FALL 2005 INTERNATIONAL STUDENT ENROLLMENT SURVEY November 2005 The survey, which tracked international students at U.S. colleges and universities, was conducted among members of the following higher education associations: American Association of Community Colleges (AACC), American Council on Education (ACE), Association of American Universities (AAU), Council of Graduate Schools (CGS), Institute of International Education (IIE) NAFSA: Association of International Educators, and National Association of State Universities and Land-Grant Colleges (NASULGC). The survey was conducted between October 3 and 21, 2005. RESPONDENTS Table 1: Respondents. Total Responses 980 Institutional Affiliation of Respondents Total Responses: 980 50.00% 40.1% (392) 40.00% 32.9% (321) 30.00% 19.7% (192) 20.00% 10.00% 4.6% (45) 2.8% (27) Other Professional School 0.00% University Tw o Year College Four-Year College Table 2: Estimated total number of international students enrolled in your institution (in ranges) Total International Student Enrollment Ranges 60.00% 52.9% (513) 50.00% 40.00% 27.9% (270) 30.00% 20.00% 8.3% (80) 10.00% 10.9% (106) 0.00% 1-100 101-500 501-1000 More than 1000 NEW INTERNATIONAL STUDENT ENROLLMENTS Tables 3a-3e: Newly Enrolled International Students Focusing only on newly admitted international students, how has that number at your institution changed this year (Fall 2005) compared to Fall 2004 (excluding any Katrinarelated enrollments)? Of all responding institutions (961), 40% reported an increase, 26% reported a decline, and 34% reported level enrollments. Of the responding institutions that enroll more than 1,000 international students (106 institutions), 51% reported increase, 26% reported declines, and 24% reported level enrollments. Of the responding two-year colleges (312), 36% reported increase, 25% reported declines, and 39% reported level enrollments. Of the responding institutions identifying themselves as “universities” (387), 48% reported increase, 24% reported declines, and 28% reported level enrollments. Of the responding four-year colleges (189), 34% reported increase, 33% reported declines, and 33% reported level enrollments. Table 3a: Newly enrolled international students, Fall 2005 compared to Fall 2004. Newly Enrolled Intl Students Fall 2005 vs. Fall 2004 34.1% (328) 35.00% 30.00% 25.00% 18.9% (182) 20.00% 10.00% 14.2% (136) 13.7% (132) 15.00% 8.5% (82) 7.7% (74) 2.8% (27) 5.00% 0.00% Substantial Some increase increase Slight increase About the same as last year Slight decline Some decline Substantial decline Table 3b: Newly enrolled international students at institutions enrolling more than 1,000 international students New ly Enrolled Int'l Students Fall 2005 vs Fall 2004 Institutions w ith m ore than 1,000 intl students 35.00% 30.2% (32) 30.00% 23.6% (25) 25.00% 18.9% (20) 20.00% 17% (18) 15.00% 10.00% 5.00% 5.7% (6) 2.8% (3) 1.9% (2) 0.00% Substantial increase Some increase Slight increase About the same as last year Slight decline Some decline Substantial decline Table 3c: Two-Year Colleges: Newly enrolled international students at institutions at two-year colleges, Fall 2005 compared to Fall 2004. Newly Enrolled Int'l Students Fall 2005 vs Fall 2004 Two-Year Colleges 39.4% (123) 40.00% 35.00% 30.00% 25.00% 20.00% 12.8% (40) 15.00% 10.00% 14.7% (46) 8.3% (26) 14.4% (45) 8.3% (26) 5.00% 1.9% (6) 0.00% Substantial increase Some increase Slight increase About the Slight decline Some decline Substantial same as last decline year Table 3d: Universities: Newly enrolled international students at institutions at “Universities” (respondents who indicated that their institutional type is “University”), Fall 2005 compared to Fall 2004. Newly Enrolled Int'l Students Fall 2005 vs Fall 2004 - "Universities" 30.00% 27.6% (107) 25.00% 23% (89) 20.00% 17.8% (69) 13.7% (53) 15.00% 10.00% 8.8% (34) 7.2% (28) 5.00% 1.8% (7) 0.00% Substantial increase Some increase Slight increase About the Slight decline Some decline same as last year Substantial decline Table 3e: Four-Year Colleges: Newly enrolled international students at institutions at four-year colleges, Fall 2005 compared to Fall 2004. Newly Enrolled Int'l Students Fall 2005 vs Fall 2004 - Four-Year Colleges 35.00% 32.8% (62) 30.00% 25.00% 18.5% (35) 20.00% 15.9% (30) 15.00% 10.00% 11.1% (21) 8.5% (16) 7.4% (14) 5.8% (11) 5.00% 0.00% Substantial increase Some increase Slight increase About the same as last year Slight decline Some decline Substantial decline TOTAL INTERNATIONAL STUDENT ENROLLMENTS Tables 4a-4f: Total International Student Enrollments How has the total enrollment of international students at your institution changed this fall (Fall 2005), compared to Fall 2004 (excluding any Katrina-related enrollments)? Of all responding institutions (970), 34% reported an increase, 33% reported a decline, and 34% reported level enrollments. Of the responding institutions that enroll more than 1,000 international students (106 institutions), 33% reported increase, 43% reported declines, and 24% reported level enrollments. Of the responding two-year colleges (316), 30% reported increase, 36% reported declines, and 34% reported level enrollments. Of the responding institutions identifying themselves as “universities” (390), 36% reported increase, 33% reported declines, and 31% reported level enrollments. Of the responding four-year colleges (191), 34% reported increase, 32% reported declines, and 35% reported level enrollments. Of the responding four-year colleges and universities (584), 36% reported increase, 33% reported declines, and 32% reported level enrollments. Table 4a: Total International Student Enrollments, Fall 2005 compared to Fall 2004 International Student Enrollment Fall 2005 vs. Fall 2004 40.00% 33.6% (326) 35.00% 30.00% 25.00% 15.00% 10.00% 20.2% (196) 17.8% (173) 20.00% 11.1% (108) 10.3% (100) 4.9% (48) 2.0% (19) 5.00% 0.00% Substantial increase Some increase Slight increase About the same as last year Slight decline Some decline Substantial decline Table 4b: Total international student enrollments at institutions with more than 1,000 international students, Fall 2005 vs. Fall 2004. Int'l Students Fall 2005 vs Fall 2004 Institutions with more than 1,000 intl students 33% (35) 35% 30% 24.5% (26) 25% 23.6% (25) 20% 15% 8.5% (9) 10% 5% 8.5% (9) 1.9% (2) 0% 0% Substantial increase Some increase Slight increase About the same as last year Slight decline Some decline Substantial decline Table 4c: Two-Year Colleges: Total international student enrollments at two-year colleges, Fall 2005 vs. Fall 2004 Int'l Students Fall 2005 vs Fall 2004 Two-Year Colleges 40.00% 34.2% (108) 35.00% 30.00% 25.00% 19.9% (63) 20.00% 15.00% 10.00% 12% (38) 11.7% (37) 13% (41) 6% (19) 3.2% (10) 5.00% 0.00% Substantial increase Some increase Slight increase About the Slight decline Some decline same as last year Substantial decline Table 4d: “Universities”: Total international student enrollments at responding institutions who indicated that they are a “university”, Fall 2005 vs. Fall 2004. Int'l Students Fall 2005 vs Fall 2004 - "Universities" 35.00% 30.8% (120) 30.00% 23.1% (90) 25.00% 20.5% (80) 20.00% 15.00% 11.3% (44) 9.2% (36) 10.00% 4.6% (18) 5.00% 0.5% (2) 0.00% Substantial increase Some increase Slight increase About the Slight decline Some decline same as last year Substantial decline Table 4e: Four-Year Colleges: Total international student enrollments at four-year colleges, Fall 2005 vs. Fall 2004 Int'l Students Fall 2005 vs Fall 2004 - Four-Year Colleges 40.00% 34.6% (66) 35.00% 30.00% 25.00% 19.9% (38) 19.9% (38) 20.00% 15.00% 9.9% (19) 9.9% (19) 10.00% 5.00% 3.7% (7) 2.1% (4) 0.00% Substantial increase Some increase Slight increase About the Slight decline Some decline same as last year Substantial decline Table 4f: Universities and Four-Year Colleges: Total international student enrollments at universities and four-year colleges (combined), Fall 2005 vs. Fall 2004 Int'l Students Fall 2005 vs Fall 2004 Universities and Four-Year Colleges 35.00% 32% (187) 30.00% 25.00% 21.9% (128) 20.4% (119) 20.00% 15.00% 10.8% (63) 9.6% (56) 10.00% 5.00% 4.3% (25) 1% (6) 0.00% Substantial increase Some increase Slight increase About the same as last year Slight decline Some decline Substantial decline COUNTRY BREAKDOWN: NEW INTERNATIONAL STUDENT ENROLLMENTS What change, if any, have you noticed for Fall 2005 compared to Fall 2004 in the number of newly admitted international students from the following places of origin (top sending countries and countries with large Muslim populations)? For most countries, respondents reported increase and decreases at similar levels. For some countries, more responding institutions reported an increase than a decline, specifically for China (29% reporting increases vs. 20% reporting declines) and Korea (36% reporting increases vs. 17% reporting declines). For other countries, more responding institutions reported a decline than an increase, specifically for Indonesia (20% reporting a decline vs. 13% reporting an increase), Malaysia (18% reporting a decline vs. 10% reporting an increase), and Pakistan (20% reporting a decline vs. 14% reporting an increase). Table 5: Country Breakdown: Newly enrolled international students, Fall 2005 compared to Fall 2004 Newly Enrolled International Students Fall 2005: Country Breakdown 36 29 18 16 13 8 In do ne si a M al ay si a Pa ki st an Sa ud iA ra bi a Ko re a C In di a hi na % of Respondents Reporting Increase 13 22 20 8 Th ai la nd 15 10 20 19 19 ig er ia 14 13 18 N 20 Ke ny a 17 18 Tu rk ey 20 AE 20 15 10 5 0 24 U 20 Eg yp t 26 25 24 Ja pa n 40 35 30 25 % of Respondents Reporting Decrease 19 DECLINES AT UNDERGRADUATE OR GRADUATE LEVEL If you enroll both graduate and undergraduate students, was the decline in international students more evident in graduate or undergraduate enrollment, for Fall 2005 compared to Fall 2004? Institutions that enroll both graduate and undergraduate students indicated that the declines were more evident at the undergraduate level. 47% (109 institutions) of the institutions that responded to that question said that declines were more evident at the undergraduate level, while 29% (66) reported more graduate level declines, and 24% (56) reported that both graduate and undergraduate levels declines were about the same. Table 6: Declines at Undergraduate or Graduate Level Was Decline in Intl Students More Evident at Grad or Undergrad Enrollments? 24% (56) 47% (109) 29% (66) Undergrad Grad Both Grad and Undergrad Declined Similarly SPECIAL STEPS TO ENSURE INTERNATIONAL ENROLLMENTS DO NOT DECLINE Has your institution taken any special steps to ensure that the number of international enrollments does not decline? Fifty percent (475) of all responding institutions have taken special steps to ensure that the number of international students on their campuses does not decline, while 50% (482) have not taken any special steps. Asked to comment on what special steps institutions have taken, responses included: expanded recruitment efforts (more recruitment trips, recruitment at both undergraduate and graduate level, full-time recruitment overseas, etc), increased marketing efforts (developing marketing or recruitment plans, analysis of competitor institutions), more grants and financial assistance to students and increased stipends to graduate assistants, enhanced communication with prospective and admitted international students (priority processing for international applicants, online chats with students from selected countries during the admission-decision making time period, etc.), better coordination with admissions offices (including hiring new enrollment managers), as well as targeted efforts to improve the environment and support services to make international students feel more welcome on campus. Table 7: Has your institution taken any special steps to ensure that the number of international enrollments does not decline? Has your institution taken any special steps to ensure that the number of international enrollments does not decline? No 50% (482) Yes 50% (475) MAJOR REASONS FOR REPORTED DECLINES IN ENROLLMENTS Based on feedback from international applicants, what do you believe are the major reasons for the decline in enrollments? Thirty-five percent (297 institutions) of the responding institutions experiencing declines in international students enrollments cited visa application processes and concerns of delays/denials as the major reason for the decline, making it the leading cause, followed by cost of tuition/fees at U.S. institutions (18% or 154 institutions) and decisions to enroll in another country’s institutions (13% or 110 institutions). Of the 109 respondents (or 13%) who chose “other” as their response, many indicated increased competition for international students among U.S. institutions, a higher number of transfers or graduating international students, lack of recruitment efforts, lack of graduate assistantships, or a combination of all the various reason listed. Table 8: Major Reasons for Reported Declines in Enrollments Based on feedback from international applicants, w hat are the m ajor reasons for the decline in enrollm ents? 5.2% (45) 5.9% (51) 11% (95) 34.5% (297) 12.7% (109) 12.8% (110) 17.9% (154) Visa application process Cost of tuition/fees at my institution Decisions to enroll in another country’s institutions Other Home country economic problems Enroll in ow n country’s higher education institution Problems/concern over fees and fee payments related to SEVIS HURRICANE KATRINA-RELATED INTERNATIONAL STUDENT ENROLLMENTS Tables 9a-9b: Hurricane Katrina-related international student enrollments. Twenty-one percent of the respondents (207 institutions) reported that that they enrolled international students who were originally enrolled in Gulf Coast campuses affected by Hurricane Katrina, while 79% (759) did not enroll any of these students. Most of these institutions (87% or 192 institutions) accepted 1-10 students, while 19 (9%) accepted 11-30 students, 2 institutions (or 1%) accepted 31-50 students, 4 (or 2%) accepted 51-100 students, and 2 (or 1%) accepted more than 100 students. In anecdotal responses, respondents indicated the types of special arrangements that they made to help Katrina-related students. These arrangements ranged from allowing late registration and late payment of fees, expedited application processing, special housing assistance, tuition waivers, tuition reduction, deferred tuition, in-state tuition for out-of-state students and special scholarships. Table 9a: For Fall 2005, did your institution enroll any international students who were originally enrolled in Gulf Coast campuses affected by Hurricane Katrina? For Fall 2005, did your institution enroll any international students w ho w ere originally enrolled in Gulf Coast cam puses affected by Hurricane Katrina Yes 21% (207) No 79% (759) Table 9b: If you have accepted such students, please check the box indicating the approximate number you have accepted. Approximate number of Hurricane-Katrina-affected international students accepted 1.8% (4) 0.9% (2) 0.9% (2) 8.7% (19) 1-10 11-30 31-50 51-100 More than 100 87.7% (192) RESPONSES FROM 17 INSTITUTIONS THAT ENROLL THE HIGHEST NUMBER OF INTERNATIONAL STUDENTS Table 10a – 10b: Responses from 17 of the institutions that host the highest numbers of international students in the United States, Fall 2005 vs. Fall 2004. Ten of the 17 institutions that host the highest numbers of international students report increases in the number of newly enrolled international students on their campuses this year, while six institutions report declines, and one campus no noticeable change. Looking at overall international students enrollments, eight of the 17 institutions reported a decline, while five reported an increase, and four reported no change. Table 10a: Newly enrolled international students at 17 institutions that enroll the highest numbers of international students, Fall 2005 compared to Fall 2004. Newly Enrolled Int'l Students Fall 2005 vs Fall 2004 17 of the institutions that host the highest number of international students 8 7 7 6 5 5 4 3 3 2 1 1 1 0 0 0 Substantial increase Some increase Slight increase About the same as last year Slight decline Some decline Substantial decline Table 10b: Overall international student enrollments at 17 institutions that enroll the highest numbers of international students, Fall 2005 compared to Fall 2004. Int'l Student Enrollments, Fall 2005 vs Fall 2004 17 of the institutions that host the highest number of international students 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 8 4 4 1 0 Substantial increase Some increase Slight increase About the same as last year Slight decline 0 0 Some decline Substantial decline