meeting information make clear that solution oriented principles will underpin the meeting? Does pre meeting information make clear that approximately 80% of the meeting will focus on solution-building? Do the agenda items emphasise that this is a collaborative and solution oriented meeting? Eg Working together to develop positive behaviour strategies … How to recognise the achievements of our pupils… Recording of Actions / Outcomes How will the actions/outcomes be recorded? [see templates] How will you record actions/outcomes during the meeting? Who will do this? Is a timekeeper needed? Meeting Area Are the principles on view in the meeting area? Are the necessary equipment and resources in place? Water / refreshments available? “Prompt” / “script” A “prompt” / “script” mapped to the agenda can be a useful aid for the facilitator to keep things on track. [see templates and exemplifications of meetings] Back to Contents 11 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 6. SOLUTION ORIENTED MEETING FORMATS and STRUCTURES The following meeting formats cover a range of meeting styles and are not meant to be prescriptive. Some meetings will have a range of structures within them. All will have a focus on strengths, what works, exceptions and goals. There are exemplifications [scripted examples] for some of the meetings on pages 1827 and templates for each meeting style on pages 28-49. There is also a “prompt” script for structuring meetings and keeping meetings on track which can be adapted to your own situation see pages 51-53. MEETINGS WITH COLLEAGUES 7 Step Solution Oriented Meeting (Problem Solving Meeting) See Exemplification on page 18-21 and Template on page 28-31 For Team / Staff Meetings. The 7 Step Solution Oriented Meeting is a problem solving format which can be used in any meeting with colleagues to solve a problem. It can also be used in pupil council meetings etc. There is a similar 7 Step meeting for using with pupils and parents. The techniques which can be incorporated into the 7 Step Solution Oriented Meeting are: • • • • Problem-free talk Goal identification and setting Exceptions-finding Scaling The 7 steps are: Step 1: Relaxation/focusing - settling in, problem free talk Step 2: Problem description - where we are now, scaling Step 3: Problem identification - what needs to change -ideas generation Step 4: Problem prioritisation - agree what needs to be worked on Step 5: Solution generation - how we will do this - ideas generation Step 6: Solution prioritisation - agree on how we will do this Step 7: Action planning - agree who will do what and when The meeting is recorded on the template as the meeting progresses [using laptop and projector/interactive whiteboard] or on a flipchart so that all stages of the solution-finding are recorded. The completed template or flip chart pages serve/s a dual purpose as a record of the meeting [minutes] and an action plan. 12 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 Back to Contents Generic Solution Oriented Meeting See Exemplification on page 22-23 and Template on page 32-34 For meetings with colleagues, with pupils and with pupils and parents. This structure can be used to facilitate a range of solution oriented meetings. Structure 1. Settling In and Establishing Core Conditions For each agenda item [problem] 2. 3. 4. 5. Acknowledge the problem / challenge and agree the core message Focus on: skills, strengths and resource; exceptions; what’s working; progress. Identify preferred future and set goals Agree Action Planning Professional Review and Development Meeting See template on page 35 For one to one meetings. This format can be used for professional review and development meetings It uses a few simple questions to good effect for individual planning and focuses on what’s working. What’s gone well this year/term? (explore positives and reflect back skills) What’s been challenging? (identify issues, what needs to improve) What do you want to be doing/where do you want to be next year? (Future focus) How will you get there? (What Continuing Professional Development [CPD] is needed? What changes are required?) How can I support you? (management support) It would be great to do it all – as well as a little – what will you do first? (collapse the goals and prioritise CPD). 13 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 Back to Contents Improvement Planning Meeting See template on pages 36-37 with solution oriented questions See template on pages 38-39 –template without questions For any planning meeting: team; departmental improvement; whole school improvement; pupil council. PLAN, DO, REVIEW CYCLE [based on Journey To Excellence 4: Planning For Excellence ] 1. VISIONING Preferred Future/Future Plans/Goal Identification Identify where we want to be… 2. a) AGREE OUTCOMES Agree where we are now, scaling [baseline] … Agree the outcomes we are going to achieve - the difference we want to make… b) AGREE OUTCOME INDICATORS Agree how we will know we have achieved these outcomes and made a difference :what we will see, hear, feel… Evidence [Qualitative, quantitative] 3. ACTION PLAN for achieving these outcomes WHAT we will do [See 2a] HOW we will do this WHO will do what WHEN we will do this 4. EVALUATING PROGRESS and IMPACT how we will make sure the Action Plan is happening how we will measure impact –have we made a difference? How we will take forward what we have learned - Back to Step 1 Back to Contents 14 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 Coaching Meeting See template on pages 40-41 For one to one meetings where the person being coached [coachee] has identified a change s/he wants to make. Problem free talk and competency profiling: What the coachee wants to achieve from the meeting, his/her strengths, skills and qualities. Goal Identification: Where the coachee would like to be- when things are different what will this be like? And what else? Exception Finding: When things are different or going better what is the coachee doing? And what else? Scaling: Where coachee is today in terms of the problem/challenge, what needs to happen to progress up the scale? And what else? Action planning: What the coachee is going to do to move one step up the scale. How will s/he know? Who else will know? Back to Contents 15 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 MEETINGS WITH PUPILS AND WITH PUPILS AND PARENTS Pupil Review Meeting See template on page 42 For progress review meetings [one to one / pupil and parents/ multi agency / tracking progress eg by key professional] This format can be used in any meeting with pupils, and pupils and parents to review progress. It can be used for re-admission meetings after exclusion. It focuses on what’s working and on next steps with agreed action/s. It is intended that the meeting is recorded on the template as the meeting progresses [using laptop and projector/interactive whiteboard] so that all participants can view the strengths and skills of the child/young person and next steps. The completed template serves a dual purpose as a record of the meeting [minutes] and an action plan. Pupil Progress / Coaching Meeting : One To One Two Versions See Template on pages 43-44 and Template on pages 45-46 This format provides a structure for a solution oriented meeting which focuses on: what’s working in a child / young person’s life, goal setting and next steps. The facilitator can be the key adult eg class teacher/ tutor/ guidance teacher. The format can be used to review progress and/or to coach a child / young person to come up with his/her own solution. Back to Contents 16 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 Pupil / Parents: 7 Step Solution Oriented Meeting (Problem Solving Meeting) See Exemplification on page 24-27 and Template on page 47-49 The 7 Step Solution Oriented Meeting is a problem solving format which can be used in any meeting with pupils, and pupils and parents, to solve a problem. Similar format can be used for meetings with colleagues see page 28-31 The techniques which can be incorporated into the 7 Step Solution Oriented Meeting are: • • • • Problem-free talk Goal identification and setting Exceptions-finding Scaling The 7 steps are: Step 1: Relaxation/focusing - problem free talk Step 2: Problem description - where we are now Step 3: Problem identification - what needs to change -ideas generation Step 4: Problem prioritisation - agree what needs to be worked on Step 5: Solution generation - how we will do this - ideas generation Step 6: Solution prioritisation - agree on how we will do this Step 7: Action planning - agree who will do what and when The meeting is recorded on the template as the meeting progresses [using laptop and projector/interactive whiteboard] or on a flipchart so that all stages of the solution-finding are recorded. The completed template or flip chart pages serve/s a dual purpose as a record of the meeting [minutes] and an action plan. Back to Contents 17 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 7. EXEMPLIFICATIONS OF MEETINGS 7 Step Solution Oriented Meeting (Problem Solving Meeting) EXEMPLIFICATION Colleagues/Pupil Council The 7 Step Solution Oriented Meeting is a problem solving format which can be used in any meeting with colleagues/pupil council etc to solve a problem. The meeting is recorded on the template as the meeting progresses [using laptop and projector/interactive whiteboard] or on a flipchart so that all stages of the solution-finding are recorded. The completed template or flip chart pages serve/s a dual purpose as a record of the meeting [minutes] and an action plan. The techniques which can be incorporated into the 7 Step Solution Oriented Meeting are: • • • • Problem-free talk Goal identification and setting Exceptions-finding Scaling Welcome to this solution oriented 7 Step Meeting! Staff/ Pupil Council etc Step 1: Relaxation/focusing Step 2: Problem description Step 3: Problem identification Step 4: Problem prioritisation VOTING Step 5: Solution generation Step 6: Solution prioritisation VOTING Step 7: Action planning 18 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 7 Step Meeting Exemplification: Colleagues Step 1 RELAXATION / FOCUSING “Problem Owner”/ Facilitator “The next ___45__ minutes are really important for us all. We are here to focus on working together and doing our best to help us move ahead with how to recognise our pupils’ achievements more effectively so that all pupils’ achievements are celebrated and recorded consistently.” Step 2 PROBLEM DESCRIPTION Facilitator gives the facts and not personal views. Tools used: Preferred Future – where we want to be when “problem” doesn’t exit. Scaling – where we are now in terms of the “problem” 1 to 10 What needs to happen to make this a worthwhile meeting. “We are going to spend the next 45 minutes working together on how to recognise our pupils’ achievements more effectively in our school so that all pupils’ achievements are celebrated and recorded consistently. Preferred future At the moment we have a rewards system which has been running for two years and has been evaluated as good practice and we also have some inspiring practice in departments where pupils are rewarded creatively for their achievements. Scaling To make this a worthwhile meeting we need to work on how to recognise our pupils’ achievements more effectively in our school so that all achievements are recognised and recorded quickly and consistently.” What needs to happen Step 3 PROBLEM IDENTIFICATION [LIST ON WHITEBOARD OR FLIPCHART] Facilitator “What are the real issues/concerns which we need to work on so that all of our pupils’ achievements are recognised and recorded more effectively and consistently in our school?” Let’s list them as How to’s [BRAIN STORMING EXERCISE] How to: Examples how to ensure all staff use the rewards system consistently how to ensure all pupil achievements are flagged up how to involve pupils in recognising achievements how to involve parents in recognising achievements etc 19 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 Step 4 PROBLEM PRIORITISATION [VOTING EXERCISE 5 Sticky dots/votes] Facilitator “Which of these How to’s do you think, if we work together on, would help best? You have 5 votes. [can use sticky dots] You can put them beside one idea or spread them out.” After voting, “how to ensure all staff use the rewards system consistently” has the most votes. Step 5 SOLUTION GENERATION Facilitator “In how many ways might we work together on ‘How to ensure all staff use the rewards system consistently’ ” IDEAS Examples Refresh the rewards system. Revisit / relaunch the rewards system at the beginning of each session. Key person / tutor to gather in and record all information on achievements. Pupils to have responsibility for sharing and recording all achievements with tutor. etc Step 6 SOLUTION PRIORITISATION [VOTING EXERCISE 5 Sticky dots/votes] Facilitator “Which idea/s in Step 5 do you think will be the best to help with recognising our pupils’ achievements more effectively.” – the challenge we spoke about at the beginning of the meeting. You have 5 votes for the idea/s you believe will sort the problem out.” “After voting, “Revisit / relaunch the rewards system at the beginning of each session” is the solution we have prioritised to ensure all staff use the rewards system consistently.” 20 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 Step 7 ACTION PLANNING [COMPLETE ON WHITEBOARD OR FLIPCHART] Facilitator “We have agreed to revisit / relaunch the rewards system at the beginning of each session in order to recognise our pupils’ achievements more effectively. We can complete our Action Plan now. What Action complete Who complete How complete By when complete Date of next meeting to check progress..” If the group feels that more than one of the solutions in Step 5 is worth taking forward it can also be included in the Action Plan. If more than one problem/issue is to be addressed you can start again from Step 4. Back to Contents Back to Meeting Format Page 12 21 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 Generic Solution Oriented Meeting EXEMPLIFICATION This is not meant to be prescriptive and the meeting format can be modified to suit most meetings where solutions and agreed actions are required. 1. Settling In and Establishing Core Conditions For each agenda item [problem] 2. Acknowledge the problem / challenge and agree the core message 3. Focus on: skills, strengths and resource; exceptions; what’s working; progress. 4. Identify preferred future and set goals 5. Agree Action Planning SETTLING IN and ESTABLISHING CORE CONDITIONS Agenda has solution oriented titles for each item. 80 / 20% solution- building focus of meeting is clear. Facilitator Purpose of Meeting and Tone Setting “Welcome to this solution oriented meeting. The purpose of our meeting is collaborative solution-building. We are here to work together on how to: read out agenda items eg improve positive relationships in the playground, develop a Wellbeing Festival etc “My role is to keep us all focused on solution-building and to apply the 80/20 rule. That means we will spend approximately 20% of time discussing the issue/challenge and 80% of our time on what’s working and solution-building.” ACKNOWLEDGE THE PROBLEM Facilitator: “Agenda Item One: How to improve positive relationships in the playground I’d like us to spend 5 minutes summarising what the problems/challenges are and try and do this in a couple of sentences [each]. We will record what the challenges are on the whiteboard / flipchart.” Appoint scribe - Encourage interruption free problem talk and “we” and “us” rather than “you” and “I” language. The problem is the problem, not the person. Listen to the issues and resist the urge to come up with solutions or to challenge views. This is the listening and acknowledging Core Message stage. 22 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 WHAT WORKS / Scaling Facilitator: “Now that we have spent 5 minutes looking at the problem/challenge we will spend 20 minutes looking at what’s working and solution-building. We will start by spending 10 minutes looking at what’s working in promoting positive relationships in the playground . We will focus on the skills and strengths we already have, the exceptions – times when things are going well and what we can do more of. Headings on whiteboard / flipchart WHAT WORKS [strengths, skills, resources, exceptions] WHAT WE CAN DO MORE OF / DIFFERENTLY [strategies / actions] PREFERRED FUTURE / GOAL IDENTIFICATION Facilitator: “Now let’s spend 10 minutes focusing on where we want to be with promoting positive relationships in the playground” and agreeing a realistic Action Plan. Headings on whiteboard / flipchart PREFERRED FUTURE [what we want to achieve; what will be different, what we will see, hear, feel; who will notice] NEXT STEP/S [identify small step/s which will take us nearer goal] AGREE ACTION PLANNING Record on whiteboard / flipchart What the agreed small change/step is Who will do what How By When What Action Who How By when Back to Contents Back to Format of Generic Solution Oriented Meeting page 13 23 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 EXEMPLIFICATION Pupil / Parents: 7 Step Solution Oriented Meeting (Problem Solving Meeting) The 7 Step Solution Oriented Meeting is a problem solving format which can be used in meetings with pupils, pupils and parents and multi agency meetings to solve a problem. The techniques which can be incorporated into the 7 Step Solution Oriented Meeting are: • • • • Problem-free talk Goal identification and setting Exceptions-finding Scaling The 7 steps are: Step 1: Relaxation/focusing - problem free talk Step 2: Problem description - where we are now Step 3: Problem identification - what needs to change -ideas generation Step 4: Problem prioritisation - agree what needs to be worked on Step 5: Solution generation - how we will do this - ideas generation Step 6: Solution prioritisation - agree on how we will do this Step 7: Action planning - agree who will do what and when The meeting is recorded on the template as the meeting progresses [using laptop and projector/interactive whiteboard] or on a flipchart so that all stages of the solutionfinding are recorded. The completed template or flip chart pages serve/s a dual purpose as a record of the meeting [minutes] and an action plan. 24 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 7 Step Meeting Exemplification: Pupils, Parents, Multi Agency Step 1 Relaxation / focusing Facilitator After Introductions and housekeeping. “The next 45 minutes are really important for John. We are here to focus on John and do our best to help John move ahead.” Step 2 Problem Description Record on whiteboard / flipchart “The Problem Owner” eg class teacher / guidance teacher gives the facts and not personal views. Facilitator “Mrs Smith please tell us why you wanted to take John to this meeting.” Record reason/s on whiteboard / flipchart “Please tell us about John’s skills and qualities. And what else?” Ask others to add to list Record skills and qualities on whiteboard / flipchart “Please tell us what’s holding John back in school.” And what else?” Ask others to add to list. Record challenges / issues on whiteboard / flipchart “Say what needs to happen to make this a worthwhile meeting for you.” Ask others to add to list. Record on whiteboard / flipchart Step 3 Problem Identification Facilitator “What are the real issues / concerns which we need to work on so that John attends school regularly? Let’s list them as How to’s [BRAIN STORMING EXERCISE] How to: Examples How to engage John in school life How to improve John’s relationship with his peers How to improve John’s experience in his Form class etc 25 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 Step 4 Problem Prioritisation Facilitator “Which of these ‘How to’s’ do you think, if we work together on, would help John best? You have 5 votes. You can put them beside one idea or spread them out. IT’S UP TO YOU TO DECIDE!” Example of a preferred option : How to engage John in school life.. Step 5 Solution Generation Facilitator “In how many ways might we work on how to engage John in school life together? Record ideas on whiteboard / flipchart IDEAS Find a buddy for John. Move John into another Form Class Involve John in Breakfast Club and Lunchtime Activities. Step 6 Solution Prioritisation Facilitator “Which idea/s in Step 5 do you think will be the best to help John attend school regularly? - the problem we talked about at the beginning? You have 5 votes for the idea/s you believe will sort the problem out.” After the vote “We have agreed to work together to involve John in Breakfast Club and Lunchtime Activities.” 26 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 Step 7 Action Planning Facilitator “ This is Our Action Plan for Success. We have agreed to involve John in Breakfast Club and Lunchtime Activities.” This is how we will do it…” What Action complete Who complete How complete By when complete Date of next meeting to check progress..” If the group feels that more than one of the solutions in Step 5 is worth taking forward it can also be included in the Action Plan. If more than one problem/issue is to be addressed you can start again from Step 4. Back to Contents Back to Format of 7 Step Meeting Page 17 27 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 TEMPLATES 7 Step Meeting Colleagues 7 Step Solution Oriented Meeting (Problem Solving Meeting) See Exemplification on pages 18-21 The 7 Step Solution Oriented Meeting is a problem solving format which can be used in any meeting with colleagues to solve a problem. The meeting is recorded on the template as the meeting progresses [using laptop and projector/interactive whiteboard] or on a flipchart so that all stages of the solution-finding are recorded. The completed template or flip chart pages serve/s a dual purpose as a record of the meeting [minutes] and an action plan. The techniques which can be incorporated into the 7 Step Solution Oriented Meeting are: • • • • Problem-free talk Goal identification and setting Exceptions-finding Scaling Welcome to this solution oriented 7 Step Meeting! Staff/ Pupil Council etc Step 1: Relaxation/focusing Step 2: Problem description Step 3: Problem identification Step 4: Problem prioritisation VOTING Step 5: Solution generation Step 6: Solution prioritisation VOTING Step 7: Action planning 28 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 TEMPLATE Step 1 7 Step Meeting Exemplification: Colleagues RELAXATION / FOCUSING “Problem Owner”/ Facilitator “The next ___45__ minutes are really important for us all. We are here to focus on working together and doing our best to help us move ahead with how to problem description Step 2 PROBLEM DESCRIPTION Facilitator gives the facts and not personal views. “We are going to spend the next _ minutes working together on how to _ Preferred future: where we want to be when “problem” doesn’t exit. At the moment we Scaling: where we are now in terms of the “problem” To make this a worthwhile meeting we need to work on how to … Step 3 PROBLEM IDENTIFICATION [LIST ON WHITEBOARD OR FLIPCHART] Facilitator “What are the real issues/concerns which we need to work on so that ___ Let’s list them as How to’s [BRAIN STORMING EXERCISE] How to: Step 4 PROBLEM PRIORITISATION [VOTING EXERCISE 5 Sticky dots/votes] Facilitator “Which of these How to’s do you think, if we work together on, would help best? You have 5 votes. You can put them beside one idea or spread them out.” After voting, “How to ________________________________________” has the most votes. 29 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 Step 5 SOLUTION GENERATION Facilitator “In how many ways might we work together on ‘How to_____________ ” IDEAS Step 6 SOLUTION PRIORITISATION [VOTING EXERCISE 5 Sticky dots/votes] Facilitator “Which idea/s in Step 5 do you think will be the best to help with __________________ .” – the challenge we spoke about at the beginning of the meeting. You have 5 votes for the idea/s you believe will sort the problem out.” “After voting, “______________________ ” is the solution we have prioritised to __________________________________ ” 30 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 Step 7 ACTION PLANNING [COMPLETE ON WHITEBOARD OR FLIPCHART] Facilitator “We have agreed to ________________in order to address the problem _______________________We can complete our Action Plan now. What Action complete Who complete How complete By when complete Date of next meeting to check progress..” If the group feels that more than one of the solutions in Step 5 is worth taking forward it can also be included in the Action Plan. If more than one problem/issue is to be addressed you can start again from Step 4. Back to Contents Back to format of 7 Step meeting page 12 31 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 TEMPLATE Generic Solution Oriented Meeting See Exemplification on page 22 and 23 This is not meant to be prescriptive and the meeting format can be modified to suit most meetings where solutions and agreed actions are required. 1. Settling In and Establishing Core Conditions For each agenda item [problem] 2. Acknowledge the problem / challenge and agree the core message 3. Focus on: skills, strengths and resource; exceptions; what’s working; progress. 4. Identify preferred future and set goals 5. Agree Action Planning SETTLING IN and ESTABLISHING CORE CONDITIONS Agenda has solution oriented titles for each item. 80 / 20% solution- building focus of meeting is clear. Facilitator Purpose of Meeting and Tone Setting “Welcome to this solution oriented meeting. The purpose of our meeting is collaborative solution-building. We are here to work together on how to: read out agenda items “My role is to keep us all focused on solution-building and to apply the 80/20 rule. That means we will spend approximately 20% of time discussing the issue/challenge and 80% of our time on what’s working and solution-building.” ACKNOWLEDGE THE PROBLEM Facilitator: “Agenda Item One: How to __________.I’d like us to spend 5 minutes summarising what the problems/challenges are and try and do this in a couple of sentences [each]. We will record what the challenges are on the whiteboard / flipchart.” - Encourage interruption free problem talk and “we” and “us” rather than “you” and “I” language. The problem is the problem, not the person. 32 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 WHAT WORKS / Scaling Facilitator: “Now that we have spent 5 minutes looking at the problem/challenge we will spend 20 minutes looking at what’s working and solution-building. We will start by spending 10 minutes looking at what’s working in ______________________________________. We will focus on the skills and strengths we already have, the exceptions – times when things are going well and what we can do more of. Headings on whiteboard / flipchart WHAT WORKS [strengths, skills, resources, exceptions] WHAT WE CAN DO MORE OF / DIFFERENTLY [strategies / actions] PREFERRED FUTURE / GOAL IDENTIFICATION Facilitator: “Now let’s spend 10 minutes focusing on where we want to be with _____________________ and agreeing a realistic Action Plan. Headings on whiteboard / flipchart PREFERRED FUTURE [what we want to achieve; what will be different, what we will see, hear, feel; who will notice] NEXT STEP/S [identify small step/s which will take us nearer goal] AGREE ACTION PLANNING Record on whiteboard / flipchart What the agreed small change/step is Who will do what How By When What Action Who How By when 33 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 TEMPLATE Generic Solution Oriented Meeting RECORDING Problems/ Challenges What Works What We Can Do More Of / Differently Preferred Future Next Steps What Action Who How By when Back to Contents Back to format of Generic meeting page 13 34 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 TEMPLATE PROFESSIONAL REVIEW AND DEVELOPMENT MEETING [Courtesy of Bernadette Cairns, ASN Manager, Highland Council] Solution oriented questions have been used successfully in the process of Professional Review and Development, as well as Peer Support. The use of a few simple questions allow for many of the solution oriented tools to be used to good effect for individual planning: What’s gone well this year/term? (explore positives and reflect back skills) What’s been challenging? (identify issues, what needs to improve) What do you want to be doing/where do you want to be next year? (Future focus) How will you get there? (what CPD is needed/changes required) How can I support you? (management support) It would be great to do it all – as well as a little – what will you do first? (collapse the goals and prioritise CPD). Back to Contents Back to format for PRD meeting page 13 35 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 TEMPLATE Improvement Planning MeetingSOLUTION ORIENTED ACTION PLANNING MEETING with solution oriented questions PLAN, DO, REVIEW CYCLE [based on Journey To Excellence 4: Planning For Excellence see model below] 1 VISIONING Agree where we want to be… plan Preferred Future/ Future Pull When we are at 10 on the scale for X what will be different? What will we / stakeholders be doing differently? What will we see / hear / feel that’s different? 2 [a] AGREE OUTCOMES Agree where we are now. What’s our baseline? What evidence do we have to illustrate this? plan Highlight Progress Scaling Where are we now on scale from 1 to 10? Strengths What’s working? Who knows? What resource do we have? Identify our outcomes. What’s the difference we want to make? Goal Identification/Setting Scaling What will take us one step up the scale? [Improved/increased] SO meeting Problem and solution prioritisation [7 Step Meeting] [b] AGREE OUTCOME INDICATORS : Qualitative and Quantitative Evidence How will we know we have achieved our outcomes and made a difference? Scaling How will we know we have moved one point up the scale? What will we be doing differently? What will we see / hear / feel? Think Qualitative and Quantitative 36 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 3 ACTION : Agree Action Plan and Complete Action/Project Plan What will we do to achieve our outcomes? plan do Goal setting WHAT will take us one step up the scale? [See 2a] HOW will we do this? WHO will do what? WHEN will we do this? 4 EVALUATING PROGRESS and IMPACT How we will make sure the Action Plan is happening? plan do review Scaling How are we doing? Highlight Progress What’s working? Exceptions Focus on exceptions How we will measure impact – did we make a difference? Scaling Highlight Progress plan Where are we now on scale? What’s different? What’s working? How will we take forward what we have learned? Back to Step 1 Back to Contents Back to Format of Improvement Planning meeting Page 14 37 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 TEMPLATE Improvement Planning MeetingSOLUTION ORIENTED ACTION PLANNING MEETING PLAN, DO, REVIEW CYCLE [based on Journey To Excellence 4: Planning For Excellence ] 1 VISIONING Preferred Future/Future Pull where we want to be… plan 2 [a] AGREED OUTCOMES where we are now [baseline] … plan The outcomes we are going to achieve - the difference we want to make… [b] AGREED OUTCOME INDICATORS : How we will know we have achieved these outcomes and made a difference: Evidence [Qualitative, Quantitative] 38 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 3 Action Plan for achieving these outcomes WHAT we will do [See 2a] … plan do HOW we will do this … WHO will do what WHEN we will do this 4 EVALUATING PROGRESS and IMPACT How we will make sure the Action Plan is happening… plan do review How we will measure impact – did we make a difference? plan How we will take forward what we have learned, Back to Step 1 Back to Contents Back to Format of Improvement Planning meeting Page 14 39 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 TEMPLATE Coaching Colleagues LISTEN Listen with curiosity Let the learner tell their story Take a not knowing stance Listen for the core message ACCEPT AND ACKNOWLEDGE Let learner know you are listening Praise FEEDBACK Feedback the core message Use learner’s words to recap goal and first small step. Emphasise future pull Praise / impressed by PROBLEM FREE TALK AND COMPETENCY PROFILING START OF COACHING SESSION What are your best hopes for this coaching session / meeting? And what else? What would you like to achieve today? And what else? How will you know later if this session / meeting has been successful? And what else? SKILLS and RESOURCES [who knows] I’d like to find out a little bit more abut what you are like at work… What do you like doing in your job? And what else? What are you good at? And what else? That must involve – list skills What skills are needed to be a good ---? Who knows/says you’ve got this skill? And who else? What other good things do they notice about you? And who else? VIRTUES [unique attributes that others may have noticed] and RESOURCES [who knows] So you are quite… funny/helpful/sharing/reliable/caring or It sounds as though you are a good listener Who else knows this about you that you have this quality/are hardworking/ caring/helpful? What other good things would s/he tell me about you if s/he was here? GOAL IDENTIFICATION Imagine the problem/situation no longer exists … What would be different? And what else? What are you doing differently? What would it feel like? Who would notice? Who else? What were the first small steps on this path? I can see how it would help you if [goal] happens 40 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 EXCEPTION FINDING Tell me about a time when this problem/situation does not happen What are you doing differently when you are standing up to the problem? When was the last time things were even a little better? What was different then? The fact that you can do x will help you do y SCALING 1 - 10 On a scale of 1 – 10 with one being worst and ten being the best, where you are today in terms of the problem? What would you be happy with? So what is it you are doing that means you are at three and not at two on the scale? How will you know when you are one point up the scale, what will be different? END OF COACHING SESSION What specific actions are you going to take? On a scale of 1-10 how motivated are you to take this action/next step? How clearly did you understand the goals/purpose of the coaching session? What did your coach say/do that motivated you to participate in the coaching session? How involved did you feel in deciding what was going to happen next? Back to Contents Back to format of Coaching meeting Page 15 41 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 TEMPLATE Pupil Review Meeting [Courtesy of Aberdeen Grammar School] Pupil Name: Date of Meeting: Present: Apologies What is going well? [Can focus on wellbeing indicators] Pupil DOB: What do we need to work on? School: How will we do this? What? Who When Back to Contents Back to Pupil Progress/ Review format Page 16 42 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 TEMPLATE Pupil Progress / Coaching [ 1 ] [Courtesy of Kincorth Academy] At the beginning of a meeting …………. What are your best hopes for this meeting? What would you like to achieve today? What is it that we can do together to get there? How will you know later that this meeting has been successful? What is better? (since we last met) Follow up questions once ‘best hope’ has been stated ……… What difference will that make?...... What else…….what else……etc. What will that look like? What will you be doing?/ What will you be doing instead? What would you rather be doing/feeling instead? In what way will that be helpful? If you were functioning at your best ……………………… What would that be like? What would you like to be doing? What would you be doing differently? How will others know? What will they see that will be different? What will they feel that will be different? Talking about the past ………………………… In this situation you have described, what worked well? What would others say they appreciated about you, in spite of the difficulties? How did you cope? What does that say about yourself? Of what you did, what would you want to carry forward? What would you not want to repeat? How would you do it differently if this happened again? What have you learned from this episode? What else……. what else…. Moving onward using scales…………… On a scale of 0-10 where 10 is your very best, where are you know? What have you done so far to get there? What needs to happen for you to go on progressing up the scale? What else…….etc. What will you be doing differently at the next step up? What else…… what else etc. How will they notice? Let’s suppose you get to the next step up tomorrow, what’s the smallest sign that will tell you that things are improving? 43 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 TEMPLATE Pupil Progress / Coaching [ 1 ] continued The next step upwards ………………… Of the thinking you have done here today, what has been helpful for you? What will you take away with you from this conversation? What would you like to see yourself doing differently between now and next time we meet? Finishing the Session ………………. If 10 equals the best meeting ever, where are we today? What have we done that has made it work this well? What needs to be different to make it even better next time? Remember! You can say “and what else” as many times as necessary as a follow up to most of these questions. Repeat the child’s words. Summarise the child’s words. Pause. Give them time to think. Back to Contents Back to Coaching format 1 Page 16 44 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 TEMPLATE Pupil Progress / Coaching [ 2 ] LISTEN Listen with curiosity Let the learner tell their story Take a not knowing stance Listen for the core message ACCEPT AND ACKNOWLEDGE Let learner know you are listening Praise FEEDBACK Feedback the core message Use learner’s words to recap goal and first small step. Emphasise future pull Praise / impressed by PROBLEM FREE TALK AND COMPETENCY PROFILING START OF COACHING SESSION What are your best hopes for this coaching session / meeting? And what else? What would you like to achieve today? And what else? How will you know later if this session / meeting has been successful? And what else? SKILLS and RESOURCES [who knows] I’d like to find out a little bit more about what you are like away from school…. What do you like doing outside school? And what else? What are you into? And what else? What are you good at? And what else? That must involve – list skills What skills are needed to be a good ---? Who says you’ve got that skill? And who else? What other good things do they notice about you? And what else? VIRTUES [unique attributes that others may have noticed] and RESOURCES [who knows] So you are quite funny/helpful/sharing/reliable/caring Who else knows this about you that you are hardworking caring etc? What other good things would he/she tell me about you if s/he was here? And what else? Does anyone in school know you are helpful etc? 45 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 Pupil Progress / Coaching [ 2 ] continued GOAL IDENTIFICATION Imagine [yourself waking up and the problem/situation no longer exists … What would be different? And what else? What are you doing differently? And what else? What would it feel like? Who would notice? Who else? What were the first small steps on this path? I can see how it would help you if [goal] happens EXCEPTION FINDING Tell me about a time when this problem/situation does not happen What are you doing differently when you are standing up to the problem? When was the last time things were even a little better? What was different then? The fact that you can do x will help you do y SCALING 1 - 10 On a scale of 1 – 10 with one being worst and ten being the best, where you are today in terms of the problem? What would you be happy with? So what is it you are doing that means you are at three and not at two on the scale? How will you know when you are one point up the scale, what will be different? END OF COACHING SESSION What specific actions are you going to take? On a scale of 1-10 how motivated are you to take this action/next step? How clearly did you understand the goals/purpose of the coaching session? What did your coach say/do that motivated you to participate in the coaching session? How involved did you feel in deciding what was going to happen next? Back to Contents Back to Coaching format 2 Page 16 46 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 TEMPLATE 7 STEP MEETING PUPILS Welcome to this solution oriented 7 Step Meeting! Step 1: Relaxation/focusing Step 2: Problem description Step 3: Problem identification Step 4: Problem prioritisation Step 5: Solution generation Step 6: Solution prioritisation Step 7: Action planning 47 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 7 STEP MEETING PUPILS Step 1 Relaxation/focusing The next _____ minutes are really important for ___x__. We are here to focus on ___x______ and do our best to help _____x____ move ahead. Step 2: Problem description “Problem Owner” _______y_____will give us the facts and not personal views. tell us why you wanted to take _____x___ to this meeting tell us about ______x____’s skills and qualities tell us what’s holding _____x__ back in school say what needs to happen to make this a worthwhile meeting for you 48 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 Step 3: Problem identification What are the real issues/concerns which we need to work on so that ____________________________________________________ Let’s list them as How to’s How to: Step 4: Problem prioritisation Which of these How to’s do you think, if we work together on, would help ____x_____ best? You have 5 votes. You can put them beside one idea or spread them out. IT’S UP TO YOU TO DECIDE! Step 5: Solution generation In how many ways might we work on How to __________________________ together? IDEAS Step 6: Solution prioritisation Which idea/s in Step 5 do you think will be the best to help ___x_____ with the problem we talked about at the beginning? You have 5 votes for the idea/s you believe will sort the problem out. 49 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 Step 7: Action planning Our Action Plan for Success We have agreed to ___idea/s______________ What Action Who How By when What Action Who How By when What Action Who How By when Date of next meeting to check progress: Back to Contents Back to 7 Step Meeting format page 17 50 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 TEMPLATE Evaluation of Solution Oriented Meeting Evaluation of Solution-Oriented Meeting Format 1) Date of meeting: ____________ 2) Please circle your role: Pupil Parent School staff Other (please specify below) 3) What did you think of the Solution-Oriented Meeting Format? Didn’t like it Liked it 4) Did you feel involved in the decision-making process? Yes No 5) Do you feel hopeful that this meeting will help things to change? Yes No …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… Evaluation of Solution-Oriented Meeting Format 1) Date of meeting: ____________ 2) Please circle your role: Pupil Parent School staff Other (please specify below) 3) What did you think of the Solution-Oriented Meeting Format? Didn’t like it Liked it 4) Did you feel involved in the decision-making process? Yes No 5) Do you feel hopeful that this meeting will help things to change? Yes Back to Contents No 51 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 TEMPLATE PLANNINING AND PREPARATION PROMPT / CHECKLIST Facilitating A Solution Oriented Meeting Facilitating a solution oriented meeting requires a range of actions by the facilitator/chair before, at the start of, during and after the meeting. AREAS / IDEAS TO REFLECT ON Planning and Co-ordination of the Arrangements What is the purpose of the meeting? What are the outcomes which need to be achieved? What is/are the problem/s / “task” which need/s to be solved? What are the priorities? Can any of the issues or agenda items be dealt with outside the meeting? Are the right people invited and coming to the meeting? What format of solution oriented meeting is best suited for your meeting/agenda items? eg 7 step meeting, review meeting, solution-building, generic? Setting the Core Conditions Agenda Does the agenda make clear that this is a solution oriented meeting? Does the pre meeting information make clear that solution oriented principles will underpin the meeting? Does the pre meeting information make clear that approximately 80% of the meeting will focus on solution-building? Do the agenda items emphasise that this is a collaborative and solution oriented meeting? Eg Working together to develop positive behaviour strategies … How to recognise the achievements of our pupils… Recording of Actions / Outcomes How will the actions/outcomes be recorded? [see templates] Will you record actions/outcomes during the meeting? Who will do this? Is a timekeeper needed? Meeting Area Are the principles on view in the meeting area? Are the necessary equipment and resources in place? Water / refreshments available? “Prompt” / “script” A “prompt” / “script” mapped to the agenda can be a useful aid for the facilitator to keep things on track. [see templates and exemplifications] Back to Contents Back to Facilitating A Solution Oriented Meeting page 10 52 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 TEMPLATE PROMPT / SCRIPT These prompts are a tool to help customise your own “script” and are not meant to be prescriptive. You can choose and adapt the phrases which suit your own style and context. NB No sign-up, no change. Collaboration enhances change. [Sycol] Settling In, Establishing Core Conditions and Purpose Welcome to this solution oriented meeting. The next 45 minutes are really important for us / person’s name The purpose of our meeting is collaborative solution-building/ to work together on how to… We are here to do our best to move ahead/forward with how to … We are here to work together on how to The focus of this meeting is how to … The issues we need to work on so that…x is achieved.. are…. We will spend approximately 20% of our time discussing the problem/issues/challenge[s] and 80% on what’s working and solution-building/ finding solutions. Solution oriented principles underpin this meeting. Remember the problem is the problem, not the person. What would you like to achieve today? For this meeting to be successful what would you like to achieve? How will we know later if this meeting has been successful? What are the issues/concerns we need to work on so that x is achieved? If a large group of people are at the meeting you can encourage participation by all by asking each participant to describe the problem in a couple of sentences to begin with. I’d like to [go round the table and] hear from you in a couple of sentences what you think the main challenges/issues/ problems we need to work on are … Listening, Accepting, Acknowledging and Agreeing the Core Message Try and use person’s own words when feeding back/summarising. Listening, Accepting, Acknowledging Can you tell me a little more about I’d like to know / understand more about… What do you mean by.........? So you’ve been feeling down lately. So things have not been easy lately – you seem to have coped well though… It must have been difficult doing x / having to put up with y. I notice that you are rolling your eyes a lot and I wonder what that might mean?’ Core Message It sounds like / it seems as though: x, y and z are the main issues/challenges that we/you need to work on… Am I right [in my thinking?] How does that sound to you? My understanding of the situation from what you have said is … Am I right [in my thinking?] After summarising How does that sound to you? Have I captured the main challenges/issues? If I’ve understood you correctly… 53 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 Keeping on Track Keep referring to the agenda, the principles, 80 / 20% format, the flipchart / whiteboard I’d like to [go round the table and] hear from you in a couple of sentences what you think the main challenges/issues/ problems we need to work on are … Can you briefly describe what you feel the challenges/problems/issues are for you/us? Now that we have identified the main challenge/s I’d like to focus on working together on how to .. We’ve heard from X and Y now I’d like to bring in Z How are we doing for time? I’d like to summarise the issues/challenges/problems we have identified so that we can move on to finding solution/s together. …..the problem is the problem, not the person. Identify and Recognise Skills and Strengths and Exceptions Build on What Works Now that we have identified the main challenge/s: I’d like us to.. let’s focus on.. let’s identify what’s working well in these areas.. What’s improving in these areas? What [existing] skills / resources do we have to manage these challenge/s? When do these challenges/problems/issues not exist? What are we/you doing differently? Who knows/recognises this? The fact we/you are already doing X will help us/you with Y. What can we do more of for this to happen? Envisaging a Better Future [preferred future], Goal setting, Highlight Progress [Scaling] What are we hoping to achieve? If we/you were functioning at our/your best in relation to these challenges / problems / issues… What would we/ you like to be doing? What would we/you be doing? What would we/you be doing differently? What will we/you be doing differently at the next step up the scale? What will others notice that will be different? What can we do more of for this to happen? What will be different when we/you start to achieve our/your goals? What would we/ you like to be doing? What would we/you be doing? What would we/you be doing differently? What will we/you be doing differently at the next step up the scale? What will others notice that will be different? What can we do more of for this to happen? 54 Taking A Solution Oriented Approach to Meetings January 2012 On a scale of 0 to 10 where 10 is our/your very best, where are we/you now? What needs to happen for us/you to go on progressing up the scale? What will be a sign that: a small change is happening? we /you have taken a small step forward? things are beginning to improve / get better? Who is the best person / who are the best people to take this forward? How? By when? Next Steps / Finishing the Meeting / Evaluation Can use flipchart / whiteboard to summarise problems/ strengths/next steps/action plan. From our discussion we have agreed that …Use flipchart / whiteboard to summarise problems/ strengths/goals/next steps/action plan. our main problems/challenges/issues are.. what’s working in relation to our main problems/challenges/issues .. what we want to achieve .. where we are now in relation to this .. our/your next step to achieve this/these outcome/s So our Action Plan is that What we/you will do How we/you will do this Who will do this By when If 10 equals the best meeting, where are we today? What have we done that has made this meeting work well? What needs to be different to make it better next time? It would be great if we /you could keep a note of/ share positive changes/evidence of improvements as we/you take action. Let’s set a date for our next meeting … Back to Contents Back to Facilitating A Solution Oriented Meeting page 10 55