Of Mice and Men Unit 1 Literature Exam (May2012) 40% of your Literature grade AO1 (15%)Respond to texts critically and select and evaluate relevant textual detail to illustrate and support interpretations AO2 (15%)Explain how language, structure, form contribute to writers’ presentation of ideas, themes and settings AO4 (10%)Relate texts to their social, cultural and historical contexts; explain how texts have been influential and significant to self and other readers in different contexts and at different times The Assessment Objectives for Unit 1 The specification states that answers should: be relevant – you don’t need to write everything you know about the text, only the things that relate to the question be sufficiently detailed – it is better to give a lot of detail about a small part of the text than trying to cover lots of different points be well structured – with a clear introduction which addresses the question and a clear conclusion that returns to the question use effective vocabulary – including literary terms where relevant use well-chosen evidence/quotations to support points. To gain a top grade, candidates should show an enthusiastic and critical personal response. The best candidates write about the author’s methods and achievements, and will concentrate on comment, not content. Key issues for improving grades Dialogue ◦ ◦ ◦ ◦ ◦ ◦ ◦ Turn taking Questions Statements Commands Interruptions Silence Language used (colloquial/dialect AO2:Devices to look out for in the extract (and other parts of novel for part B) Actions of characters Feelings of characters (expressed by narrator) Setting Symbolism Foreshadowing Literary devices Sound effects AO2:Devices to look out for in the extract (and other parts of novel for part B) Part A – detailed and sophisticated analysis of the extract Look for the devices use and focus on what they reveal Connect to themes explored in the novel Part B – essential that you discuss context relating to the themes introduced in the extract. Refer to quotes in other parts of the book to support your points. Use the same detailed approach for explaining points and devices that you used in Part A Range of points in both parts essential but analysis must be detailed and specific – use literary terms and always discuss intended effect/what device reveals Answering the question The novel was published in 1937 It focuses on American society n the 1930s and the relatively poor and deprived class of men on whom the US economy depended It is set in California during a period known as the Great Depression Context (AO4) Curly’s wife is never given a name – this shows that her identity is seen only in terms of her husband – she is an interesting and controversial character Uneducated women in rural California in the 1930s had few opportunities and were not regarded as equals They were expected to be feminine, or motherly (Aunt Clara) or were treated as sexual commodities whose sexual favours could be paid for Position of Women Read p.58-60 Explore the presentation of women in this section – how is Whit’s description of the brothel different to Steinbeck’s presentation of Curly’s wife? Refer to language and context in your answer (AO2 and AO4) Text Focus Over farming and lack on rain created a ‘Dust Bowl’ which created a situation where owners of worthless land and unskilled workers travelled to find work on ranches (George and Lennie) Steinbeck made himself unpopular with employers by writing socially critical books like OMAM but conditions were probably more squalid than described The Dust Bowl People who emigrated from Europe to America believed this new land would enable them to realise their hopes and dreams There was a less rigid class system and a lot of land – it was believed that if you worked hard you could ‘make good’ George and Lennie and Curly’s wife are believers in the American Dream The American Dream Until 1865, slavery was still legal in the USA. In fact Southern states depended on it The Northern victory in 1865 freed the slaves, but black people were still regarded as second class citizens Crooks has some social contact with the other ranch workers but he is not regarded as an equal P.91: his passive reaction to Curly’s wife’s comments show he has no rights at all Racism This section is very important. It not only establishes the closeness of Lennie and George- the ‘farm speech’ has obviously been recited before – but makes us sympathetic to their simple ambition. Their dream is to have a small farm to “live off the fatta the lan!”as Lennie says. Lennie’s response to it is like a small child being told a favourite bedtime story. Lennie’s Dream Steinbeck begins the novel by ‘painting’ a scene Explore Steinbeck’s use of language and the effects achieved Techniques: foreshadow (incident with the mice foreshadows what happens later in the novel) Section 1: Text Focus Find key quotations from section 2 that explore the characterisation of heroes and villains and also the emerging theme of loneliness Focus on the techniques use by Steinbeck: ◦ Dialogue (slang/repetition/accents/sentence length) ◦ Strengths and weaknesses of characters Section 2: Heroes,Villains and Loneliness It explains the relationship between George and Lennie, and reinforces the importance of loneliness in the novel The shooting of Candy’s dog shows us the cruelty of the world portrayed in the novel. It prepares us for the shooting of Lennie The mention of the cowboy magazine the ranch hands pretend to scorn but secretly admire is introduced. It is another dream – something unreal but something to make life bearable Importance of section 3 ‘The dawn of hope’ A rest period before the final climax Introduces the issue of racial prejudice Lennie’s anger at Crooks warns us again that Lennie can be dangerous The harsh injustice of the world is shown by the ease with which Curley’s wife can humiliate Crooks Loneliness is again emphasised Importance of section 4 ‘death on the farm’ It seals Lennie’s fate It shows the sad loneliness of Curley’s wife, as well as her negative affect on others It suggests that the dream of the farm will die with Lennie Dreams and reality Portrayal of men and women Warnings Importance of section 5 ‘murder by mistake’ Some feminists argue that Steinbeck encourages old fashioned stereotypical images of women. They argue that Steinbeck sees the use of prostitutes as a man’s right, and that the only women who appears in the novel is a passive victim, a threat to men and someone described simply in terms of her sexuality. Yet the men in the novel are also frequently imperfect and Steinbeck has sympathy for Curley’s wife: she is portrayed as a pathetic figure, with her own unrealisable dream, married to a man she hates and with nothing to distract her from her unhappy marriage. In her own way, perhaps she is as much of a victim as Lennie. In basing his novel largely round a group of men and what we might see nowadays as ‘macho’ values, Steinbeck us writing in a firmly American tradition. Steinbeck’s concentration on male figures in OMAM allows him to examine a theme more closely studied in The Grapes of Wrath: in the America of the 1930s, men are in charge. Yet both novels show how little anyone. Male or female, is actually in control of their lives. Portraying men and women (section 5) It brings the novel to a dramatic climax It finishes the novel back where it started It introduces for the first and last time two fantasy visions At the same time, it shows us Steinbeck’s brilliance at natural description It shows us the tragic but perhaps inevitable ending to George and Lennie’s relationship Importance of section 6 ‘The end of the dream’ The setting ‘background to death’ The visions Dramatic tension Irony paradox Section 6 – Text focus The visions – of Aunt Clara and the giant rabbits – are poetic , and very different from Steinbeck’s style in the rest of the novel Both visions provide a clear insight into Lennie’s feelings at the close of the novel. They show his guilt and his genuine inability to control himself-a giant with mind of child. They also show how much Lennie suffers – both Aunt Clara and the rabbit hurt and taunt Lennie Lennie’s hopelessness is a sad contrast to his hope at the start of the novel – a shattered dream Section 6 –Techniques: The visions Show that you are aware of underlying themes. The tragedy of the novel is as much about the shattering of dreams as it is about the deaths of two of its main characters Grade Booster! The section opens with a description reminiscent of the opening of the novel. In the opening, there was a heron and a water snake. Now the heron kills a water snake preparing us for the death of Lennie Note the marvelous image of the sum blazing on the Gabilan mountains, and the contrast with the shade of the pool. Steinbeck makes use of light in his descriptions. In addition, ‘tiny wind waves’ on the water remind us of the waves caused by Lennie in the opening section Section 6: Setting There is a tremendous amount of irony in the fact that George takes Carlson’s pistol to kill Lennie as an act of Mercy. His decision is based on the paradox of being cruel to be kind The novel has other paradoxes – Lennie kills Curley’s wife but is essentially innocent. Curley’s wife is a ‘tart’ who causes her own death and Lennie’s but at the same time is shown to be ‘innocent’ Section 6: Irony Significant dramatic tension is created by the dialogue between George and Lennie at the end of the novel- the reader is waiting for the inevitable There is clear dramatic irony in the comparison between the opening and closing scenes of the novel – the same setting, once filled with hope, is now a scene of despair Section 6: Dramatic Tension Poetic in its intensity Natural description Detailed Successful because of Steinbeck’s eye for detail and unusual metaphors and similes and imagery (describing the water snake as a ‘periscope’ is an effective example) Steinbeck’s style is economical – describes the essential Use of light/sound and vision is evident throughout Steinbeck’s use of light and sound gives a precise sense of perspective and distance in the novel, and fixes the moment clearly in our minds The light flaming on the Gabilan mountains is a recurrent image Descriptive Style The dialogue is colloquial (formed from everyday speech). Steinbeck blends dialogue with the descriptive style with fluency Steinbeck uses phonetic spelling to reflect the way that they sound as spoken by the characters Steinbeck uses slang to reflect the speech of the ranch workers at the time Be careful to distinguish between slang and phonetic spelling (as slang dates/changes over time)An example is ‘flop house’ for brothel Dialogue Read from ‘A tall man stood in the doorway…’ to ‘It’s a lot nicer to go around with a guy you know’. Answer both parts of the question: ◦ How do the details in the passage add to your understanding of Slim? ◦ How does Steinbeck use the character of Slim in the novel as a whole to convey ideas about working life on ranches in 1930s America? (read extract from A grade answer provided) Exam Question Read the passage and then answer the questions which follow. (a) How do the details in this passage add to your understanding of Crooks? (b) How does Steinbeck use the character of Crooks in the novel as a whole to convey important ideas about America in the 1930s? Indicative content Answers are likely to deal with some of the following aspects of the story: AO1 Details of Crooks’ room such as the tidiness; his possessions; the books; the treatments for his back; the fact he lives in the harness room. Details of what Crooks is like such as working with horses; proud; disabled; educated Details of what happens to Crooks such as racist treatment; injured by horse; momentarily drawn into dream; talks to Lennie AO2 Writer’s use of language to describe Crooks’ room such as amount of detail to show his accumulated possessions; linking of specific objects with specific qualities of Crooks; significance of copy of California Civil Code; writer’s use of Crooks as representative of how black people were treated AO4 Racism of society; Crooks’ isolation; his association with the horses. Criteria for sample question on Crooks/Racism