1 REVIEW ARTICLE ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Use of fetal nucleated red blood cells in maternal circulation, for noninvasive prenatal diagnosis of chromosomal and single gene disorders. Dr Maitreyee Faculty member in Embryology and Medical Genetics University of Seychelles American Institute of Medicine Seychelles ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------KEYWORDS: Nucleated red blood cells (NRBCs) Non-invasive prenatal diagnosis (NI-PND) single gene disorders cytogenetic disorders fetal maternal circulation trophoblasts leukocytes enrichment ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Currently available prenatal spontaneous first-trimester diagnostic procedures for abortions, and in about 2% of detection of fetal aneuploidy and pregnancies in women older single gene disorders are than 35 years who undergo ‘invasive’. These procedures prenatal diagnosis. (1) In a include chorionic villus sampling population study of more than 1 (10-12 weeks of gestation), million live births, the incidence amniocentesis (15-20 weeks of of serious single-gene disorder gestation) or umbilical blood was estimated to be 0.36%. (2) sampling (after 18 weeks of gestation). The scientists have been constantly in search of a better Along with the need for skill and method for prenatal diagnosis. A expertise, they also have low but reliable noninvasive method will well-documented risk to the be the right answer for it, as it mother and the fetus. They are will minimize the risk, and may generally not offered to all be - will be available at a lesser pregnant women. These are cost; and then a larger number indicated only in high risk of pregnant women would be pregnancies - e.g. advanced benefited by it. maternal age (> 35 years), abnormal maternal serum One of the methods that has screening results, ultrasound been under research for more detection of fetal anomalies or than 3 decades, is to enrich the likelihood of single gene fetal cells in the maternal blood. disorder. Historically, the presence of fetal cells in the maternal circulation Cytogenetic disorders are during pregnancy has been present in nearly 1% of live observed since the end of the 19th births, in almost 50% of all century. Schmorl in 1893 2 showed through the autopsy findings, the presence of trapped fetal cells in the lungs of pregnant women. Similarly, the presence of fetal cells was demonstrated by Douglas in 1959. (3) These were the trophoblasts traversing the placental barrier into the maternal circulation. By now, multiple investigators have confirmed the existence of fetal cells in maternal blood. Several types of fetal cells including trophoblasts, lymphocytes, granulocytes, stem cells, and nucleated erythrocytes can be found in maternal blood at as early as 8 weeks gestation, but in extremely low abundance. (4) Three different fetal cells have been the focus of research: trophoblasts, fetal leukocytes, and fetal erythrocytes (fetal NRBCs). But the researches on these cell types have been hampered in several ways. A. Trophoblasts: These were the first fetal cells found to traverse the placental barrier into maternal circulation. But there are certain drawbacks associated with these cells. They do not appear in maternal blood in all pregnancies. Because of their multinucleated nature, they are rapidly cleared from the maternal circulation. They are heterogeneous because of multinucleated status as well as due to placental mosaicism. (5, 6) There is difficulty in enrichment for these cells because of lack of specific antibodies. B. Leukocytes: They were first demonstrated to appear in the maternal blood in 1969 by Walknoska. (7) This was done by showing that a Y chromosome could be detected in some of the lymphocytes isolated from pregnant women bearing male fetuses. They are the first cells to be successfully enriched from maternal blood. This approach used differences in human leukocyte antigen (HLA) expression, which required HLA type of father, thereby raising the issue of paternity. Furthermore, these results were not reproduced with the same degree of success. (8) Not only that but two observations caused obstacles in further progress while using these cells: 1. The persistently high number of female-bearing pregnancies with Y chromosome positive cells, (9, 10, 11, 12) and – 2. The possible longevity of fetal leukocytes in the maternal circulation. (13) Women who had previously borne a son, had fetal leukocytes in the peripheral blood for a period of up to 1 year and in some instances 5 years postpartum.(14) In 1996, Bianchi et al showed persistence of male progenitor cells for 27 years postpartum. (15) Because of this, there always remains a possibility of getting fetal cells from previous pregnancy, and increase in the chances of wrong diagnosis. 3 In spite of the above obstacles, the research regarding leukocytes definitely suggested that fetal cells did migrate into the peripheral blood of pregnant women, from which they could be enriched for subsequent diagnostic procedures. C. Fetal NRBCs: They have been always considered as promising cells for this technique. A small number of NRBCs occur in the peripheral venous blood of women during normal pregnancy, but they are less common in the blood of healthy nulligravid women. (16, 17, 18) It was therefore believed that these cells were of fetal origin and hence could be a promising source for non-invasive prenatal diagnosis, especially since the short lifespan of erythrocytes eliminates the possibility of such cells persisting from previous pregnancies. (19) In 1957, Kleihauer et al demonstrated the presence of NRBCs in pregnant women.(20) Clayton et al in 1964 confirmed this finding by showing increase in these cells in the maternal blood when there is rhesus incompatibility, as well as following terminations or amniocentesis. (21) But in these studies, there was no independent confirmation that the NRBCs detected were indeed of fetal origin. One of the methods to give a proof of fetal origin of these cells is to show the presence of Y chromatin, which limits it to the pregnancies with male fetuses. Bianchi et al (1990) were the first to enrich for nucleated erythrocytes containing fetal DNA (on the basis of CD71 expression, a molecule highly expressed on erythrocytes). (22) Price et al (1991), Bianchi et al (1992), and Ganshirt-Ahlert et al (1993) then successfully showed the correct determination of fetal aneuploidy by this method. (23, 24, 25) Fetal erythrocytes are among the first hemopoietic cells formed during fetal development and they are detectable early during pregnancy. These cells have an advantage over leukocytes that these cells are short-lived cells, of limited replicating capacity, thereby preventing the chance of getting fetal cells from previous pregnancies. But use of these cells also was found to be associated with certain drawbacks: Anna Slunga-Tallberg et al (1995) showed that pregnancy induces NRBCs of maternal origin to appear in the maternal venous blood. A rapid increase in erythropoiesis during normal pregnancy raised the number of red cells and reticulocytes in the maternal venous blood, and this may be associated with a concomitant increase in the number of NRBCs in the peripheral blood. They found that the NRBCs in the maternal circulation were predominantly maternal in origin. (26) This finding that majority of these cells, even after enrichment for fetal cells, are of maternal origin is demonstrated 4 by other workers also. (27, 28, 29, 30) Most of the times it is difficult to confirm that the NRBCs detected are indeed of fetal origin, and not of maternal origin. In the pregnancies with male fetuses; however, the probable fetal nucleated erythrocytes will have Y chromosome. In the same way, detection of fetal NRBCs is also possible if mother is Rhesus negative and fetus is Rhesus positive. Some studies proposed that the presence of fetal cells in maternal blood is rare in normal pregnancy. They are 1 in 105 to 107 or even less, early in gestation i.e. less than 10 weeks (31, 32, 33, 34, 35), when the prenatal diagnosis is most desirable. According to the reports by Ganshirt-Alhert (1994b) (46) and Bianchi et al (1997) (34), fetal cells appear to be more frequent in aneuploid pregnancies. In the 19th century, Schmorl (1893) (3) and Clayton et al (1964) (21) showed altered fetalmaternal trafficking in preeclampsia, but there was no direct proof that the cells observed were indeed of fetal origin. In 1998, Holzgreve et al by the exclusive use of male pregnancies, determined that significantly more fetal cells traversed the placental barrier in pre-eclamptic patients (9/1000) than in the control group (2/1000) and also there was large increase in the number of NRBCs (38 versus 7) in these patients, most of which were of maternal origin. (30) Along with the difficulties in enrichment, the issues pertaining to the fetal cell recognition, cultivation, and diagnostic efficiency still remain to be explored to their fullest extent. The inability to expand fetal erythroid progenitors successfully from the maternal circulation in vitro might be explained by the fact that the occurrence of expandable fetal hematopoietic progenitor cells in the maternal blood are rare to very rare events (36, 37, 38) or that they require some as-yet unidentified culture conditions. To enhance the enrichment of fetal NRBCs, several workers have sought for more specific antibodies or biochemical markers. Since most of such studies in past have focused on the identification of male fetal cells (because of presence of Y chromatin), almost half of the patient population was not analyzed. Osamu Samura et al developed a method to determine that female gamma positive NRBCs are fetal (not maternal) in origin using DNA polymorphism. They reported that this technique allows genetic studies of all fetal NRBCs, including female fetal cells. (39) Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) was tried to support existence of fetal cells in maternal blood i.e. where the gene of interest is present in the fetal genome but absent in the maternal one e.g. in paternally inherited 5 hemoglobinopathy (40) and to determine the fetal RhD status. (41) Use of zeta globin immunophenotyping for the determination of beta thalassemia(42), fetal NRBC identification by epsilon-globin chain immunophenotyping(43), use of combined gamma and epsilon globin antibody (44) are also some of the steps towards the goal. In 2003, Cha Donghyun et al defined certain parameters to distinguish fetal NRBCs from maternal NRBCs. (45) They defined four parameters: nuclear roundness, nuclear morphology, gamma Hb staining intensity, and peripheral brightness of the stained cytoplasm. They suggested that these defined parameters might serve as computational classifiers for the automated detection of fetal NRBCs from maternal NRBCs. Jackson Laird in 2003 in a review article concludes that research attempts to use fetal cells from maternal blood for prenatal diagnosis have not had any consistent success and that much work remains to be done to develop practical technology for consistent recovery and assay of the fetal cells or fetal DNA. (47) Shinya Masaru et al used galactose-specific lectin to concentrate fetal nucleated RBCs from maternal blood (2004). (49) The same method was used by Sekizawa Akihiko et al (2007). (50) This has been thought to be one of the techniques with high sensitivity, for the separation of fetal cells.(55) Till recently, the workers have been trying both old and advanced techniques to isolate fetal NRBCs from maternal NRBCs. In 2007, a new method, a micromachined device (Biochip) was used to separate fetal cells based on differences in size and deformation characteristics. (51) The search for the fetal NRBCs in maternal circulation has been in progress in many of the ways described above; however, there is still a lot that needs to be done to achieve one of the most satisfactory means to detect and enrich the fetal NRBCs in maternal circulation. Whereas this is the current status of research in reference to the fetal NRBCs, just the presence of NRBCs in maternal circulation - (irrespective of whether they are fetal or maternal in origin) – also has been shown to be important. Maternal NRBCs In 2004, (48) antibody against gamma chain of HbF was used to detect fetal erythroblasts in maternal circulation and they were used for sex determination and genetic diagnosis of Duchenne muscular dystrophy. Anna Slunga-Tallberg et al found that there is an increase in the number of circulating NRBCs in association with pregnancy, and moreover these are predominantly of maternal origin. (26) 6 Many researchers have shown that although the small increase in the number of NRBCs in normal pregnancy is definite, the rise in the number of NRBCs is especially remarkable in association with certain specific conditions. (3, 21, 30) The observations in 2006, by Mavrou et al were also found to be on the similar lines. The number of NRBCs was determined from 20 ml of peripheral blood in 351 women in the second trimester of pregnancy, after isolation of magnetic cell sorting (MACS) with anti-CD71 antibody. They found following numbers of NRBCs in the maternal blood, in association with certain specific conditions. No 1 2 3 4 5 Condition Number of NRBCs in maternal circulation Women with 1-12 chromosomally (average normal fetuses 8) aneuploid 7-113 fetuses (average 35) Trisomy 21 average 71 Beta22-158 thalassemia (average 42) pregnancies 2-75 with abnormal (average Doppler 15) findings in both uterine arteries They concluded, this could be an additional ‘screening step’ for fetal aneuplodies, as long as the anemic status of the mother is taken into consideration. (52) In 2005, Ikeya Miki et al (2005) used lectin method for separation and recovery of NRBCs (53) in maternal blood. They showed that there was increase in maternal NRBCS in pregnancies with trisomy 18, trisomy 21, placenta previa, preeclampsia, and intrauterine fetal death. They concluded that NRBC exam may play an assisting role not only in fetal diagnosis but also in fetomaternal diagnosis. In 2007, Aali Bibi Shahnaz et al demonstrated the same finding regarding pre-eclampsia. (54) Though these studies suggest that maternal NRBCs could be useful for screening for conditions like fetal aneuploidies and fetomaternal disturbances, for definitive diagnosis we shall be still in need of a more reliable technique. Promises and Unanswered questions: Use of the fetal NRBCs would remain one of the more reliable non-invasive techniques for prenatal diagnosis. This obviously has a promise of lot of advantages over routine invasive procedures. However, there are many unanswered questions. The obvious problem is of the limited number of fetal cells found to be circulating within maternal blood. Due to this, the procedures to enrich the cells and enable single cell analysis with high sensitivity are required. Some of the recent methods of separation included a lectin-based method and autoimage analyzing. These methods have improved the 7 sensitivity of genetic analysis. (55) The ongoing progress in this field has supported the possibility of non-invasive prenatal diagnosis, although a single, definitive, accurate practicable method is yet to be established. There is still a wide scope for many more areas in research to be explored in this direction. --------------------------------------------References: 1. Thompson and Thompson Genetics in Medicine – 6th edition - Chapter 9 2. Thompson and Thompson Genetics in Medicine – 6th edition - chapter 5 3. Gussin Helene A Elicha, Elias Sherman – Culture of fetal cells from maternal blood for prenatal diagnosis – Human Reproduction Update – Vol 8 No 6 pp 523-527, 2002 4. Principles of Medical Genetics (Williams and Wilkins) – 2nd edition - chapter 12 5. Henderson, K.G., Shaw, T.E., Barret, I.J. et al, (1996) Distribution of mosaicism in human plancentae. Human Genetics, 97, 650-654) 6. Goldberg, J.D. and Wohlferd, M.M. (1997) Incidence and outcome of chromosomal mosaicism found at the time of chorionic villus sampling. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology., 176, 1349-1353 7. Walknoska, J., Conte, F.A., and Grumbach, M.M. (1969) Practical and theoretical implication of fetal/maternal lymphocyte transfer. Lancet, i, 1119-1122 8. Tharapel, A.T., Jaswaney, V.L., Dockter, M.E. et al. (1993) Inability to detect fetal metaphases in flow-sorted lymphocyte cultures based on maternal-fetal HLA differences. Fetal diagnosis and therapy., 8, 95-101 9. Schindler, A.M., Graf, E., and Martin-du-Pan, R. (1972) Prenatal diagnosis of fetal lymphocytes in the maternal blood. Obstetrics and Gynecology., 40, 340-346 10. Schroder, J. and de la Chapelle, A. (1972) Fetal lymphocytes in maternal blood. Blood, 39, 153-161 11. Grosset, L., Barelet, V., and Ordatchenko, N. (1974) Antenatal fetal sex determination from maternal blood during pregnancy. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology., 120, 6063 12. Sargent, I.L., Choo, Y.S, and Redman, C.W.G.(1994) Isolating and analyzing fetal leukocytes in maternal blood. Ann. NY Acad. Sci., 731, 154-161 13. Schroder, J., Tilikainen, A., and de la Chapelle, A. (1974) Fetal leukocytes in maternal circulation after delivery. Transplantation, 17, 346-360) 14. Ciaranfi, A, Curchod, A., and Odartchenko, N. (1977) Post-partum survival of fetal lymphocytes in the maternal blood. Schweiz. Med. Wochensch., 107, 134-138 15. Bianchi Diana W., Zickwolf, Gretchen K., Weil, Gary J., et al. (1996) Male fetal progenitor cells persist in maternal blood for as long as 27 years postpartum. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 93, 705-708 16. Bianchi, D. W., Stewart, J.E., Garber, M.F. et al. (1991) Possible effect of gestational age on the detection of fetal nucleated erythrocytes in maternal blood. Prenatal Diagnosis. 11, 523528. 17. Ganshirt-Ahlert, D., Burschyk, M., Garritsen, H.S.P., et al. 1992 Magnetic cell sorting and the transferrin receptor as potential means of prenatal diagnosis from maternal blood. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology. 166, 1350-1355. 18. Slunga-Tallberg, A., Wessman, M., Ylinen, K. et al (1994) Nucleated erythrocytes in enriched and unenriched peripheral venous blood samples from pregnant and nonpregnant women. Fetal Diagnosis and Therapy. 9, 291295 19. Wessman, M., Ylinen, K., Knuutila, S. (1992) Fetal granulocytes in maternal venous blood detected by in situ hybridization. Prenatal Diagnosis. 12, 993-1000 20. Kleihauer, E., Braun, H., and Betke, K. 1957 Klin. Wochenschr., 35, 637-638 21. Clayton, E.M., Feldhaus, W.D., and Whiteacre, F.E. 1964 Fetal erythrocytes in the maternal circulation of pregnant women. Obstetrics and Gynecology, 23, 915-919 22. Bianchi, D.W., Flint, A.F., Pizzimenti, M. et al. 1990. Isolation of fetal DNA from nucleated erythrocytes in maternal blood. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 87, 3279-3283 23. Price, J.O., Elias, S., Wachtel, S.S. et al. 1991 Prenatal diagnosis with fetal cells isolated from maternal blood by multiparameter flow cytometry. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology. 165, 1731-1737 24. Bianchi, D.W., Mahr, A., Zickwolf, G.K. et al. 1992 Detection of fetal cells with 47, XY, +21 karyotype in maternal peripheral blood. Human Genetics, 90, 368-370 25. Ganshirt-Ahlert, D., Borejesson-Stoll, R., Burschyk, M., et al. 1993 Detection of fetal trisomies 21 and 18 from maternal blood using triple gradient and magnetic cell sorting. American Journal of Reprod. Immun. 30, 194201 26. Slunga-Tallberg, A., El-Rifai, W., Keinanen, M., et al. 1995 Maternal origin of nucleated erythrocytes in peripheral venous blood of pregnant women. Human Genetics, 96, 53-57 27. Ganshirt, D., Garritsen, H.S.P., Miny, P. et al. 1994a. Fetal cells in maternal circulation throughout gestation. Lancet. 343, 1038-1039. 28. Hamada, H, Arinami, T., Sohda, S, et al. 1995. Midtrimester fetal sex determination from maternal peripheral blood by fluorescence in situ hybridization without enrichment of fetal cells. Prenatal Diagnosis. 15, 78-81. 29. Slunga-Tallberg, A., El-Rifai, W., Keinanen, M., et al. 1996 Maternal origin of transferring receptor positive cells in venous blood of pregnant women. Clinical Genetics, 49, 196-199 30. Holzgreve, W., Ghezzi, F., Di Naro, E., et al. 1998. Feto-maternal cell traffic is disturbed in 8 pre-eclampsia. Obstetrics and Gynecology., in press. 31. Ganshirt-Ahlert, D., Pohlschmidt, M., Gal, A., et al. 1990. Ratio of fetal to maternal DNA is less than 1 in 5,000 in different gestational ages in maternal blood. Clinical Genetics. 38, 38-43. 32. Hamada, H., Arinami, T., Kubo, T., et al. 1993. Fetal nucleated cells in maternal peripheral blood: Frequency and relationship to gestational age. Human Genetics, 91, 427-432 33. Hamada, H., Arinami, T., Sohda, S, et al, 1995. Mid-trimester fetal sex determination from maternal peripheral blood by fluroscence in situ hybridization without enrichment of fetal cells 34. Bianchi, D. W., Williams, J.M., Sullivan, L.M., et al, 1997. PCR quantitation of fetal cells in maternal blood in normal and aneuploid pregnancies. American Journal of Human Genetics. 61, 822-829. 35. Sohda, S., Arinami, T., Hamada, H. et al, 1997, The proportion of fetal nucleated red cells in maternal blood: Estimation by FACS analysis. Prenatal Diagnosis, 17, 743-752 36. Little M T, Langlois S, Wilson R D et al, (1997) Frequency of fetal cells in sorted subpopulations of nucleated erythroid and CD34+ hematopoietic progenitor cells from maternal peripheral blood, Blood 89, 23472358 37. Jansen M W J C, Korcer-Hakkennes K, van Leenen et al, (2000), How useful is the in vitro expansion of fetal CD34+ progenitor cells from maternal blood samples for diagnostic purposes? Prenatal Diagnosis, 20, 725-731 38. Campagnoli C, Roberts I A G, Kumar S, et al, (2002), Expandability of hematopoietic progenitors in first trimester fetal and maternal blood: implications for non-invasive prenatal diagnosis, Prenatal Diagnosis, 22, 463-469 39. Samura Osamu, Perl Barbara, Sohda Santoshi et al (2000), Female fetal cells in maternal blood: use of DNA polymorphisms to prove origin, Human Genetics, 107, 28-32 40. Camaschella , C., Multhaupt H A, Ludomirski A et al (1990) Prenatal diagnosis of fetal hemoglobin Lepore-Boston disease on maternal peripheral blood., Blood, 75, 21022106. 41. Lo Y M D, Bowell P J, Selinger M et al (1993) Prenatal determination of fetal RhD status by analysis of peripheral blood of rhesus negative mothers. Lancet, 341, 1147-1148 42. Naro Edoardo Di, Ghezzi Fabio, Vitucci Angelantonio et al (2000), Prenatal diagnosis of beta thalasemia using feta; erythroblasts enriched from maternal blood by a novel gradient, Molecular Human Reproduction, 6, 571-574 43. Cholani Mahesh, O’Donoghue Keelin, Talbert David, et al, (2001) Characterization of first trimester fetal erythroblasts for noninbvasive prenatal diagnosis, Molecular Human Reproduction, 9, 227-235 44. Christensen Britta, Philip John, LykkeHansen Lene et al (2003), Sensitivity and specificity of the identification of fetal cells in maternal blood by combined staining with antibodies against beta, gamma and epsilon blobin chains, Fetal Diagnosis and Therapy, 18, 479-484 45. Cha Donghyun, Hogan Brad, Bohmer R M, Bianchi D M et al, (2003) A simple and sensitive erythroblast scoring system to identify fetal cells in maternal blood, Prenatal Diagnosis, 23, 68-73 46. Ganshirt, D., Borejesson-Stoll, R., Burschyk, M. eta al. (1994b), Successful prenatal diagnosis from maternal blod bwith magnetic-activated cell sorting., Ann. NY Acad. Sci. 731, 103-114 47. Jackson Laird, (2003), Review, Fetal cells and DNA in maternal blood, Prenatal Diagnosis, 23, 837-846 48. Liu L, Jin C, Wang Y et al, (2004), Use of specific antibody to detect fetal erythroblasts in maternal circulation, Chinese Journal of Medical Genetics, 21 (5), 494-497. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/pubmed/15 476180 49. Shinya Masaru, Okamoto Aikou, Sago Haruhiko et al (2004), Analysis of fetal DNA from maternal peripheral blood by lectinpolymerase chanin reaction – single strand conformation polymorphism, Congenital Anomalies, 44, 142-146 50. Sekizawa Akihiko, Purwosunu Yuditiya, Matsuoka Ryu et al, (2007), Recent advances in non-invasive prenatal diagnosis through analysis of maternal blood, The journal of obstetrics and Gynecology Research, 33, 747764 51. Mohamed Hisham, Turner JN, Caggana Michele (2007), Biochip for separating fetal cells from maternal circulation, Journal of Chromatography A, 1162, 187-192. 52. Mavrou A., Kouvidi E., Antsaklis A. et al, (2006), Identification of nucleated red blood cells in maternal circulation: A second step in screening for fetal aneuploides and pregnancy complications, Prenatal Diagnosis, 27, 150-153 53. Ikeya Miki, Shinya Masaru, Kitagawa Michihiro (2005), Basic investigation of the lectin method for separation and recovery of nucleated red blood cells in maternal blood, and a study into the frequency of nucleated red blood cells in fetomaternal disorers., Congenital Anomalies, 45, 26-31 54. Aali Bibi Shahnaz, Malepour Reza, Sedig Fatemeh et al, (2007), Comparison of maternal and cord blood nucleated red blood cell count between pre-eclamptic and healthy women, Journal of Obstetrics an Gynecology Research 33, 274-278 55. Sekizawa Akihiko, Purwosunu Yuditiya, Matsuoka Ryu et al 2007) Recent advances in non-invasive prenatal DNA diagnosis through analysis of maternal blood. The Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology Research, 33, 747764 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------