Chapter 07.05 Gauss Quadrature Rule of Integration After reading this chapter, you should be able to: 1. derive the Gauss quadrature method for integration and be able to use it to solve problems, and 2. use Gauss quadrature method to solve examples of approximate integrals. What is integration? Integration is the process of measuring the area under a function plotted on a graph. Why would we want to integrate a function? Among the most common examples are finding the velocity of a body from an acceleration function, and displacement of a body from a velocity function. Throughout many engineering fields, there are (what sometimes seems like) countless applications for integral calculus. You can read about some of these applications in Chapters 07.00A-07.00G. Sometimes, the evaluation of expressions involving these integrals can become daunting, if not indeterminate. For this reason, a wide variety of numerical methods has been developed to simplify the integral. Here, we will discuss the Gauss quadrature rule of approximating integrals of the form b I f x dx a where f (x ) is called the integrand, a lower limit of integration b upper limit of integration 07.05.1 07.05.2 Chapter 07.05 Figure 1 Integration of a function. Gauss Quadrature Rule Background: To derive the trapezoidal rule from the method of undetermined coefficients, we approximated b f ( x)dx c 1 f (a) c2 f (b) (1) a Let the right hand side be exact for integrals of a straight line, that is, for an integrated form of b a 0 a1 x dx a So b x2 a a x dx a x a 1 0 a 0 1 2 a b2 a2 a0 b a a1 2 But from Equation (1), we want b b a 0 a1 x dx c1 f (a) c2 f (b) (2) (3) a to give the same result as Equation (2) for f ( x) a0 a1 x . b a 0 a1 x dx c1 a0 a1a c2 a0 a1b a a0 c1 c2 a1 c1a c2 b Hence from Equations (2) and (4), b2 a2 a0 c1 c2 a1 c1a c2 b a0 b a a1 2 (4) Gauss Quadrature Rule 07.05.3 Since a 0 and a1 are arbitrary constants for a general straight line c1 c2 b a b2 a2 2 Multiplying Equation (5a) by a and subtracting from Equation (5b) gives ba c2 2 Substituting the above found value of c2 in Equation (5a) gives ba c1 2 Therefore c1a c2 b (5a) (5b) (6a) (6b) b f ( x)dx c 1 f (a) c2 f (b) a ba ba f (a) f (b) 2 2 (7) Derivation of two-point Gauss quadrature rule Method 1: The two-point Gauss quadrature rule is an extension of the trapezoidal rule approximation where the arguments of the function are not predetermined as a and b , but as unknowns x1 and x2 . So in the two-point Gauss quadrature rule, the integral is approximated as b I f ( x)dx a c1 f ( x1 ) c2 f ( x2 ) There are four unknowns x1 , x 2 , c1 and c2 . These are found by assuming that the formula gives exact results for integrating a general third order polynomial, f ( x) a0 a1 x a 2 x 2 a3 x 3 . Hence b b f ( x)dx a0 a1 x a 2 x 2 a3 x 3 dx a a x2 a 0 x a1 a2 2 b2 a0 b a a1 The formula would then give b x3 x4 a3 3 4 a b3 a3 b4 a4 a2 a 2 a3 2 3 4 (8) b f ( x)dx c f ( x ) c f ( x c a a x a x 1 1 2 2 a 1 0 1 1 2 2 1 ) a3 x13 c2 a0 a1 x2 a 2 x22 a3 x23 (9) 07.05.4 Chapter 07.05 Equating Equations (8) and (9) gives b2 a 2 b3 a 3 b4 a 4 a 2 a3 a0 b a a1 2 3 4 c x a c x c1 a0 a1 x1 a 2 x1 a3 x1 c2 a0 a1 x2 a 2 x2 a3 x2 2 a0 c1 c2 a1 c1 x1 3 2 2 2 1 1 2 2 3 c2 x2 a3 c1 x1 c2 x2 2 3 3 (10) Since in Equation (10), the constants a 0 , a1 , a 2 , and a 3 are arbitrary, the coefficients of a 0 , a1 , a 2 , and a 3 are equal. This gives us four equations as follows. b a c1 c2 b2 a2 c1 x1 c 2 x 2 2 b3 a3 2 2 c1 x1 c 2 x 2 3 4 b a4 3 3 c1 x1 c2 x2 4 (11) Without proof (see Example 1 for proof of a related problem), we can find that the above four simultaneous nonlinear equations have only one acceptable solution ba c1 2 ba c2 2 b a 1 b a x1 2 3 2 b a 1 b a x2 2 2 3 (12) Hence b f ( x)dx c f x c f x 1 1 2 2 a ba 2 ba 1 ba ba f 2 2 3 2 ba 1 ba f 2 2 3 (13) Method 2: We can derive the same formula by assuming that the expression gives exact values for the b individual integrals of 1dx, a b b b xdx, 2 x dx, and x dx . a a a 3 The reason the formula can also be Gauss Quadrature Rule 07.05.5 derived using this method is that the linear combination of the above integrands is a general third order polynomial given by f ( x) a0 a1 x a 2 x 2 a3 x 3 . These will give four equations as follows b 1dx b a c 1 c2 a b2 a 2 a xdx 2 c1 x1 c2 x2 b b 2 x dx a b3 a 3 2 2 c1 x1 c2 x2 3 b4 a 4 3 3 (14) a x dx 4 c1 x1 c2 x2 These four simultaneous nonlinear equations can be solved to give a single acceptable solution ba c1 2 ba c2 2 b a 1 b a x1 2 3 2 b 3 b a 1 b a x2 2 2 3 (15) Hence ba ba 1 ba ba ba 1 ba (16) f f 2 2 2 2 2 2 3 3 a Since two points are chosen, it is called the two-point Gauss quadrature rule. Higher point versions can also be developed. b f ( x)dx Higher point Gauss quadrature formulas For example b f ( x)dx c 1 f ( x1 ) c2 f ( x2 ) c3 f ( x3 ) (17) a is called the three-point Gauss quadrature rule. The coefficients c1 , c2 and c3 , and the function arguments x1 , x 2 and x3 are calculated by assuming the formula gives exact expressions for integrating a fifth order polynomial a b 0 a1 x a2 x 2 a3 x 3 a4 x 4 a5 x 5 dx . a General n -point rules would approximate the integral 07.05.6 Chapter 07.05 b f ( x)dx c 1 f ( x1 ) c2 f ( x2 ) . . . . . . . cn f ( xn ) (18) a Arguments and weighing factors for n-point Gauss quadrature rules In handbooks (see Table 1), coefficients and arguments given for n -point Gauss quadrature rule are given for integrals of the form 1 n 1 i 1 g ( x)dx ci g ( xi ) (19) Table 1 Weighting factors c and function arguments x used in Gauss quadrature formulas Weighting Function Points Factors Arguments 2 3 4 5 6 c1 1.000000000 x1 0.577350269 c2 1.000000000 x2 0.577350269 c1 0.555555556 x1 0.774596669 c2 0.888888889 x2 0.000000000 c3 0.555555556 x3 0.774596669 c1 0.347854845 x1 0.861136312 c2 0.652145155 x2 0.339981044 c3 0.652145155 x3 0.339981044 c4 0.347854845 x4 0.861136312 c1 0.236926885 x1 0.906179846 c2 0.478628670 x2 0.538469310 c3 0.568888889 x3 0.000000000 c4 0.478628670 x4 0.538469310 c5 0.236926885 x5 0.906179846 c1 0.171324492 x1 0.932469514 c2 0.360761573 x2 0.661209386 c3 0.467913935 x3 0.238619186 c4 0.467913935 x4 0.238619186 Gauss Quadrature Rule 07.05.7 c5 0.360761573 x5 0.661209386 c6 0.171324492 x6 0.932469514 1 So if the table is given for g ( x)dx integrals, how does one solve 1 b f ( x)dx ? a The answer lies in that any integral with limits of a, b can be converted into an integral with limits 1, 1 . Let (20) x mt c If x a, then t 1 If x b, then t 1 such that a m(1) c b m(1) c (21) Solving the two Equations (21) simultaneously gives ba m 2 ba c (22) 2 Hence ba ba x t 2 2 ba dx dt 2 Substituting our values of x and dx into the integral gives us b 1 baba ba (23) f ( x ) dx a 1 f 2 x 2 2 dx Example 1 1 For an integral f ( x)dx, show that the two-point Gauss quadrature rule approximates to 1 1 f ( x)dx c 1 1 where c1 1 c2 1 x1 1 3 f ( x1 ) c 2 f ( x 2 ) 07.05.8 Chapter 07.05 1 x2 3 Solution Assuming the formula 1 f ( x)dx c f x c f x 1 1 2 (E1.1) 2 1 1 gives exact values for integrals 1dx, 1 1 xdx, 1 1 2 x dx, and 1 1 x dx 3 . Then 1 1 1dx 2 c 1 c2 (E1.2) 1 1 xdx 0 c x 1 1 c2 x2 (E1.3) 1 1 x 2 dx 1 2 2 2 c1 x1 c 2 x 2 3 (E1.4) 1 x dx 0 c x 3 1 1 3 c2 x2 3 (E1.5) 1 2 Multiplying Equation (E1.3) by x1 and subtracting from Equation (E1.5) gives c 2 x 2 x1 x 2 0 (E1.6) The solution to the above equation is c2 0, or/and x2 0, or/and x1 x2 , or/and x1 x2 . I. c2 0 is not acceptable as Equations (E1.2-E1.5) reduce to c1 2, c1 x1 0, 2 c1 x12 , and c1 x13 0 . But since c1 2 , then x1 0 from c1 x1 0 , but x1 0 3 2 conflicts with c1 x12 . 3 II. x2 0 is not acceptable as Equations (E1.2-E1.5) reduce to c1 c2 2 , c1 x1 0, 2 c1 x12 , and c1 x13 0 . Since c1 x1 0 , then c1 or x1 has to be zero but this violates 3 2 c1 x12 0 . 3 III. x1 x2 is not acceptable as Equations (E1.2-E1.5) reduce to c1 c2 2 , 2 2 c1 x1 c2 x1 0, c1 x12 c 2 x1 , and c1 x13 c2 x13 0 . If x1 0 , then c1 x1 c2 x1 0 3 2 2 Gauss Quadrature Rule 07.05.9 gives c1 c2 0 and that violates c1 c2 2 . If x1 0 , then that violates 2 2 c1 x12 c2 x1 0 . 3 That leaves the solution of x1 x2 as the only possible acceptable solution and in fact, it does not have violations (see it for yourself) (E1.7) x1 x2 Substituting (E1.7) in Equation (E1.3) gives (E1.8) c1 c2 From Equations (E1.2) and (E1.8), (E1.9) c1 c2 1 Equations (E1.4) and (E1.9) gives 2 2 2 x1 x 2 (E1.10) 3 Since Equation (E1.7) requires that the two results be of opposite sign, we get 1 x1 3 1 x2 3 Hence 1 f ( x)dx c 1 f ( x1 ) c 2 f ( x 2 ) (E1.11) 1 1 1 f f 3 3 Example 2 b For an integral f ( x)dx, derive the one-point Gauss quadrature rule. a Solution The one-point Gauss quadrature rule is b f ( x)dx c f x 1 (E2.1) 1 a 1 Assuming the formula gives exact values for integrals 1dx, and 1 1 xdx 1 b 1dx b a c 1 a b xdx a b2 a2 c1 x1 2 Since c1 b a, the other equation becomes (E2.2) 07.05.10 Chapter 07.05 b2 a2 2 ba x1 2 Therefore, one-point Gauss quadrature rule can be expressed as b ba a f ( x)dx (b a) f 2 (b a) x1 (E2.3) (E2.4) Example 3 What would be the formula for b f ( x)dx c 1 f (a) c2 f (b) a a x b x dx, b if you want the above formula to give you exact values of 2 0 0 that is, a linear a combination of x and x 2 . Solution If the formula is exact for a linear combination of x and x 2 , then b b2 a2 xdx c1 a c2 b a 2 b3 a3 2 2 a x dx 3 c1a c2b Solving the two Equations (E3.1) simultaneously gives b2 a 2 a b c1 2 a 2 b 2 c b 3 a 3 2 3 b 2 1 ab b 2 2a 2 6 a 2 1 a ab 2b 2 c2 6 b (E3.1) c1 (E3.2) So 1 ab b 2 2a 2 1 a 2 ab 2b 2 f (a) f (b) a f ( x)dx 6 a 6 b Let us see if the formula works. b 2 x 5 Evaluate 2 2 3 x dx using Equation(E3.3) (E3.3) Gauss Quadrature Rule 2 x 5 2 07.05.11 3 x dx c1 f (a) c2 f (b) 2 1 (2)(5) 5 2 2(2) 2 1 2 2 2(5) 2(5) 2 2(2) 2 3(2) [2(5) 2 3(5)] 6 2 6 5 46.5 2 x 5 The exact value of 2 3 x dx is given by 2 5 2 x 3 3x 2 2 x 3 x dx 2 2 2 3 46.5 Any surprises? 5 2 5 Now evaluate 3dx using Equation (E3.3) 2 5 3dx c 1 f (a ) c 2 f (b) 2 1 2(5) 5 2 2(2) 2 1 2 2 2(5) 2(5) 2 (3) (3) 6 2 6 5 10.35 5 The exact value of 3dx is given by 2 5 3dx 3x 5 2 2 9 Because the formula will only give exact values for linear combinations of x and x 2 , it does 5 not work exactly even for a simple integral of 3dx . 2 Do you see now why we choose a0 a1 x as the integrand for which the formula b f ( x)dx c 1 f (a) c2 f (b) a gives us exact values? Example 4 Use two-point Gauss quadrature rule to approximate the distance covered by a rocket from t 8 to t 30 as given by 30 140000 x 2000 ln 9 . 8 t dt 140000 2100 t 8 Also, find the absolute relative true error. 07.05.12 Chapter 07.05 Solution First, change the limits of integration from 8, 30 to 1, 1 using Equation(23) gives 30 8 30 8 30 8 30 8 f (t )dt f x dx 2 1 2 2 1 1 11 f 11x 19dx 1 Next, get weighting factors and function argument values from Table 1 for the two point rule, c1 1.000000000 . x1 0.577350269 c2 1.000000000 x2 0.577350269 Now we can use the Gauss quadrature formula 1 11 f 11x 19 dx 11c1 f 11x1 19 c 2 f 11x 2 19 1 11 f 11(0.5773503) 19 f 11(0.5773503) 19 11 f (12.64915) f (25.35085) 11(296.8317) (708.4811) 11058.44 m since 140000 f (12.64915) 2000 ln 9.8(12.64915) 140000 2100(12.64915) 296.8317 140000 f (25.35085) 2000 ln 9.8(25.35085) 140000 2100(25.35085) 708.4811 The absolute relative true error, t , is (True value = 11061.34 m) 11061.34 11058.44 100 11061.34 0.0262% t Example 5 Use three-point Gauss quadrature rule to approximate the distance covered by a rocket from t 8 to t 30 as given by 30 140000 x 2000 ln 9.8t dt 140000 2100t 8 Also, find the absolute relative true error. Gauss Quadrature Rule 07.05.13 Solution First, change the limits of integration from 8, 30 to 1, 1 using Equation (23) gives 30 8 30 8 30 8 30 8 f (t )dt f x dx 2 1 2 2 1 1 11 f 11x 19dx 1 The weighting factors and function argument values are c1 0.555555556 x1 0.774596669 c2 0.888888889 x2 0.000000000 c3 0.555555556 x3 0.774596669 and the formula is 1 11 f 11x 19dx 11c1 f 11x1 19 c 2 f 11x 2 19 c3 f 11x3 19 1 0.5555556 f 11(.7745967) 19 0.8888889 f 11(0.0000000) 19 11 0.5555556 f 11(0.7745967) 19 110.55556 f (10.47944) 0.88889 f (19.00000) 0.55556 f (27.52056) 110.55556 239.3327 0.88889 484.7455 0.55556 795.1069 11061.31 m since 140000 f (10.47944) 2000 ln 9.8(10.47944) 140000 2100(10.47944) 239.3327 140000 f (19.00000) 2000 ln 9.8(19.00000) 140000 2100(19.00000) 484.7455 140000 f (27.52056) 2000 ln 9.8(27.52056) 140000 2100(27.52056) 795.1069 The absolute relative true error, t , is (True value = 11061.34 m) 11061.34 11061.31 100 11061.34 0.0003% t 07.05.14 INTEGRATION Topic Gauss quadrature rule Summary These are textbook notes of Gauss quadrature rule Major General Engineering Authors Autar Kaw, Michael Keteltas Date February 6, 2016 Web Site http://numericalmethods.eng.usf.edu Chapter 07.05