Project AMP Dr. Antonio R. Quesada Director, Project AMP Lesson Title: The Development and Application of the Distance Formula in Two Dimensions, with an Extension to Three Dimensions Lesson Summary: Students will use inquiry-based learning to explore the mathematics involved in the development and application of the distance formula. In part one of this lesson, students will begin to discover a method for finding the lengths of horizontal and vertical segments. In part two, the students are asked to answer a series of questions in order to investigate the lengths of oblique segments by making a connection to the Pythagorean Theorem. This leads the students to a better understanding of the distance formula in twodimensions. In part three, the students will apply the distance formula, which they discovered in part two, in order to develop the equation of a circle. In part three, the students are asked to extend their understanding of the distance formula to three dimensions. Key words: horizontal distance, vertical distance, oblique line, absolute value, right triangle, hypotenuse, legs, Pythagorean Theorem, distance formula in both two- and three-dimensions, radius, circles, diagonal of a prism, diagonal of a face Background Knowledge: We expect that the students have previous knowledge regarding: Pythagorean Theorem, Absolute Value, plotting and reading points in the coordinate plane and basic algebraic simplification skills. NCTM Standards Addressed: Geometry Standard: Analyze characteristics and properties of two- and three-dimensional geometric shapes and develop mathematical arguments about geometric shapes Specify locations and describe spatial relationships using coordinate geometry and other representational systems Use visualization, spatial reasoning, and geometric modeling to solve problems Ohio Academic Content Standards: Geometry and Spatial Sense Grade 8-10: G. Prove or disprove conjectures and solve problems involving two- and threedimensional objects represented within a coordinate system. Mathematical Processes Formulate a problem or mathematical model in response to a specific need or situation, determine information required to solve the problem, choose the method for obtaining this information, and set limits for an acceptable solution. Apply mathematical knowledge and skills routinely in other content areas and practical situations Project AMP Dr. Antonio R. Quesada Director, Project AMP Learning Objectives: 1. SWBAT discover the distance between two points. This distance may be along a horizontal, a vertical or an oblique path. 2. SWBAT develop the formula for finding the distance between any two points. 3. SWBAT apply the distance formula to discover the formula for the equation of a circle. 4. SWBAT extend the two-dimensional distance formula to three-dimensions. Materials: 1. Pencil and Paper 2. Student Lesson Sheets 3. TI-Nspire or other graphing calculator or other graphing software Suggested Procedure: The following procedures may be modified to best fit your situation. We would allow the students to work in groups of three or four students per group for one to three entire class periods. 1. Introduction: Find Distances in the classroom Have three students stand in a right triangle in the room, following a horizontal line and vertical line on the floor tiles. Ask the students to count the tiles they are apart. Why is it so difficult to count the tiles between some of the students, while it is easier to count the tiles between other students? 2. Part One of the Student Handout Students will explore the length of vertical and horizontal lines. They should discover that in order to find the distance you need to subtract either the y- or x- coordinates and then take the absolute values. 3. Part Two of the Student Handout Students will discover how to find the distance between any two points in two-dimensions. This discovery, along with their previous knowledge of the Pythagorean Theorem, will lead them into the development of the distance formula. 4. Part Three of the Student Handout The students will apply the distance formula, which they discovered in Part Two, to a problem situation in order to develop the equation of a circle. 5. Closure: Re-examine the Student Right Triangles The three students will return to their locations to form the same right triangle in the room, which began this lesson. Now ask the students to figure the distance between them. 6. Extension: Part Four of the Student Handout In this extension, the students will extend the distance formula from two-dimensions into threedimensions. Project AMP Dr. Antonio R. Quesada Assessments: 1. Student Lesson Sheets 2. Questioning techniques and debriefing during the inquiry activity 3. Group Work Participation 4. The Closure Activity 5. Quiz – Form A or Form B Director, Project AMP Project AMP Dr. Antonio R. Quesada Director, Project AMP Lesson: Development and Application of the Distance Formula in Two Dimensions, with an Extension to Three Dimensions This lesson is designed to help the student develop and apply the distance formula in such a way that the formula itself is intrinsically understood and not merely memorized. Part One: Vertical and Horizontal Line Segments and Distance Problems #1-3 refer to the following diagram. 1. How many units in length is the given line segment? 2. Label the upper endpoint of the line segment, A, and the lower endpoint, B. a. What are the coordinates of point A? b. What are the coordinates of point B? 3. Use the coordinates of points A and B to determine the length of the line segment. Show your work. 4. Suppose the endpoints of a vertical line segment are C(-2, 1) and D(-2, 8). Use the coordinates of points C and D to determine the length of the line segment. Show your work. Project AMP Dr. Antonio R. Quesada Director, Project AMP 5. Let points P(x1, y1) and Q(x2, y2) represent the endpoints of a vertical line segment. a. What do we know about the values of x1 and x2? b. How can you express the length, ℓ, of the line segment from P to Q? c. Is there another way to express the length, ℓ, of the line segment from P to Q? d. Will these answers in parts b and c necessarily be the same? How are they the same? How are they different? e. Write one expression that combines your answers from parts b and c. Remember our discussions regarding absolute value. f. Clearly explain why the absolute value is necessary in your expression for part e. g. Would ℓ(P,Q) = | y1 - y2 | and ℓ(P,Q) = | y2 - y1 | be equivalent expressions? Explain. Project AMP Dr. Antonio R. Quesada Director, Project AMP 6. Suppose two points, P(x1, y1) and Q(x2, y2), lie on the same vertical line. We think of the distance, d, between P and Q as the length of the line segment connecting P and Q. a. Complete the equation below using one of your length answers from Question 5. d(P,Q) = b. Write this equation in a different manner using the other length answer from Question 5. d(P,Q) = c. Use either of these formulas to calculate the distance between points A and B from questions #1-3 above. Did you get the answer you expected? Explain. 7. Calculate the distance between the points P(5, -3) and Q(5, 7). Project AMP Dr. Antonio R. Quesada Director, Project AMP Problems #8-10 refer to the following diagram. 8. How many units in length is the given line segment? 9. Label the left-hand endpoint of the line segment, A, and the right-hand endpoint, B. What are the coordinates of point A? What are the coordinates of point B? 10. Use the coordinates of points A and B to determine the length of the line segment. Show your work. 11. Suppose the endpoints of a horizontal line segment are C(-0.8, 1) and D(-4.5, 1). Use the coordinates of points C and D to determine the length of the line segment. Show your work. Project AMP Dr. Antonio R. Quesada Director, Project AMP 12. Let points P(x1, y1) and Q(x2, y2) be the endpoints of a horizontal line segment. a. What do we know about the values of y1 and y2? b. Express the length, ℓ, of the line segment from P to Q in such a way that the answer will be appropriate whether x1 < x2 or x1 > x2. (You might want to refer to question #5.) c. Write an expression that is equivalent to your answer in part b for the length, ℓ, of the line segment from P to Q. 13. Suppose two points, P(x1, y1) and Q(x2, y2), lie on the same horizontal line. We think of the distance, d, between P and Q as the length of the line segment connecting P and Q. a. Complete the equation below using one of your length answers from Question 12 d(P,Q) = b. . Write this equation in a different manner using the other length answer from Question 12. d(P,Q) = c. Use either of these formulas to calculate the distance between points A and B from questions #8-10 above. Did you get the answer you expected? Explain. Project AMP Dr. Antonio R. Quesada Director, Project AMP 14. Calculate the distance between the points P(-5.9, 11.4) and Q(2, 11.4). 15. Write out the two formulas for distance that have been developed in Part One of this lesson. Be sure to differentiate between the horizontal and the vertical cases. 16. In Part Two of this lesson, you will need to square each of the expressions for distance that you have written in Question 15. a. Let us consider how that will look in the case of points P(x1, y1) and Q(x2, y2) which lie on the same vertical line: Square of the distance from P to Q: (| y2 - y1 |)2 True or False An equivalent expression for the square of the distance from P to Q is: (y2 - y1)2. If True, justify your answer. If False, provide a counterexample. (That is, if False, provide an example of specific values of y1 and y2 such that the two expressions produce different answers.) b. Suppose two points R(x1, y1) and S(x2, y2) lie on the same horizontal line. Considering your work in part (a), write the more simplified expression for the square of the distance from R to S. Project AMP Dr. Antonio R. Quesada Director, Project AMP Part Two: Finding Distances in the Coordinate Plane with the Distance Formula 1. Suppose you want to walk from point A (1,2) to point B (4,6). Using the sidewalks in order to stay off of the grass, you start at point A and you decide to walk due east to point C (4,2). From point C, you then turn due north and continue to walk to point B. Be careful of the graph scale. a. At point C (4,2) where the horizontal and vertical paths meet, what is the angle measure at point C? b. How far did you walk from point A to point C? (Let one full unit on the graph be equivalent to one step.) c. How far did you walk from point C to point B? d. How far did you walk all together? e. You decide to take a different horizontal and vertical route from point A to point B. Describe the direction you could walk. f. What point did you use as the new point where your vertical and horizontal paths met? g. What are your new horizontal and vertical distances? What is your new total distance? h. Were these distances the same as the other distances you found earlier? Explain why or why not. Project AMP Dr. Antonio R. Quesada Director, Project AMP Project AMP Dr. Antonio R. Quesada Director, Project AMP 2. Suppose now you decide to take a shortcut and walk directly from point A to point B, in a diagonal path. Recalling the answers from the problem above, use your horizontal distance and vertical distance, along with the angle measure at point C, to answer the following questions. a. In the diagram above, draw lengths AC and BC. What specific type of polygon is ABC? b. In this polygon, what specific name do we give to the side from point A to point B? c. What theorem have we already learned that you can apply to this situation? State this theorem. d. Using this theorem and the distances from the problem above, how far did you walk on the diagonal shortcut from point A to point B? Is this really a shortcut? Explain. Project AMP Dr. Antonio R. Quesada Director, Project AMP 3. Examine the order pairs A (1,2) and B (4,6). Using your answers for the distances from the questions above, which were figured by counting your steps walking due east and due north, is there another way to calculate these distances in order to get the same answers? In other words, how could you figure out the horizontal and vertical distances from point A(1,2) to point C(4,2) and then to point B(4,6) without actually counting steps or looking at the graph? Explain your answers below. a. Show the mathematical calculations you could use to figure out the horizontal distance from point A to point C. b. Show the mathematical calculations you could use to figure out the vertical distance from point C to point B. Project AMP Dr. Antonio R. Quesada Director, Project AMP 4. Without graphing these two new given points, S (2, 4) and T (14, 20), and without counting the number of steps, use the technique you discovered in the above problem to answer the following questions. a. What is the horizontal distance across the x-axis to move from point S in the direction of point T? b. What is the vertical distance up the y-axis to move from point S in the direction of point T? c. What is the diagonal distance directly from point S to point T? Project AMP Dr. Antonio R. Quesada Director, Project AMP 5. Suppose you want to start at any point D (x1, y1) and find the distance to any other point E (x2, y2). (Ignore the scale of the graph.) a. What expression could you use to find the horizontal distance from point D to a point F, that will become the vertex of the right triangle? Keep in mind that distance must be positive. You might want to refer to your work in Part One. b. What expression could you use to find the vertical distance from point F to point E? c. Using the general horizontal and vertical distances from point D to point F and then from point F to point E from above, how could you find the “shortcut” or diagonal distance, d, from any point D to any point E? Develop a single formula for calculating d. Make sure your formula is as simple as possible. Refer to Question 16 in Part One. The result will be “The Distance Formula” Project AMP Dr. Antonio R. Quesada Director, Project AMP 6. Write the three expressions – one for the vertical case, one for the horizontal case, and one for the oblique case – for finding distances that you have developed in Parts One and Two. 7. Could we use the distance formula that you developed for oblique lines to find the distance between two points that lie on the same vertical line or on the same horizontal line? Explain or demonstrate. 8. For each problem below, calculate the distance between the two points. State the exact answer and an approximate answer rounded to the nearest tenth. Show your work. a. (8, -2) and (5, 4) b. (3, 9) and (3, 1) c. (-6, 2) and (2, -6) d. (-10.3, -8.2) and (-12.9, -4.6) e. (1.7, 0) and (5.7, -3.1) Project AMP Dr. Antonio R. Quesada Director, Project AMP Part Three: Determining the Equation of a Circle Start with a segment on the coordinate plane. Place one endpoint at the origin. Let’s “lock down” the point located at the origin, but allow the other point to move freely, but at the same given distance from the “locked down” point. Describe what you think will happen. As a self-check, sketch by hand or use your calculator to create a sketch that either supports your conjecture or provides a counterexample. What have the outer endpoints of these segments created? What name can we apply to the segments? Project AMP Dr. Antonio R. Quesada Director, Project AMP Think about the work you have been doing with the Pythagorean Theorem and the Distance Formula. Write a brief statement describing how you might find the length of the radius of this circle. Let’s consider what has happened here so far. We have taken a segment and “locked down” one of its endpoints. That endpoint has become the center of our circle. We are going to name the center with its own ordered pair called (h, k) because this point will not change for a particular circle. The point that moves freely at a fixed distance from the center (h, k) around the circle will still be called (x, y) because that point will change its x- and y-values as it moves. The distance between any point on the circle and the center of the circle has now become the radius of our circle. Project AMP Dr. Antonio R. Quesada Director, Project AMP The definition of a circle is the set of all points P(x, y) whose distance from the center C(h, k) is r (the radius). So, point P is on the circle if and only if d(P,C) = r. (Notice that the center of the circle is not a point on the circle. It is merely a point of reference.) 1. Using the distance formula, find the equation of the circle with center C(0,0) , point P(x, y) on the circle, and radius of 5. A more common form of the equation of a circle is found by squaring both sides of the equation you have written above. Write the common form of the equation of the above circle. Is the point (0, -5) a point on the circle? Verify your answer by showing that the point either does or does not satisfy the equation of the circle. Find another point on the circle. Verify your answer by showing that the point satisfies the equation of the circle. Graph this circle on your calculator. Explain why you needed to enter two equations to produce the circle. Project AMP Dr. Antonio R. Quesada Director, Project AMP 2. Find the common equation of a circle with center C (2, 3), point P(x, y) on the circle, and radius of 5. (Note: You do not need to expand the equation.) 3. Using the distance formula, develop the equation of a circle with center C(h, k) , point P(x, y) on the circle, and radius of r. (Note: You do not need to expand the equation.) Project AMP Dr. Antonio R. Quesada Director, Project AMP Extension: More Gems from the Math Treasure Chest Three-dimensional distances So far, you have reviewed the Pythagorean Theorem. You have used the legs and the hypotenuse of a right triangle to help you make connections that have helped you discover how to find the distance between two points on the coordinate plane. In other words, you have developed the Distance Formula. Now let’s move a step forward. The juice box pictured is 12 cm tall. The panel with the picture is 8 cm wide and the side panel is 4 cm deep. Keeping the juice box upright as shown, what is the length of the shortest straw that would fit inside the box? What is the length of the longest straw that would fit inside the box? (Do not count the part of the straw that extends outside of the juice box, only the part that would fit completely inside.) What do we call this kind of segment? Draw a representation of this juice box on the graph paper below. Using your previous knowledge about the Pythagorean Theorem and your development of the Distance Formula, determine a formula that allows you to find the length of the longest straw that would fit inside the box. If you are on the right track, you should notice something similar to your previous results. Verify this answer with your instructor before moving on to the next question Can you make a conjecture about the distance between two points in three-dimensional space? Project AMP Dr. Antonio R. Quesada Director, Project AMP Test your conjecture by finding the distance between the following pairs of points. In each case, state the equation you used in the first step. If you use the list menu on your calculator to create your results, state the equation you used to generate the list of answers. Point One ( 1, 1, 1) (2, 3, 4) (7, -2, 11) (-6, -10, 5) Point Two (8, 8, 8) (-4, -3, -2) (0, 6, -12) (-15, 20, -9) Equation used Distance between points Extension Problem: Flyfishing in Wyoming 1. Gene and his son John are going fly-fishing in Wyoming and are buying an equipment locker for their pickup truck so they can store their fishing rods in it. If the dimensions of one model of equipment locker are 4.5 feet by 1.5 feet by 1.75 feet, what is the longest fishing rod that will fit? Support your answer with a short explanation stating how they can fit the rods into the locker and by showing your work. 2. The flatbed of their pickup truck can accommodate an equipment locker that fits snugly against the cab. Because of this, any equipment locker they buy has to have a width of four and a half feet, but the depth and the height can vary. Gene and John would like to buy new fly fishing rods. One model of rod is five and a half feet long and another is six feet long. Fill in the missing dimensions with measurements to the nearest half inch for the equipment locker in the tables below. If you use the list menu on your calculator to create your results, state the equation you used to generate the list of answers. Project AMP Dr. Antonio R. Quesada Director, Project AMP Length of rod 5.5 feet 5.5 feet 5.5 feet 5.5 feet Width of locker 4.5 feet 4.5 feet 4.5 feet 4.5 feet Depth of locker 2 feet 2 feet 3 inches 2 feet 6 inches 2 feet 9 inches Height of locker Length of rod 6 feet 6 feet 6 feet 6 feet Width of locker 4.5 feet 4.5 feet 4.5 feet 4.5 feet Depth of locker Height of locker 1 foot 4 inches 1 foot 7.5 inches 1 foot 10.5 inches 26 inches 3. The fishing rod that Gene and John would really like to take on their fishing trip is the FlyMaster FlexPro that is six and a half feet long. Given the fact that the equipment locker cannot be longer than four and a half feet in width and that they want to store the rods in the locker when they are on the road, they are trying to determine different size lockers that might work so they can decide whether or not they can consider buying the longer fishing rod. Help them out by finding some possible combinations of depth and height that will accommodate the FlyMaster FlexPro. Length of rod 6.5 feet 6.5 feet 6.5 feet 6.5 feet Width of locker 4.5 feet 4.5 feet 4.5 feet 4.5 feet Depth of locker Height of locker Project AMP Dr. Antonio R. Quesada NAME_______________________________________QUIZ FORM A__________ 1. Find the distance between the points (2, 3) and (-8, 3). Justify your solution. 2. Find the distance between the points (8, 5) and (8, -6). Justify your solution. 3. Find the distance between the points (-2, 8) and (4, 6). Justify your solution. 4. Give the equation of a circle with center (4, 3) and radius of 3. Director, Project AMP Project AMP Dr. Antonio R. Quesada Director, Project AMP NAME_______________________________________QUIZ FORM B__________ 1. Find the distance between the points (2, 3) and (-8, 3). Justify your solution. 2. Find the distance between the points (8, 5) and (8, -6). Justify your solution. 3. Find the distance between the points (-2, 8) and (4, 6). Justify your solution. 4. Give the equation of a circle with center (4, 3) and radius of 3. 5. Challenge Problem: Lenny owns a lawn care business. In the back of his pickup truck, he has an equipment locker that is 51 inches wide by 24 inches high by 18 inches deep. He has a couple of garden tools that are four and a half feet long. A) Will they fit into his equipment locker? B) At most, what is the longest garden tool that might fit into his locker? 6. Bonus: Consider the ideas you have developed about two- and three-dimensional distances. Write an equation that you think could be used to generate a sphere.