Ohio Northern University CE 3231 - Introduction to Environmental Engineering and Science Introduction Chemistry, Microbiology & Material Balance Water & Air Pollution Partition Coefficients and Modeling Real data characterizing risk is difficult and expensive to come across. As thousands of chemicals enter the market place each year, models help estimate the risk based upon compound structure and physical-chemical properties. Here, we examine how partition coefficients are used to make decisions. Env Risk Management Readings for This Class: Exposure Assessment pathways of exposure calculating CDI Lecture 32 Partition Coefficents and Modeling Risk (Risk III) Risk & Risk Assessment Topics Covered Include: New Chemicals Review Risk Models Partitioning Coefficients Octanol water Vapor pressure New Chemicals Review Program – Premanufacture Notice US Environmental Protection Agency Office of Pollution Prevention and Toxics Toxic Substance Control Act – Section 5 Program Goal Serve as a “gatekeeper to help manage the potential risk from chemicals new to the marketplace.” New Chemicals Review Program Risk Evaluations Risk Based - potential health risks - toxicological investigations Exposure Based - potential exposure risks - chemical property investigations - fate modeling: ranks outcomes I to IV New Chemicals Review Program Physical/Chemical Properties Boiling Point Vapor Pressure Estimate Concentration in Air Estimate Inhalation Exposure Melting Point Estimate Henry’s Law Constant Estimate Concentration in Water Estimate Volatilization from water Water Solubility (estimate) Octanol/Water Partition Coefficient (Kow, P) Estimate Absorption through skin, lungs and GI Estimate Removal in Wastewater Treatment Soil/Sorption Coefficent (Koc) (estimate) Estimate Bioconcentration Estimate Toxicity Estimate Migration through Soil to Groundwater Estimate Risk to Human Health and the Environment New Chemicals Review Program CAS Number : 000105-55-5 Chem Name : n-boulanger Mol Formula: StRuCtUrE Mol Weight : 186 Melting Pt : -10 deg C Boiling Pt : 128 deg C Water Solubility: Value : 0.01 mg/L Temp : 37 deg C Type : EXP Log Kow (logP): Value : 3.57 Type : EXP Vapor Pressure: Value : 210 mm Hg Temp : 25 deg C Type : EXP Henry's Law Constant: Value : 6.85E-004 atm-m3/mole Temp : 25 deg C Type : EST Illustrating Example N-boulanger is used to formulate air fresheners. Octanol/Water Partitioning • Reported as log Kow or log P • Used to estimate water solubility, soil sediment adsorption, biological absorption (dermal, oral, GI, inhalation), bioaccumulation, and toxicity • model for partitioning within body New Chemicals Review Program Octanol/Water Partitioning 80% of PMN process is determined through use of log Kow - fuels QSARs (Quantitative Structural Activity Relationships) or EPA’s ECOSAR (Ecological Structural Activity Relationship) used during the evaluation Experimental Determination 1. Shake Flask Method 2. Slow Stir 3. Generator Column via HPLC New Chemicals Review Program Octanol/Water Partitioning Non-experimental Estimation Methods 1. Fragment/segment summation 2. Correlations with molecular descriptors (shape, volume,…) with known chemistries 3. Correlations with Reversed Phase HPLC Retention Times of known chemistries 4. 3 dimensional structure New Chemicals Review Program The Agency prefers experimentally derived Kow values. Whenever non-experimental methods will be estimated, the most conservative value will be used! Log Kow drives partitioning between the substance and biological tissues New Chemicals Review Program Vapor Pressure • rate of vapor condensation = vaporization rate of liquid • determined experimentally through automated instruments, an isoteniscope, or gas saturation procedure • strongly hints at air fraction • can be correlated for most compounds New Chemicals Review Program Vapor Pressure drives partitioning of compound between atmosphere. New Chemicals Review Program CAS Number : 000105-55-5 Chem Name : n-boulanger Mol Formula: StRuCtUrE Mol Weight : 186 Melting Pt : -10 deg C Boiling Pt : 128 deg C Water Solubility: Value : 0.01 mg/L Temp : 37 deg C Type : EXP Log Kow: Value : 3.57 Type : EXP Vapor Pressure: Value : 210 mm Hg Temp : 25 deg C Type : EXP Henry's Law Constant: Value : 6.85E-004 atm-m3/mole Temp : 25 deg C Type : EST Putting Values into Context N-boulanger is used to formulate air fresheners. Putting Numbers into Context Henry's Constant Ranges (atm m3/mol) Aqueous Solubility Ranges High moderate low non volatile low volatility moderate volatility high volatility > 500 mM 100 - 500 mM < 100 mM < 3x10-7 3x10-7 to 1x10-5 1x10-5 to 1x10-3 > 1x10-3 Vapor Pressure Ranges (mmHg) @ 20-30 deg F Very highly volatile highly volatile moderately volatile low volatility non volatile > 10-3 10-4 to 10-3 10-5 to 10-4 10-5 to 10-6 < 10-7 logP considered a problem when logKow > 5 (will bioaccumulate) logP from 2 to 5 considered likely to bioaccumulate logP from 0 to 2 potential to bioaccumulate Putting Values into Context CAS Number : 000105-55-5 Chem Name : n-boulanger Mol Formula: StRuCtUrE Mol Weight : 186 Melting Pt : -60 deg C Boiling Pt : 128 deg C Water Solubility: Value : 0.01 mg/L Temp : 37 deg C Type : EXP Log Kow: Value : 3.57 Type : EXP Vapor Pressure: Value : 210 mm Hg Temp : 25 deg C Type : EXP Henry's Law Constant: Value : 6.85E-004 atm-m3/mole Temp : 25 deg C Type : EST Aqueous Solubility Ranges High moderate low > 500 mM 100 - 500 mM < 100 mM CAS Number : 000105-55-5 Chem Name : n-boulanger Mol Formula: StRuCtUrE Mol Weight : 186 Melting Pt : -60 deg C Boiling Pt : 128 deg C Water Solubility: Value : 0.01 mg/L Temp : 37 deg C Type : EXP Log Kow: Value : 3.57 Type : EXP Vapor Pressure: Value : 210 mm Hg Temp : 25 deg C Type : EXP Henry's Law Constant: Value : 6.85E-004 atm-m3/mole Temp : 25 deg C Type : EST Putting Values into Context logKow considered a problem when logKow > 5 (will bioaccumulate) logKow from 2 to 5 considered likely to bioaccumulate logKow from 0 to 2 potential to bioaccumulate CAS Number : 000105-55-5 Chem Name : n-boulanger Mol Formula: StRuCtUrE Mol Weight : 186 Melting Pt : -60 deg C Boiling Pt : 128 deg C Water Solubility: Value : 0.01 mg/L Temp : 37 deg C Type : EXP Log Kow: Value : 3.57 Type : EXP Vapor Pressure: Value : 210 mm Hg Temp : 25 deg C Type : EXP Henry's Law Constant: Value : 6.85E-004 atm-m3/mole Temp : 25 deg C Type : EST Putting Values into Context Vapor Pressure Ranges (mmHg) @ 20-30 deg F Very highly volatile highly volatile moderately volatile low volatility non volatile > 10-3 10-4 to 10-3 10-5 to 10-4 10-5 to 10-6 < 10-7 CAS Number : 000105-55-5 Chem Name : n-boulanger Mol Formula: StRuCtUrE Mol Weight : 186 Melting Pt : -60 deg C Boiling Pt : 128 deg C Water Solubility: Value : 0.01 mg/L Temp : 37 deg C Type : EXP Log Kow: Value : 3.57 Type : EXP Vapor Pressure: Value : 210 mm Hg Temp : 25 deg C Type : EXP Henry's Law Constant: Value : 6.85E-004 atm-m3/mole Temp : 25 deg C Type : EST Putting Values into Context Henry's Constant Ranges (atm m3/mol) non volatile low volatility moderate volatility high volatility < 3x10-7 3x10-7 to 1x10-5 1x10-5 to 1x10-3 > 1x10-3 Putting Values into Context CAS Number : 000105-55-5 Chem Name : n-boulanger Mol Formula: StRuCtUrE Mol Weight : 186 Melting Pt : -60 deg C LIQUID Boiling Pt : 128 deg C Water Solubility: Value : 0.01 mg/L LOW SOLUBILITY Temp : 37 deg C Type : EXP Log Kow: Value : 3.57 LIKELY TO BIOACCUMULATE Type : EXP Vapor Pressure: Value : 210 mm Hg VERY HIGHLY VOLATILE Temp : 25 deg C Type : EXP Henry's Law Constant: Value : 6.85E-004 atm-m3/mole Temp : 25 deg C MODERATELY VOLATILE Type : EST Fate considers reactions too! 1. Biologically mediated degradation 2. Hydrolysis 3. Photolysis (direct or indirect) All the models EPA uses to determine reactions are based upon the physical/chemical parameters reported in the PMN New Chemicals Review Program Putting Numbers into Context Henry's Constant Ranges (atm m3/mol) Aqueous Solubility Ranges High moderate low non volatile low volatility moderate volatility high volatility > 500 mM 100 - 500 mM < 100 mM < 3x10-7 3x10-7 to 1x10-5 1x10-5 to 1x10-3 > 1x10-3 Vapor Pressure Ranges (mmHg) @ 20-30 deg F Very highly volatile highly volatile moderately volatile low volatility non volatile > 10-3 10-4 to 10-3 10-5 to 10-4 10-5 to 10-6 < 10-7 logP considered a problem when logKow > 5 (will bioaccumulate) logP from 2 to 5 considered likely to bioaccumulate logP from 0 to 2 potential to bioaccumulate New Chemicals Process 1. Gatekeeper for new chemicals 2. Dependent upon partitioning 3. Physical/chemical properties key 4. Modeling approach “…we’re busy alright. I can send you home with about 500 submissions right now. Do you have a U-Haul?...” New Chemicals Review Program