WorkSafeBC Preliminary 2015 Base Premium Rates Injury Statistics and Trends Accommodation, Ski Hills, Food & Beverage, Golf Courses, Casinos and Outdoor Sport Tour go2 Health & Safety Summit August 21, 2014 Topics • • WorkSafeBC’s mandate Overview of the preliminary 2015 rates • Industry Accident & Injury Stats and Trends • Resources • Questions WorkSafeBC’s Mandate To work with workers and employers as follows: • To promote the prevention of workplace injury, illness, and disease • To rehabilitate those who are injured, and assist with timely return to work • To provide fair compensation to replace lost wages for injured workers during their recovery • To ensure sound financial management for a viable workers’ compensation system Overview of 2015 Rates The average base premium rate is projected to remain unchanged at $1.70 per $100 of employers’ assessable payroll. Increase in claims costs, Long Term Disability awards, and Health Care costs • Excess investment returns • $117 million withdrawal from the Capital Adequacy Reserve, and the capping of rate increases for industries at 20 percent have kept the average rate from increasing next year • 44 percent of employers will experience a base rate increase • 54 percent of employers will experience a base rate decrease • 2 percent of employers will have their base rate remain unchanged Overnight and Short-term Accommodation 2009 - 2013 Profile CU 761056 (Short Term Overnight Accommodation) plus 761004, 761008, 761017, 761024, 761026, 761037, and 761055 Prepared by: Business Information and Analysis (BIA) JUNE 30, 2014 2015 Rates Overnight Accommodation 6 Key Findings Overnight and Short-term Accommodation In 2013, there were 1,902 employers in this industry, a 4% decrease over the past four years. The Injury Rate for the selected CUs remains lower than the Injury Rate for all BC CUs combined. The percentage of workers returning to work within 4 weeks increased in 2013 compared to 2012 and is lower than all BC (2013: 50% for Overnight and Short-term Accommodation vs. 52% for all BC). The average Short-Term Disability Duration (work days lost per claim) for the selected CUs is similar to all-BC. Light duty cleaners, food and beverage servers contribute the most claims in the selected CUs. Compared to 2012, the number of Prevention Orders issued to employers in the selected CUs decreased by 1% to 295 orders in 2013. As of June 30, 2014, 114 Prevention Orders have been issued year-to-date. Between 2009 and 2014 YTD, there were 6 work-related deaths. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 7 Overnight and Short-term Accommodation Statistical Overview In 2013, there were 1,902 employers in this industry, a 4% decrease over the past four years. Injury Rate (per 100 Return to Work person-years of (<=4 weeks) employment) Person Years STD Duration (Average Days Lost per Claim) Serious Injuries** WorkRelated Deaths N/A 46,319 54 69 0 N/A 46,381 64 92 1 1.9 54% 46,403 66 102 4 1.8 46% 45,296 69 75 1 42,966 1.8 50% 44,384 62 71 0 $47,161,463 222,245 1.8 (Avg) 50% (Avg) 45,757 (Avg) 63 (Avg) 409 6 43% 7% 6% N/A -4% 15% 3% N/A Year STD/LTD/Fatal Claims Claim Cost Paid* Work Days Lost* 2009 809 $7,210,365 39,974 1.7 2010 871 $7,409,766 44,679 1.9 2011 911 $9,646,074 49,867 2012 866 $12,578,571 44,759 2013 832 $10,316,687 Total 4,289 2009 to 2013 % Change 3% * Note: The Claim Cost Paid and Work Days Lost relate to the claims from all years of injury and are not just the results of the given year's claims. ** Note: Serious Injuries include time-loss claims that represent either a serious medical diagnosis, or a potentially-serious medical diagnosis with a long recovery period of 50+ days paid (10+ weeks off work). Serious Injuries also include all workrelated death claims. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 8 Overnight and Short-term Accommodation Time-loss Claims per 100 Person-years of Employment Injury Rate Trend 2.5 2.3 2.3 1.9 2.0 2.3 2.3 2.3 1.9 1.8 1.8 1.7 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 2009 2010 2011 2012 Injury Rate - Overnight and Short-term Accommodation 2013 Injury Rate - All BC The Injury Rate for the selected CUs remains lower than the Injury Rate for all BC CUs combined. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 9 Overnight and Short-term Accommodation Claims and Employment Trends 47,000 900 884 46,381 880 46,500 46,319 46,403 46,000 Time-Loss Claims 861 833 840 45,500 820 45,296 800 785 799 44,384 780 45,000 44,500 Person Years 860 44,000 760 43,500 740 43,000 720 2009 2010 2011 # Time-Loss Claims 2012 2013 Person Years The estimated number of workers (Person Years) saw a slight decrease in 2013, whereas the number of time-loss claims decreased by 4%. This has resulted in a slight decrease in the Injury Rate for the selected CUs in 2013. Meanwhile, the assessable payroll has increased by 0.6% in 2013. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 10 Overnight and Short-term Accommodation STD Duration – Five Year Trend Average Short-term Disability Days per Claim 80 69 66 70 60 64 59 54 60 60 62 58 55 50 40 30 20 10 0 2009 2010 2011 Overnight and Short-term Accommodation 2012 2013 All BC The average Short-Term Disability Duration (work days lost per claim) for the selected CUs is similar to all-BC. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 11 Return to Work (RTW) The percentage of workers returning to work within 4 weeks increased in 2013 compared to 2012 and is lower than all BC (2013: 50% for Overnight and Short-term Accommodation vs. 52% for all BC). % of Claims Returning to Work within 4 Weeks 100% 80% 60% 54% 54% 46% 53% 50% 52% 40% 20% 0% 2011 2012 Overnight and Short-term Accommodation 2013 All BC Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 12 Overnight and Short-term Accommodation Occupations (Top 10) % STD/LTD/Fatal Claims, 2009 - 2013 Profile Occupation Type Light duty cleaners # of Claims % of Claims 2,145 50% Food and beverage servers 272 6% Cooks 246 6% Janitors, caretakers and building superintendents 231 5% Other trades helpers and labourers 155 4% Food counter attendants, kitchen helpers and related support occupations 137 3% Dry cleaning, laundry and related occupations 121 3% Hotel front desk clerks 103 2% Outdoor sport and recreational guides 92 2% Support occupations in accommodation, travel and facilities set-up services 90 2% Other 697 16% 4,289 100% Grand Total Light duty cleaners, food and beverage servers contribute the most claims in the selected CUs. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 13 Overnight and Short-term Accommodation Age and Gender % STD/LTD/Fatal Claims, 2009 - 2013 Profile Male Female Total Age # of Claims % of Claims # of Claims % of Claims # of Claims % of Claims 0 - 14 2 0% 0 0% 2 0% 15 - 24 188 4% 352 8% 540 13% 25 - 34 361 8% 459 11% 820 19% 35 - 44 298 7% 602 14% 900 21% 45 - 54 394 9% 830 19% 1,224 29% 55 - 64 241 6% 482 11% 723 17% 65 and Over 36 1% 43 1% 79 2% Total 1,520 35% 2,768 65% 4,288 100% Young Workers (aged 15-24) represent 13%, while Mature Workers (aged 45 - 64) represent 46% of the total STD/LTD/Fatal claims. The majority of these claims were made by females. *There is one claim where the age and gender is uncoded. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 14 Overnight and Short-term Accommodation Accident and Injury Type % STD/LTD/Fatal Claims, 2009 - 2013 Profile Accident Type Claims Overexertion Fall on Same Level Struck By Other Bodily Motion Fall from Elevation Other Claim Costs 33% 17% 12% 10% 8% 19% Overexertion Fall on Same Level Fall from Elevation Other Bodily Motion Struck By Other Work Days Lost 29% 19% 18% 7% 7% 21% Overexertion Fall on Same Level Fall from Elevation Other Bodily Motion Struck By Other 35% 20% 17% 5% 4% 20% Other Strains Back Strain Fractures Contusion Tendinitis, Tenosynovitis Other 33% 22% 12% 9% 6% 17% Injury Type Claims Other Strains Back Strain Contusion Laceration Fractures Other Claim Costs 36% 25% 11% 8% 6% 14% Other Strains Back Strain Fractures Tendinitis, Tenosynovitis Concussion Other Work Days Lost 41% 21% 14% 5% 5% 14% Overexertion contributes the most to claims, costs, and days lost in the selected CUs. The most common injury type is Other Strains, which also contributes the most claim costs and days lost. * Note: Uncoded claim costs have been proportionally allocated to coded categories Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC . 15 Overnight and Short-term Accommodation Other Injury Factors % STD/LTD/Fatal Claims, 2009 - 2013 Profile Body Part Injured Back, 1,093, 26% Other, 1,338, 31% Knee, 309, 7% Source of Injury Working Surf aces, 889, 21% Other, 1,360, 32% Wrist, Fingers & Hand, 783, 18% Shoulders, 381, 9% Ankle, Toe & Feet, 385, 9% Bodily Motion, 593, 14% Buildings & Structures, 350, 8% Boxes, Containers, 517, 12% Furniture, f ixtures, 580, 13% * Note: Uncoded claim costs have been proportionally allocated to coded categories Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC . 16 Overnight and Short-term Accommodation Serious Injury Claims Between 2009 and 2013, the selected CUs combined for 409 Serious Injury Claims*. Serious Injuries represent 10% of the claims in the selected CUs and account for 30% of the claims cost paid to date. Accident Type Injury Type Fall on Same Level 31% Fractures 47% Fall from Elevation 21% Contusion 12% Struck By 15% Laceration 12% 9% Concussion 7% 7% Back Strain Struck Against Overexertion Other 17% Other 7% 15% The serious injury claims in these CUs are more likely to involve: fall on same level, fall from elevation, fractures. *Serious Injuries include time-loss claims that represent either a serious medical diagnosis, or a potentially-serious medical diagnosis with a long recovery period of 50+ days paid (10+ weeks off work). Serious Injuries also include all work-related death claims. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 17 Overnight and Short-term Accommodation Serious Injury Claim Examples Fall on Same Level Cost Days finished cleaning bathroom and slipped on wet floor and fell to floor $ 120,486 833 pulling full laundry cart onto elevator & wheels of cart were not in good condition & due to weight in cart, it fell over & wkr fell with the cart. $ 209 Fall from Elevation 160,164 Cost bringing luggage from one room to another - carrying luggage down the stairs, wkr fell backwards and slid down 2-3 steps. $ Walking down the stairwell tripped and fell backwards. $ Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 45,405 16,000 Days 387 110 18 Overnight and Short-term Accommodation Work-Related Deaths Year CU Code Occupation 2010 761055 2011 761008 2011 761008 2011 761017 2011 761017 2012 761017 Description FATAL - OXYCODONE OVERDOSE - CLAIM ORIGINALLY Light duty cleaners ACCEPTED FOR A DISC INJURY FROM GRABBING A SLIPPING BAG OF HEAVY LAUNDRY FATAL - PULMONARY EMBOLUS DUE TO DVT DUE TO A TIBIAL Chain saw and skidder operators FRACTURE WITH PARAPLEGIA SUSTAINED INITIALLY WHEN STRUCK BY FALLING TREE, SPINAL CORD INJURY RECEIVED FATAL - 19' COMMERCIAL SPORT FISHING VESSEL WITH ONE Outdoor sport and recreational guides GUIDE AND 3 GUESTS FAILED TO RETURN TO FISHING LODGE. VESSEL NOT FOUND FELL DOWN STAIRS HITTING HEAD ON CEMENT LANDING Administrative officers PASSED AWAY IN HOSPITAL FATAL - WORKING ON HYDRAULIC-LIFTED ROW OF SEATS, Other trades helpers and labourers BRAKE GAVE WAY, SEATS FELL ON NECK & BACK OF HEAD. WKR FELL 9.5' THROUGH OPENING HITTING HEAD ON FLOOR Janitors, caretakers and building FATAL - FELL APPROX 20 FT FROM A LADDER WHILE CHECKING superintendents A SMOKE ALARM ON VAULTED CEILING Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 19 Overnight and Short-term Accommodation Prevention Activity 400 361 336 350 300 326 297 277 250 200 151 150 111 120 100 96 94 121 28 50 0 2009 2010 2011 Inspection Reports 2012 2013 2014 Other Contacts Compared to 2012, the number of Inspection Reports issued in the selected CUs decreased by 15% to 277 documents in 2013. As of June 30, 2014, 121 Inspection Reports have been issued year-to-date. Note: 2014 is currently June YTD. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 20 Overnight and Short-term Accommodation Prevention Orders 700 642 584 600 536 400 473 481 500 379 429 414 299 300 295 200 114 138 100 0 2009 2010 2011 Prevention Orders 2012 2013 2014 Order Follow-Ups Compared to 2012, the number of Prevention Orders issued to employers in the selected CUs decreased by 1% to 295 orders in 2013. As of June 30, 2014, 114 Prevention Orders have been issued year-to-date. Note: 2014 is currently June YTD. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 21 Overnight and Short-term Accommodation Penalties & Warning Letters 7 6 6 6 5 4 4 3 3 3 3 3 2 2 2 2 1 1 1 0 2009 2010 2011 Warning Letters Sent 2012 2013 2014 Penalties Imposed Between 2009 and 2014YTD, 23 warning letters were sent and 13 administrative penalties were imposed. Note: 2014 is currently June YTD. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 22 Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment Classification Unit # 761035 2009 - 2013 Profile Prepared by: Business Information and Analysis (BIA) JUNE 30, 2014 Base Rates 24 Key Findings Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment - CU # 761035 In 2013, there were 8,048 employers in this industry, a 5% increase over the past four years. The Injury Rate for the Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment CU remains lower than the Injury Rate for all BC CUs combined. The percentage of workers returning to work within 4 weeks decreased in 2013 compared to 2012 and is higher than all BC (2013: 67% for Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment vs. 52% for all BC). The average Short-Term Disability Duration (work days lost per claim) for the Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment CU is significantly lower than all BC. Food counter attendants, kitchen helpers and related support occupations, cooks contribute the most claims in the Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment CU. Compared to 2012, the number of Prevention Orders issued to employers in Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment decreased by 2% to 465 orders in 2013. As of June 30, 2014, 200 Prevention Orders have been issued year-to-date. Between 2009 and 2014 YTD, there were 5 work-related deaths. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 25 Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment - CU # 761035 Statistical Overview In 2013, there were 8,048 employers in this industry, a 5% increase over the past four years. Year STD/LTD/Fatal Claims 2009 2010 Injury Rate (per 100 Return to Work person-years of (<=4 weeks) employment) Person Years STD Duration (Average Days Lost per Claim) Serious Injuries** WorkRelated Deaths N/A 133,566 34 200 0 N/A 134,343 37 199 2 1.7 68% 132,417 38 198 0 1.8 68% 136,273 36 220 2 70,776 1.6 67% 138,583 37 203 0 $62,767,468 353,488 1.7 (Avg) 68% (Avg) 135,036 (Avg) 37 (Avg) 1,020 4 52% -2% -5% N/A 4% 9% 2% N/A Claim Cost Paid* Work Days Lost* 2,246 $9,602,969 72,486 1.7 2,212 $11,472,635 70,777 1.6 2011 2,311 $12,507,459 70,853 2012 2,441 $14,559,050 68,596 2013 2,247 $14,625,355 Total 11,457 2009 to 2013 % Change 0% * Note: The Claim Cost Paid and Work Days Lost relate to the claims from all years of injury and are not just the results of the given year's claims. ** Note: Serious Injuries include time-loss claims that represent either a serious medical diagnosis, or a potentially-serious medical diagnosis with a long recovery period of 50+ days paid (10+ weeks off work). Serious Injuries also include all workrelated death claims. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 26 Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment - CU # 761035 Time-loss Claims per 100 Person-years of Employment Injury Rate Trend 2.5 2.3 2.3 2.3 2.3 1.7 1.8 2.3 2.0 1.7 1.6 1.6 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 2009 2010 2011 2012 Injury Rate - Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment 2013 Injury Rate - All BC The Injury Rate for the Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment CU remains lower than the Injury Rate for all BC CUs combined. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 27 Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment - CU # 761035 Claims and Employment Trends 140,000 2,450 2,398 2,400 139,000 138,583 138,000 2,250 137,000 136,273 2,300 2,249 2,237 136,000 135,000 134,343 2,200 2,211 2,150 133,000 133,566 2,100 134,000 Person Years Time-Loss Claims 2,350 2,119 132,000 132,417 2,050 131,000 2,000 130,000 129,000 1,950 2009 2010 2011 # Time-Loss Claims 2012 2013 Person Years The estimated number of workers (Person Years) saw a slight increase in 2013, whereas the number of time-loss claims decreased by 8%. This has resulted in a decrease in the Injury Rate for the Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment CU in 2013. Meanwhile, the assessable payroll has increased by 4.1% in 2013. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 28 Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment - CU # 761035 STD Duration – Five Year Trend Average Short-term Disability Days per Claim 70 60 59 60 60 58 55 50 40 37 34 38 36 37 30 20 10 0 2009 2010 2011 Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment 2012 2013 All BC The average Short-Term Disability Duration (work days lost per claim) for the Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment CU is significantly lower than all BC. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 29 Return to Work (RTW) The percentage of workers returning to work within 4 weeks decreased in 2013 compared to 2012 and is higher than all BC (2013: 67% for Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment vs. 52% for all BC). % of Claims Returning to Work within 4 Weeks 100% 80% 60% 68% 68% 54% 67% 53% 52% 40% 20% 0% 2011 2012 Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment 2013 All BC Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 30 Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment - CU # 761035 Occupations (Top 10) % STD/LTD/Fatal Claims, 2009 - 2013 Profile Occupation Type # of Claims % of Claims Food counter attendants, kitchen helpers and related support occupations 3,815 33% Cooks 3,566 31% Food and beverage servers 1,286 11% Restaurant and food service managers 603 5% Chefs 429 4% Food service supervisors 276 2% Cashiers 275 2% Bakers 223 2% Bartenders 217 2% Maitres d'hotel and hosts/hostesses 136 1% Other 631 6% 11,457 100% Grand Total Food counter attendants, kitchen helpers and related support occupations, cooks contribute the most claims in the Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment CU. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 31 Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment - CU # 761035 Age and Gender % STD/LTD/Fatal Claims, 2009 - 2013 Profile Male Female Total Age # of Claims % of Claims # of Claims % of Claims # of Claims % of Claims 0 - 14 11 0% 17 0% 28 0% 15 - 24 1,961 17% 2,079 18% 4,040 35% 25 - 34 1,185 10% 1,357 12% 2,542 22% 35 - 44 685 6% 1,160 10% 1,845 16% 45 - 54 547 5% 1,359 12% 1,906 17% 55 - 64 300 3% 689 6% 989 9% 65 and Over 53 0% 50 0% 103 1% Total 4,742 41% 6,711 59% 11,453 100% Young Workers (aged 15-24) represent 35%, while Mature Workers (aged 45 - 64) represent 26% of the total STD/LTD/Fatal claims. The majority of these claims were made by females. * There are 4 claims where the age and gender were uncoded. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 32 Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment - CU # 761035 Accident and Injury Type % STD/LTD/Fatal Claims, 2009 - 2013 Profile Accident Type Claims Struck By Fall on Same Level Overexertion Exposure to Heat, Cold Struck Against Other Claim Costs 25% 18% 17% 14% 11% 15% Fall on Same Level Overexertion Struck By Fall from Elevation Other Bodily Motion Other Work Days Lost 29% 20% 12% 7% 6% 25% Fall on Same Level Overexertion Struck By Other Bodily Motion Struck Against Other 32% 14% 14% 10% 6% 23% Other Strains Back Strain Fractures Laceration Contusion Other 30% 23% 13% 7% 6% 21% Injury Type Claims Laceration Other Strains Heat Burns Back Strain Contusion Other Claim Costs 26% 22% 14% 14% 10% 13% Other Strains Fractures Back Strain Laceration Heat Burns Other Work Days Lost 33% 16% 13% 10% 6% 21% Struck By contributes the most claims, while Fall on Same Level contributes the most to claim costs in the Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment CU. The most common injury type is Laceration, while Other Strains contributes the most claim costs. * Note: Uncoded claim costs have been proportionally allocated to coded categories Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC . 33 Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment - CU # 761035 Other Injury Factors % STD/LTD/Fatal Claims, 2009 - 2013 Profile Body Part Injured Other, 3,099, 27% Wrist, Fingers & Hand, 4,541, 39% Shoulders, 536, 5% Source of Injury Other, 3,600, 32% Boxes, Containers, 2,187, 19% Ankle, Toe & Feet, 780, 7% Other Upper Extremity, 782, 7% Back, 1,719, 15% Working Surf aces, 2,088, 18% Bodily Motion, 843, 7% Animal Products, Food Products, 991, 9% Hand Tools, 1,748, 15% * Note: Uncoded claim costs have been proportionally allocated to coded categories Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC . 34 Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment - CU # 761035 Serious Injury Claims Between 2009 and 2013, the Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment CU combined for 1,020 Serious Injury Claims*. Serious Injuries represent 9% of the claims in the Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment CU and account for 39% of the claims cost paid to date. Accident Type Injury Type Struck By 30% Fractures 32% Fall on Same Level 29% Laceration 31% Struck Against 14% Contusion 9% 6% Concussion 6% 5% Heat Burns Fall from Elevation Exposure to Heat, Cold Other 15% Other 5% 17% The serious injury claims in this CU are more likely to involve: fall on same level, fractures. *Serious Injuries include time-loss claims that represent either a serious medical diagnosis, or a potentially-serious medical diagnosis with a long recovery period of 50+ days paid (10+ weeks off work). Serious Injuries also include all work-related death claims. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 35 Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment - CU # 761035 Serious Injury Claim Examples Struck By Cost cutting calamari when knife slipped and punctured left hand $ Worker was moving a cart of dishes into elevator, as the cart went over the gap between the floor $ & elevator, a plate fell off cart hitting worker on finger. Fall on Same Level 227,361 28,000 Cost Days 307 170 Days Worker slipped on some water on the floor and fell. $ 40,000 170 Walked thru swinging door in back room, took 2 steps , slipped & fell on wet floor. $ 22,000 110 Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 36 Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment - CU # 761035 Work-Related Deaths Year Occupation 2010 Restaurant and food service managers 2010 Cooks 2012 Restaurant and food service managers 2012 Food and beverage servers 2014 Chefs Description FATAL - FELL OFF TAILGATE OF PICK UP TRUCK AND HEAVY BARREL OF DIESEL LANDED ON TOP OF WORKER FATAL - DROWNED AT A LEADERS DAY OUT EVENT WHEN WKR DOVE OFF OF BOAT TO RETREIVE A PAIR OF SUNGLASSES FATAL SHOOTING FATAL GUNSHOT WOUND FATAL MESOTHELIOMA Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 37 Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment - CU # 761035 Prevention Activity 500 450 437 422 380 400 399 376 350 300 250 217 200 150 113 119 115 98 84 100 77 50 0 2009 2010 2011 Inspection Reports 2012 2013 2014 Other Contacts Compared to 2012, the number of Inspection Reports issued in Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment increased by 10% to 437 documents in 2013. As of June 30, 2014, 217 Inspection Reports have been issued year-to-date. Note: 2014 is currently June YTD. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 38 Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment - CU # 761035 Prevention Orders 800 717 700 600 641 593 500 550 532 518 475 451 465 360 400 300 200 233 200 100 0 2009 2010 2011 Prevention Orders 2012 2013 2014 Order Follow-Ups Compared to 2012, the number of Prevention Orders issued to employers in Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment decreased by 2% to 465 orders in 2013. As of June 30, 2014, 200 Prevention Orders have been issued year-to-date. Note: 2014 is currently June YTD. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 39 Restaurant or Other Dining Establishment - CU # 761035 Penalties & Warning Letters 6 5 5 5 4 4 4 3 3 2 1 1 1 2011 2012 2013 1 1 1 0 0 2009 2010 0 Warning Letters Sent 2014 Penalties Imposed Between 2009 and 2014YTD, 22 warning letters were sent and four administrative penalties were imposed. Note: 2014 is currently June YTD. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 40 Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge Classification Unit # 761034 2009 - 2013 Profile Prepared by: Business Information and Analysis (BIA) JUNE 30, 2014 Base Rates 42 Key Findings Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge - CU # 761034 In 2013, there were 767 employers in this industry, a 6% decrease over the past four years. The Injury Rate for the Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge CU remains lower than the Injury Rate for all BC CUs combined. The percentage of workers returning to work within 4 weeks decreased in 2013 compared to 2012 and is higher than all BC (2013: 63% for Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge vs. 52% for all BC). The average Short-Term Disability Duration (work days lost per claim) for the Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge CU is significantly lower than all BC. Cooks, food and beverage servers contribute the most claims in the Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge CU. Compared to 2012, the number of Prevention Orders issued to employers in Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge increased by 5% to 91 orders in 2013. As of June 30, 2014, 19 Prevention Orders have been issued year-to-date. Between 2009 and 2014 YTD, there were no work-related deaths. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 43 Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge - CU # 761034 Statistical Overview In 2013, there were 767 employers in this industry, a 6% decrease over the past four years. Year STD/LTD/Fatal Claim Cost Claims Paid* Work Days Lost* Injury Rate (per 100 Return to Work person-years of (<=4 weeks) employment) Person Years STD Duration (Average Days Lost per Claim) WorkSerious Related Injuries** Deaths 2009 217 $1,671,046 7,385 1.4 N/A 14,646 36 27 0 2010 168 $1,128,142 5,729 1.2 N/A 14,032 42 17 0 2011 234 $1,874,468 9,100 1.7 61% 13,051 51 43 0 2012 183 $2,031,535 7,519 1.3 64% 13,021 36 24 0 2013 190 $2,147,899 6,614 1.5 63% 12,868 42 33 0 Total 992 $8,853,090 36,347 1.4 (Avg) 63% (Avg) 13,524 (Avg) 41 (Avg) 144 0 2009 to 2013 % Change -12% 29% -10% 12% N/A -12% 17% 22% N/A * Note: The Claim Cost Paid and Work Days Lost relate to the claims from all years of injury and are not just the results of the given year's claims. ** Note: Serious Injuries include time-loss claims that represent either a serious medical diagnosis, or a potentially-serious medical diagnosis with a long recovery period of 50+ days paid (10+ weeks off work). Serious Injuries also include all workrelated death claims. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 44 Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge - CU # 761034 Time-loss Claims per 100 Person-years of Employment Injury Rate Trend 2.5 2.3 2.3 2.3 2.3 2.3 2.0 1.7 1.5 1.5 1.4 1.3 1.2 1.0 0.5 0.0 2009 2010 2011 Injury Rate - Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge 2012 2013 Injury Rate - All BC The Injury Rate for the Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge CU remains lower than the Injury Rate for all BC CUs combined. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 45 Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge - CU # 761034 Claims and Employment Trends 15,000 14,646 219 197 200 14,032 171 Time-Loss Claims 201 14,000 168 150 14,500 13,500 13,051 13,021 12,868 100 13,000 Person Years 250 12,500 50 12,000 11,500 0 2009 2010 2011 # Time-Loss Claims 2012 2013 Person Years The estimated number of workers (Person Years) saw a slight decrease in 2013, whereas the number of time-loss claims increased by 15%. This has resulted in an increase in the Injury Rate for the Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge CU in 2013. Meanwhile, the assessable payroll has increased by 1.7% in 2013. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 46 Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge - CU # 761034 STD Duration – Five Year Trend Average Short-term Disability Days per Claim 70 60 59 60 55 60 58 51 50 42 40 42 36 36 30 20 10 0 2009 2010 2011 Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge 2012 2013 All BC The average Short-Term Disability Duration (work days lost per claim) for the Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge CU is significantly lower than all BC. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 47 Return to Work (RTW) The percentage of workers returning to work within 4 weeks decreased in 2013 compared to 2012 and is higher than all BC (2013: 63% for Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge vs. 52% for all BC). % of Claims Returning to Work within 4 Weeks 100% 80% 61% 60% 64% 54% 63% 53% 52% 40% 20% 0% 2011 2012 Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge 2013 All BC Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 48 Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge - CU # 761034 Occupations (Top 10) % STD/LTD/Fatal Claims, 2009 - 2013 Profile Occupation Type # of Claims % of Claims Cooks 386 39% Food and beverage servers 125 13% Bartenders 114 11% Food counter attendants, kitchen helpers and related support occupations 93 9% Security guards and related security service occupations 58 6% Restaurant and food service managers 53 5% Retail salespersons 39 4% Chefs 28 3% Other service support occupations, n.e.c. 16 2% Janitors, caretakers and building superintendents 15 2% Other 65 7% Grand Total 992 100% Cooks, food and beverage servers contribute the most claims in the Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge CU. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 49 Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge - CU # 761034 Age and Gender % STD/LTD/Fatal Claims, 2009 - 2013 Profile Male Female Total Age # of Claims % of Claims # of Claims % of Claims # of Claims % of Claims 0 - 14 2 0% 0 0% 2 0% 15 - 24 181 18% 137 14% 318 32% 25 - 34 173 17% 133 13% 306 31% 35 - 44 73 7% 98 10% 171 17% 45 - 54 47 5% 74 7% 121 12% 55 - 64 22 2% 38 4% 60 6% 65 and Over 10 1% 4 0% 14 1% Total 508 51% 484 49% 992 100% Young Workers (aged 15-24) represent 32%, while Mature Workers (aged 45 – 64) represent 18% of the total STD/LTD/Fatal claims. The slight majority of these claims were made by males. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 50 Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge - CU # 761034 Accident and Injury Type % STD/LTD/Fatal Claims, 2009 - 2013 Profile Accident Type Claims Struck By Overexertion Fall on Same Level Acts of Violence, Force Exposure to Heat, Cold Other Claim Costs 25% 17% 14% 11% 10% 24% Acts of Violence, Force Overexertion Struck By Fall on Same Level Fall from Elevation Other Work Days Lost 33% 17% 11% 11% 8% 20% Overexertion Fall on Same Level Acts of Violence, Force Struck By Other Bodily Motion Other 24% 20% 14% 8% 7% 28% Other Strains Fractures Back Strain Laceration Concussion Other 27% 20% 18% 12% 6% 17% Injury Type Claims Laceration Other Strains Back Strain Heat Burns Fractures Other Claim Costs 27% 21% 14% 10% 8% 20% Other Strains Fractures Concussion Back Strain Laceration Other Work Days Lost 30% 19% 11% 10% 7% 23% Struck By contributes the most claims, while Acts of Violence, Force contributes the most to claim costs in the Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge CU. The most common injury type is Laceration, while Other Strains contributes the most claim costs. * Note: Uncoded claim costs have been proportionally allocated to coded categories Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC . 51 Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge - CU # 761034 Other Injury Factors % STD/LTD/Fatal Claims, 2009 - 2013 Profile Body Part Injured Other, 277, 28% Wrist, Fingers & Hand, 370, 37% Other Upper Extremity, 53, 5% Source of Injury Other, 305, 31% Boxes, Containers, 194, 20% Shoulders, 58, 6% Ankle, Toe & Feet, 90, 9% Back, 144, 15% Working Surf aces, 163, 16% Bodily Motion, 78, 8% People, 92, 9% Hand Tools, 160, 16% * Note: Uncoded claim costs have been proportionally allocated to coded categories Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC . 52 Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge - CU # 761034 Serious Injury Claims Between 2009 and 2013, the Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge CU combined for 144 Serious Injury Claims*. Serious Injuries represent 15% of the claims in the Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge CU and account for 53% of the claims cost paid to date. Accident Type Injury Type Struck By 25% Fractures 40% Acts of Violence, Force 24% Laceration 31% Fall on Same Level 19% Concussion 6% Struck Against 11% Dislocation 4% Fall from Elevation Other 8% 13% Other Injuries Other 3% 15% The serious injury claims in this CU are more likely to involve: acts of violence, force, fractures. *Serious Injuries include time-loss claims that represent either a serious medical diagnosis, or a potentially-serious medical diagnosis with a long recovery period of 50+ days paid (10+ weeks off work). Serious Injuries also include all work-related death claims. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 53 Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge - CU # 761034 Serious Injury Claim Examples Struck By Cost Days Taking a glass out of dishwasher, it broke in wkr's hand. $ 44,000 330 Holding door open for band member carrying an amp who banged against the door and wkr's hand on door knob was crushed between chair rail. $ 153,000 310 Acts of Violence, Force Cost Days Guarding front door of club when a previously removed customer came back and shot worker with a gun. $ 41,000 240 Involved in altercation with agressive patrons, worker was punched in head 5 to 6 times. $ 15,000 300 Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 54 Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge - CU # 761034 Prevention Activity 140 120 120 107 101 94 100 80 65 60 40 23 20 19 24 18 9 27 7 0 2009 2010 2011 Inspection Reports 2012 2013 2014 Other Contacts Compared to 2012, the number of Inspection Reports issued in Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge increased by 45% to 94 documents in 2013. As of June 30, 2014, 27 Inspection Reports have been issued year-to-date. Note: 2014 is currently June YTD. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 55 Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge - CU # 761034 Prevention Orders 200 183 180 160 140 158 156 160 134 115 120 100 85 87 87 91 80 60 40 19 20 23 0 2009 2010 2011 Prevention Orders 2012 2013 2014 Order Follow-Ups Compared to 2012, the number of Prevention Orders issued to employers in Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge increased by 5% to 91 orders in 2013. As of June 30, 2014, 19 Prevention Orders have been issued year-to-date. Note: 2014 is currently June YTD. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 56 Pub, Bar, Night Club, or Lounge - CU # 761034 Penalties & Warning Letters 3.5 3 3 2.5 2 1.5 1 1 1 0.5 0 0 0 2010 2011 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2009 Warning Letters Sent 2012 2013 2014 Penalties Imposed Between 2009 and 2014YTD, four warning letters were sent and one administrative penalty was imposed. Note: 2014 is currently June YTD. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 57 Ski Hill or Gondola Ride Classification Unit # 761038 2009 - 2013 Profile Prepared by: Business Information and Analysis (BIA) JUNE 30, 2014 Base Rates 59 Key Findings Ski Hill or Gondola Ride - CU # 761038 In 2013, there were 42 employers in this industry, a 8% increase over the past four years. The Injury Rate for the Ski Hill or Gondola Ride CU remains higher than the Injury Rate for all BC CUs combined. The percentage of workers returning to work within 4 weeks stayed the same in 2013 compared to 2012 and is higher than all BC (2013: 58% for Ski Hill or Gondola Ride vs. 52% for all BC). The average Short-Term Disability Duration (work days lost per claim) for the Ski Hill or Gondola Ride CU is significantly lower than all BC. Program leaders and instructors in recreation, sport and fitness contribute the most claims in the Ski Hill or Gondola Ride CU. There were 119 Prevention Orders issued between 2009 and 2014YTD. As of June 30, 2014, 10 Prevention Orders have been issued year-to-date. Between 2009 and 2014 YTD, there was one work-related death. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 60 Ski Hill or Gondola Ride - CU # 761038 Statistical Overview In 2013, there were 42 employers in this industry, a 8% increase over the past four years. Year STD/LTD/Fatal Claim Cost Claims Paid* Work Days Lost* Injury Rate (per 100 Return to Work person-years of (<=4 weeks) employment) Person Years STD Duration (Average Days Lost per Claim) WorkSerious Related Injuries** Deaths 2009 263 $3,167,524 9,386 8.0 N/A 3,379 39 53 0 2010 252 $2,356,752 10,264 7.2 N/A 3,278 45 41 0 2011 236 $2,110,487 8,693 7.4 61% 3,061 44 32 0 2012 257 $3,032,505 9,912 7.8 58% 3,164 47 49 0 2013 232 $2,943,084 8,519 7.5 58% 3,090 43 38 1 Total 1,240 $13,610,352 46,774 7.6 (Avg) 59% (Avg) 3,194 (Avg) 43 (Avg) 213 1 2009 to 2013 % Change -12% -7% -9% -6% N/A -9% 12% -28% N/A * Note: The Claim Cost Paid and Work Days Lost relate to the claims from all years of injury and are not just the results of the given year's claims. ** Note: Serious Injuries include time-loss claims that represent either a serious medical diagnosis, or a potentially-serious medical diagnosis with a long recovery period of 50+ days paid (10+ weeks off work). Serious Injuries also include all workrelated death claims. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 61 Ski Hill or Gondola Ride - CU # 761038 Time-loss Claims per 100 Person-years of Employment Injury Rate Trend 9.0 8.0 8.0 7.2 7.4 7.8 7.5 7.0 6.0 5.0 4.0 3.0 2.3 2.3 2.3 2.3 2.3 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2.0 1.0 0.0 Injury Rate - Ski Hill or Gondola Ride Injury Rate - All BC The Injury Rate for the Ski Hill or Gondola Ride CU remains higher than the Injury Rate for all BC CUs combined. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 62 Ski Hill or Gondola Ride - CU # 761038 Claims and Employment Trends 3,500 280 Time-Loss Claims 260 269 3,400 3,379 3,278 3,300 250 246 3,200 240 237 230 231 228 3,164 Person Years 270 3,100 3,090 220 3,061 3,000 210 2,900 200 2009 2010 2011 # Time-Loss Claims 2012 2013 Person Years The estimated number of workers (Person Years) saw a slight decrease in 2013, whereas the number of time-loss claims decreased by 6%. This has resulted in a decrease in the Injury Rate for the Ski Hill or Gondola Ride CU in 2013. Meanwhile, the assessable payroll has increased by 1.4% in 2013. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 63 Ski Hill or Gondola Ride - CU # 761038 STD Duration – Five Year Trend Average Short-term Disability Days per Claim 70 60 58 55 47 50 40 60 59 60 44 45 43 39 30 20 10 0 2009 2010 2011 Ski Hill or Gondola Ride 2012 2013 All BC The average Short-Term Disability Duration (work days lost per claim) for the Ski Hill or Gondola Ride CU is significantly lower than all BC. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 64 Return to Work (RTW) The percentage of workers returning to work within 4 weeks stayed the same in 2013 compared to 2012 and is higher than all BC (2013: 58% for Ski Hill or Gondola Ride vs. 52% for all BC). % of Claims Returning to Work within 4 Weeks 100% 80% 61% 60% 54% 58% 58% 53% 52% 40% 20% 0% 2011 2012 Ski Hill or Gondola Ride 2013 All BC Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 65 Ski Hill or Gondola Ride - CU # 761038 Occupations (Top 10) % STD/LTD/Fatal Claims, 2009 - 2013 Profile Occupation Type # of Claims % of Claims Program leaders and instructors in recreation, sport and fitness 685 55% Operators and attendants in amusement, recreation and sport 262 21% Construction millwrights and industrial mechanics 32 3% Janitors, caretakers and building superintendents 21 2% Accommodation, travel, tourism and related services supervisors 18 1% Food counter attendants, kitchen helpers and related support occupations 16 1% Outdoor sport and recreational guides 14 1% Other service support occupations, n.e.c. 14 1% Cooks 12 1% Heavy-duty equipment mechanics 12 1% Other 154 12% 1,240 100% Grand Total Program leaders and instructors in recreation, sport and fitness contribute the most claims in the Ski Hill or Gondola Ride CU. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 66 Ski Hill or Gondola Ride - CU # 761038 Age and Gender % STD/LTD/Fatal Claims, 2009 - 2013 Profile Male Female Total Age # of Claims % of Claims # of Claims % of Claims # of Claims % of Claims 0 - 14 0 0% 1 0% 1 0% 15 - 24 232 19% 159 13% 391 32% 25 - 34 278 22% 143 12% 421 34% 35 - 44 159 13% 50 4% 209 17% 45 - 54 101 8% 23 2% 124 10% 55 - 64 47 4% 21 2% 68 5% 65 and Over 19 2% 5 0% 24 2% Total 836 67% 402 32% 1,238 100% Young Workers (aged 15-24) represent 32%, while Mature Workers (aged 45 – 64) represent 15% of the total STD/LTD/Fatal claims. The majority of these claims were made by males. * There are 2 claims where the age and gender were uncoded. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 67 Ski Hill or Gondola Ride - CU # 761038 Accident and Injury Type % STD/LTD/Fatal Claims, 2009 - 2013 Profile Accident Type Claims Fall from Elevation Fall on Same Level Other Bodily Motion Overexertion Struck By Other Claim Costs 37% 15% 13% 13% 11% 11% Fall from Elevation Fall on Same Level Struck By Other Bodily Motion Struck Against Other Work Days Lost 52% 14% 11% 9% 4% 9% Fall from Elevation Other Bodily Motion Fall on Same Level Struck By Overexertion Other 39% 34% 10% 7% 4% 6% Other Strains Fractures Concussion Back Strain Dislocation Other 44% 16% 13% 11% 8% 8% Injury Type Claims Other Strains Back Strain Fractures Concussion Contusion Other Claim Costs 43% 15% 14% 10% 8% 10% Fractures Other Strains Concussion Back Strain Contusion Other Work Days Lost 47% 25% 9% 8% 5% 6% Fall from Elevation contributes the most to claims, costs, and days lost in the Ski Hill or Gondola Ride CU. The most common injury type is Other Strains, while Fractures contributes the most claim costs. * Note: Uncoded claim costs have been proportionally allocated to coded categories Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC . 68 Ski Hill or Gondola Ride - CU # 761038 Other Injury Factors % STD/LTD/Fatal Claims, 2009 - 2013 Profile Body Part Injured Knee, 267, 21% Other, 384, 31% Wrist, Fingers & Hand, 109, 9% Back, 210, 17% Source of Injury Head, 124, 10% Shoulders, 146, 12% Other, 263, 21% Working Surf aces, 585, 47% Vehicles, 67, 5% People, 70, 6% Miscellaneous, 75, 6% Bodily Motion, 180, 15% * Note: Uncoded claim costs have been proportionally allocated to coded categories Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC . 69 Ski Hill or Gondola Ride - CU # 761038 Serious Injury Claims Between 2009 and 2013, the Ski Hill or Gondola Ride CU combined for 213 Serious Injury Claims*. Serious Injuries represent 18% of the claims in the Ski Hill or Gondola Ride CU and account for 50% of the claims cost paid to date. Accident Type Injury Type Fall from Elevation 54% Fractures 63% Fall on Same Level 18% Other Strains 12% Other Bodily Motion 9% Concussion 10% Struck By 7% Dislocation 5% Struck Against 3% Laceration 3% Other 8% Other 6% The serious injury claims in this CU are more likely to involve: fall from elevation, fractures. *Serious Injuries include time-loss claims that represent either a serious medical diagnosis, or a potentially-serious medical diagnosis with a long recovery period of 50+ days paid (10+ weeks off work). Serious Injuries also include all work-related death claims. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 70 Ski Hill or Gondola Ride - CU # 761038 Serious Injury Claim Examples Fall from Elevation Cost Snowboarding between work stations, caught an edge and fell. Days $ 10,000 90 Wearing a helmet skiing down a run & ski got caught under the snow & wkr tripped & fell forward $ hitting head on hard packed snow. 51,000 210 Fall on Same Level Cost Days Wkr was skiing down mountain when lost control & fell hitting a tree. $ 30,000 160 Wkr slipped & fell on sidewalk. sidewalk was plowed but not salted or sanded. $ 15,000 90 Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 71 Ski Hill or Gondola Ride - CU # 761038 Prevention Activity 90 77 80 70 60 60 53 58 51 50 40 39 37 32 33 32 27 30 19 20 10 0 2009 2010 2011 Inspection Reports 2012 2013 2014 Other Contacts Compared to 2012, the number of Inspection Reports issued in Ski Hill or Gondola Ride decreased by 45% to 32 documents in 2013. As of June 30, 2014, 19 Inspection Reports have been issued year-to-date. Note: 2014 is currently June YTD. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 72 Ski Hill or Gondola Ride - CU # 761038 Prevention Orders 50 44 45 40 37 35 32 31 30 27 25 25 20 14 15 14 10 10 5 5 4 1 0 2009 2010 2011 Prevention Orders 2012 2013 2014 Order Follow-Ups There were 119 Prevention Orders issued between 2009 and 2014YTD. As of June 30, 2014, 10 Prevention Orders have been issued year-to-date. Note: 2014 is currently June YTD. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 73 Ski Hill or Gondola Ride - CU # 761038 Penalties & Warning Letters 1.2 1 1 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 0 0 2009 2010 0 0 0 0 0 2012 2013 0 0 0 2011 Warning Letters Sent 2014 Penalties Imposed Between 2009 and 2014YTD, no warning letters were sent and two administrative penalties were imposed. Note: 2014 is currently June YTD. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 74 Casino or Other Gaming Operations (not elsewhere specified) Classification Unit # 761054 2009 - 2013 Profile Prepared by: Business Information and Analysis (BIA) JUNE 30, 2014 2015 Base Rates 76 Casino or Other Gaming Operations (not elsewhere specified) - CU # 761054 Key Findings In 2013, there were 29 employers in this industry, a 21% increase over the past four years. The Injury Rate for the Casino or Other Gaming Operations (not elsewhere specified) CU decreased by 19.4% since the prior year. The percentage of workers returning to work within 4 weeks decreased in 2013 compared to 2012 and is lower than all BC (2013: 48% for Casino or Other Gaming Operations (not elsewhere specified) vs. 52% for all BC). The average Short-Term Disability Duration (work days lost per claim) for the Casino or Other Gaming Operations (not elsewhere specified) CU is similar to all-BC. Operators and attendants in amusement, recreation and sport, security guards and related security service occupations, food and beverage servers, cashiers contribute contribute the most claims in the Casino or Other Gaming Operations (not elsewhere specified) CU. There were 117 Prevention Orders issued between 2009 and 2014YTD. As of June 30, 2014, 12 Prevention Orders have been issued year-to-date. Between 2009 and 2014 YTD, there were no work-related deaths. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 77 Casino or Other Gaming Operations (not elsewhere specified) - CU # 761054 Statistical Overview In 2013, there were 29 employers in this industry, a 21% increase over the past four years. Year STD/LTD/Fatal Claim Cost Claims Paid* Work Days Lost* Injury Rate (per 100 Return to Work person-years of (<=4 weeks) employment) Person Years STD Duration (Average Days Lost per Claim) WorkSerious Related Injuries** Deaths 2009 155 $885,251 7,360 3.1 N/A 4,702 50 13 0 2010 132 $835,278 5,158 2.5 N/A 4,792 44 8 0 2011 118 $961,322 5,728 2.4 62% 4,986 54 11 0 2012 130 $1,213,208 6,440 2.6 50% 4,671 59 6 0 2013 113 $1,690,104 6,145 2.1 48% 5,174 64 10 0 Total 648 $5,585,163 30,831 2.5 (Avg) 53% (Avg) 4,865 (Avg) 54 (Avg) 48 0 2009 to 2013 % Change -27% 91% -17% -34% N/A 10% 29% -23% N/A * Note: The Claim Cost Paid and Work Days Lost relate to the claims from all years of injury and are not just the results of the given year's claims. ** Note: Serious Injuries include time-loss claims that represent either a serious medical diagnosis, or a potentially-serious medical diagnosis with a long recovery period of 50+ days paid (10+ weeks off work). Serious Injuries also include all workrelated death claims. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 78 Casino or Other Gaming Operations (not elsewhere specified) - CU # 761054 Time-loss Claims per 100 Person-years of Employment Injury Rate Trend 3.5 3.1 3.0 2.5 2.5 2.0 2.6 2.4 2.3 2.3 2.3 2.3 2.3 2.1 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Injury Rate - Casino or Other Gaming Operations (not elsewhere specif ied) Injury Rate - All BC The Injury Rate for the Casino or Other Gaming Operations (not elsewhere specified) CU decreased by 19.4% since the prior year. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 79 Casino or Other Gaming Operations (not elsewhere specified) - CU # 761054 Claims and Employment Trends 5,300 160 5,174 148 120 Time-Loss Claims 120 119 121 5,200 5,100 108 5,000 100 4,986 4,900 80 4,800 4,792 60 40 Person Years 140 4,700 4,702 4,671 4,600 20 4,500 4,400 0 2009 2010 2011 # Time-Loss Claims 2012 2013 Person Years The estimated number of workers (Person Years) saw a significant increase in 2013, whereas the number of time-loss claims decreased by 11%. This has resulted in a decrease in the Injury Rate for the Casino or Other Gaming Operations Meanwhile, the assessable payroll has increased by 6.7% in 2013. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 80 Casino or Other Gaming Operations (not elsewhere specified) - CU # 761054 STD Duration – Five Year Trend Average Short-term Disability Days per Claim 70 60 59 60 59 64 60 58 54 55 50 50 44 40 30 20 10 0 2009 2010 2011 2012 Casino or Other Gaming Operations (not elsewhere specified) 2013 All BC The average Short-Term Disability Duration (work days lost per claim) for the Casino or Other Gaming Operations (not elsewhere specified) CU is similar to all-BC. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 81 Casino or Other Gaming Operations (not elsewhere specified) - CU # 761054 Return to Work (RTW) The percentage of workers returning to work within 4 weeks decreased in 2013 compared to 2012 and is lower than all BC (2013: 48% for Casino or Other Gaming Operations (not elsewhere specified) vs. 52% for all BC). % of Claims Returning to Work within 4 Weeks 100% 80% 62% 60% 54% 50% 53% 48% 52% 40% 20% 0% 2011 2012 2013 Casino or Other Gaming Operations (not elsewhere specified) All BC Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 82 Casino or Other Gaming Operations (not elsewhere specified) - CU # 761054 Occupations (Top 10) % STD/LTD/Fatal Claims, 2009 - 2013 Profile Occupation Type # of Claims % of Claims Operators and attendants in amusement, recreation and sport 177 27% Security guards and related security service occupations 71 11% Food and beverage servers 66 10% Cashiers 59 9% Accommodation, travel, tourism and related services supervisors 56 9% Food counter attendants, kitchen helpers and related support occupations 41 6% Cooks 41 6% Casino occupations 36 6% Chefs 17 3% Bartenders 11 2% Other 73 11% Grand Total 648 100% Operators and attendants in amusement, recreation and sport, security guards and related security service occupations, food and beverage servers, cashiers contribute the most claims in the Casino or Other Gaming Operations (not elsewhere specified) CU. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 83 Casino or Other Gaming Operations (not elsewhere specified) - CU # 761054 Age and Gender % STD/LTD/Fatal Claims, 2009 - 2013 Profile Male Female Total Age # of Claims % of Claims # of Claims % of Claims # of Claims % of Claims 0 - 14 0 0% 0 0% 0 0% 15 - 24 28 4% 44 7% 72 11% 25 - 34 64 10% 83 13% 147 23% 35 - 44 53 8% 105 16% 158 24% 45 - 54 38 6% 142 22% 180 28% 55 - 64 30 5% 51 8% 81 13% 65 and Over 6 1% 4 1% 10 2% Total 219 34% 429 66% 648 100% Young Workers (aged 15-24) represent 11%, while Mature Workers (aged 45 - 64) represent 41% of the total STD/LTD/Fatal claims. The majority of these claims were made by females. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 84 Casino or Other Gaming Operations (not elsewhere specified) - CU # 761054 Accident and Injury Type % STD/LTD/Fatal Claims, 2009 - 2013 Profile Accident Type Claims Claim Costs Overexertion Struck By Fall on Same Level Other Bodily Motion Struck Against Other 25% 18% 17% 13% 7% 21% Overexertion Fall on Same Level Other Bodily Motion Struck By Fall from Elevation Other Work Days Lost 34% 13% 13% 12% 11% 17% Overexertion Struck By Fall on Same Level Other Bodily Motion Fall from Elevation Other 46% 15% 10% 9% 7% 14% Other Strains Back Strain Contusion Tendinitis, Tenosynovitis Fractures Other 27% 15% 14% 13% 12% 20% Injury Type Claims Claim Costs Other Strains Back Strain Contusion Laceration Tendinitis, Tenosynovitis Other 40% 21% 15% 8% 5% 13% Other Strains Back Strain Contusion Fractures Concussion Other Work Days Lost 42% 14% 11% 9% 8% 16% Overexertion contributes the most to claims, costs, and days lost in the Casino or Other Gaming Operations (not elsewhere specified) CU. The most common injury type is Other Strains, which also contributes the most claim costs and days lost. * Note: Uncoded claim costs have been proportionally allocated to coded categories Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC . 85 Casino or Other Gaming Operations (not elsewhere specified) - CU # 761054 Other Injury Factors % STD/LTD/Fatal Claims, 2009 - 2013 Profile Body Part Injured Wrist, Fingers & Hand, 147, 23% Other, 200, 31% Knee, 37, 6% Source of Injury Other, 183, 28% Working Surf aces, 136, 21% Shoulders, 55, 8% Ankle, Toe & Feet, 73, 11% Boxes, Containers, 116, 18% Vehicles, 48, 7% Buildings & Structures, 52, 8% Back, 136, 21% Bodily Motion, 113, 18% * Note: Uncoded claim costs have been proportionally allocated to coded categories Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC . 86 Casino or Other Gaming Operations (not elsewhere specified) - CU # 761054 Serious Injury Claims Between 2009 and 2013, the Casino or Other Gaming Operations (not elsewhere specified) CU combined for 48 Serious Injury Claims*. Serious Injuries represent 8% of the claims in the Casino or Other Gaming Operations (not elsewhere specified) CU and account for 35% of the claims cost paid to date. Accident Type Injury Type Struck By 31% Contusion 35% Fall on Same Level 25% Fractures 31% Struck Against 17% Laceration 13% Fall from Elevation 10% Concussion 13% Other Bodily Motion 8% Other Strains 4% Other 8% Other 4% The serious injury claims in this CU are more likely to involve: struck by, struck against, contusions, fractures, concussions. *Serious Injuries include time-loss claims that represent either a serious medical diagnosis, or a potentially-serious medical diagnosis with a long recovery period of 50+ days paid (10+ weeks off work). Serious Injuries also include all work-related death claims. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 87 Casino or Other Gaming Operations (not elsewhere specified) - CU # 761054 Serious Injury Claim Examples Struck By Cost Days Finger got crushed between the heavy doors of a vault. $ 11,000 110 Worker went to open a large cupboard/cupboard broke off and the corner of the cupboard struck worker in forehead/face. $ 13,000 190 Fall on Same Level Cost Days Worker slipped and fell hitting head on the floor. $ 44,000 180 Slipped on icy ground and fell backwards hitting head on ground. $ 91,000 370 Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 88 Casino or Other Gaming Operations (not elsewhere specified) - CU # 761054 Prevention Activity 38 40 35 30 30 25 24 22 23 18 20 17 17 15 16 11 12 10 5 5 0 2009 2010 2011 Inspection Reports 2012 2013 2014 Other Contacts There were 147 Inspection Reports issued between 2009 and 2014YTD. As of June 30, 2014, 16 Inspection Reports have been issued year-to-date. Note: 2014 is currently June YTD. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 89 Casino or Other Gaming Operations (not elsewhere specified) - CU # 761054 Prevention Orders 45 41 42 41 40 35 30 23 25 15 20 18 20 13 14 20 13 12 10 10 5 0 2009 2010 2011 Prevention Orders 2012 2013 2014 Order Follow-Ups There were 117 Prevention Orders issued between 2009 and 2014YTD. As of June 30, 2014, 12 Prevention Orders have been issued year-to-date. Note: 2014 is currently June YTD. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 90 Casino or Other Gaming Operations (not elsewhere specified) - CU # 761054 Penalties & Warning Letters 1.2 1 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2011 2012 0 0 0 0 0 2009 2010 Warning Letters Sent 2013 2014 Penalties Imposed Between 2009 and 2014YTD, one warning letter was sent and no administrative penalties were imposed. Note: 2014 is currently June YTD. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 91 Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility Classification Unit # 761031 2009 - 2013 Profile Prepared by: Business Information and Analysis (BIA) JUNE 30, 2014 2015 Base Rates 93 Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility - CU # 761031 Key Findings In 2013, there were 310 employers in this industry, a 3% increase over the past four years. The Injury Rate for the Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility CU increased by 18% since the prior year. The percentage of workers returning to work within 4 weeks increased in 2013 compared to 2012 and is higher than all BC (2013: 64% for Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility vs. 52% for all BC). The average Short-Term Disability Duration (work days lost per claim) for the Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility CU is significantly lower than all BC. Landscaping and grounds maintenance labourers, cooks contribute the most claims in the Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility CU. Compared to 2012, the number of Prevention Orders issued to employers in Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility increased by 17% to 34 orders in 2013. As of June 30, 2014, two Prevention Orders have been issued year-to-date. Between 2009 and 2014 YTD, there was one work-related death. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 94 Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility - CU # 761031 Statistical Overview In 2013, there were 310 employers in this industry, a 3% increase over the past four years. Year STD/LTD/Fatal Claim Cost Claims Paid* Work Days Lost* Injury Rate (per 100 Return to Work person-years of (<=4 weeks) employment) Person Years STD Duration (Average Days Lost per Claim) WorkSerious Related Injuries** Deaths 2009 141 $762,481 4,195 2.3 N/A 6,099 33 16 0 2010 113 $1,365,921 3,509 1.9 N/A 5,840 33 12 1 2011 145 $938,721 4,026 2.5 64% 5,384 36 10 0 2012 109 $1,044,770 4,001 1.9 63% 5,358 35 8 0 2013 123 $1,056,617 3,705 2.3 64% 5,240 43 17 0 Total 631 $5,168,510 19,436 2.2 (Avg) 64% (Avg) 5,584 (Avg) 36 (Avg) 63 1 2009 to 2013 % Change -13% 39% -12% 1% N/A -14% 29% 6% N/A * Note: The Claim Cost Paid and Work Days Lost relate to the claims from all years of injury and are not just the results of the given year's claims. ** Note: Serious Injuries include time-loss claims that represent either a serious medical diagnosis, or a potentially-serious medical diagnosis with a long recovery period of 50+ days paid (10+ weeks off work). Serious Injuries also include all workrelated death claims. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 95 Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility - CU # 761031 Time-loss Claims per 100 Person-years of Employment Injury Rate Trend 3.0 2.5 2.5 2.0 2.3 2.3 2.3 2.3 2.3 2.3 2.3 1.9 1.9 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Injury Rate - Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility Injury Rate - All BC The Injury Rate for the Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility CU increased by 18% since the prior year. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 96 Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility - CU # 761031 Claims and Employment Trends 6,200 6,099 135 140 138 Time-Loss Claims 120 6,000 120 5,840 5,800 104 112 100 5,600 80 5,400 60 5,384 5,358 Person Years 160 5,240 5,200 40 5,000 20 4,800 0 2009 2010 2011 # Time-Loss Claims 2012 2013 Person Years The estimated number of workers (Person Years) saw a slight decrease in 2013, whereas the number of time-loss claims increased by 15%. This has resulted in an increase in the Injury Rate for the Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility CU. Meanwhile, the assessable payroll has decreased by 0.05% in 2013. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 97 Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility - CU # 761031 STD Duration – Five Year Trend Average Short-term Disability Days per Claim 70 60 59 60 60 58 55 50 43 40 36 33 35 33 30 20 10 0 2009 2010 2011 2012 Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility 2013 All BC The average Short-Term Disability Duration (work days lost per claim) for the Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility CU is significantly lower than all BC. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 98 Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility - CU # 761031 Return to Work (RTW) The percentage of workers returning to work within 4 weeks increased in 2013 compared to 2012 and is higher than all BC (2013: 64% for Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility vs. 52% for all BC). % of Claims Returning to Work within 4 Weeks 100% 80% 64% 60% 54% 64% 63% 53% 52% 40% 20% 0% 2011 2012 2013 Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility All BC Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 99 Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility - CU # 761031 Occupations (Top 10) % STD/LTD/Fatal Claims, 2009 - 2013 Profile Occupation Type # of Claims % of Claims Landscaping and grounds maintenance labourers 223 35% Cooks 100 16% Food and beverage servers 65 10% Nursery and greenhouse workers 58 9% Landscape and horticulture technicians and specialists 34 5% Food counter attendants, kitchen helpers and related support occupations 24 4% Janitors, caretakers and building superintendents 18 3% Operators and attendants in amusement, recreation and sport 14 2% Other small engine and small equipment repairers 12 2% Restaurant and food service managers 10 2% Other 73 12% Grand Total 631 100% Landscaping and grounds maintenance labourers, cooks contribute the most claims in the Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility CU. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 100 Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility - CU # 761031 Age and Gender % STD/LTD/Fatal Claims, 2009 - 2013 Profile Male Female Total Age # of Claims % of Claims # of Claims % of Claims # of Claims % of Claims 0 - 14 0 0% 0 0% 0 0% 15 - 24 86 14% 62 10% 148 23% 25 - 34 71 11% 26 4% 97 15% 35 - 44 73 12% 31 5% 104 16% 45 - 54 95 15% 55 9% 150 24% 55 - 64 74 12% 26 4% 100 16% 65 and Over 31 5% 1 0% 32 5% Total 430 68% 201 32% 631 100% Young Workers (aged 15-24) represent 23%, while Mature Workers (aged 45 - 64) represent 40% of the total STD/LTD/Fatal claims. The majority of these claims were made by males. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 101 Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility - CU # 761031 Accident and Injury Type % STD/LTD/Fatal Claims, 2009 - 2013 Profile Accident Type Claims Overexertion Struck By Fall on Same Level Fall from Elevation Other Bodily Motion Other Claim Costs 29% 19% 12% 8% 8% 23% Overexertion Fall from Elevation Fall on Same Level Repetitive Motion Struck By Other Work Days Lost 32% 16% 14% 11% 7% 20% Overexertion Fall on Same Level Fall from Elevation Struck By MVIs Other 25% 19% 16% 12% 11% 18% Other Strains Back Strain Fractures Contusion Tendinitis, Tenosynovitis Other 29% 18% 17% 9% 7% 20% Injury Type Claims Other Strains Back Strain Laceration Contusion Fractures Other Claim Costs 25% 25% 14% 12% 6% 18% Other Strains Fractures Back Strain Other Injuries Tendinitis, Tenosynovitis Other Work Days Lost 28% 26% 20% 8% 5% 14% Overexertion contributes the most to claims, costs, and days lost in the Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility CU. The most common injury type is Other Strains, which also contributes the most claim costs and days lost. * Note: Uncoded claim costs have been proportionally allocated to coded categories Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC . 102 Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility - CU # 761031 Other Injury Factors % STD/LTD/Fatal Claims, 2009 - 2013 Profile Body Part Injured Back, 160, 25% Other, 192, 30% Shoulders, 35, 6% Source of Injury Other, 225, 36% Working Surf aces, 101, 16% Wrist, Fingers & Hand, 138, 22% Knee, 46, 7% Hand Tools, 84, 13% Ankle, Toe & Feet, 60, 10% Vehicles, 77, 12% Bodily Motion, 68, 11% Boxes, Containers, 76, 12% * Note: Uncoded claim costs have been proportionally allocated to coded categories Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC . 103 Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility - CU # 761031 Serious Injury Claims Between 2009 and 2013, the Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility CU combined for 63 Serious Injury Claims*. Serious Injuries represent 10% of the claims in the Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility CU and account for 49% of the claims cost paid to date. Accident Type Injury Type Struck By 25% Fractures 46% Fall on Same Level 25% Laceration 17% Fall from Elevation 19% Back Strain 8% Struck Against 11% Contusion 8% MVIs 10% Amputation Other 10% Other 6% 14% The serious injury claims in this CU are more likely to involve: struck by, falls, and fractures. *Serious Injuries include time-loss claims that represent either a serious medical diagnosis, or a potentially-serious medical diagnosis with a long recovery period of 50+ days paid (10+ weeks off work). Serious Injuries also include all work-related death claims. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 104 Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility - CU # 761031 Serious Injury Claim Examples Struck By Cost Days Wkr lifted a 40 lb reel, turned to walk to left, caught foot on the mower tire & twisted. $ 11,000 40 A bottle of wine fell off the shelf onto wkr's head. $ 24,000 140 Fall on Same Level Cost Days Dining recently been mopped, wkr stepped into a wet spot, fell backwards. $ 45,000 130 Coming down the wooden ramp, slipped on ice & landed. $ 17,000 180 Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 105 Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility - CU # 761031 Work-Related Deaths Year Occupation 2010 Landscape and horticulture technicians and specialists Description FATAL - DISSECTING AORTIC ANEURYS - TRYING TO PRY A SHELF OFF THE WALL Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 106 Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility - CU # 761031 Prevention Activity 70 58 60 50 45 39 36 40 30 34 23 20 14 7 10 8 6 6 2 0 2009 2010 2011 Inspection Reports 2012 2013 2014 Other Contacts Compared to 2012, the number of Inspection Reports issued in Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility increased by 15% to 39 documents in 2013. As of June 30, 2014, 6 Inspection Reports have been issued year-to-date. Note: 2014 is currently June YTD. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 107 Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility - CU # 761031 Prevention Orders 120 100 100 91 80 68 72 60 42 40 29 38 29 34 34 20 2 1 0 2009 2010 2011 Prevention Orders 2012 2013 2014 Order Follow-Ups Compared to 2012, the number of Prevention Orders issued to employers in Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility increased by 17% to 34 orders in 2013. As of June 30, 2014, two Prevention Orders have been issued yearto-date. Note: 2014 is currently June YTD. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 108 Golf Course, Driving Range, Pitch and Putt, or Lawn Bowling Facility - CU # 761031 Penalties & Warning Letters 1.2 1 1 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 0 0 2009 2010 0 0 0 2011 2012 0 0 0 0 0 Warning Letters Sent 2013 2014 Penalties Imposed Between 2009 and 2014YTD, two warning letters were sent and no administrative penalties were imposed. Note: 2014 is currently June YTD. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 109 Outdoor Sport Tour Classification Unit # 761028 2009 - 2013 Profile Prepared by: Business Information and Analysis (BIA) JUNE 30, 2014 Key Findings Outdoor Sport Tour - CU # 761028 In 2013, there were 442 employers in this industry, a 3% increase over the past four years. The Injury Rate for the Outdoor Sport Tour CU remains higher than the Injury Rate for all BC CUs combined. The percentage of workers returning to work within 4 weeks increased in 2013 compared to 2012 and is lower than all BC (2013: 47% for Outdoor Sport Tour vs. 52% for all BC). The average Short-Term Disability Duration (work days lost per claim) for the Outdoor Sport Tour CU is significantly higher than all BC. Outdoor sport and recreational guides contribute the most claims in the Outdoor Sport Tour CU. There were 74 Prevention Orders issued between 2009 and 2014YTD. As of June 30, 2014, no Prevention Orders have been issued year-to-date. From 2009 to 2014 YTD, no Warning Letters were sent and no Penalties were imposed. Between 2009 and 2014 YTD, there was one work-related death. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 111 2015 Base Rates Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 112 Outdoor Sport Tour - CU # 761028 Statistical Overview In 2013, there were 442 employers in this industry, a 3% increase over the past four years. Year STD/LTD/Fatal Claim Cost Claims Paid* Work Days Lost* Injury Rate (per 100 Return to Work person-years of (<=4 weeks) employment) Person Years STD Duration (Average Days Lost per Claim) WorkSerious Related Injuries** Deaths 2009 43 $697,256 4,213 3.1 N/A 1,246 100 10 0 2010 50 $624,867 3,880 4.6 N/A 1,230 90 9 0 2011 47 $1,355,770 3,979 3.5 52% 1,255 85 9 1 2012 39 $1,080,399 3,243 3.0 36% 1,269 121 11 0 2013 58 $648,658 3,961 3.5 47% 1,558 106 10 0 Total 237 $4,406,949 19,276 3.5 (Avg) 45% (Avg) 1,312 (Avg) 103 (Avg) 49 1 2009 to 2013 % Change 35% -7% -6% 13% N/A 25% 6% 0% N/A * Note: The Claim Cost Paid and Work Days Lost relate to the claims from all years of injury and are not just the results of the given year's claims. ** Note: Serious Injuries include time-loss claims that represent either a serious medical diagnosis, or a potentially-serious medical diagnosis with a long recovery period of 50+ days paid (10+ weeks off work). Serious Injuries also include all workrelated death claims. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 113 Outdoor Sport Tour - CU # 761028 Time-loss Claims per 100 Person-years of Employment Injury Rate Trend 5.0 4.6 4.5 4.0 3.5 3.5 3.1 3.0 3.0 2.5 3.5 2.3 2.3 2.3 2.3 2.3 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 Injury Rate - Outdoor Sport Tour Injury Rate - All BC The Injury Rate for the Outdoor Sport Tour CU remains higher than the Injury Rate for all BC CUs combined. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 114 Outdoor Sport Tour - CU # 761028 Claims and Employment Trends 60 56 55 1,800 1,600 44 Time-Loss Claims 1,246 40 39 1,230 1,558 1,269 1,400 1,200 1,255 38 1,000 30 800 Person Years 50 600 20 400 10 200 0 0 2009 2010 2011 # Time-Loss Claims 2012 2013 Person Years The estimated number of workers (Person Years) saw a significant increase in 2013, whereas the number of time-loss claims increased by 45%. This has resulted in an increase in the Injury Rate for the Outdoor Sport Tour CU in 2013. Meanwhile, the assessable payroll has increased by 24.9% in 2013. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 115 Outdoor Sport Tour - CU # 761028 STD Duration – Five Year Trend Average Short-term Disability Days per Claim 140 121 120 106 100 100 90 85 80 60 55 60 59 60 58 40 20 0 2009 2010 2011 Outdoor Sport Tour 2012 2013 All BC The average Short-Term Disability Duration (work days lost per claim) for the Outdoor Sport Tour CU is significantly higher than all BC. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 116 Outdoor Sport Tour - CU # 761028 Return to Work (RTW) The percentage of workers returning to work within 4 weeks increased in 2013 compared to 2012 and is lower than all BC (2013: 47% for Outdoor Sport Tour vs. 52% for all BC). % of Claims Returning to Work within 4 Weeks 100% 80% 60% 52% 54% 53% 47% 52% 36% 40% 20% 0% 2011 2013 2012 Outdoor Sport Tour All BC Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 117 Outdoor Sport Tour - CU # 761028 Occupations (Top 10) % STD/LTD/Fatal Claims, 2009 - 2013 Profile Occupation Type # of Claims % of Claims Outdoor sport and recreational guides 143 60% Tour and travel guides 26 11% Program leaders and instructors in recreation, sport and fitness 8 3% Light duty cleaners 4 2% Chefs 4 2% Operators and attendants in amusement, recreation and sport 4 2% Water transport deck and engine room crew 4 2% Heavy-duty equipment mechanics 4 2% Photographers 3 1% Other trades helpers and labourers 3 1% Other 34 14% Grand Total 237 100% Outdoor sport and recreational guides contribute the most claims in the Outdoor Sport Tour CU. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 118 Outdoor Sport Tour - CU # 761028 Age and Gender % STD/LTD/Fatal Claims, 2009 - 2013 Profile Male Female Total Age # of Claims % of Claims # of Claims % of Claims # of Claims % of Claims 0 - 14 0 0% 0 0% 0 0% 15 - 24 24 10% 34 14% 58 24% 25 - 34 61 26% 30 13% 91 38% 35 - 44 35 15% 7 3% 42 18% 45 - 54 25 11% 7 3% 32 14% 55 - 64 11 5% 2 1% 13 5% 65 and Over 1 0% 0 0% 1 0% Total 157 66% 80 34% 237 100% Young Workers (aged 15-24) represent 24%, while Mature Workers (aged 45 - 64) represent 19% of the total STD/LTD/Fatal claims. The majority of these claims were made by males. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 119 Outdoor Sport Tour - CU # 761028 Accident and Injury Type % STD/LTD/Fatal Claims, 2009 - 2013 Profile Accident Type Claims Fall from Elevation Overexertion Struck By Other Bodily Motion Fall on Same Level Other Claim Costs 25% 22% 14% 11% 9% 20% Struck By Fall from Elevation Overexertion Fall on Same Level Caught In Other Work Days Lost 29% 28% 10% 6% 6% 21% Fall from Elevation Struck By Overexertion Fall on Same Level Other Bodily Motion Other 40% 31% 10% 10% 2% 6% Other Strains Fractures Back Strain Concussion Contusion Other 22% 15% 15% 10% 9% 30% Injury Type Claims Other Strains Back Strain Fractures Contusion Laceration Other Claim Costs 44% 16% 12% 9% 5% 13% Fractures Other Strains Concussion Back Strain Laceration Other Work Days Lost 49% 23% 13% 3% 3% 9% Fall from Elevation contributes the most claims, while Struck By contributes the most to claim costs in the Outdoor Sport Tour CU. The most common injury type is Other Strains, while Fractures contributes the most claim costs. * Note: Uncoded claim costs have been proportionally allocated to coded categories Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC . 120 Outdoor Sport Tour - CU # 761028 Other Injury Factors % STD/LTD/Fatal Claims, 2009 - 2013 Profile * Note: Uncoded claim costs have been proportionally allocated to coded categories Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC . 121 Outdoor Sport Tour - CU # 761028 Serious Injury Claims Between 2009 and 2013, the Outdoor Sport Tour CU combined for 49 Serious Injury Claims*. Serious Injuries represent 21% of the claims in the Outdoor Sport Tour CU and account for 45% of the claims cost paid to date. Accident Type Injury Type Fall from Elevation 29% Fractures 51% Struck By 16% Other Strains 12% Overexertion 10% Laceration 8% Fall on Same Level 10% Concussion 8% Other Bodily Motion 10% Dislocation Other 24% Other 8% 12% The serious injury claims in this CU are more likely to involve: fractures. *Serious Injuries include time-loss claims that represent either a serious medical diagnosis, or a potentially-serious medical diagnosis with a long recovery period of 50+ days paid (10+ weeks off work). Serious Injuries also include all work-related death claims. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 122 Outdoor Sport Tour - CU # 761028 Serious Injury Claim Examples Fall from Elevation Cost Days Worker hopped onto a horse and the horse pulled away causing worker to fall and landed onto a stump. $ 14,000 210 Fell from a height of approx 20 ft, building new zipline, landed on hip on rock. $ 12,000 50 Struck By Cost Worker stabbed self in hand while cutting up moose. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC $ 26,000 Days 120 123 Outdoor Sport Tour - CU # 761028 Work-Related Deaths Year Occupation 2011 Outdoor sport and recreational guides Description FATAL - HELI-SKI GUIDE STOPPED TO TAKE A PHOTOGRAPH ON THE SWANSON GLACIER FELL INTO A DEEP CREVASSE WHEN SNOW BENEATH GAVE WAY Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 124 Outdoor Sport Tour - CU # 761028 Prevention Activity 35 31 29 30 25 25 21 20 16 16 16 14 15 14 13 13 10 3 5 0 2009 2010 2011 Inspection Reports 2012 2013 2014 Other Contacts There were 103 Inspection Reports issued between 2009 and 2014YTD. As of June 30, 2014, 3 Inspection Reports have been issued year-to-date. Note: 2014 is currently June YTD. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 125 Outdoor Sport Tour - CU # 761028 Prevention Orders 45 42 40 35 35 28 30 25 20 15 16 12 17 14 9 10 5 8 2 0 0 0 2009 2010 2011 Prevention Orders 2012 2013 2014 Order Follow-Ups There were 74 Prevention Orders issued between 2009 and 2014YTD. As of June 30, 2014, no Prevention Orders have been issued year-to-date. Note: 2014 is currently June YTD. Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 126 What’s Wrong with this Photo Resources Employer Safety Planning Toolkit EBooks Web books Videos Slide Shows Industry Safety Information Centre Small Business & Young Worker Resource Portals Prepared by Business Information & Analysis, WorkSafeBC 127 Employer Safety Planning Tool Kit - home Your opinion matters! Primary tools If you have questions or comments, use the Feedback button to let us know. Additional Tools The applications in the right provide additional Safety Planning resources. The Tool Kit tells a safety story for an organization. Your rates and forecasts Your Return-to-Work performance Your injuries and claim details Your Data How you compare to your peers Your performance snapshot 129 Industry Safety Information Centre 130 HR Best Practices Research Industry Health & Safety Certificate of Recognition WorkSafeBC (www.worksafebc.com) •Field Officers, Ergonomist, Engineers, Hearing, RTW •Violence Prevention, Mental Health in the Workplace, Employers’ Advisers Office (www.labour.gov.bc.ca/eao/) •Free training seminars on H&S and Claims Management 131 Send people home safe and healthy 132